Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Property Discussion Guide - Atty. Tiamson PDF
Property Discussion Guide - Atty. Tiamson PDF
DISCUSSION GUIDE
ATTY. ERWIN L. TIAMSON
I. INTRODUCTION
A. What is Property?
1. In general term:
• Property concerns legal relations among people regarding control and disposition of valued
resources. Property is not about control of things; it is about relations of people with regard to
thing, and because the things we value are not confined to tangible objects, it makes more
sense to treat property in terms of valued resources.
• Property in the broadest sense is a set of claims that people have in resources that
correspond to duties of respect from others. Property delineates the rights people have to
control and derive value from resources in the world.
• Property is a general term for the rules that govern people's access to and control of things
like land, natural resources, the means of production, manufactured goods, including texts,
ideas, inventions, and other intellectual products.
• Ownership - For most people, property means the things we own. An owner has the power to
control the property that he owns. It may take various forms, including the right to exclude, to
use, to transfer. Ownership concerns a package of various entitlements and responsibilities.
Bundle of Rights.
• Property regulation as management of conflicting rights. A property system, through the
legislature and the courts - must adjudicate conflicts among property rights holder to reconcile
incompatible entitlements. Rule of law.
b) Communism/Socialism
• Preeminence of state ownership;
• Citizens have limited property, the state owned most of the resources (Super Regalian
Doctrine)
• The state decides what is best to do with resources;
• Planned economy
4. Legal Perspective
• Property is an entitlement to resources protected by legal institutions
• Lawyers, however, understand property as legal relations among persons with respect to
things. Some scholars deem property to be a natural right while others view it as a delegation
of covering poser or as a package of legal entitlement.3 (Citing Prof. Henry Smith [traditional
legal doctrines] and Prof. Wesley Hohfeld [bundle of rights]. Prof. Smith - conceptualized
property as a framework for “interaction of persons in society” as well as the foundation and
infrastructure of private law. 4
• Property laws delineate the rights people have to control and derive value from resources in
the world. Property laws tell us what is mine and what is not mine. Without rules about this,
the world will be a chaotic and probable quite violent place to live in.
• The concept of property is reserved for a legally protected entitlement. A thing is not property
in the legal sense unless its holder could vindicate his/her rights in the court of laws.
• Property as an institution embraces these many forms and different societies have various
mixtures of them.
B. Purpose of Property5
• Institution of property provides for an effective way of managing society’s resources. -
Decentralisation in the management of resources and permits owners-managers to specialise
in developing the knowledge and skill pertinent to their particular resources.
• Provides a powerful set of incentives for person to make investments in and engage in
effective management of resources they control. Reaping what you sow.
2 See Thomas W. Merril & Henry E. Smith, What Happened to Property in Law and Economics, 111 YALE L. J. 357, 380 (2001)
3 Joseph W. Singer, Property as the Law of Democracy, 63 Duke L. J. 1287 (2014)
4 Property as the Law of Things, 125 HARV. L. REV. 1691 (2012)
5 Thomas W. Merril and Henry E. Smith, The Oxford Introduction to U.S. Law: Property, Oxford University Press, 2010
• Facilitates the making of contracts regarding the use and control of resources. - Exchange of
property rights, we know who use and control the resources.
• It is a source of individual autonomy - private individuals controls the direction of their lives
because they have the means; critical to personal identify or to the development of individual
personality
• It is important to the preservation of liberty and a source of countervailing power to the power
of the State. With private property, individuals can organized oppositions, if the government
controls all the resources, autocracy.
D. Theories of Property
• All five theories help form the foundation of property law.
• No one theory is accepted as the only justification for property
1. First Possession
• Rules of first possession are the regulation of a competitive process of acquiring unowned
resources.
• It is the allocation of property rights to the first possessor.
• Intended to reduced conflict and unnecessary competition;
• Much less wasteful of resources if a clear winner emerges early on in the process of
appropriation;
• Notice to others that a claim is being asserted is important for #2; the lack of notice might
lead others to compete with the original hunter;
• The end result of first possession is private property
• Rule on Discovery - the thing is awarded to those who first made a claim on the resources
2. Labor Theory
• John Locke resigned the each person is entitled to the property produced through his own
labor. Locked argued that when a person mixed his own labor with natural resources which
are unowned, he acquired property rights in the mixture. Before labor was added, the thing
had no value, once labor is mixed, the thing becomes private property.
• More applicable in areas where there is no established ownership, i.e. British colonization of
North America
(1) Universality
• all valuable, scarce resources must be owned by someone. An economy where certain
resources cannot be use by someone would be smaller than the same economy where
this resources could be used.
(2) Exclusivity
• If an owner is unable to exclude others from the use and enjoyment of the property, then
the owner has no incentive to improve the property.
6 Harold Demsetz, Toward a Theory of Property Rights, 57 AM. ECON. REV. PAPERS & PROC. 347 (1967)
7 Howard Gensler, Property Law as an Optimal Economic Foundation, 35 Washburn L.J. 50, 51-52 (1995)
(3) Universality
• The more efficient person should be allowed to acquire the property of the less efficient one
for mutual benefit. The right to transfer is vital for efficiency in our market economy because
it helps ensure that property is devoted to its most valuable use. What is the extent of the
restrictions
4. Democracy
• In a state in which private property does not exist, citizens are dependent on the good will of
the government. They come to the state as beggars rather than right holders.
• Any challenge to the state may be stifled or driven underground by virtue of the fact that
serous haleness could result i the withdrawal of the goods that give people basic security.
• A right to private property, free from government interference, is in this sense a necessary
basis for a democracy.8
5. Personhood
• Georg Hegel - argues that property is necessary for an individual’s personal development.
Each person has a close emotional connection to certain tangible things, which virtually
become part of one’s self.
• Margaret Jane Radin - the gauge of the strength or significance of someone’s relationship
with an object by the kind of pain that should be occasioned by its loss; pain that cannot be
relieved by a simple object’s replacement; because of this connection to the property, the
owner should be accorded a broad liberty with respect to control of that thing.
• All things equal, a right to personhood priority should be given priority over a conflicting claim
by the owner of non-personhood property. 9
2. Legal Positivism
a) Property rights are defined by law.
