You are on page 1of 79

CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU.

N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE

1. OM PAL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 09/11/2010 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -OCULAR EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 1562 = 2010 (13 ) SCR 558 = 2010 (14 ) SCC 200 = 2010 (12 ) JT 120 = 2010 (11
) SCALE 621
2. PRAJEET KUMAR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 02/04/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -OCULAR EVIDENCE -BIHAR
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 412 = 2008 (5 ) SCR 969 = 2008 (4 ) SCC 434 = 2008 (4 ) JT 257 = 2008 (4
) SCALE 442

1. SHYAM GOPAL BINDAL & ORS .Vs. LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER & ANR DOJ : 11/01/2010 ORDER
CIVIL LAW -SUIT FOR INJUNCTION -DECLARATION -ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 690 = 2010 (2 ) SCC 316 = 2010 (1 ) JT 323 = 2010 (1 ) SCALE 241
2. H.P. VEDAVYASACHAR .Vs. SHIVASHANKARA & ANR. DOJ : 03/08/2009 JUDGEMENT
CIVIL PROCEDURE -ABDUCTION -ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE -APPLICATION
Citation(s) 2009 (12 ) SCR 268 = 2009 (8 ) SCC 231 = 2009 (15 ) JT 348 = 2009 (11 ) SCALE 31
3. HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION .Vs. M/S CORK MANUFACTURING CO. DOJ
: 27/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -SECOND APPEAL -ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 56 = 2007 (9 ) SCR 508 = 2007 (8 ) SCC 120 = 2007 (10 ) JT 473 = 2007 (10
) SCALE 515
4. STATE OF GUJARAT & ANR. .Vs. MAHENDRAKUMAR PARSHOTTAMBHAI DESAI (DEAD) BY LRS. DOJ
: 10/04/2006 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE -PRODUCTION -GUJARAT
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 1864 = 2006 (9 ) SCC 772 = 2006 (4 ) JT 600 = 2006 (4 ) SCALE 265
5. DIVYASH PANDIT .Vs. MANAGEMENT NCCBM DOJ : 13/01/2005 JUDGEMENT
LABOUR LAW -EMPLOYEES -CHARGES -ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 92 = 2005 (2 ) SCC 684 =
6. KARNATAKA BOARD OF WAKF .Vs. GOVERNMENT OF INDIA & ORS. DOJ : 16/04/2004 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE -PRODUCTION -ENTITLEMENT
Citation(s) 2004 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 255 = 2004 (10 ) SCC 779 = 2004 (4 ) SCALE 856
7. DONDAPATI NARAYANA REDDY .Vs. DUGGIREDDY VENKATANARAYANA REDDY & ORS. DOJ
: 29/08/2001 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -WRIT PETITION -AMENDMENT -ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3685 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCC 115 = 2001 ( 7 ) JT 112 = 2001 ( 5 ) SCALE 566
8. N. KAMALAM (DEAD) .Vs. AYYASAMY DOJ : 03/08/2001 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -APPEAL -ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE -PERMISSION
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2802 = 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 272 = 2001 ( 7 ) SCC 503 = 2001 ( 6 ) JT 219 = 2001 ( 5
) SCALE 65
9. RAMBHAU & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 26/04/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -APPELLATE COURT -ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2120 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCR 210 = 2001 ( 4 ) SCC 759 = 2001 ( 5 ) JT 121 = 2001 ( 3
) SCALE 539
10. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. T.N. SAHANI & ORS. DOJ : 12/10/2000 ORDER
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE -APPEAL -PENDING
Citation(s) 2001 (10 ) SCC 619 = 2000 ( 3 ) Suppl. JT 90 =
11. JAIPUR DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY .Vs. KAILASHWATI DEVI DOJ : 02/09/1997 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE -ELIGIBILITY -PARTY
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 3243 = 1997 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 664 = 1997 ( 7 ) SCC 297 = 1997 ( 7 ) JT 643 = 1997 ( 5
) SCALE 658
12. GURDEV SINGH .Vs. MEHNGA RAM DOJ : 11/07/1997 ORDER
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -REVISION -HIGH COURTS -ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 3572 = 1997 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 693 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCC 507 = 1997 ( 7 ) JT 56 = 1997 ( 5
) SCALE 222
13. GULZAR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 03/02/1992
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -PENDENCY OF APPEAL -ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 446

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 1 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

1. HIMANSHU @ CHINTU .Vs. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI DOJ : 04/01/2011 JUDGEMENT


EVIDENCE -HOSTILE WITNESS -ADMISSIBILITY IN EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 (1 ) SCR 48 = 2011 (2 ) SCC 36 = 2011 (1 ) JT 123 = 2011 (1 ) SCALE 30
2. K.B. SAHA & SONS PVT. LTD. .Vs. DEVELOPMENT CONSULTANT LTD. DOJ : 12/05/2008 JUDGEMENT
TRANSFER OF PROPERTY -LEASE DEED -REGISTRATION -ADMISSIBILITY IN EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 850 = 2008 (8 ) SCR 290 = 2008 (8 ) SCC 564 = 2008 (9 ) JT 12 = 2008 (9
) SCALE 490
1. DWARKA DASS & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 13/11/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -APPRAISAL OF EVIDENCE -HIGH COURTS -POWERS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 185 = 2002 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 150 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 204 = 2002 ( 9 ) JT 292 = 2002 ( 8
) SCALE 396
1. PREM PRAKASH @ LILLU & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 07/07/2011 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -KIDNAPPING -RAPE -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 2677 = 2011 (10 ) SCR 27 = 2011 (11 ) SCC 687 = 2011 (7 ) JT 213 = 2011 (7
) SCALE 379
2. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. MUNNI RAM & ORS. DOJ : 26/10/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPEAL AGAINST ACQUITTAL -FINDING OF FACT -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2010 (14 ) SCR 120 = 2010 (14 ) SCC 364 = 2010 (12 ) JT 180 = 2010 (11 ) SCALE 321
3. PREM SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 06/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2573 = 2009 (7 ) SCR 1142 = 2009 (14 ) SCC 494 = 2009 (8 ) JT 185 = 2009 (7
) SCALE 637
4. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. SUKHPAL SINGH & ORS. DOJ : 12/01/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 (4 ) SCC 385 = 2009 (2 ) SCALE 406
5. MAN BAHADUR .Vs. STATE OF H.P. DOJ : 23/09/2008 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -RIGHT OF ACCUSED -NDPS -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 369 = 2008 (13 ) SCR 955 = 2008 (16 ) SCC 398 = 2008 (10 ) JT 518 = 2008 (12
) SCALE 801
6. KURELLA NAGA DRUVA VUDAYA BHASKARA RAO .Vs. GALLA JANI KAMMA ALIAS NACHARAMMA DOJ
: 04/08/2008 JUDGEMENT
TENANCY -JURISDICTION OF COURT -CIVIL COURT -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 690 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 849 = 2008 (15 ) SCC 150 = 2008 (9 ) JT 295 = 2008 (11
) SCALE 160
7. PRAJEET KUMAR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 02/04/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -OCULAR EVIDENCE -BIHAR
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 412 = 2008 (5 ) SCR 969 = 2008 (4 ) SCC 434 = 2008 (4 ) JT 257 = 2008 (4
) SCALE 442
8. HEM CHAND .Vs. STATE OF JHARKHAND DOJ : 13/03/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -JURISDICTION OF COURT -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1903 = 2008 (4 ) SCR 985 = 2008 (5 ) SCC 113 = 2008 (4 ) JT 64 = 2008 (3
) SCALE 598
9. GOBARBHAI NARANBHAI SINGALA .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS. DOJ : 29/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -EXPEDITIOUS DISPOSAL -GUJARAT
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1134 = 2008 (2 ) SCR 131 = 2008 (3 ) SCC 775 = 2008 (2 ) JT 96 = 2008 (2
) SCALE 82
10. BIJOY DAS .Vs. STATE OF WEST BENGAL DOJ : 28/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DYING DECLARATION -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CALCUTTA
Citation(s) 2008 (2 ) SCR 86 = 2008 (4 ) SCC 511 = 2008 (2 ) JT 123 = 2008 (2 ) SCALE 62
11. WORKMEN OF BALMADIES ESTATES .Vs. MANAGEMENT BALMADIES ESTATE AND ORS. DOJ
: 18/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
LABOUR LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -LABOUR COURT -POWER
Citation(s) 2008 (1 ) SCR 867 = 2008 (4 ) SCC 517 = 2008 (1 ) JT 587 = 2008 (1 ) SCALE 517
12. RAM PAL & ANR .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 14/12/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -COMMON INTENTION -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 244 = 2007 (13 ) SCR 789 = 2007 (15 ) SCC 79 = 2008 (1 ) JT 11 = 2007 (14
) SCALE 394
13. KISHAN SINGH & ANR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 12/10/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -UNNATURAL DEATH -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 233 = 2007 (11 ) SCR 155 = 2007 (14 ) SCC 204 = 2007 (12 ) JT 91 = 2007 (12
) SCALE 148
14. KULWINDER SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 06/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 2868 = 2007 (8 ) SCR 891 = 2007 (10 ) SCC 455 = 2007 (10 ) JT 35 = 2007 (9
) SCALE 621

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 2 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

15. B. C. DEVA @ DYAVA .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 25/07/2007 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -KARNATAKA
Citation(s) 2007 (8 ) SCR 509 = 2007 (12 ) SCC 122 = 2007 (9 ) JT 558 = 2007 (9 ) SCALE 338
16. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. RAJU BHASKAR POTPHODE DOJ : 18/07/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -BOMBAY MUMBAI
Citation(s) 2007 (8 ) SCR 396 = 2007 (11 ) SCC 261 = 2007 (9 ) JT 405 = 2007 (9 ) SCALE 280
17. ABDUL RASHID ABDUL RAHIMAN PATEL AND ORS .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 10/07/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 (9 ) SCC 1 = 2007 (9 ) JT 194 = 2007 (9 ) SCALE 72
18. SUJOY SEN @ SUJOY KR. SEN .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 08/05/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CALCUTTA
Citation(s) 2007 (6 ) SCR 112 = 2007 (6 ) SCC 32 = 2007 (6 ) JT 465 = 2007 (6 ) SCALE 560
19. STATE OF TRIPURA .Vs. RAM BIR SINGH & ORS. DOJ : 08/05/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -JUDGMENT -GUWAHATI
Citation(s) 2007 (6 ) SCR 117 = 2007 (11 ) SCC 442 = 2007 (6 ) JT 467 = 2007 (6 ) SCALE 563
20. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. SIRAJ AHMED NISAR AHMED & ORS. DOJ : 07/05/2007 JUDGEMENT
TADA -CONFESSION -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -BOMBAY MUMBAI
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1859 = 2007 (6 ) SCR 40 = 2007 (5 ) SCC 161 = 2007 (6 ) JT 482 = 2007 (6
) SCALE 621
21. PRAKASH KUMAR @ PRAKASH BHUTTO .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 24/04/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2007 (5 ) SCR 532 = 2007 (4 ) SCC 266 = 2007 (7 ) JT 60 = 2007 (6 ) SCALE 91
22. BANDI CHANDRAIAH .Vs. STATE REPRESENTED BY ITS S H O A P DOJ : 22/03/2007 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -TRIAL -DYING DECLARATION -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2007 (4 ) SCC 154 =
23. BANDU .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 09/03/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2007 (3 ) SCR 848 = 2007 (4 ) SCC 211 = 2007 (4 ) SCALE 291
24. B NOHA .Vs. STATE OF KERALA & ANR DOJ : 06/11/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -ILLEGAL GRATIFICATION -BURDEN OF PROOF
Citation(s) 2006 (8 ) Suppl. SCR 368 = 2006 (12 ) SCC 277 = 2006 (11 ) SCALE 288
25. KAILASH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 29/09/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -ORAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 (6 ) Suppl. SCR 793 = 2006 (11 ) SCC 420 = 2006 (9 ) JT 278 = 2006 (9 ) SCALE 681
26. RITESH CHAKARVARTI .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 29/09/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -NDPS -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -M P
Citation(s) 2006 (6 ) Suppl. SCR 772 = 2006 (12 ) SCC 321 = 2006 (12 ) JT 416 = 2006 (9 ) SCALE 644
27. BALBIR SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 26/09/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -DYING DECLARATION -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 3221 = 2006 (6 ) Suppl. SCR 636 = 2006 (12 ) SCC 283 = 2006 (12 ) JT 316 = 2006 (9
) SCALE 537
28. BHIMAPPA CHANDAPPA HOSAMANI & ORS .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 20/09/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -WITNESS -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 2006 (6 ) Suppl. SCR 393 = 2006 (11 ) SCC 323 = 2006 (12 ) JT 76 = 2006 (9 ) SCALE 406
29. MANAGING DIRECTOR NORTHEAST K.R.T.C. .Vs. DEVIDAS MANIKRAO SADANANDA DOJ
: 15/09/2006 JUDGEMENT
LABOUR LAW -DEPARTMENTAL ENQUIRY -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -STANDARD OF PROOF
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 3273 = 2006 (6 ) Suppl. SCR 284 = 2006 (8 ) SCC 52 = 2006 (9 ) SCALE 352
30. JAGDISH MURAV .Vs. STATE OF U.P. & ORS. DOJ : 24/08/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ATTEMPT TO MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 2006 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 219 = 2006 (12 ) SCC 626 = 2006 (7 ) JT 596 = 2006 (8 ) SCALE 433
31. PULICHERLA NAGARAJU @ NAGARAJA REDDY .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 18/08/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -SELF DEFENCE -A P
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 3010 = 2006 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 633 = 2006 (11 ) SCC 444 = 2006 (8 ) SCALE 133
32. SADA RAM .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 01/08/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1909 = 2006 (13 ) SCC 528 = 2006 (7 ) JT 430 = 2006 (7 ) SCALE 657
33. SYED IBRAHIM .Vs. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH DOJ : 27/07/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -NORMAL DISCREPANCIES -MATERIAL DISCREPANCIES
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 2908 = 2006 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 105 = 2006 (10 ) SCC 601 = 2006 (6 ) JT 597 = 2006 (7
) SCALE 399
34. OM PRAKASH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 11/05/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -ALLAHABAD
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 2214 = 2006 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 318 = 2006 (9 ) SCC 787 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 3 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

35. ASHOK KUMAR & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 05/05/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -RIGHT OF PRIVATE DEFENCE
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 2419 = 2006 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 947 = 2006 (10 ) SCC 157 = 2006 (5 ) JT 419 = 2006 (5
) SCALE 331
36. MUNICIPAL COUNCIL SUJANPUR .Vs. SURINDER KUMAR DOJ : 05/05/2006 JUDGEMENT
LABOUR LAW -INDUSTRIAL DISPUTE -BACK WAGES -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 914 = 2006 (5 ) SCC 173 = 2006 (11 ) JT 226 = 2006 (5 ) SCALE 505
37. DEEPAK CHANDRAKANT PATIL .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 08/03/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -LAST SEEN TOGETHER -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 1708 = 2006 (10 ) SCC 151 = 2006 (3 ) JT 537 = 2006 (3 ) SCALE 229
38. VIRENDRA KUMAR TRIPATHY .Vs. NIRMALA DEVI & ORS. DOJ : 23/02/2006 ORDER
CIVIL TRIAL -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -SUCCESSION -CERTIFICATE
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 1724 = 2006 (2 ) SCR 459 = 2006 (3 ) SCC 615 = 2006 (3 ) SCALE 189
39. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. SHIV KUMAR DOJ : 20/04/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EYE WITNESS -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2992 = 2005 (11 ) SCC 212 = 2005 (5 ) JT 550 = 2005 (4 ) SCALE 379
40. IQBAL SINGH MARWAH & ANR. .Vs. MEENAKSHI MARWAH & ANR. DOJ : 11/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -FORGERY -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CIVIL & CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2119 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 708 = 2005 (4 ) SCC 370 = 2005 (3 ) JT 195 = 2005 (3
) SCALE 93
41. RAVI KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 04/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -FIR -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1929 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 548 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 315 = 2005 (3 ) JT 62 = 2005 (2
) SCALE 534
42. BALBIR SINGH ETC. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB ETC. DOJ : 03/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -COMMON INTENTION -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CREDIBILITY OF THE WITNESSES
Citation(s) 2005 (9 ) SCC 299 = 2005 (3 ) JT 7 = 2005 (2 ) SCALE 478
43. DEVKARAN & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 03/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RIGHT OF PRIVATE DEFENCE -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -RAJASTHAN
Citation(s) 2005 (10 ) SCC 255 =
44. SHASHIDHAR PURANDHAR HEGDE & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 15/10/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -IMPRISONMENT -FINE
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 5075 = 2004 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 536 = 2004 (12 ) SCC 492 = 2004 (9 ) JT 177 = 2004 (8
) SCALE 843
45. HARJINDER SINGH @ BHOLA .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 27/07/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -SETTING ASIDE
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 3962 = 2004 (11 ) SCC 253 = 2004 (6 ) JT 23 = 2004 (6 ) SCALE 289
46. MARUTI RAMA NAIK .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 09/09/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -SETTING ASIDE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3884 = 2003 ( 7 ) JT 627 = 2003 ( 7 ) SCALE 270
47. HEM RAJ & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 09/09/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 4259 = 2003 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 466 = 2003 (12 ) SCC 241 = 2003 (7 ) JT 2002 =
48. SURINDER SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 05/09/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3811 = 2003 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 401 = 2003 (10 ) SCC 26 = 2003 (1
) Suppl. JT 226 = 2003 (7 ) SCALE 184
49. DHIRAJBHAI GORAKHBHAI NAYAK .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 25/07/2003 JUDGEMENT
SERVICE LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2855 = 2003 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 754 = 2003 (9 ) SCC 322 = 2003 (6 ) JT 189 = 2003 (5
) SCALE 469
50. AMZAD ALI@ AMZAD KHA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 22/07/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3587 = 2003 ( 6 ) SCC 270 = 2003 ( 6 ) JT 160 = 2003 ( 5 ) SCALE 340
51. JANDEL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH DOJ : 08/05/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3991 = 2003 ( 9 ) SCC 110 = 2003 ( 4 ) JT 558 = 2003 ( 4 ) SCALE 608
52. THAMAN KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF UNION TERRITORY OF CHANDIGARH DOJ : 06/05/2003 JUDGEMENT
MURDER -MOTIVE -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -DISMISSAL
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3975 = 2003 (3 ) SCR 1190 = 2003 (6 ) SCC 380 = 2003 (4 ) JT 478 = 2003 (4
) SCALE 531
53. BIMLA DEVI .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 10/04/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -SETTING ASIDE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 4138 = 2003 (10 ) SCC 118 = 2003 ( 4 ) JT 1 = 2003 ( 3 ) SCALE 743

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 4 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

54. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. HARBANS SINGH & ANR. DOJ : 10/04/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2268 = 2003 (11 ) SCC 203 = 2003 (4 ) JT 9 = 2003 (3 ) SCALE 788
55. SALIM AKHTAR @ MOTA .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 09/04/2003 JUDGEMENT
TADA -ARMS & AMMUNITION -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 4076 = 2003 (3 ) SCR 470 = 2003 (5 ) SCC 499 = 2003 (3 ) SCALE 698
56. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. PREMI & ORS. DOJ : 20/02/2003 JUDGEMENT
APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -REVERSAL -SETTING ASIDE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 1750 = 2003 ( 2 ) SCR 266 = 2003 ( 9 ) SCC 12 = 2003 ( 2 ) JT 232 = 2003 ( 2
) SCALE 346
57. ANIL KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 13/02/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 1596 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCR 1067 = 2003 ( 3 ) SCC 569 = 2003 ( 2 ) JT 175 = 2003 ( 2
) SCALE 74
58. ANIL KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 13/02/2003
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 1596 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCR 1067 = 2003 ( 3 ) SCC 569 = 2003 ( 2 ) JT 175 = 2003 ( 2
) SCALE 74
59. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. SUCHA SINGH & ORS. DOJ : 11/02/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 1471 = 2003 ( 3 ) SCC 153 = 2003 ( 2 ) JT 70 = 2003 ( 2 ) SCALE 30
60. JAI PAL & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 31/01/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 1012 = 2003 ( 9 ) SCC 41 = 2003 ( 1 ) JT 472 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCALE 521
61. STATE OF H.P. .Vs. PREM CHAND DOJ : 16/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CHILD WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 708 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 518 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 328
62. MD. RUSTAM @ RUSTAM .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 11/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 562 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 273 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 286
63. P. VENKATASWARLU .Vs. STATE OF A.P. & ORS. DOJ : 10/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 574 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 46 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 280
64. YUNIS @ KARIYA .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 10/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -MOTIVE -M P
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 539 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 425 = 2002 ( 9 ) SCALE 245
65. MOHAN LAL .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 03/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 698 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 14 = 2002 (10 ) JT 179 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 25
66. ARVIND PRAKASH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 29/11/2002 JUDGEMENT
APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL -REVERSAL -HIGH COURTS
Citation(s) 2002 (10 ) SCC 37 = 2002 (10 ) JT 19 = 2002 (8 ) SCALE 642
67. NATHU SINGH YADAV .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 22/11/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -PRECAUTIONARY PRINCIPLE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 4451 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 366 = 2002 (9 ) JT 591 = 2002 (8 ) SCALE 539
68. KILEDAR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 21/11/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EYE WITNESS -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 (10 ) JT 93 =
69. PUNJAB SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 13/11/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL -PUNJAB
Citation(s) 2002 (10 ) JT 275 =
70. ANTHONY D'SOUZA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 30/10/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 258 = 2002 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 572 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 259 = 2002 ( 9 ) JT 257 = 2002 ( 8
) SCALE 240
71. ANTHONY D'SOUZA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 30/10/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -FALSE STATEMENT -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 258 = 2002 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 572 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 259 = 2002 ( 9 ) JT 257 = 2002 ( 8
) SCALE 240
72. GANGADHAR BEHERA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF ORISSA DOJ : 10/10/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -INTERESTED WITNESS
Citation(s) 2002 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 183 = 2002 ( 8 ) SCC 381 = 2002 ( 8 ) JT 135 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCALE 402

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 5 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

73. SARWAN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 07/10/2002 JUDGEMENT


TADA -SCENE OF OCCURENCE -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CHILD ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 128 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 240 = 2002 ( 8 ) JT 114 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCALE 351
74. KALI NAYAK @ MUKHI .Vs. STATE OF ORISSA DOJ : 03/10/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 201 =
75. BACHHITAR SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 26/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 621 = 2002 ( 8 ) SCC 125 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 413 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCALE 59
76. AJITSINH ANDUBHA PARMAL & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 26/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3469 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 625 = 2002 ( 8 ) JT 127 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCALE 191
77. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. DAVID RAZARIO AND ANR. DOJ : 17/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -STATEMENT -ADMISSIBILITY -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3272 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 419 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 728 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 283 = 2002 ( 6
) SCALE 500
78. MOHAR & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 17/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3279 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 393 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCALE 516
79. SHAYAM SUNDER .Vs. STATE OF CHHATTISGARH DOJ : 16/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -INTERESTED WITNESS -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3292 = 2002 ( 8 ) SCC 39 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 317 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCALE 481
80. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. M.N. RAMDAS DOJ : 05/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3109 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 112 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 639 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 621 = 2002 ( 6
) SCALE 214
81. GURJANT SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 03/09/2002 ORDER
APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL -REVERSAL -HIGH COURTS
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 238 =
82. N. SHIVAKUMAR @ SHIVANNA .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 30/07/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 ( 6 ) JT 583 =
1. SHANMUGHAN .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 19/01/2012 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2012 AIR 1142 = 2012 (2 ) SCC 788 = 2012 (2 ) JT 35 = 2012 (1 ) SCALE 636
2. MADHU .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 13/01/2012 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2012 AIR 664 = 2012 (2 ) SCC 399 = 2012 (1 ) JT 181 = 2012 (1 ) SCALE 226
3. GAJRAJ .Vs. STATE (NCT) OF DELHI DOJ : 22/09/2011 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2011 (12 ) SCR 701 = 2011 (10 ) SCC 675 = 2011 (14 ) JT 68 = 2011 (10 ) SCALE 695
4. MUSTKEEM @ SIRAJUDEEN .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 13/07/2011 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -OBJECT
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 2769 = 2011 (9 ) SCR 101 = 2011 (11 ) SCC 724 = 2011 (7 ) JT 304 = 2011 (7
) SCALE 481
5. BHAGWAN DASS .Vs. STATE (NCT) OF DELHI DOJ : 09/05/2011 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -HONOUR KILLING -MOTIVE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 1863 = 2011 (6 ) SCR 330 = 2011 (6 ) SCC 396 = 2011 (6 ) JT 345 = 2011 (5
) SCALE 498
6. INSPECTOR OF POLIC, TAMIL NADU .Vs. JOHN DAVID DOJ : 20/04/2011 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2011 (7 ) SCR 354 = 2011 (5 ) SCC 509 = 2011 (5 ) JT 1 = 2011 (4 ) SCALE 878
7. SANJAY KUMAR JAIN .Vs. STATE OF DELHI DOJ : 16/12/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -WIFE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 363 = 2010 (14 ) SCR 1135 = 2011 (11 ) SCC 733 = 2010 (13 ) JT 377
8. THATHAMSETTY SURESH .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 22/11/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 (13 ) SCR 890 = 2011 (1 ) SCC 318 = 2010 (12 ) SCALE 279
9. VARUN CHAUDHARY .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 29/10/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONVICTION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ABSENCE OF MOTIVE
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 72 = 2010 (13 ) SCR 296 = 2011 (12 ) SCC 545 = 2010 (11 ) JT 419
10. MOHD. USMAN MOHD. ISLAM SHAIKH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 26/10/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -WIFE -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 277 = 2010 (13 ) SCR 746 = 2010 (13 ) SCC 330 = 2010 (11 ) SCALE 564

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 6 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

11. MOHD. USMAN MOHD. ISLAM SHAIKH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 26/10/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 277 = 2010 (13 ) SCR 746 = 2010 (13 ) SCC 330 = 2010 (11 ) SCALE 564
12. SANTOKH SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 01/09/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 3274 = 2010 (10 ) SCR 886 = 2010 (8 ) SCC 784 = 2010 (9 ) JT 352 =
13. G. PARASHWANATH .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 18/08/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 2914 = 2010 (10 ) SCR 377 = 2010 (8 ) SCC 593 = 2010 (8 ) JT 633 = 2010 (8
) SCALE 315
14. BABU .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 11/08/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -POISONING -DEATH -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2010 (9 ) SCR 1039 = 2010 (9 ) SCC 189 = 2010 (8 ) JT 560 = 2010 (8 ) SCALE 185
15. MANNU SAO .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 22/07/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 (8 ) SCR 811 = 2010 (12 ) SCC 310 = 2010 (8 ) JT 449 = 2010 (7 ) SCALE 138
16. SANATAN NASKAR & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF WEST BENGAL DOJ : 08/07/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 3570 = 2010 (8 ) SCC 249 = 2010 (8 ) JT 279 = 2010 (6 ) SCALE 699
17. NIRANJAN PANJA .Vs. STATE OF WEST BENGAL DOJ : 14/05/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 (7 ) SCR 113 = 2010 (6 ) SCC 525 = 2010 (5 ) JT 204 = 2010 (5 ) SCALE 651
18. SATNI BAI .Vs. STATE OF M.P. (NOW CHHATTISGARH) DOJ : 29/01/2010 JUDGEMENT
CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2010 (2 ) SCR 186 = 2010 (2 ) SCC 646 = 2010 (1 ) JT 560 = 2010 (1 ) SCALE 694
19. SATNI BAI .Vs. STATE OF M.P. (NOW CHHATTISGARH) DOJ : 29/01/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2010 (2 ) SCR 186 = 2010 (2 ) SCC 646 = 2010 (1 ) JT 560 = 2010 (1 ) SCALE 694
20. MUSHEER KHAN @ BADSHAH KHAN & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 28/01/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 762 = 2010 (2 ) SCR 119 = 2010 (2 ) SCC 748 = 2010 (1 ) JT 535 = 2010 (1
) SCALE 676
21. AFTAB AHMAD ANASARI .Vs. STATE OF UTTARANCHAL DOJ : 12/01/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 773 = 2010 (1 ) SCR 1027 = 2010 (2 ) SCC 583 = 2010 (1 ) JT 424 = 2010 (1
) SCALE 408
22. JAYABALAN .Vs. U.T. OF PONDICHERRY DOJ : 06/11/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -WIFE -BURNING -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 (15 ) SCR 736 = 2010 (1 ) SCC 199 = 2009 (14 ) JT 401 = 2009 (13 ) SCALE 614
23. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. NARESH @ RAM NARESH DOJ : 26/08/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 (13 ) SCR 589 = 2009 (9 ) SCC 368 = 2009 (11 ) JT 109 = 2009 (11 ) SCALE 699
24. PANNAYAR .Vs. STATE OF T.NADU BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE DOJ : 17/08/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 85 = 2009 (13 ) SCR 367 = 2009 (9 ) SCC 152 = 2009 (10 ) JT 461 = 2009 (11
) SCALE 504
25. STATE OF A.P. .Vs. S. SWARNALATHA & ORS. DOJ : 04/08/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -ACQUITTAL -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 (12 ) SCR 289 = 2009 (8 ) SCC 383 = 2009 (13 ) JT 383 = 2009 (11 ) SCALE 7
26. GANESH GOGOI .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 07/07/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2955 = 2009 (7 ) SCC 404 = 2009 (9 ) JT 59 = 2009 (9 ) SCALE 135
27. SUBRAMANIAM .Vs. STATE OF TAMIL NADU & ANR. DOJ : 13/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1493 = 2009 (14 ) SCC 415 = 2009 (7 ) JT 403 = 2009 (7 ) SCALE 317
28. STATE OF W.B. .Vs. DIPAK HALDER & ANR. DOJ : 08/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1883 = 2009 (8 ) SCR 530 = 2009 (7 ) SCC 288 = 2009 (7 ) JT
29. JOYDEEP NEOGI @ BUBAI .Vs. STATE OF WEST BENGAL DOJ : 08/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -KIDNAPPING -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1635 = 2009 (8 ) SCR 291 = 2009 (15 ) SCC 83 = 2009 (7 ) JT
30. RAMESH BHAI & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 24/04/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1482 = 2009 (6 ) SCR 949 = 2009 (12 ) SCC 603 = 2009 (7 ) JT

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 7 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

31. M.A. ANTONY @ ANTAPPAN .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 22/04/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2549 = 2009 (6 ) SCR 829 = 2009 (6 ) SCC 220 = 2009 (7 ) JT 372 = 2009 (6
) SCALE 36
32. KRISHNA GHOSH .Vs. STATE OF WEST BENGAL DOJ : 31/03/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CRUELTY -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2279 = 2009 (5 ) SCR 333 = 2009 (12 ) SCC 413 = 2009 (4 ) JT 658 = 2009 (5
) SCALE 124
33. VITHAL EKNATH ADLINGE .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 27/02/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2067 = 2009 (3 ) SCR 532 = 2009 (11 ) SCC 637 = 2009 (3 ) JT 158 = 2009 (3
) SCALE 327
34. PAWAN .Vs. STATE OF UTTARANCHAL DOJ : 26/02/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 (3 ) SCR 468 = 2009 (15 ) SCC 259 = 2009 (3 ) JT 87 = 2009 (3 ) SCALE 195
35. NARAYAN .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 25/02/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1895 = 2009 (2 ) SCR 1200 = 2009 (11 ) SCC 118 = 2009 (3 ) JT 179 = 2009 (3
) SCALE 272
36. SYED HAKKIM & ANR. .Vs. STATE REP. BY DY. SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE KARUR DISTT. T.N. DOJ
: 23/02/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CRUELTY -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 (2 ) SCR 1060 = 2009 (4 ) SCC 324 = 2009 (3 ) JT 443 = 2009 (3 ) SCALE 277
37. STATE OF GOA .Vs. PANDURANG MOHITE DOJ : 08/12/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1066 = 2008 (17 ) SCR 176 = 2008 (16 ) SCC 714 = 2008 (12 ) JT 541 = 2008 (16
) SCALE 72
38. ARUN BHAKTA @ THULU .Vs. STATE OF WEST BENGAL DOJ : 05/12/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1228 = 2008 (17 ) SCR 73 = 2008 (17 ) SCC 367 = 2008 (12 ) JT 513 =
39. BALDEV SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 01/12/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 963 = 2008 (16 ) SCR 826 = 2008 (14 ) SCC 768 = 2008 (15 ) SCALE 366
40. MOHD. AZAD@SAMIN .Vs. STATEOF WEST BENGAL DOJ : 05/11/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -POST MORTEM EXAMINATION -ALCOHOL
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1307 = 2008 (15 ) SCR 468 = 2008 (15 ) SCC 449 = 2008 (11 ) JT 658 = 2008 (14
) SCALE 52
41. MULA DEVI & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND DOJ : 04/11/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -HARASSMENT -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 655 = 2008 (15 ) SCR 319 = 2008 (14 ) SCC 511 = 2008 (11 ) JT 423 = 2008 (13
) SCALE 672
42. HAR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND DOJ : 18/09/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LAST SEEN TOGETHER -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 204 = 2008 (13 ) SCR 621 = 2008 (15 ) SCC 477 = 2008 (10 ) JT 212 = 2008 (12
) SCALE 604
43. SHIVAJI @ DADYA SHANKAR ALHAT .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 05/09/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 56 = 2008 (13 ) SCR 81 = 2008 (15 ) SCC 269 = 2008 (9 ) JT 528 = 2008 (12
) SCALE 210
44. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. RAJA @ JALIL DOJ : 28/08/2008 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1285 = 2008 (12 ) SCR 945 = 2008 (10 ) SCC 318 = 2008 (10 ) JT 249 = 2008 (12
) SCALE 522
45. CHATTAR SINGH & ANR .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 26/08/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -PUNJAB & HARYANA
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 378 = 2008 (12 ) SCR 765 = 2008 (14 ) SCC 667 = 2008 (10 ) JT 230
46. B. VENKAT SWAMY .Vs. VIJAYA NEHRU & ANR. DOJ : 25/08/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2008 (12 ) SCR 687 = 2008 (10 ) SCC 260 = 2008 (13 ) JT 628 = 2008 (11 ) SCALE 656
47. MANIVEL & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 08/08/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LAST SEEN TOGETHER -MURDER
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 702 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 1036 = 2008 (12 ) SCC 748 = 2008 (9 ) JT 31
48. DEVIDAS RAMSUNDAR SHUKLA .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 06/08/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CRUELTY
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1292 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 968 = 2008 (12 ) SCC 755 = 2008 (9 ) JT 134

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 8 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

49. DEVIDAS RAMSUNDAR SHUKLA .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 06/08/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -SECOND MARRIAGE -CRUELTY
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1292 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 968 = 2008 (12 ) SCC 755 = 2008 (9 ) JT 134 = 2008 (11
) SCALE 148
50. I. RAVINDRA REDDY .Vs. SHAIK KHADER MASTHAN & ORS. DOJ : 04/08/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LAST SEEN TOGETHER -A P
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 748 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 873 = 2008 (15 ) SCC 178 = 2008 (11 ) SCALE 128
51. MUNIGADAPPA MEENAIAH .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 23/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -INTERESTED WITNESS -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 3027 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 172 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 661 = 2008 (10 ) SCALE 376
52. INSPECTOR OF POLICE T.N. .Vs. BALAPRASANNA DOJ : 21/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONFESSIONAL STATEMENT
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 648 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 31 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 645 = 2008 (8 ) JT 242 = 2008 (10
) SCALE 466
53. KUSUMA ANKAMA RAO .Vs. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH DOJ : 07/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2819 = 2008 (10 ) SCR 89 = 2008 (13 ) SCC 257 = 2008 (7 ) JT 360 = 2008 (9
) SCALE 652
54. NATRAJ CHINNAPPA NAIR .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 07/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1305 = 2008 (10 ) SCR 85 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 105 = 2008 (7 ) JT 284 = 2008 (9
) SCALE 664
55. KUSUMA ANKAMA RAO .Vs. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH DOJ : 07/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2819 = 2008 (10 ) SCR 89 = 2008 (13 ) SCC 257 = 2008 (7 ) JT 360 = 2008 (9
) SCALE 652
56. KUSUMA ANKAMA RAO .Vs. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH DOJ : 07/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LAST SEEN TOGETHER -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2819 = 2008 (10 ) SCR 89 = 2008 (13 ) SCC 257 = 2008 (7 ) JT 360 = 2008 (9
) SCALE 652
57. ROOP SINGH @ RUPA .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 20/06/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 444 = 2008 (10 ) SCR 52 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 79 = 2008 (11 ) JT 101 = 2008 (9
) SCALE 432
58. VENKATESAN .Vs. STATE OF TAMIL NADU DOJ : 16/05/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LAST SEEN TOGETHER
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2369 = 2008 (8 ) SCR 1060 = 2008 (8 ) SCC 456 = 2008 (6 ) JT 640 = 2008 (9
) SCALE 319
59. VENKATESAN .Vs. STATE OF TAMIL NADU DOJ : 16/05/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LAST SEEN TOGETHER -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2369 = 2008 (8 ) SCR 1060 = 2008 (8 ) SCC 456 = 2008 (6 ) JT 640 = 2008 (9
) SCALE 319
60. MOHAN ANNA CHAVAN .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 16/05/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -RAPE MINOR GIRL -RAREST OF RARE CASE
Citation(s) 2008 (8 ) SCR 1072 = 2008 (7 ) SCC 561 = 2008 (7 ) JT 51 = 2008 (9 ) SCALE 474
61. MOHAN ANNA CHAVAN .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 16/05/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DEATH SENTENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -RAPE
Citation(s) 2008 (8 ) SCR 1072 = 2008 (7 ) SCC 561 = 2008 (7 ) JT 51 = 2008 (9 ) SCALE 474
62. KRISHNAN .Vs. STATE REPRESENTED BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE DOJ : 08/05/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -BENEFIT OF DOUBT -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 (15 ) SCC 430 = 2008 (6 ) JT 282 = 2008 (7 ) SCALE 96
63. DINESH BORTHAKUR .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 13/03/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EVIDENCE RELATING TO THE REACTION OF
SNIFFER DOG
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2205 = 2008 (4 ) SCR 881 = 2008 (5 ) SCC 697 = 2008 (4 ) SCALE 487
64. BALWANT SINGH & ORS .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 06/02/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -WITNESS -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1243 = 2008 (2 ) SCR 497 = 2008 (12 ) SCC 237 = 2008 (2 ) JT 269 = 2008 (2
) SCALE 247
65. SATTATIYA @ SATISH RAJANNA KARTALLA .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 16/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -INTERFERENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1184 = 2008 (3 ) SCC 210 = 2008 (1 ) JT 434 = 2008 (1 ) SCALE 399
66. K.T. PALANISAMY .Vs. STATE OF TAMIL NADU DOJ : 11/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1095 = 2008 (1 ) SCR 581 = 2008 (3 ) SCC 100 = 2008 (2 ) JT 107

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 9 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

67. HEMANT TRIVEDI .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 25/10/2007 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 (14 ) SCC 513 = 2007 (12 ) SCALE 605
68. MALLESHAPPA .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 21/09/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 69 = 2007 (10 ) SCR 153 = 2007 (13 ) SCC 399 = 2007 (11 ) JT 234
69. SANWARIYA LAL .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 14/09/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 3219 = 2007 (9 ) SCR 943 = 2007 (12 ) SCC 751 = 2007 (11 ) JT 403
70. HARISHCHANDRA LADAKU THANGE .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 30/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 2957 = 2007 (9 ) SCR 562 = 2007 (11 ) SCC 436 = 2007 (10 ) JT 496
71. ANOKH SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 21/08/2007 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -GUILT -ESTABLISHMENT
Citation(s) 2007 (11 ) SCC 434 =
72. SHAIK MASTAN VALI .Vs. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH DOJ : 03/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1240 = 2007 (8 ) SCR 779 = 2007 (9 ) SCC 342 = 2007 (9 ) JT 604 = 2007 (9
) SCALE 555
73. SUJOY SEN @ SUJOY KR. SEN .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 08/05/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -CALCUTTA
Citation(s) 2007 (6 ) SCR 112 = 2007 (6 ) SCC 32 = 2007 (6 ) JT 465 = 2007 (6 ) SCALE 560
74. HATTI SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 17/04/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2007 (5 ) SCR 221 = 2007 (12 ) SCC 471 = 2007 (5 ) SCALE 760
75. DNYANESHWAR .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 20/03/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -DOWRY -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2007 (4 ) SCR 248 = 2007 (10 ) SCC 445 = 2007 (5 ) SCALE 350
76. YOGESH NARAIN SAXENA .Vs. STATE OF UTTARANCHAL DOJ : 09/03/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -UTTARANCHAL
Citation(s) 2007 (3 ) SCR 856 = 2009 (16 ) SCC 547 = 2007 (4 ) JT 604 = 2007 (4 ) SCALE 247
77. MANJUNATH CHENNABASAPA MADALLI .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 19/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 2080 = 2007 (2 ) SCR 795 = 2007 (9 ) SCC 160 = 2007 (3 ) JT 550
78. RAM SINGH .Vs. SONIA & ORS DOJ : 15/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -POLICE CUSTODY
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1218 = 2007 (2 ) SCR 651 = 2007 (3 ) SCC 1 = 2007 (3 ) JT 287
79. DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER GSRTC .Vs. KADARBHAI J SUTHAR DOJ : 13/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EVIDENCE -PENOLOGY
Citation(s) 2007 (2 ) SCR 550 = 2007 (10 ) SCC 561 = 2007 (8 ) JT 564 = 2007 (3 ) SCALE 39
80. SHIVU AND ANR .Vs. R G HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AND ANR DOJ : 13/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EVIDENCE -PENOLOGY
Citation(s) 2007 (2 ) SCR 555 = 2007 (4 ) SCC 713 = 2007 (3 ) JT 333 = 2007 (3 ) SCALE 157
81. RAJ KUMAR PRASAD TAMARKAR .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR & ANR DOJ : 04/01/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2007 (1 ) SCR 13 = 2007 (10 ) SCC 433 = 2007 (1 ) JT 239 = 2007 (1 ) SCALE 19
82. BABLU @ MUBARIK HUSSAIN .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 12/12/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -DEATH SENTENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 697 = 2006 (10 ) Suppl. SCR 835 = 2006 (13 ) SCC 116 = 2006 (14 ) SCALE 15
83. ALOKE NATH DUTTA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 12/12/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CRIMINAL CONSPIRACY -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 (10 ) Suppl. SCR 662 = 2007 (12 ) SCC 230 = 2006 (13 ) SCALE 467
84. GAGAN KANOJIA & ANR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 24/11/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -KIDNAPPING & MURDER OF MINOR -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DEATH PENALTY
Citation(s) 2006 (9 ) Suppl. SCR 413 = 20 (13 ) SCC 516 = 2006 (12 ) SCALE 479
85. MOHAMMED ARSHAD .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA & ORS DOJ : 24/11/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DYING DECLARATION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -AURANGABAD
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 624 = 2006 (9 ) Suppl. SCR 359 = 2006 (12 ) SCC 293 = 2006 (12 ) SCALE 370
86. ANIL @ RAJU NAMDEV PATIL .Vs. ADMINISTRATION OF DAMAN & DIU, DAMAN & ANR DOJ
: 24/11/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -KIDNAPPING -RANSOM
Citation(s) 2006 (9 ) Suppl. SCR 466 = 2006 (13 ) SCC 36 = 2006 (10 ) JT 586 = 2006 (12 ) SCALE 516

