Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bird Study: To Cite This Article: S. J. Ormerod, Stephanie J. Tyler & J. M. S. Lewis (1985) Is The
Bird Study: To Cite This Article: S. J. Ormerod, Stephanie J. Tyler & J. M. S. Lewis (1985) Is The
Bird Study
Publication details, including instructions for authors and
subscription information:
http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/tbis20
To cite this article: S. J. Ormerod , Stephanie J. Tyler & J. M. S. Lewis (1985) Is the
breeding distribution of Dippers influenced by stream acidity?, Bird Study, 32:1, 32-39, DOI:
10.1080/00063658509476852
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the
“Content”) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis,
our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warranties whatsoever
as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any
opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the
authors, and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy
of the Content should not be relied upon and should be independently verified
with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any
losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other
liabilities whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection
with, in relation to or arising out of the use of the Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any
substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing,
systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden.
Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/
page/terms-and-conditions
Downloaded by [North Dakota State University] at 16:12 29 October 2014
Bird Study (1985) 32, 32-39
oncern has been expressed recently over Da Prato & Langslow (1976), there are few
C the acidity of streams and rivers in
some upland regions of the United Kingdom
published data on relationships between
breeding distribution and prey availability.
(e.g. Harriman & Morrison 1982; Stoner et al. Recent indications from the River Wye were
1984; Fry & Cooke 1984). From these and that breeding Dippers were absent from the
many other studies (e.g. Sutcliffe & Carrick upper reaches which were known to have
1973; Townsend et al. 1983) it is known that low densities of aquatic macroinvertebrates
acidic water courses support impoverished (Brooker & Morris 1980; Round & Moss
macroinvertebrate faunas by comparison 1984).
with physiographically similar water courses This paper describes the breeding abun-
which are less acidic. Dippers Cinclus cinclus dance of Dippers (as the number of pairs per
are dependent on aquatic macroinvertebrates 10 km of river) in 1982 in the catchment of
as a food supply (Creutz 1966; Ormerod, the Welsh River Wye and on the Grwyne
in press); therefore, it is conceivable that Fawr (an adjacent tributary of the River Usk)
surface-water acidity might indirectly in relation to dietary requirements, prey-
influence their distribution. An examination abundance and some environmental factors.
of this possibility seems desirable in view of Data on breeding abundance are also em-
the current interest in this topic (e.g. Haines ployed from earlier studies on the same river
1981). system (RSPB 1977; Round & Moss 1984).
Whilst there has been little temporal The study area has been described else-
change in the numbers of Dippers breeding where (Edwards & Brooker 1982; Ormerod et
on British census plots since at least 1974 al., in press).
(Taylor & Marchant 1982), there are striking
spatial differences in breeding abundance
METHODS
both between regions (Sharrock 1976;
Marchant & Hyde 1980) and within them
Abundance of breeding Dippers
(Mawby 1961; Round & Moss 1984). Rela-
tionships have been proposed between Breeding abundances on most tributaries
breeding abundance and altitude (Sharrock were assessed using methods similar to the
1976; Shaw 1978; Marchant & Hyde 1980), BTO Waterways Bird Survey (Marchant &
river gradient (Marchant & Hyde 1980; Hyde 1979). Over 180 km of tributaries were
Round & Moss 1984) and the availability of visited on at least seven occasions between
shallow riffles (Robson 1956; Shooter 1970). 9 March 1982 and 7 July 1982, and three
With the exception of a qualitative study by registrations was the minimum criterion to
32
Dippers and stream acidity 33
confirm Dipper territories. Breeding abun- 1983, either during ringing operations or
dances on the Rivers Monnow, Honddu and from stones in the vicinity of nests. After the
Grwyne Fawr were assessed from fewer deflocculation and examination of faecal
visits to territories which had been occupied pellets at x40, macroinvertebrate prey-items
by actively breeding birds in previous years could be identified to family and quantified
(Tyler, unpublished data). Territory locations by counting mouthparts. Fish remains were
were plotted on 1: 50,000 OS maps. Breeding more difficult to quantify, and it was as-
abundances were calculated firstly over each sumed that the presence of fish bones in any
10 km stretch from the source to the mouth faecal pellet indicated that one fish had been
of each tributary and, secondly, over reaches ingested. Probably this resulted in an over-
5 km upstream and downstream from 23 estimate, since no pellet contained more than
sites at which macroinvertebrate abundances a few fish vertebrae.