• The theory that legal rules are valid only be cause they are enacted by existing political
authority or accepted as binding in a given society not because they are grounded in morality
or in natural law.
• Property rights are thus defined by the State
c) Property as Notice
• Property law comes in a standard set of forms and serves as notice to everyone,
depending on the physical nature and character, and location of the property on how to
behave. The in rem aspect of property gives information to large and indefinite audience on
how to interact with each other with regard to the thing.
• Property needs to be general, stable, and give proper notice on the widest possible
audience. Achieving generality, stability, and notice requires managing information:
facilitating coordination on this scale requires simplicity and a degree of formalism precisely
because the audience is in rem.11
• The Duty to Keep Off - The other side of the owner’s right to exclude, use and transfer
properties, it is the duty of the other members of society to keep off, to respect such rights,
unless the owner has given permission to enter or use the thing. Property in the broadest
sense is a set of claims that people have in resources that correspond to duties of respect
in others generally.
• In rem proceeding and the jurisdiction of the court over a thing. In rem proceeding
allows a person to place some things under the authority of the court, which will, after
providing to all interested claimants the required notice and opportunity to be heard, make
a definitive adjudication of who owns the thing.
4. Right to Exclude
a) William Blackstone12
• According to Blackstone, property is “the sole and despotic dominion which one man claims
and exercises over the external things of the world, in total exclusion of the right of any
other individual in the universe.”
• Arguably one of the most significant and essential elements in defining our understanding
of what constitutes property. Historically, the right to exclude concerns the relationship
between people with respect to things, “such that the so-called owner can exclude others
from certain activities or permit others to engage in those activities and in either case
secure assistance of the law in carrying out this decision.” But, from a present-day
perspective, the right has evolved beyond the legal constructs of traditional property law to
also encompass legal entitlements and benefits possessed by one person over another
irrespective of the legal relationship between such person and the thing in which the right is
claimed.
11 Henry E. Smith, The Language of Property: Form, Context, and Audience, 55 STAN. L. REV. 1105, 1148–57 (2003).
12 William Blackstone, Commentary on the Laws of England
13 Thomas W. Merrill, Property and the Right to Exclude, 77 Neb. L. Rev. (1998)
• Custom
• Public Accommodation Laws
• Anti-discriminatory Laws
5. Bundle of Rights
• Property as Bundle of Rights
• This school of thought denies the existence of any essential core tot he concept of property.
Rather, property is jest a word denoting a bundle of rights or more metaphorically, a bundle
of stick - in which each individual stick (whether it be a right or privilege) can be added or
removed without necessarily changing the characterization of the bundle as property.
• The Legal Realist movement that started in the 1920 advance this alternative view in order
to debunk the notion of property as a natural high protected by the Constitution against
fundamental reform.
• Trinity of Rights - to exclude, to use and to transfer defines the core property.
• The law shifted from giving the owner dictatorial control over who and what to exclude or
include, and instead seeks to prescribe rules about permissible and impermissible uses
that constrain all relevantly situated owners. Exclusion shoes off into governance.
• Perspective and Analysis14 - “At least since Blackstone, property rights discourses has been
plagued by absolutism, the notion that the right of property should be defined as the “sole and
despotic dominion” over the res, to the “total exclusion of the right of any other individual in the
universe.” Property professors and courts generally refer to the collection of rights that private
property owners enjoy vis-a-vis other landowners and the public as a “bundle of sticks” in an
attempt to render rather abstract concepts more concrete. The prevailing metaphor, however,
lends itself to a formalistic, absolutist conception of these interests, implying that the stick,
such as the right to devise or the right to convey, are things… therefore the composition of the
bundle must be an immutable and essential state of affairs. In contrast, many scholars insist
that property rights are neither static nor absolute. The recognition of private property interest
involves tradeoffs with community values and egalitarian goals; therefore the exact
composition of the bundle of sticks must be recognized as a mediation between these
interests. Moreover, the palace struck is always tentative, subject to constant re-evaluation in
the light of current needs and norms.
• Countryside and Rights of Way Act (England and Wales) - Many landowners in the United
Kingdom have, in the past, strongly defended their property rights. Even uncultivated and
unenclosed land was formerly heavily protected in some areas, mostly to preserve the land
owner's hunting or fishing rights. This in turn left the general public with little access to natural
areas. The Act implements the so-called "right to roam" (also known as jus spatiandi) long
sought by the Ramblers' Association and its predecessors, on certain upland and uncultivated
areas of England and Wales. The act refers to areas of “mountain, moor, heath and down” in
addition to registered common land; not all uncultivated land is covered. The Ramblers'
Association works to increase the rights of walkers in the United Kingdom and has been a
driving force behind the recent legislation increasing the public's access to the wilderness.
14 Sparkling and Coletta, Property - A Contemporary Approach, 2nd Edition, West (2012), p. 65-66
b) Rights as Property
(1) Real Rights
(2) Personal Rights
(3) Distinctions
3. Kinds of Property
a) As to Ownership
(1) Common/Res Nullious
(2) Public Dominion
(a) Property intended for public use (Art. 420, par. 1, NCC)
(b) Property for public service (Art. 420, par. 2, NCC)
(c) Property for the development of national wealth (Art. 420, par. 2, NCC)
(d) Patrimonial property (Article 421, NCC)
b) As to Physical Characteristics
(1) Immovable Property (Real Property)
(a) Enumeration of Immovable Property (Art. 415, NCC)
(b) Classes of Immovable Property
i) Immovable by nature - paragraphs 1 and 8
ii) Immovable by incorporation - paragraphs 2,3,4, and 6
iii) Immovable by destination - paragraphs 4,5,6,7 and 9
iv) Immovable by analogy or by law - paragraph 10
(c) Extent of Ownership (Art. 437, NCC)
i) Includes the surface and everything under it and he can construct thereon any works
or make any plantations and exceptions which he may deem proper, without
detriment to servitudes and subject to special laws and ordinances. He cannot
complain of the reasonable requirement of aerial navigation.
ii) Minerals are not included; Article XII of the Constitution
iii) Republic Act No. 7942 (Philippine Mining Act of 1991)
(1) Section 76. Entry into Private Lands and Concession Areas. - Subject to prior
notification, holders of mining rights shall not be prevented from entry into private
lands and concession areas by surface owners, occupants, or concessionaires
when conduction mining operations therein: provided, that any damage done to
the property of the surface owner, occupant, or concessionaire as a consequence
of such operations shall be properly compensated as may be provided for in the
implementing rules and regulations: provided further, that to guarantee such
compensation, the person authorized to conduct mining operation shall, prior
thereto, post a bond with the regional director used on the the of properties, the
prevailing rices in and around the area where the mining operations are to be
conducted, with surety or sureties satisfactory to the regional director.
iv) Commonwealth Act No. 141 (Public Land Act)
(1) Section 110. Patents or certificates issued under the provision of this Act shall not
include nor convey the title to any gold, silver, copper, iron, or other metals or
minerals or other substances containing minerals, guano, gum, precious stones,
coal, or coal oil contained in lands granted thereunder. These shall remain to be
property of the State.