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 10 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

87. VIKRAMJIT SINGH @ VICKY .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 24/11/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -WIFE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 (9 ) Suppl. SCR 375 = 2006 (12 ) SCC 306 = 2006 (12 ) SCALE 321
88. YUVARAJ AMBAR MOHITE .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 19/10/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 (7 ) Suppl. SCR 677 = 2006 (12 ) SCC 512 = 2006 (10 ) SCALE 369
89. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH .Vs. MUKESH & ORS. DOJ : 19/10/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONFESSION -EXAMINATION OF ACCUSED -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 (7 ) Suppl. SCR 492 = 2006 (13 ) SCC 197 = 2006 (10 ) SCALE 346
90. TRIMUKH MAROTI KIRKAN .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 11/10/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -BURDEN OF PROOF
Citation(s) 2006 (7 ) Suppl. SCR 156 = 2006 (10 ) SCC 681 = 2006 (9 ) JT 50 = 2006 (10 ) SCALE 190
91. RAMJEE RAI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 24/08/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CRIMINAL TRIAL -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CORPUS DELICTI
Citation(s) 2006 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 240 = 2006 (13 ) SCC 229 = 2006 (7 ) JT 610 = 2006 (8 ) SCALE 440
92. GOLUSULA ELLAIAH .Vs. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH DOJ : 20/07/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -A P
Citation(s) 2006 (11 ) SCC 175 = 2006 (7 ) JT 173 = 2006 (7 ) SCALE 235
93. RAMREDDY RAJESHKHANNA REDDY & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 24/03/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 1656 = 2006 (3 ) SCR 348 = 2006 (10 ) SCC 172 = 2006 (4 ) JT 16 = 2006 (3
) SCALE 452
94. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. DESH RAJ DOJ : 09/03/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 1712 = 2006 (9 ) SCC 278 = 2006 (3 ) SCALE 194
95. DEEPAK CHANDRAKANT PATIL .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 08/03/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 1708 = 2006 (10 ) SCC 151 = 2006 (3 ) JT 537 = 2006 (3 ) SCALE 229
96. REDDY SAMPATH KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH DOJ : 08/09/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -GRUESOME MURDER -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 3478 = 2005 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 133 = 2005 (7 ) SCC 603 = 2005 (8 ) JT 294 = 2005 (7
) SCALE 270
97. ANANTALAL GHOSH .Vs. STATE OF WEST BENGAL DOJ : 07/09/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -WEST BENGAL
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 3415 = 2005 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 113 = 2005 (12 ) SCC 474 = 2005 (8 ) JT 292 = 2005 (7
) SCALE 237
98. STATE OF KERALA .Vs. V. BABY DOJ : 13/04/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 3010 = 2005 (11 ) SCC 270 = 2005 (5 ) JT 256 = 2005 (4 ) SCALE 198
99. GAYADIN .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 10/02/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPEAL AGAINST ACQUITTAL -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -PROSECUTION WITNESS
Citation(s) 2005 (12 ) SCC 267 =
100. GAYADIN .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 10/02/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPEAL AGAINST ACQUITTAL -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2005 (12 ) SCC 267 =
101. KANTI LAL .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 21/04/2004 JUDGEMENT
MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 2536 = 2004 (10 ) SCC 113 = 2004 (1 ) Suppl. JT 487 = 2004 (4 ) SCALE 795
102. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. RAJA RAM DOJ : 13/08/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3601 = 2003 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 445 = 2003 (8 ) SCC 180 = 2003 (7 ) JT 399 = 2003 (6
) SCALE 489
103. BABU S/O RAVEENDRAN .Vs. BABU S/O BAHULEYAN & ANR. DOJ : 11/08/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 389 = 2003 (7 ) SCC 37 = 2003 (6 ) JT 615 = 2003 (6 ) SCALE 276
104. PAWAN KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 23/07/2003 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2987 = 2003 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 710 = 2003 (11 ) SCC 241 = 2003 (6 ) JT 309 = 2003 (5
) SCALE 552
105. BABUDAS .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 29/04/2003 JUDGEMENT
MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -SETTING ASIDE
Citation(s) 2003 ( 9 ) SCC 86 = 2003 ( 4 ) JT 289 = 2003 ( 4 ) SCALE 389

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 11 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

106. BHARAT .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 30/01/2003 ORDER


CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CONFESSION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 1433 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCR 748 = 2003 ( 3 ) SCC 106 = 2003 ( 1 ) JT 635 = 2003 ( 1
) SCALE 610
107. BHARAT .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 30/01/2003 ORDER
MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -SETTING ASIDE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 1433 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCR 748 = 2003 ( 3 ) SCC 106 = 2003 ( 1 ) JT 635 = 2003 ( 1
) SCALE 610
108. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. ARUN KUMAR GUPTA DOJ : 08/01/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 801 = 2003 ( 2 ) SCC 202 = 2003 ( 1 ) JT 49 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCALE 76
109. SUBIMAL SARKAR .Vs. SACHINDRA NATH MONDAL & ORS. DOJ : 08/01/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 1108 = 2003 ( 2 ) SCC 566 = 2003 ( 1 ) JT 72 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCALE 62
110. KANTILAL @ K.L. GORDHANDAS SONI .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 11/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 684 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 39 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 232
111. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. A.B. NAGARAJ & ANR. DOJ : 10/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 666 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 1 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 249
112. STATE OF KERALA .Vs. THANIYULLA PARAMBATH BALAN DOJ : 26/11/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -KERALA
Citation(s) 2002 (10 ) JT 232 =
113. ALAMGIR .Vs. STATE (NCT) DELHI DOJ : 12/11/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 282 = 2002 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 88 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 21 = 2002 ( 9 ) JT 347 = 2002 ( 8
) SCALE 373
114. SAHADEVAN @ SAGADEVAN .Vs. STATE REP. BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE CHENNAI DOJ : 01/11/2002 JUDGEMENT
DEATH IN POLICE CUSTODY -LAST SEEN TOGETHER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 215 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 534 = 2002 ( 9 ) JT 366 = 2002 ( 8 ) SCALE 311
115. RAVINDER PARKASH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 04/10/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) SCC 426 = 2002 ( 8 ) JT 89 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCALE 270
116. RAVINDER PARKASH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 04/10/2002 JUDGEMENT
CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LAST SEEN TOGETHER -WITNESS -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) SCC 426 = 2002 ( 8 ) JT 89 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCALE 270
117. JAIPAL .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 01/10/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3447 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 714 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 169 = 2002 ( 8 ) JT 29 = 2002 ( 7
) SCALE 154
118. JAIPAL .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 01/10/2002 JUDGEMENT
POISONING -WIFE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3447 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 714 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 169 = 2002 ( 8 ) JT 29 = 2002 ( 7
) SCALE 154
119. MADHO SINGH .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 26/09/2002 ORDER
MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -SETTING ASIDE
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 305 =
120. RAM PRASAD .Vs. STATE OF U.P. & ANR. DOJ : 25/09/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MULTIPLE MURDERS -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 263 =
121. RAM PRASAD .Vs. STATE OF U.P. & ANR. DOJ : 25/09/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL -HIGH COURTS
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 263 =
122. PARAMASIVAM @ PARAMAN @ KOTTIYAN & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF TAMIL NADU DOJ : 17/09/2002 ORDER
MURDER -WITNESS -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 214 =
123. GURPREET SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 12/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -BRIDE BURNING -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3217 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 337 = 2002 ( 8 ) SCC 18 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 58 = 2002 ( 6
) SCALE 363
124. ASHISH BATHAM .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 09/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3206 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 146 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 317 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 593 = 2002 ( 6
) SCALE 289

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 12 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

125. ASHISH BATHAM .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 09/09/2002 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3206 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 146 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 317 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 593 = 2002 ( 6
) SCALE 289
126. BALU SONBA SHINDE .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 06/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3137 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 135 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 543 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 611 = 2002 ( 6
) SCALE 281
127. MOHD. KHALID .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 03/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONFESSIONAL STATEMENT -COMMON INTENTION -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 31 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 334 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 486 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCALE 238
128. MOHIBUR RAHMAN & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 21/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3064 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 715 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 235 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCALE 49
129. MANI KUMAR THAPA .Vs. STATE OF SIKKIM DOJ : 19/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2920 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 157 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 349 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCALE 1
130. KULDIP SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 14/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL -PUNJAB
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3023 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 757 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 97 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 569
131. DHANANJAY SHANKAR SHETTY .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 31/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2787 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 352 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 596 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 559 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 387
132. N. SHIVAKUMAR @ SHIVANNA .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 30/07/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 6 ) JT 583 =
133. VISHWAJIT SHANKAR KHAVANEKAR .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 30/07/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -MAHARASHTRA
Citation(s) 2002 ( 6 ) JT 565 =
134. TAPUBHA BHAGVANJI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 30/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -DEATH BY BURNING -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2794 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 530 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 559 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 391
135. VITHAL TUKARAM MORE & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 23/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2715 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 20 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 289 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 289
136. MANDHARI .Vs. STATE OF CHATTISGARH DOJ : 16/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1961 = 2002 ( 4 ) SCC 308 = 2002 ( 4 ) JT 232 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCALE 568
137. GEORGE .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 03/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1647 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCR 895 = 2002 ( 4 ) SCC 475 = 2002 ( 3 ) JT 582 = 2002 ( 3
) SCALE 287
138. AYYUB ETC. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 28/02/2002 JUDGEMENT
TADA -CONVICTION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1192 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCR 106 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCC 510 = 2002 ( 2 ) JT 371 = 2002 ( 2
) SCALE 349
139. MOTIRAM GAMAN PAWAR .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 07/02/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 2 ) JT 637 =
140. VINOD KUMAR & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 30/01/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 2 ) JT 486 =
141. PRAKASH DHAWAL KHAIRNAR PATIL .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 12/12/2001 JUDGEMENT
CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONFESSIONAL STATEMENT -CORROBORATION -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 340 = 2001 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 612 = 2002 (2 ) SCC 35 = 2001 (2 ) Suppl. JT 243 = 2001
(8 ) SCALE 482
142. SUDAMA PANDEY & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 05/12/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 293 = 2001 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 465 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 679 = 2001 (10 ) JT 278 = 2001 ( 8
) SCALE 376
143. GANESH LAL .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 31/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -MINOR -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 619 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 731 = 2001 ( 9 ) JT 383 = 2001 ( 7 ) SCALE 551

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 13 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

144. GANESH LAL .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 31/10/2001 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -CONVICTION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -PRESUMPTION
Citation(s) 2001 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 619 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 731 = 2001 ( 9 ) JT 383 = 2001 ( 7 ) SCALE 551
145. SUBHASH CHAND .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 16/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE MINOR GIRL -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 163 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 702 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 505 = 2001 ( 7 ) SCALE 246
146. SUBHASH CHAND .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 16/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CONVICTION -VALIDITY -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2001 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 163 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 702 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 505 = 2001 ( 7 ) SCALE 246
147. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. MOHD. HANIF MOHIDDIN SHAIKH DOJ : 18/07/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL -HIGH COURTS
Citation(s) 2001 (10 ) JT 132 =
148. GADE LAKSHMI MANGRAJU @ RAMESH .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 10/07/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -FINGER PRINT -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2677 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCR 830 = 2001 ( 6 ) SCC 205 = 2001 ( 5 ) JT 340 = 2001 ( 4
) SCALE 265
149. JAWAHAR LAL & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 11/05/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -BRIDE BURNING -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ALIBI
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2209 = 2001 ( 5 ) SCC 300 = 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 122 = 2001 ( 4 ) SCALE 166
150. BIBHACHHA .Vs. STATE OF ORISSA DOJ : 08/05/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2274 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCR 546 = 2001 ( 6 ) SCC 376 = 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 251 = 2001 ( 4
) SCALE 38
151. DHANANJAYA REDDY ETC. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 14/03/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONFESSION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 1512 = 2001 ( 2 ) SCR 399 = 2001 ( 4 ) SCC 9 = 2001 ( 3 ) JT 395 = 2001 ( 2
) SCALE 452
152. PAWAN KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 13/03/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DYING DECLARATION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -BRIDE BURNING
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 1324 = 2001 ( 2 ) SCR 389 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCC 628 = 2001 ( 3 ) JT 475 = 2001 ( 2
) SCALE 440
153. NAJRA .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 08/02/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2001 ( 5 ) JT 530 =
154. SANJAY @ KAKA ETC. ETC. .Vs. STATE (N.C.T. OF DELHI) DOJ : 07/02/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 979 = 2001 ( 1 ) SCR 904 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCC 190 = 2001 ( 2 ) JT 461 = 2001 ( 1
) SCALE 695
155. M. NARSINGA RAO .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 12/12/2000 JUDGEMENT
PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -BRIBE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -PRESUMPTION
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 318 = 2000 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 584 = 2001 ( 1 ) SCC 691 = 2000 ( 3
) Suppl. JT 559 = 2000 ( 8 ) SCALE 303
156. STATE GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI .Vs. SUNIL & ANR. DOJ : 29/11/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -RAPE
Citation(s) 2000 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 144 = 2001 ( 1 ) SCC 652 = 2000 ( 3 ) Suppl. JT 267 = 2000 ( 7 ) SCALE 692
157. SAJU .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 15/11/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -CONSPIRACY
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 175 = 2000 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 621 = 2001 ( 1 ) SCC 378 = 2000 ( 2
) Suppl. JT 609 = 2000 ( 7 ) SCALE 424
158. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. HARI MOHAN & ORS. DOJ : 07/11/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MURDER -SENTENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 142 = 2000 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 440 = 2000 ( 8 ) SCC 598 = 2000 ( 2
) Suppl. JT 467 = 2000 ( 7 ) SCALE 348
159. MANISH DIXIT .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 18/10/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ABDUCTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 93 = 2000 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 74 = 2001 ( 1 ) SCC 596 = 2000 ( 2 ) Suppl. JT 237 = 2000
( 7 ) SCALE 218
160. VASA CHANDRASEKHAR RAO .Vs. PONNA SATYANARAYANA & ANR. DOJ : 05/05/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 2138 = 2000 ( 6 ) SCC 286 = 2000 ( 6 ) JT 465 = 2000 ( 4 ) SCALE 635
161. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. SURESH DOJ : 10/12/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -RAPE
Citation(s) 1999 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 215 = 2000 (1 ) SCC 471 = 1999 (9 ) JT 513 = 1999 (7 ) SCALE 386

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 14 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

162. V. VIJAYKUMAR .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 10/12/1999 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MURDER -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 586 = 1999 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 208 = 2000 (1 ) SCC 628 = 1999 (9 ) JT 528 = 1999 (7
) SCALE 381
163. C.K. RAVEENDRAN .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 02/12/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 369 = 1999 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 140 = 2000 (1 ) SCC 225 = 1999 (9 ) JT 408 = 1999 (7
) SCALE 304
164. MUJEEB .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 29/11/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 591 = 1999 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 16 = 2000 (10 ) SCC 315 = 1999 (9 ) JT 299 = 1999 (7
) SCALE 249
165. MOLAI & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 26/10/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 177 = 1999 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 104 = 1999 ( 9 ) SCC 581 = 1999 ( 8 ) JT 361 = 1999 ( 6
) SCALE 606
166. DAMODAR .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 01/10/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -WITNESS -MURDER
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 50 = 2000 (10 ) SCC 328 = 1999 ( 8 ) JT 62 = 1999 ( 6 ) SCALE 306
167. STATE OF T.N. .Vs. RAJENDRAN DOJ : 22/09/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -BENEFIT OF DOUBT -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -BRIDE BURNING
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3535 = 1999 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 89 = 1999 (8 ) SCC 679 = 1999 (7 ) JT 348 = 1999 (6
) SCALE 145
168. JALALSAB SHAIKH .Vs. STATE OF GOA DOJ : 11/08/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -FALSE STATEMENT
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 571 = 1999 ( 6 ) SCC 410 = 1999 ( 6 ) JT 177 = 1999 ( 5 ) SCALE 62
169. MOHD. ZAHID .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 20/07/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 2416 = 1999 ( 6 ) SCC 120 = 1999 ( 5 ) JT 5 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCALE 173
170. ARVIND @ PAPPU .Vs. STATE DELHI ADMINISTRATION DOJ : 10/05/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -PROOF -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1999 ( 2 ) SCR 1217 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCC 486 = 1999 ( 3 ) JT 554 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCALE 44
171. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. TEJA RAM & ORS. DOJ : 19/03/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1776 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCR 29 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCC 507 = 1999 ( 2 ) JT 279 = 1999 ( 2
) SCALE 169
172. VIJAYAN @ RAJAN ETC. .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 16/02/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONSPIRACY -WITNESS -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1086 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCR 659 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCC 54 = 1999 ( 1 ) JT 499 = 1999 ( 1
) SCALE 479
173. VIJAYAN @ RAJAN ETC. .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 16/02/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1086 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCR 659 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCC 54 = 1999 ( 1 ) JT 499 = 1999 ( 1
) SCALE 479
174. SANJIV KUMAR ETC. .Vs. STATE OF H.P. DOJ : 22/01/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MURDER -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 782 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCR 217 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCC 288 = 1999 ( 1 ) JT 116 = 1999 ( 1
) SCALE 120
175. DWARKADAS GEHANMAL .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 20/11/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 ( 1 ) SCC 57 = 1998 ( 8 ) JT 100 = 1998 ( 6 ) SCALE 204
176. UDAY KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 21/09/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ACQUITTAL -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 3317 = 1998 ( 7 ) SCC 478 = 1998 ( 6 ) JT 493 = 1998 ( 5 ) SCALE 364
177. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. MAHAVIR @ MAHAVIR PRASAD DOJ : 29/07/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -BRIDE BURNING -ALIBI -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 3041 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCC 199 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 274 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCALE 365
178. STATE OF H.P. .Vs. MANOHAR SINGH THAKUR DOJ : 28/07/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT -NOT CONFIRMED -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2941 = 1998 ( 6 ) SCC 158 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 204 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCALE 297
179. MD. MAHIRUDDIN .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 23/07/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -FALSE STATEMENT -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 307 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCC 252 = 1998 ( 3 ) JT 195 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCALE 306

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 15 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

180. BRIJLAL PRASAD SINHA .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 13/07/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CAPITAL INVESTMENT -NOT JUSTIFIED
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2443 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCR 529 = 1998 ( 5 ) SCC 699 = 1998 ( 4 ) JT 534 = 1998 ( 4
) SCALE 25
181. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. MADHUKAR GOVIND PAKHARE DOJ : 16/04/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL -HIGH COURTS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2978 = 1998 ( 3 ) JT 466 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCALE 208
182. RONNY @ RONALD JAMES ALWARIS .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 05/03/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT -NOT CONFIRMED -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1251 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCR 162 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCC 625 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 375 = 1998 ( 2
) SCALE 261
183. SHAIKH AYUB .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 26/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1285 = 1998 ( 9 ) SCC 521 = 1998 ( 7 ) JT 115 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCALE 171
184. SHEIKH ABDUL HAMID .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 04/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -NOT CONFIRMED
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 942 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCR 546 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCC 188 = 1998 ( 1 ) JT 377 = 1998 ( 1
) SCALE 368
185. STATE OF T.N. ETC. .Vs. SURESH (A-2) & ANR. DOJ : 05/12/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE -ACCOMPLICE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1044 = 1997 ( 6 ) Suppl. SCR 203 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCC 372 = 1997 ( 9 ) JT 647 = 1997 ( 7
) SCALE 402
186. STATE OF T.N. .Vs. P. MUNIAPPAN ETC. DOJ : 02/12/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -HANGING -SUICIDE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 504 = 1997 ( 6 ) Suppl. SCR 124 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCC 515 = 1997 ( 9 ) JT 572 = 1997 ( 7
) SCALE 358
187. RAJENDRA KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 21/11/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -BRIDE BURNING -LIFE IMPRISONMENT -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2896 = 1998 ( 9 ) SCC 343 = 1997 ( 9 ) JT 221 = 1997 ( 7 ) SCALE 107
188. HARGOVANDAS DEVRAJBHAI PATEL .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 18/11/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ACQUITTAL -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 370 = 1997 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 154 = 1998 ( 9 ) SCC 17 = 1998 ( 4 ) JT 384 = 1997 ( 7
) SCALE 30
189. SUDAMA ROY @ JADAV .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 24/10/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -LIFE IMPRISONMENT -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1997 ( 8 ) JT 554 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 598
190. LEKHRAJ @ HARISINGH .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 22/10/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ACQUITTAL -TRIAL COURT -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 242 = 1997 ( 8 ) JT 746 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 649
191. GULZAR ALI .Vs. STATE OF H.P. DOJ : 21/10/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -HANDWRITING -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 559 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCC 192 = 1997 ( 8 ) JT 564 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 483
192. R. RAJENDRAN NAIR .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 14/10/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EYE WITNESS -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1 = 1997 ( 8 ) JT 369 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 361
193. PAKKIRISAMY .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 30/09/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONFESSION -CORROBORATION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 107 = 1997 ( 8 ) SCC 158 = 1997 ( 8 ) JT 310 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 315
194. M. SUSEELA .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 16/09/1997 JUDGEMENT
MEDICAL JURISPRUDENCE -SUICIDE -DEATH -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 3493 = 1997 ( 8 ) SCC 168 = 1997 ( 8 ) JT 148 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 128
195. M. SUSEELA .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 16/09/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DEATH -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 3493 = 1997 ( 8 ) SCC 168 = 1997 ( 8 ) JT 148 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 128
196. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. BHOJA POOJARI DOJ : 09/09/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 3812 = 1997 (11 ) SCC 537 = 1997 ( 7 ) JT 748 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 18
197. KAMAL MURU .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 08/09/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -MURDER
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 3802 = 1997 ( 7 ) JT 715 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 94
198. STATE OF GUJARAT .Vs. ANIRUDHSING DOJ : 10/07/1997 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MOTIVE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2780 = 1997 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 234 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCC 514 = 1997 ( 6 ) JT 236 = 1997 ( 4
) SCALE 724

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 16 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

199. MOHD. AMAN .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 08/05/1997 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -FINGER PRINT -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2960 = 1997 (10 ) SCC 44 = 1997 ( 5 ) JT 451 = 1997 ( 4 ) SCALE 134
200. PARAMJIT SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 10/12/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1614 = 1997 ( 4 ) SCC 156 = 1997 ( 1 ) JT 336 = 1996 ( 9 ) SCALE 129
201. INDRADEO MISHRA .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 10/12/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 (11 ) JT 661 = 1996 ( 9 ) SCALE 133
202. STATE OF H.P. .Vs. DHANI RAM DOJ : 25/09/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 1996 ( 8 ) JT 522 = 1996 ( 7 ) SCALE 152
203. SHERA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 28/08/1996 ORDER
EVIDENCE -APPROVER -CORROBORATION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 304 = 1996 (10 ) SCC 330 = 1996 Suppl. JT 543 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 345
204. GENTELA VIJAYAVARDHAN RAO .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 28/08/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MURDER -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 2791 = 1996 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 273 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCC 241 = 1996 ( 7 ) JT 491 = 1996 ( 6
) SCALE 231
205. MEHBUB SAMSUDDIN MALEK .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 23/08/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONSPIRACY -IDENTIFICATION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 136 = 1996 (10 ) SCC 480 = 1996 ( 7 ) JT 404 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 102
206. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. RAMESH PRASAD MISRA DOJ : 13/08/1996 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 2766 = 1996 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 631 = 1996 (10 ) SCC 360 = 1996 ( 9 ) JT 566 = 1996 ( 6
) SCALE 90
207. RAMESH BABULAL DOSHI .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 02/05/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EYE WITNESS -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 2035 = 1996 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 265 = 1996 ( 9 ) SCC 225 = 1996 ( 6 ) JT 79 = 1996 ( 4
) SCALE 185
208. MULAK RAJ .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 19/01/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 2868 = 1996 ( 1 ) SCR 791 = 1996 ( 7 ) SCC 308 = 1996 ( 1 ) JT 401 = 1996 ( 1
) SCALE 419
209. BHAGWAN DASS .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 16/01/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 2928 = 1996 ( 1 ) JT 483 = 1996 ( 1 ) SCALE 327
210. STATE OF M.P. .Vs. SHYAMSUNDER TRIVEDI DOJ : 09/05/1995 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -POLICE CUSTODY -DEATH -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 44 = 1995 ( 4 ) SCC 262 = 1995 ( 4 ) JT 445 = 1995 ( 3 ) SCALE 343
211. AKHILESH HAJAM .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 28/04/1995 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 ( 3 ) SCR 864 = 1995 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 357 = 1995 ( 4 ) JT 238 = 1995 ( 3 ) SCALE 60
212. PREM KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 02/03/1995 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1995 ( 2 ) SCR 455 = 1995 ( 3 ) SCC 228 = 1995 ( 3 ) JT 123 = 1995 ( 2 ) SCALE 50
213. U.O.I. .Vs. D. MOHAN DOJ : 01/02/1995 JUDGEMENT
SERVICE LAW -TRANSFER -SPECIAL CIRCUMSTANCES -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 ( 1 ) SCR 747 = 1995 ( 3 ) SCC 115 = 1995 ( 2 ) JT 244 = 1995 ( 1 ) SCALE 424
214. SUNDARAMURTHI .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 16/12/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1994 ( 6 ) Suppl. SCR 653 = 1995 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 567 = 1995 ( 1 ) JT 188 = 1994 ( 5
) SCALE 330
215. P.K. NARAYANAN .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 27/10/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONSPIRACY -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 ( 1 ) SCC 142 = 1994 ( 4 ) SCALE 740
216. BUDHA SATYA VENKATA S. RAO .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 07/10/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1994 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 639 = 1994 ( 6 ) JT 438 = 1994 ( 4 ) SCALE 480
217. ANSHAD .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 22/04/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -RECOVERY OF CRIME ARTICLES
Citation(s) 1994 ( 4 ) SCC 381 = 1994 ( 3 ) JT 324 = 1994 ( 2 ) SCALE 653

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 17 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

218. RAMPAL PITHWA RAHIDASS .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 01/03/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1994 ( 2 ) SCR 179 = 1994 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 73 = 1994 ( 2 ) JT 573 = 1994 ( 1 ) SCALE 768
219. ESHWARAIAH .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 27/01/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1994 ( 1 ) SCR 387 = 1994 ( 2 ) SCC 677 = 1994 ( 1 ) JT 199 = 1994 ( 1 ) SCALE 219
220. DHANANJOY CHATTERJEE @ DHANA .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 11/01/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -PRINCIPLES
Citation(s) 1994 ( 1 ) SCR 37 = 1994 ( 2 ) SCC 220 = 1994 ( 1 ) JT 33 = 1994 ( 1 ) SCALE 48
221. HANUMAN .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 25/11/1993 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1994 AIR 1307 = 1994 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 39 =
222. GOKARAJU VENKATANARASA RAJU .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 24/08/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 737 = 1993 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCC 191 = 1993 ( 5 ) JT 71 = 1993 ( 3 ) SCALE 495
223. PRABHUDAYAL .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 14/05/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -BENEFIT OF DOUBT -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 2164 = 1993 ( 3 ) SCR 878 = 1993 ( 3 ) SCC 573 = 1993 ( 4 ) JT 475 = 1993 ( 2
) SCALE 941
224. KUNDULA BALA SUBRAHMANYAM .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 26/03/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -BRIDE BURNING
Citation(s) 1993 ( 2 ) SCR 666 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCC 684 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 559 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCALE 214
225. SURINDER PAL JAIN .Vs. DELHI ADMINISTRATION DOJ : 05/03/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MOTIVE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 1723 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCR 226 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 681 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 206 = 1993 ( 1
) SCALE 792
226. SURINDER PAL JAIN .Vs. DELHI ADMINISTRATION DOJ : 05/03/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -RECOVERY OF ORNAMENTS
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 1723 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCR 226 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 681 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 206 = 1993 ( 1
) SCALE 792
227. SURINDER PAL JAIN .Vs. DELHI ADMINISTRATION DOJ : 05/03/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DOG SQUAD
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 1723 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCR 226 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 681 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 206 = 1993 ( 1
) SCALE 792
228. SARDAR SINGH .Vs. STATE ( DELHI ADMINISTRATION ) DELHI DOJ : 23/02/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 1696 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCR 65 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 393 = 1993 ( 4 ) JT 534 = 1993 ( 1
) SCALE 681
229. SARBIR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 11/02/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1993 ( 1 ) SCR 1027 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 41 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 159 = 1993 ( 1 ) SCALE 573
230. RATTNI .Vs. STATE OF H.P. DOJ : 04/02/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -POISONING
Citation(s) 1993 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCC 669 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 100 = 1993 ( 1 ) SCALE 259
231. JARNAIL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 20/01/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MOTIVE -ABSENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1993 ( 1 ) SCR 260 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 91 = 1993 ( 1 ) JT 207 = 1993 ( 1 ) SCALE 153
232. SAROJINI .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 16/10/1992 JUDGEMENT
DOWRY DEATH -ACQUITTAL -HIGH COURTS -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 25 = 1993 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCC 632 = 1992 Suppl. JT 433 = 1992 ( 3
) SCALE 70
233. SAROJINI .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 16/10/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DOWRY DEATH
Citation(s) 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 25 = 1993 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCC 632 = 1992 Suppl. JT 433 = 1992 ( 3
) SCALE 70
234. JASBIR KAUR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 17/09/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 151 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 654 = 1992 Suppl. JT 648 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 726
235. CHANDU @ CHANDRAHAS .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 15/09/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LAST SEEN TOGETHER
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 2302 = 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 358 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 738
236. CHANDU @ CHANDRAHAS .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 15/09/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -RECOVERY OF SHIRT
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 2302 = 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 358 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 738

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 18 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

237. BABUDA .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 28/08/1992 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -SUSPICION
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 2091 = 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 438 = 1992 ( 5 ) JT 307 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 712
238. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. VED NARAIN DOJ : 23/07/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 265 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 705 = 1993 Suppl. JT 587 =
239. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. LAKSHMANAIAH DOJ : 21/07/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 100 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCR 579 = 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 420 = 1992 ( 4 ) JT 326 = 1992 ( 2
) SCALE 45
240. ANANT BHUJANGRAO KULKARNI .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 15/05/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 110 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 267 = 1992 ( 4 ) JT 228 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 1299
241. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. RAVINDRA PRAKASH MITTAL (DR.) DOJ : 28/04/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -INGREDIENTS
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 2045 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 815 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 300 = 1992 ( 3 ) JT 114 = 1992 ( 1
) SCALE 937
242. GANESHLAL .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 10/04/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 502 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 106 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 592 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 811
243. MULAKH RAJ .Vs. SATISH KUMAR DOJ : 10/04/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1175 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 484 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 43 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 554 = 1992 ( 1
) SCALE 804
244. SAKHARAM .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 12/02/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -JUVENILE INNOCENCE -PRESUMPTION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 758 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCR 638 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCC 153 = 1992 ( 1 ) JT 515 = 1992 ( 1
) SCALE 320
245. SAKHARAM .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 12/02/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CHILD
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 758 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCR 638 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCC 153 = 1992 ( 1 ) JT 515 = 1992 ( 1
) SCALE 320
246. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. ASHOK KUMAR SRIVASTAVA DOJ : 14/01/1992 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CUMULATIVE EFFECT -DOUBT
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 840 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCR 37 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCC 86 = 1992 ( 1 ) JT 340 = 1992 ( 1
) SCALE 149
247. JAHARLAL DAS .Vs. STATE OF ORISSA DOJ : 12/04/1991 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1991 AIR 1388 = 1991 ( 2 ) SCR 298 = 1991 ( 3 ) SCC 27 = 1991 ( 2 ) JT 264 = 1991 ( 1
) SCALE 713
248. MALKIAT SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 10/04/1991 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -FIR
Citation(s) 1991 ( 2 ) SCR 256 = 1991 ( 4 ) SCC 341 = 1991 ( 2 ) JT 190 = 1991 ( 1 ) SCALE 722
249. S.D. SONI .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 21/12/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -SUICIDE
Citation(s) 1991 AIR 917 = 1990 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 668 = 1992 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 567 = 1991 ( 1 ) JT 1 = 1990
( 2 ) SCALE 1342
250. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. MADHUKAR NARAYAN MARDIKAR DOJ : 23/10/1990 JUDGEMENT
-CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -UNCHASTE WOMAN
Citation(s) 1991 AIR 207 = 1991 ( 1 ) SCC 57 = 1990 ( 4 ) JT 169 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCALE 849
251. KISHORE CHAND .Vs. STATE OF H.P. DOJ : 29/08/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 2140 = 1990 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 105 = 1991 ( 1 ) SCC 286 = 1990 ( 3 ) JT 662 = 1990 ( 2
) SCALE 369
252. CHANDRAN @ SURENDRAN .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 28/08/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 2148 = 1991 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 39 = 1990 ( 3 ) JT 718 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCALE 420
253. KISHAN LAL SETHI .Vs. JAGAN NATH DOJ : 17/04/1990 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -BURNS
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1357 = 1990 ( 3 ) SCC 45 = 1990 ( 3 ) JT 100 = 1990 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCALE 104
254. STATE DELHI ADMINISTRATION .Vs. N.S. GIANI DOJ : 04/04/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CORRUPTION -IRON & STEEL
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1190 = 1990 ( 3 ) SCC 325 = 1990 ( 2 ) JT 76 = 1990 ( 1 ) SCALE 654

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 19 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

255. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. LALLA SINGH DOJ : 13/03/1990


CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1013 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCC 687 = 1990 ( 1 ) JT 553 = 1990 ( 1 ) SCALE 572
1. RAJESH PANDEY .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 25/03/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -COGENT EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 (4 ) SCR 1147 = 2009 (5 ) SCC 132 = 2009 (7 ) JT 140 = 2009 (4 ) SCALE 533
1. SOORARAM PRATAP REDDY & ORS .Vs. DIST. COLLECTOR, RANGA REDDY DISTT. & ORS. DOJ
: 05/09/2008 JUDGEMENT
LAND ACQUISITION -PUBLIC PURPOSE -DECLARATION -CONCLUSIVE EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 (13 ) SCR 126 = 2008 (9 ) SCC 552 = 2008 (9 ) JT 622 = 2008 (12 ) SCALE 367
1. MANGILAL .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 26/04/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -CONFLICT WITH MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 Suppl. SCC 529 = 1990 ( 2 ) JT 198 = 1990 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCALE 117
1. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. KISHANPAL & ORS. DOJ : 08/08/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CREDIBILITY OF EVIDENCE -UNLAWFUL ASSEMBLY
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1238 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 1048 = 2008 (16 ) SCC 73 = 2008 (8 ) JT 650 = 2008 (11
) SCALE 233
1. LAL BAHADUR SHRIRAMDATTA CHAUDHARI .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 09/10/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONVICTION -DIRECT EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1991 AIR 34 = 1991 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 546 = 1990 ( 4 ) JT 157 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCALE 736
1. GEEJAGANDA SOMAIAH .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 12/03/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -DISCLOSURE EVIDENCE -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1355 = 2007 (3 ) SCR 899 = 2007 (9 ) SCC 315 = 2007 (4 ) JT 380 = 2007 (4
) SCALE 314
1. CITY AND INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION .Vs. DOSU AARDESHIR BHIWANDIWALA & ORS. DOJ
: 14/11/2008 JUDGEMENT
CONSTITUTION -JURISDICTION OF HIGH COURT -DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE -DUE PROCEDURE OF LAW
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 571 = 2008 (16 ) SCR 28 = 2009 (1 ) SCC 168 = 2008 (12 ) JT 127 = 2008 (14
) SCALE 23
2. DULI CHAND .Vs. U.O.I. DOJ : 16/07/1990 ORDER
SERVICE LAW -PENSION -FREEDOM FIGHTER -DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 Suppl. SCC 762 =
1. SAMPATH KUMAR .Vs. INSPECTOR OF POLICE KRISHNAGIRI DOJ : 02/03/2012 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -DISCREPANCY
Citation(s) 2012 AIR 1249 = 2012 (4 ) SCC 124 = 2012 (2 ) JT 661 = 2012 (3 ) SCALE 271
2. SHARAD .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 31/01/2012 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2012 (2 ) JT 26 = 2012 (2 ) SCALE 42
3. COMMISSIONER OF POLICE DELHI & ORS. .Vs. JAI BHAGWAN DOJ : 10/05/2011 JUDGEMENT
SERVICE LAW -DISMISSAL -EVIDENCE -REINSTATEMENT
Citation(s) 2011 (7 ) SCR 558 = 2011 (6 ) SCC 376 = 2011 (6 ) JT 63 = 2011 (5 ) SCALE 696
4. BHANU VALVE .Vs. STATE DOJ : 18/04/2011 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -DAUGHTER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 SCR 769 = 2011 (4 ) JT 495 = 2011 (4 ) SCALE 762
5. K.K. VELUSAMY .Vs. N. PALANISAMY DOJ : 30/03/2011 JUDGEMENT
SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE -EVIDENCE -REOPENING -APPLICATION
Citation(s) 2011 (4 ) SCR 31 = 2011 (11 ) SCC 275 = 2011 (4 ) JT 38 = 2011 (4 ) SCALE 61
6. K.K. VELUSAMY .Vs. N. PALANISAMY DOJ : 30/03/2011 JUDGEMENT
CIVIL PROCEDURE -REOPENING -EVIDENCE -RECALL
Citation(s) 2011 (4 ) SCR 31 = 2011 (11 ) SCC 275 = 2011 (4 ) JT 38 = 2011 (4 ) SCALE 61
7. SUBRAMANI @ JEEVA @ KULLAJEEVA .Vs. S.H.O., ODIYANSALAI DOJ : 30/03/2011 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2011 SCR 25 = 2011 (5 ) JT 403 = 2011 (5 ) SCALE 139
8. STATE OF M.P. .Vs. RAMESH & ANR. DOJ : 18/03/2011 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CHILD WITNESS -EVIDENCE -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2011 (5 ) SCR 1 = 2011 (4 ) SCC 786 = 2011 (4 ) JT 62 = 2011 (3 ) SCALE 619
9. H. SIDDIQUI (D) BY LRS. .Vs. A. RAMALINGAM DOJ : 04/03/2011 JUDGEMENT
SPECIFIC RELIEF -EVIDENCE -SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE -SUIT
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 1492 = 2011 (5 ) SCR 587 = 2011 (4 ) SCC 240 = 2011 (3 ) JT 522 = 2011 (3
) SCALE 290
10. KILAKKATHA PARAMBATH SASI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 04/02/2011 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -INCONSISTENCY
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 1064 = 2011 (2 ) SCR 540 = 2011 (4 ) SCC 552 = 2011 (3 ) JT 70 = 2011 (2
) SCALE 213

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 20 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

