Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.productschool.com
Product-Market Fit
value proposition is a statement of
how you meet the target customers
unmet needs, the features deliver that
Dan Olsen —
value, and the UX is how the
Author of The Lean Product Playbook
customer experiences receiving that
value. If everything is aligned, then
you have Product-Market Fit.
What does it actually mean to
have Product-Market fit?
The Lean Product Process
The Product-Market Fit Pyramid
To achieve Product-Market Fit via the
• UX Lean Product Process, you begin at
• Feature Set the bottom of the pyramid and work
your way up.
• Value Proposition
• Determine your target customer.
• Underserved Needs
• Identify underserved customer
• Target Customer needs.
Often companies have an idea of their When talking about needs, we can
target customer which sounds good drill down into Problem Space versus
at first but, upon digging deeper, is Solution Space.
actually very vague. “Millennials”
sounds good at first glance, but when • Problem Space: A customer problem,
you stop and think about it you need or benefit that the product
realize this is a hugely diverse group should address. This is a product
with diverse needs and problems. You requirement.
need to go deeper. For example: • Solution Space: A specific
“Millennials who aspire to cook at implementation or design that is
home.” intended to address that requirement.
Customers can share high-level needs Too often, PMs barrel right into
but have different detailed needs. For solution space without taking the
example, a soccer mom and a young time to think about the problem
speed demon may share the high- space. This is why a NASA contractor
level need of: “Transportation within spent $1 million back in the 60s on
100 miles of my home”, but their R&D to invent a “Space Pen” that
detailed needs are going to be very could write in zero gravity, while the
different! The soccer mom probably Soviet Union merely gave their
needs space to transport her kids, astronauts $0.50 pencils! Both solve
their friends, and their athletic gear. the problem, but with significantly
She probably values safety, and different levels of cost!
maybe fuel economy. The speed
demon probably values speed, style,
The NASA “Space Pen” exists purely
image. This is why there are so many
in the solution space. Dan Olsen calls
different types of cars on the road!
this “solution pollution” - NASA’s
goal was to “create a pen that writes
in space.” If the goal was focused on
the problem - “the need to write in
space” the idea of a pen would not
have polluted their focus, and they
would have saved $1 million!
Given that the problem space is likely • How satisfied is the user while using
to contain many needs, it’s important this product?
to prioritize based on customer value.
But how do we do these? Dan Olsen Plotting these two metrics on a
proposes a formula: simple graph, we come up with three
important types of features/benefits.
Importance vs. Satisfaction
Must-have - A met need does not
• Importance: Take a customer’s always lead directly to satisfaction,
stated needs - for example, to save but it can help users avoid the
time, save money, and ask them unhappiness of having that need
“How important is this to you on a unmet. For example, seat belts are a
scale of 1 to 10.” This is an easy way must-have for a car, but using them
to determine the importance of a doesn’t confer satisfaction to the
particular need. customer! Once each seat has a belt,
there is no room for this need to be
• Satisfaction: Ask the customer how
further met. That’s the end of the
satisfied they are with the current
road. Must-have features can be the
solutions available to them.
core service your product delivers,
but what differentiates it from the
A competitive market is a need with a competition.
high importance that is currently being
well met by other companies. Try to
Performance - More is better, less is
look for a need that is of high
worse. A microchip that is 10% faster
importance, but is currently being
than a competitors’ is 10% better. Not
poorly met. This is where opportunities
having it causes problems, having it
are found.
provides value.
• W h i c h u s e r b e n e fi t s a r e yo u
providing?
Uncovering Truths.”
How To Get Your Product “Hired” -
Find Out:
Let’s break this down.
• What are the jobs that occur in your
customers’ lives?
Empowering People
• Under what circumstances do these
jobs occur?
Empowering people to overcome
needs requires an understanding of • How can your product be “hired” to
what your users’ needs really are. do these jobs for your customer?
You can look at “jobs to be done” (jtbd) For example, a user may have a great
as a particular kind of nuanced User experience BUT if they’re unable to
Story. Here’s a tasty example: explain that experience to their
bosses, your product won’t succeed.
Milkshake Metaphor: Two types of You need to constantly ask the
people buy milkshakes. Adults who fundamental questions about the
buy them for their long commute to why. You are striving for a sense of
t h e s t o r y t h a t yo u r c u s t o m e r
work, and adults who buy them after
school for their kids. The two users experiences as they use your product.
need the milkshake to do different
“jobs.” The first group wants a large Uncovering Truths
milkshake with a small straw that
takes longer to drink and “entertains”
them during the commute. The Uncovering truths mean having a
second group needs a small milkshake methodology of validating the many
with a big straw that will quickly assumptions that go into designing
satisfy their kids without making great products.
them sick.