were also assessed. Similar data on breeding Prey-weight contributions were estimated
Downloaded by [North Dakota State University] at 16:12 29 October 2014
distribution over a further 50 km were for each type of prey item by multiplying the
drawn from Round & Moss (1984) for the recorded number of faecal occurrences by a
upper Wye and from the RSPB (1977) for the mean dry weight. For macroinvertebrates,
upper Wye, the River Tarenig and the River the latter were derived for each family from
Elan. The latter figures were used in con- field collections (n = 10-70 individuals). For
junction with macroinvertebrate data from fish, a dry weight (220 mg) equivalent to
five further sites sampled in 1982. that of a brown trout Salm° trutta of length 7
cm was derived from data given by Milner et
al. (1978). Total dietary dry weights were
Environmental variables
then converted to calorific values using
Altitudes and gradients were assessed for tables provided by Cummins (Si Wuycheck
each surveyed reach using 1: 50,000 OS (1971).
maps. Mean pH values, based in each case
on at least 15 determinations in different
RESULTS
seasons, were provided by the Welsh Water
Authority, together with historical data on
Abundance of breeding Dippers and
the pH of some rivers of contrasting water
environmental variables
chemistry.
On the Rivers Monnow, Honddu, Grwyne
Fawr (Black Mountains rivers) and Ithon, the
Macroinvertebrate abundances
abundance of breeding Dippers was greatest
Macroinvertebrates were sampled in March— on upper reaches which had steep gradients
April 1982, at each of 28 sites, by one oper- (15-30 m/km), and the first occupied terri-
ator using a standardized kick-sampling tory occurred within 1-2 km of the source
technique (2 x 3 minutes per site; net mesh (Figure 1). However, the upper reaches of the
aperture 440 p.m). Abundances for each Rivers Irfon and Wye held few or no breed-
macroinvertebrate order (numbers of indivi- ing Dippers, despite the presence of suitable
duals per sampling interval) were deter- gradients, and the first occupied territories
mined in the laboratory. This method gave were 8 and 15 km from their respective
abundance estimates which correlated sources (Figure 1). These latter rivers had, in
strongly with values from more quantitative their upper reaches, low pH (means: 6.16,
techniques (e.g. Armitage et al. 1974). 6.38; long-term minima: 4.5) and soft waters
(mean total hardnesses 10-12 mg CaCO 3 /1)
by contrast with the upper reaches of the
Dietary analysis
River Ithon and the rivers draining the Black
The diet of adult and nestling Dippers was Mountains (pH means: 7.51-8.20; minima:
assessed at 16 sites throughout the study 6.8-7.3. Mean total hardnesses 60-150 mg
area by the analysis of 72 and 75 faecal CaCO 3 /1). There was also some evidence of a
pellets respectively. These were collected in historical fall in the pH of the upper Irfon,
34 S.J. Ormerod et al.
5
1
k
rwy ne Fawr
2
Monnow
Downloaded by [North Dakota State University] at 16:12 29 October 2014
10 20 30 40 50 60
Figure 1. The distribution of breeding Dippers on five rivers in the Wye catchment and on
the adjacent Grwyne Fawr.
The upper figure shows the altitudinal profile and the symbols indicate the position of the
nearest occupied territory to the source. The histogram represents the abundance of breeding
Dippers in each 10 km stretch.
and of some tributaries of the upper Wye, reaches of the upper River Irfon and the
which was not apparent for the upper Ithon upper Wye.
(Figure 2).
Overall, the abundance of breeding
Abundances of Dippers and
Dippers, on the upper reaches of the 17
macroinvertebrates
tributaries for which data were available,
showed a strong correlation with mean pH Some macroinvertebrate groups, notably
(Figure 3). For the complete data-set, breed- trichopteran larvae (caddis-flies) and
ing abundance showed no significant corre- ephemeropteran nymphs (may-flies), were
lation with either altitude (r = —0.22, ns) or also scarce in the acidic tributaries and the
gradient (r =- 0.09, ns), although there was abundance of breeding Dippers showed a
a significant correlation with the latter particularly strong correlation with the
(r = 0.70, n = 21; P < 0.001) after the removal abundance of the former (Figure 4c). There
from the analysis of data from the acidic was also a significant positive correlation
Dippers and stream acidity 35
a
as
. • • • • So
• •
• • •
75.
• •• • • se • •
• . • • S • • IS—.•
• •
• •
65
Downloaded by [North Dakota State University] at 16:12 29 October 2014
5.5
4-5
pH
85
•• •
6-5
•• •
• • • •
•
• 00 0
5-5
4.5
1963 6.5 67 69 71 73 75 77 79 81 83
Year
Figure 2. Winter spot-metred pH readings on (a) the upper River Ithon and (b) the upper
River Irfon (open symbols) and two tributaries of the upper Wye (closed symbols). The lines
were fitted by least squares regression to combined data.
10 b
r ..54
6 6
•
MO •
4 4 M • •
SIX
•
2 2
0
Downloaded by [North Dakota State University] at 16:12 29 October 2014
0
10 100 1000 15 100 1000
Ephemeroptera N 1j°g103 Plecoptera N Dog io ]
10
-78
8.