11. KILAKKATHA PARAMBATH SASI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 04/02/2011 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 1064 = 2011 (2 ) SCR 540 = 2011 (4 ) SCC 552 = 2011 (3 ) JT 70 = 2011 (2
) SCALE 213
12. RABINDRA KUMAR PAL @ DARA SINGH .Vs. REPUBLIC OF INDIA DOJ : 21/01/2011 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 1436 = 2011 (1 ) SCR 929 = 2011 (2 ) SCC 490 = 2011 (1 ) JT 350 = 2011 (1
) SCALE 615
13. ALAMELU AND ANR .Vs. STATE REPRESENTED BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE DOJ : 18/01/2011 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -AGE OF VICTIM -SCHOOL TRANSFER CERTIFICATE -EVIDENTIARY VALUE
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 715 = 2011 (2 ) SCR 147 = 2011 (2 ) SCC 385 = 2011 (1 ) JT 265 = 2011 (1
) SCALE 575
14. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. CHHOTEYLAL DOJ : 14/01/2011 JUDGEMENT
NON APPLICATION OF MIND -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 697 = 2011 (1 ) SCR 406 = 2011 (2 ) SCC 550 = 2011 (1 ) JT 228 = 2011 (1
) SCALE 454
15. NARWINDER SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 05/01/2011 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -ABETMENT OF SUICIDE -NON MENTION OF THE PROVISION IN CHARGE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 686 = 2011 (1 ) SCR 110 = 2011 (2 ) SCC 47 = 2011 (1 ) JT 89 = 2011 (1
) SCALE 114
16. M. NAGESHWAR RAO .Vs. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH DOJ : 05/01/2011 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -SUSPICION -MURDER
Citation(s) 2011 (1 ) SCR 608 = 2011 (2 ) SCC 188 = 2011 (1 ) JT 31 = 2011 (1 ) SCALE 99
17. HIMANSHU @ CHINTU .Vs. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI DOJ : 04/01/2011 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2011 (1 ) SCR 48 = 2011 (2 ) SCC 36 = 2011 (1 ) JT 123 = 2011 (1 ) SCALE 30
18. HIMANSHU @ CHINTU .Vs. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI DOJ : 04/01/2011 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -HOSTILE WITNESS -ADMISSIBILITY IN EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 (1 ) SCR 48 = 2011 (2 ) SCC 36 = 2011 (1 ) JT 123 = 2011 (1 ) SCALE 30
19. SAROJ & ORS. .Vs. HET LAL & ORS. DOJ : 07/12/2010 JUDGEMENT
MOTOR VEHICLES -ACCIDENT -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 671 = 2010 (14 ) SCR 513 = 2011 (1 ) SCC 388 = 2010 (13 ) JT 739 = 2010 (13
) SCALE 185
20. GOPAL SWAROOP .Vs. KRISHNA MURARI MANGAL & ORS. DOJ : 25/11/2010 JUDGEMENT
WILL -EVIDENCE -UNPRIVILEGED WILLS -EXECUTION
Citation(s) 2010 (14 ) SCR 211 = 2010 (14 ) SCC 266 = 2011 (1 ) JT 195 = 2010 (12 ) SCALE 470
21. MONICA BEDI .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 09/11/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CRIMINAL CONSPIRACY -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 (13 ) SCR 522 = 2011 (1 ) SCC 284 = 2010 (12 ) JT 239 = 2010 (11 ) SCALE 629
22. SATYA NARAYAN TIWARI @ JOLLY & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 28/10/2010 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 (12 ) SCR 1137 = 2010 (13 ) SCC 689 = 2010 (12 ) JT 154 = 2010 (11 ) SCALE 481
23. RANJIT SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH DOJ : 27/10/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 255 = 2010 (14 ) SCR 133 = 2011 (4 ) SCC 336 = 2010 (12 ) JT 167 = 2010 (11
) SCALE 391
24. NARAYANA .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 05/10/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2010 (14 ) SCC 453 = 2010 (11 ) JT 29 = 2010 (10 ) SCALE 542
25. BRUNDABAN MOHARANA & ANR. .Vs. THE STATE OF ORISSA DOJ : 28/09/2010 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2010 (11 ) SCR 812 = 2010 (13 ) SCC 381 = 2010 (11 ) SCALE 692
26. SAQUIB ABDUL HAMEED NACHAN .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 11/08/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -POTA -CONFESSION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2010 (9 ) SCR 833 = 2010 (9 ) SCC 93 = 2010 (8 ) JT 355 = 2010 (8 ) SCALE 140
27. S. ARUL RAJA .Vs. STATE OF TAMIL NADU DOJ : 30/07/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MOTIVE -PROOF
Citation(s) 2010 (9 ) SCR 356 = 2010 (8 ) SCC 233 = 2010 (8 ) JT 158 = 2010 (7 ) SCALE 545
28. S. ARUL RAJA .Vs. STATE OF TAMIL NADU DOJ : 30/07/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2010 (9 ) SCR 356 = 2010 (8 ) SCC 233 = 2010 (8 ) JT 158 = 2010 (7 ) SCALE 545
29. PRITHI .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 27/07/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CORPUS DELICTI -MEANING
Citation(s) 2010 (9 ) SCR 33 = 2010 (8 ) SCC 536 = 2010 (7 ) JT 567 = 2010 (7 ) SCALE 344

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 21 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

30. SIDDANKI RAM REDDY .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 27/07/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -REVERSE
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 3000 = 2010 (8 ) SCR 1119 = 2010 (7 ) SCC 697 = 2010 (8 ) JT 48 = 2010 (7
) SCALE 332
31. VIJAY @ CHINEE .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 27/07/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -GANG RAPE -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 (8 ) SCR 1150 = 2010 (8 ) SCC 191 = 2010 (7 ) JT 576 = 2010 (7 ) SCALE 502
32. CHUNNI LAL .Vs. STATE OF UP DOJ : 05/07/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 2467 = 2010 (7 ) SCR 410 = 2010 (7 ) SCC 496 = 2010 (6 ) JT 400 = 2010 (6
) SCALE 204
33. NANHAR & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 11/06/2010 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2010 (7 ) SCR 384 = 2010 (11 ) SCC 423 = 2010 (6 ) JT 196 = 2010 (6 ) SCALE 178
34. DURGA PRASAD & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 14/05/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2010 (7 ) SCR 104 = 2010 (9 ) SCC 73 = 2010 (8 ) JT 228 = 2010 (6 ) SCALE 18
35. C. MAGESH & ORS. ETC. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 30/04/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -LABOUR DISPUTE -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 2768 = 2010 (5 ) SCR 623 = 2010 (5 ) SCC 645 = 2010 (4 ) JT 467 = 2010 (4
) SCALE 520
36. SIDHARTHA VASHISHT @ MANU SHARMA .Vs. STATE (NC T OF DELHI) DOJ : 19/04/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 2352 = 2010 (4 ) SCR 103 = 2010 (6 ) SCC 1 = 2010 (4 ) JT 107 = 2010 (4 ) SCALE 1
37. RAM BABU .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 19/04/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DACOITY -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 2143 = 2010 (4 ) SCR 771 = 2010 (5 ) SCC 63 = 2010 (4 ) JT 98 = 2010 (4
) SCALE 126
38. SANGAPPA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 09/03/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPEAL AGAINST ACQUITTAL -LIMITATION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 977 = 2010 (3 ) SCR 213 = 2010 (3 ) SCC 686 = 2010 (2 ) JT 479 = 2010 (2
) SCALE 713
39. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. GURU CHARAN & ORS. DOJ : 23/02/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 1459 = 2010 (2 ) SCR 1110 = 2010 (3 ) SCC 721 = 2010 (2 ) JT 462 = 2010 (2
) SCALE 554
40. KIRPAL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 23/02/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 (2 ) SCR 1133 = 2010 (3 ) SCC 347 = 2010 (2 ) JT 516 = 2010 (2 ) SCALE 593
41. SATYAVIR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 11/02/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ATTEMPT TO MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPEAL AGAINST ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2010 (2 ) SCR 729 = 2010 (3 ) SCC 174 = 2010 (2 ) JT 340 = 2010 (2 ) SCALE 313
42. TUKARAM S. DIHOLE .Vs. MANIKRAO SHIVAJI KOKATE DOJ : 05/02/2010 JUDGEMENT
ELECTION LAW -ALLEGATIONS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 965 = 2010 (2 ) SCR 396 = 2010 (4 ) SCC 329 = 2010 (1 ) JT 631 = 2010 (2
) SCALE 109
43. BODDELLA BABUL REDDY .Vs. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR HIGH COURT OF A.P. DOJ : 06/01/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONTRADICTIONS -DELAY IN FIR
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 3231 = 2010 (1 ) SCR 149 = 2010 (3 ) SCC 648 = 2010 (1 ) JT 24
44. HARI KISHAN .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 06/01/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -INJURED WITNESS -EVIDENCE -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 3215 = 2010 (1 ) SCR 134 = 2010 (2 ) SCC 131 = 2010 (1 ) JT 59
45. PANNEY @ PRATAP NARAIN SHUKLA & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 09/12/2009 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2010 (3 ) SCR 594 = 2010 (11 ) SCC 753 = 2010 (6 ) JT 193 = 2010 (3 ) SCALE 424
46. PANNEY @ PRATAP NARAIN SHUKLA & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 09/12/2009 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 (3 ) SCR 594 = 2010 (11 ) SCC 753 = 2010 (6 ) JT 193 = 2010 (3 ) SCALE 424
47. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. RAM SAJIVAN & ORS. DOJ : 04/12/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MASS MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 1738 = 2009 (16 ) SCR 154 = 2010 (1 ) SCC 529 = 2009 (14 ) JT 626 = 2009 (14
) SCALE 376
48. K.H. SHEKARAPPA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 03/12/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CUSTODIAL DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 (3 ) SCR 883 = 2009 (17 ) SCC 1 = 2010 (3 ) JT 660 = 2010 (3 ) SCALE 681

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 22 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

49. WAHID KHAN .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 01/12/2009 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -CORROBORATION
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 1 = 2009 (15 ) SCR 1207 = 2010 (2 ) SCC 9 = 2009 (14 ) JT 510 = 2009 (14
) SCALE 220
50. WAHID KHAN .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 01/12/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 1 = 2009 (15 ) SCR 1207 = 2010 (2 ) SCC 9 = 2009 (14 ) JT 510 = 2009 (14
) SCALE 220
51. JAYABALAN .Vs. U.T. OF PONDICHERRY DOJ : 06/11/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 (15 ) SCR 736 = 2010 (1 ) SCC 199 = 2009 (14 ) JT 401 = 2009 (13 ) SCALE 614
52. CHIKKARANGAIAH & ORS .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 02/09/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2646 = 2009 (17 ) SCC 497 = 2009 (11 ) JT 653 = 2009 (12 ) SCALE 146
53. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. NARESH @ RAM NARESH DOJ : 26/08/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -LAST SEEN TOGETHER
Citation(s) 2009 (13 ) SCR 589 = 2009 (9 ) SCC 368 = 2009 (11 ) JT 109 = 2009 (11 ) SCALE 699
54. MURLI & ANR .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 18/08/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 (13 ) SCR 378 = 2009 (9 ) SCC 417 = 2009 (12 ) JT 259 = 2009 (11 ) SCALE 512
55. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. RAJINDER SINGH DOJ : 11/08/2009 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 1428 = 2009 (13 ) SCR 609 = 2009 (15 ) SCC 612 = 2009 (12 ) JT 277 = 2009 (12
) SCALE 174
56. BHERU LAL & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 10/08/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -INTERESTED WITNESS -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 3208 = 2009 (13 ) SCR 212 = 2009 (9 ) SCC 119 = 2009 (11 ) JT 674 = 2009 (11
) SCALE 40
57. STATE OF M.P. .Vs. SHEETLA SAHAI & ORS. DOJ : 04/08/2009 JUDGEMENT
PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -HASDEO BANGO MASOORY DAM PROJECT -FRAMING OF CHARGES -
EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1744 = 2009 (12 ) SCR 1048 = 2009 (8 ) SCC 617 = 2009 (10 ) JT 388 = 2009 (10
) SCALE 632
58. CHAMPABEN GOVINDBHAI .Vs. POPATBHAI MANIILAL AND ORS DOJ : 31/07/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -MURDER -APPEAL AGAINST ACQUITTAL -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2231 = 2009 (11 ) SCR 776 = 2009 (13 ) SCC 662 = 2009 (10 ) JT 180 = 2009 (10
) SCALE 307
59. CHALLAMMA .Vs. TILAGA & ORS DOJ : 31/07/2009 JUDGEMENT
FAMILY LAW -INSURANCE CLAIM -MARITAL STATUS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 (11 ) SCR 831 = 2009 (9 ) SCC 299 = 2009 (10 ) JT 246 = 2009 (10 ) SCALE 511
60. M. YOGENDRA & ORS. .Vs. LEELAMMA N. & ORS. DOJ : 29/07/2009 JUDGEMENT
SUCCESSION LAW -HINDU SUCCESSION -EVIDENCE -VALID MARRIAGE
Citation(s) 2009 (12 ) SCR 38 = 2009 (15 ) SCC 184 = 2009 (15 ) JT 99 = 2009 (11 ) SCALE 166
61. PANTANGI BALARAMA VENKATA GANESH .Vs. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH DOJ : 23/07/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 3129 = 2009 (11 ) SCR 636 = 2009 (14 ) SCC 607 = 2009 (10 ) SCALE 69
62. SHANKER & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 16/07/2009 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2009 (17 ) SCC 702 = 2009 (13 ) SCALE 93
63. MALLAPPA SIDDAPPA ALAKANUR & ORS .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 07/07/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPEAL AGAINST ACQUITTAL -EVIDENCE -REAPPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2959 = 2009 (10 ) SCR 196 = 2009 (14 ) SCC 748 = 2009 (9 ) JT 33 = 2009 (9
) SCALE 159
64. PAYAPPAR SREE DHARMASASTHA TEMPLE A. COM. .Vs. A.K. JOSSEPH & ORS. DOJ : 07/07/2009 JUDGEMENT
CIVIL PROCEDURE -FIRST APPEAL -EVIDENCE -NON APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2009 (10 ) SCR 762 = 2009 (14 ) SCC 628 = 2009 (9 ) JT 367 = 2009 (9 ) SCALE 408
65. MUSAUDDIN AHMED .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 06/07/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 3813 = 2009 (14 ) SCC 541 = 2009 (9 ) JT 65 = 2009 (9 ) SCALE 155
66. BHAIRON SINGH .Vs. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH DOJ : 29/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ORAL EVIDENCE -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2603 = 2009 (13 ) SCC 80 = 2009 (7 ) JT 495 = 2009 (8 ) SCALE 634
67. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. SOHAN SINGH DOJ : 15/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -ILLEGAL GRATIFICATION -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1887 = 2009 (6 ) SCC 444 = 2009 (7 ) JT 355 = 2009 (8 ) SCALE 260

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 23 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

68. JAYENDRA VISHNU THAKUR .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER DOJ : 11/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -TADA -EVIDENCE -RECORDING
Citation(s) 2009 (8 ) SCR 591 = 2009 (7 ) SCC 104 = 2009 (8 ) JT 5 = 2009 (7 ) SCALE 757
69. JAYENDRA VISHNU THAKUR .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER DOJ : 11/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -RECORDING -ACCUSED -ABSENCE
Citation(s) 2009 (8 ) SCR 591 = 2009 (7 ) SCC 104 = 2009 (8 ) JT 5 = 2009 (7 ) SCALE 757
70. NINGAPPA YALLAPPA HOSAMANI AND ORS .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA & ORS DOJ : 08/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -STATEMENT -CONVICTION -MAINTAINABILITY
Citation(s) 2009 (8 ) SCR 421 = 2009 (14 ) SCC 582 = 2009 (8 ) JT 66 = 2009 (8 ) SCALE 59
71. BAKSHISH RAM & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 08/05/2009 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2717 = 2009 (6 ) SCC 561 = 2009 (6 ) JT 431 = 2009 (7 ) SCALE 231
72. BAKSHISH RAM & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 08/05/2009 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -CRUELTY -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2717 = 2009 (6 ) SCC 561 = 2009 (6 ) JT 431 = 2009 (7 ) SCALE 231
73. VALLABHANENI VENKATESHWARA RAO .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 08/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -VERACITY -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 (7 ) SCR 1210 = 2009 (6 ) SCC 484 = 2009 (8 ) JT 160 = 2009 (7 ) SCALE 678
74. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. SHOBHANATH & ORS. DOJ : 08/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2395 = 2009 (6 ) SCC 600 = 2009 (7 ) JT 234 = 2009 (8 ) SCALE 10
75. GURUNATH DONKAPPA KERI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 06/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1485 = 2009 (7 ) SCR 817 = 2009 (13 ) SCC 34 = 2009 (7 ) JT 361 = 2009 (7
) SCALE 482
76. GURUNATH DONKAPPA KERI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 06/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1485 = 2009 (7 ) SCR 817 = 2009 (13 ) SCC 34 = 2009 (7 ) JT 361 = 2009 (7
) SCALE 482
77. JAKIR .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 06/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2437 = 2009 (8 ) SCR 276 = 2009 (6 ) SCC 646 = 2009 (7 ) JT 557 = 2009 (7
) SCALE 677
78. SHRISHTI NARAIN JHA .Vs. BINDESHWAR JHA & ORS. DOJ : 05/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DACOITY -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2010 AIR 465 = 2009 (7 ) SCR 442 = 2009 (6 ) SCC 457 = 2009 (13 ) JT 674 = 2009 (7
) SCALE 1
79. AKULA VEERA VENKATA SURYA PRAKASH @ BABI .Vs. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF A.P. DOJ
: 05/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -SETTING ASIDE
Citation(s) 2009 (7 ) SCR 543 = 2009 (15 ) SCC 246 = 2009 (7 ) JT 230 = 2009 (6 ) SCALE 734
80. AKULA VEERA VENKATA SURYA PRAKASH @ BABI .Vs. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF A.P. DOJ
: 05/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2009 (7 ) SCR 543 = 2009 (15 ) SCC 246 = 2009 (7 ) JT 230 = 2009 (6 ) SCALE 734
81. STATE OF A.P. .Vs. V.V. PANDURANGA RAO DOJ : 04/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1449 = 2009 (7 ) SCR 421 = 2009 (15 ) SCC 211 = 2009 (7 ) JT 570 = 2009 (6
) SCALE 684
82. STATE OF A.P. .Vs. V.V. PANDURANGA RAO DOJ : 04/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1449 = 2009 (7 ) SCR 421 = 2009 (15 ) SCC 211 = 2009 (7 ) JT 570 = 2009 (6
) SCALE 684
83. HIMMAT SUKHADEO WAHURWAGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 01/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -REAPPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2292 = 2009 (7 ) SCR 364 = 2009 (6 ) SCC 712 = 2009 (6 ) JT 342 = 2009 (6
) SCALE 627
84. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. SHANTAPPA MADIVALAPPA GALAPUJI AND ORS. DOJ : 20/04/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CHILD WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 (6 ) SCR 729 = 2009 (12 ) SCC 731 = 2009 (5 ) JT 660 = 2009 (6 ) SCALE 68
85. KANTI LAL .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 17/04/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2703 = 2009 (6 ) SCR 525 = 2009 (12 ) SCC 498 = 2009 (5 ) JT 635 = 2009 (6
) SCALE 116

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 24 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

86. STATE OF ORISSA .Vs. PRASANNA KUMAR MOHANTY DOJ : 09/04/2009 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -CROSS EXAMINATION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1774 = 2009 (5 ) SCR 843 = 2009 (7 ) SCC 412 = 2009 (14 ) JT 159 = 2009 (6
) SCALE 110
87. SATYAPAL .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 08/04/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2190 = 2009 (5 ) SCR 577 = 2009 (6 ) SCC 635 = 2009 (5 ) JT 291 = 2009 (5
) SCALE 431
88. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. CHAMPA LAL DOJ : 01/04/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DEATH BY BURNING -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1808 = 2009 (5 ) SCR 463 = 2009 (12 ) SCC 571 = 2009 (5 ) JT 352 = 2009 (5
) SCALE 156
89. RAZAK JINNESAB KARAJAGI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 01/04/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 2009 (5 ) SCR 422 = 2009 (13 ) SCC 522 = 2009 (4 ) JT 667 = 2009 (5 ) SCALE 116
90. SATISH KUMAR BATRA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 01/04/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2180 = 2009 (5 ) SCR 451 = 2009 (12 ) SCC 491 = 2009 (5 ) JT 403 = 2009 (5
) SCALE 280
91. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. RAMA KANT & ORS. DOJ : 31/03/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2009 (7 ) SCR 233 = 2009 (14 ) SCC 213 = 2009 (7 ) JT 149 = 2009 (6 ) SCALE 540
92. SURESH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 27/02/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ATTEMPT TO MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1476 = 2009 (3 ) SCR 547 = 2009 (13 ) SCC 538 = 2009 (3 ) JT 163 = 2009 (4
) SCALE 222
93. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. DINESH DOJ : 25/02/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 272 = 2009 (2 ) SCR 1175 = 2009 (11 ) SCC 566 = 2009 (3 ) JT 106 = 2009 (3
) SCALE 345
94. MAHENDRA PRATAP SINGH .Vs. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH DOJ : 24/02/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 (2 ) SCR 1033 = 2009 (11 ) SCC 334 = 2009 (3 ) JT 120 = 2009 (3 ) SCALE 122
95. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. BANNE @ BAIJNATH & ORS. DOJ : 10/02/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPEAL AGAINST ACQUITTAL -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2009 (4 ) SCC 271 = 2009 (3 ) JT 552 = 2009 (3 ) SCALE 35
96. PREM KANWAR .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 07/01/2009 JUDGEMENT
DOWRY DEATH -SUICIDE -DETERMINATION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1242 = 2009 (1 ) SCR 37 = 2009 (3 ) SCC 726 = 2009 (1 ) JT 197 = 2009 (1
) SCALE 230
97. RAMDEO KAHAR & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 19/12/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1803 = 2008 (17 ) SCR 1364 = 2008 (17 ) SCC 517 = 2009 (2 ) JT 198 = 2009 (1
) SCALE 634
98. G. GNANAM @ GNANAMOORTHY .Vs. METROPOLITAN TRANSPORT CORPORATION DOJ
: 16/12/2008 JUDGEMENT
MOTOR VEHICLES -CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE -EVIDENCE -COMPENSATION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1166 = 2008 (17 ) SCR 767 = 2009 (2 ) SCC 71 = 2008 (13 ) JT 289 = 2008 (16
) SCALE 362
99. BHARPUR SINGH & ORS. .Vs. SHAMSHER SINGH DOJ : 12/12/2008 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -BILL -DOCUMENTS -PRESUMPTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1766 = 2008 (17 ) SCR 517 = 2009 (3 ) SCC 687 = 2009 (1 ) JT 590 = 2009 (1
) SCALE 481
100. TARSEM SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 12/12/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -PRESUMPTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1454 = 2008 (17 ) SCR 379 = 2008 (16 ) SCC 155 = 2008 (13 ) JT 185 = 2008 (16
) SCALE 148
101. INDRA PAL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 02/12/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 958 = 2008 (16 ) SCR 990 = 2008 (16 ) SCC 648 = 2008 (15 ) SCALE 400
102. BABASAHEB APPARAO PATIL .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 28/11/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1461 = 2008 (16 ) SCR 769 = 2008 (17 ) SCC 425 = 2009 (1 ) JT 55 = 2008 (15
) SCALE 205

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 25 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

103. SONU KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF H.P. DOJ : 22/10/2008 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -PARTICIPATION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 810 = 2008 SCR 1019 = 2008 (13 ) SCALE 646
104. ARJUN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF H.P. DOJ : 22/10/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -PARTICIPATION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 242 = 2008 SCR 1013 = 2008 (11 ) JT 369 = 2008 (13 ) SCALE 649
105. BAL KISHAN .Vs. STATE OF H.P. DOJ : 22/10/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -PARTICIPATION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 812 = 2008 (14 ) SCR 1026 = 2008 (16 ) SCC 11 = 2008 (13 ) SCALE 642
106. HANUMAN RAM .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN AND ORS. DOJ : 13/10/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -CROSS EXAMINATION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 69 = 2008 (14 ) SCR 348 = 2008 (15 ) SCC 652 = 2008 (11 ) JT 154 = 2008 (13
) SCALE 155
107. STATE OF A.P. .Vs. P. SATYANARAYANA MURTHY DOJ : 03/10/2008 JUDGEMENT
PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -BRIBE -EVIDENCE -RELIABLE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2008 (14 ) SCR 213 = 2008 (9 ) SCC 674 = 2008 (11 ) JT 95 = 2008 (13 ) SCALE 152
108. MUBARIK KHAN .Vs. NABABKHA @ NAWAB & ORS. DOJ : 01/10/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -HIGH COURTS
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 655 = 2008 (14 ) SCR 124 = 2008 (15 ) SCC 672 = 2008 (11 ) JT 127 = 2008 (13
) SCALE 151
109. STATE BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE, TAMILNADU .Vs. N. RAJAMANICKAM AND ORS. DOJ : 16/09/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ACQUITTAL -EVIDENCE -CREDIBILITY
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 802 = 2008 (13 ) SCR 596 = 2008 (13 ) SCC 303 = 2008 (10 ) JT 247 = 2008 (12
) SCALE 633
110. GUNNANA PENTAYYA @ PENTADU & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 20/08/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 940 = 2008 (12 ) SCR 342 = 2009 (16 ) SCC 59 = 2008 (9 ) JT 304 = 2008 (11
) SCALE 557
111. BALDEV SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 04/08/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 913 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 828 = 2008 (13 ) SCC 233 = 2008 (8 ) JT 690 = 2008 (11
) SCALE 120
112. DINESH SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 04/08/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CULPABLE HOMICIDE -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 711 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 801 = 2008 (15 ) SCC 745 = 2008 (8 ) JT 684 = 2008 (11
) SCALE 113
113. GODREJ PACIFIC TECH. LTD. .Vs. COMPUTER JOINT INDIA LTD. DOJ : 30/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -REEXAMINATION -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 591 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 571 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 108 = 2008 (10 ) SCALE 648
114. RAJBABU & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 24/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -SETTING ASIDE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 3212 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 270 = 2008 (17 ) SCC 526 = 2008 (8 ) JT 250 = 2008 (10
) SCALE 437
115. INSPECTOR OF POLICE T.N. .Vs. BALAPRASANNA DOJ : 21/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONFESSIONAL STATEMENT
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 648 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 31 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 645 = 2008 (8 ) JT 242 = 2008 (10
) SCALE 466
116. INSPECTOR OF POLICE T.N. .Vs. BALAPRASANNA DOJ : 21/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 648 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 31 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 645 = 2008 (8 ) JT 242 = 2008 (10
) SCALE 466
117. MOTI LAL .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 15/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 882 = 2008 (10 ) SCR 983 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 20 = 2008 (8 ) JT 271 = 2008 (10
) SCALE 81
118. DAMARA VENKATA MURALI KRISHNA RAO .Vs. GURUJUPALLI SATVATHAMMA DOJ : 14/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -RECOVERY -PROMISSORY NOTE -A.P.
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1381 = 2008 (10 ) SCR 933 = 2008 (12 ) SCC 170 = 2008 (10 ) SCALE 240
119. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. GAJANAN @ HEMANT JANARDHAN WANKHEDE DOJ : 09/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -NAGPUR
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 528 = 2008 (10 ) SCR 541 = 2008 (8 ) SCC 38 = 2008 (7 ) JT 491 = 2008 (9
) SCALE 802
120. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. BHAIYA LAL VERMA DOJ : 07/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -EVIDENCE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2831 = 2008 (10 ) SCR 123 = 2008 (15 ) SCC 161 = 2008 (7 ) JT 373

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 26 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

121. SYED PEDA AOWLIA .Vs. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR HIGH COURT OF A.P. HYDERABAD DOJ : 13/06/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -REVIEW -REMITTANCES
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2573 = 2008 (9 ) SCR 1151 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 394 = 2008 (9 ) SCALE 356
122. SYED PEDA AOWLIA .Vs. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR HIGH COURT OF A.P. HYDERABAD DOJ : 13/06/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -ACQUITTAL -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2573 = 2008 (9 ) SCR 1151 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 394 = 2008 (9 ) SCALE 356
123. PANNEERSELVAM .Vs. STATE OF TAMIL NADU DOJ : 15/05/2008 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -CONVICTION -MADRAS
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 508 = 2008 (8 ) SCR 962 = 2008 (17 ) SCC 190 = 2008 (6 ) JT 559 = 2008 (8
) SCALE 151
124. STATE OF M.P. & ANR. .Vs. ANSHUMAN SHUKLA DOJ : 12/05/2008 JUDGEMENT
LIMITATION -ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION -REFERRED LARGER BENCH -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2454 = 2008 (8 ) SCR 349 = 2008 (7 ) SCC 487 = 2008 (8 ) SCALE 425
125. T. NAGAPPA .Vs. Y.R. MURALIDHAR DOJ : 24/04/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS -DEFENCE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2010 = 2008 (6 ) SCR 959 = 2008 (5 ) SCC 633 = 2008 (6 ) JT 153 = 2008 (6
) SCALE 642
126. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. LALA @ ABDUL SALAM DOJ : 21/02/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -SITE OF INCIDENT CHANGED
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1497 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 145 = 2008 (3 ) JT 69 = 2008 (2 ) SCALE 692
127. N. SRIHARI (D) THROUGH LRS. & ORS. .Vs. N. PRAKASH & ORS. DOJ : 19/02/2008 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -SUIT -A.P.
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1548 = 2008 (3 ) SCR 62 = 2008 (4 ) SCC 683 = 2008 (3 ) JT 255 = 2008 (2
) SCALE 709
128. SHER SINGH & ANR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 15/02/2008 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -ADMISSIBILITY -PUNJAB & HARYANA
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1426 = 2008 (2 ) SCR 959 = 2008 (4 ) SCC 265 = 2008 (2 ) JT 423 = 2008 (2
) SCALE 492
129. SHAIKH RAFIQ & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 22/01/2008 ORDER
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -RELIABILITY -AURANGABAD
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1362 = 2008 (1 ) SCR 1100 = 2008 (3 ) SCC 691 = 2008 (1 ) SCALE 653
130. NEEBHA KAPOOR .Vs. JAYANTILAL KHANDWALA & ORS. DOJ : 22/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -SUMMARY SUIT -EVIDENCE -BOMBAY MUMBAI
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1117 = 2008 (1 ) SCR 1012 = 2008 (3 ) SCC 770 = 2008 (2 ) JT 29 = 2008 (1
) SCALE 575
131. VIKAS & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 21/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -BRIDE BURNING -HOSTILE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2008 (1 ) SCR 933 = 2008 (2 ) SCC 516 = 2008 (1 ) JT 541 = 2008 (1 ) SCALE 545
132. SAMBHAJI HINDURAO DESHMUKH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 17/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2008 (11 ) SCC 186 = 2008 (1 ) JT 569 = 2008 (1 ) SCALE 499
133. KUNJU @ BALACHANDRAN .Vs. STATE OF TAMIL NADU DOJ : 16/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1381 = 2008 (1 ) SCR 781 = 2008 (2 ) SCC 151 = 2008 (1 ) JT 450 = 2008 (1
) SCALE 479
134. TULSA & ORS. .Vs. DURGHATIYA & ORS. DOJ : 15/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -SALE DEED -SETTING ASIDE -PERMANENT INJUNCTION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1193 = 2008 (1 ) SCR 709 = 2008 (4 ) SCC 520 = 2008 (1 ) SCALE 432
135. VIJAY SHANKAR SHINDE & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 15/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1198 = 2008 (1 ) SCR 705 = 2008 (2 ) SCC 670 = 2008 (1 ) SCALE 379
136. GAUDIYA MISSION .Vs. SHOBHA BOSE & ANR. DOJ : 15/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
SUCCESSION -EVIDENCE -STATUTORY APPEAL -DISMISSAL
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1012 = 2008 (1 ) SCR 674 = 2008 (17 ) SCC 714 = 2008 (1 ) JT 384 = 2008 (1
) SCALE 390
137. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. JAGGU RAM DOJ : 04/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 982 = 2008 (12 ) SCC 51 = 2008 (1 ) JT 199 = 2008 (1 ) SCALE 22
138. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. JAGGU RAM DOJ : 04/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 982 = 2008 (12 ) SCC 51 = 2008 (1 ) JT 199 = 2008 (1 ) SCALE 22
139. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. PUNNI & ORS. DOJ : 04/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 932 = 2008 (1 ) SCR 85 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 153 = 2008 (1 ) JT 164 = 2008 (1
) SCALE 43

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 27 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

140. RAM PAL & ANR .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 14/12/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -COMMON INTENTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 244 = 2007 (13 ) SCR 789 = 2007 (15 ) SCC 79 = 2008 (1 ) JT 11 = 2007 (14
) SCALE 394
141. RAM PAL & ANR .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 14/12/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 244 = 2007 (13 ) SCR 789 = 2007 (15 ) SCC 79 = 2008 (1 ) JT 11 = 2007 (14
) SCALE 394
142. UJJAGAR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 13/12/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 190 = 2007 (13 ) SCR 653 = 2007 (13 ) SCC 90 = 2008 (1 ) JT 1 = 2007 (14
) SCALE 428
143. KESHAV .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 12/12/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -SETTING ASIDE
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1150 = 2007 (13 ) SCR 264 = 2007 (13 ) SCC 284 = 2007 (14 ) SCALE 174
144. SARABJIT RICK SINGH .Vs. UNION OF INDIA DOJ : 12/12/2007 JUDGEMENT
EXTRADITION -MAGISTRATE -INQUIRY -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 368 = 2007 (13 ) SCR 321 = 2008 (2 ) SCC 417 = 2007 (14 ) SCALE 263
145. GURUNATH MANOHAR PAVASKAR & ORS .Vs. NAGESH SIDDAPPA NAVALGUND & ORS DOJ
: 11/12/2007 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -BURDEN OF PROOF -REVENUE RECORD
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 901 = 2007 (13 ) SCR 77 = 2007 (13 ) SCC 565 = 2007 (14 ) SCALE 283
146. DISTRICT BASIC EDUCATION OFFICER .Vs. DHANANJAI KUMAR SHUKLA AND ANR. DOJ
: 07/12/2007 JUDGEMENT
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA -RECRUITMENT -EVIDENCE -QUALIFICATIONS
Citation(s) 2007 (13 ) SCR 972 = 2008 (3 ) SCC 481 = 2008 (1 ) JT 508 = 2008 (1 ) SCALE 396
147. PARAMJIT SINGH @ MITHU SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB THROUGH SECRETARY (HOME) DOJ
: 31/10/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 441 = 2007 (11 ) SCR 776 = 2007 (13 ) SCC 530 = 2007 (12 ) SCALE 728
148. MANILAL HIRAMAN CHAUDHARI .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 09/10/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 161 = 2007 (10 ) SCR 817 = 2007 (12 ) SCC 521 = 2007 (11 ) JT 618 = 2007 (11
) SCALE 736
149. MOHTESHAM MOHD ISMAIL .Vs. SPL DIRECTOR ENFORCEMENT DIRECTORATE & ANR DOJ
: 09/10/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -FOREIGN EXCHANGE -EVIDENCE -CONFESSION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1656 = 2007 (10 ) SCR 804 = 2007 (8 ) SCC 254 = 2007 (12 ) JT 41 = 2007 (11
) SCALE 741
150. HARIOM AGRAWAL .Vs. PRAKASH CHAND MALVIYA DOJ : 08/10/2007 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -STAMP DUTY -EVIDENCE -M.P.
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 166 = 2007 (10 ) SCR 772 = 2007 (8 ) SCC 514 = 2007 (12 ) JT 49 = 2007 (11
) SCALE 705
151. RADHU .Vs. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH DOJ : 14/09/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2007 (12 ) SCC 57 = 2007 (11 ) JT 91 = 2007 (11 ) SCALE 96
152. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. RAJU DOJ : 14/09/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 3225 = 2007 (9 ) SCR 970 = 2007 (11 ) SCC 490 = 2007 (11 ) JT 397 = 2007 (11
) SCALE 114
153. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. PARTHU DOJ : 13/09/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 10 = 2007 (9 ) SCR 932 = 2007 (12 ) SCC 754 = 2007 (11 ) JT 513 = 2007 (11
) SCALE 460
154. HARISHCHANDRA LADAKU THANGE .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 30/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 2957 = 2007 (9 ) SCR 562 = 2007 (11 ) SCC 436 = 2007 (10 ) JT 496 = 2007 (10
) SCALE 464
155. RAGHUNANDAN .Vs. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH DOJ : 27/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 2973 = 2007 (9 ) SCR 475 = 2007 (9 ) SCC 347 = 2007 (10 ) JT 431 = 2007 (10
) SCALE 353
156. SUBHASH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 21/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ROBBERY -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 448 = 2007 (12 ) SCC 63 = 2007 (10 ) JT 516 = 2007 (10 ) SCALE 105

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 28 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

157. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. TULSHIRAM BHANUDAS KAMBLE & ORS DOJ : 21/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 3042 = 2007 (9 ) SCR 185 = 2007 (14 ) SCC 627 = 2007 (10 ) JT 597 = 2007 (10
) SCALE 166
158. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. TULSHIRAM BHANUDAS KAMBLE & ORS DOJ : 21/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TRESPASS -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 3042 = 2007 (9 ) SCR 185 = 2007 (14 ) SCC 627 = 2007 (10 ) JT 597 = 2007 (10
) SCALE 166
159. KITTUSAMY .Vs. STATE OF TAMIL NADU DOJ : 13/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 2796 = 2007 (8 ) SCR 1000 = 2007 (11 ) SCC 238 = 2007 (10 ) JT 175 = 2007 (10
) SCALE 7
160. RAJENDRA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U P & ANR DOJ : 06/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 2786 = 2007 (8 ) SCR 834 = 2007 (7 ) SCC 378 = 2007 (9 ) JT 613 = 2007 (9
) SCALE 593
161. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. NANA & ORS DOJ : 02/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2007 (8 ) SCR 771 = 2007 (9 ) SCC 398 = 2007 (10 ) JT 52 = 2007 (9 ) SCALE 545
162. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. MADESHA & ORS DOJ : 01/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DISAPPEARANCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 (8 ) SCR 757 = 2007 (7 ) SCC 35 = 2007 (10 ) JT 54 = 2007 (9 ) SCALE 523
163. MEHIBOOBSAB ABBASABI NADAF .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 01/08/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DEATH BY BURNING -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 2666 = 2007 (8 ) SCR 713 = 2007 (13 ) SCC 112 = 2007 (10 ) JT 62 = 2007 (9
) SCALE 473
164. IDDAR & ORS .Vs. AABIDA & ANR DOJ : 25/07/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -RECORDING OF STATEMENT -EVIDENCE -RAJASTHAN
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 3029 = 2007 (8 ) SCR 518 = 2007 (11 ) SCC 211 = 2007 (9 ) JT 552 = 2007 (9
) SCALE 358
165. ARVIND KUMAR & ANR .Vs. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH DOJ : 24/07/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 2674 = 2007 (8 ) SCR 474 = 2007 (12 ) SCC 681 = 2007 (9 ) JT 398 = 2007 (9
) SCALE 325
166. KULWANT SINGH @ KULBANSH SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 21/06/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2007 (7 ) SCR 1178 = 2007 (15 ) SCC 670 = 2007 (9 ) JT 250 = 2007 (8 ) SCALE 655
167. SWAMY SHRADDANANDA @ MURALI MANOHAR MISHRA .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ
: 18/05/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 2531 = 2007 (7 ) SCR 616 = 2007 (12 ) SCC 288 = 2007 (7 ) JT 403 = 2007 (8
) SCALE 1
168. BENGA BEHERA & ANR. .Vs. BRAJA KISHORE NANDA & ORS. DOJ : 15/05/2007 JUDGEMENT
WILL -EVIDENCE -REGISTRATION -SUCCESSION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1975 = 2007 (6 ) SCR 853 = 2007 (9 ) SCC 728 = 2007 (8 ) JT 86 = 2007 (7
) SCALE 228
169. RAVI @ RAVICHANDRAN .Vs. STATE REP BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE DOJ : 27/04/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION PARADE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1729 = 2007 (5 ) SCR 766 = 2007 (15 ) SCC 372 = 2007 (7 ) JT 55 = 2007 (6
) SCALE 216
170. ABDULVAHAB ABDULMAJID SHAIKH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 24/04/2007 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CONFESSION -VOLUNTARY NATURE -DETERMINATION
Citation(s) 2007 (5 ) SCR 538 = 2007 (4 ) SCC 257 = 2007 (6 ) SCALE 127
171. J. YASHODA .Vs. K. SHOBHA RANI DOJ : 19/04/2007 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -SECONDARY EVIDENCE -ADMISSIBILITY -A P
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1721 = 2007 (5 ) SCR 367 = 2007 (5 ) SCC 730 = 2007 (6 ) JT 64 = 2007 (6
) SCALE 6
172. RAMA PASWAN & ORS .Vs. STATE OF JHARKHAND DOJ : 13/04/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -EXAMINATION
Citation(s) 2007 (5 ) SCR 83 = 2007 (11 ) SCC 191 = 2007 (9 ) JT 336 = 2007 (5 ) SCALE 646
173. GAJANAND AGARWAL .Vs. STATE OF ORISSA AND ANR DOJ : 12/04/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -BAIL -EVIDENCE -EXAMINATION
Citation(s) 2007 (5 ) SCR 68 = 2007 (14 ) SCC 537 = 2007 (5 ) SCALE 639

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 29 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

