Professional Documents
Culture Documents
19 Bleaching PDF
19 Bleaching PDF
BLEACHING 1
19.1 Purpose 1
19.5 Bibliography 27
19.5.1 General Information on Bleaching 27
19.5.2 Oxidative Bleaches . . ....... . ........... . 29
19.5.3 Reductive Bleaches 30
19.5.4 Light Bleaching 31
19. BLEACHING
Oxidation or reduction of discoloration within paper supports.
19.1 Purpose
Primarily one of restoration i.e., generally a cosmetic procedure used to diminish
discoloration which severely interferes with the visual integrity or original tone of
the object, but which cannot be diminished in any other relatively safe manner.
Less frequently, bleaching might be used to remove staining material which is
contributing to accelerated deterioration of the object (e.g., stains containing iron,
oils, etc.). In this second instance, bleaching may in some ways improve the
relative permanence of the paper.
19.2.1 Extent to Which the Same Effect can be Achieved with Another Method
Believed to be Safer
(Note: Since the potential for damage varies with the bleach, alternate
treatment method and object under consideration, it is important to
evaluate each combination separately.)
A. Risk to the object (i.e., change, degradation, etc.) and the conservator
(i.e., health and safety); many bleaches are toxic to the conservator or
may have a vigorous bubbling action which could disrupt paper
surfaces.
A. Hydrogen Peroxide
Formula: H2O2 (HOOH/HOO-).
Advantages: Can decolorize wood pulp stains and mat burn; can
convert darkened lead white to white lead sulfate (see 3. Media
Problems); only oxidizing bleach which can be used with lignin
containing papers; bleaching action is more controllable than that
obtained with chlorine bleaches; least reversion of all oxidizing
bleaches (i.e., less yellowing after bleaching) although with ligneous
papers reversion can still be rapid; fumehood not required unless
used with ether.
B. Hypochlorites
1. Calcium Hypochlorite
Formula: CaOCl.
Chloramine-B (N-chlorobenzenesulfonamido)
Formula: C7H7CINNaO2S (chloramine-T)
C6H5CINNaO2S (chloramine-B)
Mechanism: Solvent (water or alcohol) reacts with chloramine-T to
release hypochlorite; OCl works by chlorination and oxidation.
-
D. Chlorine Dioxide
Formula: ClO2.
E. Potassium Permanganate
Formula: KMnO4,
Mechanism: Oxidation.
C. Sodium Sulfite
Formula: NaSO3
D. Sodium Thiosulfate
Formula: Na2S2O4
A. Borohydrides
Chemicals in this group are effective bleaches, anti-chlors (the only
anti-chlorwebymvschloraine-Tdypts),
and chemical stabilizers of cellulose.
1. Sodium Borohydride
Formula: NaBH 4,
2. Tetramethylammonium Borohydride
Formula: N(CH3)4BH4.
Disposal:
19.3.4 Light
A. Natural Light
Mechanism: Most likely photo-oxidation; free radical pathways, like
H2O 2.
Preparation: Access to daylight; pure water with or without the
addition of chemicals to obtain alkaline pH; ethanol:water (e.g., 9:1
solution has been used in tests).
B. Artificial Light
Mechanism: See 19.3.4 A.
C. Balance
A. Synthetic brushes
B. Swabs
C. Cotton wads
D. Poultices
C. Floating screens
D. Suction table
F. UF3 Plexi
G. Hair dryer
A. Gloves
B. Respirator
C. Fumehood
D. Goggles
D. Thermometer
2. Suction Table
Repeat steps 1 and 2, above. 3) place object on table and wet
with water; allow the stabilizer to settle, if a colloidal silicate type
is used in bleach (for suction table work the addition of EDTA
(about 0.1 M) to bleach solution is preferred); spray clear
supernatant from settled solution (alternatively, use a clear
solution containing EDTA) on object to bleach object; if
bleaching is proceeding too rapidly in any area, selectively spray
with distilled, recalcified, or deionized water; wash extensively by
spraying with water; dry object; takesurface pH and deacidify
only if necessary and appropriate for specific object.