Facts and data that can allow you to
make better, smarter decisions.
Inspiring Empathy
Quantitative analysis can be powerful.
Facebook found that when you have
Inspiring empathy requires systematically seven or more friends, you are likely to
communicating user problems in a way stick around. With Twitter, the
that can be easily understood. It shows threshold seems to be 30 followers.
your users that you understand them,
and builds a connection. Users can tell you a lot but often that
themselves don’t accurately understand
Think about the delight that users how they are using a product. If you
experience when they use your product. don’t gather data, you can build a
You want your customers to be product based on assumptions. For
delighted, but the only way to do this is e x a m pl e , wh e n Fa c e b o ok fi r s t
by learning something which gives you released the newsfeed feature in
a deep, empathetic understanding of 2006, there was a huge backlash.
how your users feel.
Users said they didn't like it.
Numbers showed otherwise. The
newsfeed has been an undeniable
success. In this case, data succeeded
where users’ own self-knowledge
had failed. If you want to see Ketan
Nayak’s ProductCon SF full talk,
watch it here.
The Only Metric that Some of the key concepts regarding
Matters
this overall topic of measuring
success include understanding key
users, churn, virality, and your user
Josh Elman — VP of Product at l i fe t i m e . The se c o nc ep ts c o me
Robinhood, Partner at Greylock together to form the vital framework
that allows you to discern what
impact your product truly has on the
The best way to build products
world.
that solve real problems and have an
impact on users is to understand if and
how people are really using them. If Analyzing the Product Launch
you really want to understand your
consumers, you must first define the
metrics you’ll use to measure their One of the most important aspects of
overall satisfaction. developing a product is the launch.
All products, companies, and even
new features start with zero users. As
One of the most important ideas that
with any venture, you should have
product people should be thinking
already designed something that
about is metrics. The best way to
attracts users and delivers value, if
make sure your product performs to
not, what are you doing?
its full potential is by measuring your
progress at every step.
The first set of data you must retrieve
is asking your early adopters, even
“Success is measured the ones who stopped using the
product, about their journey. These
according to how many experiences can be positive, negative,
confused, or any feeling that gives
times your users you an idea of who is using your
product and how. Once you have a
perform a key behavior collection of stories, you can translate
1. Availability
“If it feels effortless, it
Picture this situation. You’re at your feels true.”
favorite lunch joint. There are two
queues: one for sandwiches, another
one for salad. Your doctor recently 2. Anchoring
told you that you have to cut down on
sandwiches. At the same time, there Here’s another example for you. And
are way more people queueing for a it can be a very personal one. When
salad. In fact, you only have a few they make you a salary offer during
minutes for lunch today. an interview, that first number can
determine your whole outlook on the
What do you pick? Even though you job. Even if you know amounts are
rationally know that you should go open for negotiation, and you feel in a
for a salad today, the fact that the strong position, that first exchange
sandwich is much easier to reach will will likely determine your attitude
influence your decision. It will take a during the selection process.
lot of willpower to patiently queue for
the salad. In other words, “the first thing
considered always carries more
Believing an idea might work is based on weight than it should.”
its availability. Can you communicate it
easily? Do you have the tools to start As Odean argues, most “deals”
tomorrow? Is its impact easy to operate on System 1, where we don’t
measure? have much time to think or make
complicated operations. Initial values
Both your team and your users will get will work as a benchmark for future
behind your features and products if ones. So be very careful in your initial
they feel like they’re simple and projections, even if you manage to
direct. A good marketing campaign justify costs with System 2 arguments
will appeal to System 2 thinking, but a and a thousand spreadsheets!
great roadmap will take into account
“The first thing Leveraging Cognitive Biases: 7
Steps
considered always
carries more weight Odean has a set of essential tips he
uses to avoid these biases. Check
than it should.” them out:
7. Play the Long Game - The people Things like averaging values, or
you are trying to persuade will championing simplicity, are permanent
most likely matter much more characteristics of the human thought.
than the decision you are trying to Facing your internal and external
stakeholders with this in mind will
persuade them of. Be prepared to
be persuaded if your audience is greatly facilitate your product plans.
more experienced, this will show
cooperation and help establish a For more examples of cognitive biases
relation for future interactions. and tips for how understanding them
can improve your persuasiveness,
check out Tyler Odean’s recommended
Summing Up: Don’t Ditch your reading Thinking Fast and Slow.
