Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Borchert 2014
Borchert 2014
ABSTRACT
Interference with tumor suppressor pathways by polyomavirus-encoded tumor antigens (T-Ags) can result in transformation.
IMPORTANCE
MCPyV is one of the 12 known polyomaviruses that naturally infect humans. Among these, it is of particular interest since it is
the only human polyomavirus known to be involved in tumorigenesis. MCPyV is thought to be causally linked to MCC, a rare
skin tumor. In these tumors, viral DNA is monoclonally integrated into the genome of the tumor cells in up to 90% of all MCC
cases, and the integrated MCV genomes, furthermore, harbor signature mutations in the so-called early region that selectively
abrogate viral replication while preserving cell cycle deregulating functions of the virus. This study describes comparative stud-
ies of early region T-Ag protein characteristics, their ability to bind to Rb and p53, and their transforming potential.
3144 jvi.asm.org Journal of Virology p. 3144 –3160 March 2014 Volume 88 Number 6
Functional Characterization of the MCPyV LT Antigen
binding domain located in the C terminus. The N terminus, in- primary baby rat kidney cells by early region constructs encoding
cluding the J domain and the LxCxE motif, can be sufficient to full-length and truncated MCPyV LT genes. Collectively, our data
transform cells in vitro (14). Similar to SV40 LT-Ag, the LT pro- support the hypothesis that truncated MCPyV LT-Ag plays an
teins encoded by the related JC and BK polyomaviruses have also important role during the pathogenesis of MCC.
been shown to induce transformation in vitro, although less effi-
ciently than those of SV40 (15, 16). The lower transformation MATERIALS AND METHODS
efficiency is a likely consequence of the reduced affinity with Cell lines. 293 cells (30), H1299 cells (31), and Saos-2 cells (32) were
which these proteins bind to the Rb family of tumor suppressors grown as monolayer cultures in Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium
(17). (DMEM) supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum (FCS) and 5% penicil-
Interestingly, all large tumor antigen (LT-Ag) sequences recov- lin-streptomycin in a 5% CO2 atmosphere at 37°C. PFSK-1 cells, WaGa
ered from primary MCC tumors or tumor-derived cell lines har- cells, and MKL-1 cells were grown in RPMI medium supplemented with
bor signature mutations that lead to the expression of shortened 10% FCS and 5% penicillin-streptomycin.
LT-Ag proteins. These truncation products unequivocally pre- Plasmids and transient transfections. The MCPyV LT full-length ex-
serve the Rb binding motif, but they lack a functional origin bind- pression construct (pCMV2b-MCPyVLTFL) was generated by PCR am-
plification using a taqExpand PCR amplification system (Roche Diagnos-
ing domain (OBD) and ATPase/helicase region (10, 18, 19). It is
scribed (28). Briefly, DNA was digested with DpnI to distinguish repli- trifugation (4°C, 14,000 rpm, 30 min). After normalizing for protein con-
cated DNA from input DNA and EcoRI for linearization. Digested DNA centration, whole-cell extracts were subjected to immunoprecipitation.
was resolved on a 1% agarose gel, transferred to Hybond-N⫹ (Amersham Supernatant was precleared by adding 35 l protein A/G Sepharose (Santa
Pharmacia) membrane by Southern blotting, UV cross-linked, and hy- Cruz) for 30 min at 4°C. A 10-l antibody solution was added to the lysate,
bridized overnight at 42°C with a 32P-labeled probe (Rediprime II DNA and the mixture was rotated at 4°C O/N. Thirty-five microliters of protein
labeling system, random-primed labeled; GE Healthcare) corresponding A/G Sepharose was added for 1 h at 4°C with rotation. Beads were washed
to the restriction fragment HinDIII/EcoRV (pCR2.1-MCPyVori). 5⫻ (TN buffer), and FLAG proteins were eluted from the beads by com-
Antibodies and Western blot analysis. For protein extraction, pel- petition with the FLAG peptide (100 g/ml) or by adding SDS loading
leted cells were resuspended in lysis buffer (50 mM Tris [pH 8.0], 150 mM buffer and with subsequent boiling of the samples.