3. Local
a. Float Bleaching:
(Similar to float washing, see 16. Washing, to be published.)
Place relaxed paper on a support (screen, web, or Plexiglas)
and allow it to float on the meniscus of the water or of the
bleaching solution. If desired, and possible, stained edges can
be sunk, up to about one-half the surface area of the paper,
depending on its weight, absorbency, etc. Spot bleaching can
be done with a soft fine brush, spray, or cotton wad poultice.
Caution must be exercised when removing the item from the
19. Bleaching, page 21
b. Blotter Bleaching:
This is good for objects too fragile for immersion or floating
but which need even bleaching, but may not adequately
remove materials solubilized during bleaching process. It can
also substitute for a suction table if one is not available. The
technique is especially good for removing stains on the verso
of the object. A blotter is saturated with the bleaching
solution and the object, relaxed with moisture, is placed upon
it, and monitored until desired effect is achieved.
c. Spot Bleaching:
1. Suction table: (see 27. Suction Table Treatments, to be
published).
B. Hypochlorites
1. Calcium Hypochlorite
Applications are generally by immersion, but can be applied
locally or overall by many of the techniques already described
above. An example of one aqueous immersion technique is as
follows: 1) neutralize object before bleaching if it is acidic ,and
prepare three baths: an alkaline water bath (pH 9); a bleach bath
of 0.05% to 0.5% calcium hypochlorite; and an anti-chlor of a 1-
19. Bleaching, page 22
2. Sodium Hypochlorite
Application is generally by immersion, but can be applied locally
or overall by many of the techniques previously described.
D. Chlorine Dioxide
Fumehood is mandatory for health and safety of the conservator.
Aqueous applications are generally by immersion. A typical
immersion technique is as follows: 1) pretreat paper as necessary; 2)
prepare a 2% solution of sodium chlorite for every liter of solution
and add 15 ml to 25 ml of formalin solution (40% formaldehyde in
water for every liter of solution); 3) wearing respirator, immerse wet
object into bleach until just before desired effect is achieved; 4)
remove paper and rinse extensively in water (use of fumehood
recommended for washing procedure); 5) dry object and take surface
pH; 6) following bleaching deacidify in calcium hydroxide for 30
minutes if necessary and appropriate for object; 7) neutralize bleach
bath prior to disposal with 2-7% thiosulfate to eliminate any active
chemicals which may remain; test for chlorine residues with KI/I2
strips.
I. Borohydrides
As an anti-chlor, see 19.3.2 A.
K. Natural Light
Pretreat object as necessary (surface cleaning, washing, etc.); immerse
in purified water made alkaline with ammonium hydroxide (no
precipitate), magnesium or calcium bicarbonate; mask from sun
where necessary (e.g., cover with aluminum foil or polyester film with
white-out to block specific areas from sun; light-sensitive areas such
as signatures can be masked with starch paste or appropriate
fixative); cover with UF3 plexiglas or UV-stabilized Lexan, position
over top of tray at least one inch, with air space to avoid
condensation, and set in sunlight; additional bleaching will occur from
light reflected off the sides of white tubs; during 2-4 hours of
exposure, set-up should be monitored for changes in cast shadows,
temperature, or bath evaporation; blue wool standards may be placed
beside tray and/or under glass to monitor light intensity; rinse in
fresh bath after bleaching.
19. Bleaching, page 24
L. Artificial Light
Pretreat object as necessary (surface cleaning, washing, etc.); immerse
in purified, buffered water; expose to appropriate artificial lights (i.e.,
8 Sylvania cool white bulbs, 34 watts; 8 GE spectra bulbs, 40-100
watts; Norelco daylight, 34 watts, etc.); mask if necessary; turn object
over if necessary; expose anywhere from 2-12 hours (safest).
Bleaching can be done simultaneously on both sides of the object
using top and bottom light banks and a tray made of UV-stabilized
Lexan.
