Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A R T I C LE I N FO A B S T R A C T
Keywords: Emissions from vehicles include particles from tire and brake wearing that can settle down and join industrial
Street dust discharges into street dust. Metals present in street dust may create ecological and health threats and their
Heavy metals analysis is of great environmental relevance. The city of Monterrey, Mexico is an industrial pillar of the country
XRF and shows an increasing fleet during the last years, which has yielded higher traffic and emissions. This study
Human health
analyzes 44 street dust samples taken across the city for total element concentrations by using X-ray fluores-
Risk assessment
cence. Associations and indicators are calculated to define possible origins, levels of pollution, natural or an-
thropogenic sources, and ecological and human health risks. High concentrations of As, Ba, Cu, Fe, Mo, Ni, Pb,
Ti, and Zn were found. Main sources of metals were defined as: tire wearing for Zn and Fe; brake wearing for Ba,
Cu, Fe, Pb and Zr; additional industrial sources for Mo, Ni, Pb, and Ti; and other natural sources for As.
Ecological risk was found to be moderate across the city and risk due to Pb concentrations was established for
children.
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: erurrutia@espe.edu.ec (R. Urrutia-Goyes), ornel@itesm.mx (N. Ornelas-Soto).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2018.04.054
Received 13 March 2018; Received in revised form 20 April 2018; Accepted 26 April 2018
Available online 21 May 2018
0147-6513/ © 2018 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
R. Urrutia-Goyes et al. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 159 (2018) 198–204
2. Methods
2.2. Sampling
In order to analyze the concentration of metals in street dust and Street dust samples were collected in August 2017. The sampling
soil, techniques such as inductively coupled mass spectrometry, X-ray process was completed throughout the day (20–30 °C), within one week
fluorescence (XRF), and atomic absorption have been used (OSHA, after several without any rain during the dry season. Specific locations
2014; USEPA, 2014). The advantages of using a portable XRF device can be seen in Fig. 1. Two plastic brushes (with thick and thin bristles
include multi-element analysis, immediate results, simple sample pre- respectively) were used to sweep street dust up onto a flat piece of
paration, and the ability to take non-destructive measurements in the paper and then placed into a zip locked plastic bag. Water and a cloth
field. The technique is based on the release of energy produced by the were used to clean tools after sampling to avoid cross contamination.
interaction between electrons and a radiation applied to the atoms of Each sample represents 400–800 g of dust from an area of approxi-
the sample. Such energy is detected and matched to signature spec- mately one square meter on road shoulders, at a distance of few cen-
trums that are element-dependent (USEPA, 2015; Weindorf et al., timeters away from the curb or gutter. Subsequently, samples were
2014). disaggregated, air-dried and stored in the laboratory at room tem-
The aim of this study is to characterize street dust from an over- perature.
populated city in Mexico by using portable XRF to assess any associa-
tion to natural or anthropogenic sources such as traffic or industry 2.3. Analysis
emissions, and to find any possible risks posed to the environment and
human health. To the best of our knowledge, the present study would Any vegetation and gravel-sized particles were removed from every
be first of its kind to intertwine sources, sinks, and repercussions in a street dust sample collected. Plastic bags were then poured out onto a
city from Mexico. This work can serve as a multidisciplinary example of 250 µm sieve. Samples were sieved and the resulting subsamples were
the sources and effects of pollution present in highly populated and placed into plastic bags (100 µm thickness) before homogenizing by
industrialized cities across the globe. mixing and rotating at 45 degrees. Shaking of the subsamples was
avoided since it produces stratification. The subsample in the bag was
then flattened to form a uniform layer of approx. 3 cm thickness. Loss of
Fig. 2. Box plots of (standardized) concentrations (in mg/kg) of the elements present in street dust in Monterrey.
199
R. Urrutia-Goyes et al. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 159 (2018) 198–204
Fig. 3. Spatial distribution and concentration (in mg/kg) of the elements present in street dust samples from Monterrey. Circles represent sampling locations.
material due to sieving was insignificant (Gerlach et al., 2002; Hall Tennessee, Knoxville, USA; XLSTAT 2017 from Addinsoft, Paris, France;
et al., 2014; Urrutia-Goyes et al., 2018, 2017). and The Unscrambler 10.1 from CAMO, Oslo, Norway. Among the
An Olympus Delta Premium 6000 PXRF analysis device was used to process run by these packages are descriptive statistics, principal
quantify the presence of metals. After factory- and laboratory-calibra- component analysis (PCA), cluster analysis (CA), spatial interpolation,
tion, the measurement window of the device was placed on top of the and human health risk assessment representation.