(2) The prohibition applies also to lease of public lands under Section 41. The lease
of agricultural lands may be cancelled after notice if the said lands is more
valuable for mineral extraction.
(d) Hidden Treasures (Art. 438/439, NCC)
i) Hidden and unknown deposit of money, jewelry or other precious objects (Personal
Property) the lawful ownership of which does not appear (Art. 439, NCC)
ii) Belongs to the owner of the land/building (Principle of Accession)
iii) If by chance 1/2 belongs to the finder but not when he is a trespasser
iv) The State ay acquire hidden treasure at their just price; Ground: Science/Art
II. OWNERSHIP
• The delineation of ownership is as old as human written records.
A. In General
• Ownership signifies that dominion or indefinite right of use, control and disposition (constituent
elements) which one may lawfully exercise over particular things or objects.
• The delineation of ownership is as old as human written records.
• Ownership is a Biblical Concept: The Mosaic laws as described in the Ten Commandments or the
laws on takings in Exodus 22:1-15, as well as the host of other Levitical laws throughout the first
five books of the Old Testament, are all attempts to legally define ownership.
• From the Hammurabi code to the English common law the notion of legal ownership, or legal
rights, to property is well defined.
• In the words of William Blackstone (English Jurist): “The third absolute right; inherent in every
Englishman, is that of property: which consists in the free use, enjoyment and disposal of all his
acquisitions, without any control or diminution, save only by the laws of the land”.
1. Definition
a) In its strict sense
(1) Property signifies that dominion or indefinite right of user, control and disposition which one
may lawfully exercise over particular things or objects (63 Am Jur 2d).
(2) Property is composed of certain constituent elements, namely, the unrestricted right of use,
enjoyment and disposal of the particular subject of property.
c) Meaning of Title
(1) Refers to that which is the subject of ownership, and is that which is the foundation of
ownership.
(2) It is the evidence of a person’s right or of the extent of his interest; the means whereby the
owner is enable to maintain or assert his possession and enjoyment.
(3) Colour of title is that which gives a semblance or appearance of title, but is not the title in
fact. It is anything which shows the extent of the occupant’s claim
B. Incidents of Ownership
1. Right to Exclude
a) Right to Exclude under the Civil Code (Art. 429, NCC)
• The owner or lawful possessor of a thing has the right to exclude any person from the
enjoyment and disposal of the thing.
c) Self-Help
d) Exception
• Lawful Interference in cases of acts of necessities Art. 432, NCC
• Compensate affected owner for damages
2. Right to Use
a) General Statement under Art. 428 of the Civil Code
(1) Par. (1) The owner has the right to enjoy things without other limitations
b) Exceptions:
• Limitation by law
• Injurious Use - The owner of the thing cannot make use it in such a manner as to injure the
rights of a third person (Article 431, NCC)
• An owner may put his property to any use not unlawful, however absolute and unqualified
may be his title, an owner holds the property under the implied liablitiy that his use of it
shall not be injurious to the equal enjoyment of others having an equal right to the
enjoyment of their property of others nor injurious to the rights of the community. a claim of
restrictions and limitation in the use of such property must be clearly and indubitable
established
• Governmental control and regulate properties to secure the general safety, the public
welfare and the peace, good order and morals of the community. This does not confer
power to control rights which are purely and exclusively private, but it does authorise
• The establishment of laws requiring each citizen so to conduct himself and use his own
property as not unnecessarily to injure another. The state may provide regulations as to the
acquisition, enjoyment and disposition of property and may even take private property for a
public purpose, subject to the right of the individual to just compensation.
• Property is subject to certain burdens which it must bear in common with other property of
a like kind.
3. Right to Transfer
a) In General.
• It includes the right of alienation or disposition in any lawful manner which the owner deems
fit. The transfer must comply with the mode appropriate to the kind of property in order to be
effectual.
c) Kinds of Transfers
(1) Assignment of ownership
(2) Assignment of rights only
4. Right to Vindicate
a) In General
• Includes the right to protect and defend such possession against the intrusion or trespass of
others through judicial relief but in certain instances may include self-help; and
b) Presumptions
• The law favour actual possessors (Article 433 of the Civil Code)
III. CO-OWNERSHIP
A. In General
The ownership of an undivided thing or rights belongs to different person (Art. 484)
B. Incidents of Co-ownership
1. General Rule
a) Presumption is equal shares (Art. 485, NCC)
b) Full ownership of his share (Art. 493, NCC)
c) On Share - the share of the co-owners in the benefits as well as in the charges are
proportional to their interest and any stipulation altering this proportion is void . (Art. 485,
NCC)
2. On Right to Use
a) Any co-owner may use the thing in accordance with its purpose (Art. 486, NCC)
b) Cannot use it in such a way as to injure the interest of the co-owners or prevents them from
using it according to their rights
c) Co-owner may not alter the thing in common even though it will benefit all co-owners; judicial
relief if the withholding of consent is prejudicial (Art. 491) or if the resolution of the majority is
prejudicial (Art. 492)
3. On Right to Exclude
a) May not exclude co-owners (Art. 486)
b) Prescription does not run against co-owner as long as he recognises the co-ownership (Art.