174. BISWAJIT HALDER @ BABU HALDER & ORS .Vs. STATE OF WEST BENGAL DOJ : 19/03/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -W B
Citation(s) 2007 (4 ) SCR 120 = 2008 (1 ) SCC 202 = 2007 (5 ) JT 360 = 2007 (4 ) SCALE 462
175. NAMDEO .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 13/03/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -BOMBAY MUMBAI
Citation(s) 2007 (3 ) SCR 939 = 2007 (14 ) SCC 150 = 2007 (4 ) JT 618 = 2007 (4 ) SCALE 337
176. RAMESH CHANDER SINGH .Vs. HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD & ANR DOJ : 26/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
BAIL -EVIDENCE -MURDER -ALLAHABAD
Citation(s) 2007 (3 ) SCR 198 = 2007 (4 ) SCC 247 = 2007 (4 ) JT 135 = 2007 (3 ) SCALE 559
177. SHAJAHAN & ORS .Vs. STATE OF KERALA & ANR DOJ : 26/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -KERALA
Citation(s) 2007 (3 ) SCR 212 = 2007 (12 ) SCC 96 = 2007 (3 ) SCALE 618
178. VIVIDH MARBLES PVT LTD .Vs. COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER DOJ : 23/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -ESTOPPEL -INCENTIVE SCHEME -RAJASTHAN
Citation(s) 2007 (3 ) SCR 140 = 2007 (3 ) SCC 580 = 2007 (4 ) JT 448 = 2007 (3 ) SCALE 487
179. BHANDARI CONSTRUCTION COMPANY .Vs. NARAYAN GOPAL UPADHYE DOJ : 20/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
CONSUMER PROTECTION -BURDEN OF PROOF -EVIDENCE -COST
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1441 = 2007 (2 ) SCR 924 = 2007 (3 ) SCC 163 = 2007 (3 ) SCALE 386
180. KALEGURA PADMA RAO & ANR .Vs. THE STATE OF A P REP BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR DOJ
: 19/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CULPABLE HOMICIDE
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1299 = 2007 (2 ) SCR 781 = 2007 (12 ) SCC 48 = 2007 (3 ) JT 513 = 2007 (3
) SCALE 209
181. MANJUNATH CHENNABASAPA MADALLI .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 19/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 2080 = 2007 (2 ) SCR 795 = 2007 (9 ) SCC 160 = 2007 (3 ) JT 550 = 2007 (3
) SCALE 226
182. RAM SINGH .Vs. SONIA & ORS DOJ : 15/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CRIMINAL TRIAL -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1218 = 2007 (2 ) SCR 651 = 2007 (3 ) SCC 1 = 2007 (3 ) JT 287 = 2007 (3
) SCALE 106
183. JAKKI @ SELVARAJ AND ANR .Vs. STATE REP BY THE IP COIMBATORE DOJ : 14/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -RITUAL COMPETITION
Citation(s) 2007 (2 ) SCR 584 = 2007 (9 ) SCC 589 = 2007 (3 ) JT 344 = 2007 (3 ) SCALE 166
184. DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER GSRTC .Vs. KADARBHAI J SUTHAR DOJ : 13/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EVIDENCE -PENOLOGY
Citation(s) 2007 (2 ) SCR 550 = 2007 (10 ) SCC 561 = 2007 (8 ) JT 564 = 2007 (3 ) SCALE 39
185. SHIVU AND ANR .Vs. R G HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AND ANR DOJ : 13/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EVIDENCE -PENOLOGY
Citation(s) 2007 (2 ) SCR 555 = 2007 (4 ) SCC 713 = 2007 (3 ) JT 333 = 2007 (3 ) SCALE 157
186. BISHNU PRASAD SINHA & ANR .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 16/01/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 848 = 2007 (1 ) SCR 916 = 2007 (11 ) SCC 467 = 2007 (2 ) JT 428 = 2007 (2
) SCALE 42
187. JAMEEL .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 16/01/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -JUVENILE JUSTICES -EVIDENCE -UNNATURAL OFFENCE
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 971 = 2007 (1 ) SCR 946 = 2007 (11 ) SCC 420 = 2007 (3 ) JT 237 = 2007 (2
) SCALE 32
188. VIRENDRA KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 16/01/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -SUICIDE -DEATH
Citation(s) 2007 (1 ) SCR 970 = 2007 (9 ) SCC 211 = 2007 (2 ) JT 452 = 2007 (2 ) SCALE 103
189. BISHNU PRASAD SINHA & ANR .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 16/01/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -RAPE -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 848 = 2007 (1 ) SCR 916 = 2007 (11 ) SCC 467 = 2007 (2 ) JT 428 = 2007 (2
) SCALE 42
190. NIRANJAN UMESHCHANDRA JOSHI .Vs. MRUDULA JYOTI RAO & ORS DOJ : 15/12/2006 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -PROOF -EXECUTION OF WILL -BURDEN OF PROOF
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 614 = 2006 (10 ) Suppl. SCR 1214 = 2006 (13 ) SCC 433 = 2007 (1 ) JT 466 = 2006
(14 ) SCALE 186
191. AVTAR SINGH & ORS .Vs. GURDIAL SINGH & ORS DOJ : 04/12/2006 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -PROOF -ADMISSION
Citation(s) 2006 (10 ) Suppl. SCR 33 = 2006 (12 ) SCC 552 =
192. LANKESWAR MALAKAR AND ORS .Vs. R. DEKA AND ORS DOJ : 30/11/2006 ORDER
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -SECOND APPEAL -EVIDENCE -GAUHATI
Citation(s) 2006 (9 ) Suppl. SCR 895 = 2006 (13 ) SCC 570 = 2006 (14 ) SCALE 46

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 30 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

193. BASO PRASAD & ORS .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 24/11/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1019 = 2006 (9 ) Suppl. SCR 431 = 2006 (13 ) SCC 65 = 2006 (12 ) SCALE 354
194. KARUPPUSAMY & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 29/09/2006 JUDGEMENT
ONUS OF PROOF -RIGHT OF PRIVATE DEFENCE -EVIDENCE -MADRAS
Citation(s) 2006 (6 ) Suppl. SCR 785 = 2006 (11 ) SCC 459 = 2006 (9 ) SCALE 716
195. S. CHINNASAMY , R. SOUNDARARAJAN .Vs. SEED INSPECTOR , COIMBATORE & ANR. DOJ
: 29/09/2006 JUDGEMENT
ESSENTIAL COMMODITIES -INVESTIGATION -EVIDENCE -SEEDS
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 109 = 2006 (6 ) Suppl. SCR 918 = 2006 (11 ) SCC 486 = 2006 (9 ) JT 1 = 2006 (10
) SCALE 7
196. SHAM SHANKAR KANKARIA .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 01/09/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 2006 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 709 = 2006 (13 ) SCC 165 = 2006 (8 ) JT 538 =
197. SHAM SHANKAR KANKARIA .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 01/09/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -COMMON INTENTION -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 709 = 2006 (13 ) SCC 165 = 2006 (8 ) JT 538 =
198. RAM BADAN SHARMA .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 21/08/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -DISAPPEARANCE
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 2855 = 2006 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 795 = 2006 (10 ) SCC 115 = 2006 (7 ) JT 490 = 2006 (8
) SCALE 210
199. STATE BANK OF INDIA .Vs. RAMESH DINKAR PUNDE DOJ : 11/08/2006 JUDGEMENT
SERVICE LAW -MISCONDUCT -EVIDENCE -REAPPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2006 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 511 = 2006 (7 ) SCC 212 = 2006 (7 ) JT 383 = 2006 (8 ) SCALE 11
200. RAJENDRA & ORS .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 27/07/2006 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -RECORDING -AUTHORITY
Citation(s) 2006 (10 ) SCC 759 = 2006 (7 ) SCALE 662
201. AMRIT VANASPATI CO LTD .Vs. KHEM CHAND & ANR DOJ : 12/07/2006 JUDGEMENT
LABOUR LAW -EVIDENCE -ABDUCTION -COURT POWER
Citation(s) 200 AIR 2739 = 2006 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 481 = 2006 (6 ) SCC 325 = 2006 (6 ) JT 436 = 2006 (7
) SCALE 229
202. STATE BANK OF INDIA & ANR. .Vs. MULA SAHAKARI SAKHAR KARKHANA LTD. DOJ : 06/07/2006 JUDGEMENT
CONTRACT -EVIDENCE -INDEMNITY -DOCUMENT
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 2361 = 2006 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 320 = 2006 (6 ) SCC 293 = 2006 (6 ) JT 152 = 2006 (6
) SCALE 600
203. PANAKANTI SAMPATH RAO .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 18/05/2006 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2006 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 765 = 2006 (9 ) SCC 658 = 2006 (7 ) JT 253 = 2006 (6 ) SCALE 142
204. RAVINDER SINGH GORKIN .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 12/05/2006 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CRIMINAL TRIAL -JUVENILE JUSTICES -ALLAHABAD
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 2157 = 2006 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 615 = 2006 (5 ) SCC 584 = 2006 (5 ) JT 468 = 2006 (5
) SCALE 682
205. NIRA RADIA .Vs. DHEERAJ SINGH AND ANR DOJ : 10/05/2006 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -BAIL -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 (9 ) SCC 760 =
206. SAHEBRAO & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 03/05/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CRUELTY -SUICIDE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 2002 = 2006 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 737 = 2006 (9 ) SCC 794 = 2006 (11 ) JT 260 = 2006 (5
) SCALE 172
207. ANIL RISHI .Vs. GURBAKSH SINGH DOJ : 02/05/2006 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -BURDEN OF PROOF -SALE DEED -SUIT FOR DECLARATION
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 1971 = 2006 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 659 = 2006 (5 ) SCC 558 = 2006 (11 ) JT 521 = 2006 (5
) SCALE 153
208. ANIL RISHI .Vs. GURBAKSH SINGH DOJ : 02/05/2006 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -BURDEN OF PROOF -REVERSAL
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 1971 = 2006 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 659 = 2006 (5 ) SCC 558 = 2006 (11 ) JT 521 = 2006 (5
) SCALE 153
209. BUDHAN SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 25/04/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -NON APPEARANCE
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 1959 = 2006 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 261 = 2006 (4 ) SCC 740 = 2006 (11 ) JT 365 = 2006 (4
) SCALE 570
210. COMMISSIONER OF POLICE NEW DELHI .Vs. NARENDER SINGH DOJ : 05/04/2006 JUDGEMENT
SERVICE LAW -MISCONDUCT -EVIDENCE -TERMINATION
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 1800 = 2006 (3 ) SCR 872 = 2006 (4 ) SCC 265 = 2006 (4 ) JT 328 = 2006 (4
) SCALE 161

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 31 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

211. T. ARUNTPERUNJOTHI .Vs. STATE THRU S.H.O. PONDICHERRY DOJ : 05/04/2006 JUDGEMENT
DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -SETTING ASIDE
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 2475 = 2006 (3 ) SCR 799 = 2006 (9 ) SCC 467 = 2006 (4 ) JT 300 = 2006 (4
) SCALE 103
212. T. ARUNTPERUNJOTHI .Vs. STATE THRU S.H.O. PONDICHERRY DOJ : 05/04/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 2475 = 2006 (3 ) SCR 799 = 2006 (9 ) SCC 467 = 2006 (4 ) JT 300 = 2006 (4
) SCALE 103
213. DIRECTOR VOCATIONAL EDUCATION & TRAINING AND ANR. .Vs. NASHIM SHAIKH CHAND DOJ
: 27/03/2006 ORDER
LABOUR LAW -INDUSTRIAL DISPUTE -CONTINUOUS SERVICE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 (10 ) SCC 301 =
214. CHURCH OF SOUTH INDIA TRUST ASSN .Vs. LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER AND TEHSILDAR DOJ
: 02/03/2006 ORDER
LAND ACQUISITION -CERTIFIED COPY -EVIDENCE -ACCEPTANCE
Citation(s) 2006 (9 ) SCC 676 =
215. RAVIKUMAR @ KUTTI RAVI .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 22/02/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 1448 = 2006 (9 ) SCC 240 = 2006 (2 ) JT 555 = 2006 (2 ) SCALE 449
216. YERUMALLA LATCHAIAH .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 21/02/2006 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2006 (9 ) SCC 713 =
217. BANSRAJ LALTAPRASAD MISHRA .Vs. STANLEY PARKER JONES DOJ : 16/02/2006 JUDGEMENT
PROPERTY LAW -EVIDENCE -SUIT FOR POSSESSION -BOMBAY MUMBAI
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 3569 = 2006 (2 ) SCR 334 = 2006 (3 ) SCC 91 = 2006 (3 ) JT 480 = 2006 (2
) SCALE 471
218. STATE OF A.P. .Vs. S. RAYAPPA & ORS. DOJ : 14/02/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -RELATED WITNESS
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 3709 = 2006 (2 ) SCR 200 = 2006 (4 ) SCC 512 = 2006 (2 ) JT 392 = 2006 (2
) SCALE 321
219. STATE OF A.P. .Vs. S. RAYAPPA & ORS. DOJ : 14/02/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 3709 = 2006 (2 ) SCR 200 = 2006 (4 ) SCC 512 = 2006 (2 ) JT 392 = 2006 (2
) SCALE 321
220. STATE OF A.P. .Vs. S. RAYAPPA & ORS. DOJ : 14/02/2006 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -RELATED WITNESS -ADMISSIBILITY -TESTIMONY
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 3709 = 2006 (2 ) SCR 200 = 2006 (4 ) SCC 512 = 2006 (2 ) JT 392 = 2006 (2
) SCALE 321
221. NISAR KHAN @ GUDDU & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF UTTARANCHAL DOJ : 25/01/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2006 (9 ) SCC 386 = 2006 (2 ) JT 262 = 2006 (2 ) SCALE 25
222. SIVAKUMAR .Vs. STATE BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE DOJ : 08/12/2005 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -RECORDING -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 653 = 2005 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 578 = 2006 (1 ) SCC 714 = 2005 (10 ) JT 379 = 2005 (10
) SCALE 75
223. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. CHATUR SINGH DOJ : 17/11/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOUBLE MURDER -EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 745 = 2005 (13 ) SCC 360 = 2005 (10 ) JT 302 = 2005 (9 ) SCALE 444
224. PARBATA .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 16/11/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 747 = 2005 (13 ) SCC 398 = 2005 (10 ) JT 314 = 2005 (9 ) SCALE 544
225. RAJAN RAI .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 10/11/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 433 = 2005 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 128 = 2006 (1 ) SCC 191 = 2005 (9 ) JT 518 = 2005 (9
) SCALE 260
226. TRILOKI NATH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 28/10/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -SELF DEFENCE
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 321 = 2005 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 931 = 2005 (13 ) SCC 323 = 2005 (9 ) JT 370 = 2005 (9
) SCALE 76
227. SURENDRANAGAR DISTRICT .Vs. JETHABHAT PITAMBERBHAI DOJ : 25/10/2005 JUDGEMENT
LABOUR LAW -EVIDENCE -ADVERSE INFERENCE -SUSTAINABILITY
Citation(s) 2005 (8 ) SCC 450 = 2005 (9 ) JT 163 = 2005 (8 ) SCALE 627
228. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. GANGA RAM & ORS. DOJ : 25/10/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 20 = 2005 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 524 = 2005 (13 ) SCC 239 = 2005 (9 ) JT 362 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 32 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

229. STATE THROUGH INSPECTOR OF POLICE A.P. .Vs. K. NARASIMHACHARY DOJ : 07/10/2005 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DOCUMENT -HANDWRITING
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 628 = 2005 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 197 = 2005 (8 ) SCC 364 = 2005 (12 ) JT 553
230. SARUP SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 04/10/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 4345 = 2005 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 965 = 2005 (12 ) SCC 591 = 2005 (12 ) JT 340
231. TIRATH KUMARI @ RAJ RANI .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 04/10/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 4429 = 2005 (12 ) SCC 561 = 2005 (10 ) JT 451 = 2005 (8 ) SCALE 328
232. BECHARA KORA MODI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 20/09/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -SOLE WITNESS -TESTIMONY
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 638 = 2005 (13 ) SCC 395 = 2005 (8 ) JT 410 = 2005 (7 ) SCALE 455
233. SANATAN RANA .Vs. STATE OF JHARKHAND DOJ : 19/09/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DACOITY WITH MURDER -EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 3532 = 2005 (12 ) SCC 596 = 2005 (8 ) JT 391 = 2005 (7 ) SCALE 353
234. SATBIR SINGH & ORS .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 14/09/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 3546 = 2005 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 182 = 2005 (12 ) SCC 72 = 2005 (8 ) JT 394
235. JITENDRA SINGH .Vs. MANGE RAM & ANR DOJ : 12/09/2005 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -BAIL -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 (13 ) SCC 392 =
236. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. HAKAM SINGH DOJ : 31/08/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 3759 = 2005 (7 ) SCC 408 = 2005 (8 ) JT 68 = 2005 (7 ) SCALE 43
237. PEERAPPA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 09/08/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -COMMON OBJECT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 (12 ) SCC 461 = 2005 (7 ) JT 282 = 2005 (6 ) SCALE 358
238. K. VENGADACHALAM .Vs. K.C. PALANISAMY DOJ : 08/08/2005 ORDER
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -FORGERY -EVIDENCE -DOCUMENT
Citation(s) 2005 (7 ) SCC 352 =
239. STATE (N.C.T. OF DELHI) .Vs. NAVJOT SANDHU @ AFSAN GURU DOJ : 04/08/2005 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CONFESSION -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT -IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 3820 = 2005 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 79 = 2005 (11 ) SCC 600 = 2005 (7 ) JT 1
240. GHANASHYAM DAS .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 27/07/2005 ORDER
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -ORAL DYING DECLARATION -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2005 (13 ) SCC 387 =
241. JAGDISH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 12/05/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ATTEMPT TO MURDER -COMMON INTENTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2576 = 2005 (11 ) SCC 146 = 2005 (5 ) JT 579 = 2005 (5 ) SCALE 258
242. SEEMAN @ VEERANAM .Vs. STATE BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE DOJ : 12/05/2005 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2503 = 2005 (11 ) SCC 142 = 2005 (5 ) JT 555 = 2005 (5 ) SCALE 194
243. MISHRILAL & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. & ORS. DOJ : 11/05/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2005 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 259 = 2005 (10 ) SCC 701 = 2005 (5 ) JT 559 = 2005 (5 ) SCALE 144
244. MAHENDRA SINGH .Vs. GULAB DOJ : 10/05/2005 JUDGEMENT
ELECTION LAW -CORRUPT PRACTICE -EVIDENCE -CANDIDATE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2515 = 2005 (4 ) SCC 522 = 2005 (5 ) SCALE 83
245. K. RAHEJA DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 05/05/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2350 = 2005 (3 ) SCR 1210 = 2005 (5 ) SCC 162 = 2005 (5 ) JT 161 = 2005 (4
) SCALE 668
246. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. SHIV KUMAR DOJ : 20/04/2005 JUDGEMENT
MURDER -EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2992 = 2005 (11 ) SCC 212 = 2005 (5 ) JT 550 = 2005 (4 ) SCALE 379
247. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. GAMBHIR SINGH & ORS. DOJ : 20/04/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -COMMON INTENTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2439 = 2005 (11 ) SCC 271 = 2005 (5 ) JT 553 = 2005 (4 ) SCALE 342
248. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. GAMBHIR SINGH & ORS. DOJ : 20/04/2005 JUDGEMENT
MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2439 = 2005 (11 ) SCC 271 = 2005 (5 ) JT 553 = 2005 (4 ) SCALE 342
249. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. BIRAM LAL DOJ : 13/04/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2327 = 2005 (3 ) SCR 580 = 2005 (10 ) SCC 714 = 2005 (5 ) JT 475 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 33 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

250. K.R. SOORACHARI .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 13/04/2005 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2674 = 2005 (11 ) SCC 214 = 2005 (5 ) JT 252 = 2005 (5 ) SCALE 200
251. RANJITSING BRAHMAJEETSING SHARMA .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA & ANR. DOJ : 07/04/2005 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -BRAIN MAPPING -ADMISSIBILITY -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2277 = 2005 (3 ) SCR 345 = 2005 (5 ) SCC 294 = 2005 (4 ) JT 123 = 2005 (3
) SCALE 774
252. KAMALANANTHA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 05/04/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -CONSPIRACY -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2132 = 2005 (3 ) SCR 182 = 2005 (5 ) SCC 194 = 2005 (4 ) JT 170 = 2005 (3
) SCALE 706
253. KAMALANANTHA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 05/04/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -DNA
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2132 = 2005 (3 ) SCR 182 = 2005 (5 ) SCC 194 = 2005 (4 ) JT 170 = 2005 (3
) SCALE 706
254. RAM SEWAK .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 29/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2005 (12 ) SCC 143 =
255. HEM RAJ & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 29/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2110 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 1152 = 2005 (10 ) SCC 614 = 2005 (3 ) JT 600 = 2005 (3
) SCALE 482
256. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. MOHINDER SINGH DOJ : 14/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DATE OF BIRTH -HOROSCOPE -EVIDENTIARY VALUE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1868 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 758 = 2005 (3 ) SCC 702 = 2005 (3 ) JT 220 = 2005 (3
) SCALE 173
257. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. MOHINDER SINGH DOJ : 14/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -DATE OF BIRTH -EVIDENCE -SUBSTANTIAL QUESTION
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1868 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 758 = 2005 (3 ) SCC 702 = 2005 (3 ) JT 220 = 2005 (3
) SCALE 173
258. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. MOHINDER SINGH DOJ : 14/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -AGE -PROOF
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1868 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 758 = 2005 (3 ) SCC 702 = 2005 (3 ) JT 220 = 2005 (3
) SCALE 173
259. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. MOHINDER SINGH DOJ : 14/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -PROOF OF DATE OF BIRTH -SECOND APPEAL -PUNJAB & HARYANA
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1868 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 758 = 2005 (3 ) SCC 702 = 2005 (3 ) JT 220 = 2005 (3
) SCALE 173
260. SHEIKH MEHEBOOB @ HETAK & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 10/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CREDIBILITY
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1805 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 628 = 2005 (10 ) SCC 387 = 2005 (3 ) JT 137 = 2005 (3
) SCALE 55
261. RAVI KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 04/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -FIR -DELAY -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1929 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 548 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 315 = 2005 (3 ) JT 62
262. RAVI KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 04/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CULPABLE HOMICIDE -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1929 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 548 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 315 = 2005 (3 ) JT 62 = 2005 (2
) SCALE 534
263. BALBIR SINGH ETC. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB ETC. DOJ : 03/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CULPABLE HOMICIDE -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2005 (9 ) SCC 299 = 2005 (3 ) JT 7 = 2005 (2 ) SCALE 478
264. HARBANS KAUR .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 01/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -RELATED WITNESS -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 2989 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 450 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 195 = 2005 (3 ) JT 233 = 2005 (2
) SCALE 457
265. MANGU KHAN & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 24/02/2005 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -REAPPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1912 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 368 = 2005 (10 ) SCC 374 = 2005 (2 ) JT 575 =
266. SHANTI .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 15/02/2005 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -BRIDE BURNING -DYING DECLARATION -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2005 (12 ) SCC 287 =
267. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. SATISH DOJ : 08/02/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT -U P
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1000 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 1132 = 2005 (3 ) SCC 114 = 2005 (2 ) JT 153 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 34 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

268. AYODHYA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR & ORS. DOJ : 03/02/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -APPEAL AGAINST ACQUITTAL -INTERFERENCE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1022 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 584 = 2005 (2 ) JT 635 = 2005 (2 ) SCALE 46
269. AYODHYA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR & ORS. DOJ : 03/02/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT -APPEAL AGAINST ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1022 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 584 = 2005 (2 ) JT 635 = 2005 (2 ) SCALE 46
270. KAMESH PANJIYAR @ KAMLESH PANJIYAR .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 01/02/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 785 = 2005 (1 ) SCR 903 = 2005 (2 ) SCC 388 = 2005 (2 ) JT 218 = 2005 (1
) SCALE 739
271. SUNIL KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 19/01/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -INTERESTED WITNESS -RELATED WITNESS
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1096 = 2005 (1 ) SCR 612 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 283 = 2005 (2 ) JT 1 = 2005 (1
) SCALE 608
272. RAMESHWAR PANDEY & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 18/01/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -COMMON OBJECT -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1064 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 210 = 2005 (2 ) JT 92 = 2005 (1 ) SCALE 543
273. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. SHRI KRISHAN DOJ : 16/12/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 762 = 2005 (10 ) SCC 399 = 2005 (1 ) SCALE 1
274. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. PAPPU @ YUNUS & ANR. DOJ : 01/12/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -REMITTANCES
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1248 = 2004 (6 ) Suppl. SCR 585 = 2005 (3 ) SCC 594 = 2005 (1 ) JT 153 = 2004 (10
) SCALE 147
275. DAULAT RAM & ORS .Vs. SODHA & ORS DOJ : 16/11/2004 JUDGEMENT
SUCCESSION LAW -EVIDENCE -TESTIMENTARY SUCCESSION -SECOND WILL
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 233 = 2005 (1 ) SCC 40 = 2004 (10 ) JT 50 = 2004 (9 ) SCALE 442
276. SHASHIDHAR PURANDHAR HEGDE & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 15/10/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -KIDNAPPING -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 5075 = 2004 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 536 = 2004 (12 ) SCC 492 = 2004 (9 ) JT 177
277. CHAVA ANKAMA RAO & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 12/10/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1447 = 2004 (13 ) SCC 160 = 2004 (9 ) JT 187 = 2004 (8 ) SCALE 684
278. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. SHEO SANEHI & ORS. DOJ : 06/10/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4974 = 2004 (12 ) SCC 347 = 2004 (9 ) JT 197 = 2004 (8 ) SCALE 520
279. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. SHEO SANEHI & ORS. DOJ : 06/10/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MOTIVE -ALIBI
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4974 = 2004 (12 ) SCC 347 = 2004 (9 ) JT 197 = 2004 (8 ) SCALE 520
280. SACHCHEY LAL TIWARI .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 06/10/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 5039 = 2004 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 107 = 2004 (11 ) SCC 410 = 2004 (8 ) JT 534
281. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. SHEO SANEHI & ORS. DOJ : 06/10/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4974 = 2004 (12 ) SCC 347 = 2004 (9 ) JT 197 = 2004 (8 ) SCALE 520
282. SACHCHEY LAL TIWARI .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 06/10/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CHANCE WITNESS -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 5039 = 2004 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 107 = 2004 (11 ) SCC 410 = 2004 (8 ) JT 534 = 2004 (8
) SCALE 539
283. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. TEG BAHADUR & ORS. DOJ : 29/09/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2004 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 840 = 2004 (13 ) SCC 300 = 2004 (8 ) JT 116 = 2004 (8 ) SCALE 341
284. ARUN GARG .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB & ANR. DOJ : 29/09/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 852 = 2004 (8 ) SCC 251 = 2004 (8 ) JT 124 = 2004 (8 ) SCALE 273
285. PRAMOD MANDAL .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 17/09/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DACOITY -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2004 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 479 = 2004 (13 ) SCC 150 = 2004 (7 ) JT 583 = 2004 (7 ) SCALE 718
286. PRAMOD MANDAL .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 17/09/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2004 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 479 = 2004 (13 ) SCC 150 = 2004 (7 ) JT 583 = 2004 (7 ) SCALE 718
287. RAM KISHAN & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 10/09/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4676 = 2004 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 287 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 736 = 2004 (7 ) JT 516 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 35 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

288. MUNICIPAL CORPORATION FARIDABAD .Vs. SIRI NIWAS DOJ : 06/09/2004 JUDGEMENT
LABOUR LAW -EVIDENCE -NON PRODUCTION -EMPLOYEES
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4681 = 2004 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 145 = 2004 (8 ) SCC 195 = 2004 (7 ) JT 248 = 2004 (7
) SCALE 437
289. STATE OF A.P. .Vs. K. PUNARDANA RAO DOJ : 03/09/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4194 = 2004 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 104 = 2004 (10 ) SCC 500 = 2004 (7 ) JT 501 = 2004 (7
) SCALE 362
290. U.O.I. .Vs. MUNNA & ANR. DOJ : 27/08/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -NARCOTIC DRUGS -EVIDENCE -PRESUMPTION
Citation(s) 2004 ( 7 ) SCC 178 = 2004 ( 7 ) JT 512 = 2004 ( 7 ) SCALE 252
291. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. JAGMOHAN SINGH KULDIP SINGH ANAND & ORS. DOJ : 27/08/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -REVISIONAL JURISDICTION -HIGH COURTS
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4412 = 2004 (7 ) SCC 659 = 2004 (7 ) JT 495 = 2004 (7 ) SCALE 201
292. RAJINDER & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA & ANR. DOJ : 25/08/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -RELATED WITNESS
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4352 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 784 = 2004 (7 ) JT 481 = 2004 (7 ) SCALE 217
293. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH .Vs. KISHAN CHAND & ORS. DOJ : 20/08/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -RELATED WITNESS -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4671 = 2004 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 640 = 2004 (7 ) SCC 629 = 2004 (6 ) JT 535 = 2004 (7
) SCALE 75
294. DASHRATH SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 13/08/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -INJURY -NON EXPLANATION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4488 = 2004 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 561 = 2004 (7 ) SCC 408 = 2004 (6 ) JT 505 = 2004 (7
) SCALE 3
295. JAI SHREE YADAV .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 12/08/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -MURDER -ANTI TIMED FIR -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4443 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 788 = 2004 (6 ) JT 519 = 2004 (6 ) SCALE 587
296. RAVI .Vs. STATE REP. BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE DOJ : 12/08/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -COMMON OBJECT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2004 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 484 = 2004 (11 ) SCC 266 = 2004 (6 ) JT 482 = 2004 (6 ) SCALE 601
297. RAVI .Vs. STATE REP. BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE DOJ : 12/08/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -RELATED WITNESS -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2004 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 484 = 2004 (11 ) SCC 266 = 2004 (6 ) JT 482 = 2004 (6 ) SCALE 601
298. RAVI .Vs. STATE REP. BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE DOJ : 12/08/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 484 = 2004 (11 ) SCC 266 = 2004 (6 ) JT 482 = 2004 (6 ) SCALE 601
299. JAI SHREE YADAV .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 12/08/2004 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -PARTISAN WITNESS -EYE WITNESS -SON
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4443 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 788 = 2004 (6 ) JT 519 = 2004 (6 ) SCALE 587
300. KARNAM RAM NARSAIAH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 05/08/2004 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4363 = 2004 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 361 = 2005 (10 ) SCC 629 = 2004 (8 ) JT 134 = 2004 (7
) SCALE 408
301. KARNAM RAM NARSAIAH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 05/08/2004 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -COMMON INTENTION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4363 = 2004 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 361 = 2005 (10 ) SCC 629 = 2004 (8 ) JT 134 = 2004 (7
) SCALE 408
302. HARJINDER SINGH @ BHOLA .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 27/07/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CHANCE WITNESS -TESTIMONY
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 3962 = 2004 (11 ) SCC 253 = 2004 (6 ) JT 23 = 2004 (6 ) SCALE 289
303. GANGAMMA & ORS. .Vs. SHIVALINGAIAH DOJ : 21/07/2004 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DOCUMENT -CONTENT -PRESUMPTION
Citation(s) 2005 (9 ) SCC 359 =
304. ANIL SHARMA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF JHARKHAND DOJ : 30/04/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -COMMON INTENTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 2294 = 2004 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 907 = 2004 (5 ) SCC 679 = 2004 (1
) Suppl. JT 559 = 2004 (5 ) SCALE 289
305. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. VEER SINGH & ORS. DOJ : 28/04/2004 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -ACQUITTAL -REMITTANCES
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4614 = 2004 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 790 = 2004 (10 ) SCC 117 = 2004 (2
) Suppl. JT 90 = 2004 (5 ) SCALE 159
306. KANTI LAL .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 21/04/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 2536 = 2004 (10 ) SCC 113 = 2004 (1 ) Suppl. JT 487 = 2004 (4 ) SCALE 795

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 36 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

307. JANAK SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 19/04/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 2495 = 2004 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 378 = 2004 (11 ) SCC 385 = 2004 (1
) Suppl. JT 224 = 2004 (4 ) SCALE 670
308. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. AJAIB SINGH & ORS DOJ : 13/04/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 2466 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 94 = 2004 (1 ) Suppl. JT 69 = 2004 (4 ) SCALE 587
309. NARENDRA SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 12/04/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 3249 = 2004 (3 ) SCR 1148 = 2004 (10 ) SCC 699 = 2004 (1 ) Suppl. JT 29 = 2004 (4
) SCALE 543
310. SABBITA SATYAVATHI .Vs. BANDALA SRINIVASARAO DOJ : 15/03/2004 JUDGEMENT
MURDER -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4540 = 2004 (10 ) SCC 620 = 2004 (3 ) JT 547 = 2004 (3 ) SCALE 295
311. DANI SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 12/03/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4570 = 2004 (2 ) SCR 1138 = 2004 (13 ) SCC 203 = 2004 (3 ) JT 367
312. CHARAN SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 10/03/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 2828 = 2004 (2 ) SCR 925 = 2004 (4 ) SCC 205 = 2004 (3 ) JT 334 = 2004 (3
) SCALE 71
313. VASANT VITHU JADHAV .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 09/03/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ATTEMPT TO MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 2678 = 2004 (2 ) SCR 861 = 2004 (9 ) SCC 31 = 2004 (3 ) JT 267 = 2004 (3
) SCALE 62
314. RAM BRIKSH SINGH & ORS. .Vs. AMBIKA YADAV & ANR. DOJ : 09/03/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 4583 = 2004 (7 ) SCC 665 = 2004 (4 ) JT 382 = 2004 (3 ) SCALE 53
315. BALJEET SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 24/02/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -DISAPPEARANCE
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 1714 = 2004 ( 3 ) SCC 122 = 2004 ( 3 ) JT 93 = 2004 ( 2 ) SCALE 632
316. AMAN KUMAR & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 10/02/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -PROSECUTRIX
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 1497 = 2004 (2 ) SCR 237 = 2004 (4 ) SCC 379 = 2004 (2 ) JT 274 = 2004 (2
) SCALE 356
317. SASHI JENA & ORS. .Vs. KHADAL SWAIN & ANR. DOJ : 10/02/2004 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -SOLITARY WITNESS -HOSTILE WITNESS -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 1492 = 2004 (2 ) SCR 260 = 2004 (4 ) SCC 236 = 2004 (2 ) JT 339 = 2004 (2
) SCALE 348
318. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. NAWAB SINGH (DEAD) & ORS. DOJ : 03/02/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 1511 = 2004 (2 ) SCR 52 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 84 = 2004 (2 ) JT 79 = 2004 (2 ) SCALE 185
319. SIMON & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 29/01/2004 JUDGEMENT
TADA -EVIDENCE -ACCUSED -IDENTIFICATION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 2775 = 2004 (1 ) SCR 1164 = 2004 (2 ) SCC 694 = 2004 (2 ) JT 124 = 2004 (2
) SCALE 112
320. DASTAGIR SAB & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 22/01/2004 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -RAPE -IDENTIFICATION PARADE -NECESSITY
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 2884 = 2004 (1 ) SCR 952 = 2004 (3 ) SCC 106 = 2004 (1 ) JT 635 = 2004 (2
) SCALE 8
321. BORGARAM DEURI .Vs. PREMODHAR BORA & ANR. DOJ : 05/01/2004 JUDGEMENT
ELECTION LAW -CORRUPT PRACTICE -EVIDENCE -DISMISSAL
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 1386 = 2004 (1 ) SCR 103 = 2004 (2 ) SCC 227 = 2004 (1 ) JT 102
322. BACHHU NARAIN SINGH .Vs. NARESH YADAV DOJ : 19/12/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 3055 = 2003 (12 ) SCC 647 = 2003 (10 ) JT 407 = 2003 (10 ) SCALE 932
323. CHANAKYA DHIBAR (DEAD) .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 19/12/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CHANCE WITNESS -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2003 (6 ) Suppl. SCR 1181 = 2004 (12 ) SCC 398 = 2003 (10 ) JT 209 = 2003 (10 ) SCALE 883
324. MOIJULLAH @ PUTTAN .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 19/12/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -CONSPIRACY -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 3186 = 2004 (2 ) SCC 90 = 2003 (10 ) JT 325 = 2003 (10 ) SCALE 860
325. BACHHU NARAIN SINGH .Vs. NARESH YADAV DOJ : 19/12/2003 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -INFORMANT -PRESENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 3055 = 2003 (12 ) SCC 647 = 2003 (10 ) JT 407 = 2003 (10 ) SCALE 932

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 37 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

326. K. ANBAZHAGAN .Vs. SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE & ORS. ETC. DOJ : 18/11/2003 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -EXAMINATION -ACCUSED -PHYSICAL APPEARANCE
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 524 = 2003 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 610 = 2004 (3 ) SCC 767 = 2003 (9 ) JT 31 = 2003 (9
) SCALE 680
327. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. MELA SINGH DOJ : 06/11/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 257 = 2003 (12 ) SCC 464 = 2003 (8 ) JT 562 = 2003 (9 ) SCALE 387
328. PREM SAGAR .Vs. DHARAMBIR & ORS. DOJ : 29/10/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -SINGLE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 21 = 2003 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 1037 = 2004 (1 ) SCC 113 = 2003 (8 ) JT 76 = 2003 (9
) SCALE 24
329. RATANSINH DALSUKHBHAI NAYAK .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 29/10/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CHILD WITNESS -COMPETENCY
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 23 = 2003 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 1030 = 2004 (1 ) SCC 64 = 2003 (8 ) JT 53 = 2003 (9
) SCALE 14
330. SIMON & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 16/10/2003 JUDGEMENT
TADA -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -SETTING ASIDE
Citation(s) 2003 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 869 = 2004 (1 ) SCC 74 = 2003 (8 ) JT 587 = 2003 (9 ) SCALE 348
331. SIMON & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 16/10/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 869 = 2004 (1 ) SCC 74 = 2003 (8 ) JT 587 = 2003 (9 ) SCALE 348
332. STATE OF M.P. .Vs. GHUDAN DOJ : 15/10/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 797 = 2003 (12 ) SCC 485 = 2003 (2 ) Suppl. JT 481 = 2003 (8 ) SCALE 655
333. STATE OF M.P. .Vs. GHUDAN DOJ : 15/10/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 797 = 2003 (12 ) SCC 485 = 2003 (2 ) Suppl. JT 481 = 2003 (8 ) SCALE 655
334. STATE OF M.P. .Vs. KRIPARAM DOJ : 25/09/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 (12 ) SCC 675 = 2003 (2 ) Suppl. JT 90 = 2003 (8 ) SCALE 89
335. MUNNA @ SURENDRA KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 16/09/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3346 = 2003 (11 ) SCC 480 = 2003 (1 ) Suppl. JT 314 = 2003 (7 ) SCALE 510
336. MOHINDER SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB & ORS. DOJ : 11/09/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL -PUNJAB
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 4399 = 2004 (12 ) SCC 311 = 2003 (1 ) Suppl. JT 117 = 2003 (7 ) SCALE 372
337. MOHINDER SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB & ORS. DOJ : 11/09/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 4399 = 2004 (12 ) SCC 311 = 2003 (1 ) Suppl. JT 117 = 2003 (7 ) SCALE 372
338. HEM RAJ & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 09/09/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 4259 = 2003 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 466 = 2003 (12 ) SCC 241 = 2003 (7 ) JT 2002 =
339. MARUTI RAMA NAIK .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 09/09/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3884 = 2003 ( 7 ) JT 627 = 2003 ( 7 ) SCALE 270
340. VAJRAPU SAMBAYYA NAIDU & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF A.P. & ORS. DOJ : 02/09/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -UNLAWFUL ASSEMBLY -CULPABLE HOMICIDE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3706 = 2003 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 299 = 2004 (10 ) SCC 152 = 2003 (7 ) JT 558 = 2003 (7
) SCALE 44
341. KALIYAPERUMAL & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 27/08/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3828 = 2003 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 1 = 2004 (9 ) SCC 157 = 2003 (7 ) JT 392 = 2003 (6
) SCALE 707
342. MUNNA .Vs. STATE (N.C.T. OF DELHI) DOJ : 27/08/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ACCUSED -SUB TENANTS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3805 = 2003 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 1048 = 2003 (10 ) SCC 599 = 2003 (7 ) JT 361 = 2003 (6
) SCALE 698
343. MUNNA .Vs. STATE (N.C.T. OF DELHI) DOJ : 27/08/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ROBBERY -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3805 = 2003 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 1048 = 2003 (10 ) SCC 599 = 2003 (7 ) JT 361 = 2003 (6
) SCALE 698
344. KRISHNA GOPE .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 25/08/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3114 = 2003 (10 ) SCC 45 = 2003 ( 7 ) JT 376 = 2003 ( 6 ) SCALE 578

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 38 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

345. HAMLET @ SASI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 21/08/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3682 = 2003 (10 ) SCC 108 = 2003 ( 7 ) JT 351 = 2003 ( 6 ) SCALE 514
346. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. RAJA RAM DOJ : 13/08/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3601 = 2003 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 445 = 2003 (8 ) SCC 180 = 2003 (7 ) JT 399 = 2003 (6
) SCALE 489
347. GOVT. OF N.C.T. OF DELHI .Vs. JASPAL SINGH DOJ : 08/08/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -OFFICIAL SECRETS ACT
Citation(s) 2003 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 335 = 2003 (10 ) SCC 586 = 2003 (7 ) JT 302 = 2003 (6 ) SCALE 181
348. GOLAKONDA VENKATESWARA RAO .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 01/08/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2846 = 2003 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 96 = 2003 (9 ) SCC 277 = 2003 (6 ) JT 438 = 2003 (5
) SCALE 646
349. GURDEV SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 01/08/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MASS MURDER -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 4187 = 2003 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 80 = 2003 (7 ) SCC 258 = 2003 (6 ) JT 386 = 2003 (6
) SCALE 25
350. BRIJRANI .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 31/07/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -INTERESTED WITNESS -PRESENCE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3566 = 2003 ( 6 ) JT 445 = 2003 ( 5 ) SCALE 580
351. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. BHAWANI & ANR. DOJ : 31/07/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 4230 = 2003 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 996 = 2003 (7 ) SCC 291 = 2003 (6 ) JT 369 = 2003 (5
) SCALE 595
352. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. AMAJAPPA & ORS. DOJ : 31/07/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2003 ( 9 ) SCC 468 = 2003 ( 7 ) JT 126 = 2003 ( 5 ) SCALE 671
353. HARIJANA NARAYANA & ORS .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 30/07/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -UNLAWFUL ASSEMBLY
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2851 = 2003 (11 ) SCC 681 = 2003 (6 ) JT 170 = 2003 (5 ) SCALE 546
354. MALKHANSINGH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 08/07/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -CORROBORATION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2669 = 2003 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 443 = 2003 (5 ) SCC 746 = 2003 (5 ) JT 323 = 2003 (5
) SCALE 152
355. STATE, THROUGH SPECIAL CELL, NEW DELHI .Vs. NAVJOT SANDHU @ AFSHAN GURU & ORS. DOJ
: 09/05/2003 JUDGEMENT
POTA -CONSPIRACY -CONVERSATION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2003 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 130 = 2003 (6 ) SCC 641 = 2003 (4 ) SCALE 629
356. JANDEL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH DOJ : 08/05/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3991 = 2003 ( 9 ) SCC 110 = 2003 ( 4 ) JT 558 = 2003 ( 4 ) SCALE 608
357. BALRAM SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 07/05/2003 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -WITNESS -NON EXAMINATION -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2213 = 2003 (11 ) SCC 286 = 2003 (4 ) JT 569 = 2003 (4 ) SCALE 561
358. THAMAN KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF UNION TERRITORY OF CHANDIGARH DOJ : 06/05/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3975 = 2003 (3 ) SCR 1190 = 2003 (6 ) SCC 380 = 2003 (4 ) JT 478 = 2003 (4
) SCALE 531
359. BABUDAS .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 29/04/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ALIBI -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 ( 9 ) SCC 86 = 2003 ( 4 ) JT 289 = 2003 ( 4 ) SCALE 389
360. BRIJPAL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 29/04/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2460 = 2003 (11 ) SCC 219 = 2003 (4 ) JT 378 = 2003 (4 ) SCALE 395
361. VISVESWARAN .Vs. STATE REP. BY S.D.M. DOJ : 28/04/2003 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -RAPE -POLICE CONSTABLE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2471 = 2003 (3 ) SCR 978 = 2003 (6 ) SCC 73 = 2003 (4 ) JT 367 = 2003 (4
) SCALE 344
362. BIMLA DEVI .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 10/04/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 4138 = 2003 (10 ) SCC 118 = 2003 ( 4 ) JT 1 = 2003 ( 3 ) SCALE 743
363. SADHU RAM & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 10/04/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -SOLITARY WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 3530 = 2003 (11 ) SCC 231 = 2003 (4 ) JT 13 = 2003 (3 ) SCALE 751

