Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Induced Membranes Secrete Growth Factors Including Vascular and Osteoinductive Factors and Could Stimulate Bone Regeneration
Induced Membranes Secrete Growth Factors Including Vascular and Osteoinductive Factors and Could Stimulate Bone Regeneration
Ort hopaed ic
Research
ELSEVIER Journal of Orthopaedic Research 22 (2004) 73-79
www.elsevier.com/locate/ort hres
Abstract
Based on a new concept, a procedure combining induced membranes and cancellous autografts allows the reconstruction of wide
diaphyseal defects. In the first stage of this procedure, a cement spacer is inserted into the defect; the spacer is responsible for the
formation of a pseudo-synovial membrane. In the second stage, the defect is reconstructed two months later by an autologous
cancellous bone graft. The aim of this study was to evaluate the histological and biochemical characteristics of these membranes
induced in rabbits. Histological studies carried out two, four, six, and eight weeks following implantation revealed a rich vascu-
larization. Qualitative and quantitative immunochemistry showed production of growth factors (VEGF, TGFPI) and osteoin-
ductive factors (BMP-2). Maximum BMP-2 production was obtained four weeks after the implantation, and, at this time, induced
membranes favored human bone marrow stromal cell differentiation to the osteoblastic lineage. Should these results be confirmed in
humans, bone reconstruction could be carried out earlier than previously thought and in better conditions than expected, the
membrane playing the role of an in situ delivery system for growth and osteoinductive factors.
0 2003 Orthopaedic Research Society. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
cells (HBMSC) differentiation and proliferation was Ccdl prol(fifi.ration o / huniuri hone murroii' .siromul wlls ( H B M S C )
studied. HBMSC were obtained with consent from one patient, who un-
derwent a femoral head replacement. Stromal cells were obtained as
described previously [22] and were cultured in Iscove's Modified
Methods Dubelcco's Medium (IMDM, Gibco, Grand Island. NY) supple-
mented with 10% (vlv) of fetal calf serum (FCS, Gibco, Grand Island,
Estohlishnient u / induced nimihrune wtockls in ruhhii.y NY). HBMSC were seeded in 25 cm2 dishes ( 2 x 10' cellslcm2) and
cultured in 0.5 ml of I M D M supplemented with fetal calf serum (FCS)
A 3 cm long incision was made bilaterally on the back of 16 Fauve lo'%)(v/v), pencilin-streptomycin 1/1000' 1 pl/ml, Amphotericin B 10
de Bourgogne rabbits (average weight: 3.7 kg) obtained from a licensed p l h l , and 10 p1 of specimen protein extracts (subcutaneous tissue
vendor (Dombes, Romans, France). Rabbits were anesthetized, and (control) or membrane). The medium was changed every two days.
four subcutaneous tunnels were made from the incision to allow the Two subcutaneous samples and two membrane samples were ran-
insertion of four cylindrical methylmethacrylate spacers (Surgical domly selected from the groups obtained after two and four weeks. An
Simplex P, Howmedica Intl Inc, Co. Clare, Ireland), 1 cm in diameter additional reference group was created that consisted of bone marrow
and 5 cm long. The wound was closed with fast absorbable 3/0 cuta- stromal cells cultured with I M D M alone as control. Analysis of cell
neous sutures (Vicryl rapide'", Johnson & Johnson. Ethicon-France), growth was performed after one, three, six, and nine days in culture,
and a protective aluminum spray dressing (Aluspray@,Vetoquinol. which consisted in a rapid colorimetric assay for cellular growth and
Lure, France) was applied over the wound. Animals were then as- survival using a tetrazolium salt [13].