494, par. 5)
4. On Right to Transfer
a) Any co-owner may alienate, assign or mortgage his right (Art. 493)
b) Any co-owner may substitute another person in the enjoyment of the use except if personal
rights are involved (Art. 493)
c) Creditors and Assignees may take part in the division but cannot impugn any partition that has
been executed (Art. 497)
5. On Right to Vindicate
a) Any co-owner may bring an action for Ejectment (Art. 487)
C. Obligations of Co-Owners
a) Contribute to the expenses for preservation and to taxes. (Art. 488)
b) Contribute to the expenses for improvement upon majority decision (Art. 489). Majority
decision must include co-owners representing controlling interest (Art. 492)
c) As far a practicable, other co-owners must be notified before a co-owner incur expenses for
preservation.
D. Right to Partition
1. Incidents
a) Any co-owner may demand partition any time in so far as his share is concern (Art. 492 and
496);
b) Mutual accounting for benefits receive and reimbursement (Art. 500);
c) Creditors or assignees of a co-owner may take part in the division and object to its being
effected without their concurrence (Art. 497).
d) Kinds of Partition (Art. 496)
(1) Private Partition (Art. 496)
(2) Judicial Partition (Art. 496)
4. Warranty
a) Every co-owner shall be liable for defects of title and quality of the portion assigned to each of
he other co-owners. (Art. 501)
E. Renunciation of Shares
a) A co-owner may renounce his share share as may be equivalent to this share of the expenses
and taxes but not when it is detrimental to the interest of the co-ownership (Art. 488)
IV. POSSESSION
A. Definitions
1. Possession in General
• Possession is the holding of a thing or the enjoyment of a right (Art. 523). Only things and
rights which are susceptible of being appropriated may be the object of possession (Art. 430)
• Possession is the fact of having or holding property in one’s power; the exercise of dominion
over property; the right under which on may exercise control over something to the exclusion
of all others;
• Any of the usual outward marks of ownership may suffice as possession in the absence of
manifest power in someone else.
2. Actual Possession
• Physical occupancy or control over property
3. Acquisitive Prescription
• The acquisition of a title to a thing by open, continues, exclusive, notorious and hostile
possession over a statutory period.
4. Adverse Possession
• The enjoyment of property with a claim of right when the enjoyment is opposed to another
person’s claim and is continuous, exclusive, hostile, open and notorious.
5. Bonafide Possession
• Possession of property by a person who in good faith does not know that the property’s
ownership is disputed.
6. Constructive Possession
• Control or dominion over a property without actual possession or custody of it. Thus, when a
possessor holds title to a property and physically possesses part of it, the law will deem the
possessor hold constructive possession of the rest of the property described in the title.
7. Exclusive Possession
• The exercise of exclusive dominion over property including the use and benefit of the property.
8. Hostile Possession
• Possession asserted against the claims of all others especially the true or record owner
9. Notorious Possession
• Possession or control that is evident to others;
• Possession of property that, because it is generally known by people in the area where the
property is located, gives rise to a presumption that the actual owner has notice of it.
10. Prescription
• The extinction of a title or right by failure to claim or exercise it over a long period of time.
C. Acquisition of Possession
1. How possession is acquired (Art. 531)
a) Material Occupation
b) Exercise of a Right
c) Control over thing/right that are subject to the action of our will (Art. 560)
D. Loss of Possession
1. General Rule (Art. 554)
a) By abandonment of the thing
b) By assignment made to another either by onerous or gratuitous title
c) By destruction or total loss of the thing or because it goes out of commerce
d) By the possession of another
(1) One year
(2) Ten years - real right of possession is lost
(3) Prescription on immovables is subject to land registration laws
2. Presumptions
• Movables are not deemed lost as long as they remain under the control of the possessor even
thought the time being he ay not know its whereabout.
E. Effects of Possession
1. Possession is respected and will be restored if disturbed, writ of ejectment may be issued (Art.
539, NCC)
2. Presumptions of Ownership in favor of Actual Possessors
a) Just title - if possession is in the concept of an owner; possessor cannot be obliged to show or
prove it. (Art. 541, NCC)
b) A possessor who shows possession at some previous time is presumed to have held
possession also during the intermediate period in the absence of proof to the contrary. (Art.
459, NCC)
c) Possession of real properties presumes possession of movables (Art. 542, NCC)
3. Rules in common possession (Art. 534, NCC)
a) Allocation after division is presumed to have been possessed during the entire duration of co-
possession
b) Interruption of possession prejudices all the possessors
c) In case of Civil Interruption, the Rules of Court applies
d) Tacking of Possession
F. Adverse Possession
1. Concept
• Possession without authority and adverse to the interest of the lawful possessor;
(b) Refund
i) For necessary expenses with right of retention until reimbursement (Art. 546, par. 1)
ii) For useful expenses with right of retention - owner has the option to refund or to pay
increase in value (Art. 546 par. 2)
iii) For expenses for pure luxury or mere pleasure (Art. 548)
(c) Removal
i) Of useful improvements if it can be done without damage or refund (Art. 547)
ii) Of ornaments for embellishment if it suffers no injury and if owner does not prefer to
refund (Art. 548)
(d) Liability
i) Not liable for the deterioration or loss except if there is fraudulent intent or negligence
after judicial summons
(b) Refund
• For necessary expenses only without right of retention (Art. 546 and 549)
(c) Removal
• Of improvement for pure luxury or please if no injury is cause and the lawful
possessor does not prefer to retina the by paying its value (Art. 549)
(d) Liability
• Liable for losses including fortuitous events
b) Prescription
By prescription, one acquires ownership and other real rights through the lapse of time in
theater and under the conditions laid down by law. In the same way, rights and conditions are
lost by prescription (Art. 1106, NCC). Possession has to be in the concept of an owner, public,
peaceful and uninterrupted (Art. 1118, NCC). However, lands registered under the Torrens
System of land registration is not subject to prescription (Section 47, PD No. 1529 or the
Property Registration Decree, “Section 47. Certificate not subject to prescription. No title to
registered land in derogation of the title of the registered owner shall be acquired by
prescription or adverse possession.”
e) Rule on Prescriptions
(1) All things which are within the commerce of men are susceptible of prescription, unless
otherwise provided. Property of the State or any of its subdivision not patrimonial in
character shall not be the object of prescription. (Art. 1113, NCC)
(2) Movables possessed through a brie can never be acquired through prescription by the
offender (Art. 1133, NCC)
(3) Tacking of possession
(4) Interruptions
(a) Acts of possession by mere tolerance of the owner is not adverse possession for
purposes of prescription (Art. 1119, NCC)
(b) Possession is interrupted naturally or civilly (Art. 1120, NCC).
i) Natural - when through any cause it should cease for more than one year and the old
possession is not revived if a new possession should be exercise by the same
adverse claimant (Art. 1121, NCC).
ii) Civil - by judicial summons to the possessor (Art. 1122). Possession in wartime when
the civil courts are not open, shall not be counted in favor of adverse claimant (Art.
