Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This is a critical moment in human history, Raghuram G. Rajan argues, when wrong
choices could derail human economic progress.
The Third Pillar asks tough questions: why, when economies of developed countries
are growing, do we feel such economic despair? Why, when exciting new technolo-
gies on the horizon promise to solve our most intractable problems, is unhappiness
so widespread? What about shrinking opportunities for a large mass of people? Why
are even well-educated workers who hold decent middle-class jobs so disheartened?
What is the way forward?
The Third Pillar is about the three pillars that support society and how we can restore
the right balance between them so that society prospers. Two of the pillars are the
usual suspects: the state and markets. It is the neglected third pillar, the community,
that Dr Rajan reintroduces into the debate. Dr Rajan argues that many of the eco-
nomic and political concerns today across the world, including the rise of populist
nationalism, can be traced to the diminution of the community. The state and mar-
kets have expanded their powers and reach in tandem, and left the community rela-
tively powerless.
Dr Rajan departs from traditional thinking. The economy is not based on just two
struts—markets and governments—but also depends on a neglected third: the local
community. Neglecting social issues is not just myopic, Rajan argues, it is dangerous.
He calls for a return to empowering local communities as an antidote to growing
despair and unrest.
Society suffers when any of the pillars weakens or is overly strengthened, relative to
the others. Too weak the markets and society becomes unproductive, too weak a com-
munity and society tends toward crony capitalism, too weak the state and society turns
fearful and apathetic. Conversely, too much market and society becomes inequitable,
too much community and society becomes static, and too much state and society
becomes authoritarian. Therefore, a balance is essential, and Dr Rajan presents a way
to achieve it.
In a section focused on India, Dr Rajan observes that India, with its more
pluralistic and open-access political system, is better positioned for the com-
munity to create more separation between the state and markets. Its weakest
pillar is the state. India also has a private sector that is still dependent on the
state, which makes it a feeble constraint on it. So India has the paradox of
having an ineffective but only moderately limited state. India’s challenge in the
years to come is not its democracy, which is probably the only way to keep a
country with such varied communities together, but the need to strengthen
both state capacity and private-sector independence.
Dr Rajan discusses how to harness the strengths of a vibrant but chaotic de-
mocracy, why India has not done as well as China and the threat of populist
nationalism, predicting that a democratic, open, tolerant India will be an im-
portant, responsible contributor to global governance in the decades to come,
though populist nationalism around the world will make this less likely.
Released in September 2017 by HarperCollins India, I Do What I Do has sold over 100,000
copies in India.
A strikingly insightful analysis of the penalties of neglecting the critically important role
of community, by concentrating too much on the perceived efficiency of the markets and
the state. Rajan brings out loudly and clearly why this imbalance needs urgent correction.
– Amartya Sen, Nobel Prize Winner in Economic Science
My parents lived through the Great Depression, the rise in Fascism and World War II. I
thought I was brought up in a world organised in a fundamentally different way. I was
wrong. We all need to start thinking about this issue right now and this book is a place
to begin.
– James A. Robinson, co-author of Why Nations Fall
The Third Pillar offers an insightful perspective into our most pressing challenges. This book
offers a way forward for all of us. Essential reading for anyone interested in how econo-
mies can and should function.
– Linda Yueh, author of The Great Economists
Few economists span the world of policy and scholarship with such distinction, and fewer
still have been so consistently right about the wrong turns the world economy has taken.
Rajan presents a bold, original version that significantly advances our contemporary
debate on the ills of democracies and movies it onto new terrain.
– Dani Rodrik, Professor, Harvard University and author of The Globalization Paradox
Raghuram Rajan has done it again. Fresh, insightful and engaging, The Third Pillar offers a
brilliant reckoning with one of the today’s most important and potentially crippling chal-
lenges.
– Mohamed El-Erian, Author of When Markets Collide and The Only Game in Town
The Third Pillar is a must-read for everyone seeking a way to preserve democracy as we’ve
known it.
– Janet Yellen, Chair of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve 2014–18