Professional Documents
Culture Documents
£1500
Race bikes
How fast and light a bike can you get for around
£1500? Paul Vincent and Cara Coolbaugh find out
On test
Scott CR1 Team £1,549 PBK Team 2007 £1,499 Focus Cayo Exp £1,399 Condor Bellissima £1,299
H
ad you asked us a year ago to gaze
into a crystal ball, we would have
In the wake The Scott CR1 Team builds on the
predicted the widespread return of of stiff exciting ride of the original C1
aluminium as a high-end frame
material. Back then, all the signs were
competition
that the shortfall in the availability of from web-
carbon fibre would by now have made
carbon bike frames at this price
based sellers,
uneconomical. But having seen prices some of the
drop in recent months to previously
unheard of levels, the message is to enjoy
biggest
the carbon party while you can. names have
In the wake of stiff competition from
web-based sellers, some of the biggest
raised the
names in the cycle industry have, in bar for value
recent months, raised the bar for value
for money. While until very recently it
for money
was quite reasonable to expect to get a
carbon bike based on Shimano’s ‘entry-
level race’ 105 groupset for £1,500, it is
now possible to bag one equipped with Neat features like these
pro-level Dura-Ace components for the aluminium dropouts
same money. give the Scott frame a
For this month’s test, we have chosen classy look
Curved rear seatstays three full carbon framed cycles: the Scott
are believed to help CR1 Team and two bikes from website-
dissipate vibration based brands PBK and Wiggle, the top-
of-the-range PBK Team and the second
from top Focus Cayo Expert.
Because carbon bikes with female-
specific geometry start above our £1500
price point, we have selected the Condor
Bellissima that is based on an aluminium
The PBK has frame, with carbon seatstays and a
the highest carbon fork. The Bellissima is Condor’s
first women-specific frame, but many in
groupset their vast men’s range come in sizes
specification down to 46cm too. With a personalised
fitting as part of the package, Condor
that we make a comfortable riding position a
have seen real priority. The big question, though, is
how the Bellissima stands up among a
on a bike at stable full of carbon lightweights.
this price
Frame
Scott 9 PBK 8 Focus 9 Condor 9
Six years ago Scott found a way of
producing a carbon frame, the C1,
without using lugs, the normal method
WHEELS
Scott 8 PBK 8 Focus 8 Condor 9 Our test shows that if you can
Both the Scott and PBK are specified
stretch your budget to around the
with Mavic’s well proven entry-level
£1,500 mark youll get even better
Aksium Race wheels. These, and the
value for money
Shimano equivalent WH-R500
wheels, are specified on more
production bikes than any other and Racing 7s, which isn’t a criticism tyres are designed for high mileage into a longer one. The stiff and
are neither light nor interesting to because the 7s kick off the range riders. We found they rolled well responsive ride character is
look at, but curiously manage to ride with a high level of quality, and and also felt grippy in the corners thankfully one notch down from the
faster than you would expect. This each successive wheelset is lighter thanks to the slightly softer rubber extreme end of the stiffness
can be attributed to high spoke and pricier. The rear wheel is the compound on the shoulders. No spectrum, where the Isaac Sonic and
tensions and a design that aims to newer Evolution model that boasts punctures during testing either. new Principia Ellipse Carbon lie,
reduce the amount of dishing a 90g loss of weight, fewer spokes though we still found ourselves
needed on the rear wheel, thus and a refined hub body over the HANDLING skirting around road surface
increasing stiffness. 2006 version. Both front and rear Scott 9 PBK 8 Focus 9 Condor 8 irregularities to avoid numb fingers
The hubs use cartridge bearings wheels have 24 spokes each and The original Scott C1 (tested back and a sore backside.
and are relatively new to the Mavic Fulcrum hubs with well sealed in issue 147, August 2003) gave an The Scott’s outright stiffness
range, and we have had no cause to cartridge bearings. Rims are injection of excitement, and the makes it feel more planted to the
question their quality. thoughtfully manufactured for a CR1 Team builds on that with an road and stiffer than the PBK,
The Continental UltraRaces are precise balance with two oversized even greater sense of smooth particularly at racing speeds, and
listed as high mileage tyres with a spokes running opposite the join. refinement that makes you want to while we expected the thin fork
180 TPI casing and Kevlar beneath Hutchinson’s Quartz 700x23c turn your hour-long training run blades to create some unwanted flex
the tread. Fitted to the Scott, they on fast downhill sections, this wasn’t
behaved well when driven hard into the case. The steering also proved to
corners and hung on well to rain- The PBK has a top quality Dura-Ace groupset, be pin-point accurate when leaning
soaked surfaces. The PBK’s Vittoria but the lack of other chainring options loses hard into corners.