1136, NCC)
(c) Adverse possessor makes express or tacit recognition of owner’s right (Art. 1125, NCC)
V. ACCESSION
A. General rule:
1. The law assigned ownership of things produced to the owner of the principal (Art. 440, 441 and
422, NCC)
a) Natural - spontaneous products of the soil, and the your and other products of animals;
b) Industrial - produced by lands of any kind through cultivation or labor; and
c) Civil - rents of building, the price of leases of lands and other property and the amount of
perpetual or life annuities or there similar income.
2. The owner has the obligation to pay for the expenses made by third persons in their production,
gathering, and preservation (Art. 443, NCC)
a) Base on the principle of unjust enrichment;
b) Expenses that are required by the condition of the work on the property;
c) A possessor in bad faith is considered as a third person if he turned over the produce of the
land that are already separated from the immovable (Tolentino saying that this is the general
rule, Art. 449 is the exception; Tacas vs. Tabon)
3. The law presumed that the accessory thing belongs to owner of the principal
a) The possession of real property presumes that of the movables therein, soloing as it is not
shown that they should be excluded (Art. 542, NCC)
b) The possession of movable is not deemed lost so long as hey remain under he control of the
possessor even though for the time being he may not know their whereabouts (Art. 556, NCC)
B. Types of Accession
1. Accession discreta
• Right of the owner pertaining to the fruits
2. Accession continua
• Right of the owner pertaining to things attached or incorporated
2. Definition of Principal
(1) Not the ornament (Art. 467, NCC)
(2) The one with greater value (Art. 468, NCC)
(3) The one with greater volume (Art. 468, NCC)
3. Rule on Separation
a) The Principal does not acquire the Accessory if the two objects can be separated without
injury. (Art. 469, 2nd par., NCC)
b) When the accessory is more valuable than the principal, the owner may demand separation
even if there would be injury.
c) If the things are mixed (no principal/accessory), proportional division bearing in mind the value
of the things mixed. (Art. 472, NCC)
B. Trespass
1. Concept
• Trespass to land is the most commonly associated with the term trespass; it takes the form of
an unlawful physical invasion or usurpation of rights in real property”. In acts of trespass, the
trespasser should have no legal right on the property
• Generally, it is not necessary to prove harm to a possessor's legally protected interest; and
• Liability for unintentional intrusions; see good faith and bad faith.
• Trespass to chattels, also known as trespass to goods or trespass to personal property, is
defined as "an intentional interference with the possession of personal property by another.
• The lessor is not obliged to answer for a mere act of trespass which a person may cause on
the use of the thing leased; but the lessee shall have a direct action against the intruder (Art.
1664, NCC)
• Mere acts of trespass does not suspend payment in sale (Art. 1590)
2. Cause of Action
a) The owner has the right of action against the holder and possessor of the thing in order to
recover it. (Art. 428, Par. 2, NCC)
b) Presumption of ownership is given to actual possessor (Art. 433, NCC)
c) In an action to recover, plaintiff must rely on the strength of his title and not on the weakness
of the defendant’s claim (Art. 434, NCC)
b) Criminal Prosecution
(1) Usurpation of Real Rights under Article 312 of the RPC
(a) By means of violence against or intimidation of persons takes possession of any real
property
(b) Usurp any real rights in property belonging to another
(2) Other Form of Swindling under Article 316 of the RPC
(a) Any person who pretending to be the owner of any real property shall convey, sell,
encumber of mortgage the same
(b) Any Person who knowing that the property is encumbered shall dispose the same
although such encumbrance is not recorded
(c) Any person who sell, mortgage or encumber real property use as surety in a bond
f) Writ of Possession
(1) A separate action for recovery of possession is not necessary, the court may issue a writ of
possession to eject the occupant of the land in the following instances:
(2) Land Registration Proceedings
(3) Extra-judicial Foreclosure of Mortgage as against the mortgagor
(4) Judicial Foreclosure as against the mortgagor
(5) Execution Sale
g) Eviction and Demolition under Republic Act No. 7279 (Urban Development and
Housing Act of 1992)
(1) Section 28. Eviction and Demolition - Eviction and demolition shall be discourage. Eviction
and demolition, however, may be allowed under the following situations:
(a) When persons or entities occupy danger areas such as esteros, railroad tracks, garbage
dumps, riverbanks, shorelines, waterways, and other public places such as sidewalks,
roads, parks and playgrounds;
(b) When government infrastructure projects with available ending are about to be
implemented; or
(c) When there is a tour order for eviction and demolition.
In the execution of eviction and demolition orders involving underprivileged and homeless citizens,
the following shall be mandatory:
(a) Notice upon the affected person at least thirty (30) days prior to the date of eviction or
demolition;
(b) Adequate consultations on the matter of settlement with the duly designated
representatives of the families to be resettled and the affected communities int he areas
where they are to be relocated;
(c) Presence of local government officials or their representatives during eviction or
demotion;
(d) Proper identification of all persons taking part in the demolition;
(e) Execution of eviction or demolition only during regular office hour from Mondays to
Fridays and during good weather unless the affected families consent otherwise;
(f) No use of heavy equipment for demotion except for structures that are permanent and of
concrete materials;
(g) Proper Uniform for members of the PNP who shall occupy the first line of law
enforcement and observe proper disturbance control procedure; and
(h) Adequate relocation, whether temporary or permanent, provided, however that incases
of eviction and demolition pursuant to a court order involving underprivileged and
homeless citizens, relocation shall be undertaken by the local government unit
concerned and the National Housing Authority with the assistance of other government
agencies within forth-five (45) days form service of notice of final judgement by the court,
after which period the said order shall be executed: provided, further, that should
relocation no be impossible with the said period, financial assistance in the amount
equivalent to the prevailing minimum wage multiplied by sixty (60) days shall be
extended to the affected families by the local government unit concerned.