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 39 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

364. SALIM AKHTAR @ MOTA .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 09/04/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 4076 = 2003 (3 ) SCR 470 = 2003 (5 ) SCC 499 = 2003 (3 ) SCALE 698
365. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. PRAFUL B. DESAI DOJ : 01/04/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -RECORDING -VIDEO CONFERENCING
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2053 = 2003 ( 3 ) SCR 244 = 2003 ( 4 ) SCC 601 = 2003 ( 3 ) JT 382 = 2003 ( 3
) SCALE 554
366. KACHA KANTI SEVA SAMITY & ANR. .Vs. KACHA KANTI DEVI & ORS. DOJ : 28/03/2003 JUDGEMENT
PROPERTY -EVIDENCE -TEMPLE -SHEBAITSHIP
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 608 = 2003 ( 3 ) SCR 99 = 2003 ( 4 ) SCC 665 = 2003 ( 3 ) JT 333 = 2003 ( 3
) SCALE 453
367. LALIT POPLI .Vs. CANARA BANK & ORS. DOJ : 18/02/2003 JUDGEMENT
SERVICE LAW -EVIDENCE -MISCONDUCT -TERMINATION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 1795 = 2003 ( 2 ) SCR 100 = 2003 ( 3 ) SCC 583 = 2003 ( 5 ) JT 494 = 2003 ( 2
) SCALE 358
368. M T W TENWING NAMGYAL & ORS. .Vs. MOTILAL LAKHOTIA & ORS. DOJ : 05/02/2003 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -SUIT -RECOVERY OF POSSESSION -LAND
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 1448 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCR 877 = 2003 ( 5 ) SCC 1 = 2003 ( 5 ) JT 173 = 2003 ( 1
) SCALE 709
369. CHERLOPALLI CHELIMINABI SAHEB & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 31/01/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 1014 = 2003 ( 2 ) SCC 571 = 2003 ( 2 ) JT 151 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCALE 525
370. ZAFAR .Vs. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH DOJ : 15/01/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CHILD WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 931 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCR 363 = 2003 ( 3 ) SCC 51 = 2003 ( 2 ) JT 126 = 2003 ( 1
) SCALE 299
371. BALDEV SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 06/01/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2098 = 2003 ( 9 ) SCC 45 = 2003 ( 1 ) JT 10 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCALE 20
372. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. PANCHAKSHARI GURUPADAYYA HIRAMATH DOJ : 20/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 825 = 2002 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 705 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 229 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 682
373. ALAMGIR SANI .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 20/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2108 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 277 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 708
374. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. PANCHAKSHARI GURUPADAYYA HIRAMATH DOJ : 20/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 825 = 2002 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 705 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 229 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 682
375. KUNHIMODEENKUTTY & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 18/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -KERALA
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 836 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 352 = 2002 (10 ) JT 574 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 655
376. KUNHIMODEENKUTTY & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 18/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -ALTERATION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 836 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 352 = 2002 (10 ) JT 574 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 655
377. JANKI NARAYAN BHOIR .Vs. NARAYAN NAMDEO KADAM DOJ : 17/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
SUCCESSION LAW -EVIDENCE -WILL -EXECUTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 761 = 2002 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 175 = 2003 (2 ) SCC 91 = 2002 (10 ) JT 340 = 2002 (9
) SCALE 628
378. JASBIR & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 16/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -ALIBI
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 554 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 324 = 2002 (10 ) JT 530 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 317
379. JASBIR & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 16/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 554 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 324 = 2002 (10 ) JT 530 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 317
380. YUNIS @ KARIYA .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 10/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 539 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 425 = 2002 ( 9 ) SCALE 245
381. B.L. SREEDHAR & ORS. .Vs. K.M. MUNIREDDY (DEAD) & ORS. DOJ : 05/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -ESTOPPEL -APPLICABILITY
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 578 = 2002 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 601 = 2003 ( 2 ) SCC 355 = 2002 (10 ) JT 363 = 2002 ( 9
) SCALE 183
382. B.L. SREEDHAR & ORS. .Vs. K.M. MUNIREDDY (DEAD) & ORS. DOJ : 05/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -SUIT FOR DECLARATION -INJUNCTIONS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 578 = 2002 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 601 = 2003 ( 2 ) SCC 355 = 2002 (10 ) JT 363 = 2002 ( 9
) SCALE 183

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 40 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

383. JOSEPH .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 03/12/2002 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -SOLITARY WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 507 = 2002 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 439 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 465 = 2002 (10 ) JT 12 = 2002 ( 9
) SCALE 9
384. STATE OF KERALA .Vs. THANIYULLA PARAMBATH BALAN DOJ : 26/11/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -CULPABLE HOMICIDE
Citation(s) 2002 (10 ) JT 232 =
385. CHACKO .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 22/11/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 265 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 112 = 2002 ( 9 ) JT 425 = 2002 ( 8 ) SCALE 523
386. KILEDAR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 21/11/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -FIR -DELAY IN SENDING
Citation(s) 2002 (10 ) JT 93 =
387. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. CHANDU & ORS. DOJ : 21/11/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -INTERESTED WITNESS -TESTIMONY
Citation(s) 2002 (10 ) JT 427 =
388. PUNJAB SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 13/11/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 2002 (10 ) JT 275 =
389. MANOHARAN & ORS. .Vs. STATE REP. BY S.I. OF POLICE CHEVAYUR DOJ : 12/11/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 (10 ) JT 201 =
390. ANTHONY D'SOUZA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 30/10/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -FALSE STATEMENT -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 258 = 2002 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 572 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 259 = 2002 ( 9 ) JT 257 = 2002 ( 8
) SCALE 240
391. STATE OFF TAMILNADU .Vs. MARIAPPAN & ORS. DOJ : 24/10/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 ( 9 ) JT 381 =
392. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH .Vs. KARANAM BALARAMAKRISHNA MURTHY & ORS. DOJ : 23/10/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 (10 ) JT 551 =
393. STATE OF TAMIL NADU .Vs. KAMARAJ DOJ : 23/10/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION -TADA
Citation(s) 2002 ( 9 ) JT 398 = 2003 ( 5 ) SCALE 90
394. SATISH KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 08/10/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -AUTHENTICITY
Citation(s) 2002 ( 9 ) JT 286 =
395. SARWAN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 07/10/2002 JUDGEMENT
TADA -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -PUNJAB
Citation(s) 2002 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 128 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 240 = 2002 ( 8 ) JT 114 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCALE 351
396. RAMBAI .Vs. STATE OF CHHATTISGARH DOJ : 04/10/2002 JUDGEMENT
DEATH BY BURNING -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) SCC 83 = 2002 ( 8 ) JT 3 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCALE 304
397. RAMBAI .Vs. STATE OF CHHATTISGARH DOJ : 04/10/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) SCC 83 = 2002 ( 8 ) JT 3 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCALE 304
398. BHUP SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 01/10/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -ALTERATION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 230 =
399. BHUP SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 01/10/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -COMMON INTENTION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 230 =
400. RAMAMURTHY .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 01/10/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -NATURAL WITNESS
Citation(s) 2009 (16 ) SCC 296 = 2002 (8 ) JT 314 =
401. SARDUL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 27/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
COURTS -DUTY -ANALYSIS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3462 = 2002 ( 8 ) SCC 372 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 496 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCALE 50
402. SHRIKANT ANANDRAO BHOSALE .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 26/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
INSANITY -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL -MAHARASHTRA
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3399 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 612 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 748 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 386 = 2002 ( 7
) SCALE 37

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 41 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

403. MADHO SINGH .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 26/09/2002 ORDER


CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -LAST SEEN TOGETHER
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 305 =
404. SHRIKANT ANANDRAO BHOSALE .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 26/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
MURDER -EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT -INSANITY
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3399 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 612 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 748 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 386 = 2002 ( 7
) SCALE 37
405. JAIPAL .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 19/09/2002 ORDER
EVIDENCE -DISCLOSURE -WITNESS -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 232 =
406. AVTAR SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 18/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
NARCOTIC DRUGS -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -SETTING ASIDE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3343 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 482 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 419 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 245 = 2002 ( 6
) SCALE 539
407. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. DAVID RAZARIO AND ANR. DOJ : 17/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ROBBERY -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3272 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 419 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 728 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 283 = 2002 ( 6
) SCALE 500
408. PARAMASIVAM @ PARAMAN @ KOTTIYAN & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF TAMIL NADU DOJ : 17/09/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -FINGER PRINT -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 214 =
409. STATE OF ORISSA .Vs. SITANSU SEKHAR KANUNGO DOJ : 17/09/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -NARCOTIC DRUGS -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 292 =
410. MOHAR & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 17/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
REAPPRECIATION -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL -REVERSAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3279 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 393 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCALE 516
411. SHAYAM SUNDER .Vs. STATE OF CHHATTISGARH DOJ : 16/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3292 = 2002 ( 8 ) SCC 39 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 317 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCALE 481
412. DANA YADAV @ DAHU & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 13/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3325 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 363 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 295 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 68 = 2002 ( 6
) SCALE 447
413. BHAROSI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 12/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3299 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 239 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 25 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCALE 347
414. K.G. PREMSHANKER .Vs. INSPECTOR OF POLICE & ANR. DOJ : 12/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -QUASHING OF PROCEEDINGS -PERMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3372 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 350 = 2002 ( 8 ) SCC 87 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 30 = 2002 ( 6
) SCALE 371
415. BALU SONBA SHINDE .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 06/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3137 = 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 135 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 543 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 611 = 2002 ( 6
) SCALE 281
416. DEVI LAL .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 04/09/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -PRIVATE DEFENCE -RIGHT
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 165 =
417. MOHD. KHALID .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 03/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -CRIMINAL CONSPIRACY
Citation(s) 2002 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 31 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 334 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 486 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCALE 238
418. GURJANT SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 03/09/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 238 =
419. ALI MEHNDI .Vs. STATE GOVERNMENT OF NCT DELHI DOJ : 27/08/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ROBBERY -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 108 =
420. KOMAL & ORS .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 23/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3057 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 82 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 227 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCALE 68
421. KOMAL & ORS .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 23/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3057 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 82 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 227 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCALE 68

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 42 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

422. RATTAN LAL .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 20/08/2002 ORDER


CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -NATURAL WITNESS -WIFE
Citation(s) 2002 ( 7 ) JT 627 =
423. RATTAN LAL .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 20/08/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2002 ( 7 ) JT 627 =
424. NALLABOTHU VENKAIAH .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 20/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2945 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 606 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 117 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 213 = 2002 ( 6
) SCALE 26
425. HARJIT SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 16/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3040 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 581 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 739 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 123 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 644
426. HARJIT SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 16/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
SELF DEFENCE -ATTEMPT TO MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3040 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 581 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 739 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 123 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 644
427. HARDEEP .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA & ANR. DOJ : 16/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION -ACQUITTAL -HARYANA
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3018 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 556 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 11 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 144 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 608
428. HARDEEP .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA & ANR. DOJ : 16/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3018 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 556 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 11 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 144 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 608
429. RAMILABEN HASMUKHBHAI KRISTI & ANR. ETC. .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 14/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -RECORDING
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2996 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 530 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 56 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 54 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 631
430. KULDIP SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 14/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3023 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 757 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 97 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 569
431. DORYODHAN & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 14/08/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CHILD WITNESS -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 152 =
432. MUNNUSWAMY & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 14/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2994 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 550 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 700 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 106 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 605
433. KALAHASTHRI PATTABHIRAMI REDDY .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 14/08/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ALIBI -SUSTAINABILITY
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 99 =
434. KALAHASTHRI PATTABHIRAMI REDDY .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 14/08/2002
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ALIBI -SUSTAINABILITY
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 99 =
435. MUTHU .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 13/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -INCONSISTENCY
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2902 = 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 158 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 32 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 583
436. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. NAGDU @ BUJHARAT DOJ : 13/08/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DACOITY -IDENTIFICATION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 8 ) JT 124 =
437. K. SADANAND @ NAIDU .Vs. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR , A.P. DOJ : 13/08/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CHEATING -KIDNAPPING
Citation(s) 2009 (16 ) SCC 375 = 2002 (8 ) JT 174 =
438. MAHADEO SAHNI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 13/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3032 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 502 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 656 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 87 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 577
439. VADUGU CHANTI BABU .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 13/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -FATHER -RELATIVE -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2911 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 547 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 42 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 559
440. K. SADANAND @ NAIDU .Vs. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR , A.P. DOJ : 13/08/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -SETTING ASIDE
Citation(s) 2009 (16 ) SCC 375 = 2002 (8 ) JT 174 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 43 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

441. MAHADEO SAHNI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 13/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -REAPPRECIATION -SUPREME COURT
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3032 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 502 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 656 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 87 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 577
442. VADUGU CHANTI BABU .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 13/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2911 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 547 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 42 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 559
443. TARUN BORA @ ALOK HAZARIKA .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 12/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
TADA -KIDNAPPING -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2926 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 458 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 39 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 78 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 624
444. PATNALA VENKATA RAMANA .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 07/08/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -ACCEPTANCE
Citation(s) 2002 ( 6 ) JT 442 =
445. PATNALA VENKATA RAMANA .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 07/08/2002 ORDER
EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -COUNCILLOR -ACCEPTANCE
Citation(s) 2002 ( 6 ) JT 442 =
446. DHARMA RADAKA WALVI .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 07/08/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2002 (10 ) SCC 233 = 2002 (6 ) JT 430 =
447. RAM ANUP SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 07/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3006 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 686 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 621 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 500
448. VIKAS .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 02/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2830 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 435 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 728 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 573 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 477
449. TORAN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 01/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2807 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 390 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 494 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 498 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 407
450. PRITAM NATH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 01/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2846 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 397 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 321 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 563 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 429
451. PRITAM NATH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 01/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -SOLE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2846 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 397 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 321 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 563 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 429
452. BABU RAM & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 01/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -INTERESTED WITNESS -TESTIMONY
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2815 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 366 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 518 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 542
453. HARIJANA THIRUPALA & ORS. .Vs. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR HIGH COURT OF A.P. HYDERABAD DOJ
: 01/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2821 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 379 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 470 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 551
454. HARIJANA THIRUPALA & ORS. .Vs. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR HIGH COURT OF A.P. HYDERABAD DOJ
: 01/08/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -COMMON INTENTION -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2821 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 379 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 470 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 551
455. PRAMOD MAHTO .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 31/07/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 ( 9 ) SCC 215 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 568 = 2003 (10 ) SCALE 489
456. DHANANJAY SHANKAR SHETTY .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 31/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DOUBT -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2787 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 352 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 596 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 559
457. SHANKAR MAHTO & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 31/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CHILD WITNESS -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2857 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 431 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 512 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 382
458. VISHWAJIT SHANKAR KHAVANEKAR .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 30/07/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 6 ) JT 565 =
459. N. SHIVAKUMAR @ SHIVANNA .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 30/07/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 ( 6 ) JT 583 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 44 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

460. KALPANA MAZUMDAR .Vs. STATE OF ORISSA DOJ : 30/07/2002 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -BRUTAL MURDER -CHILD
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2826 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 299 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 536 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 490 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 375
461. GAJULA VENKATESWARA RAO & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 29/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2775 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 487 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 404 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 358
462. GAJULA VENKATESWARA RAO & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 29/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -NATURAL WITNESS -APPRECIATION -A P
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2775 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 487 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 404 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 358
463. THANGAVELU .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 29/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -ACQUITTAL -T N
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2759 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 498 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 429 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 329
464. SYED GANI .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 25/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DESTRUCTION -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2726 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 527 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 380 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 326
465. PODAPATI MALAKONDAIAH .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 25/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION -EYE WITNESS -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2724 = 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 11 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 299 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 319
466. PODAPATI MALAKONDAIAH .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 25/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2724 = 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 11 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 299 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 319
467. LAXMAN .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 24/07/2002 ORDER
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -ADMISSIBILITY -MAHARASHTRA
Citation(s) 2002 (6 ) SCC 710 = 2002 (6 ) JT 313 = 2002 (5 ) SCALE 418
468. LAXMAN .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 24/07/2002 ORDER
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -CERTIFICATE -DOCTOR
Citation(s) 2002 (6 ) SCC 710 = 2002 (6 ) JT 313 = 2002 (5 ) SCALE 418
469. RACHHPAL SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 23/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2710 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 462 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 388 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 308
470. MATHURA YADAV @ MATHURA MAHATO & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 23/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2707 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 451 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 326 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 297
471. RAKESH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 18/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2721 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 213 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 384 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 438 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 283
472. RAVINDRA SHANTARAM SAWANT .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 08/05/2002 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -POLICE WITNESS -RELIABILITY -INDEPENDENT WITNESS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2461 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCR 881 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCC 604 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 190 = 2002 ( 4
) SCALE 501
473. MALHU YADAV & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 01/05/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -COMMON INTENTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2137 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCR 676 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCC 724 = 2002 ( 4 ) SCALE 285
474. SUBASH PARBAT SONVANE .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 24/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -EVIDENCE -GUJARAT
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2169 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCR 359 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCC 86 = 2002 ( 4 ) JT 348 = 2002 ( 4
) SCALE 40
475. GIRDHAR SHANKAR TAWADE .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 24/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CRUELTY -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2078 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCR 376 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCC 177 = 2002 ( 4 ) JT 357 = 2002 ( 4
) SCALE 44
476. SUKHCHAIN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA & ORS. DOJ : 24/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2002 ( 3 ) SCR 408 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCC 100 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 277 = 2002 ( 4 ) SCALE 111
477. EZHIL & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 24/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -PRESUMPTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2017 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCR 431 = 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 189 = 2002 ( 4 ) JT 375 = 2002 ( 4
) SCALE 102
478. EZHIL & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 24/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -KIDNAPPING -MURDER
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2017 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCR 431 = 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 189 = 2002 ( 4 ) JT 375 = 2002 ( 4
) SCALE 102

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 45 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

479. VASHRAM NARSHIBHAI RAJPARA .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 24/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2211 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCR 422 = 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 168 = 2002 ( 4 ) JT 403 = 2002 ( 4
) SCALE 95
480. STATE OF ORISSA .Vs. DIBAKAR NAIK & ORS. DOJ : 23/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -PROSECUTION WITNESS -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2148 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCR 307 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCC 323 = 2002 ( 4 ) JT 303 = 2002 ( 4
) SCALE 62
481. STATE OF ORISSA .Vs. THAKARA BESRA & ANR. DOJ : 16/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1963 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCR 173 = 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 86 = 2002 ( 4 ) JT 235 = 2002 ( 3
) SCALE 570
482. STATE OF ORISSA .Vs. THAKARA BESRA & ANR. DOJ : 16/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -REAPPRECIATION -ORISSA
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1963 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCR 173 = 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 86 = 2002 ( 4 ) JT 235 = 2002 ( 3
) SCALE 570
483. RACHAPALLI ABBULU & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 08/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -UNLAWFUL ASSEMBLY -A P
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1805 = 2002 ( 4 ) SCC 208 = 2002 ( 4 ) JT 39 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCALE 377
484. RAMA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 05/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -REAPPRECIATION -HIGH COURTS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1814 = 2002 ( 4 ) SCC 571 = 2002 ( 3 ) JT 566 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCALE 355
485. ZORAWAR SINGH & ANR. .Vs. SARWAN SINGH (D) BY LRS. & ANR. DOJ : 04/04/2002 JUDGEMENT
SPECIFIC RELIEF -AGREEMENT OF SALE -PURCHASE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1711 = 2002 ( 4 ) SCC 460 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 561 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCALE 280
486. BHAGWAN SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 22/03/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -RELATIONS OF DECEASED
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1621 = 2002 ( 4 ) SCC 85 = 2002 ( 3 ) JT 387 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCALE 169
487. SUKLIYA .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 21/03/2002 ORDER
MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 ( 5 ) JT 302 =
488. KHET SINGH .Vs. U.O.I. DOJ : 20/03/2002 JUDGEMENT
NARCOTIC DRUGS -SEARCH AND SEIZURE -EVIDENCE -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1450 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCR 598 = 2002 ( 4 ) SCC 380 = 2002 ( 3 ) JT 208 = 2002 ( 3
) SCALE 58
489. KALPESH KUMAR @ BHAJIYU GUNVANTLAL SONI .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 19/03/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -OMISSION -TESTIMONY
Citation(s) 2009 (16 ) SCC 343 = 2002 (1 ) Suppl. JT 101 =
490. ASHOK KUMAR PANDEY .Vs. STATE OF DELHI DOJ : 15/03/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1468 = 2002 ( 4 ) SCC 76 = 2002 ( 3 ) JT 103 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCALE 647
491. RAJESH @ RAJU CHANDULAL GANDHI & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 07/03/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -REAPPRECIATION -HIGH COURTS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1412 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCR 304 = 2002 ( 4 ) SCC 426 = 2002 ( 3 ) JT 395 = 2002 ( 2
) SCALE 497
492. RAJESH @ RAJU CHANDULAL GANDHI & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 07/03/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1412 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCR 304 = 2002 ( 4 ) SCC 426 = 2002 ( 3 ) JT 395 = 2002 ( 2
) SCALE 497
493. SHAMBHU .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 06/03/2002 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -APPRECIATION -M P
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1307 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCC 561 = 2002 ( 2 ) JT 632 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCALE 454
494. KESHAVLAL .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 04/03/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION -M P
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1221 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCC 254 = 2002 ( 2 ) JT 628 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCALE 410
495. MAHENDRA PAL .Vs. RAM DASS MALANGER & ORS. DOJ : 01/03/2002 JUDGEMENT
ELECTION LAW -RECOUNTING OF VOTES -REFUSAL -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1291 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCR 169 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCC 457 = 2002 ( 2 ) JT 396 = 2002 ( 2
) SCALE 389
496. STATE OF HARYANA .Vs. VIDHYA DHAR DOJ : 01/03/2002 JUDGEMENT
NARCOTIC DRUGS -RECOVERY -EVIDENCE -IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1208 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCR 151 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCC 296 = 2002 ( 2 ) JT 361
497. KANCHANA .Vs. P. MANIAN DOJ : 28/02/2002 ORDER
RENT LAW -REVISION -WILLFUL DEFAULT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 36 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 46 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

498. AYYUB ETC. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 28/02/2002 JUDGEMENT


EVIDENCE -CONFESSION -RECORDING -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1192 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCR 106 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCC 510 = 2002 ( 2 ) JT 371 = 2002 ( 2
) SCALE 349
499. GOKUL & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 27/02/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 67 =
500. HARISINGH M. VASAVA .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 27/02/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1212 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCR 57 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCC 475 = 2002 ( 2 ) JT 333 = 2002 ( 2
) SCALE 324
501. GOKUL & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 27/02/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -M P
Citation(s) 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 67 =
502. SUKHBIR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 20/02/2002 JUDGEMENT
SUPREME COURT -POWERS -EVIDENCE -REVIEW PETITION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1168 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCR 1152 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCC 327 = 2002 ( 3 ) JT 345 = 2002 ( 2
) SCALE 244
503. RANGE FOREST OFFICER .Vs. S.T. HADIMANI DOJ : 15/02/2002 ORDER
SERVICE LAW -TERMINATION -EVIDENCE -AFFIDAVIT
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1147 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCR 1080 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCC 25 = 2002 ( 2 ) JT 238 = 2002 ( 2
) SCALE 242
504. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. RAM NIWAS DOJ : 07/02/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL -APPEAL
Citation(s) 2002 ( 2 ) JT 457 =
505. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. RAM NIWAS DOJ : 07/02/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CHILD WITNESS -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 ( 2 ) JT 457 =
506. CHANDER PAL .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 07/02/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 989 = 2002 (1 ) SCR 872 = 2002 (2 ) SCC 755 = 2002 (2 ) JT 30 = 2002 (2
) SCALE 85
507. MOTIRAM GAMAN PAWAR .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 07/02/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 2 ) JT 637 =
508. GANANATH PATTNAIK .Vs. STATE OF ORISSA DOJ : 06/02/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ADMISSIBILITY -PERPETUAL LEASE
Citation(s) 2002 (1 ) SCR 845 = 2002 (2 ) SCC 619 = 2002 (1 ) JT 608 = 2002 (2 ) SCALE 36
509. GURDIAL SINGH & ORS. .Vs. RAJ KUMAR ANEJA & ORS. DOJ : 04/02/2002 JUDGEMENT
RENT LAW -EVICTION -SUB LETTING -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1003 = 2002 (1 ) SCR 817 = 2002 (2 ) SCC 445 = 2002 (1 ) JT 633 = 2002 (2
) SCALE 13
510. BHUPAN .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 04/02/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 820 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCC 556 = 2002 ( 1 ) JT 545 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCALE 4
511. DEEPAK KUMAR .Vs. RAVI VIRMANI & ANR. DOJ : 01/02/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1320 = 2002 (1 ) SCR 786 = 2002 (2 ) SCC 737 = 2002 (1 ) JT 555 = 2002 (1
) SCALE 570
512. DEEPAK KUMAR .Vs. RAVI VIRMANI & ANR. DOJ : 01/02/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -COURTS -DUTY
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 1320 = 2002 (1 ) SCR 786 = 2002 (2 ) SCC 737 = 2002 (1 ) JT 555 = 2002 (1
) SCALE 570
513. IRENE .Vs. V.S. VENKATARAMAN & ANR. DOJ : 30/01/2002 ORDER
RENT LAW -SUB LETTING -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 2 ) JT 124 =
514. BABURAM .Vs. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH DOJ : 29/01/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -BRIDE BURNING -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 758 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCC 502 = 2002 ( 1 ) JT 506 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCALE 461
515. AKHIL ALI JEHANGIR ALI SAYYED .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 24/01/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -ARREST
Citation(s) 2003 ( 2 ) SCC 708 = 2002 ( 2 ) JT 158 =
516. T. MOHAN .Vs. KANNAMMAL & ANR. DOJ : 23/01/2002 ORDER
EVIDENCE -AGREEMENT OF SALE -EXECUTION -DOCUMENT
Citation(s) 2002 (10 ) SCC 82 = 2002 (2 ) JT 163 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 47 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

517. STATE OF HARYANA .Vs. VIKRAM SINGH DOJ : 22/01/2002 JUDGEMENT


NARCOTIC DRUGS -SEARCH AND SEIZURE -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 731 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCC 676 = 2002 ( 1 ) JT 235 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCALE 288
518. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. SURINDER KAUR (D) DOJ : 21/01/2002 ORDER
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -MOTOR VEHICLES -AWARD -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 ( 1 ) JT 426 =
519. PANDURANG KALU PATIL & ANR. .Vs. STAE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 17/01/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 733 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCR 338 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCC 490 = 2002 ( 1 ) JT 229 = 2002 ( 1
) SCALE 290
520. DEVI RAM .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 17/01/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -SUICIDE -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 (10 ) SCC 76 = 2002 (2 ) JT 166 =
521. STATE OF HARYANA .Vs. RAM SINGH DOJ : 15/01/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 620 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCR 208 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCC 426 = 2002 ( 1 ) JT 273 = 2002 ( 2
) SCALE 149
522. KAJAL SEN & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 15/01/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 617 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCC 551 = 2002 ( 1 ) JT 106 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCALE 133
523. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. SHIV CHARAN DOJ : 15/01/2002 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -TESTIMONY
Citation(s) 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 381 = 2002 ( 1 ) JT 403 =
524. MADHUKAR D. SHENDE .Vs. TARABAI ABA SHEDAGE DOJ : 09/01/2002 JUDGEMENT
SUCCESSION LAW -WILL -EXECUTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 637 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCR 132 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCC 85 = 2002 ( 1 ) JT 74 = 2002 ( 1
) SCALE 103
525. DARSHAN SINGH & ORS. .Vs. GUJJAR SINGH (DEAD) BY LRS. & ORS. DOJ : 08/01/2002 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -PRESUMPTION -DEATH -NOT HEARD FOR SEVEN DAYS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 606 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCR 91 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCC 62 = 2002 ( 1 ) JT 11 = 2002 ( 1
) SCALE 70
526. DILAWAR BALU KURANE .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 08/01/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -FRAMING OF CHARGES -TRIAL COURT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 564 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCR 75 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCC 135 = 2002 ( 1 ) JT 6 = 2002 ( 1
) SCALE 47
527. JASSA SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 08/01/2002 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -BENEFIT OF DOUBT -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 520 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCC 481 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 593 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCALE 26
528. LIMBAJI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 14/12/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -PRESUMPTION -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 491 = 2001 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 672 = 2001 (10 ) SCC 340 = 2001 (2
) Suppl. JT 79 = 2001 (8 ) SCALE 522
529. PRAKASH DHAWAL KHAIRNAR PATIL .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 12/12/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONFESSIONAL STATEMENT
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 340 = 2001 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 612 = 2002 (2 ) SCC 35 = 2001 (2 ) Suppl. JT 243 = 2001
(8 ) SCALE 482
530. MAJID ETC. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 11/12/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 382 = 2001 (10 ) SCC 6 = 2001 (10 ) JT 353 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCALE 448
531. MEHARBAN SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 05/12/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -PROSECUTION WITNESS -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 299 = 2001 (10 ) SCC 57 = 2001 (10 ) JT 459 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCALE 382
532. BRIJ LAL .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 04/12/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -HARYANA
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 291 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 700 = 2001 (10 ) JT 510 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCALE 359
533. RAMA MANGARUJI CHACHERKAR .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 04/12/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -BOMB BLAST -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 283 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 724 = 2001 (10 ) JT 514 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCALE 347
534. BRIJ LAL .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 04/12/2001 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -DISCREPANCY -EFFECT
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 291 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 700 = 2001 (10 ) JT 510 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCALE 359
535. MADANLAL .Vs. SHYAMLAL DOJ : 09/11/2001 ORDER
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE -AGREEMENT OF SALE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 100 = 2001 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 252 = 2002 (1 ) SCC 535 = 2001 (2
) Suppl. JT 389 = 2001 (8 ) SCALE 172

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 48 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

536. JAYAWANT DATTATRAY SURYARAO .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 05/11/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 143 = 2001 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 54 = 2001 (10 ) SCC 109 = 2001 ( 9 ) JT 605 = 2001 ( 8
) SCALE 36
537. SEWAKE @ RAMSEWAK .Vs. STATE OF M.P. & ANR. DOJ : 31/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -NATURAL WITNESS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 50 = 2001 (10 ) SCC 1 = 2001 ( 9 ) JT 312 = 2001 ( 7 ) SCALE 570
538. THANEDAR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 30/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 175 = 2001 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 579 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 487 = 2001 ( 9 ) JT 293 = 2001 ( 7
) SCALE 499
539. THANEDAR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 30/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -IDENTIFICATION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 175 = 2001 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 579 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 487 = 2001 ( 9 ) JT 293 = 2001 ( 7
) SCALE 499
540. GULAM HUSSAIN SHAIKH CHOUGULE .Vs. S. REYNOLDS SUPTD. OF CUSTOMS MARMGOA DOJ
: 19/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CUSTOMS -EVIDENCE -STATEMENT -RECORDING
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2930 = 2001 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 476 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 155 = 2001 ( 9 ) JT 89 = 2001 ( 7
) SCALE 409
541. PATEL HIRALAL JOITARAM .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 18/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DEATH BY BURNING -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2944 = 2001 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 378 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 22 = 2001 ( 9 ) JT 282 = 2001 ( 7
) SCALE 440
542. MANGILAL .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN & ANR. DOJ : 18/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CRUELTY -ATTEMPT TO MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2937 = 2001 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 392 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCC 519 = 2001 ( 9 ) JT 172 = 2001 ( 7
) SCALE 324
543. KASHIRAM & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 17/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2902 = 2001 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 263 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 71 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 650 = 2001 ( 7
) SCALE 310
544. T.N. LAKSHMAIAH .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 16/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -INSANITY -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3828 = 2001 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 200 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 219 = 2001 ( 9 ) JT 95 = 2001 ( 7
) SCALE 256
545. RAMJI SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 12/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -COMMON INTENTION -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3853 = 2001 ( 9 ) SCC 528 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 521 = 2001 ( 7 ) SCALE 148
546. ANANGA UDAY SINGH DEO .Vs. RANGA NATH MISHRA & ORS. DOJ : 12/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
ELECTION LAW -RAJYA SABHA -CORRUPT PRACTICE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2992 = 2001 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 88 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 499 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 574 = 2001 ( 7
) SCALE 172
547. MUNSHI PRASAD & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 10/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONVICTION -DEFENCE WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3031 = 2001 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 25 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 351 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 406 = 2001 ( 7
) SCALE 114
548. DINESH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 10/10/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2374 = 2001 (10 ) JT 144 =
549. CHANDRA SHEKHER BIND & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 09/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 4024 = 2001 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 658 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCC 690 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 386
550. DILIP & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 09/10/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3049 = 2001 ( 9 ) SCC 452 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 390 = 2001 ( 7 ) SCALE 51
551. AMARJEET SINGH .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 04/10/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -NARCOTIC DRUGS -INCONSISTENCY
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2634 = 2003 (11 ) SCC 498 = 2001 (10 ) JT 540 =
552. KALYAN & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 28/09/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -FIR -PARTISAN WITNESS
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3976 = 2001 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 407 = 2001 ( 9 ) SCC 632 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 200
553. SURJIT KAUR .Vs. D.S. KAPOOR & ORS. DOJ : 28/09/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -COMPLAINT -GROUNDS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 ( 9 ) SCC 468 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 198 = 2001 ( 6 ) SCALE 567

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 49 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

554. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. NAIB DIN DOJ : 28/09/2001 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -AFFIDAVIT -SAMPLE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3955 = 2001 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 396 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCC 578 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 189 = 2001 ( 6
) SCALE 532
555. RAM GULAM CHAUDHURY AND ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 25/09/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -INVESTIGATION -VISIBILITY
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2842 = 2001 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 279 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCC 311 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 110 = 2001 ( 6
) SCALE 490
556. JASBIR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 20/09/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2386 = 2001 (10 ) JT 552 =
557. GURPRIT SINGH @ BITTU .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 20/09/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -CONFESSION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2390 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 201 = 2001 (10 ) JT 217 =
558. DARSHAN .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 19/09/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -SELF DEFENCE -AFTER INCIDENT
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2344 = 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 755 = 2001 (10 ) JT 555 =
559. MURUGAIAH .Vs. ANNATHAI DOJ : 18/09/2001 ORDER
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -HINDU MARRIAGE -CONJUGAL RIGHTS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 604 = 2001 (10 ) JT 558 =
560. GOPAL .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 18/09/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -NARCOTIC DRUGS -EVIDENCE -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2337 = 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 595 = 2001 (10 ) JT 543 =
561. GOPAL .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 18/09/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -NARCOTIC DRUGS -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2337 = 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 595 = 2001 (10 ) JT 543 =
562. SUKHDEV YADAV & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 13/09/2001 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -STATEMENT -TRUTHWORTHINESS -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3678 = 2001 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 91 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCC 86 = 2001 ( 7 ) JT 597 = 2001 ( 6
) SCALE 292
563. SUKHDEV YADAV & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 13/09/2001 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -STATEMENT -SUSPENSION -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3678 = 2001 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 91 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCC 86 = 2001 ( 7 ) JT 597 = 2001 ( 6
) SCALE 292
564. JAGDISH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 13/09/2001 ORDER
NARCOTIC DRUGS -SEARCH AND SEIZURE -EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2540 = 2003 ( 9 ) SCC 159 = 2001 (10 ) JT 330 =
565. MUNGESHWAR PRASAD CHAURASIA .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 13/09/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -PARENTS
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2531 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 163 = 2001 (10 ) JT 344 =
566. PURAN SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 12/09/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -BIHAR
Citation(s) 2001 ( 8 ) JT 647 =
567. KRIPAL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. & ORS. DOJ : 12/09/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -ALTERATION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2547 = 2001 (10 ) JT 341 =
568. P.H. PANDIAN .Vs. P. VELDURAI & ANR. DOJ : 11/09/2001 ORDER
ELECTION LAW -DISQUALIFICATION -CORRUPT PRACTICE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 ( 9 ) JT 10 = 2001 ( 6 ) SCALE 449
569. LATEL .Vs. STATE OF CHHATTISGARH DOJ : 11/09/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -PRIVATE DEFENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3747 = 2001 ( 9 ) SCC 135 = 2001 ( 7 ) JT 618 = 2001 ( 6 ) SCALE 265
570. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. RAMANJANAPPA & ORS. DOJ : 11/09/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONVICTION -ACQUITTAL -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3515 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCC 387 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 19 = 2001 ( 6 ) SCALE 290
571. BISHWANATH JHA & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 06/09/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -DACOITY -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2001 (10 ) JT 333 =
572. LALLOO & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH DOJ : 05/09/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -RELIABILITY -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 431 = 2001 ( 9 ) JT 18 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCALE 338
573. OCHATHEVAR .Vs. STATE BY INSP. OF POLICE T.N. DOJ : 05/09/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -COMMON INTENTION -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2392 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 203 = 2001 (10 ) JT 266 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 50 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

574. CHHIDAMILAL & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 04/09/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -ALTERATION
Citation(s) 2002 ( 9 ) SCC 369 = 2001 ( 9 ) JT 42 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCALE 341
575. DONDAPATI NARAYANA REDDY .Vs. DUGGIREDDY VENKATANARAYANA REDDY & ORS. DOJ
: 29/08/2001 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -SUIT -PARTITION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3685 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCC 115 = 2001 ( 7 ) JT 112 = 2001 ( 5 ) SCALE 566
576. FIROZUDDIN BASHEERUDDIN & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 20/08/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CRIMINAL CONSPIRACY -EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3488 = 2001 ( 7 ) SCC 596 = 2001 ( 6 ) JT 547 = 2001 ( 5 ) SCALE 33
577. KANNUSAMI .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 14/08/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2001 (10 ) JT 524 =
578. AYODHYA PATHAK & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 14/08/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2001 (10 ) JT 103 =
579. VICCO LABORATORIES .Vs. ART COMMERCIA ADVERTISING PVT. LTD. DOJ : 13/08/2001
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION -EVIDENCE -COURT INTERFERENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2753 = 2001 (1 ) Suppl. SCR 451 = 2001 (7 ) SCC 81 = 2001 (6 ) JT 566 = 2001 (5
) SCALE 180
580. N. KAMALAM (DEAD) .Vs. AYYASAMY DOJ : 03/08/2001 JUDGEMENT
SUCCESSION LAW -TRANSFER OF PROPERTY -WILL -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2802 = 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 272 = 2001 ( 7 ) SCC 503 = 2001 ( 6 ) JT 219 = 2001 ( 5
) SCALE 65
581. NIRMALA DEVI .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 01/08/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CHILD -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 (10 ) JT 86 =
582. NIRMALA DEVI .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 01/08/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -IMPRISONMENT -ENHANCEMENT
Citation(s) 2001 (10 ) JT 86 =
583. STATE OF M.P. .Vs. SARDAR DOJ : 25/07/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -UNLAWFUL ASSEMBLY -EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3121 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCR 1161 = 2001 ( 6 ) SCC 433 = 2001 ( 6 ) JT 41 = 2001 ( 4
) SCALE 548
584. GADE LAKSHMI MANGRAJU @ RAMESH .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 10/07/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -FINGER PRINT -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2677 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCR 830 = 2001 ( 6 ) SCC 205 = 2001 ( 5 ) JT 340 = 2001 ( 4
) SCALE 265
585. SUO MOTO PROCEEDINGS AGAINST MR. R. KARUPPAN ADVOCATE .Vs. DOJ : 12/05/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -AFFIDAVIT -VALIDITY
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2204 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCR 750 = 2001 ( 5 ) SCC 289 = 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 332 = 2001 ( 4
) SCALE 199
586. KANTI DEVI & ANR. .Vs. POSHI RAM DOJ : 11/05/2001 JUDGEMENT
FAMILY LAW -PATERNITY -CHILD -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2226 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCR 729 = 2001 ( 5 ) SCC 311 = 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 87 = 2001 ( 4
) SCALE 195
587. KANTI DEVI & ANR. .Vs. POSHI RAM DOJ : 11/05/2001 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CHILD -BIRTH -LEGITIMACY
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2226 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCR 729 = 2001 ( 5 ) SCC 311 = 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 87 = 2001 ( 4
) SCALE 195
588. LAXMIBAI .Vs. KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION BANGALORE DOJ : 11/05/2001 ORDER
MOTOR VEHICLES -ACCIDENT -EVIDENCE -COMPENSATION
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2208 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCR 747 = 2001 ( 5 ) SCC 59 = 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 364
589. SULEKH CHAND .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 02/05/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -MURDER
Citation(s) 2001 (10 ) SCC 154 = 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 507 =
590. KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPN. .Vs. LAKSHMIDEVAMMA & ANR. DOJ : 01/05/2001 JUDGEMENT
ENQUIRY REPORT -ADDITIONAL CHARGES -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2090 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCR 284 = 2001 ( 5 ) SCC 433 = 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 461
591. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. BASAPPA DOJ : 26/04/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 329 =
592. NIHORE KOERI AND ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 10/04/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -ASSAULT
Citation(s) 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 297 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 51 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

