Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Geophysical Society of Houston: Inside
Geophysical Society of Houston: Inside
of Houston
VOL. 32, NO. 3 NEWSLETTER NOVEMBER 1996
The Geophysical Society of Houston Newsletter (ISSN 1082-0817) is published monthly except July and August by the Geophysical Society of Houston, 7457 Harwin,
Suite 301, Houston, Texas 77036. Subscription to the Geophysical Society of Houston Newsletter is included in the membership dues ($20.00 annually). Periodicals
Postage Paid in Houston, Texas.
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Geophysical Society of Houston Newsletter, 7457 Harwin, Suite 301, Houston, TX 77036.
2
Technical Luncheon in a particular survey area. For every We do not record the continuous
survey, the chosen recording geometry wave field in time or space. In both
November 18 must be balanced against the terrain and dimensions, we sample the wave field
Topic: Surface Seismic Data available equipment to yield a smooth at discrete points. The recording
Acquisition: Current time and motion demand. geometry must sample the seismic wave
Technology, Trends and field in such a manner that we avoid
Issues A second backdrop against which spatially aliasing data from the point
Speaker: Dr. Fred J. Barr we geophysicists find ourselves laboring diffractors, as well as any source-
is an increasing demand to reduce our generated noise. Any 3-D recording
Introduction seismic crew “footprints” on the geometry being contemplated for a
environment, as well as a growing survey must be analyzed on the basis of
We curr ently demand to acquire data in areas that not only midpoint fold, offset, and
find ourselves armed include transition zones. As luck would azimuth distributions, but also on the
with a dazzling array have it, many of these transition zones range and uniformity of dips that the
of technologies with represent some of the world’s more wave equation operators contribute to
which to acquire ecologically fragile areas. We’ve each cell’s output trace. Otherwise, the
seismic data. These developed equipment and methods to recording geometry may introduce
technologies, as well satisfy these conflicting demands and amplitude and phase anomalies that
as their attendant continue to refine them. could be misinterpreted as subsurface
trends and issues, have developed in geologic changes.
response to both market and technical Finally, and thankfully, some “spit
forces, powerful forces at work for and polish” is being applied to, or at Seismic Energy Sources
several decades. least contemplated for, some existing
seismic tools to improve our ability to The air gun remains the dominant
The market forces demand lower meet today’s market demands. These energy source in marine seismic
costs for finding and producing include reevaluating vibrator data acquisition. Until recently, the sleeve air
hydrocarbons. The technical forces, as processing to improve its quality, and gun demonstrated clear performance
if to test our collective sense of humor, infusing new technology into the ocean- advantages over other available designs;
have led us to realize that high-quality bottom cable method to improve the recent improvements have narrowed
3-D data represent surface seismic’s resolution of marine data. It also the performance gap. There have been
most effective contribution to that goal. includes a return of serious interest in innovative developments with
The rub, of course, is that acquiring and recording mode-converted shear waves, generator-injector gun clusters to
processing high-quality 3-D seismic data as well as time lapse 3-D surveys for produce quite high pulse-to-bubble
is, itself, very expensive. monitoring reservoir fluid movements. ratios. And further refinements in
methods of computing far-field air gun
This apparent dichotomy has 3-D Geometry Design array signatures from near-field
resulted in pressure to reduce the cost measurements have been targeted at
of acquiring and processing 3-D data. The recording geometry with which time-lapse 3-D surveys, also referred to
Seismic contractors and equipment 3-D data are acquired has been, and as 4-D.
manufacturers have responded with remains, among the most contentious
methods and systems to increase issues facing geophysicists. It has a big Potential environmental concerns
acquisition and processing productivity. impact upon the cost of a 3-D survey. have resulted in some reengineering of
In the marine environment, the trend the marine vibrator source in an attempt
has been toward towing more streamers Whereas modern wave-equation to improve low-frequency output.
and sources in an effort to illuminate a imaging algorithms such as DMO and However, there has also been concern
larger subsurface area with each pass migration have drastically improved the expressed that impulses may disturb
of the vessel over a prospect. accuracy and resolution of seismic data, marine creatures less than long duration
Unfortunately, while providing higher the amplitude and phase of their outputs oscillatory signals that are similar to, or
productivity, these wide-tow have also proven much more sensitive could mask, their communication
configurations have also introduced to the acquisition geometry than are signals.
significant amplitude and phase simple NMO and stacking. This
anomalies into the final imaged data, sensitivity can be appreciated using The vibrator remains the dominant
reducing their quality. Huygen’s Principle which leads one to land energy source, in part because of
understand that every reflecting horizon, its lower operating expense. Units
In land operations, the quest has dipping or flat, can be represented as capable of generating peak forces
led to methods yielding higher an infinite number of point diffractors. approaching 65,000 pounds have been
production, lighter and more reliable Each of these point diffractors contains developed and have allowed sweep
equipment, and shooting geometries dips ranging from -90 to +90 degrees. times to be significantly reduced,
that require fewer shots or receiver
stations, whichever are more expensive
Continued on page 6
3
Seismic Data Potential Fields SIG Engineer at the Creole Petroleum Corp.
