Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2015 Oilfield Technology Apr PDF
2015 Oilfield Technology Apr PDF
SHUTTING
E
mergency shutdown valves are used
in offshore production platforms as key
components of more complex emergency support
systems (ESS). The API RP 14C standards for designing,
installing and testing ESS describe emergency shutdown systems
(ESD), gas detection, containment systems, fire detection and
subsurface safety valve (SSSV) systems. ESS provide a level of
protection by initiating shut‑in functions and minimising the
consequences of emergency situations, typically related to
uncontrolled flooding, escape of hydrocarbons, or outbreak of fire
in hydrocarbon‑carrying areas.
The aim of ESD systems is to protect personnel, facilities and
equipment, and minimise any damage to the environment that
might result from a catastrophic event. For example, both the
destruction of the Piper Alpha platform in 1988 and the accident at
the Brent Bravo facility in 2003 were caused by a lack of ESD valves.
Continuous improvement in the ESD design is a top priority for safety
management and increases the reliability of the whole system.
The intent of this article is to describe Velan ABV’s experience
in the design aspects of ESD valves and actuators and to highlight
the fact that requirements can range greatly from facility to
facility.
Background
While the number of ESD systems needed in an offshore platform
depends on its complexity and production capacity, there are
common levels of activation for different hazard situations. A less
serious critical situation is the unit shut down, where only a restricted
area or individual process is involved in the shut down process. A
more serious situation would be a surface process shutdown, where
all the production activity is shut down and all the pipeline processes
and injection SDVs fail, leaving some utilities such as main power
generation available. The third and most catastrophic situation is the
total platform shutdown, in which all the processes including power
generation are shutdown, the wellheads and sub‑surface safety
valves close, and the blowdown valves open to depressurise the
platform. In this case, the only system still active is the emergency
generator for firefighting systems.
A more general definition of a safety instrumented system
(SIS) has been proposed by IEC 61508 and ISA 84.00.01, where it is
described as a distinct and reliable system with the purpose of taking
a process to a safe state when predetermined conditions are violated.
Figure 1. ESD ball valve, 16 in. reduced bore, pressure class 2500, with An SIS is composed of several sensors, a programmable logic
hub end-connections and completed with a pneumatic SY actuator controller (PLC), and a final control element. Sensors collect
equipped with hydraulic damper and several quick exhaust valves for information necessary to determine if a dangerous situation could
very fast closing operation. Control panel includes two redundant SOVs, occur and, when such a situation is identified, the PLC disconnects
pilot valves and smart PST device ensuring a SIL 3 certification of the the power of the ESD solenoids and moves the valve into its safe
whole system. position.
The implemented
control loop function
is defined as the safety
instrumented function
(SIF). Performance can
be measured in terms of
reliability and availability.
Reliability is the probability
of performing the correct
logic safety function under
specifically determined
operating conditions for
a defined time period.
Availability is the fraction
of the total time that a
protective system is able to
function on demand.
SIF is designed to
minimise process risks to a
tolerable level, assigning to
each one a safety integrity
Figure 2. Typical SIS schematic diagram. level (SIL). IEC and ISA
Figure 3. ESD ball valve, 18 in. full bore, pressure class 2500 with Inconel
Valves overlay on all the internal wetted parts, completed with hydraulic
The main standards for offshore valves are API 6D and API 6A, even
SY actuator spring return and manual PST device. External painting
if EPCs and/or operators integrate these norms with their own suitable for offshore severe service.
specifications. Furthermore, valves could be in accordance with
the NORSOK standards developed by the Norwegian petroleum
industry, with the aims of providing equipment suitable for the Debris can often be trapped between a valve’s seats and the
extreme North Sea weather conditions. Commonly, even though ball, where it scratches the contact surfaces during strokes. This
EPCs’/operators’ specifications are influenced by experience and damage can compromise the tight shutoff function. Soft‑seated
procurement policies, nevertheless a design agreement with the valves are considered more vulnerable compared to hard seats and,
valve manufacturer has to be reached. even if some EPCs prefer soft‑seated design due to their zero leakage
The most common ESD valve is the trunnion ball valve. Valves capacity, metal‑seated valves with tungsten carbide hard facing are
can be either reduced or full bore, although all the valves installed more reliable.
to protect risers and exported oil and gas systems have to be full Moreover, wellhead fluids might have considerable amounts
bore since they must be piggable. This pipe cleaning has to be done of H2S, which corrodes the internal wetted surface. To counter
carefully and demands a perfect valve bore alignment, otherwise the this, the valve material must meet NACE MR‑01‑75 standards; in
pig can damage seats and ball surfaces, especially during the first addition, the protection of all seat and sealing areas with corrosion
commissioning when the line could contain dirty debris remaining resistant alloys (CRA) is recommended. Confined spaces are
from the piping assembly. mainly exposed to aggressive pitting and crevice corrosion. Nickel
Two major risks of dangerous failures negatively affect the target alloys are commonly used due to their excellent weld deposition
by closing the line with a quarter turn rotation of the ball: this can characteristics and superior crevice corrosion resistance.
result in seized seats and a jammed stem. The process fluid and the An important precaution to take to help avoid stem jam is
external environment also play a big role in determining the probability using external seals to isolate the bushing areas from the outside
of the valve failing. The operating fluid can be a single clean phase of environment. When valves are in a horizontal position or located
crude oil, gas, condensates, or a mixture of them, but especially at in splash zones, seawater and rain can seep into the stem packing,
the beginning of the process the fluid is ‘dirty’ and strongly abrasive. leading to premature stem failures due to corrosion. Furthermore
A ball valve fixed in the same position for a long period also faces the for fast operations of high‑pressure valves, some design precautions
risk that sand and debris could be pushed by the flow in the upstream have to be considered to achieve the right coupling between stem
ring cavity, creating a consolidated mass that can act as a wedge at and actuator. Narrow tolerances, longer bushings and reference
the bottom of the seat ring and increasing the valves’ torque or, in the pins help guarantee a perfect alignment between axes.
worst case scenario, causing the upstream seat to seize. To deal with
this, the valve design should include emergency sealing injection on its Actuation
seats, whereby the injection of a lubricant or a flushing fluid can act as The most common actuator for ESD systems is the pneumatic scotch
a hydraulic ‘push’ lifting the seat ring off the ball face. yoke (SY) spring return, even though the hydraulic version could be a