signed to a study group according to necropsy time (two, four, six, and
eight weeks). In the postoperative period, animals were allowed to feed Cell diferentiution of HBA4SC
and move without restriction. This protocol was conducted in accor-
dance with the recommendations of the French Ministries of Research HBMSC were seeded in 75 cm2 dishes (lo4 cells/cm') and were
and Agriculture on the care and use of laboratory animals. cultured into the same medium supplemented with the induced mem-
Four animals were sacrificed at each time point, and the mem- branes (including controls) obtained after two and four weeks. Ana-
branes surrounding the implants were removed. On the inidline of the lysis of cell differentiation was assessed by the measurement of alkaline
back of each animal, four samples of subcutaneous tissue were taken to phosphatase (AL-P) activity after one, three, six, and nine days of
serve as a control. All the specimens were divided in two parts: the first culture with Sigma diagnostic kit (85L-2, St Louis, MO). using naphtol
was fixed in 10% (vlv) formalin solution, embedded in paraffin, and cut AS-MX phosphate as substrate. Results were expressed in nmole
in 5 pm sections for histological study, and the second was frozen at phosphate transferred/min/pg proteins.
-40 "C prior to protein extraction.
membrane (Fig. IC). Immunostaining performed on the BMP-2 at every time point (Fig. 2). In the induced
same sections also showed multiple sites of fixation for membranes, high concentrations of both VEGF and
antibodies against VEGF (Fig. 1D). At six and eight TGFPl were observed as early as the second week and
weeks, no major changes occurred, though edema was were stable during the following weeks (Fig. 2A and B).
almost completely resorbed, and multinucleated giant However, at six weeks, concentrations of growth factors
cells were less numerous. were still five times higher in the membranes than in
the controls. The differences between membranes and
Growth fuctor content in membranes controls were significant for TGF-P1 and VEGF (p <
0.001). Interestingly, the concentration of BMP-2 was
The control group (subcutaneous tissue) demon- initially close to that of the control, but thereafter in-
strated a low concentration for VEGF, TGFP1, and creased to its highest level at the fourth week and then
16 Ph. Pelisxier et ul. I Jouniul o f Oriholmdic Research 22 (2004) 73-79
0.1
0
4JA
I I I I
2 4 6 8
Weeks
.-C
d 2.5
2
w 2 L
2_
w
c 1.5
2 4 6 8
Weeks
0.4 ,
.$ 0.35 -
c
2
P
0.3 -
0.25 -
\
g 0.2 -
<
n
0.15 -
I 0.1 -
rn
0.05 -
C
0 ’
2 4 6 8
Weeks
Fig. 2. Growth factor levels in the induced membranes. VEGF (A), TGFbl (B), and BMP-2 (C) concentrations in protein extracts arising from
induced membranes and subcutaneous tissue (control) obtained alier two, four, six, and eight weeks were quantified by ELtSA methods. Values
represent the mean k s.d. at each time-point ( n = 4 for both groups). p < 0.001 between membranes and controls.
decreased to the basal level at the last time point. six days. In contrast, addition of membrane extracts
However, the difference between membranes and con- (harvested at two and four weeks) stimulated cell
trols was significant at four and six weeks (p < 0.001). growth. The difference between membranes and controls
was significant (p < 0.001).
Cell prolifkrution
Cell diferent iut ion
Influence of the membranes on bone marrow cell
proliferation was monitored until the eighth day (Fig. Differentiation of bone marrow stromal cells was
3). Since infection occurred in the cell cultures, the re- followed by the measurement of AL-P activity used as
sults were unavailable after this time point. As expected, an early bone differentiation marker. Related to the
HBMSC did not proliferate in medium without fetal calf production of BMP-2 in induced membranes after four
serum. Addition of subcutaneous tissue extract (control weeks, differentiation of HBMSC to osteoblastic lineage
group) maintained the cell growth at the initial level for was observed in the presence of membranes obtained
0.25 tween control and membranes obtained after two weeks
(p = 0.015), which contained traces of BMP-2 but sig-
0.20 nificant levels of TGFP- 1 and angiogenic factors.