593. UKA RAM .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 10/04/2001 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 1814 = 2001 ( 2 ) SCR 1052 = 2001 ( 5 ) SCC 254 = 2001 ( 4 ) JT 472 = 2001 ( 3
) SCALE 251
594. NARSINGH PRASAD SINGH .Vs. RAJ KUMAR @ PAPPU & ORS. DOJ : 04/04/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DYING DECLARATION -MENTALLY ILL -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 1828 = 2001 ( 2 ) SCR 984 = 2001 ( 4 ) SCC 522 = 2001 ( 4 ) JT 531 = 2001 ( 3
) SCALE 250
595. SATNAM SINGH (DEAD) BY LRS & ORS. .Vs. SADHU SINGH & ORS. DOJ : 29/03/2001 ORDER
EVIDENCE -WITNESS -DEATH -CROSS EXAMINATION
Citation(s) 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 545 =
596. SUCHA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 22/03/2001 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -ABDUCTION -MURDER -PRESUMPTION
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 1436 = 2001 ( 2 ) SCR 644 = 2001 ( 4 ) SCC 375 = 2001 ( 4 ) JT 107 = 2001 ( 2
) SCALE 543
597. MUNDLAPADI KRISHNAIAH .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 22/03/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -RELIABILITY
Citation(s) 2003 (12 ) SCC 188 = 2001 (5 ) JT 322 = 2001 (4 ) SCALE 594
598. TARA CHAND DUBEY (DEAD) BY LRS. .Vs. AJIT KUMAR MUKHERJEE (DEAD) BY LRS. DOJ : 21/03/2001 ORDER
SPECIFIC RELIEF -PART PERFORMANCE -EVIDENCE -WILLINGNESS
Citation(s) 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 621 =
599. STATE OF KERALA .Vs. VASUDEVAN PILLAI DOJ : 20/03/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -ACQUITTAL -HIGH COURTS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 ( 5 ) JT 483 =
600. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR HIGH COURT OF A.P. .Vs. THOTA SESHU & ANR. DOJ : 20/03/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2001 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 511 =
601. SOHAN & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA & ANR. DOJ : 02/03/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 1380 = 2001 ( 2 ) SCR 309 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCC 620 = 2001 ( 3 ) JT 262 = 2001 ( 2
) SCALE 357
602. BOYA T. VENKATESWARLU & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 01/03/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -INJURY -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2419 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 208 = 2001 (5 ) JT 309 =
603. KAREWWA & ORS. .Vs. HUSSENSAB KHANSAHEB WAJANTRI & ORS. DOJ : 01/03/2001 ORDER
EVIDENCE -PRESUMPTION -ENTRY -REVENUE RECORD
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 504 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 315 = 2001 (1 ) Suppl. JT 611 =
604. SANDEEP .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 26/02/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 1103 = 2001 ( 9 ) SCC 41 = 2001 ( 3 ) JT 136 = 2001 ( 2 ) SCALE 331
605. BIPIN SHANTILAL PANCHAL .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT & ANR. DOJ : 22/02/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -EVIDENCE -RECORDING -SPEEDY TRIAL
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 1158 = 2001 ( 2 ) SCR 29 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCC 1 = 2001 ( 3 ) JT 120
606. SETH PAL .Vs. STATE OF H. P. DOJ : 21/02/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 (12 ) SCC 169 = 2001 (1 ) Suppl. JT 255 =
607. HANSRAJ @ HANSU SHANKAR GAUD & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 15/02/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -INTERESTED WITNESS -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2001 ( 5 ) JT 315 = 2001 ( 2 ) SCALE 577
608. SWARN KAUR & ORS. .Vs. JAL KAUR & ORS. DOJ : 08/02/2001 ORDER
EVIDENCE -SALE DEED -CONSIDERATION -PROOF
Citation(s) 2001 ( 5 ) JT 250 =
609. NAJRA .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 08/02/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2001 ( 5 ) JT 530 =
610. SANJAY @ KAKA ETC. ETC. .Vs. STATE (N.C.T. OF DELHI) DOJ : 07/02/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 979 = 2001 ( 1 ) SCR 904 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCC 190 = 2001 ( 2 ) JT 461 =
611. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. CHIRANJILAL DOJ : 01/02/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -INTERESTED WITNESS -EVIDENCE -CORROBORATION
Citation(s) 2001 ( 5 ) JT 259 =
612. MANUBHAI CHIMANLAL SENMA (SENWA) AND OTHERS .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 11/01/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -COMMON INTENTION -WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2004 (10 ) SCC 173 = 2001 (3 ) JT 482 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 52 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

613. ABDUL RASHID .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 11/01/2001 ORDER


NARCOTIC DRUGS -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -CONFESSION
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2422 = 2001 ( 9 ) SCC 578 = 2001 ( 3 ) JT 183 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCALE 546
614. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. MAGNI RAM DOJ : 10/01/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 2430 = 2001 ( 9 ) SCC 589 = 2001 ( 3 ) JT 541 =
615. LAL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT & ANR. DOJ : 09/01/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 746 = 2001 ( 1 ) SCR 111 = 2001 ( 3 ) SCC 221 = 2001 ( 1 ) JT 410 = 2001 ( 1
) SCALE 284
616. MAKHAN LAL BANGAL .Vs. MANAS BHUNIA & ORS. DOJ : 03/01/2001 JUDGEMENT
ELECTION LAW -CORRUPT PRACTICE -EVIDENCE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 490 = 2001 ( 1 ) SCR 17 = 2001 ( 2 ) SCC 652 = 2001 ( 1 ) JT 252 = 2001 ( 1
) SCALE 11
617. BABU KUTTAN R. PILLAI & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 15/12/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DACOITY -CRIMINAL CONSPIRACY
Citation(s) 2001 ( 9 ) SCC 409 = 2001 ( 1 ) JT 66 = 2000 ( 8 ) SCALE 418
618. GURA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 06/12/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -EVIDENCE -HOSTILE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 330 = 2000 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 408 = 2001 ( 2 ) SCC 205 = 2000 ( 3
) Suppl. JT 528 = 2000 ( 8 ) SCALE 147
619. STATE GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI .Vs. SUNIL & ANR. DOJ : 29/11/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -RAPE
Citation(s) 2000 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 144 = 2001 ( 1 ) SCC 652 = 2000 ( 3 ) Suppl. JT 267 = 2000 ( 7
) SCALE 692
620. KANHAIYALAL VISHINDAS GIDWANI .Vs. ARUN DATTATRAY MEHTA & ORS. DOJ : 16/11/2000 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -BURDEN OF PROOF -NOMINATION -SIGNATURE
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 3681 = 2001 ( 1 ) SCC 78 = 2000 ( 3 ) Suppl. JT 1 = 2000 ( 7 ) SCALE 545
621. SHAMSHER KHAN .Vs. STATE (NCT OF DELHI) DOJ : 19/10/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -SENTENCE
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 3662 = 2000 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 287 = 2000 ( 8 ) SCC 568 = 2000 ( 7 ) SCALE 253
622. MANISH DIXIT .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 18/10/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ABDUCTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 93 = 2000 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 74 = 2001 ( 1 ) SCC 596 = 2000 ( 2 ) Suppl. JT 237 = 2000
( 7 ) SCALE 218
623. STATE OF KERALA .Vs. P. SUGATHAN DOJ : 26/09/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONSPIRACY -SCOPE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 3323 = 2000 ( 8 ) SCC 203 = 2000 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 161 = 2000 ( 6 ) SCALE 487
624. BHAGWAN DAS .Vs. GIRJA SHANKER DOJ : 20/09/2000 ORDER
EVIDENCE -PARTITION DEED -REGISTRATION -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2000 ( 1 ) Suppl. JT 246 =
625. STATE OF W.B. .Vs. MIR MOHAMMAD OMAR & ORS. ETC. DOJ : 29/08/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ABDUCTION -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 2988 = 2000 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 712 = 2000 ( 8 ) SCC 382 = 2000 ( 9 ) JT 467 = 2000 ( 6
) SCALE 148
626. STATE OF H.P. .Vs. MANGO RAM DOJ : 24/08/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -CONSENT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 2798 = 2000 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 626 = 2000 ( 7 ) SCC 224 = 2000 ( 9 ) JT 408 = 2000 ( 6
) SCALE 89
627. S. SAKTIVEL (DEAD) .Vs. M. VENUGOPAL PILLAI DOJ : 10/08/2000 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DEEDS & DOCUMENTS -REGISTRATION -FAMILY SETTLEMENT
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 2633 = 2000 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 361 = 2000 ( 7 ) SCC 104 = 2000 ( 9 ) JT 345 = 2000 ( 5
) SCALE 517
628. ROSAMMAL ISSETHEENAMMAL FERNANDEZ (DEAD) .Vs. JOOSA MARIYAN FERNANDEZ DOJ
: 09/08/2000 ORDER
EVIDENCE -PARTITION -GIFT DEED -GENUINENESS
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 2857 = 2000 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 336 = 2000 ( 7 ) SCC 189 = 2000 ( 9 ) JT 240 = 2000 ( 5
) SCALE 600
629. GULAM HUSSAIN & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF DELHI DOJ : 04/08/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -BRIDE BURNING -DYING DECLARATION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 2480 = 2000 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 141 = 2000 ( 7 ) SCC 254 = 2000 ( 8 ) JT 466 = 2000 ( 5
) SCALE 430
630. SUDHAKAR & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 17/07/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -RAPE -SUICIDE
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 2602 = 2000 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 507 = 2000 ( 6 ) SCC 671 = 2000 ( 8 ) JT 184 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 53 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

631. STATE OF TAMIL NADU .Vs. J. JAYALALITHA DOJ : 09/05/2000 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONFESSION -EXCULPATORY STATEMENT
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 1589 = 2000 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 23 = 2000 ( 5 ) SCC 440 = 2000 ( 6 ) JT 260 = 2000 ( 4
) SCALE 390
632. AJAY SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 27/04/2000 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -MURDER
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 3538 = 2000 ( 9 ) SCC 730 = 2000 ( 7 ) JT 391 =
633. NIRMAL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 30/03/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -RECORDING
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 1416 = 2000 ( 2 ) SCR 807 = 2000 ( 4 ) SCC 41 = 2000 ( 4 ) JT 85 = 2000 ( 2
) SCALE 645
634. SURESH RAI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 30/03/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -RIVALRY
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 2207 = 2000 ( 2 ) SCR 796 = 2000 ( 4 ) SCC 84 = 2000 ( 4 ) JT 12 = 2000 ( 3
) SCALE 1
635. SUBHRA MUKHERJEE & ANR. .Vs. BHARAT COKING COAL LTD. & ORS. DOJ : 08/03/2000 JUDGEMENT
COMPANY LAW -LIFTING THE CORPORATE VEIL -EVIDENCE -BURDEN OF PROOF
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 1203 = 2000 ( 3 ) SCC 312 = 2000 ( 3 ) JT 55 = 2000 ( 2 ) SCALE 259
636. RANG BAHADUR SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 07/03/2000 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -BENEFIT OF DOUBT -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 1209 = 2000 ( 3 ) SCC 454 = 2000 ( 2 ) JT 621 = 2000 ( 2 ) SCALE 247
637. KALLIKATT KUNHU .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 24/02/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 1235 = 2000 ( 1 ) SCR 1162 = 2000 ( 3 ) SCC 50 = 2000 ( 2 ) JT 379 = 2000 ( 2
) SCALE 74
638. KOLUTTUMOTTIL RAZAK .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 24/02/2000 ORDER
NARCOTIC DRUGS -EVIDENCE -SEARCH AND SEIZURE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2000 ( 4 ) SCC 465 =
639. COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS .Vs. TELEVISION & COMPONENTS LTD. DOJ : 24/02/2000 ORDER
CUSTOMS -VALUATION -TAPE DECK MECHANISMS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 1114 = 2000 ( 1 ) SCR 1139 = 2000 ( 3 ) SCC 131 = 2000 ( 2 ) JT 412 = 2000 ( 2
) SCALE 35
640. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH .Vs. SURINDER MOHAN & OTHERS DOJ : 07/02/2000 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CROSS EXAMINATION -RIGHT OF ACCUSED -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 1862 = 2000 ( 1 ) SCR 659 = 2000 ( 2 ) SCC 396 = 2000 ( 1 ) JT 593 = 2000 ( 1
) SCALE 450
641. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. KHEMRAJ DOJ : 10/01/2000 ORDER
EVIDENCE -SECONDARY EVIDENCE -AFFIDAVIT
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 1759 = 2000 ( 9 ) SCC 241 = 2000 ( 2 ) JT 40 =
642. RANDHIR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA & ANR. DOJ : 06/01/2000 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -FALSE STATEMENT -COURTS
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 544 = 2000 ( 1 ) SCC 760 = 2000 ( 1 ) JT 59 = 2000 ( 1 ) SCALE 39
643. SATNAM SINGH .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 17/12/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -DEATH
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 423 = 1999 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 422 = 2000 (1 ) SCC 662 = 1999 (10 ) JT 138 = 1999 (7
) SCALE 539
644. MOHD. ANWAR .Vs. STATE OF DELHI DOJ : 17/12/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -COMMON INTENTION -MURDER
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 465 = 1999 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 485 = 2000 (1 ) SCC 615 = 1999 (10 ) JT 121 = 1999 (7
) SCALE 552
645. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. SURESH DOJ : 10/12/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -RAPE
Citation(s) 1999 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 215 = 2000 (1 ) SCC 471 = 1999 (9 ) JT 513 = 1999 (7 ) SCALE 386
646. PADAM SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 30/11/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -REASONABLE DOUBT
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 361 = 1999 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 59 = 2000 (1 ) SCC 621 = 1999 (9 ) JT 351
647. L.L. KALE .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 30/11/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 366 = 2000 ( 1 ) SCC 295 = 1999 ( 9 ) JT 342 = 1999 ( 7 ) SCALE 254
648. ISHWAR DASS JAIN (DEAD) THRU LRS. .Vs. SOHAN LAL (DEAD) BY LRS. DOJ : 29/11/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -MORTGAGE -REDEMPTION -DEEDS & DOCUMENTS
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 426 = 1999 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 24 = 2000 (1 ) SCC 434 = 1999 (9 ) JT 305
649. NARAYAN SHARMA (DR.) & ANR. .Vs. PANKAJ KR. LEHKAR (DR.) & ORS. DOJ : 03/11/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -ADMISSION -MEDICAL COLLEGE -ASSAM
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 72 = 1999 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 364 = 2000 ( 1 ) SCC 44 = 1999 ( 8 ) JT 612

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 54 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

650. DWARIKA PRASAD SATPATHY .Vs. BIDYUT PRAVA DIXIT & ANR. DOJ : 14/10/1999 JUDGEMENT
FAMILY LAW -MARRIAGE -EVIDENCE -MAINTENANCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3348 = 1999 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 684 = 1999 ( 7 ) SCC 675 = 1999 ( 8 ) JT 329 = 1999 ( 6
) SCALE 579
651. RAMJI RAI .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 13/10/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT -NOT CONFIRMED
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3857 = 1999 (8 ) SCC 389 = 1999 (8 ) JT 236 = 1999 (6 ) SCALE 565
652. ABDUL RASHID IBRAHIM MANSURI .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 12/10/1999 ORDER
NARCOTIC DRUGS -SEARCH AND SEIZURE -EVIDENCE -REFERRED THREE JUDGE BENCH
Citation(s) 2000 ( 2 ) SCC 217 =
653. HEIKRUJAM CHAOBA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF MANIPUR DOJ : 12/10/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -CONDITION PRECEDENT
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 59 = 1999 ( 8 ) SCC 458 = 1999 ( 8 ) JT 205 = 1999 ( 6 ) SCALE 509
654. LEELA RAM (D) THRU DULI CHAND .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA & ANR. DOJ : 06/10/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -EXPERT OPINION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3717 = 1999 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 435 = 1999 (9 ) SCC 525 = 1999 (8 ) JT 274 = 1999 (6
) SCALE 477
655. MAHABIR PRASAD JAIN .Vs. GANGA SINGH DOJ : 05/10/1999 JUDGEMENT
SPECIFIC RELIEF -SUMMARY SUIT -TENANCY -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3873 = 1999 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 415 = 1999 (8 ) SCC 274 = 1999 (7 ) JT 639 = 1999 (6
) SCALE 370
656. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. K. YARAPPA REDDY DOJ : 05/10/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -MURDER
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 185 = 1999 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 359 = 1999 ( 8 ) SCC 715 = 1999 ( 8 ) JT 10 = 1999 ( 6
) SCALE 330
657. KAMAKSHA RAI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 01/10/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION -MURDER
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 53 = 1999 ( 8 ) SCC 701 = 1999 ( 7 ) JT 598 = 1999 ( 6 ) SCALE 296
658. SUKHAR .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 01/10/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -INJURED WITNESS -CORROBORATION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3883 = 1999 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 314 = 1999 (9 ) SCC 507 = 1999 (7 ) JT 537 = 1999 (6
) SCALE 280
659. JAI KARAN .Vs. STATE OF (N.C.T. DELHI) DOJ : 27/09/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3512 = 1999 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 200 = 1999 (8 ) SCC 161 = 1999 (7 ) JT 514 = 1999 (6
) SCALE 198
660. JAI KARAN .Vs. STATE OF (N.C.T. DELHI) DOJ : 27/09/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DYING DECLARATION -BRIDE BURNING -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3512 = 1999 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 200 = 1999 (8 ) SCC 161 = 1999 (7 ) JT 514 = 1999 (6
) SCALE 198
661. RAMMI @ RAMESHWAR ETC. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 21/09/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -WITNESS -REEXAMINATION -INCONSISTENCY
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3544 = 1999 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 1 = 1999 (8 ) SCC 649 = 1999 (7 ) JT 247 = 1999 (6
) SCALE 69
662. RAMESH PRASAD .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 17/09/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -FIR -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 398 = 1999 ( 9 ) SCC 433 = 1999 ( 7 ) JT 115 = 1999 ( 6 ) SCALE 1
663. RAMESH S/O LAXMAN GAVLI .Vs. STATE OF M.P. & ORS. DOJ : 16/09/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -DELAY
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3759 = 1999 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 603 = 2000 (1 ) SCC 243 = 1999 (6 ) JT 627 = 1999 (5
) SCALE 641
664. NARENDER SINGH .Vs. MALA RAM & ANR. DOJ : 15/09/1999 JUDGEMENT
ELECTION LAW -LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY -CORRUPT PRACTICE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3655 = 1999 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 438 = 1999 (8 ) SCC 198 = 1999 (7 ) JT 24 = 1999 (5
) SCALE 521
665. SARJUDAS .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 15/09/1999 ORDER
NARCOTIC DRUGS -EVIDENCE -EXPERT OPINION -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 403 = 1999 ( 8 ) SCC 508 = 1999 ( 8 ) JT 118 = 1999 ( 6 ) SCALE 417
666. RAVINDER KUMAR SHARMA .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 14/09/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -NEWS -NEWSPAPER -PRESUMPTION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3571 = 1999 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 339 = 1999 (7 ) SCC 435 = 1999 (6 ) JT 565
667. STATE OF H.P. .Vs. JAI LAL & ORS. DOJ : 13/09/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -EXPERT EVIDENCE -CROP -DESTRUCTION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3318 = 1999 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 318 = 1999 ( 7 ) SCC 280 = 1999 ( 6 ) JT 548 = 1999 ( 5
) SCALE 445

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 55 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

668. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. GURDEEP SINGH DOJ : 08/09/1999 JUDGEMENT


EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -CORROBORATION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3724 = 1999 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 237 = 1999 (7 ) SCC 714 = 1999 (6 ) JT 514 = 1999 (5
) SCALE 388
669. UMAR ABDUL SAKOOR SORATHIA .Vs. INTELLIGENCE OFFICER NARCOTIC CONTROL BUREAU DOJ
: 06/08/1999 JUDGEMENT
NARCOTIC DRUGS -FRAMING OF CHARGES -IDENTIFICATION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 2562 = 1999 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 113 = 2000 ( 1 ) SCC 138 = 1999 ( 5 ) JT 394 = 1999 ( 4
) SCALE 497
670. SHRIPATRAO .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 04/08/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -DEATH
Citation(s) 2000 (10 ) SCC 320 = 1999 ( 6 ) JT 264 = 1999 ( 5 ) SCALE 206
671. SUMITRA BANIK .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 29/07/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -COMMON INTENTION -EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 2594 = 1999 ( 9 ) SCC 24 = 1999 ( 5 ) JT 362 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCALE 477
672. PAL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 22/07/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -IDENTIFICATION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 2548 = 1999 ( 5 ) JT 224 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCALE 351
673. MOHD. ZAHID .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 20/07/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 2416 = 1999 ( 6 ) SCC 120 = 1999 ( 5 ) JT 5 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCALE 173
674. PON ADITHAN .Vs. DEPUTY DIRECTOR NARCOTICS CONTROL BUREAU MADRAS DOJ : 16/07/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CONFESSION -STATEMENT -CUSTODY
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 2355 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCR 897 = 1999 ( 6 ) SCC 1 = 1999 ( 4 ) JT 540 = 1999 ( 4
) SCALE 89
675. BANK OF INDIA & ANR. .Vs. DEGALA SURYANARAYANA DOJ : 12/07/1999 JUDGEMENT
SERVICE LAW -DEPARTMENTAL ENQUIRY -JUDICIAL REVIEW -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 2407 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCR 824 = 1999 ( 5 ) SCC 762 = 1999 ( 4 ) JT 489 = 1999 ( 4
) SCALE 75
676. RAMPRASAD .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 12/05/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -STATEMENT -APPROVER -CORROBORATION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1969 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCR 519 = 1999 ( 5 ) SCC 30 = 1999 ( 4 ) JT 74 = 1999 ( 3
) SCALE 623
677. RAMPRASAD .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 12/05/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -ADMISSIBILITY -ALIVE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1969 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCR 519 = 1999 ( 5 ) SCC 30 = 1999 ( 4 ) JT 74 = 1999 ( 3
) SCALE 623
678. STATE OF HARYANA .Vs. BHAGIRATH DOJ : 12/05/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EXPERT -EXPERT OPINION -COURTS
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 2005 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCR 529 = 1999 ( 5 ) SCC 96 = 1999 ( 3 ) JT 602 = 1999 ( 3
) SCALE 613
679. STATE OF T.N. THRU. SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE CBI/SIT .Vs. NALINI & ORS. DOJ : 11/05/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONFESSION -EVIDENCE -CONSPIRACY
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 2640 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCR 1 = 1999 ( 5 ) SCC 253 = 1999 ( 4 ) JT 106 = 1999 ( 3
) SCALE 241
680. BANOLATA MOHAPATRA .Vs. STATE OF ORISSA DOJ : 11/05/1999 JUDGEMENT
SERVICE LAW -SENIORITY -EVIDENCE -EDUCATION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1739 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCR 457 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCC 618 = 1999 ( 4 ) JT 10 = 1999 ( 3
) SCALE 582
681. NAWAB SINGH .Vs. INDERJIT KAUR DOJ : 06/05/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -SECONDARY EVIDENCE -RENT LAW -EVICTION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1668 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCC 413 = 1999 ( 3 ) JT 419 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCALE 170
682. SURJIT SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 05/05/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 2855 = 1999 ( 5 ) SCC 718 = 1999 ( 4 ) JT 8 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCALE 699
683. M. OMKAR .Vs. REVURI PRAKASH REDDY & ORS. DOJ : 04/05/1999 JUDGEMENT
ELECTION LAW -RECOUNTING OF VOTES -APPLICATION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 2167 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCC 508 = 1999 ( 4 ) JT 24 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCALE 522
684. STATE OF HARYANA .Vs. TEK SINGH & ORS. DOJ : 03/05/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -HIGH COURTS -EVIDENCE -SITUATION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1742 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCR 967 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCC 682 = 1999 ( 3 ) JT 423 = 1999 ( 3
) SCALE 143
685. STATE OF HARYANA .Vs. TEK SINGH & ORS. DOJ : 03/05/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -FIR
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1742 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCR 967 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCC 682 = 1999 ( 3 ) JT 423

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 56 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

686. PAWAN KUMAR GUPTA .Vs. ROCHIRAM NAGDEO DOJ : 20/04/1999 JUDGEMENT
BENAMI TRANSACTION -SALE DEED -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1823 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCR 767 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCC 243 = 1999 ( 3 ) JT 191 = 1999 ( 2
) SCALE 702
687. MANOJ @ BHAU & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 08/04/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -UNLAWFUL ASSEMBLY -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1620 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCR 487 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCC 268 = 1999 ( 2 ) JT 580 =
688. VIJAYAN @ VIJAYAKUMAR .Vs. STATE OF REP. BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE DOJ : 22/03/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1311 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCR 89 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCC 36 = 1999 ( 2 ) JT 322 = 1999 ( 2
) SCALE 164
689. VIJAYAN @ VIJAYAKUMAR .Vs. STATE OF REP. BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE DOJ : 22/03/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -PHOTOGRAPHER -PRIVATE DEFENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1311 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCR 89 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCC 36 = 1999 ( 2 ) JT 322 = 1999 ( 2
) SCALE 164
690. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. TEJA RAM & ORS. DOJ : 19/03/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1776 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCR 29 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCC 507 = 1999 ( 2 ) JT 279 = 1999 ( 2
) SCALE 169
691. VIDHYADHAR .Vs. MANKIKRAO & ANR. DOJ : 17/03/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -PRESUMPTION -WITNESS -EXAMINATION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1441 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCR 1168 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCC 573 = 1999 ( 2 ) JT 183 = 1999 ( 2
) SCALE 93
692. ISWAR BHAI C. PATEL @ BACHU BHAI PATEL .Vs. HARIHAR BEHERA & ANR. DOJ : 16/03/1999 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -JOINDER -EVIDENCE -PRESUMPTION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1341 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCR 1097 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCC 457 = 1999 ( 2 ) JT 250 = 1999 ( 2
) SCALE 108
693. TEHERAKHATOON (D) BY LRS. .Vs. SALAMBIN MOHAMMAD DOJ : 26/02/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DEEDS & DOCUMENTS -GENUINENESS -SIGNATURE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1104 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCR 901 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCC 635 = 1999 ( 2 ) JT 45 = 1999 ( 1
) SCALE 634
694. JIWAN DASS ETC. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 26/02/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MISAPPROPRIATION -PUBLIC SERVANT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1301 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCR 922 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCC 530 = 1999 ( 2 ) JT 1 = 1999 ( 1
) SCALE 648
695. JIWAN DASS ETC. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 26/02/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -ADMISSION -MISAPPROPRIATION -PUBLIC SERVANT
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1301 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCR 922 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCC 530 = 1999 ( 2 ) JT 1 = 1999 ( 1
) SCALE 648
696. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. MAJOR SINGH & ORS. DOJ : 17/02/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -INJURED WITNESS -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1073 = 1999 ( 9 ) SCC 106 = 1999 ( 1 ) JT 494 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCALE 511
697. VIJAYAN @ RAJAN ETC. .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 16/02/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1086 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCR 659 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCC 54 = 1999 ( 1 ) JT 499
698. INDUSTRIAL CREDIT & DEVELOPMENT SYNDICATE NOW CALLED ICDS LT .Vs. SMITHABEN H. PATEL & ORS. DOJ
: 10/02/1999 JUDGEMENT
CONTRACT LAW -JUDGEMENT DEBTOR -NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1036 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCR 555 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCC 80 = 1999 ( 1 ) JT 430
699. STATE OF HARYANA .Vs. RAM PAL & ANR. DOJ : 09/02/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -COMMON INTENTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 ( 9 ) SCC 83 = 1999 ( 1 ) JT 417 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCALE 333
700. RAMCHANDRA OHDAR .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 04/02/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONVICTION -EVIDENCE -GRIEVOUS HURT
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 998 = 1999 ( 9 ) SCC 97 = 1999 ( 1 ) JT 450 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCALE 406
701. RAM KHILARI .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 03/02/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1002 = 1999 ( 9 ) SCC 89 = 1999 ( 1 ) JT 453 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCALE 417
702. GANGES WATERPROOF WORKS (P) LTD. .Vs. U.O.I. DOJ : 29/01/1999 JUDGEMENT
ARBITRATION -ARBITRATOR -MISCONDUCT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1102 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCC 33 = 1999 ( 1 ) JT 191 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCALE 193
703. MOHAN SINGH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 28/01/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -WOUNDS & WEAPONS
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 883 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCR 276 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCC 428 = 1999 ( 1 ) JT 149 = 1999 ( 1
) SCALE 163

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 57 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

704. CALCUTTA MUNICIPAL CORPN. .Vs. PAWAN K. SARAF DOJ : 13/01/1999 ORDER
FOOD ADULTERATION -EVIDENCE -REPORT -PUBLIC ANALYST
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 738 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCR 74 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCC 400 = 1999 ( 1 ) JT 39 = 1999 ( 1
) SCALE 31
705. U.P. STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPN. & ORS. .Vs. MUSAI RAM & ORS. DOJ : 12/01/1999 ORDER
SERVICE LAW -DEPARTMENTAL ENQUIRY -EVIDENCE -JUDICIAL REVIEW
Citation(s) 1999 ( 3 ) SCC 372 = 1999 ( 6 ) JT 6 =
706. PARAS YADAV .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 12/01/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -OMISSION -MURDER
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 644 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCR 55 = 1999 ( 2 ) SCC 126 = 1999 ( 1 ) JT 25 = 1999 ( 1
) SCALE 26
707. DWARKADAS GEHANMAL .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 20/11/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 ( 1 ) SCC 57 = 1998 ( 8 ) JT 100 = 1998 ( 6 ) SCALE 204
708. MAHANTAPPA & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 12/11/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 314 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCC 163 = 1998 ( 7 ) JT 566 = 1998 ( 6 ) SCALE 124
709. IN RE: .Vs. AJAY KUMAR PANDEY ADVOCATE DOJ : 25/09/1998 JUDGEMENT
CONTEMPT OF COURT -SCANDALIZING COURT -CRITICISM -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 3299 = 1998 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 87 = 1998 ( 7 ) SCC 248 = 1998 ( 6 ) JT 571 = 1998 ( 5
) SCALE 393
710. JASPAL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 24/09/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1548 = 1998 ( 7 ) SCC 289 = 1998 ( 6 ) JT 600 = 1998 ( 5 ) SCALE 444
711. RANJIT SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 22/09/1998 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -ACCUSED -SESSIONS COURT
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 3148 = 1998 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 8 = 1998 ( 7 ) SCC 149 = 1998 ( 6 ) JT 512 = 1998 ( 5
) SCALE 375
712. BADRUDDIN .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 21/09/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -COMMON INTENTION -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 3243 = 1998 ( 7 ) SCC 300 = 1998 ( 6 ) JT 488 = 1998 ( 5 ) SCALE 358
713. GURMUKH RAM MADAN (DR.) .Vs. BHAGWAN DAS MADAN DOJ : 31/08/1998 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CERTIFIED COPY -DEEDS & DOCUMENTS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2776 = 1998 ( 7 ) SCC 367 = 1998 ( 6 ) JT 169 = 1998 ( 5 ) SCALE 4
714. PANCHHI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 19/08/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -WITNESS -CHILD WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2726 = 1998 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 40 = 1998 ( 7 ) SCC 177 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 565 = 1998 ( 4
) SCALE 603
715. RAJESH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 13/08/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ABDUCTION -MINOR GIRL -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2724 = 1998 ( 7 ) SCC 324 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 581 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCALE 592
716. SURESH N. BHUSARE & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 11/08/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 3131 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCC 220 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 578 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCALE 601
717. BIHARILAL SONI & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 06/08/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -BRIDE BURNING -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 3114 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCC 229 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 544 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCALE 634
718. DIRECTOR GENERAL INDIAN COUNCIL OF MEDICAL RESEARCH & ORS. .Vs. ANIL KUMAR GHOSH & ANR. DOJ
: 06/08/1998 JUDGEMENT
SERVICE LAW -DEPARTMENTAL ENQUIRY -EVIDENCE -PENALTY
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2592 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCR 1034 = 1998 ( 7 ) SCC 97 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 317 = 1998 ( 4
) SCALE 409
719. RAVINDRA @ RAVI BANSI GOHAR ETC. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA & ORS. DOJ : 04/08/1998 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION PARADE -PLACES -PRACTICE & PROCEDURE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 3031 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCR 978 = 1998 ( 6 ) SCC 609 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 292 = 1998 ( 4
) SCALE 381
720. JAI PRAKASH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 30/07/1998 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -HIGH COURTS
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3361 = 1998 (7 ) SCC 284 = 1998 (5 ) JT 308 = 1998 (4 ) SCALE 363
721. SREERAMA MURTHY .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 29/07/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 3040 = 1998 ( 6 ) SCC 232 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 305 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCALE 396
722. ADYA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 29/07/1998 ORDER
EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -OCCURAL EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 3011 = 1998 ( 6 ) SCC 439 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 327 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCALE 402

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 58 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

723. VAJRALA PARIPURNACHARY .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 28/07/1998 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2680 = 1998 ( 6 ) SCC 463 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 224 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCALE 293
724. KAVITA .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 23/07/1998 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -MEDICAL JURISPRUDENCE -DROWNING
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2473 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCR 902 = 1998 ( 6 ) SCC 108 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 149 = 1998 ( 4
) SCALE 246
725. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. RAJENDRA SINGH DOJ : 22/07/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2554 = 2009 (11 ) SCC 106 = 1998 (5 ) JT 193 = 1998 (4 ) SCALE 288
726. SUBHASH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 21/07/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -CONVICTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1463 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 217 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCALE 307
727. LAKHIYA DEVI .Vs. GIRJA YADAV & ORS. DOJ : 14/07/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2395 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCR 588 = 1999 ( 1 ) SCC 203 = 1998 ( 4 ) JT 593 = 1998 ( 4
) SCALE 125
728. CHACKO @ JACOB .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 29/04/1998 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -INDEPENDENT WITNESS -INJURED WITNESS -NATURAL WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2250 = 1998 ( 5 ) SCC 602 = 1998 ( 4 ) JT 220 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCALE 659
729. SHAIKH UMAR AHMED SHAIKH .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 28/04/1998 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION PARADE -OBJECT -TADA
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1922 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCR 1209 = 1998 ( 5 ) SCC 103 = 1998 ( 3 ) JT 535 = 1998 ( 3
) SCALE 290
730. GOVINDASAMI .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 22/04/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT -RAREST OF RARE CASE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2889 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCR 1135 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCC 531 = 1998 ( 3 ) JT 260 = 1998 ( 3
) SCALE 188
731. RAM BIHARI YADAV .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 21/04/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -CORROBORATION
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1850 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCR 1097 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCC 517 = 1998 ( 3 ) JT 290 = 1998 ( 3
) SCALE 200
732. MOHAR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 16/04/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -INJURY
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2912 = 1998 ( 9 ) SCC 654 = 1998 ( 3 ) JT 582 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCALE 327
733. MOHD. IQBAL M. SHAIKH .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 15/04/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2864 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCR 734 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCC 494 = 1998 ( 3 ) JT 135 =
734. P. KUNHALI .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 15/04/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 ( 3 ) JT 550 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCALE 264
735. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. SIKANDAR ALI DOJ : 03/04/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1862 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCR 658 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCC 298 = 1998 ( 3 ) JT 18 =
736. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. BHOLA SINGH DOJ : 31/03/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1983 = 1998 ( 3 ) JT 286 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCALE 161
737. PUNJAB URBAN PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY .Vs. SHIV SARASWATI IRON & STEEL RE-ROLLING
MILLS DOJ : 24/03/1998 JUDGEMENT
SPECIFIC RELIEF -SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE -EVIDENCE -CONTRACT LAW
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2352 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCC 539 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 587 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCALE 451
738. G.S. WALIA .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 19/03/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -DEATH
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2857 = 1998 ( 5 ) SCC 150 = 1998 ( 3 ) JT 449 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCALE 182
739. GEORGE .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 18/03/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION PARADE -FIR
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1376 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCR 303 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCC 605 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 496 = 1998 ( 2
) SCALE 411
740. AMRIK SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 17/03/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 ( 2 ) JT 561 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCALE 370
741. JOGINDER SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 06/03/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -PRIVATE DEFENCE -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2844 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 426 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCALE 285

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 59 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

742. RONNY @ RONALD JAMES ALWARIS .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 05/03/1998 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION PARADE -WITNESS -SEARCH AND SEIZURE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1251 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCR 162 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCC 625 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 375 = 1998 ( 2
) SCALE 261
743. VARGHESE .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 03/03/1998 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -ROBBERY -WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 ( 2 ) JT 436 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCALE 247
744. KOVVURI SURYA BHASKARA REDDY .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 03/03/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1570 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCR 44 = 1998 ( 9 ) SCC 504 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 275 = 1998 ( 2
) SCALE 178
745. RAJAYYAN & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF KERALA & ANR. DOJ : 03/03/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -SUICIDE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1211 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCR 61 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCC 85 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 248 = 1998 ( 2
) SCALE 153
746. NACHATTAR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 03/03/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2884 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 433 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCALE 343
747. TIRUMALA TIRUPATI DEVASTHANAMS .Vs. K.M. KRISHNAIAH DOJ : 02/03/1998 JUDGEMENT
SPECIFIC RELIEF -EVIDENCE -POSSESSION -ADVERSE POSSESSION
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1132 = 1998 (2 ) SCR 9 = 1998 (3 ) SCC 331 = 1998 (2 ) JT 231 = 1998 (2
) SCALE 119
748. CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION CBI .Vs. V.C. SHUKLA & ORS. DOJ : 02/03/1998 JUDGEMENT
PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -HAWALA CASE -EVIDENCE -CONFESSION
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1406 = 1998 (1 ) SCR 1153 = 1998 (3 ) SCC 410 = 1998 (2 ) JT 172 = 1998 (2
) SCALE 84
749. SANKARA NAGAMALLESWARA RAO & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 26/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DYING DECLARATION -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1998 ( 8 ) SCC 407 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 230 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCALE 111
750. MANGE RAM .Vs. STATE DELHI ADMINISTRATION DOJ : 26/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DYING DECLARATION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 ( 2 ) JT 450 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCALE 341
751. ALI AHMAD & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 26/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -MURDER
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1232 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 241 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCALE 118
752. ALI AHMAD & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 26/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CONVICTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1232 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 241 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCALE 118
753. VELAN KUTTY .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 26/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2888 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 557 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCALE 392
754. SANTENU MITRA .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 20/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
JUVENILE JUSTICES -AGE -DATE OF BIRTH -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1587 = 1998 ( 5 ) SCC 697 = 1998 ( 6 ) JT 404 =
755. STATE OF A.P. .Vs. VEDDULA VEERA REDDY DOJ : 19/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -INTENTION -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1206 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCR 1007 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCC 145 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 67 = 1998 ( 1
) SCALE 684
756. MANORANJAN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF DELHI DOJ : 19/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -STATEMENT
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2811 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCC 523 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 168 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCALE 73
757. RAM KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 19/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -PRIVATE DEFENCE -DEATH -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1437 = 1998 SCR 1017 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 18 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCALE 694
758. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. NAHAR SINGH (DEAD) & ORS. DOJ : 18/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MOTIVE -EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1328 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCR 948 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCC 561 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 41 = 1998 ( 1
) SCALE 699
759. V. UTHIRAPATHI .Vs. ASHRAB ALI DOJ : 18/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
RENT LAW -EVICTION -DECREE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1168 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCR 937 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCC 148 = 1998 ( 2 ) JT 55 = 1998 ( 1
) SCALE 648
760. K. URMILA .Vs. RAM KUMAR VERMA DOJ : 17/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
RENT LAW -EVICTION -BONAFIDE REQUIREMENT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1188 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCC 57 = 1998 ( 1 ) JT 710 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCALE 635

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 60 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