subsample and readings were taken for 90 s in soil mode to reach the
detection limits defined by the manufacturer. Certified Reference 2.5. Pollution Indicators
Materials (CRMs) NIST-2710a and NIST-2711a (from NIST®), and CRM-
023 and CRM-025 (from AccuStandards®) were used to evaluate the Pollution indicators Enrichment Factor (EF) and Geoaccumulation
accuracy of the measurements in addition to a blank sample that Index (Igeo) were calculated for the samples taken across the city. EF for
comprises silica sand (USEPA, 2007). After multiple readings and al- elements present in street dust samples was calculated using Mn as a
though results are element dependent, the calculated relative standard reference element since it showed low variability. EF and Igeo were
deviation values ranged from 1% to 21% and mean recoveries ranged calculated according to Eq. (1) and Eq. (2), where C and B are the
from 92% to 113%. Overall, the device was considered appropriate to concentrations of the studied element n and the reference element ref,
perform the required analysis. in the sample and in the background, respectively. Background values
for the studied elements were obtained from official local sources or
2.4. Statistics and spatial representation from reported concentrations in the earth's crust (Bourliva et al., 2016;
Muller, 1969; Rudnick and Gao, 2003; SGM, 2000).
Elemental concentrations were analyzed by descriptive statistics
and plotted. Correlations were assessed between variables. Data sets 2.6. Ecological and human health risk assessment
were also evaluated by principal component analysis (PCA) and cluster
analysis (CA) to define any relationship between variables from street Potential Ecological Risk Index (RI), Hazard Quotient (HR) and
dust samples. Spatial representation and statistical analyses were per- Cancer Risk (CR) were calculated for the city. RI was calculated ac-
formed by using software packages SADA 5.0 from The University of cording to Eq. (3), where Tri is the toxic response factor. HQ and CR
200
R. Urrutia-Goyes et al. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 159 (2018) 198–204
⎝ ×Bn ⎠
1.5 (2)
Pearson correlation coefficients for the analyzed elements were
7 C calculated (see Table S4). Some positive and relatively strong cor-
RI = ∑i =1 Tri ⎛ n ⎞
⎜ ⎟
⎝ Bn ⎠ (3) relations (p < 0.05) were found among Ba, Fe, Mn and Zr; Cr, Fe,
and Zr; Fe and Zn; Fe and Zr; Ni and Mn; As and Pb; Ba and Mn;
HQ = CDI /RfD (4)
suggesting similar sources for their release. On the other hand, weak
CR = CDI × SF (5) relationships were found for Ti and the rest of the elements showing
origins more unique for this element. Detailed analysis based on PCA
Ring × EF × ED and CA might help with the identification of shared sources and is
CDIing = Cexp × × 10−6
BW × AT (6) hence necessary.
Rinh × EF × ED Two principal components explained more than 90% of the total
CDIinh = Cexp × variance. Principal component 1 explained 85% of the total variance
PEF × BW × AT (7)
and confirms that Ti and Zn have a distinct source of release (see
SA × SAF × ABS × EF × ED Fig. 4.a). On the other hand, Ba, Cr, Cu Pb, Ni, and Zr appear to a
CDIdermal = Cexp × × 10−6
BW × AT (8) have a common origin. Additionally, hierarchical cluster analysis
201
R. Urrutia-Goyes et al. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 159 (2018) 198–204
Fig. 5. Boxplots of EF and Igeo indicators for the studied elements in street dust in Monterrey.
was applied to the data set in order to identify similar groups ac- pads wearing. Chemical elements, such as As, Cr, Ni, and Pb could
cording to concentrations. Fig. 4.b shows a dendrogram where three have different industrial sources since they also show high con-
main clusters can be recognized. Again, Ti seems to have an in- centrations.
dependent source since it shows the greatest dissimilarity, whereas
Ba, Cu, Pb, and Zr appear in a different cluster confirming their 3.3. Pollution Indicators
shared origin from braking pads.
Correlation analysis, PCA and CA have led to the conclusion that In order to prove that anomalous concentrations occur due to nat-
elements with similar sources can be grouped as follows: Ti as an ural or anthropogenic sources, pollution indicators EF and Igeo were
independent element possibly from wearing of brake pads and in- calculated. Enrichment factors greater than 10 and geoacummulation
dustry releasing; Zn and Fe released from tire wear dust and heavy indicator values greater than 1 suggest anthropogenic sources. Fig. 5
traffic across the city; and Ba, Cu, Fe, Pb, and Zr released from brake shows box plots for EF and Igeo calculated for every element considered
202
R. Urrutia-Goyes et al. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 159 (2018) 198–204
4. Conclusion
203
R. Urrutia-Goyes et al. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 159 (2018) 198–204
Table 1
Health risks for adults and children due to exposure to the studied elements in street dust in Monterrey.
Element Concentration Ingestion Inhalation Dermal Total
Hazard (Adult) Hazard (Child) Hazard (Adult) Hazard (Adult) Hazard (Adult)
204