All of the currently available treatments with organic solvents use either
alcohol or ether which can be safer for the object by diminishing
bubbling or ink solubility etc.; frequently the only variation from the
aqueous method is that a different solvent is used. If alcohol is the
solvent, ethanol is the best choice for reasons of lower toxicity; always
test paper and image for sensitivity to solvent (color changes and/or
solubilization are possible); a fumehood is usually mandatory; proper
safety precautions should be observed in disposing of bleach and rinse
baths.
A. Hydrogen Peroxide
1. Immersion
1) Dilute reagent grade 30 or 50% hydrogen peroxide to 10%
with water and adjust solution to alkaline pH with ammonium
hydroxide (or other hydroxides), Na4EDTA, or carbonates of
magnesium or calcium; dilute with ethanol to desired
concentration of about 2.0-3.0%; 2) immerse solvent-safe object
and allow bleaching to proceed; 3) rinse object with alcohol.
2. Local
Spot bleaching, see 19.4.1 A.
D. Light
See 19.4.1 K.; bleaching efficiency seems to be approximately the
same regardless of percent of ethanol added to buffered water.
Certain amount of water should be tolerable as paper should be
rinsed in water to increase solubilization of acids produced during
bleaching.
A. Hydrogen Peroxide
1) Mix 10 ml of 30% hydrogen peroxide with 100 ml diethyl or
dipropyl ether in a glass container and cover (ether is toxic and
explosive); 2) let stand until the ether/peroxide portion starts to rise
(no more than 2-3. hr); 3) suspend the object on a screen over a tray
of the solution; 4) long term stability of object will be less if washing
cannot be carried out after bleaching.
B. Chlorine Dioxide
Gaseous chlorine dioxide was previously thought to be suitable for
water or solvent sensitive objects which cannot be washed; current
recommendation is that washing after bleaching is important to avoid
serious degradation and reversion of cellulose; gaseous methods have
been used for objects in which it was necessary to minimize exposure
to water and which had design elements which were likely to be
solubilized in the bleach bath. The chemical proportions given below
are from Gettens 1952 (smaller quantities of formaldehyde may
suffice): 1) dampen or humidify object (necessary for bleaching
action; also, ensures more even penetration); 2) mix 60 g sodium
chlorite in 3 liters water with 75 ml of 37% formaldehyde and pour
in deep tray; solution should turn yellow-green in less than 15 min; 3)
test stains with a swab moistened with solution; rinse test spot; 4)
wearing respirator place damp object on a screen suspended over the
19. Bleaching, page 26
Annis, A.K. and B.M. Reagan. "Evaluation of Selected Bleaching Treatments Suitable
for Historic White Cottons." Studies in Conservation, Vol. 24, No. 4, November
1979, pp. 171-178.
Barrow, W. J. "Test Data of Naturally Aged Papers." Permanence/Durability of the
Book -- II. Richmond, VA: N. J. Barrow Research Lab, Inc., 1964.
Burgess, H.D. "Relationships Between Colour Production in Cellulose and the Chemical
Changes Brought About by Bleaching." Postprints. Washington, DC: AIC-BPG,
1982, pp. 20-28.
Burgess, H.D. "The Use of Gel Permeation Chromatography in Investigating the
Degradation of Cellulose during Conservation Bleaching." C Preprints.
Washington, DC: IIC, 1982, 85ff.
Burgess, H.D. and IF Hanlan. 'The Degradation of Cellulose in Conservation Bleaching
Treatments." Journal of IIC-Canadian Group, Vol. 4, No. 2, 1979, pp. 15-22.
Casey, James P. Pulp and Paper. Vol. 1. 2nd printing. NY: Interscience Publishers, 1966.
19. Bleaching, page 28
Daniels, Vincent. "The Elimination of Bleaching Agents from Paper." The Paper
Conservator, Vol. 1, 1976, pp. 9-11.
