Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Elegans 413
Sensory neurons
Interneurons Tail
Head Command interneurons
Motor neurons
Nerve ring
Amphid sensillum
AIY AIZ
RIA
RIB
RIM
PVC AVD
AVB AVA
AVE
B A
Forward Backward
Figure 1 Schematic diagram of the main components of the neural circuits that mediate mechanosensory, chemosensory, and
thermosensory behaviors that have been studied in learning and memory paradigms in C. elegans. Chemical synaptic connections are
represented by lines with arrowheads, while electrical gap junctions are represented by lines terminating in ovals. From Giles AC, Rose
JK, and Rankin CH et al. (2006) Investigations of learning and memory in Caenorhabditis elegans. Neurobiology of C. elegans.
International Review of Neurobiology 69: 37–71.
at 30 s, 5 min, and 10 min after delivery of the last Genes involved in short-term habituation Thus far,
tap. Short-term habituation differs depending upon four genes have been shown to be important for short-
the ISI used (Figure 2). Short ISI produce deep levels term habituation to tap: eat-4, encoding a homolog of
of habituation that show rapid spontaneous recov- the mammalian glutamate vesicular transporter,
ery, whereas long ISI produce intermediate levels of VGlut1; cat-2, encoding a homolog of the mammalian
habituation that show slower spontaneous recovery. tyrosine hydroxylase; dop-1, encoding a homolog
These behaviorally different forms of short-term habit- of the mammalian type 1 dopamine receptor; and
uation are hypothesized to correlate with multiple hab-1, whose gene product has yet to be identified.
molecular forms of short-term memory. The eat-4 mutant worms show normal response to tap
Learning and Memory in Invertebrates: C. Elegans 415
2.5 10 s interstimulus interval by spaced training. The protocol for spaced training
in C. elegans that induces LTM consists of four blocks
X Reversal magnitude (mm)
Trained 20 20 20 20
taps taps taps taps
10
24 h test
taps
Control 1
tap
a
Wild-type eat-4
120 120
% Control response
% Control response
**
60 60
0 0
Mean Mean
nmr-1 glr-1
120 120
% Control response
% Control response
**
60 60
0 0
b Mean Mean
Control
c Trained
Figure 3 Long-term memory (LTM) paradigm and corresponding genetic analysis. (a) Protocol for spaced training in C. elegans that
induces LTM. Trained worms receive four blocks of 20 taps administered at a 60 s ISI with a 1 h rest period between each training block,
while control worms receive one tap. After 24 h, ten taps are administered to both control and trained worms to test for memory. Memory is
seen when trained worms show significantly smaller responses than do control worms. (b) Mean reversal lengths of wild-type worms and
of eat-4, nmr-1, and glr-1 mutants during the ten test taps, 24 h after training, measured as a percentage of control reversal lengths for
trained and control worms. Wild-type and nmr-1 mutants show normal LTM, whereas eat-4 and glr-1 do not. (c) Fluorescent imaging of a
GLR-1–GFP fusion protein 24 h after LTM training in trained and untrained control worms. GLR-1 expression levels are observed to
decrease for trained worms. Scale bar ¼ 20 mm.
Chemosensory Learning and Memory The neural circuit that mediates chemotaxis has
been mapped (Figure 1) and consists of many more
Worms are attracted and migrate toward cations,
sensory neurons than do the other behaviors dis-
anions, cyclic nucleotides, and volatile chemicals; this cussed in this article. In total, 11 pairs of sensory
behavior is termed chemotaxis (Figure 4). Chemotaxis neurons in the head region of the worm are respon-
is usually measured through either one of two com-
sible for chemotaxis. Eight pairs have sensory endings
mon assays: the first is orientation, quantified by
that are in contact with the external environment and
tracking the path of individual worms as they migrate
for the most part detect water-soluble attractants.
toward or away from a chemical, and the second
The additional three pairs are enclosed in the amphid
is accumulation, quantified by counting the number
sheath and their main role is to detect volatile chemicals.
of worms that collect at the location of the chemical.
Because these 11 pairs of neurons respond to such a
This behavior has been found subject to several forms large number of different chemical substances, it is
of learning in C. elegans: habituation to low levels of thought that single chemosensory neurons are capable
odorants, state-dependent adaptation to high levels of
of detecting multiple chemicals, and, further, this
odorants, classical conditioning, and aversive learning.