(Lagoven S.A.). From 1965 to 1967
Processing SIG he was a member of the Geophysics
Date: November 21
Thursday Department of the Ministry of Energy
Date: November 20 and Mines of the Republic of Venezuela.
Wednesday Time: 5:30 - Social Hour,
6:30 - Dinner, Between 1967 and 1969 he was a
Time: 4:00 p.m. - 6:00 p.m. graduate student at the University of
Location: Exxon Production 7:30 - Talk
Location: Hess Building, Toronto in Canada where he finished
Research Company, his M.Sc. In Geophysics.
Rm S-202, 3121 Buffalo Speedway
3120 Buffalo speedway Cost: $20.00
Topic: Constrained Gravity Back in Venezuela he became head of
Cost: NO CHARGE; please call the Geophysics Department at the
917-0218 for reservation. interpretation in the
major sedimentary basins MEM and started his academic career
Topic: Ocean bottom cable as Instructor at the Universidad Central
acquisition and processing of Venezuela.
Speaker: Victor Graterol de Venezuela. In 1974, as a member
Speakers: Joel Starr, PGS Tensor of the Physics Department of the Simon
Organizer: Jerry Kapoor, Reservation: Chuck Campbell, ACCEL
Services, Inc. Bolivar University, he developed the
Western Geophysical former Geophysics Section that today
Young Kim, campbell@neosoft.com,
or 713-993-0671 is the Earth Science Department, part
Exxon Production of Engineering Geophysics at this
Research Company prestigious institution. Victor has over
Parking: The location is on the west Abstract:
In the evaluation of sedimentary basins 30 years experience in Potential
side of Buffalo speedway Methods concentrated in acquisition,
between Richmond and with extensive gravity and magnetic
coverage , but with limited seismic data, processing and interpretation of gravity-
Alabama. There are two magnetic surveys. He classified and
parking lots for visitors: the integrated interpretation of the three
types of geophysical information is evaluated over a half a million gravity
one at north and another land, marine and airborne stations that
at south of the building. strictly necessary to establish not only
the possible potential of the basin, but form today the USB-Venezuela gravity
also to define the follow up exploration data base.
OBS Processing
Mr. Joel Starr, PGS Tensor program.
At present he is an international
Constrained Gravity interpretation is the consulting potential field geophysicist
Ocean Bottom Seismic (OBS) interpreter doing work for companies
processing combines the geophysical key to establishing basin potential.
Control points coming from the limiting such as Carson Services - Aerogravity
challenges of processing land seismic Division and First Exchange Corp. He
data with the data volume challenges existing seismic data and direct
information from wells and geological is a member of the SOVG and SEG.
of processing marine seismic data. OBS
acquisition provides stationary receivers, surface maps, can be employed to
which allows for superior statics, and obtain regional and residual constrained
positioning solutions. However, the maps that permit a more adequate
independence of the sources and quantitative gravity modeling method
for outlining the main existing geological GSH AUXILIARY
recording system means geometry
initialization over a typical 500 square structures in the basin. The final NEWS
mile surveys can strain traditional composite structural interpreted map Auxiliary Of ficers for
methods. In addition, OBS has its own showing the top of the main density 1996-1997
unique processes such as dual sensor interface , also permit the optimum
President–Jeanne Cooley
technology. design for the location of the eventual
follow seismic program. President Elect–Roxanne
This talk explores the today’s challenges
Antonation
for processing Ocean Bottom Seismic
surveys. Examples of constrained gravity 1st Vice President–Joyce Kubik
interpretation for specific areas within 2nd Vice President–Phyllis Evans
the Eastern Venezuelan , Guarumen
and Maracaibo basins are presented to Secretary–Ann Schneider
illustrate this approach in the Treasurer–Charlcie Dial
interpretation of potential field data. Historian–Cass Hanson
4
Upcoming GSH
ATTENTION MEMBERS Auxilliary Events
OFFICE MOVE Luncheons:
This year the HGS Research & is also attempting to acquire new feature
New Publications Committee is articles for our Bulletin that fill a niche Spring Brunch
attempting to complete two ongoing in our profession. In particular, we are
projects and initiate several new ones. seeking short, timely, hard hitting March 2, 1997
Work on our carryover projects, Low articles on exploration-related The First Methodist Church and
Resistivity Pays of the World and The technologies or regionally important Music Academy of Sugar Land
Building Stones of Houston, is exploration strategies or trends. These presenting a potpourri of
progressing and will hopefully be need not be “scholarly works” as is Musical Comedy hits.