Libby, C. Earl, ed. Pulp and Paper Science and Technology Vol. 1. NY: McGraw-Hill
Book Co., 1962.
Meller, A. "Oxidation by Chlorous Acid and Reduction by Sodium Borohydride of
Chemically Modified Celluloses." TAPPI, Vol. 38, No. 11, Nov. 1955, pp. 682-
687.
Rapson, W. Howard, ed. The Bleaching of Pulp. TAPPI Monograph Series, No. 27, New
York: TAPPI, 1963.
Rapson, W. H., C.B. Anderson and A. Magned, "Natural Aging of Laboratory Bleached
Pulps." TAPPI Paper Reservation Symposium, Washington, DC Oct. 1988, pp.
53-58.
Robson, H.L. "Bleaching Agents." Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology. 2nd ed.
Raymond E. Kirk, Herman F. Mark, John J. McKetta Jr., and Donald F.
Othmer, eds. New York: Interscience Publishers, 1963.
Santucci, L. "Degradation of Paper Treated with Oxidants." Problems of Conservation in
Museums. ICOM Traveaux et publications VIII, London: George Allan and
Unwin, Ltd., 1969.
19. Bleaching, page 29
Singh, R. P., ed. The Bleaching of Pulp. 3rd Ed. TAPPI Monograph Series, Atlanta, GA:
TAPPI Press, 1979.
Sutermeister, Edwin. Chemistry of Pulp and Pa p er Makin , 2nd ed. London: John Wiley
& Sons, Inc., 1929.
Watters, Mark and Irene Preston. "The Bleaching of Paper Pulps in the Paper Industry."
Unpublished annotated bibliography, Conservation Center Institute of Fine Arts,
New York University, 1978.
Agnihotri, V.G. "Chemistry of Hydrogen Peroxide Bleaching." Textile Dyer and Printer,
September 1975, pp. 39-40.
Ash, Nancy. "A Note on the Use of Magnesium Bicarbonate in Hydrogen Peroxide
Solutions." BPG Annual Volume 2. Washington, DC: AIC, 1983.
Banks, Paul N. "Paper Cleaning." Journal of the Guild of Book Workers, Vol. V, No. 1,
1966.
Gettens, John R. 'The Bleaching of Stained and Discolored Pictures on Paper with
Sodium Chlorite and Chlorine Dioxide." Museum, Vol. 5, No. 2, 1952.
Hofenk-de Graaf, Judith. 'The Effect of Chloramine-T on Paper." ICOM Preprints 4th
Triennial Meeting. Venice, 1975, 75/15/4.
Holst, G., "The Chemistry of Bleaching and Oxidizing Agents," Chemical Reviews, Vol.
54, 1954, pp. 168-94.
Lewin, H. and J.A. Epstein. "Functional Groups and Degradation of Cotton Oxidized by
Hypochlorite." Journal of Polymer Science, Vol. 58, 1962.
Schumb, W.C., C.N. Scatterfield, and R.N. Wentworth. Hydrogen Peroxide. New York:
Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1955.
Burgess, Helen. "The Bleaching Efficiency and Color Reversion of Three Borohydride
Derivatives." AIC Preprints, Milwaukee, 1982, pp. 40-48.
Mayer, W.C. and C.P. Donofrio. "Reductive Bleaching of Mechanical Pulp with Sodium
Boronydride." Pulp and Paper, October, 1958.
Baker, C. "Practical Methods for Sun and Artificial Light Bleaching Paper." AIC Book
and Paper Group Postprints, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, May 1982.
Baker, C. "The Double-Sided Light Bleaching Bank." AIC Book and Paper Group
Annual, 4, 1986, pp. 88-91.
Branchick, T., K. Keyes and C.F. Tahk. "A Study of the Bleaching of Naturally Aged
Paper by Natural and Artificial Light." AIC Preprints, 1982, Milwaukee, p. 29 ff.
Eldridge, B.P. "A Sun Bleaching Project." AIC Book and Paper Postprints, Milwaukee,
May 1982, pp. 1-4.
