ASL Literature Critique for Stories with Handshape Constraints Rubric

Poor Needs Work Acceptable Excellent/Advanced

Analysis Lack of critical thinking Weak critical thinking Good critical thinking In depth critical
analysis, don’t have analysis, few specific analysis, some specific thinking analysis,
specific strengths and strengths and strengths and excellent specific
weaknesses, don’t weaknesses, provides weaknesses, provides strengths and
have examples to few examples to some examples to weaknesses, provides
support strengths and support strengths and support strengths and many examples to
weaknesses. weaknesses. weaknesses. support strengths and
weaknesses.
Weight: 80% Points: 0-10 Points: 11-20 Points: 21-30 Points: 31-40
Evaluation Poor evaluation, Weak evaluation, Good evaluation, clear Excellent evaluation,
doesn’t explain why doesn’t clearly explain explanation of why very detailed
you like or don’t like why you like or don’t you like or don’t like explanation of why you
the work. like the work. the work. like or don’t like the
work.
Weight: 20% Points: 0-3 Points: 4-6 Points: 7-8 Points: 9-10