brought to closure with publication in required for many of our scientific Lakeside Country Club
1997. However, it has been some years journals, but brief papers that expose
since we have issued a major new our readership to important information
publication form our Society. I believe in as efficient and timely a fashion as Spring Bus Tour
that a local Professional Society of our possible. We envision that many of
size and stature should be a leader in these will be early publication of ideas
April 9, 1997
publication of technical and exploration and results to a focused audience that
Day trip to Austin including
related topics of regional interest. To may later be “fleshed-out” in more
tour of Governor’s Mansion
that end, our Committee is actively formal journals of broader circulation.
soliciting publication opportunities from The HGS/GSH can offer these authors
individuals and other Professional a quality Bulletin with a readership of
There is also a Duplicate Bridge
Societies that will be of interest and use about 5,000 and a short turnaround to
Group that meets at 7:30 p.m.
to our membership. We will consider publication. Both the HGS Bulletin and
on the 2nd Friday of each month
sole publication of appropriate material GSH Newsletter can serve our
at the Bridge Studio, 6640
or co-publication with sister Societies. professions by filling this niche in the
Harwin.
If you know of such opportunities please industry. If you have ideas for such
pass them on to me by phone at (366- articles please contact either the HGS
If you are interested in attending
2198), by fax at (366-2404), or by e- or GSH.
any or all of the auxiliary
mail at (ran!elson@hou.amoco.com).
functions as a guest or would like
In addition to soliciting new
to join our organization, contact
publications, this year our Committee
Barbara Thigpen, GSH Liaison,
at 497-3299.
5
Continued from page 3 the field with completely correct eliminated the receiver ghost spectral
geometry information reduces the time notch and, therefore, increased the
achieving higher productivity.
required to process land 3-D data by data’s bandwidth. With numerous other
between 20 and 30 percent. However, advantages inherent in the method
Recording Instrumentation
on some particularly remote prospects, including surface consistent geometry
much more extensive processing is and elimination of the need for cell
The 24-bit sigma-delta analog-to-
being implemented. flexing, the method has produced
digital converter has almost completely
imaged data with greater resolution
replaced the instantaneous floating
On marine vessels, parallel- than those produced with towed
point amplifier in new land, marine and
processing super computers have been streamers. Its use has been extended to
transition zone recording systems. To-
installed. In one known case, a waters clear of obstacles.
date, the primary benefits of this
processing flow culminating in a final,
technology have been smaller and
pre-stack time migrated cube was Experiments with time-lapse 3-D,
lighter instruments, reduced power
implemented and was able to keep up or 4-D, surveys began more than 10
requirements and improved reliability.
with the data acquisition. years ago. Interest in this technology
These new systems provide increased
has recently risen dramatically. Mapping
linearity and instantaneous dynamic
The future of powerful onboard fluid front movements, as well as
resolution, and write higher quality data
computers, or at least that of having estimating reservoir properties to refine
to tape. However, our ability to
the processing geophysicists onboard, reservoir simulator models, are aimed
capitalize upon these improvements by
has been clouded somewhat by the at increasing the efficiency with which
shrinking spatial arrays, recording more
advent of wavelet-transform based data hydrocarbons are produced. Estimating
noise and attenuating that noise in data
compression algorithms. A major oil reservoir properties has also led to a
processing has been slower to develop.
company recently implemented such a recurrent interest in recording and
data compression algorithm and processing mode-converted shear
The increasing numbers of surveys
compared the processing results from waves. For reservoirs in marine settings,
that include open water, transition zone
a 3-D survey’s uncompressed data with this interest has also expanded the
and land topographies have spawned
those from the same data that had been industry’s focus on the ocean-bottom
the development of more flexible
compressed by a factor of 60, sent to a cable method with three-component
recording systems. These systems are
processing center via a satellite link, and geophones in addition to hydrophones.
being designed to accommodate a
uncompressed using the same Shear waves can’t propagate through
receiver spread that contains ocean-
algorithm. The data telemetry rate was water.