NaCl, 1% NP-40, 0.5% Na-deoxycholate, 5 mM EDTA, 0.1% SDS). Pro- FACS-FRET. Fluorescence-activated cell sorter–fluorescence reso-
teins were separated by SDS-PAGE and blotted on a nitrocellulose mem- nance energy transfer (FACS-FRET) was performed as recently described
brane. Primary antibodies specific for polyomavirus proteins used in this (44) using the Clontech vectors pEYFP-C1/N1 and pECFP-C1/N1.
study include MCPyV LT-Ag mouse monoclonal antibody (MAb) Merkel cell polyomavirus sequences were N- and C-terminally tagged
Cm2B4 (10) (Santa Cruz) and SV40 LT mouse MAb Pab419 (41). p53 using the pEYFP-N1 vector and the restriction sites NheI/AgeI and BsrGI/
mouse MAb DO-1, polyclonal Ab FL-393, Brd4 specific rabbit polyclonal NotI, respectively. Tagged SV40 LT-Ag was generated using the
Ab H-250, and Rb rabbit polyclonal Ab M-153 were purchased from Santa pEYFP-C1 vector with restriction sites NheI/AgeI for N-terminal tagging
expression was induced with 0.5 mM IPTG, and cells were grown at 16°C the position of the last preserved amino acid, i.e., the last amino
for 18 h. The purification strategy has been described before (48). acid position preceding stop codon or frameshift mutations. As
MST. The microscale thermophoresis (MST) background has been shown in Fig. 1A, most mutations (n ⫽ 31; 78%) result in trunca-
reviewed recently (49). The dissociation constant of bacterially expressed tion between aa 243 and 329 and remove the origin binding do-
N-terminally truncated LT proteins binding to the purified Rb pocket main (OBD), whereas only 7 mutations (18%) leave the OBD
domain was measured using a Monolith NT115 (NanoTemper). Purified
intact. Furthermore, the 31 proximal mutations map upstream of
Rb pocket domain fragments were Alexa 647 labeled by following the
manufacturer’s protocol. A solution of monomeric LT proteins was seri- the 57-kDa splice donor, such that the spliced transcripts would
ally diluted as indicated in Results. The labeled Rb pocket domain was likewise generate a truncated LT-Ag. In 9 cases, the mutations are
incubated with the LT protein dilutions at room temperature in the dark located within the 57-kDa intron, and these isolates should thus be
for 30 min. Measurements were performed with 50 mM Tris [pH 7.4], able to produce a full-length 57-kDa T-Ag.
0.05% Tween [150 mM], and 200 mM or 250 mM NaCl at 50% red For each amino acid position encoded by the second exon of
light-emitting diode (LED) power and 60% infrared (IR) laser power the full-length LT-Ag gene, we next calculated the P value for the
using hydrophilic capillaries. Measurements were also carried out at 20% hypothesis that this position is subject to either positive or nega-
and 40% IR laser power. Three independent measurements at the condi- tive selection in MCC (see Materials and Methods for details of the
tions described in Results were executed. Data analysis was performed statistical analysis). The P values for negative selection of the
FIG 1 Preservation of the LxCxE motif in MCC-derived LT-Ag proteins is highly significant. (A) Frequency plot showing the position of the last preserved amino
acid (i.e., the last position preceding stop codon or frameshift mutations) across 42 MCC-derived truncated MCPyV LT-Ag genes. (B) Amino acid alignment of
SV40 LT-Ag (GI: 297591903) and MCPyV LT-Ag (GI: 372100550) using LALIGN. Identical, conserved, and semiconserved amino acids are indicated by
asterisks, colons, and periods, respectively. The functional DnaJ, OBD, zinc finger, and helicase/ATPase domains, as well as the Rb binding LxCxE motif, are
shown as light gray boxes in panels A and B. Regions that undergo positive or negative selection according to our statistical analysis are marked. In panel A, dark
gray boxes labeled U1 and U2 symbolize regions that are unique to MCPyV and not present in SV40. The position of a recently identified functional NLS in
MCPyV LT-Ag (50) and the partially conserved NLS of SV40 are labeled NLS a and b, respectively. Underlined amino acids in panel B highlight the bipartite
regions that mediate p53 binding of SV40 LT-Ag, and individual residues that make direct contact with p53 are additionally marked by arrows (72).