0
5
$ 0.15
Discussion
*
9
W
0
C
9 0.10 The technique for bone reconstruction described by
2n
u)
Masquelet combines the induction of a membrane by
the means of a cement spacer with a later cancellous
0.05
autograft [10,12,17]. The first role of the spacer is me-
chanical as it obviates fibrous tissue invasion of the re-
0.00 cipient site. The second role is biological, by the
1 3 6 induction of the surrounding membrane, the histological
Days in culture characteristic of which has already been studied. Mem-
I 2 3 Cell culture with IMDM without fetal calf serum branes formed at the bone-cement interface of a total
E 3 Cell culture in the presence of subcutaneous tissue (control) hip replacement prosthesis have the histological and
0Cell culture in the presence of two-week-maturation membrane histochemical characteristics of a synovial-like lining.
ICell culture in the presence of four-week-maturationmembrane In our study, the membrane also had the aspect of a
Fig. 3. Cell growth of HBMSC in the presence of protein extracts of
synovial-like epithelium with few inflammatory cells.
either subcutaneous tissue (control) o r induced membrane (after two The surrounding fibrous capsule was mostly arranged
and four weeks of maturation). HBMSC cultured in the presence of parallel to the spacer surface. Periprosthetic capsular
medium without fetal calf serum were used as basal cell growth con- tissues surrounding breast prostheses have similar char-
trol. Values represent the mean f s.d. at each time-point ( n = 4 at each acteristics, but differences exist between the membranes
point for both groups). p < 0.001 between membranes and controls.
formed around smooth and textured implants. Synovial-
like metaplasia, villous hyperplasia, and foreign mate-
rial were more often observed around textured implants
within the first five years [25]. As the cement spacer
surface in our study was smooth, we also observed a
rare villous hyperplasia and very few foreign-body
.- reactions.
.
E
U
0.8 Bone grafts should be covered by healthy tissues,
such as muscles flaps, to be revascularized. According to
2 0.6 Masquelet et al. [12], a cancellous autograft placed in
v)
-
C
?!
B
0.4
such a recipient site behaves as a foreign body and is
subject to resorption. The well-known function of this
-g
aJ
0.2
induced membrane is therefore to protect the graft from
the environment and to vascularize it. This hypothesis is
C
in accordance with the rare multinucleated giant cells
0
1 3 6 9
present at the inner side of the capsule, which could
Days in culture
prevent resorption, and with the rich vascularization
observed as soon as the second week. The small capil-
Cell culture with IMDM without fetal calf serum
laries persisted until the end of the eighth week, but
B Cell culture in the presence of subcutaneous tissue (control)
additional larger vessels developed in the outer part of
0Cell culture in the presence of two-week-maturation membrane the membrane by the fourth week.
ICell culture in the presence of four-week-maturation membrane
Angiogenesis is now recognized as an essential step
Fig. 4. Alkaline phosphatase activity of HBMSC cultured in the in osteogenesis, and microvessel cells are identified as
presence of protein extracts of either subcutaneous tissue (control) o r having a direct relationship to bone formation [ 16,231
induced membrane (after two and four weeks of maturation). HBMSC because of their proximity to osteoblasts and osteopro-
cultured in the presence of medium without fetal calf serum were used
genitor cells at sites of new bone formation. One of the
as basal enzymatic activity control. Data are expressed in nmole
phosphate transferredlminlpg protein as the mean f s.d. ( n = 4 at each most important growth and survival factors for endo-
point for both groups). p = 0.015 between control group and mem- thelium is the VEGF that induces angiogenesis and
branes. plays an important role in regulating vasculogenesis [7].
Most types of cells, but usually not endothelial cells
after four weeks (Fig. 4), which strongly stimulated themselves, secrete VEGF. For example, in chronic
AL-P activity. The difference was still significant be- wounds, VEGF is secreted by wound macrophages and
78 Ph. Pt.1i.vskr et ul. I Journd qf’ Ortl7opardie Research 22 (2004) 73-79