Rubino Pro tyres also performed it points, while the Focuss finishing The PBK’s upright riding position
well on wet surfaces and they kit earns it top marks and compliant, user-friendly ride
continue to be one of the best budget place it firmly in the sportive
tyres available. category. It dampens road shocks
Easton have huge experience in before they get through to the rider’s
the design and manufacture of contact points, although in this
handlebars, stems and tubing, but respect it is harder to feel that telltale
are relatively new to wheel
production. Despite this lack of
experience, their mid-range Ascent 2 JARGON BUSTERS
wheel is one of the best we have Folding bead Kevlar is used in place of a
come across at any price. The Vista steel-reinforcing bead to save tyre weight
wheels on the Cayo represent the Compact chainset Smaller chainrings –
entry point on the Easton range. usually 34/50t (teeth) – that make it easier
They use stainless steel j-bend to tackle hills than a traditional 39/53t
spokes – 20 at the front, 24 at the High modulus carbon A top quality
rear – all radially laced apart from carbon thats stiffer than a medium
the two-cross pattern on the modulus but not necessarily stronger
driveside of the rear wheel. The rim Lugs Angled sockets that the frame tube
is a 30mm depth in a v-section and ends fit into to join them all together
the hubs use cartridge bearings. Steerer Fork tube the stem attaches to
Both wheels remained perfectly true In-line seatpost The seatpost clamp is at
throughout the test. The Michelin the top of the tube as opposed to behind it,
Lithion tyres fitted are the most as with a set back/laid back post
reasonably priced tyres from the Dishing Term for the way the spokes on the
French firm and have a folding bead cassette side of a rear wheel are shorter and
and eco-friendly silica tread. more steeply angled than the other side
The Bellissima’s Fulcrum Racing Toe overlap When the riders feet brush the
5s are unflashy but good looking front tyre when turning slowly
wheels that are well suited to the Two-cross Where each spoke is crossed by
bike and price point. They’re just two others along its length – crossing
one rung up from the entry-level spokes improves a wheels lateral strength
34 77 71 66 61 57 54 48 44 40 37
Chainring
Wheels
Wheels Front & Rear: Easton Vista 20/24. Round stainless 34 77 71 66 61 57 54 48 44 40 37
Wheels 50 113 104 96 90 84 79 71 64 59 54
Front & Rear: Mavic Aksium Race spokes crossed on drive side
Tyres: Continental Ultra Race 23mm Front & Rear: Mavic Aksium Race Tyres: Michelin Lithion 23mm
Tyres: Vittoria Rubino Pro 23mm Wheels
Wheel weight: 1,737g Rr, 1,292g Fr Wheel weight: 1,689g Rr, 1,187g Fr
Wheel weight: 1,223g Fr, 1,582g Rr Front & Rear: Fulcrum Racing 5 and Racing 5
Other components Other components Evolution (rear), Fulcrum Racing hubs
Other components
Handlebar stem: Ritchey Comp aluminium Handlebar stem: Concept extreme 4-bolt Tyres: Hutchinson Quartz, 700x23c
oversize 12cm Handlebar stem: Ritchey Comp 13cm oversize 11cm Wheel weight (no skewer): 1,300g Fr; 1,740g Rr
Handlebars: Ritchey Comp aluminium oversize, Handlebars: Ritchey Comp 44 (46cm overall) Handlebars: Concept extreme flat-topped
Headset: Prorace integrated raised stacking Other components
45cm overall 45cm anatomic
Headset: Ritchey semi-integrated 30mm) Headset: FSA Integrated Stem: Deda Quattro, OS, 90mm
Saddle: Selle Italia C2 Saddle: Ritchey Comp Saddle: By Velo for Focus Bars: Deda Big Piega, 40cm (outside to outside)
Seatpost: Ritchey Carbon Pro 31.6mm Seatpost: Prorace 31.6mm carbon setback-type Seatpost: Concept Extreme 27.2mm setback, Headset: Condor Integrated
Brakeset: Shimano 105 Brakeset: Dura-Ace two-bolt type Saddle: Fizik Pave Sport
Accessories: None Brakeset: Shimano Ultegra Seatpost: Condor Carbon with layback
Accessories: None Brakeset: Shimano Ultegra
Accessories: None