FIG 2 Viral replication assays using pCR2.1-ori plasmids and LT expression plasmids. (A) Southern blot of HIRT DNA extracts from PFSK-1 cells transfected
with 1 g pCR2.1 MCPyV-ori and N-terminally or C-terminally tagged MCPyV LT expression constructs. (B) Western blot of PFSK-1 cells expressing MCPyV
LT-Ag 48 h posttransfection. Mock, mock transfection; d, days.
FIG 6 MCC-derived truncated MCPyV tLT proteins do not repress p53-dependent transcription in transiently transfected H1299 cells. Subconfluent H1299
cells were transfected with pRL-TK, pRE-Luc, pc53-SN3, and LT-Ag expression constructs (100 ng pZIPTEX-SV40LTFL, 3 g pCMV2b-MCPyVLTFL, 200 ng
pCMV2b-MCPyVLTMCCL-12, 200 ng pCMV2b-MCPyVLTMCCL-11, 200 ng pCMV2b-MCPyVLTMCCL-3, 200 ng pCMV2b-MCPyVLTMCV350). DNA amounts
were adjusted with empty vector such that the total amount of transfected DNA was equal in each sample. The cells were harvested after 48 h and analyzed for
firefly luciferase activity and Renilla luciferase activity. (A) Normalized luciferase activity relative to that of the positive control (cells transfected with p53 and
reporter constructs) is shown. Adenovirus E1B-55k-wt protein efficiently repressing p53-dependent transcription was used as an internal control. P values using
an unpaired t test are indicated. (B) Western blot of cells analyzed in panel A with loading of equal amounts of LT protein expressed under these conditions.
Unspecific background binding of Cm2B4 Ab staining is indicated with an asterisk.
TABLE 1 FACS-FRET results teins in vivo (Table 1). In contrast, we did not measure any
Construct FRET signal (%)b FRET signal for N- or C-terminally tagged MCPyV LT fusion
CFP/YFP proteins (full-length or truncated) (Table 1 and data not shown)
YFP CFP distancea Expt A Expt B Expt C or for any of the various p53 fusions, indicating that MCPyV
SV40 LT N p53 N 1 0.4 1.5 1.4 LT-Ag most likely does not directly bind to p53.
SV40 LT N p53 C 1 0 0 0 MCPyV FL and truncated LT-Ag bind to Rb and release Rb-
SV40 LT C p53 N 2 24.4 20.7 29.3
dependent repression of E2F-regulated transcription. The abil-
SV40 LT C p53 C 3 76.4 80.1 71.1
ity of tumor-derived truncated full-length and LT proteins of
p53 N SV40 LT N 1 0.7 0.9 0.2
p53 C SV40 LT N 1 1.6 1.9 0.4 MCPyV to bind to Rb through the highly conserved LxCxE motif
p53 N SV40 LT C 2 41.1 40.2 44.5 has previously been confirmed by coimmunoprecipitation exper-
p53 C SV40 LT C 3 47.3 32.1 36.2 iments (9). Here, we compared coprecipitation efficiencies of Rb
MCPyV LT N p53 N 0 0 0 and SV40 LT-Ag as well as full-length and truncated MCPyV LT
MCPyV LT N p53 C 0 0 0 proteins. As in our previous p53 binding studies, we used a larger
MCPyV LT C p53 N 0 0 0 amount of the full-length MCPyV expression construct to obtain
MCPyV LT C p53 N 0 0 0 expression levels comparable to those of the truncated proteins.
