Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Final Capstone Report
Final Capstone Report
Table of contents:
Individual Contributions:
Lara:
Problem definition
Detailed design
Performance evaluation
Marilynn:
Table of Contents
Individual contributions
Design requirements
Conceptual design
Lessons learned
Glendening-Hunt 4
Problem Definition:
According to the US Department of Energy, 1.3 million gallons of oil spill into US waters alone
each year. Most spills are small, but some are enormous, spilling up to 500,000 gallons of oil
into the water. This is also a major problem outside of the United States. Major oil spills can be
incredibly damaging to ecosystems, harming wildlife and polluting the ocean for years after the
spill. The harm done to animals can be deadly, and ecosystems will likely struggle to recover.
The existing methods of cleaning up oil spills are also very harmful to the environment. There
are three main methods: chemical dispersants, burning off the oil, and skimmers. Chemical
dispersants further pollute the water, burning releases toxic chemicals into the air, and skimmers
are not effective enough at stopping oil from sinking to the bottom. Because of these
shortcomings, a solution is needed that will effectively clean up oil spills without doing even
Design Requirements:
Oil spills are difficult to clean up from the ocean, and the oil is hard to get rid of after it is
collected. An ideal product to clean up oil would be environmentally friendly, float, remove the
oil, consume the oil, and be easy to transport. The consumption of the oil would be by a bacteria
called alcanivorax borkumensis. The perfect product would be very absorbent, but mainly soak
up the oil, not the water. Absorbing the material will make the product heavy, so the product also
cannot sink from the weight because that would pollute the ocean and be difficult to pull by a
Glendening-Hunt 5
boat. The project being safe for the environment is also important because the purpose of it is to
improve the environment. It would defeat its own purpose if it is harmful to the environment.
Must be transportable.
Conceptual Design:
Alternative Concepts:
Three concepts were created with the design requirements after brainstorming 5 possible
Concept 1 is a bacteria infused sponge that soaks up oil and is made up of eco-friendly materials.
It would be dragged by a drone so that the machinery does not have as much risk of getting oil
Concept 2 will gather the oil like a boom and have bacteria grown inside of it. The bacteria will
be living and growing in the sponge. The sponge will also be pulled around by a boat gathering
Concept 3 will be a sponge soaked in the bacteria and dropped off of a boat. It will float in the
water, releasing the bacteria and when it is soaked in oil it will be picked up by a boat. The
sponge will also be biodegradable in case it sinks or breaks apart, but not immediately
biodegradable.
Evaluation of Alternatives:
The scoring criteria for the concepts are floats well, bacteria works well, easy to transport, safe
for the environment, and cost efficient. We scored the concepts with a decision matrix, shown
● Floats well- This is necessary so that the product doesn’t sink to bottom of ocean and
pollute.
● Bacteria works well- This is the staple of the project because the bacteria eats the oil.
● Safe for environment- The product’s main goal is to clean the environment; further
● Cost efficient- The product must be inexpensive enough that people are willing to buy it.
Glendening-Hunt 8
● Floats well and bacteria works well are weighted the highest because they are the main
● Safe for the environment was next highest because the product is designed to clean
oceans.
● Easy to transport and low cost are the lowest because the main target consumer is oil
companies and they can afford and have the resources to use the product. The product
Selection of a Concept:
Concept 1 had the highest evaluation at 6.2 as seen in Table 3. Because of this it is the winning
design. The only change is that the drone and boat ideas will be swapped though because the
transportability score would increase, making it an even better concept. The drone idea also did
not seem as feasible as the boat, so it makes sense to switch them. The product will be a bacteria
infused sponge that soaks up oil, is dragged by a boat, and is made up of eco-friendly materials.
Glendening-Hunt 9
Detailed Design:
The design is a 30 meter by 15 meter cotton fiber sponge infused with Alcanivorax Borkumensis
bacteria and pulled by two boats. The sponge is inlaid with two steel rings, which are used to tie
on the nylon rope attaching the sponge to the boat. The cotton fiber sponge has multiple layers
for maximum oil absorption. The sponge is soaked in a solution containing Alcanivorax
will provide the bacteria extra nutrients to feed on so they can maximize their efficiency.
Although there is a risk that these nutrients will upset the ecosystem, the bacteria will feed on
them and minimize their presence, and proper oversight and management will be in place. The
boats, as well as pulling the sponge, will churn the water, which adds even more to the bacteria’s
The cotton fiber material in the sponge was chosen after extensive research and testing.