Learning and Memory in Invertebrates: C. Elegans 417
Training Testing
Stimulus
Chemotaxis No preexposure
Control
Dishabituating
Adaptation stimulus*
and Preexposure
habituation to stimulus
State-
dependent
Preexposure cue absent
State-dependent to stimulus
learning and state-
dependent cue
State-
dependent
cue present
CS+
Classical
conditioning
CS−
Figure 4 Schematic diagram of chemotaxis and the adaptation, habituation, state-dependent learning, and classical conditioning
paradigms. In chemotaxis, worms migrate toward an attractive odor (green) such as diacetyl, rather than to a control stimulus (blue) such
as water. Adaptation and habituation are produced by preexposing worms to an attractive chemical stimulus for an extended period of
time. When worms are later tested for chemotaxis they no longer show a preference for that chemical over a control chemical. Adaptation
is induced by exposing worms to high concentrations of the stimulus, whereas habituation to Naþ or diacetyl is induced by exposure low
concentrations. Once worms are habituated to Naþ or diacetyl they can be dishabituated* by exposing them briefly to a high concentration
of that chemical; this does not occur for adaptation. In the paradigm for state-dependent learning starved or inebriated worms are
preexposed to an odor and learn to associate this odor with their physiological state. Thus, when worms are later exposed to that odor they
only show adaptation when they are in the same physiological state as when they were preexposed. In the differential classical
conditioning paradigm worms are first preexposed to an odor (conditioned stimulus, CSþ; green) in the presence of food (unconditioned
stimulus, US) and then preexposed to another odor without food (CS; red). When worms are later placed in the presence of both odors
they show a preference for the odor that was previously paired with food (CSþ).
suggests that one site of plasticity for chemotaxis behav- State-dependent learning C. elegans can show state-
ior may be intraneuronal. dependent learning – that is to say, they can make
associations between their physiological state and
Adaptation
stimuli in their environment (Figure 4). Worms can
Adaptation, a decrease in responding after lengthy associate a feeding state or an inebriated state,
exposure to a stimulus (i.e., no longer noticing an induced by ethanol, with adaptation to an odor.
odor after a long exposure to it), itself is not consid- When starved worms are preexposed to odor, in this
ered learning; however, it can have associations case benzaldehyde, they show greater adaptation to
formed so that it plays a role in associative learning that odor than do unstarved control worms. When
in experiments of state dependency. In the adaptation worms are preexposed to the odor in the presence of
paradigm worms are exposed to a high concentration an excess of food, they show less adaptation than
of a particular odorant for a determined period, called do control worms. The neurotransmitter serotonin,
the adaptation period. After the worms are moved to a which is known to be important in other feeding-
chemotaxis assay plate (test odorant on one side and a state-dependent behaviors, has been shown to mediate
control substance on the other) (Figure 4), the chemo- this feeding-state-dependent association. Similar to
taxis index ((number migrated to test number the feeding-state experiments, inebriated worms pre-
migrated to control)/total number) is measured. exposed to an odor only show adaptation to that odor
418 Learning and Memory in Invertebrates: C. Elegans
when they are tested in the presence of inebriating subunit has also been shown to be an important gene
doses of ethanol. for chemosensory learning: glr-1 mutants show defi-
ciencies for both chemotactic habituation and differen-
Habituation
tial classical conditioning. Last, mutations in the gene
Habituation to some chemosensory stimuli can also hen-1, whose gene product is a low-density lipoprotein
be observed in C. elegans. Preexposure to weak con- (LDL) receptor-like secretory protein, lead to abnormal
centrations of either Naþ or diacetyl causes the sensory integration of chemosensory signals and no
worms to habituate to that chemical; this can be observed learning.