4. In Personal Property
a) Self Help (Art. 429, NCC)
(1) The owner or lawful possessor of a thin has the right to exclude any person from the
enjoyment and disposal thereof. For this purpose, he may use force as may be reasonable
necessary to repel or prevent an actual or threatened unlawful physical invasion or
usurpation of his property.
b) Criminal Prosecution
(1) Revised Penal Code Book II, Title 10 "Crime against Property"
(a) Robbery
(b) Brigandage
(c) Theft
(d) Arson
(e) Malicious Mischief
c) Replevin
(1) Is a lawsuit that enables a person to get back personal property taken wrongfully or
unlawfully and get compensation for resulting losses
(2) From medieval times, there has also come down to us a summary process, known as
replevin, by which a man out of whose possession goods have been taken may obtain their
return until the right to the goods can be determined by a court of law. Replevin arose out of
the need of a turbulent society to discourage resort to self help and although for a long time
primarily used in disputes about distress between landlord and tenant, it was gradually
expanded to cover all cases of allegedly wrongful dispossession. If the plaintiff wanted
return of his chattel in specie, replevin was a more appropriate remedy than either trespass
or trover in which only damages could be recovered. Restoration of the property is, of
course, only provisional, pending determination of title.
(3) Rule 60 of the Rules of Court (Recovery of possess of personal property)
(a) A party praying for the recovery of possession of personal property ay, at the
commencement of the action or at any time before answer, apply for an order for the
delivery of such property to him.
(b) The applicant must give bond, executed to the adverse party in boodle the value of the
property, for the return of the property to the adverse party if such return be adjudged
and for the payment to the adverse party of such sum as he may recover from the
applicant in the action.
(c) The adverse party may file a counter bond double the value of the property
3. Nuisance according to the object or objects that it affects (Art. 695, NCC) - Public
and Private Nuisance (Art. 695, NCC)
a) Public Nuisance or Common Nuisance affects a community or neighborhood or any
considerable number of persons although the extent of annoyance or range or damage is
unequal
b) Private nuisance affects only specific individuals and not the whole community; violates only
private rights
4. Nature
a) Per Se
(1) Nuisance at all times and under any circumstances, regardless of location or surroundings
b) Per Incidens
(1) Nuisance by reason of the circumstance and surroundings
c) A nuisance per se when it affects the immediate safety of persons and property may be
summarily abated under the law of necessity.
d) A nuisance per incidens, which depend upon certain conditions and circumstance, and its
existence being a question of fact, cannot be abated without due hearing or judicial
intervention.
6. Remedies
a) Prosecution under the Penal Code
(1) Limited to public nuisance
b) Civil Action
(1) If public nuisance - action shall be commence by the city (Art. 701)
(2) Exception - it may be filed by a private person if it is specially injurious to him
E. Quieting of Title
1. An action brought to remove a cloud on title to real property by reason of any instrument, record,
claim, encumbrance or proceedings which is apparently valid or effective but is in truth and in
fact invalid, ineffective or unenforceable, and may be prejudicial to said title. (Art. 476)
2. Legal or equitable title to or interest to real property
3. Return of all the benefits acquired by the plaintiff to the defendant (Art. 479)
`
b) Dominant Estate
• The land benefitting from the estate is called the dominant estate
c) Servient Estate
• The land burdens by an easement is called servient estate
2. Kinds of Easements
a) Continuous or Discontinuous
b) Apparent or Non-apparent
c) Positive or Negative
d) Legal and Voluntary
e) Legal and Private Easements
(1) Legal Easements:
• Imposed by law for public use - governed by special laws
b) By Title
• Continuous non-apparent and discontinuous easements - by title
b) Servient Estate
• The owner of the servient estate cannot impair, in any manner whatsoever, the use of the
servitude. The owner of the servient estate retains the ownership of the portion on which
the easement is established, and may use the same in such a manner as not to affect the
exercise of the easement.
• Exception - should the easement become very inconvenient to the owner of the servient
estate, it may be changed at his expense, provided he offers another place or manner
equally convenient without injuring the dominant estates.
5. Extinguishment of Easements
a) By merger;
b) By prescription or non-user (form and manner) for ten years, however, If the dominant estate
belongs to several persons in common, the use of the easement by any one of them prevents
prescription with respect to the others;
c) By its condition making the easement unusable unless revived prior to prescription;
d) By the contract (term, condition, redemption) as agreed by the owners of the dominant and
servient estate; and
e) By the renunciation of the owner of the dominant estate
6. Special Law: Presidential Decree No. 1096 (National Building Code of the
Philippines)
a) Repealed Republic Act No. 6541 (An Act to Ordain and Institute a National Building Code of
the Philippines
b) Section 301. Building Permits. - No person, firm or corporation, including any agency or
instrumentality of the government shall erect, construct, alter, repair, move, convert or
demolish any building or structure or cause the same to be done without first obtaining a
building permit therefor from the Building Official assigned in the place where the subject
building is located or the building work is to be done.
c) Chapter 2: Administration and Enforcement (related to nuisance)
d) Chapter 6: Fire Resistive Requirements in Construction (related to party walls)
e) Chapter 8: Light and Ventilation (related to party walls, light and view)
f) Chapter 9: Sanitation (related to waters, drainage of buildings)
g) Chapter 10: Building Projection Over Public Streets (related to right of way, light and view,
distances)
h) Chapter 12: General Design and Construction Requirements (related to lateral and subjacent
supports)
i) Chapter 20: Signs (related to light and view)
15 http://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/Rights_to_light
line of the latter when they do, and in cases of oblique view from the dividing line
between the two properties (Article 671, NCC).
c) Covered by Chapter VII (Light and Ventilation) of the National Building Code of the Philippines
(Presidential Decree No. 1096)
(1) Section 808. Window Openings (P.D. 1096) - Every room intended for any use, not
provided with artificial ventilation system as herein specified in this Code, shall be provided
with a window or windows with a total free area of openings equal to at least ten percent of
the floor area of room, and such window shall open directly to a court, yard, public street or
alley, or open water courses.
(2) Section 804 (P.D. 1096) - Size and Dimension of Courts.
(a) Minimum size of courts and their least dimensions
shall be governed by the use, type of construction, and height of the building as
provided in the rules and regulations promulgated by the Secretary, provided that the
minimum horizontal dimension of court shall be not less than 2.00 meters.