Experiments were conducted to determine the best material between three choices: peat moss,
polypropylene, and cotton fiber. The results of these experiments showed that the cotton fiber
absorbed the most oil. It is also natural and biodegradable. Polypropylene is not natural or
biodegradable, and peat moss does not soak up oil effectively. The sponge acts as a sort of
skimmer, soaking up oil on the surface of the water while the bacteria breaks down oil beneath
the surface. The fiber is very effective at soaking up oil and not water. Therefore, it does not sink
unless it has soaked up more than its capacity of oil. Another advantage of the fiber is that it
becomes stronger in water, making it a good material to withstand ocean conditions. Below is a
The rings used to connect the skimmer sponge to the rope will be made of stainless steel because
of its rust resistant properties. The rope will be tied to the ring, which will be inlaid in the
sponge. However, the rings in the prototype were 3D printed from PLA, a biodegradable plastic,
to save money and time. Below is are photos of the PLA prototype ring, showing the placement
The product will utilize nylon rope to connect the sponge to the boats. Nylon is a good material
for boating because it is strong and does not break down easily in the sun and water. Below is a
The final aspect of the product is the A. Borkumensis bacteria. It feeds on hydrocarbons called
alkanes in the oil, helping to consume it. After metabolizing the alkanes, it produces
biosurfactants, which emulsify the oil and make it even easier to break down.
Glendening-Hunt 12
Towards the beginning of the project, two experiments were conducted to determine the
materials used in the product and the way the sponge soaks up oil. In the first experiment, the the
three materials mentioned above were tested: peat moss, polypropylene, and cotton fiber. Below
The second experiment was known as the “skim or soak” experiment. In one set of trials, the
cotton fiber piece was skimmed across the surface of the oil. In the other set, the cotton fiber sat
Skim 1 30 mL +/- 5 mL
Skim 2 35 mL +/- 5 mL
Skim 3 35 mL +/- 5 mL
Soak 1 35 mL +/- 5 mL
Soak 2 25 mL +/- 5 mL
Soak 3 25 mL +/- 5 mL
These experiments showed that cotton fiber was the best material to use, and the sponge should
Manufacturing Details:
The main product to manufacture for this apparatus is the cotton fiber sheet that will be used as a
skimmer. This can be manufactured by a third party and bought for the apparatus. The fiber is
woven into a sheet, and will have to be custom-made to fit the size requirements of the skimmer.
Below is a diagram showing how raw fiber is turned into the yarn that is woven into a sheet.
The main joining method used is the steel ring that will allow the nylon rope to be tied onto the
sheet of fiber. These rings will be made of stainless steel. These rings will also be manufactured
by a third party and sold to the producers of the apparatus, who will cut holes in the cotton fiber
sheet to place the rings into the fiber. The hole will be slightly smaller than the steel ring, so the
ring can be securely wedged into place. This will allow the rope to be tied on with a secure knot
used in boating, and the rope will be tied on the other end to an attachment on the boat to join it
to the sponge. The rope will also be provided by a third party boating materials supplier or
Performance Evaluation:
After the prototype was manufactured, performance tests were conducted to evaluate the strength
and effectiveness of the prototype. In the first performance test, water and two cups of oil were
poured into a baby pool, and the small-scale cotton fiber sponge was pulled by two “boats” to
test its effectiveness in soaking up oil. In the second performance test, four tablespoons of motor
oil were poured into a small container of water, and a strain of archaea that performs very
similarly to the A. Borkumensis bacteria was added. Then, the degradation of oil over time was
It was predicted that the sponge would soak up half the oil, and that is about what happened. It
was also predicted that the bacteria would break down all of the oil, and although that did not
happen, there was definite oil degradation. Further experiments must be conducted with the
Lessons Learned:
A way to improve the product could be to test a wider range of materials and run tests on
how to improve the efficiency of the bacteria. If more sorbent materials were tested, a better,
more efficient, and cheaper material to create the sponge of the product could be found and used.
Also, had the alcanivorax borkumensis bacteria been cheaper, experiments regarding how to
maximize it could have been run. If the bacteria was tested with different methods of stimulating
it to consume the oil faster, it would have greatly improved the product. Unfortunately, the
alcanivorax borkumensis was too expensive to buy and test. These two tests, materials and
bacteria efficiency, would have made the product much better, had they been done.
The capstone project taught students that the first few design steps are mainly
brainstorming, research, data collection, and conceptual designs. They are the foundation of the
project. Design step 4 is when physical testing is started and the prototype is modelled. The
actual prototype is not built or tested until step 6 and 7. It was shocking that most of the design
cycle steps are planning. There is a lot of analysis, research, and debate that goes on in
engineering before the building even starts. The design cycle also leaves a lot of room to
redesign and test aspects of the designs, which is great in order to create the best product
possible.
Teaming up in the capstone project taught many valuable lessons and skills. It fostered
many teamwork skills like communication, collaboration, leadership, and responsibility. These
are vital life skills as well because they are in everyday life, and especially the working world.
The capstone project was a projection of what a project would be like for a real engineer. It gave
students the opportunity to experience a possible career after high school. Working with a
Glendening-Hunt 16
partner helped develop more understanding and consideration for other people’s ideas. Learning
from peers is a great way to learn. Teaming up creates relationships, which is what the world and