bottom cable remote units, as well as
able to keep up with the acquisition and
land cable and radio linked remote units,
the processing comparison results were Finally, a recently published
all of which are controlled and recorded
impressive. The satellite link costs were technical article eloquently explains
by a single central unit.
nominal. why, in some cases, land vibrators
output more energy in the form of
Positioning and Navigation
Improved Technologies harmonics and subharmonics of the
pilot sweep than in the form of the
Both land and marine navigation
In 1988, a need was expressed to sweep signal itself. In the latter part of
and positioning have been completely
acquire 3-D data over producing marine that article, the author presents the
upgraded with Global Positioning
reservoirs where production and drilling result of using a near trace as a measure
Satellite receivers and systems.
platfor ms made towing streamers of what was actually output by the
Although the system’s signals that are
dangerous or impossible. The ocean- vibrator and of performing signature
available for civilian access are less
bottom cable method, essentially land deconvolution on the other traces in
accurate than those used by the military,
data acquisition at sea, represented a order to collapse constructively the
the inclusion of receivers at known
promising solution. However, data from harmonics into each reflection wavelet.
locations provide submeter accuracies
the method’s ocean-bottom The result was encouraging.
in x, y, and z virtually everywhere in
hydrophones suffered from ghost
the world.
reflections from the water surface that Biography
accompanied each legitimate reflection
Field Processing
wavelet. In water depths greater than Frederick J. Barr began college at
about 10 meters, deconvolution is Texas A&M University in 1961,
Compact, powerful workstations
unable to eliminate these ghost majoring in electrical engineering. Prior
with full seismic processing software
reflections. A method was developed to receiving his bachelor’s degree in
systems are appearing in many land
that successfully eliminated these ghost 1966, he worked summers on a Shell
crew base camps. The vast majority of
reflections. The solution was to record bay-cable seismic crew that was
land crew field processing is performed
data from both hydrophones and conducting a long-ter m program
to verify the accuracy of the shooting
geophones at each receiver station and covering the shallow bay systems along
geometry information associated with
then to properly combine them in
each shot record. The ability to leave
processing. This enhancement Continued on page 7
6
Continued from page 6
the Texas Gulf Coast. During the
course of those summers, he performed
every difficult and unpleasant task the
HOLIDAY PARTY 1996
crew could gleefully assign a college A New Look For Our Good Times:
summer hire. From that experience he
gained a valuable understanding of
Coming in December!
seismic data acquisition as well as a deep
and abiding appreciation for the
concept of higher education. [Dateline HOUSTON] — The GSH is launching a NEW campaign of holiday
cheer this year, and YOU can be part of it! Our annual holiday party will have a
Fred continued his education in the brand new face reflecting our members’ requests. It will be held from 5 to 9
electrical engineering department of
p.m. on Thursday, December 5, to conserve your scarce weekend time around
Texas A&M, earning a master’s degree
in 1968 and a Ph.D. in 1970. He the holidays. At the quietly elegant DoubleTree Hotel at Post Oak, there will be
performed his master’s thesis and Ph.D. plenty of room to network, mingle, and rekindle friendships in our spacious
dissertation research in the areas of party area, with multiple bar stations for your convenience. We want to free
statistical communication theory and
your time for celebrating, not waiting in line for tickets or drinks! There will be
electromagnetic wave propagation,
respectively. When Petty Geophysical carving stations and hot & cold buffet finger foods to satisfy while you visit,
Engineering Company offered a job to giving you a smorgasbord _and_ mobility. Casual seating will be available.
perform research and development,
focused on data acquisition, these
Please plan to join our party, and encourage your friends and fellow GSH
research backgrounds and the “seismic
summers” made the move to members to do the same. This will be a perfect opportunity for your group- or
geophysics an easy decision. company-wide gathering under the GSH umbrella. Treat your special clients to
an elegant evening! If you and/or your company would like to make reservations
Fred remained in research as Petty
for this special celebration, please call 560-1104. We look forward to hearing
and Ray Geophysical were merged to
form Geosource in 1973. He was from you soon. Hope we see you all there!
named director of R&D in 1976. In
1978, the president of Petty-Ray The Christmas Party Committee would like to express its
decided Fred would benefit from
appreciation for sponsorship of this event by Landmark Graphics
experience in operations management.