Tools, Change your Thinking!
If you want to watch Tyler Odean’s
One of the most common problems ProductCon SF full talk, watch it here.
with leadership in product management
guides is their tendency to overshoot.
They often list several approaches and
tools you can use to improve now.
Experimentation
(CLV), but they realized that they can’t
wait for 29 months to see whether
someone takes more or less time to
Byron Jones —
churn as a result of an experiment.
Ultimately, they turned to data science
Director of PM at Optimizely
to predict user CLV based on short-
term changes in behavior.
Byron Jones is a former NASA
Engineer who has brought his
knowledge and skills into the Product The Six Habits of Experimentation
Management realm. His NASA
background and five years as a PM at
Optimizely makes him well equipped Building these “Six Habits of
to provide advice on Building a Culture Experimentation” will help your
of Experimentation.
company gain usable data to make
better decisions and improve behavior
Jones posits that fostering experimentation quickly.
can lead to major growth if you have an
experimentation mindset and form 1. The first habit Jones speaks on is the
strong habits early on.
necessity of leaders asking about
experiment results. Jones says, "culture
Why Experimentation Matters starts from the top," so PMs must be
available and attentive to their team
members. This shows that ideas are
How do you know that a product, or a valued, giving them the confidence to
product change, is successful or not? work harder knowing they will be
Different people, different places, heard.
different experiences, it’s impossible to
control for all of the externalities that
2. Second, Jones says that teams can
make it difficult to explain the story
"protect" their ideas by framing them
your data is trying to tell you.
as experiments. This changes the
Experimentation is the only way to
conversation from risk and investment
systematically determine the effect that
to testing and data, allowing teams to
your product is going to have.
have more opportunities to capitalize
on promising ideas.
3. The third habit is that leaders should actions, you will see an increase in
always celebrate wins and losses; while experiments and an increase in
wins increase profit or have other successful decisions.
positive effects, losses allow for teams
to re-evaluate, re-test, and find a By implementing these six habits, you
solution. Jones refers to this as the will be able to build your own culture
Experimentation Singularity, where of experimentation at your venture,
experimentation becomes self- allowing for major growth and
reinforcing. innovation from your teams.
4. For the fourth habit, Jones says that If you want to listen to Byron Jones’ full
teams must hire for an experimentation ProductCon SF talk, watch it here.
mindset. He says this can be achieved by
requiring interviewees to present a data
set, and then, look for the applicant who
can best use context to tell a story about
the truth of the data.
With this broader framework in mind, The next step in the PM evolution is
let’s explore each “rung” on the PM “Doing work with help.” You’re no
ladder, and dive into the type of work longer in the entry position, you’re
and thinking what will be required now a full blown Product Manager.
from you at each level. Congrats! Sims said that now, it isn’t
about receiving help, rather, doing said that you must increase your team’s
work. performance through effective leadership.
At this point, you will be building Effective leadership means you need to
products from end to end and make sure you set the direction of an
interpreting massive amounts of data, entire company initiative using your
requiring you to proactively communicate own product philosophy. If your team
with your team. Lastly, Sims stated the doesn’t hold a unified philosophy, you
importance of instilling a vision in your may run into many inconsistencies
team and making sure you deflect between disciplines. Sims provided us
praise and absorb blame. with an example using her own
product philosophy:
Breger stated that having a diverse Lesson Eight: Scale Your Product
team is crucial to understanding your Team Thoughtfully, But Make Sure
They’re Ready for Success
users and developing the products they
want. By surrounding yourself with
team members who have a diverse Understand the stage of the product
background, you can create an and feature set that you have. Assign
environment where employees can the right people to the right areas
complement each other. This based on a clear strategy and roadmap.
introduces new perspectives, so you A fundamental aspect to forming a
can benefit from insights that you scalable team is making sure they're
wouldn’t be able to come up with on set up for success; it is easy for great
your own. ideas to be lost when teams aren't
given the resources or attention they
Lesson Six: Surround Yourself with need to succeed.
People Who Compliment You
Lesson Nine: Know What You’re
Looking for In Your Career, and Do
Surround yourself with people whose
strengths compliment your weaknesses, Everything to Make it Happen
and vice-versa. This requires you to be
honest about your own limitations, and PMs must have career goals and the
seek out people who have the talents motivation to achieve them. Without
and abilities that you lack. this growth mindset, you will become
stagnant and so will your team.