6
•
,0 •
Figure 4. Relationships between the abundances of breeding Dippers (pairs per 10 km) and
selected macroinvertebrate groups (N = numbers per 2 x 3 minute kick sample; log. scale).
Breeding abundances assessed in 1977 (RSPB 1977) = open symbols; assessed in 1982 =
closed symbols. The lines were fitted by least squares regression and the encircled values, for
the impounded River Elan, excluded.
Table 1. The diets of breeding Dippers and their nestlings in the study area in 1983 assessed by faecal
analysis
Prey item Total number of items Caloric value (kcal)
Adults (n=72) Nestlings (n=75) Adults (%) Nestlings (%) Combined (%)
Trichopteran larvae 176 430 8.17 (31.8) 32.29 (68.9) 40.46 (55.8)
Ephemeropteran nymphs 484 269 4.74 (18.4) 2.76 ( 5.7) 7.50 (10.3)
Plecopteran nymphs 90 30 1.15 ( 4.5) 0.41 ( 0.9) 1.56 ( 2.1)
Others 54 36 0.37 ( 1.4) 0.29 ( 0.6) 0.66 ( 0.9)
Fish 10 10 11.22 (43.7) 11.22 (23.9) 22.44 (30.9)
Note: The caloric values for each macroinvertebrate order have been summed from calculations made at
family level. Method in text.
38 S.J. Ormerod et al.
In the present study, all the streams which tebrates, notably larval Trichoptera, which
showed evidence of an historical fall in pH were also prey of importance to Dippers
drained from catchments which were when feeding nestlings. Breeding abundance
25-40% covered by mature forests; none also correlated with stream acidity, although
had breeding Dippers within 8 km of its the latter probably had an indirect effect
source in 1982. No scientific data are avail- through the food supply. Trends in historical
able on the historical distribution of Dippers data indicated that several rivers in the
over these reaches. However, Colonel catchment had become more acidic over
Morrey Salmon (pers. comm.) provided recent decades and at least one of these
information on occupied nest-sites which showed a concomitant reduction in the
indicated that Dippers bred on the upper number of breeding Dippers.
River Irfon in the mid-1950s at abundances
in excess of nine pairs per 10 km, and other REFERENCES
anecdotal accounts (Smith 1967) corroborate
Armitage, P.D., Machale, A.M. & Crisp, D.T. (1974)
this observation. Few other changes, for
A survey of stream invertebrates in the Cow
example in the availability of nest-sites, have
Green basin (upper Teesdale) before inun-
occurred along this reach (Ormerod, un- dation. Freshwat. Biol. 4, 369-398.
published). Such an apparent decrease in Brooker, M.P. & Morris, D.L. (1980) A survey of
population, which accompanied an increase the macroinvertebrate riffle fauna of the River
in the acidity of this river, is not consistent Wye. Freshwat. Biol. 10, 437-458.
with data from other studies of Dipper Carlson, A. (1983) Maximizing energy delivery to
populations which have either remained dependent young: a field experiment with Red-
constant (Taylor & Marchant 1982) or have backed Shrikes (Lanius collurio). J. Anim. Ecol.
shown considerable increase (Perry 1983) 52, 697-704.
Creutz, G. (1966) Die Wasseramsel (Wittenberg
over recent years. Hence a more widespread
Lutherstadt, DDR, A. Ziemsen Verlag).
regional survey of the distribution and
Cummins, K.W. & Wuycheck, J.C. (1971) Calorific
breeding success of Dippers in soft-water equivalents for investigations in ecological
areas of upland Scotland or Wales might be energetics. Mitt. int. Verein. them'. angew.
desirable in the light of the results presented 18, 158 pp.
here. Davies, N.B. (1977) Prey selection and the search
strategy of the Spotted Flycatcher (Muscicapa
striata): a field study in optimal foraging. Anim.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Behav. 25, 1016-1033.
We are grateful to Colonel H. Morrey Salmon Edwards, R.W. & Brooker, M.P. (1982) The Ecology
of the Wye (The Hague, Junk).
and Welsh Water Authority for allowing
Enokson, B. & Nilsson, S.G. (1983) Territory size
access to unpublished data, and to Dr A. S.
and population density in relation to food
Gee and R. A. Jenkins for comments on the supply in the Nuthatch Sitta europaea Ayes.
manuscript. Our thanks are also due to J. Anim. Ecol. 52, 927-935.
Roger Lovegrove, Mark Boilstone and Fry, G.L.A. & Cooke A.S. (1984) Acid deposition
Dr Lennox Campbell of the RSPB. S.J.O. was and its implications for nature conservation in
Dippers and stream acidity 39