761. PAMMI @ BRIJENDRA SINGH .Vs. GOVT. OF M.P. DOJ : 12/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION PARADE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1185 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCR 842 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCC 700 = 1998 ( 1 ) JT 686 = 1998 ( 1
) SCALE 577
762. PAWAN KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 09/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -CRUELTY -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 958 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCR 746 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCC 309 = 1998 ( 1 ) JT 565 = 1998 ( 1
) SCALE 486
763. STATE OF BIHAR .Vs. ANIRUDH THAKUR DOJ : 06/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DACOITY -EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 921 = 1998 ( 9 ) SCC 616 = 1998 ( 1 ) JT 505 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCALE 419
764. BHARAT SALES LTD. M/S. .Vs. LIFE INSURANCE CORPN. OF INDIA LIC DOJ : 05/02/1998 JUDGEMENT
RENT LAW -EVICTION -SUB LETTING -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1240 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCR 711 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCC 1 = 1998 ( 1 ) JT 753 = 1998 ( 1
) SCALE 613
765. C.V. GOVINDAPPA .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 22/01/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONVICTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 792 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCC 763 = 1998 ( 1 ) JT 193 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCALE 166
766. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. SATYANARAYAN DOJ : 21/01/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CULPABLE HOMICIDE -EVIDENCE -INJURED WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2060 = 1998 ( 8 ) SCC 404 = 1998 ( 1 ) JT 426 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCALE 304
767. RAM KUMAR & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 08/01/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1491 = 1998 ( 9 ) SCC 1 = 1998 ( 9 ) JT 370 =
768. STATE OF KERALA .Vs. M.T. ANANDAN & ANR. DOJ : 06/01/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ACQUITTAL -HIGH COURTS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 673 = 1998 ( 1 ) JT 35 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCALE 55
769. SRI JINNAT MIA @ JINU MIA .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 12/12/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ACQUITTAL -TRIAL COURT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 533 = 1998 ( 9 ) SCC 319 = 1997 (10 ) JT 104 = 1997 ( 7 ) SCALE 614
770. JAGDISH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 12/12/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -STATEMENT
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 732 = 1997 (10 ) JT 28 = 1997 ( 7 ) SCALE 625
771. GENERAL COURT MARTIAL .Vs. ANILTEJ SINGH DHALIWAL COL. DOJ : 12/12/1997 JUDGEMENT
MILITARY LAW -COURT MARTIAL -EVIDENCE -PUNISHMENT
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 983 = 1997 ( 6 ) Suppl. SCR 470 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCC 756 = 1997 (10 ) JT 110 = 1997 ( 7
) SCALE 717
772. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. BANDU @ PRADIP PUNDALIK & ORS. ETC. DOJ : 11/12/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONSPIRACY -EVIDENCE -FIR
Citation(s) 1998 ( 1 ) JT 1 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCALE 2
773. KOTTA PRAKASHAN .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 11/12/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -UNLAWFUL ASSEMBLY -EVIDENCE -RIOTS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1521 = 1997 ( 6 ) Suppl. SCR 408 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCC 609 = 1997 (10 ) JT 18 = 1997 ( 7
) SCALE 577
774. BANWARI RAM .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 10/12/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -UNLAWFUL ASSEMBLY -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 674 = 1998 ( 9 ) SCC 3 = 1997 (10 ) JT 92 = 1997 ( 7 ) SCALE 562
775. STATE OF T.N. ETC. .Vs. SURESH (A-2) & ANR. DOJ : 05/12/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1044 = 1997 ( 6 ) Suppl. SCR 203 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCC 372 = 1997 ( 9 ) JT 647 = 1997 ( 7
) SCALE 402
776. STATE OF T.N. ETC. .Vs. SURESH (A-2) & ANR. DOJ : 05/12/1997 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -STATEMENT -CONFESSION -CORROBORATION
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1044 = 1997 ( 6 ) Suppl. SCR 203 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCC 372 = 1997 ( 9 ) JT 647 = 1997 ( 7
) SCALE 402
777. ASHWANI KUMAR SHARMA .Vs. YADUVANSH SINGH & ORS. DOJ : 01/12/1997 JUDGEMENT
ELECTION LAW -PETITION -EVIDENCE -BIHAR
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 337 = 1997 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 616 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCC 416 = 1997 ( 9 ) JT 541 = 1997 ( 7
) SCALE 319
778. JAG NARAIN DUSADH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 27/11/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONVICTION -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1533 = 1997 (10 ) JT 87 = 1997 ( 7 ) SCALE 516
779. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. SARUP SINGH DOJ : 27/11/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -ACQUITTAL -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2899 = 1997 ( 9 ) JT 539 = 1997 ( 7 ) SCALE 318

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 61 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

780. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. BALDEV SINGH DOJ : 19/11/1997 ORDER


CONSTITUTIONAL LAW -FAIRNESS & REASONABLENESS -NARCOTIC DRUGS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 ( 2 ) SCC 724 =
781. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. BALDEV SINGH DOJ : 19/11/1997 ORDER
NARCOTIC DRUGS -SEARCH AND SEIZURE -EVIDENCE -WOMEN
Citation(s) 1998 ( 2 ) SCC 724 =
782. BHANA KHALPA BHAI PATEL .Vs. ASSISTANT COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS BULSAR GUJARAT DOJ
: 18/11/1997 JUDGEMENT, CUSTOMS -GOLD -CONVICTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1487 = 1997 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 163 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCC 222 = 1997 ( 9 ) JT 114
783. SELVARAJ .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 13/11/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -LIFE IMPRISONMENT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 133 = 1998 ( 9 ) SCC 308 = 1997 ( 9 ) JT 97 = 1997 ( 7 ) SCALE 12
784. SURENDER NARAIN @ MUNNA PANDEY .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 07/11/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -IDENTIFICATION PARADE -EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 192 = 1997 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 97 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCC 76 = 1997 ( 9 ) JT 72 = 1997 ( 6
) SCALE 675
785. KALPNATH RAI .Vs. STATE THRU CBI DOJ : 06/11/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -CONFESSION
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 201 = 1997 ( 8 ) SCC 732 = 1997 ( 9 ) JT 18 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 689
786. KALPNATH RAI .Vs. STATE THRU CBI DOJ : 06/11/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -POLICE WITNESS -EVIDENCE -TADA
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 201 = 1997 ( 8 ) SCC 732 = 1997 ( 9 ) JT 18 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 689
787. RAJU @ RAJENDRA .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 22/10/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION PARADE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 275 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCC 169 = 1997 ( 8 ) JT 610 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 453
788. GULZAR ALI .Vs. STATE OF H.P. DOJ : 21/10/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -HANDWRITING -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 559 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCC 192 = 1997 ( 8 ) JT 564 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 483
789. RAMBILAS .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 03/10/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 3954 = 1997 Suppl. SCR 405 = 1997 ( 8 ) JT 359 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCALE 337
790. C. SAMPATH KUMAR .Vs. ENFORCEMENT OFFICER ENFORCEMENT DIRECTORATE MADRAS DOJ
: 16/09/1997 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -FERA -EVIDENCE -COMPULSION
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 16 = 1997 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 142 = 1997 ( 8 ) SCC 358 = 1997 ( 8 ) JT 135 = 1997 ( 6
) SCALE 140
791. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. RAJENDRA JAWANMAL GANDHI DOJ : 11/09/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -PUNISHMENT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 3986 = 1997 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 68 = 1997 ( 8 ) SCC 386 = 1997 ( 8 ) JT 43 = 1997 ( 6
) SCALE 80
792. SHABAD PULLA REDDY .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 20/08/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -IDENTIFICATION PARADE -DELAY -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 3087 = 1997 ( 8 ) SCC 495 = 1997 ( 7 ) JT 455 = 1997 ( 5 ) SCALE 512
793. B. SUBBA RAO & ORS. .Vs. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR HIGH COURT OF A.P. AT HYDERABAD DOJ
: 07/08/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -UNLAWFUL ASSEMBLY -FIR -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 3427 = 1997 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 370 = 1997 (11 ) SCC 478 = 1997 ( 7 ) JT 329 = 1997 ( 5
) SCALE 407
794. STATE OF GUJARAT .Vs. ANIRUDHSING DOJ : 10/07/1997 ORDER
EVIDENCE -POLICE OFFICER -HOSTILE WITNESS -FIR
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2780 = 1997 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 234 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCC 514 = 1997 ( 6 ) JT 236 = 1997 ( 4
) SCALE 724
795. HARPAL SINGH .Vs. DEVINDER SINGH DOJ : 09/07/1997 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -WITNESS -EXAMINATION -PRESUMPTION
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2914 = 1997 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 648 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCC 660 = 1997 ( 6 ) JT 10 = 1997 ( 4
) SCALE 459
796. ASHA @ ASHANAND .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 08/05/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2828 = 1997 ( 5 ) JT 294 = 1997 ( 4 ) SCALE 130
797. DATTU RAMRAO SAKHARE .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 08/05/1997 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CHILD WITNESS
Citation(s) 1997 ( 5 ) SCC 341 = 1997 ( 5 ) JT 370 = 1997 ( 4 ) SCALE 121
798. SANJEEV KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 06/05/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 3717 = 1997 (10 ) SCC 40 = 1997 ( 5 ) JT 559 = 1997 ( 4 ) SCALE 63

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 62 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

799. RAZAKALI KHURESHI SANDHI .Vs. STATE OPF GUJARAT DOJ : 05/05/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2538 = 1997 ( 5 ) JT 375 = 1997 ( 4 ) SCALE 15
800. ROHTAS .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 02/05/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -MURDER
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2444 = 1997 ( 5 ) JT 140 = 1997 ( 3 ) SCALE 777
801. HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY THRU. ITS REGISTRAR .Vs. SHIRISH KUMAR RANGRAO PATIL DOJ
: 30/04/1997 JUDGEMENT
JUDICIAL SERVICE -DEPARTMENTAL ENQUIRY -BIAS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2631 = 1997 ( 3 ) SCR 1131 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCC 339 = 1997 ( 5 ) JT 337 = 1997 ( 4
) SCALE 181
802. BALO YADAV .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 29/04/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -RIOTS -MURDER
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2678 = 1997 ( 3 ) SCR 1071 = 1997 ( 5 ) SCC 360 = 1997 ( 5 ) JT 117 = 1997 ( 3
) SCALE 729
803. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. LAKHAN DOJ : 11/04/1997 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MOTIVE -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 ( 3 ) SCR 865 = 1997 ( 9 ) SCC 679 = 1997 ( 5 ) JT 33 = 1997 ( 3 ) SCALE 647
804. HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY THRU. ITS REGISTRAR .Vs. UDAYSINGH S/O GANPATRAO NAIK
NIMBALKAR DOJ : 09/04/1997 ORDER
JUDICIAL SERVICE -DEPARTMENTAL ENQUIRY -EVIDENCE -GRATIFICATION
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2286 = 1997 ( 3 ) SCR 803 = 1997 ( 5 ) SCC 129 = 1997 ( 5 ) JT 298 = 1997 ( 4
) SCALE 26
805. ANITA .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 08/04/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 ( 4 ) JT 553 = 1997 ( 3 ) SCALE 473
806. ACHUTANANDA BAIDYA .Vs. PRAFULLYA KUMAR GAYEN DOJ : 08/04/1997 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -ORAL SETTLEMENT -ORAL EVIDENCE -PROPERTY
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2077 = 1997 ( 3 ) SCR 709 = 1997 ( 5 ) SCC 76 = 1997 ( 5 ) JT 75 = 1997 ( 3
) SCALE 475
807. COMMISSIONER OF POLICE .Vs. JAYASURIAN DOJ : 04/04/1997 ORDER
SERVICE LAW -DEPARTMENTAL ENQUIRY -INQUIRY REPORT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 ( 6 ) SCC 75 =
808. U.O.I. .Vs. R.V. SWAMY @ R. VELLAICHAMY DOJ : 31/03/1997 ORDER
FREEDOM FIGHTER -PENSION -ELIGIBILITY -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2069 = 1997 ( 3 ) SCR 458 = 1997 ( 9 ) SCC 446 = 1997 ( 4 ) JT 579 = 1997 ( 3
) SCALE 492
809. SUKHDEO .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 11/03/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RIOTS -HARIJAN -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1849 = 1997 (10 ) SCC 102 = 1997 ( 3 ) JT 406 = 1997 ( 2 ) SCALE 594
810. UNITED PLANTERS ASSIN. OF SOUTHERN INDIA .Vs. K.G. SANGAMESWARAN DOJ : 06/03/1997 JUDGEMENT
LABOUR LAW -DISMISSAL -ENQUIRY -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1300 = 1997 ( 2 ) SCR 756 = 1997 ( 4 ) SCC 741 = 1997 ( 3 ) JT 379 = 1997 ( 2
) SCALE 559
811. SAHAB SINGH .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 03/03/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONVICTION -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 945 = 1997 ( 3 ) JT 181 = 1997 ( 2 ) SCALE 429
812. RAE BARELI KSHETRIYA GRAMIN BANK .Vs. BHOLA NATH SINGH DOJ : 28/02/1997 ORDER
SERVICE LAW -DEPARTMENTAL ENQUIRY -EVIDENCE -HIGH COURTS
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1908 = 1997 ( 2 ) SCR 588 = 1997 ( 3 ) SCC 657 = 1997 ( 3 ) JT 717 = 1997 ( 3
) SCALE 86
813. ANWAR .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 24/02/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONSPIRACY -CONVICTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 ( 9 ) SCC 766 = 1997 ( 3 ) JT 1 = 1997 ( 2 ) SCALE 322
814. SHAM LAL .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 20/02/1997 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -PRESUMPTION -DOWRY DEATH
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1873 = 1997 ( 2 ) SCR 309 = 1997 ( 9 ) SCC 759 = 1997 ( 3 ) JT 91 = 1997 ( 2
) SCALE 328
815. SATBIR .Vs. SURAT SINGH DOJ : 12/02/1997 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CHANCE WITNESS -RELATED WITNESS -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1160 = 1997 ( 2 ) SCR 1 = 1997 ( 4 ) SCC 192 = 1997 ( 2 ) JT 650 = 1997 ( 2
) SCALE 62
816. VIJENDER .Vs. STATE OF DELHI DOJ : 12/02/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -KIDNAPPING -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 ( 1 ) SCR 1181 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCC 171 = 1997 ( 3 ) JT 131 = 1997 ( 2 ) SCALE 127

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 63 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

817. K.I. PAVUNNY .Vs. ASSISTANT COLLECTOR (HEAD QUARTER) C.C.E. COCHIN DOJ : 03/02/1997 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CONFESSION -CUSTOMS -SEARCH AND SEIZURE
Citation(s) 1997 ( 1 ) SCR 797 = 1997 ( 3 ) SCC 721 = 1997 ( 2 ) JT 120 = 1997 ( 1 ) SCALE 640
818. SUNIL KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 28/01/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -WITNESS
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 940 = 1997 ( 1 ) SCR 589 = 1997 (10 ) SCC 570 = 1997 ( 2 ) JT 1
819. RAJA RAM .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 16/01/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -STATEMENT
Citation(s) 1997 ( 1 ) JT 530 = 1997 ( 1 ) SCALE 353
820. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. ANI @ HANIF DOJ : 13/01/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -TRIAL
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1023 = 1997 ( 1 ) SCR 199 = 1997 ( 6 ) SCC 162 = 1997 ( 1 ) JT 460
821. SUKHPAL .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 08/01/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -DEATH
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 468 = 1997 ( 9 ) SCC 773 = 1997 ( 1 ) JT 387 = 1997 ( 1 ) SCALE 139
822. SITARAMACHARYA (DEAD) THRU .Vs. GURURAJACHARYA (DEAD) THRU LRS DOJ : 06/01/1997 ORDER
EVIDENCE -WRITTEN STATEMENT
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 806 = 1997 ( 1 ) SCR 18 = 1997 ( 2 ) SCC 548 = 1997 ( 1 ) JT 535 =
823. NATHUNI YADAV .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 20/12/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1808 = 1996 (10 ) Suppl. SCR 905 = 1998 ( 9 ) SCC 238 = 1997 ( 1 ) JT 406 =
824. NET RAJ SINGH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 19/12/1996 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -BURDEN OF PROOF -PRESUMPTION -THEFT
Citation(s) 1996 (10 ) Suppl. SCR 375 = 1997 ( 3 ) SCC 525 = 1996 (11 ) JT 279 = 1996 ( 9 ) SCALE 417
825. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. RAGHUBIR SINGH DOJ : 13/12/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -SON -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 (10 ) Suppl. SCR 91 = 1997 ( 3 ) SCC 775 = 1996 (11 ) JT 200 = 1996 ( 9 ) SCALE 265
826. BOOTA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 12/12/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 1996 (11 ) JT 680 = 1996 ( 9 ) SCALE 233
827. RATTAN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF H.P. DOJ : 11/12/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -FIR
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 768 = 1996 ( 9 ) Suppl. SCR 938 = 1997 ( 4 ) SCC 161 = 1996 (11 ) JT 218 =
828. MOHMEDRAFIZ HUSENMIYA THAKOR .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 03/12/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1520 = 1996 ( 9 ) Suppl. SCR 504 = 1997 (10 ) SCC 578 = 1996 (11 ) JT 196 =
829. THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE BOMBAY .Vs. BHAGWAN V. LAHANE DOJ : 26/11/1996 ORDER
SERVICE LAW -DATE OF BIRTH -EVIDENCE -CORRECTION
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1986 = 1996 ( 9 ) Suppl. SCR 199 = 1997 ( 1 ) SCC 247 = 1996 Suppl. JT 41
830. HARDEV SINGH .Vs. HARBHEJ SINGH DOJ : 20/11/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ACQUITTAL -EVIDENCE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1487 = 1996 ( 8 ) Suppl. SCR 856 = 1997 ( 1 ) SCC 80 = 1997 ( 1 ) JT 29 =
831. CHINNAMMAL .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 20/11/1996 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -DYING DECLARATION -EVIDENCE -FIR
Citation(s) 1996 ( 8 ) Suppl. SCR 927 = 1997 ( 1 ) SCC 145 = 1996 Suppl. JT 310 = 1996 ( 8 ) SCALE 502
832. STATE OF A.P. .Vs. GANGULA SATYA MURTHY DOJ : 19/11/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1588 = 1996 ( 8 ) Suppl. SCR 808 = 1997 ( 1 ) SCC 272 = 1996 (10 ) JT 550 =
833. ASHOK YADAV .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 19/11/1996 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1996 ( 8 ) Suppl. SCR 820 = 1996 (11 ) SCC 618 = 1996 Suppl. JT 293 = 1996 ( 8 ) SCALE 671
834. SEWA KAUR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 07/11/1996 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1843 = 1996 Suppl. SCR 601 = 1996 Suppl. JT 591 = 1996 ( 8 ) SCALE 348
835. STATE OF M.P. .Vs. DHIRENDRA KUMAR DOJ : 05/11/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -THEFT
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 318 = 1996 ( 8 ) Suppl. SCR 443 = 1997 ( 1 ) SCC 93 = 1996 (10 ) JT 93
836. RANVIR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 01/11/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -ANNUBAI
Citation(s) 1996 (11 ) SCC 595 = 1996 (10 ) JT 19 = 1996 ( 8 ) SCALE 19
837. BHAGIRATH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 30/10/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -WITNESS
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 234 = 1997 ( 1 ) SCC 481 = 1996 ( 9 ) JT 654 = 1996 ( 7 ) SCALE 882

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 64 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

838. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. BAL KISHAN DAS DOJ : 29/10/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 225 = 1996 Suppl. SCR 49 = 1996 (10 ) JT 292 = 1996 ( 7 ) SCALE 845
839. BHARTU .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 24/10/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONVICTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 281 = 1996 ( 9 ) JT 595 = 1996 ( 7 ) SCALE 757
840. PARVEEN .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 24/10/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 310 = 1996 (11 ) SCC 365 = 1996 ( 9 ) JT 511 = 1996 ( 7 ) SCALE 753
841. BALLU .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 10/10/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -CONFESSION
Citation(s) 1996 ( 9 ) JT 177 = 1996 ( 7 ) SCALE 503
842. NARESH MOHANLAL JAISWAL .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 09/10/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1523 = 1996 (11 ) SCC 547 = 1996 ( 9 ) JT 163 = 1996 ( 7 ) SCALE 499
843. KUMBHAR DHIRAJLAL MOHANLAL .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 04/10/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -BRIDE BURNING -DYING DECLARATION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1531 = 1996 ( 7 ) Suppl. SCR 177 = 1996 (11 ) SCC 117 = 1996 ( 8 ) JT 701
844. MEHARBAN .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 27/09/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MOTIVE -DYING DECLARATION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1528 = 1996 (10 ) SCC 615 = 1996 ( 7 ) SCALE 272
845. BANDLAMUDDI ATCHUTA RAMAIAH .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 26/09/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -FIR -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 496 = 1996 ( 7 ) Suppl. SCR 34 = 1996 (11 ) SCC 133 = 1996 ( 8 ) JT 502
846. PERIASAMI .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 25/09/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -PRIVATE DEFENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 1996 ( 6 ) Suppl. SCR 757 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCC 457 = 1996 ( 8 ) JT 449 = 1996 ( 7 ) SCALE 202
847. MOHINDER SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 23/09/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -TADA
Citation(s) 1996 (11 ) SCC 369 = 1996 ( 8 ) JT 519 = 1996 ( 7 ) SCALE 95
848. SHANKAR GAJANAN KALAN .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 20/09/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1996 (11 ) SCC 151 = 1996 ( 9 ) JT 315 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 748
849. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. GURMIT SINGH DOJ : 19/09/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 500 = 1996 ( 9 ) JT 125 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 753
850. SAHIB SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 13/09/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2417 = 1996 ( 6 ) Suppl. SCR 245 = 1996 (11 ) SCC 685 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 518
851. DEVINDER .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 13/09/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 454 = 1996 Suppl. SCR 249 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 520
852. U.O.I. .Vs. MOHAN SINGH DOJ : 09/09/1996 ORDER
FREEDOM FIGHTER -PENSION -EVIDENCE -IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 1996 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 686 = 1996 (10 ) SCC 351 = 1996 ( 8 ) JT 341 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 783
853. PREM PAL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 03/09/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 388 = 1996 (10 ) SCC 301 = 1996 ( 7 ) JT 647 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 318
854. DARSHAN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 30/08/1996 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -OCCURAL EVIDENCE -ARMS & AMMUNITION
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 364 = 1996 (10 ) SCC 283 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 263
855. YAMUNA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 28/08/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 2826 = 1996 ( 7 ) JT 485 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 248
856. SHERA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 28/08/1996 ORDER
EVIDENCE -APPROVER -CORROBORATION -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 304 = 1996 (10 ) SCC 330 = 1996 Suppl. JT 543 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 345
857. ABDUL FAZAL SIDDIQUI .Vs. FATEHCHAND HIRAWAT DOJ : 20/08/1996 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -CHEATING -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 807 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCC 32 = 1996 ( 8 ) JT 104 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 224
858. BALBIR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 20/08/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1996 ( 7 ) JT 342 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 72

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 65 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

859. CHHOTU .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 20/08/1996 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -ATTEMPT TO MURDER -EVIDENCE -FIR
Citation(s) 1996 ( 7 ) JT 346 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 80
860. BUDDHI KOTA SUBBARAO (DR.) .Vs. K. PARASARAN DOJ : 13/08/1996 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -FALSE STATEMENT
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 2687 = 1996 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 574 = 1996 ( 5 ) SCC 530 = 1996 ( 7 ) JT 265
861. GOLLA PULLANNA .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 13/08/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 2727 = 1996 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 603 = 1996 (10 ) SCC 223 = 1996 ( 5 ) SCALE 788
862. BALDEV SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB THRU. COLLECTOR DOJ : 07/08/1996 ORDER
LAND ACQUISITION -COMPENSATION -MARKET VALUE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 3498 = 1996 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 359 = 1996 (10 ) SCC 37 = 1996 ( 8 ) JT 280
863. SURJIT SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 07/08/1996 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -ARMS & AMMUNITION -HAND GERNADE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1996 (10 ) SCC 281 = 1996 ( 7 ) JT 635 = 1996 ( 5 ) SCALE 683
864. NIRANJAN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 26/04/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS -APPROVER
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 3254 = 1996 ( 9 ) SCC 98 = 1996 ( 5 ) JT 582 = 1996 ( 3 ) SCALE 774
865. T.N. ELECTRICITY BOARD .Vs. N. RAJU REDDIAR DOJ : 24/04/1996 JUDGEMENT
GOVERNMENT CONTRACT -RATE -WRITTEN STATEMENT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 2025 = 1996 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 739 = 1996 ( 4 ) SCC 551 = 1996 ( 6 ) JT 14
866. T.N. ELECTRICITY BOARD .Vs. N. RAJU REDDIAR DOJ : 24/04/1996 JUDGEMENT
CONTRACT LAW -AGREEMENT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 2025 = 1996 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 739 = 1996 ( 4 ) SCC 551 = 1996 ( 6 ) JT 14
867. SARADA SMT. .Vs. MANIKKOTH KOMBRA RAJENDRAN DOJ : 22/04/1996 ORDER
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -AGREEMENT
Citation(s) 1996 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 624 = 1996 ( 8 ) SCC 345 = 1996 ( 6 ) JT 1 = 1996 ( 4 ) SCALE 393
868. RAM DUTT .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 17/04/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 ( 4 ) JT 760 = 1996 ( 3 ) SCALE 619
869. MOTILAL DAULATRAM BORA .Vs. MURLIDHAR RAMCHANDRA BHUTABE BY HIS LRS. DOJ : 16/04/1996 ORDER
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -EVIDENCE -FACTS -APPRECIATION
Citation(s) 1996 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 393 = 1996 ( 9 ) SCC 392 = 1996 ( 5 ) JT 615 = 1996 ( 4 ) SCALE 37
870. RAM NATH MAHTO .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 10/04/1996 ORDER
EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION PARADE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 2511 = 1996 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 163 = 1996 ( 8 ) SCC 630 = 1997 (10 ) JT 478 =
871. GIRISH YADAV .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 29/03/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 3098 = 1996 ( 3 ) SCR 1021 = 1996 ( 8 ) SCC 186 = 1996 ( 3 ) JT 615 =
872. T. VENKATA NARAYANA .Vs. VENKATA SUBBAMMA SMT. (DEAD) DOJ : 29/03/1996 ORDER
WILL -SUCCESSION LAW -SPECIFIC RELIEF -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 1807 = 1996 ( 3 ) SCR 1042 = 1996 ( 4 ) SCC 457 = 1996 ( 4 ) JT 425 =
873. PATTU LAL .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 27/03/1996 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -WIFE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 3197 = 1996 ( 3 ) SCR 1016 = 1996 ( 8 ) SCC 228 = 1996 ( 4 ) JT 95 =
874. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. NOORIE @ NOOR JAHAN DOJ : 26/03/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ACQUITTAL -HIGH COURTS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 3073 = 1996 ( 3 ) SCR 886 = 1996 ( 9 ) SCC 104 = 1996 ( 3 ) JT 570 =
875. R. PUTHUNAINAR ALHITHAN .Vs. P.H. PANDIAN DOJ : 26/03/1996 ORDER
EVIDENCE -FACTS -ELECTION LAW -EXPENDITURE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 1599 = 1996 ( 3 ) SCR 932 = 1996 ( 3 ) SCC 624 = 1996 ( 4 ) JT 146 =
876. BIHAR STATE BOARD OF RELIGIOUS TRUST .Vs. RAMSUBARAN DAS DOJ : 29/02/1996 JUDGEMENT
TRUST LAW -PUBLIC TEMPLE -EVIDENCE -MUZAFFARPUR
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 3354 = 1996 ( 3 ) SCR 56 = 1996 ( 9 ) SCC 305 = 1996 Suppl. JT 533 =
877. SURJIT SINGH .Vs. BALBIR SINGH DOJ : 29/02/1996 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -FORGED DOCUMENT -EVIDENCE -COURTS
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 1592 = 1996 ( 3 ) SCR 70 = 1996 ( 3 ) SCC 533 = 1996 ( 3 ) JT 363 =
878. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. FAZILAR REHMAN DOJ : 26/02/1996 ORDER
EVIDENCE -DEEDS & DOCUMENTS -PRESUMPTION -THIRTY YEARS OLD
Citation(s) 1996 ( 2 ) SCALE SP81
879. HARI CHAND .Vs. STATE OF DELHI DOJ : 12/02/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ALIBI -ACQUITTAL -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 1477 = 1996 ( 9 ) SCC 112 = 1996 ( 2 ) JT 140 = 1996 ( 2 ) SCALE 16

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 66 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

880. BRIJ PAL .Vs. STATE DELHI ADMINISTRATION DOJ : 01/02/1996 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -TADA -EVIDENCE -BALLISTIC EXPERT
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 2915 = 1996 ( 1 ) SCR 1143 = 1996 ( 2 ) SCC 676 = 1997 (10 ) JT 399 =
881. STATE OF T.N. .Vs. S. SUBRAMANIAM DOJ : 24/01/1996 ORDER
SERVICE LAW -DISMISSAL -PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 1232 = 1996 SCR 968 = 1996 ( 2 ) JT 114 = 1996 ( 1 ) SCALE 810
882. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. GURMIT SINGH DOJ : 16/01/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -FIR -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 1393 = 1996 ( 1 ) SCR 532 = 1996 ( 2 ) SCC 384 = 1996 ( 1 ) JT 298 =
883. KOCHUKAKKADA ABOOBACKER .Vs. ATTAH KASIM DOJ : 16/01/1996 ORDER
PARTITION -EVIDENCE -HIGH COURTS
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 3111 = 1996 ( 1 ) SCR 570 = 1996 ( 7 ) SCC 389 = 1996 ( 1 ) JT 658 =
884. KASHIBAI W/O LACHIRAM .Vs. PARWATIBAI W/O LACHIRAM DOJ : 25/09/1995 JUDGEMENT
HINDU LAW -ADOPTION -WILL -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 63 = 1995 ( 6 ) SCC 213 = 1995 ( 7 ) JT 48 = 1995 ( 5 ) SCALE 615
885. YARASANI OBULESU .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 06/09/1995 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CONVICTION -LIMITATION LAW -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 582 = 1995 ( 7 ) JT 415 = 1995 ( 5 ) SCALE 166
886. V.M. MATHEW .Vs. V.S. SHARMA DOJ : 29/08/1995 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -RELEVANCY
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 109 = 1995 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 131 = 1995 ( 6 ) SCC 122 = 1995 ( 6 ) JT 318 =
887. KHAGENDRA LALL DUTTA .Vs. JACOB SOLE JACOB DOJ : 17/08/1995 ORDER
RENT LAW -EVICTION -SUB TENANCY -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 803 = 1995 ( 5 ) SCC 446 = 1995 ( 5 ) SCALE 32
888. BALBIR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 16/08/1995 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ACQUITTAL -TRIAL COURT -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 472 = 1995 ( 4 ) SCALE 764
889. INDUBEN ASHOKRAO NALVADE (DEAD) .Vs. DHIRAJLAL SHIVLAL SURATI DOJ : 14/08/1995 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -SUIT -SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 2486 = 1995 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 541 = 1995 ( 6 ) JT 299 = 1995 ( 4 ) SCALE 824
890. KARNEL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 11/08/1995 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -EVIDENCE -PANCHBAI
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 2472 = 1995 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 629 = 1995 ( 5 ) SCC 518 = 1995 ( 6 ) JT 437 =
891. AMARJIT SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 27/07/1995 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 390 = 1995 ( 5 ) JT 529 = 1995 ( 4 ) SCALE 555
892. JASWINDER KAUR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 26/07/1995 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 2327 = 1995 ( 5 ) JT 532 = 1995 ( 4 ) SCALE 546
893. RAMESH KUMAR GUPTA .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 12/07/1995 JUDGEMENT
PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -EVIDENCE -POLICE
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 2121 = 1995 ( 5 ) SCC 320 = 1995 ( 6 ) JT 88 = 1995 ( 4 ) SCALE 389
894. STATE OF KARNATAKA BY H.A.L. AIRPORT POLICE BANGALORE .Vs. THANGARAJ DOJ : 12/07/1995 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ACQUITTAL -HIGH COURTS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 2124 = 1995 ( 7 ) JT 516 = 1995 ( 4 ) SCALE 353
895. CHAND KHAN .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 11/07/1995 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 2140 = 1995 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 848 = 1995 ( 5 ) SCC 448 = 1995 ( 5 ) JT 329 =
896. BURN STANDARD CO. LTD. .Vs. DINABANDHU MAJUMDAR DOJ : 21/04/1995 JUDGEMENT
SERVICE LAW -RETIREMENT -DATE OF BIRTH -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 1499 = 1995 ( 3 ) SCR 712 = 1995 ( 4 ) SCC 172 = 1995 ( 4 ) JT 23 =
897. ASHARFI LAL .Vs. KOILI (DEAD) DOJ : 20/04/1995 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 1440 = 1995 ( 4 ) SCC 163 = 1995 ( 5 ) JT 496 = 1995 ( 2 ) SCALE 827
898. SUKHWANT SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 28/03/1995 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -BALLISTIC EXPERT
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 1601 = 1995 ( 2 ) SCR 1190 = 1995 ( 3 ) SCC 367 = 1995 ( 3 ) JT 495 =
899. GULAB CHAND .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 28/03/1995 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -STOLEN GOODS
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 1598 = 1995 ( 3 ) SCR 27 = 1995 ( 3 ) SCC 574 = 1995 ( 5 ) JT 373 =
900. M.O. SHAMSUDHIN .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 21/03/1995 JUDGEMENT
PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -EVIDENCE -CORROBORATION -BRIBE
Citation(s) 1995 ( 2 ) SCR 900 = 1995 ( 3 ) SCC 351 = 1995 ( 3 ) JT 367 = 1995 ( 2 ) SCALE 298

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 67 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

901. SHEIKH ISHAQUE .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 10/03/1995 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT -EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1995 ( 2 ) SCR 692 = 1995 ( 3 ) SCC 392 = 1995 ( 5 ) JT 638 = 1995 ( 2 ) SCALE 271
902. JAGANNATH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 12/01/1995 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 712 = 1995 ( 1 ) SCR 198 = 1995 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 564 = 1995 ( 1 ) JT 553
903. MADHUSUDAN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 12/01/1995 ORDER
PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION -EVIDENCE -FIR -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 1437 = 1996 (11 ) SCC 248 =
904. MAROTI .Vs. TULSIRAM DOJ : 15/11/1994 ORDER
RENT LAW -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1994 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 499 = 1994 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 746 = 1995 ( 2 ) JT 371
905. SUSHIL .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 08/11/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1994 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 294 = 1995 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 363 = 1994 ( 7 ) JT 341 =
906. N. JAYALAKSHMI AMMAL .Vs. R. GOPALA PATHAR DOJ : 09/09/1994 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 995 = 1994 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 310 = 1995 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 27 = 1994 ( 6 ) JT 19
907. SURESH CHANDRA BAHRI .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 13/07/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1994 AIR 2420 = 1994 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 483 = 1995 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 80 =
908. ANAR DEVI .Vs. NATHU RAM DOJ : 13/05/1994 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -ESTOPPEL -DOCTRINE
Citation(s) 1994 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 70 = 1994 ( 4 ) SCC 250 = 1994 ( 4 ) JT 164 = 1994 ( 2 ) SCALE 1034
909. SUKHVINDER SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 12/05/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WRITING -SIGNATURE
Citation(s) 1994 ( 5 ) SCC 152 = 1994 ( 4 ) JT 1 = 1994 ( 2 ) SCALE 877
910. SURAJMAL KANIA LAL SONI .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 12/05/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -UNAUTHORISED POSSESSION -OPIUM -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1994 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 276 = 1994 ( 4 ) JT 144 = 1994 ( 2 ) SCALE 924
911. THAKKAR VRAJLAL BHIMJEE .Vs. THAKKAR JAMNADAS VALJEE DOJ : 11/05/1994 ORDER
EVIDENCE -MORTGAGE -ATTESTING WITNESS
Citation(s) 1994 ( 4 ) SCC 723 =
912. G. SATYANARAYANA REDDY .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 09/05/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 1994 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 287 = 1994 ( 4 ) JT 216 = 1994 ( 2 ) SCALE 857
913. BHAGWAN KAUR W/O BACHAN SINGH .Vs. KARTAR KAUR W/O BACHAN SINGH DOJ : 28/04/1994 ORDER
EVIDENCE -REGISTRATION -ATTESTATION -WILL
Citation(s) 1994 ( 5 ) SCC 135 =
914. ANSHAD .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 22/04/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -RECOVERY OF CRIME ARTICLES
Citation(s) 1994 ( 4 ) SCC 381 = 1994 ( 3 ) JT 324 = 1994 ( 2 ) SCALE 653
915. MEESALA RAMAKRISHAN .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 13/04/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 1994 ( 4 ) SCC 182 = 1994 ( 3 ) JT 232 = 1994 ( 2 ) SCALE 569
916. SHANKAR @ GAURI SHANKAR .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 04/04/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1994 ( 4 ) SCC 478 = 1994 ( 3 ) JT 54 = 1994 ( 2 ) SCALE 435
917. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. MUKUNDE SINGH DOJ : 18/01/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ALIBI
Citation(s) 1994 ( 2 ) SCC 191 = 1994 ( 1 ) JT 109 = 1994 ( 1 ) SCALE 95
918. DHANANJOY CHATTERJEE @ DHANA .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 11/01/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -PRINCIPLES
Citation(s) 1994 ( 1 ) SCR 37 = 1994 ( 2 ) SCC 220 = 1994 ( 1 ) JT 33 = 1994 ( 1 ) SCALE 48
919. SATISH KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 12/10/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MURDER -WIFE
Citation(s) 1993 ( 6 ) JT 558 = 1993 ( 4 ) SCALE 216
920. TUKARAM GUNDU NAIK .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 05/10/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1994 ( 1 ) SCC 465 = 1993 Suppl. JT 135 = 1993 ( 4 ) SCALE 15
921. SMT. CHAND DHAWAN .Vs. JAWAHARLAL DHAWAN DOJ : 11/06/1993 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -FINAL JUDGMENT -JUDGEMENT IN REM
Citation(s) 1993 ( 3 ) SCR 954 = 1993 ( 3 ) SCC 406 = 1993 ( 4 ) JT 22 = 1993 ( 3 ) SCALE 1

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 68 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

922. GOUTAM KUNDU .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 14/05/1993 JUDGEMENT


EVIDENCE -LEGITIMACY -CHILD -DURING MARRIAGE
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 2295 = 1993 ( 3 ) SCR 917 = 1993 ( 3 ) SCC 418 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 443 = 1993 ( 2
) SCALE 994
923. GOUTAM KUNDU .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 14/05/1993 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -PATERNITY -BLOOD TEST -GUIDELINES
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 2295 = 1993 ( 3 ) SCR 917 = 1993 ( 3 ) SCC 418 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 443 = 1993 ( 2
) SCALE 994
924. GOVIND NARAIN .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 31/03/1993 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -EVIDENTIARY VALUE
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 2457 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 343 = 1993 Suppl. JT 522 =
925. KUNDULA BALA SUBRAHMANYAM .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 26/03/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -BRIDE BURNING
Citation(s) 1993 ( 2 ) SCR 666 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCC 684 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 559 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCALE 214
926. SURINDER PAL JAIN .Vs. DELHI ADMINISTRATION DOJ : 05/03/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -RECOVERY OF ORNAMENTS
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 1723 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCR 226 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 681 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 206 = 1993 ( 1
) SCALE 792
927. SURINDER PAL JAIN .Vs. DELHI ADMINISTRATION DOJ : 05/03/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DOG SQUAD
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 1723 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCR 226 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 681 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 206 = 1993 ( 1
) SCALE 792
928. RAM BILAS .Vs. JAGAT NARAIN SHRIVASTAVA (DEAD) DOJ : 25/02/1993 ORDER
EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1994 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 113 =
929. BHIMAPPA JINNAPPA NAGANUR .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 25/02/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -ACQUITTAL -HIGH COURTS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 1469 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 449 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 165 = 1993 ( 1 ) SCALE 705
930. SARDAR SINGH .Vs. STATE ( DELHI ADMINISTRATION ) DELHI DOJ : 23/02/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -HIDING -MURDER
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 1696 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCR 65 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 393 = 1993 ( 4 ) JT 534 = 1993 ( 1
) SCALE 681
931. SARDAR SINGH .Vs. STATE ( DELHI ADMINISTRATION ) DELHI DOJ : 23/02/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 1696 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCR 65 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 393 = 1993 ( 4 ) JT 534 = 1993 ( 1
) SCALE 681
932. STATE OF H.P. .Vs. RAGHUBIR SINGH DOJ : 18/02/1993 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -RAPE -TESTIMONY
Citation(s) 1993 ( 2 ) SCR 17 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCC 622 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 152 = 1993 ( 1 ) SCALE 708
933. SARBIR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 11/02/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1993 ( 1 ) SCR 1027 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 41 = 1993 ( 2 ) JT 159 = 1993 ( 1 ) SCALE 573
934. PULARU .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 21/01/1993 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CORROBORATION
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 1487 = 1993 Suppl. JT 514 =
935. JARNAIL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 20/01/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ORAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1993 ( 1 ) SCR 260 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 91 = 1993 ( 1 ) JT 207 = 1993 ( 1 ) SCALE 153
936. DHARAM SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 22/10/1992
CRIMINAL LAW -WITNESS -EYE WITNESS -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 319 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 532 = 1992 ( 6 ) JT 98 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCALE 35
937. SAROJINI .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 16/10/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DOWRY DEATH
Citation(s) 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 25 = 1993 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCC 632 = 1992 Suppl. JT 433 = 1992 ( 3
) SCALE 70
938. SAROJINI .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 16/10/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -SUICIDE -HOMICIDE
Citation(s) 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 25 = 1993 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCC 632 = 1992 Suppl. JT 433
939. U.O.I. .Vs. J.S. BRAR DOJ : 09/10/1992 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CONFESSION -WITNESS
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 773 = 1992 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 916 = 1993 ( 1 ) SCC 176 = 1992 ( 6 ) JT 266 =
940. U.O.I. .Vs. J.S. BRAR DOJ : 09/10/1992 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -ACCOMPLICE -CORROBORATION
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 773 = 1992 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 916 = 1993 ( 1 ) SCC 176 = 1992 ( 6 ) JT 266 = 1992 ( 2
) SCALE 749

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 69 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