(b) All inner courts shall be connected to a street or yard, either by a passageway with a
minimum width of 1.20 meters or by a door through a room or rooms.
(c) Every court shall have a width of not less than 2.00 meters for one (1) or two (2) storey
buildings. However, if the court is treated as a yard or vice versa, this may be reduced to
not less than 1.50 meters in cluster living units such as quadruplexes, rowhouses and
the like, with adjacent courts with an area of not less than 3.00 sq. meters. Provided
further, that the separation walls or fences, if any, shall not be higher than 2.00 meters.
(3) Theories
(a) Utilitarian theory - land is solely the owner’s property to develop as the owner please
(b) Green theory - ecological ethic emphasises the moral duty of humanity to act as a
steward of natural life (J. Peter Bryne, Green Property, 7 Const. Comment. 239, 243
(1990)
(c) Public Trust Doctrine - lands are deemed to be owned in trust by the sovereign for the
benefit of the public
(d) Bundle of rights - title does not include the right to violate the public trust.
2. Eminent Domain
a) Art. 435. No person shall be deprive of his property except by competent authority and for
pubic use an always upon payment of just compensation.
3. Taxation
a) The theorem states that if trade in an externality is possible and there are sufficiently low
transaction costs, bargaining will lead to an efficient outcome regardless of the initial
allocation of property. In practice, obstacles to bargaining or poorly defined property rights can
prevent Coasian bargaining.
b) Meaning of Transaction Cost - any direct costs, as well as any concomitant inefficiencies in
production or misallocation that resulted from them. When property rights are protected and
maintained in any context, transaction costs exist. In economics and related disciplines, a
transaction cost is a cost incurred in making an economic exchange. In the neoclassical
approach, enforcement-type costs within firms are not transaction costs. Transaction costs
consist of those costs that occur between firms or individuals from the process of market
exchange.
c) If transaction costs are prohibitively high then property rights will neither be established nor
maintained and property rights will be zero. The reverse, however, is not necessarily true. If
property rights are complete in some situation, there are two possibilities, either transaction
costs are zero, or costs may have been incurred to guarantee the property rights simply
because the benefits of doing so exceed the costs - in which case transaction costs are
positive. Further, when property rights are zero, transaction costs could also be zero. For
example, if a property right could never be established, despite the resources devoted
towards such a goal, no one would bother making any expenditures towards establishing
property rights and the good would remain unowned. For example, there are no property
rights over the planet Venus and no efforts have been made to establish any.
2. Conditions:
a) Physical object;
b) Actual possession or control;
c) Intention to and capacity to acquire
d) Specific Resources: wild animals, hidden treasure and abandoned movables.
e) Res nulius
• includes domesticated animals that returned to the wild (20 days to reclaim, otherwise it
shall be considered as res nullius);
3. Special Rules:
a) Bees (right to pursue, 2 days);
b) Pigeons and fish (enticement rule);
c) Hidden treasure (Art. 438, NCC); Finder must return (1/10 reward) or he is liable for theft
under RPC Article 308, Par. (1);
d) Abandoned property becomes res nullius
4. Republic Act No. 9147 (Wildlife Resources Conservation Act and Protections Act)
a) State Policy
(1) Implements the policy of the State to Conserve the country’s wildlife resources and their
habitats for sustainability
(2) Objectives: Conserve, protect, regulate the collection and trade, pursue commitment to
international conventions, and to initiate scientific studies on the conservation and
protection of wildlife.
b) Illegal Acts:
(1) Section 27 enumerates the illegal acts;
(a) Killing, destroying, and injuring wildlife species;
(b) Damaging critical habitats;
(c) Introduction, reintroduction or restocking of wildlife resources;
(d) Collecting, hunting, possessing, trading, and transporting of wildlife and their by
products/derivative including active nests, nest trees, host plants and the like; and
(e) Other similar acts
c) Subject to exceptions:
(1) Section 7 and Section 27 (paragraph a, subparagraph i to v)
(2) Use by indigenous people
In accordance with customs and practices traditionally observed, accepted and recognized
including killing and destroying if part of religious rituals of established indigenous peoples
community; exception: does not cover threatened species
(3) DENR may issue permits for:
(a) Wildlife farm or culture;
(b) Wildlife collector’s permit;
(c) Gratuitous permit;
(d) Local Transport Permit; and
(e) Export/Import/Re-export permit.
c) animus revertendi
• intent to recover
d) res alicujus
• possession is lost but not ownership
B. Intellectual Creation
1. General Principles:
a) Properties that are created by the human mind
b) Creation are transformed into physical objects
(1) Physical copy of the book or in the case of songs and music the copy of the recording is
owned by the buying public
(2) Many can use it without interfering with each other’s use. It is a public good or a good that
can be consumed without reducing any other person’s consumption of it. However, the
intellectual content of the created object is owned by the author or the creator.
(3) Authors and inventors are given an incentive by giving a limited monopoly on writings and
inventions.
2. Copyright
a) Objective
• To promote science and useful arts, the constitution authorizes congress to give authors
and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writing and discoveries
b) As Incentive to creators
• Holds the right to exclude, prevent others from reproducing the work, creating derivative
works,, distributing copies of the work to the public, publicly performing the wok or
displaying during the term of the copy right. The owner may transfer her copyright to others
or destroy the copyright by abandoning it.
d) Copyright Infringement
• To prevail in a copyright infringement action, the plaintiff must prove that:
1. Plaintiff owns the copyright;
2. The defendant actually copied the plaintiff’s work; and
3. The ordinary observer would conclude that the defendant’s work was substantially
similar to the plaintiff’s work
3. Patent
a) Objective
• To promote science
• Patent Office - authorized to issue patent to anyone who invents or discovers any new and
useful process, machine, manufacture or composition of matter or any new and useful
improvement thereof.
b) Utilitarian Mandate
• Inventors are obliged to reveal how he made the invention so that others may improve it
c) What can be patented
• There are four (4) categories of inventions to qualify for a patent; any process, machine,
manufacture, or composition of matter. Abstract concept, mathematical algorithms,
scientific principles and physical phenomena cannot be patented.