observed as a decreased percentage of worms migrat-
ing in the direction of the chemical stimulus. This Aversive Learning
habituation can be differentiated from adaptation One of the most recent forms of learning discovered
by the application of a dishabituating stimulus, a in C. elegans is the capacity to modify its chemo-
short exposure to a higher concentration of the chemi- sensory preferences after being exposed to pathogenic
cal. This brief exposure immediately reverses the bacteria. This means that C. elegans can learn to
behavior such that an increase in the percentage of avoid odors or tastes associated with familiar patho-
worms migrating in the direction of the weak concen- genic bacteria and in turn increase its preference for
tration of the chemical stimulus is seen (Figure 4). odors or tastes associated with familiar nonpatho-
This does not occur for adaptation. Whether worms genic bacteria. In this paradigm, worms were placed
habituate to either Naþ or diacetyl or adapt to these on pathogenic bacteria for 4 h and subsequently for
chemical stimuli is determined by the concentration 4 h on nonpathogenic bacteria. This was followed by
of the chemical. Habituation is seen at low concen- a choice test whereby half of the agar plate contained
trations of these chemicals, whereas adaptation is the pathogenic bacteria and the other half contained
seen at higher concentrations. the nonpathogenic bacteria. Worms were observed to
avoid the pathogenic bacteria and were attracted
Classical Conditioning
to the nonpathogenic bacteria. This study also identi-
Differential classical conditioning, a form of associa- fied serotonin and the gene mod-1, the gene product
tive learning, has been shown to exist in C. elegans. of which is a serotonin-gated chloride channel, as
The first paradigm used to investigate this type of important components to this behavior.
learning consisted of preexposing worms to two
odors and pairing one odor with (conditioned stimu-
Thermotactic Learning and Memory
lus; CSþ) and the other odor without (CS) food.
After training, worms placed on a test plate that Behavioral plasticity has also been shown in
contain both the CSþ and CS odors significantly C. elegans for thermotactic behavior. Thermotaxis is
preferred the odor which had been paired with food defined as movement toward or away from a thermal
(Figure 4). Differential classical conditioning can also stimulus. Worms can learn to associate a particular
be demonstrated by pairing an aversive stimulus, such temperature with the presence or absence of food.
as garlic, with the CSþ odor. In this paradigm worms This can be measured by placing the worms on a tem-
significantly prefer the CS odor that was not paired perature gradient; if the worms have recently been well
with the aversive stimulus. Since the development of fed in an environment at a constant temperature they
these paradigms, several others have been intoduced. will migrate to this temperature when placed on the
These include pairing odors with feeding states and gradient (Figure 5). Conversely, if the worms have
tastes. Thus, these studies illustrate that the small recently experienced starvation at a constant tempera-
worm with its tiny nervous system is capable of com- ture they will avoid this temperature when placed on the
plex chemosensory learning. gradient. This behavior is termed isothermal tracking.
The circuit that mediates thermotaxis has been
Genes involved in classical conditioning Several mapped and consists of one pair of anterior sensory
genes identified by means of genetic screens and neurons (AFD) in the head region that project to several
behavioral investigations are important for differen- anterior interneurons (AIY, AIZ, and RIA) which com-
tial classical conditioning. Two as yet unidentified pute the information (Figure 1). Through laser ablation
genes, lrn-1 and lrn-2, show normal chemotaxis and experiments it has been demonstrated that AIY may
chemotactic habituation but are deficient for condi- signal for thermotaxis to warmer temperatures, while
tioning. As discussed earlier, the glutamate receptor AIZ may signal for thermotaxis to cooler temperatures.
subunit, GLR-1, is important for LTM for habituation These two interneurons converge onto RIA, which
to mechanosensory stimulus; the gene for this receptor is proposed to be a site of thermotactic integration.
Learning and Memory in Invertebrates: C. Elegans 419
such as tax-2, tax-4, ttx-3, and lin-11, which have This rich learning and memory repertoire exhibited
mutations in genes that encode cyclic nucleotide- by C. elegans along with its mapped nervous system
gated channels and transcription factors (Figure 5). and fully sequenced genome make it an ideal inverte-
To investigate mutants defective for forming asso- brate model organism to study learning and memory.
ciations between temperature and food a genetic Other advantages to using C. elegans for this are
screen was done that looked for worms abnormal the plethora of mutants available for analysis, the
for updating their isothermal tracking. From this, increasing number of fluorescent fusion proteins for
three mutants, aho-1, aho-2, and aho-3, were identi- studying protein localization and function, and
fied. These mutants show normal thermotaxis when homology between worms and higher organisms.