FIG 7 Full-length MCPyV LTFL weakly binds Rb in transiently transfected H1299 cells while truncated MCPyV tLT strongly interacts with Rb. Cells were Downloaded from http://jvi.asm.org/ on June 17, 2019 by guest
cotransfected with Rb and LT expression constructs. To ensure equal levels of expression, 3 g of the full-length LT and 0.5 g of truncated LT expression
constructs were used. Empty vector was used to the total amount of transfected DNA such that it was equal in each sample. Cells were harvested after 72 h, and
total-cell extracts were prepared. Coimmunoprecipitation of MCPyV LTFL (A), SV40 LTFL (B), and MCPyV tLT (C) using polyclonal Rb serum for precipitation
of interacting proteins. (D) Full-length MCPyV LT FL or truncated MCPyV tLT proteins (E and F) were precipitated with an anti-FLAG antibody; coprecipitating
proteins were eluted with FLAG peptide (peptide eluate). In addition, beads were boiled in sample buffer (beads eluate). Cell lysate from H1299 cells transfected
with a vector control (Mock control) were used as a negative control in co-IP experiments. Beads were boiled in sample buffer to control for unspecific binding.
increase in cdc2 and cyclinA2 expression when truncated MCPyV Truncated MCPyV LT-Ag display high binding affinity to the
LT protein or SV40 LT protein was expressed. In contrast, MCPyV Rb pocket domain. To follow up on our coimmunoprecipitation
LT full-length protein expression did not induce a significant in- results, where we consistently observed robust binding of Rb to
crease of cdc2 and cyclinA2 expression levels. These data suggest truncated MCPyV-LT proteins, we sought to further investigate
that, at least under the conditions used here, truncated LT is more parameters of the interaction by use of microscale thermophoresis
potent than the full-length protein in its ability to induce tran- (MST), a novel method that allows the quantitative measurement
scription of authentic E2F target genes. of binding affinities between proteins in solution (61). For this
In summary, we show for the first time that tumor-derived repression, (ii) full-length, but not truncated, MCPyV LT-Ag binds
MCPyV T-Ag genes are oncogenes that induce substantial altera- indirectly to p53 and interferes with p53-dependent transcriptional
tions in morphology and growth behavior of primary rodent ep- activation, and (iii) full-length and MCC-derived T-Ag genes can
ithelial cells, despite the inability of tLT-Ags to bind to p53 or induce the transformation of primary rat epithelial cells.
reduce p53-dependent transcription. MCPyV is the only human polyomavirus known to induce
tumors in its host. A number of findings suggest a causative role of
DISCUSSION MCPyV in Merkel cell carcinoma tumorigenesis: the virus can be
In this study, we performed a biochemical, molecular, and functional identified in the majority of MCC biopsy specimens (3, 4, 6–9),
characterization of full-length and MCC-derived truncated MCPyV MCPyV DNA is monoclonally integrated in the tumor cells (3, 9),
LT proteins. Key findings of our study include the facts that (i) trun- the viral T-Ags are expressed in tumor cells (5, 10), and LT-Ag
cated LT-Ags bind with high affinity to Rb and release transcriptional sequences isolated from tumor cells harbor tumor-specific muta-
FIG 10 Binding affinity of truncated LT proteins to Rb pocket domain determined by microscale thermophoresis. Binding curves of bacterially expressed and
purified His-tagged MCPyV LT1-244 (A) or SV40 LT7-117 (B) binding to the Rb pocket domain Rb382-771 at a 150 mM salt concentration (conc.). Fitting curve and
parameters are depicted.
TABLE 2 Kd values determined by microscale thermophoresisa quent cell death and is qualitatively different from a knockdown of
Kd value for Rb382–771 sT-Ag only (26). Interestingly, however, Shuda and colleagues re-
cently demonstrated that approximately 5 to 10% of MCCs ex-
Construct 150 mM NaCl 250 mM NaCl
press sT antigen but are negative for LT protein expression (25).