d) Elements
(1) Utility - useful invention, benefit to human
(2) Novelty - new invention; prior arts examination
(3) Non-obviousness - obvious to persons with ordinary skills
(4) Enablement - description in details to enable a person skilled in the art to which it pertains
to make use of the same.
e) Patents Infringement
• Too prevail in a patent infringement action, the plaintiff must show either:
1. Literal infringement; or
2. Infringement under the “doctrine of equivalents”.
4. Trademarks
a) Objective
• While copyrights and patent law seek to encourage creative efforts, the goals of trademark
are different. Its goal is to protect consumer form being deceived inter purchasing shoddy
goods and services
b) Trademark Infringement
• To prevail in a trademark infringement action, the plaintiff must prove:
1. Plaintiff is holding a valid trademark with priority over the defendant’s mark
2. the defendant’s mark is likely to cause confussion or deceive consuments
3. Or a defendant may be liable for trademark dilution if his conduct blurs or tarnished the
plaintiff.s famous mark.
b) Assignment of Rights
C. Voluntary Transfers and Transactions
1. Sales
a) Redemption
b) Pacto de Retro
2. Donations
3. Barter or Exchange
4. Extra-Judicial Settlement of Estate
5. Lease
6. Agency
7. Mortgages
a) Real Estate
b) Chattel
8. Judicial Foreclosure
9. Estra-Judicial Forecloures
D. Involuntary Transfers and Transactions
1. Adverse Claim
2. Attachment and Execution
3. Lis Pendens
X. Donation
A. Defintion
1. A voluntary contract by which the donor expressly agrees to give, without consideration,
something to the donee, and the latter in an equally express manner accepts the gift.
2. In Roman law and in some modern codes this contract carries with it only the obligation of
transferring the ownership of the thing in question; actual ownership is obtained only by the real
traditio or handing over of the thing itself, or by the observation of certain juridically prescribed
formalities.
B. Kinds
1. Simple Donation
a) Donation is an act of liberality whereby a person disposes gratuitously of a thing or right in
favour of another who accepts it (Art. 725, NCC); and
b) Ilegal or impossible conditions that are imposed in simple donation are considered as not
imposed (Art. 727, NCC).
2. Remuneratory
a) A donation is called remunerative when inspired by a sentiment of gratitude for services
rendered by the donee. (Art. 726, NCC)
b) Remunerates past services which do not constitute a demandable debts; and
c) The donation is not payment for a demandable debts.
3. Conditional
a) When a condition, charge or burden (also called “modes”) is is imposed by the donor to the
donee in consideration of the donation. .
b) It does not affect the rights of the donee. It is an accessory disposition where the benefit
conferred on the donee is restricted by the statement of the purpose to which the thing shall be
applied or the imposition of a presentation to be performed by the donee.
c) The portion exceeding the value of the burden imposed constitutes a real donation while the
portion equivalent to the burden is governed by the rules on obligations and contracts.
4. Onerous Donation
a) Donations for a valuable consideration that is demandable agains the donor or when it
imposes a burden equivalent to the value of he donation.
b) Essentially, this is a contract is is governed by the rules of contracts (Art. 722, NCC)
c) As to when it will take effect:
D. Capacity
1. Who may give donations or receive donations
a) All persons who may contract and dispose of their property may make a donation (Art. 735,
NCC);
b) Donor’s capacity shall be determined as of the time of the making of the donation (Art. 737,
NCC)
(1) “Making of the Donation” refers to the perfection of the donation;
(2) After acceptance of the donee of the donation.
c) Guardians and trustees cannot donate the property entrusted to them (Art. 736, NCC)
3. Void Donations
a) Between persons who are guilty of adultery or concubinage at the time of the donation;
b) Made to a public officer or his wife, descendants and ascendants, in consideration of his office.
c) Applicable to insurance as well
4. Formalities
a) Public Instrument
b) Acceptance, Notification and Ratification
XI. USUFRUCT
A. Definition:
1. Usufruct gives a right to enjoy the property of another with the obligation of preserving its form
and substance, unless the title constituting it or the law otherwise provides (Art. 562, NCC). It is
constituted by law, by the will of private persons in acts inter-vivos or mortis cause and by
prescription (Art. 563, NCC). The rights and obligation of the usufuctuary are provided in the title
or in case of deficiency by the code (Art. 565, NCC).
B. Rights and Obligation of the Owner
1. To make any works, improvements and plantings as long as it will not diminish the usufruct or
prejudice the right of the usufructuary
2. To received the thing at the end of the Usufruct
3. Things that deteriorates - obligation to return as is
4. Consumables - pay the appraised value at the time of the usufruct or to return the same quantity
and quality or pay the current price at the time the usufructuary ceases.
5. To transfer or alienate the thing but he cannot alter its form or substance or do anything thereon
which may be prejudicial to the usufructuary
6. To be notified of the inventory and receive security for the thing
7. To remove trees that may be left in cases of calamities
8. To administer the thing if the usufructuary fails to give security
9. To make ordinary repairs if the usufructuary refused after demand, at the expense of the
usufructuary
10. To pay for extra-ordinary repairs upon notice, right to demand legal interest for the time the
usufructuary last
11. Pay taxes on that relates directly on the capital
C. Rights of Usufructuary
1. Entitled to the fruits growing at the time the usufruct begins (See Article 588, NCC on Security).
2. Entitled to Civil fruits - can lease the land - proportionate to the time
3. Entitled to the benefits from industrial and commercial enterprise - proportionate
4. In Wood land - natural fruits, including ordinary cutting without prejudicing the preservation of the
land. Cannot cut down trees unless it be to restore or improve the land and must inform the
owner.
5. Entitled to transfer or alienate his right of usufructuary
6. Entitled to Vindicate - may obliged the owner to give him authority to file action but his right to the
fruit is limited to what is adjudged to belong to the owner
7. Entitled to Set-Off the improvements introduce against the damage
8. Collect matured credits which forms part of the usufruct if he has given security (or upon
authority of the owner or the court)
E. Extinguishment of Usufruct
1. Death of Usufructuary
2. Expiration of the term, fulfillment of the condition
3. Merger of the usufruct and ownership
4. Renunciation of the usufructuary
5. Total loss - insurance (with or without contribution; building or no rebuilding)
6. Termination of the right of right of the person constituting the usufruct
7. Prescription