Feller, Robert L., S.B. Lee, and J. Bogaard. "Bleaching by Light: Effect of pH on the
Bleaching or Darkening of Papers Both in the Dry and Immersed Condition
Under Visible and Under Near Ultraviolet Radiation." Conservation of Historic
and Artistic Works on Paper Abstracts. Ottawa, Canada: CCI, October 3-7, 1988.
Feller, Robert L., S.B. Lee, and J. Bogaard. "Bleaching by Light: Studies of the
Bleaching of Thermally Discolored Sugars and Other "Model" Compounds."
Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works on Paper Abstracts. Ottawa, Canada:
CCI, October 3-7, 1988.
Feller, Robert L., S.B. Lee, and J. Bogaard. "Relation of Cellulose Chain Scission to Hot
Alkali Soluble Content during Thermal and Photochemical Degradation in
Paper." Journal of Imaging Science, Vol. 29, No. 2, March/April 1985, pp. 61-64.
Feller, R.L, S.B. Lee, and J. Bogaard. "The Darkening and Bleaching of Paper by
Various Wavelengths in the Visible and Ultraviolet." AIC Book and Paper
Postprints, Milwaukee, May 1982, pp. 65.
"Stains that I have locally bleached include: mat burns that impinged
on the design, especially in modern works; oily stains that inhibited
the enjoyment of old master works; foxing stains in fine art in
prominent locations on the sheet; discoloration from [wooden]
backing shingles that created sharp contrasts between general sheet
tone and severe discoloration.
C. "I believe strongly in the value of stain removal, using a bleach only
as a last resort. Bleaching is relative, and it should be contemplated
only if the media are sound and if the paper, especially the texture,
19. Bleaching, page 35
will not be affected. Too many bleached objects are cold white, soft
and wooly after treatment because too many conservators have
focused on the stain and ignored the lustrous, hard, creamy areas of
undamaged paper. The sacrifice of the latter in the service of
removal of the former can never be justified. These judgments are
made through experience, which often provides its surprises. I have
tried to learn from these. Nothing in my experience matches
sunbleaching, for ease of control and for aesthetic quality of result.
These two criteria, plus the subjective satisfaction derived from not
putting chemicals into the paper, have made me reject almost all
other bleaches. I retain hydrogen peroxide because of its ease for
local application and its apparent relative safety. I would never
bleach anything which cannot be rinsed; fortunately the suction disk
permits local rinsing." (MC)
19.6.3 Treatments
A. "I have noticed that residue from Na Borohydride bleaching may be
detectable with ultra-violet light. I saw a whitish fluorescence when
examining a drawing on green paper with U.V. after matline
reduction. Repeated rinsing with water removed fluorescing residues.
With light white or off-white papers this fluorescence may not be
detectable." (NA)
C. "The most common stains I bleach are pressure sensitive tape stains,
mat burns and foxing stains. Overall sunstaining and cardboard burns
are also candidates for light bleaching if washing has not satisfactorily
reduced the offending discoloration.
"I generally light bleach in a plain water bath. I have had bad
experiences with carbonates forming on the surface of the art works
during light bleaching so I have shied away from incorporating them
in the bleaching bath. In addition, the water in my area [Fort Worth,
Texas] is relatively high in carbonates. This may explain why I have
noticed no difference in effectiveness of bleaching since I started
using plain water.
"I am loath to expose any colored inks to the light and will commonly
mask off colored areas. Effective masks can be constructed of Mylar
and water insoluble markers or blotter cutouts. Tape stains are
commonly treated in this manner, masking the entire object and
creating only a small "window of vulnerability" (to quote Keiko
Keyes) that is exposed to the light.
Contributors: Cathy Baker, Karl Buchberg, Marjorie Cohn, Theresa Fairbanks, Chris
Foster, Antoinette King, John Krill, Holly Krueger, Debora Mayer, Gina McKay Lodge,
Jill Sterrett, Mark Stevenson, Judith Walsh.