Lesson Seven: Put Smart People on Always have career goals and be on
Hard Projects, Don’t Worry About the lookout for opportunities to achieve
Background. them; your personal motivation will be
contagious to your employees,
facilitating a more productive and
Don’t worry about team members prosperous team. If you want to
backgrounds when assigning tasks, watch Breger’s ProductCon SF full
rather, put smart people on hard talk, watch it here.
How to Unleash Your
Lesson Learned at Adobe: Listen
Inner Leader to Your Gut
Kenneth Berger —
Fmr Product Manager, Slack Kenneth spent over 8 years at Adobe.
Starting as an enthusiastic newcomer
Everyone thinks leadership is determined to shake things up, he
something they are missing. People soon found himself as part of the “old
try and fill this perceived “hole” with guard.” He was comfortable with the
conferences, books, and articles on hours and the paycheck. So he stayed,
Medium. But Kenneth Berger explains despite the gut feeling that he wasn’t
that leadership does not come from a in the right place. Then, after 8 years,
book. It is not a missing skill. What Kenneth was laid off.
prevents most people from embracing
their leadership style are the limiting The key lesson here is to listen to your
beliefs that they don’t even know gut and be curious about what those
they have. inner feelings have to say. It can be a
little scary, because your gut is
probably telling you to break out of
What Beliefs Are Limiting Your your comfort zone. But the payoff is
Potential as a Leader? huge - it means you can work in a
way that is consistent with your
values. It means you’re fulfilled.
This is something that many people
aren’t comfortable thinking about,
but this is what is really holding us Lesson Learned at YesGraph: It’s
back.
Not Your Job to be Right
From working at a number of leading
Silicon Valley companies and having YesGraph is a startup co-founded by
both positive and negative experiences, Kenneth. His co-founder had an
Kenneth learned a number of key engineering background, Kenneth
lessons about leadership that we will had a design background. The
explore below. founders quickly fell into heated
arguments. It seemed critically
important to be right. The thing is, month. He asked what he could do to
the job of a founder isn’t to be right. make it right. He was reinstated, but
It’s to make a company successful. at a cost.
When the founders put being right
above being effective, the startup Suddenly, the work was imbued with
suffered. fear. It was clear that something had
not been right. After three months,
Your job is not about winning the Kenneth’s position was eliminated
argument in the meeting. It’s about and he was moved to another role.
the bigger stuff. When you let go of Kenneth fought for his old role, and
the good feeling that comes from again held onto the position. But the
fighting to be right and focus instead u n d e r ly i n g i s s u e s we r e n e ve r
on the bigger mission, that’s when resolved, and after another 9 months
you step into the role of being a Kenneth left Slack permanently.
leader.
The lesson here is to always discuss
Lesson Learned at Slack: Name the underlying causes of tension and
negativity. If they are not discussed,
the Elephant in the Room they only get bigger. Once you name
the “elephant,” it’s not an elephant
anymore. It’s just a regular business
When Kenneth left YesGraph, he was
problem. Good leaders name the hard
determined to avoid drama and focus
truths.
instead on putting his head down and
working. He believed in Slack from the
start. They were making an impact. Lesson Learned Coaching: You
But Kenneth didn’t fully understand
his job at the company. He thought it Choose Your Own Story
was conventional PM work: talking to
customers, determining features, etc. After leaving Slack after only a year,
Kenneth felt like a failure. But he
What Kenneth hadn’t realized was didn’t stay in this negative frame of
that Slack was the CEO’s “baby.” mind. He chose instead to tell his own
Kenneth wasn’t hired to write specs. story. He started writing and
He was hired to take care of this speaking. Slack wasn’t a failure, it
“baby.” And that’s a very different was an amazing achievement that
job description. Kenneth was almost came with many lessons. Kenneth
fired from Slack after about one
chose to define his own perspective, When you choose a perspective
and embrace new possibilities. where more is possible, you’re being
a visionary.
Kenneth learned that the value he
gained from his Product work often If you want to listen to Kenneth’ s
came down to offering people support ProductCon SF full talk, watch it
through one on one conversations. here.
When he realized the impact a simple
hour-long conversation could have
on someone’s life and career, he
knew that was the path for him. So he
became a coach. This was the
perspective that felt right for him.
Amrit Pal
Product Manager at Square
Watch the talk here
Byron Jones
Gayle McDowell
Director of Product at Optimizely Author of Cracking the PM Interview
Watch the talk here Watch the talk here
Kenneth Berger
Fmr Product Manager at Slack
Watch the talk here