From 1978 to 1982, he held positions Corporation.
of general manager and vice-president,
general manager in the Electronic
Systems Division of Geosource where
geophysical recording equipment and
minicomputer based processing systems Party tickets are $15 per person for GSH members to purchase for
were designed, manufactured and themselves and their guests, $25 for non-members to purchase
marketed. directly, payable in advance. By 11/30/96, please send this
registration with your check to the Geophysical Society of Houston
In 1982, Fred was promoted to
Corporate Director of Technology for to:
Geosource. The company had Lorinda Driskill
expanded its product and service lines c/o 3782 Georgetown
to include seismic, wireline, pumps and
Houston, TX 77005-2822.
precision metering. However, in late
1983, when the precipitous decline in
Name(s) of Attendees: ______________________________________________
the energy business started to manifest
itself, Geosource divested its non-
seismic businesses and Fred returned to Company/Address: _________________________________________________
the R&D department as manager.
City & Zip: _______________________________________________________
In late 1988, Halliburton purchased
Geosource and merged them with GSI
Contact Telephone Number: _________________________ [ ] office [ ] home
Continued on page 11
7
Continued from page 1
Figure 2. A simple, two-trace comparison pattern that can be used with correlation or semblance analysis. A single similarity
measurement is output for the central trace at the center of the time window. Photo courtesy of CAEX Services
Figure 3. Correlation values reflect discontinuities in this example of relatively flat data. Photo courtesy of CAEX Services
Stratigraphic feature
detection tips
For detection of channels and
similar features, good results have been
achieved by running comparison tests.
A starting point would be a time window
of 100 ms and a two-trace comparison
pattern outputting minimum correlation
values. Correlation values will tend to
be higher for stratigraphic features than
for faults. Testing may reveal correlation
values of 0.7 to 1.0.
Termination event
processing and mapping
Interpretive poststack processing
can also allow the mapping of geologic
terminations associated with sequence
stratigraphy events. Events such as
unconformities, downlap, onlap and
other sequence boundary related events
can be enhanced by this method of
specialized poststack processing. The
preliminary step is to dip-filter the data Figure 4. Horizons depicting areas of downlap, onlap, and subparallel terminating
with respect to an unconformity viewed events are displayed on the unconformity surface.
in the inline direction three times.
To enhance the downlap events and Figure 5. When the downlap horizon is displayed, zones of significant downlap
generate a downlap horizon, each inline termination against the unconformity (bright areas) are apparent.
is processed in turn as follows:
• Convert the seismic data to cosine
of phase to prevent amplitude Continued on page 11
9
GEOPHYSICAL SOCIETY OF HOUSTON
10
Continued from page 9
Attention
GSH Members
Figure 6. RMS amplitudes extracted from the original data give a much less distinct
picture of where downlap termination is occurring.
If your address label on
this GSH Newsletter has
anomalies from affecting the results. processing can be used to generate a
• Flatten the section on the series of maps. Maps of onlapping and a blue stripe on it, your
unconformity horizon. subparallel zones can be made by
• Apply an FK fan filter, keeping dips changing the FK dip range to enhance membership is expiring.
of +1 to +20 ms/trace. onlap or subparallel terminations. Maps
• Unflatten the section. of events terminating underneath the
• Extract RMS amplitudes above the unconformity can be made by using an
unconformity horizon and output this attribute enhancing windows below the Please take a few
new horizon. unconformity. Terminating events maps
on neighboring unconformities can be moments and renew
Although this flow describes only made by changing the horizon used for
the downlap horizon, poststack flattening and RMS extraction. your GSH membership.
You can do so by
11
SUNDAY MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY SATURDAY
Submittals and suggestions should be sent to the GSH Editor at 7457 Harwin, Suite 301, Hous- 1 2
ton, TX 77036, or call Cliff Kelley, Editor, at 368-8103, or Fax to 368-8182. Deadline for
submission is the 1st of the month preceding publication: e.g., September 1 for the October
issue. Digital or electronic submittals required.
NOVEMBER 1996
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
HGS General Meeting HGS HGS Charisma
Dinner Environment Engineering Wrkstn Course
Dr. Carl Fiduk/UnivColo: John B. McVaugh, P.E., R.E.M.
Modeling Giant Structural The ISO 14000 Environmental
Traps in Perdido Fold Belt, Management Standards
GoM Steak & Ale @ 8135 Katy
Frwy.
GSH
17 18 19 20 21 Potential Fields SIG
5:30 p.m.
22 23
HGS International GSH HESS
UMC: Discovery off Ivory Seismic Data Processing
Coast HGS General Meeting
SIG
5:30 p.m. Lunch (SIPES)
4:00 p.m.
Westchase Hilton Lillian Flakes & Ricard
Exxon Production Research
Fillon/
Company Rm. S-202
HGS Emerging Technology
GSH Technical Luncheon Dan Morris
11:30 a.m. Coherency Technology Co
HESS 5:30 p.m.
Radisson Suite Hotel
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
12