SV40 LT7-117 1950 nM (367.5) — Since sT-Ag, but not LT-Ag, was also found to be able to transform
MCPyV LT-Ag1-244 51.3 nM (38.1) 121 nM (35.2) rat-1 cells (25), it could be argued that sT-Ag may represent the
a
Average Kd value of three independent measurements by applying microscale major oncogene of MCPyV. In such a scenario, it also appears
thermophoresis. Standard deviations are indicated in parentheses. —, no binding.
possible that preservation of the LxCxE motif in LT-Ag is an indi-
rect result of the pressure to maintain a functional sT-Ag gene.
tions that lead to premature truncation of LT-Ag, presumably due Our survey and a statistical analysis of truncated LT-Ag coding
to a selection pressure to abrogate viral replication (9, 18, 64, 65). regions, however, clearly indicate that MCC development selects
It is striking that all truncated LT proteins retain the LxCxE motif, for the presence of an amino-terminal region that significantly
a fact that would seem to provide a strong argument for a domi- extends beyond the first exon shared with the sT-Ag gene and
nant requirement for LT-Ag-mediated Rb inactivation during which includes the LxCxE motif. As this selection also applies to
MCC pathogenesis. Support for this hypothesis comes from the the integrated genomes of those MCC tumors that have ceased to
FIG 11 Subcellular localization of Rb protein in cells transiently transfected with truncated MCPyV tLT-Ag. H1299 cells were transiently transfected with Rb and
the indicated LT expression plasmids. At 48 h posttransfection, cells were stained with Cm2B4 MAb, Pab419 MAb, and FITC (Rb)/TRITC (LT)-conjugated
secondary antibodies.
tance especially during the early steps of MCC tumorigenesis. At ingly, besides the nuclear LT-Ag fraction, we find that a consider-
later stages, a subset of MCC tumors may become independent of able subfraction of not only NLS-deficient but also truncated LT-
continuous LT-Ag expression, perhaps as a result of the acquisi- Ags that still contain an NLS localizes to the cytoplasm. Given the
tion of additional mutations within the cellular genome and im- fact that similar observations were made for the MCC-derived cell
munological pressure to limit viral gene expression. Recent pub- line MKL-1 (which likewise expresses a tLT that still contains the
lications by Cheng et al. and Li et al. demonstrated by using reported NLS), one might argues against the possibility that the
immortalized cells that truncated MCPyV-LT proteins, in con- partial cytoplasmic localization occurs only during ectopic ex-
trast to full-length LT protein, efficiently promote cell growth (21, pression. This observation raises the possibility that an additional
29); this result suggests that the MCC-specific truncations of feature of truncated LT-Ags may be their ability to relocalize in-
LT-Ag may serve to abrogate growth inhibitory properties map- teraction partners to the cytoplasm. We have shown through ex-
ping to the C terminus of MCPyV LT protein. amples that this is the case for ectopically and endogenously ex-
In contrast to the preserved LxCxE motif, our analysis suggests pressed Rb protein. Of note, we think it unlikely that the partial
that there is no positive selection for the presence of a functional cytoplasmic relocalization of Rb itself has functional conse-
NLS in MCC-derived tLT-Ags. At a calculated molecular mass of quences, given that full-length (and strictly nuclear) LT protein
30.5 kDa or less, truncated LT proteins that lack an NLS should efficiently relieves Rb-mediated transcriptional repression. It thus
nevertheless be able to enter the nucleus via passive diffusion, a may be more interesting to consider such a mechanism for other
hypothesis that is supported by our localization studies. Interest- interaction partners of truncated LT-Ags, e.g., cellular proteins
that bind to the unique ⬃110-amino-acid region which precedes percentage of apoptotic cells (data not shown), characteristics