they are cultivated in a well-fed state, but they cannot These all suggest that important findings on learning
learn to avoid the cultivation temperature if they are and memory of general interest are possible and very
conditioned in a starved state. The deficit exhibited likely using the worm as a model system.
by these mutants implies that these mutations inter-
fere with associating the encoded temperature with See also: Conditioning: Theories; Cyclic AMP (cAMP) Role
the feeding state, but does not interfere with the in Learning and Memory; Long-Term Potentiation (LTP):
encoding of the temperature itself. Thus, on top Mossy Fiber cAMP-Dependent Presynaptic LTP; Operant
of identifying genes involved in this learning para- Conditioning of Reflexes; Procedural Learning: Classical
digm, this screen also illustrates that the two aspects Conditioning.
of thermotaxis exist (the thermal memory and the
associative learning).
Several other genes implicated in thermotaxis have
Further Reading
been also been identified. One such gene encodes De Bono M and Maricq AV (2005) Neuronal substrates of complex
neuronal calcium sensor-1 (NCS-1); ncs-1 mutants behaviors in C. elegans. Annual Review of Neuroscience 28:
perform cryophilically on the thermotactic learning 451–501.
Giles AC, Rose JK, and Rankin CH (2006) Investigations of
assay. Selective rescue of NCS-1 in the AIY inter- learning and memory in Caenorhabditis elegans. Neurobiology
neuron led to a full behavioral recovery. Rescue of of C. elegans. International Review of Neurobiology 69: 37–71.
NCS-1 in AIY with a transgene containing a point Hobart O (2003) Behavioral plasticity in C. elegans: Paradigms,
mutation in the calcium-binding region did not result circuits, genes. Journal of Neurobiology 54: 203–223.
in a behavioral recovery, suggesting that intracellular Mohri A, Kodama E, Kimura KD, et al. (2005) Genetic control
of temperature preference in the nematode Caenorhabditis
calcium signaling in the AIY interneuron may be impor- elegans. Genetics 169: 1437–1450.
tant for thermotactic learning. Lastly, hen-1 (shown to Mori I (1999) Genetics of chemotaxis and thermotaxis in the
play a role in chemosensory learning) is also involved in nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Annual Review of Genetics
thermotaxis learning. Mutants deficient for this gene 33: 399–422.
will migrate to their cultivation temperature indepen- Rankin CH (2002) From gene to identified neuron to behavior in
Caenorhabditis elegans. Nature Reviews Genetics 3: 622–630.
dent of the feeding state with which it was previously Rankin CH, Beck DO, and Chiba CM (1990) Caenorhabditis
paired. The involvement of HEN-1 in both chemosen- elegans: A new model system for the study of learning and
sory and thermotactic learning provides support for a memory. Behavioural Brain Research 37: 89–92.
role of this protein in general sensory integration. Riddle DL, Blumenthal T, Meyer BJ, et al. (1997) C. elegans. II.
Cold Spring Harbor, NY: Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press.
Rose JK and Rankin CH (2001) Analyses of habituation in
Conclusion Caenorhabditis elegans. Learning & Memory 8: 63–69.
Steidl S, Rose JK, and Rankin CH (2003) Stages of memory in the
Investigations into behavioral plasticity in C. elegans nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Behavioral and Cognitive
have demonstrated that this simple worm is capable Neurosciences Review 2: 3–14.
of many forms of learning and memory in a variety of Wood WB (1988) The Nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Cold
sensory modalities. Simple forms of learning include Spring Harbor, NY: Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press.
Zhang Y, Lu H, and Bargmann CI (2005) Pathogenic bacteria
chemosensory and mechanosensory habituation and induce aversive olfactory learning in Caenorhabditis elegans.
dishabituation. The complex learning behaviors Nature 438: 179–184.
exhibited by the worm include classical conditioning,
context conditioning, state-dependent learning, and
aversive learning. Several important genes for these Relevant Websites
behaviors have already been identified and investiga- http://elegans.swmed.edu – Caenorhabditis elegans World Wide
tions into identifying other genes continue, as do Web server (University of Texas, Southwestern Medical Center).
studies attempting to link the molecular mechanisms http://www.wormbase.org – WormBase (Cold Spring Harbor
responsible for learning and memory. Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, NY).