the LxCxE region. Another interesting case is that of interaction which have been described for MCC tumor cells (71). It should be
partners that relocalize to the nucleus when complexed with full- pointed out our experiments employ genomic clones that harbor
length LT-Ag but fail to do so upon interaction with the truncated the entire early region from wild-type or MCC-derived MCPyV
protein, such as the lysosomal processing regulator hVam6p (66). genomes. These constructs thus should be able to express not only
It should also be noted that transformation by cytoplasmic LT but also sT, and it is likely that the sT protein contributes to the
LT-Ags is not without precedent, given that artificially generated transformation events observed in our assays. We have not explic-
mutants of SV40 LT-Ag that fail to localize to the nucleus have itly tested the transforming potential of sT-deficient LT expres-
been found to be capable of transforming continuously growing sion constructs (such constructs would also be expected to yield
rodent cells (67). significantly lower LT levels due to the absence of sT-mediated
In SV40, binding to Rb and p53 contributes to LT protein stabilization of the LT protein). However, given that only con-
functions during viral replication and cellular transformation. structs encoding truncated LT proteins yield continuously grow-
SV40 LT protein binds directly to the DNA binding domain of ing colonies in focus formation assays, and since tLT expression
p53, thereby suppressing p53-mediated transcriptional activa- furthermore resulted in the outgrowth of larger colonies in an-
tion. The C-terminal domain of LT contains two regions, box 1 chorage-independent growth assays, our data suggest an impor-
replication. PLoS Pathog. 8:e1003021. http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal tumor antigen are defective for binding cellular protein p53. Virology
.ppat.1003021. 168:13–21. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0042-6822(89)90398-X.
40. Schreiner S, Wimmer P, Groitl P, Chen SY, Blanchette P, Branton PE, 57. Peden KW, Srinivasan A, Vartikar JV, Pipas JM. 1998. Effects of muta-
Dobner T. 2011. Adenovirus type 5 early region 1B 55K oncoprotein- tions within the SV40 large T antigen ATPase/p53 binding domain on viral
dependent degradation of cellular factor Daxx is required for efficient replication and transformation. Virus Genes 16:153–165. http://dx.doi
transformation of primary rodent cells. J. Virol. 85:8752– 8765. http://dx .org/10.1023/A:1007941622680.
.doi.org/10.1128/JVI.00440-11. 58. Staib C, Pesch J, Gerwig R, Gerber JK, Brehm U, Stangl A, Grummt F.
41. Harlow E, Crawford LV, Pim DC, Williamson NM. 1981. Monoclonal 1996. p53 inhibits JC virus DNA replication in vivo and interacts with JC
antibodies specific for simian virus 40 tumor antigens. J. Virol. 39:861– virus large T-antigen. Virology 219:237–246. http://dx.doi.org/10.1006
869. /viro.1996.0241.
42. Nevels M, Rubenwolf S, Spruss T, Wolf H, Dobner T. 1997. The 59. Dilworth SM. 1990. Cell alterations induced by the large T-antigens of
adenovirus E4orf6 protein can promote E1A/E1B-induced focus forma- SV40 and polyoma virus. Semin. Cancer Biol. 1:407– 414.
tion by interfering with p53 tumor suppressor function. Proc. Natl. Acad. 60. Imperiale MJ, Major EO. 2007. Polyomaviruses, p 2263–2298. In Knipe
Sci. U. S. A. 94:1206 –1211. http://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.94.4.1206. DM, Howley PM, Griffin DE, Lamb RA, Martin MA, Roizman B, Straus
43. Hermannstädter A, Ziegler C, Kuhl M, Deppert W, Tolstonog GV. SE (ed), Fields virology, 5th ed. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Philadel-
2009. Wild-type p53 enhances efficiency of simian virus 40 large-T- phia, PA.
antigen-induced cellular transformation. J. Virol. 83:10106 –10118. http: 61. Wienken CJ, Baaske P, Rothbauer U, Braun D, Duhr S. 2010. Protein-
//dx.doi.org/10.1128/JVI.00174-09. binding assays in biological liquids using microscale thermophoresis. Nat.