941. JASBIR KAUR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 17/09/1992 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 151 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 654 = 1992 Suppl. JT 648 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 726
942. CHANDU @ CHANDRAHAS .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 15/09/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -LAST SEEN TOGETHER
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 2302 = 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 358 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 738
943. CHANDU @ CHANDRAHAS .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 15/09/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -RECOVERY OF SHIRT
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 2302 = 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 358 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 738
944. JAIRAM .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 09/09/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -OCCURAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 92 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 578 = 1992 ( 5 ) JT 376 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 771
945. BABUDA .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 28/08/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -SUSPICION
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 2091 = 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 438 = 1992 ( 5 ) JT 307 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 712
946. HARINDER SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 11/08/1992 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ROBBERY -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1976 = 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 467 =
947. BABU POOJARI .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 11/08/1992 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -INQUEST REPORT -FIR
Citation(s) 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 304 = 1992 ( 5 ) JT 572 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCALE 76
948. BHUPENDRA NATH PRASAD .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 31/07/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CARDIO RESPIRATORY FAILURE
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 300 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 547 = 1992 ( 4 ) JT 309 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 101
949. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. NARAYAN DOJ : 30/07/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -COMPETENCE TO TESTIFY -VICTIM OF RAPE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 2004 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 615 = 1992 ( 4 ) JT 282 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 82
950. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. VED NARAIN DOJ : 23/07/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 265 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 705 = 1993 Suppl. JT 587 =
951. P. SATYANARAYAN MURTY .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 22/07/1992 JUDGEMENT
BENAMI TRANSACTION -EVIDENCE -BURDEN OF PROOF -GUIDELINES TO DETERMINE
Citation(s) 1992 ( 4 ) SCC 39 = 1992 ( 4 ) JT 454 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 134
952. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. LAKSHMANAIAH DOJ : 21/07/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 100 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCR 579 = 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 420 = 1992 ( 4 ) JT 326 = 1992 ( 2
) SCALE 45
953. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. SUKHDEO SINGH @ SUKHA DOJ : 15/07/1992 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -EXPERT EVIDENCE -HANDWRITING -FINGER PRINT
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 2100 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCR 480 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 700 = 1992 ( 4 ) JT 73 = 1992 ( 2
) SCALE 9
954. ANANT BHUJANGRAO KULKARNI .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 15/05/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 110 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 267 = 1992 ( 4 ) JT 228 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 1299
955. MADAN GOPAL KAKKAD .Vs. NAVAL DUBEY DOJ : 29/04/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -RAPE MINOR GIRL
Citation(s) 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 921 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 204 = 1992 ( 3 ) JT 270 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 957
956. MADAN GOPAL KAKKAD .Vs. NAVAL DUBEY DOJ : 29/04/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONFESSION
Citation(s) 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 921 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 204 = 1992 ( 3 ) JT 270 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 957
957. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. RAVINDRA PRAKASH MITTAL (DR.) DOJ : 28/04/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -INGREDIENTS
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 2045 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 815 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 300 = 1992 ( 3 ) JT 114 = 1992 ( 1
) SCALE 937
958. K.M. SINGH .Vs. SECRETARY ASSOCIATION OF INDIAN UNIVERSITIES DOJ : 21/04/1992 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -SPECIAL OATH -GURUDWARA & MANDIR
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1356 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 630 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 129 = 1992 ( 4 ) JT 12
959. RAJINDER SINGH @ KADA .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 21/04/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1433 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 574 = 1992 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 13 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 575
960. MULAKH RAJ .Vs. SATISH KUMAR DOJ : 10/04/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1175 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 484 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 43 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 554 = 1992 ( 1
) SCALE 804

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 70 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

961. GANESHLAL .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 10/04/1992 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 502 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 106 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 592 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 811
962. T.M. JOSEPH .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 07/04/1992 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -GRATIFICATION -EVIDENCE -IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1922 = 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 465 =
963. STATE OF T.N. .Vs. KARUPPUSAMY DOJ : 31/03/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CONFESSION -CORROBORATION
Citation(s) 1993 ( 2 ) SCR 415 = 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 78 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 451 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 747
964. STATE OF ORISSA .Vs. DAMBARU NAIKO DOJ : 31/03/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -KIDNAPPING -GANG RAPE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1161 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 393 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCC 522 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 517
965. KIRTAN BHUYAN .Vs. STATE OF ORISSA DOJ : 31/03/1992 ORDER
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -INVESTIGATION -EVIDENCE -PRIVATE DEFENCE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1579 = 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 558 =
966. STATE OF A.P. .Vs. Y. BASAVADEVUDU DOJ : 26/03/1992 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -BURDEN OF PROOF -KNOWLEDGE
Citation(s) 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 344 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 30 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 399 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 730
967. B. HANUMANTHA RAO .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 26/03/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -BURDEN OF PROOF -BRIBE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1201 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 358 = 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 323 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 433 =
968. DULAR MAHTO .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 26/03/1992 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 927 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 467 = 1992 ( 3 ) JT 307 =
969. BAWA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 26/03/1992 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -INJURY
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 292 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 754 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 497 =
970. STATE OF M.P. .Vs. SUNDER LAL DOJ : 13/03/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION PARADE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1413 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCC 578 = 1992 ( 3 ) JT 14 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 698
971. DEV RAJ .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 11/03/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -GRIEVOUS HURT
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 950 = 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 81 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 302 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 608
972. GANGOTRI SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 11/03/1992 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -RECORDING -MAGISTRATE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 948 = 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 327 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 417 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 610
973. BIRI SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 06/03/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -OCCURAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 264 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 229 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 558
974. JAMMI RAJA RAO .Vs. SRI ANJANEYASWAMI TEMPLE VALU DOJ : 06/03/1992 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -INAM REGISTERS -ENTRIES -EVIDENTIARY VALUE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1110 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 47 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 14 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 470 =
975. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. HARDEO DOJ : 06/03/1992 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -OCCURAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1854 = 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 473 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 324 =
976. SAKHARAM .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 12/02/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CHILD
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 758 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCR 638 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCC 153 = 1992 ( 1 ) JT 515 =
977. NAND KUMAR SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 04/02/1992 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -RELIABILITY -FORGED SIGNATURE -DEVELOPMENT OFFICER L.I.C.
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1939 = 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 111 = 1992 ( 1 ) JT 456 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 287
978. CHANDRA MOHAN TIWARI .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 22/01/1992 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 891 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCR 313 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCC 105 = 1992 ( 1 ) JT 258 =
979. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. ASHOK KUMAR SRIVASTAVA DOJ : 14/01/1992 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CUMULATIVE EFFECT -DOUBT
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 840 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCR 37 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCC 86 = 1992 ( 1 ) JT 340
980. SOHRABKHAN .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 14/01/1992 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -SINGLE WITNESS -CLOSE RELATIONSHIP
Citation(s) 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 173 =
981. JAHARLAL DAS .Vs. STATE OF ORISSA DOJ : 12/04/1991 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1991 AIR 1388 = 1991 ( 2 ) SCR 298 = 1991 ( 3 ) SCC 27 = 1991 ( 2 ) JT 264 = 1991 ( 1
) SCALE 713

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 71 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

982. MALKIAT SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 10/04/1991 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -FIR
Citation(s) 1991 ( 2 ) SCR 256 = 1991 ( 4 ) SCC 341 = 1991 ( 2 ) JT 190 = 1991 ( 1 ) SCALE 722
983. S.D. SONI .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 21/12/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -SUICIDE
Citation(s) 1991 AIR 917 = 1990 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCR 668 = 1992 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 567 = 1991 ( 1 ) JT 1 = 1990
( 2 ) SCALE 1342
984. DILAWAR HUSSAIN S/O MOHAMMDBHAI LALIWALA .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 05/10/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 1991 AIR 56 = 1990 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 108 = 1991 ( 1 ) SCC 253 = 1990 ( 4 ) JT 282 = 1990 ( 2
) SCALE 788
985. KISHORE CHAND .Vs. STATE OF H.P. DOJ : 29/08/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 2140 = 1990 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 105 = 1991 ( 1 ) SCC 286 = 1990 ( 3 ) JT 662 = 1990 ( 2
) SCALE 369
986. CHANDRAN @ SURENDRAN .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 28/08/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 2148 = 1991 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 39 = 1990 ( 3 ) JT 718 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCALE 420
987. GURJA BEDIA .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 01/08/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -FIR
Citation(s) 1990 SCR 572 = 1990 Suppl. SCC 521 = 1990 ( 3 ) JT 317 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCALE 151
988. RAJ KUMAR RAJINDER SINGH .Vs. STATE OF H.P. DOJ : 20/07/1990 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DOCUMENTS -AMBIGUOUS LANGUAGE -ORAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1833 = 1990 ( 3 ) SCR 469 = 1990 ( 4 ) SCC 320 = 1990 ( 3 ) JT 215 = 1990 ( 2
) SCALE 95
989. MANGILAL .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 26/04/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS -CONFLICT WITH MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 Suppl. SCC 529 = 1990 ( 2 ) JT 198 = 1990 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCALE 117
990. VIJAYEE SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 20/04/1990 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -BURDEN OF PROOF -ALIBI
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1459 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCR 573 = 1990 ( 3 ) SCC 190 = 1990 ( 2 ) JT 596 = 1990 ( 1
) Suppl. SCALE 163
991. KISHAN LAL SETHI .Vs. JAGAN NATH DOJ : 17/04/1990 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -DYING DECLARATION -BURNS
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1357 = 1990 ( 3 ) SCC 45 = 1990 ( 3 ) JT 100 = 1990 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCALE 104
992. ANVARUDDIN .Vs. SHAKOOR DOJ : 30/03/1990
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EXPERT EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1242 = 1990 ( 3 ) SCC 266 = 1990 ( 2 ) JT 83 = 1990 ( 1 ) SCALE 636
993. STATE THRU. C.B.I. / NEW DELHI .Vs. S.J. CHOUDHARY DOJ : 22/03/1990 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -EXPERT EVIDENCE -TYPE SCRIPT -PRIVATE LOTTERY
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1050 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCR 124 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCC 481 = 1990 ( 2 ) JT 15 = 1990 ( 1
) SCALE 617
994. RAJ KUMAR KARWAL .Vs. U.O.I. DOJ : 21/03/1990
EVIDENCE -CONFESSION -OFFICER -DEPTT. OF REVENUE INTELLIGENCE
Citation(s) 1991 AIR 45 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCR 63 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCC 409 = 1990 ( 1 ) JT 503 = 1990 ( 1
) SCALE 509
995. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. SIDDAPPA BASANAGOUDA PATIL DOJ : 15/03/1990
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -SCENE OF OCCURENCE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1047 = 1990 Suppl. SCC 257 = 1990 ( 1 ) JT 441 = 1990 ( 1 ) SCALE 569
996. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. LALLA SINGH DOJ : 13/03/1990
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1013 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCC 687 = 1990 ( 1 ) JT 553 = 1990 ( 1 ) SCALE 572
997. RAMDEO RAI YADAV .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 01/03/1990
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION PARADE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1180 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCC 675 = 1990 ( 1 ) JT 356 = 1990 ( 1 ) SCALE 584
998. BEJOY SINGH @ VIJAY NARAIN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 07/02/1990
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 814 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCC 159 = 1990 ( 1 ) JT 161 = 1990 ( 1 ) SCALE 132
999. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. RAM ASREY DOJ : 07/02/1990
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 Suppl. SCC 12 = 1990 ( 1 ) JT 162 = 1990 ( 1 ) SCALE 128
1000. B.N. SINGH .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 07/02/1990
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1628 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCC 154 = 1990 ( 1 ) JT 164 = 1990 ( 1 ) SCALE 129

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 72 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

1001. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. CHANDRAPRAKASH KEWALCHAND JAIN DOJ : 18/01/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -RAPE POLICE OFFICER
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 658 = 1990 (1 ) SCR 115 = 1990 (1 ) SCC 550 = 1990 (1 ) JT 61 = 1990 (1
) SCALE 33
1002. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. U.O.I. DOJ : 06/05/1977
EVIDENCE -NEWSPAPER
Citation(s) 1977 AIR 1361 = 1978 ( 1 ) SCR 1 = 1977 ( 3 ) SCC 592 =
1003. STATE OF BOMBAY .Vs. KATHI KALU OGHAD DOJ : 04/08/1961 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -ACCUSED -WITNESS -SELF INCRIMINATORY INFORMATION
Citation(s) 1961 AIR 1808 = 1962 SCR 10 =
1. GUNNANA PENTAYYA @ PENTADU & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 20/08/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE OF WITNESS -UNLAWFUL ASSEMBLY -COMMON OBJECT
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 940 = 2008 (12 ) SCR 342 = 2009 (16 ) SCC 59 = 2008 (9 ) JT 304 = 2008 (11
) SCALE 557
1. DINESH BORTHAKUR .Vs. STATE OF ASSAM DOJ : 13/03/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -EVIDENCE RELATING TO THE REACTION OF
SNIFFER DOG
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2205 = 2008 (4 ) SCR 881 = 2008 (5 ) SCC 697 = 2008 (4 ) SCALE 487
1. V KISHAN RAO .Vs. NIKHIL SUPER SPECIALITY HOSPITAL & ANOTHER DOJ : 08/03/2010 JUDGEMENT
CONSUMER PROTECTION -MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE -EXPERT EVIDENCE -REQUIREMENT
Citation(s) 2010 (5 ) SCR 1 = 2010 (5 ) SCC 513 = 2010 (4 ) JT 630 = 2010 (4 ) SCALE 662
2. STATE OF H.P. .Vs. JAI LAL & ORS. DOJ : 13/09/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -EXPERT EVIDENCE -CROP -DESTRUCTION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3318 = 1999 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 318 = 1999 ( 7 ) SCC 280 = 1999 ( 6 ) JT 548 = 1999 ( 5
) SCALE 445
3. HARBHAJAN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 04/03/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT -EXPERT EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1183 = 1997 ( 3 ) JT 278 = 1997 ( 2 ) SCALE 528
4. STATE THRU. CBI NEW DELHI .Vs. S.J. CHOUDHARY DOJ : 13/02/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EXPERT EVIDENCE -TYPEWRITING
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 1491 = 1996 ( 2 ) SCR 556 = 1996 ( 2 ) SCC 428 = 1996 ( 2 ) JT 186 = 1996 ( 2
) SCALE 37
5. MAFABHAI NAGARBHAI RAVAL .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 14/08/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EXPERT EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EXPERT -MURDER
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 2186 = 1992 ( 4 ) SCC 69 = 1992 ( 4 ) JT 555 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 170
6. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. SUKHDEO SINGH @ SUKHA DOJ : 15/07/1992 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -EXPERT EVIDENCE -HANDWRITING -FINGER PRINT
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 2100 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCR 480 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 700 = 1992 ( 4 ) JT 73 = 1992 ( 2
) SCALE 9
7. PEERLESS GENERAL FINANCE & INVESTMENT CO. LTD. .Vs. RESERVE BANK OF INDIA DOJ : 30/01/1992
COURTS -EXPERT EVIDENCE -ECONOMIC POLICY -RESERVE BANK OF INDIA
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1033 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCR 406 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCC 343 = 1992 ( 1 ) JT 405 = 1992 ( 1
) SCALE 216
8. ANVARUDDIN .Vs. SHAKOOR DOJ : 30/03/1990
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -EXPERT EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1242 = 1990 ( 3 ) SCC 266 = 1990 ( 2 ) JT 83 = 1990 ( 1 ) SCALE 636
9. STATE THRU. C.B.I. / NEW DELHI .Vs. S.J. CHOUDHARY DOJ : 22/03/1990 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -EXPERT EVIDENCE -TYPE SCRIPT -PRIVATE LOTTERY
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1050 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCR 124 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCC 481 = 1990 ( 2 ) JT 15 = 1990 ( 1
) SCALE 617
1. MAHILA VINOD KUMARI .Vs. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH DOJ : 11/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -FABRICATED EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2965 = 2008 (10 ) SCR 869 = 2008 (8 ) SCC 34 = 2008 (7 ) JT 537 = 2008 (10
) SCALE 97
1. SR. DIVISIONAL MANAGER, O.I.CO. LTD. & ANR .Vs. TARGET PLYWOOD INDUSTRIES LTD. DOJ
: 07/07/2009 JUDGEMENT
CONSUMER PROTECTION -FIRE INSURANCE -DEDUCTION -FALSE EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1388 = 2009 (10 ) SCR 356 = 2009 (7 ) SCC 759 = 2009 (9 ) JT 42
2. RATTANLAL .Vs. STATE OF JAMMU & KASHMIR DOJ : 10/04/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -FALSE EVIDENCE -J&K
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1254 = 2007 (4 ) SCR 1029 = 2007 (13 ) SCC 18 = 2007 (5 ) JT 538
3. MOHAN SINGH .Vs. PREM SINGH & ANR. DOJ : 01/10/2002 JUDGEMENT
FALSE EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION -PRESENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3582 = 2002 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 5 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 236 = 2002 (8 ) JT 7 = 2002 (6
) SCALE 168

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 73 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

1. C.C.E. AHMEDABAD .Vs. SURBHI ENTERPRISES DOJ : 02/02/2005 JUDGEMENT


EXCISE LAW -MANUFACTURE -PLEADING & PROOF -FRESH EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 (12 ) SCC 280 =
2. BOARD OF TRUSTEES FOR THE PORT OF CALCUTTA .Vs. ACHINTYA KUMAR MONDAL DOJ
: 27/04/1993 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -APPEAL -REMAND -FRESH EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 2278 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 25 = 1993 ( 4 ) JT 37 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCALE 656
1. UT OF DADRA AND HAVRLI AND ANR .Vs. FATEHSINH MOHANSINH CHAUHAN DOJ : 14/08/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -MATERIAL EVIDENCE -PERSONAL PRESENCE -EXAMINATION
Citation(s) 2006 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 522 = 2006 (7 ) SCC 529 = 2006 (7 ) JT 419 = 2006 (8 ) SCALE 36
2. UT OF DADRA AND HAVRLI AND ANR .Vs. FATEHSINH MOHANSINH CHAUHAN DOJ : 14/08/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -MATERIAL EVIDENCE -SUMMON -POWERS
Citation(s) 2006 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 522 = 2006 (7 ) SCC 529 = 2006 (7 ) JT 419 = 2006 (8 ) SCALE 36
1. SURAJ SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 24/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -MEDICAL & OCULAR EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 631 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 286 = 2008 (16 ) SCC 686 = 2008 (8 ) JT 411 = 2008 (10
) SCALE 536
2. KHAMBAM RAJA REDDY & ANR. .Vs. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR HIGH COURT OF A.P. DOJ : 21/09/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -MEDICAL & OCULAR EVIDENCE -CRIMINAL TRIAL
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 3236 = 2006 (6 ) Suppl. SCR 446 = 2006 (11 ) SCC 239 = 2006 (12 ) JT 164 = 2006 (9
) SCALE 438
1. SUBRAMANI @ JEEVA @ KULLAJEEVA .Vs. S.H.O., ODIYANSALAI DOJ : 30/03/2011 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -TEST IDENTIFICATION -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 SCR 25 = 2011 (5 ) JT 403 = 2011 (5 ) SCALE 139
2. BUDHADEV KARMASKAR .Vs. STATE OF WEST BENGAL DOJ : 14/02/2011 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EYE WITNESS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CORROBORATION
Citation(s) 2011 (2 ) SCR 925 = 2011 (11 ) SCC 538 = 2011 (2 ) JT 115 = 2011 (2 ) SCALE 435
3. BUDHADEV KARMASKAR .Vs. STATE OF WEST BENGAL DOJ : 14/02/2011 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -DELAY IN FILING -EYE WITNESS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 (2 ) SCR 925 = 2011 (11 ) SCC 538 = 2011 (2 ) JT 115 = 2011 (2 ) SCALE 435
4. OM PAL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 09/11/2010 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -OCULAR EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 AIR 1562 = 2010 (13 ) SCR 558 = 2010 (14 ) SCC 200 = 2010 (12 ) JT 120 = 2010 (11
) SCALE 621
5. BOYA HANUMAN & ANR .Vs. STTE OF A.P. DOJ : 11/11/2009 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 (17 ) SCC 625 = 2009 (14 ) SCALE 134
6. RAJENDRA & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH DOJ : 08/04/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -WITNESS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2558 = 2009 (5 ) SCR 589 = 2009 (13 ) SCC 480 = 2009 (5 ) JT 305 = 2009 (5
) SCALE 423
7. S.RAMAKRISHNA .Vs. THE STATE REP. BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF A.P. HYDERABAD DOJ
: 20/10/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -RAPE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 885 = 2008 (14 ) SCR 851 = 2009 (1 ) SCC 133 = 2008 (11 ) JT 635 = 2008 (14
) SCALE 8
8. DINESH SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 04/08/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RIGHT OF PRIVATE DEFENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 711 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 801 = 2008 (15 ) SCC 745 = 2008 (8 ) JT 684 = 2008 (11
) SCALE 113
9. ANIRUDDHA SINGH & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 16/05/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EYE WITNESS -BENEFIT OF DOUBT -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 (11 ) SCC 403 = 2008 (8 ) SCALE 338
10. BENJAMIN .Vs. STATE REPRESENTED BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE DOJ : 11/01/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -INTENTION -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1383 = 2008 (1 ) SCR 656 = 2008 (3 ) SCC 745 = 2008 (1 ) JT 511 =
11. KAPILDEO MANDAL & ORS .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 29/11/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -PATNA
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 533 = 2007 (12 ) SCR 668 = 2008 (16 ) SCC 99 = 2007 (13 ) JT 202
12. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. MUSHTAQ ALAM DOJ : 25/07/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -ALLAHABAD
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 2672 = 2007 (8 ) SCR 526 = 2007 (11 ) SCC 215 = 2007 (9 ) JT 556 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 74 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

13. SANTOSH @ SANTUKRAO .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 09/05/2007 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -ASSAULT & MURDER -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -MAHARASHTRA
Citation(s) 2007 (6 ) SCR 199 = 2007 (13 ) SCC 457 = 2007 (7 ) JT 223 = 2007 (6 ) SCALE 718
14. SHYAM .Vs. STATE OF M P THROUGH P S BERCHA DOJ : 15/02/2007 JUDGEMENT
MEDICAL EVIDENCE -DELAY IN FIR -FIR
Citation(s) 2007 (2 ) SCR 706 = 2009 (16 ) SCC 531 = 2007 (3 ) JT 497 = 2007 (3 ) SCALE 181
15. MOHD SHAKEEL .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 22/11/2006 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -INJURY -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -DEATH
Citation(s) 2007 (3 ) SCC 119 =
16. KAILASH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 29/09/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -ORAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 (6 ) Suppl. SCR 793 = 2006 (11 ) SCC 420 = 2006 (9 ) JT 278 = 2006 (9 ) SCALE 681
17. STATE OF TAMIL NADU .Vs. RAVI @ NEHRU DOJ : 04/07/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE MINOR GIRL -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -MADRAS
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 2568 = 2006 (3 ) Suppl. SCR 156 = 2006 (10 ) SCC 534 = 2006 (6 ) JT 379 = 2006 (6
) SCALE 441
18. BUDH SINGH & ORS .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 12/05/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -ACQUITTAL -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 AIR 2500 = 2006 (2 ) Suppl. SCR 715 = 2006 (9 ) SCC 731 = 2006 (11 ) JT 503 = 2006 (5
) SCALE 666
19. RAVI KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 04/03/2005 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -FIR -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1929 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 548 = 2005 (9 ) SCC 315 = 2005 (3 ) JT 62 = 2005 (2
) SCALE 534
20. AMRITA ALIAS AMRITLAL .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 09/02/2004 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RELATED WITNESS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2004 (12 ) SCC 224 = 2004 (2 ) JT 295 = 2004 (2 ) SCALE 343
21. STATE OF PUNJAB .Vs. MELA SINGH DOJ : 06/11/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2004 AIR 257 = 2003 (12 ) SCC 464 = 2003 (8 ) JT 562 = 2003 (9 ) SCALE 387
22. AMAR SINGH .Vs. BALWINDER SINGH & ORS. DOJ : 31/01/2003 JUDGEMENT
MURDER -EYE WITNESS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 1164 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCR 754 = 2003 ( 2 ) SCC 518 = 2003 ( 2 ) JT 1
23. GYASIRAM & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 06/01/2003 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -COMMON INTENTION -EYE WITNESS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 2097 = 2002 (10 ) SCC 375 = 2003 (1 ) JT 8 = 2003 (1 ) SCALE 27
24. ASHOK KUMAR .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 17/12/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 777 = 2002 Suppl. SCR 159 = 2002 (10 ) JT 526 = 2002 (9 ) SCALE 382
25. SUBHASH RAMKUMAR BIND @ VAKIL & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 12/11/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT
Citation(s) 2003 AIR 269 = 2002 ( 4 ) Suppl. SCR 65 = 2003 ( 1 ) SCC 506 = 2002 ( 9 ) JT 445 =
26. SHAMSHER SINGH @ SHERA .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 26/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
EYE WITNESS -NON EXAMINATION -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -HARYANA
Citation(s) 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 536 = 2002 ( 7 ) JT 558 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCALE 46
27. VITHAL TUKARAM MORE & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 23/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
MURDER -MARRIED WOMEN -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -MAHARASHTRA
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2715 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 20 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 289 = 2002 ( 5 ) SCALE 289
28. RAMESHWAR DAYAL AND ORS. .Vs. STATE OF M.P. AND ANR. DOJ : 29/01/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -UNLAWFUL ASSEMBLY -COMMON INTENTION -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 754 = 2002 ( 3 ) SCC 45 = 2002 ( 1 ) JT 418 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCALE 443
29. DINESH & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 10/10/2001 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2374 = 2001 (10 ) JT 144 =
30. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. RAMANJANAPPA & ORS. DOJ : 11/09/2001 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -INJURY -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2001 AIR 3515 = 2001 ( 8 ) SCC 387 = 2001 ( 8 ) JT 19 = 2001 ( 6 ) SCALE 290
31. MUNDLAPADI KRISHNAIAH .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 22/03/2001 ORDER
STRANGULATION -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -WITNESS
Citation(s) 2003 (12 ) SCC 188 = 2001 (5 ) JT 322 = 2001 (4 ) SCALE 594
32. MUJEEB .Vs. STATE OF KERALA DOJ : 29/11/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -IDENTIFICATION -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 591 = 1999 (5 ) Suppl. SCR 16 = 2000 (10 ) SCC 315 = 1999 (9 ) JT 299 = 1999 (7
) SCALE 249

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 75 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

33. STATE OF H.P. .Vs. LEKH RAJ & ANR. DOJ : 02/11/1999 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -IDENTIFICATION -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -RAPE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 3916 = 1999 (4 ) Suppl. SCR 286 = 2000 (1 ) SCC 247 = 1999 (9 ) JT 43 =
34. MOHD. ZAHID .Vs. STATE OF T.N. DOJ : 20/07/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 2416 = 1999 ( 6 ) SCC 120 = 1999 ( 5 ) JT 5 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCALE 173
35. ADYA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 29/07/1998 ORDER
EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -OCCURAL EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 3011 = 1998 ( 6 ) SCC 439 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 327 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCALE 402
36. SANTOSH RANI JAIN & ANR. .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 23/07/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -DOWRY DEATH -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 2633 = 1998 ( 6 ) SCC 460 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 237 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCALE 332
37. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. HARBAN SAHAI DOJ : 20/04/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE -FIR -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 ( 2 ) SCR 1056 = 1998 ( 6 ) SCC 50 = 1998 ( 3 ) JT 443 = 1998 ( 3 ) SCALE 178
38. VINAYAK SHIVAJIRAO POL .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 22/01/1998 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CAPITAL PUNISHMENT -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 1096 = 1998 ( 1 ) SCR 309 = 1998 ( 2 ) SCC 233 = 1998 ( 1 ) JT 184 = 1998 ( 1
) SCALE 159
39. MANGAT RAI .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 09/07/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -WIFE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2838 = 1997 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 661 = 1997 ( 7 ) SCC 507 = 1997 ( 6 ) JT 24 =
40. HARBHAJAN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 04/03/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -BENEFIT OF DOUBT -EXPERT EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 1183 = 1997 ( 3 ) JT 278 = 1997 ( 2 ) SCALE 528
41. SUKHPAL .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 08/01/1997 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -DEATH
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 468 = 1997 ( 9 ) SCC 773 = 1997 ( 1 ) JT 387 = 1997 ( 1 ) SCALE 139
42. STATE OF KERALA .Vs. SASI DOJ : 31/10/1996 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -CONVICTION -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 ( 8 ) Suppl. SCR 304 = 1996 (11 ) SCC 251 = 1996 Suppl. JT 403 = 1996 ( 8 ) SCALE 241
43. STATE OF KARNATAKA .Vs. DIWAKARA BHAT DOJ : 23/09/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -INJURY -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -FIR
Citation(s) 1996 (11 ) SCC 148 = 1996 ( 8 ) JT 457 = 1996 ( 7 ) SCALE 97
44. DARSHAN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 30/08/1996 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -OCCURAL EVIDENCE -ARMS & AMMUNITION
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 364 = 1996 (10 ) SCC 283 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 263
45. PREM RAJ .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 07/05/1996 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EYE WITNESS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 3294 = 1996 ( 6 ) JT 117 = 1996 ( 4 ) SCALE 252
46. STATE OF M.P. .Vs. SUBHAN DOJ : 15/04/1996 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -FIR -CHILD WITNESS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 3345 = 1996 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 333 = 1996 ( 9 ) SCC 46 = 1996 ( 5 ) JT 414 =
47. HARDIAL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 09/04/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -PRIVATE DEFENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1996 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 114 = 1996 ( 8 ) SCC 237 = 1996 ( 4 ) JT 215 = 1996 ( 3 ) SCALE 378
48. JAGDISH NARAIN .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 12/03/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EYE WITNESS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 3136 = 1996 ( 3 ) SCR 250 = 1996 ( 8 ) SCC 199 = 1996 ( 3 ) JT 89 =
49. HARI CHAND .Vs. STATE OF DELHI DOJ : 12/02/1996 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EYE WITNESS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1996 AIR 1477 = 1996 ( 9 ) SCC 112 = 1996 ( 2 ) JT 140 = 1996 ( 2 ) SCALE 16
50. BUDHA SATYA VENKATA S. RAO .Vs. STATE OF A.P. DOJ : 07/10/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1994 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 639 = 1994 ( 6 ) JT 438 = 1994 ( 4 ) SCALE 480
51. MANI RAM .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 13/05/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EYE WITNESS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1994 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 63 = 1994 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 289 = 1994 ( 4 ) JT 62 = 1994 ( 2 ) SCALE 970
52. RAMAPPA VASAPPA BADIGER .Vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA DOJ : 22/02/1994 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -EYE WITNESS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1994 ( 2 ) JT 91 = 1994 ( 1 ) SCALE 704
53. PULARU .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 21/01/1993 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CORROBORATION
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 1487 = 1993 Suppl. JT 514 =

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 76 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

54. KAMESHWAR SINGH & RAM BABU SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 12/08/1992 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -WITNESS -EYE WITNESS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1992 ( 6 ) JT 85 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCALE 102
55. BHUPENDRA NATH PRASAD .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 31/07/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -CARDIO RESPIRATORY FAILURE
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 300 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 547 = 1992 ( 4 ) JT 309 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 101
56. STATE KARNATAKA .Vs. MAHABALESHWAR GOURYA NAIK DOJ : 15/05/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -RAPE -SUICIDE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 2043 = 1992 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 179 = 1992 ( 3 ) JT 319 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 1222
57. MADAN GOPAL KAKKAD .Vs. NAVAL DUBEY DOJ : 29/04/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -RAPE MINOR GIRL
Citation(s) 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 921 = 1992 ( 3 ) SCC 204 = 1992 ( 3 ) JT 270 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 957
58. DARBARA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 21/04/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -WOUNDS & WEAPONS -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -LIFE IMPRISONMENT
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1429 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 586 = 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 295 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 580
59. BAWA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 26/03/1992 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -INJURY
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 292 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 754 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 497 =
60. DEV RAJ .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 11/03/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -GRIEVOUS HURT
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 950 = 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 81 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 302 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 608
61. CHANDRA MOHAN TIWARI .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 22/01/1992 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 891 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCR 313 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCC 105 = 1992 ( 1 ) JT 258 =
62. B.N. SINGH .Vs. STATE OF GUJARAT DOJ : 07/02/1990
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1628 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCC 154 = 1990 ( 1 ) JT 164 = 1990 ( 1 ) SCALE 129
63. BEJOY SINGH @ VIJAY NARAIN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF W.B. DOJ : 07/02/1990
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 814 = 1990 ( 2 ) SCC 159 = 1990 ( 1 ) JT 161 = 1990 ( 1 ) SCALE 132
64. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA .Vs. CHANDRAPRAKASH KEWALCHAND JAIN DOJ : 18/01/1990 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -RAPE POLICE OFFICER
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 658 = 1990 (1 ) SCR 115 = 1990 (1 ) SCC 550 = 1990 (1 ) JT 61 = 1990 (1 ) SCALE 33
1. SURJIT SINGH @ GURMIT SINGH .Vs. STATE OF PUNJAB DOJ : 28/04/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -FIR -NOT AN EVIDENCE -NOT AN ENCYCLOPEADIA OF CASE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1389 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCR 786 = 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 208 = 1992 ( 4 ) JT 131 =
1. ADYA SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 29/07/1998 ORDER
EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -OCCURAL EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 1998 AIR 3011 = 1998 ( 6 ) SCC 439 = 1998 ( 5 ) JT 327 = 1998 ( 4 ) SCALE 402
2. DARSHAN SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 30/08/1996 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -OCCURAL EVIDENCE -ARMS & AMMUNITION
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 364 = 1996 (10 ) SCC 283 = 1996 ( 6 ) SCALE 263
3. JAIRAM .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 09/09/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -OCCURAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 92 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 578 = 1992 ( 5 ) JT 376 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 771
4. JAIRAM .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 09/09/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -PRIVATE DEFENCE -OCCURAL EVIDENCE -MURDER
Citation(s) 1993 AIR 92 = 1993 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 578 = 1992 ( 5 ) JT 376 = 1992 ( 2 ) SCALE 771
5. STATE OF U.P. .Vs. HARDEO DOJ : 06/03/1992 ORDER
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -OCCURAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1992 AIR 1854 = 1993 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCC 473 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 324 =
6. BIRI SINGH .Vs. STATE OF U.P. DOJ : 06/03/1992 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -OCCURAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1992 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCC 264 = 1992 ( 2 ) JT 229 = 1992 ( 1 ) SCALE 558
1. BHAIRON SINGH .Vs. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH DOJ : 29/05/2009 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ORAL EVIDENCE -ADMISSIBILITY
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 2603 = 2009 (13 ) SCC 80 = 2009 (7 ) JT 495 = 2009 (8 ) SCALE 634
2. TIKKA RAM & ANR. .Vs. KARTARA (DECEASED) THRU LRS. & ORS. DOJ : 14/05/2008 JUDGEMENT
TENANCY & LAND LAWS -TENANCY RIGHTS -PRE EMPTION -ORAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 1022 = 2008 (8 ) SCR 719 = 2008 (12 ) SCC 634 = 2008 (8 ) SCALE 201
3. RAM SWAROOP .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 25/03/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -ORAL EVIDENCE -EYE WITNESS
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 1747 = 2008 (5 ) SCR 484 = 2008 (13 ) SCC 515 = 2008 (4 ) JT 401 = 2008 (4
) SCALE 566

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 77 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

4. SHYAM .Vs. STATE OF M P THROUGH P S BERCHA DOJ : 15/02/2007 JUDGEMENT


CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -ORAL EVIDENCE -DELAY
Citation(s) 2007 (2 ) SCR 706 = 2009 (16 ) SCC 531 = 2007 (3 ) JT 497 = 2007 (3 ) SCALE 181
5. KAILASH .Vs. STATE OF M.P. DOJ : 29/09/2006 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL TRIAL -APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -MEDICAL EVIDENCE -ORAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2006 (6 ) Suppl. SCR 793 = 2006 (11 ) SCC 420 = 2006 (9 ) JT 278 = 2006 (9 ) SCALE 681
6. STATE OF HARYANA .Vs. VIKRAM SINGH DOJ : 22/01/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -NARCOTIC DRUGS -ORAL EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 731 = 2002 ( 2 ) SCC 676 = 2002 ( 1 ) JT 235 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCALE 288
7. ACHUTANANDA BAIDYA .Vs. PRAFULLYA KUMAR GAYEN DOJ : 08/04/1997 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -ORAL SETTLEMENT -ORAL EVIDENCE -PROPERTY
Citation(s) 1997 AIR 2077 = 1997 ( 3 ) SCR 709 = 1997 ( 5 ) SCC 76 = 1997 ( 5 ) JT 75 = 1997 ( 3
) SCALE 475
8. THAKUR SEN NEGI .Vs. DEV RAJ NEGI DOJ : 05/05/1993 JUDGEMENT
ELECTION LAW -CORRUPT PRACTICE -POSTER -ORAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1994 AIR 2526 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 645 = 1993 ( 3 ) JT 189 = 1993 ( 2 ) SCALE 738
9. JARNAIL SINGH .Vs. STATE OF HARYANA DOJ : 20/01/1993 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -EVIDENCE -ORAL EVIDENCE -MOTIVE
Citation(s) 1993 ( 1 ) SCR 260 = 1993 ( 3 ) Suppl. SCC 91 = 1993 ( 1 ) JT 207 = 1993 ( 1 ) SCALE 153
10. BHOOLCHAND .Vs. KAY PEE CEE INVESTMENTS DOJ : 10/10/1990 JUDGEMENT
RENT LAW -EVICTION -BONAFIDE NEED -ORAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1991 AIR 2053 = 1990 ( 2 ) Suppl. SCR 251 = 1991 ( 1 ) SCC 343 = 1991 ( 1 ) JT 186 = 1990 ( 2
) SCALE 711
11. RAJ KUMAR RAJINDER SINGH .Vs. STATE OF H.P. DOJ : 20/07/1990 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -DOCUMENTS -AMBIGUOUS LANGUAGE -ORAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1990 AIR 1833 = 1990 ( 3 ) SCR 469 = 1990 ( 4 ) SCC 320 = 1990 ( 3 ) JT 215 = 1990 ( 2
) SCALE 95
1. STATE OF HARYANA .Vs. SHIBU @ SHIV NARAIN & ORS. DOJ : 25/07/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -APPEAL AGAINST ACQUITTAL -REAPPRAISAL OF EVIDENCE -MISCARRIAGE OF JUSTICE
Citation(s) 2009 AIR 609 = 2008 (11 ) SCR 361 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 377 = 2008 (10 ) SCALE 445
2. STATE OF HARYANA .Vs. RAM SARUP DOJ : 04/09/2002 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -REAPPRAISAL OF EVIDENCE -ACQUITTAL
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 3114 = 2002 ( 7 ) SCC 250 = 2002 ( 6 ) JT 433 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCALE 201
3. DHANANJAY SHANKAR SHETTY .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 31/07/2002 JUDGEMENT
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW -REAPPRAISAL OF EVIDENCE -SUPREME COURT -INTERFERENCE
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 2787 = 2002 ( 1 ) Suppl. SCR 352 = 2002 ( 6 ) SCC 596 = 2002 ( 5 ) JT 559 = 2002 ( 5
) SCALE 387
4. LAL MANDI .Vs. STAE OF WEST BENGAL DOJ : 04/04/1995 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -CRIMINAL APPEAL -SUPREME COURT -REAPPRAISAL OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 1995 AIR 2265 = 1995 ( 3 ) SCR 134 = 1995 ( 3 ) SCC 603 = 1997 (10 ) JT 586 = 1995 ( 2
) SCALE 571
1. T. THIMMAIAH (D) BY LRS. .Vs. VENKATACHALA RAJU (D) BY LRS. DOJ : 09/05/2008 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -REVIEW -REAPPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -KARNATAKA
Citation(s) 2008 (11 ) SCC 107 = 2008 (7 ) JT 137 = 2008 (8 ) SCALE 138
2. T. THIMMAIAH (D) BY LRS. .Vs. VENKATACHALA RAJU (D) BY LRS. DOJ : 09/05/2008 JUDGEMENT
CIVIL PROCEDURE -SUIT FOR DECLARATION -REAPPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE -KARNATAKA
Citation(s) 2008 (11 ) SCC 107 = 2008 (7 ) JT 137 = 2008 (8 ) SCALE 138
3. MANGU KHAN & ORS. .Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN DOJ : 24/02/2005 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -REAPPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 AIR 1912 = 2005 (2 ) SCR 368 = 2005 (10 ) SCC 374 = 2005 (2 ) JT 575 = 2005 (2
) SCALE 365
1. SYED PEDA AOWLIA .Vs. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR HIGH COURT OF A.P. HYDERABAD DOJ : 13/06/2008 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MURDER -APPEAL AGAINST ACQUITTAL -REVIEWING THE EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2008 AIR 2573 = 2008 (9 ) SCR 1151 = 2008 (11 ) SCC 394 = 2008 (9 ) SCALE 356
1. J. YASHODA .Vs. K. SHOBHA RANI DOJ : 19/04/2007 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -SECONDARY EVIDENCE -ADMISSIBILITY -A P
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 1721 = 2007 (5 ) SCR 367 = 2007 (5 ) SCC 730 = 2007 (6 ) JT 64 = 2007 (6
) SCALE 6
2. RAM CHANDER .Vs. RAM SINGH ALIAS BHUNDE & ANR DOJ : 23/09/2005 ORDER
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -SUBSTANTIAL QUESTION OF LAW -SECONDARY EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2005 (13 ) SCC 91 =
3. STATE OF H.P. & ANR. .Vs. AKSHARA NAND (D) BY LRS. & ORS. DOJ : 15/03/2000 JUDGEMENT
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE -SECOND APPEAL -SECONDARY EVIDENCE -DEEDS & DOCUMENTS
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 1828 = 2000 ( 3 ) SCC 661 = 2000 ( 3 ) JT 212 = 2000 ( 2 ) SCALE 375

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 78 of 79


CASE LAW COLLECTED BY ADVOCATE - SRIDHARA BABU. N
TUMKUR-KARNATAKA-PH- 9880339764

4. STATE OF RAJASTHAN .Vs. KHEMRAJ DOJ : 10/01/2000 ORDER


EVIDENCE -SECONDARY EVIDENCE -AFFIDAVIT
Citation(s) 2000 AIR 1759 = 2000 ( 9 ) SCC 241 = 2000 ( 2 ) JT 40 =
5. NAWAB SINGH .Vs. INDERJIT KAUR DOJ : 06/05/1999 JUDGEMENT
EVIDENCE -SECONDARY EVIDENCE -RENT LAW -EVICTION
Citation(s) 1999 AIR 1668 = 1999 ( 4 ) SCC 413 = 1999 ( 3 ) JT 419 = 1999 ( 3 ) SCALE 170
1. NILESH DINKAR PARADKAR .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 09/03/2011 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -MCOCA -VOICE IDENTIFICATION TEST -SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Citation(s) 2011 (3 ) SCR 792 = 2011 (4 ) SCC 143 = 2011 (3 ) JT 429 = 2011 (3 ) SCALE 473
2. AMITSINGH BHIKAMSING THAKUR .Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA DOJ : 05/01/2007 JUDGEMENT
CRIMINAL LAW -IDENTIFICATION PARADE -SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION
Citation(s) 2007 AIR 676 = 2007 (1 ) SCR 191 = 2007 (2 ) SCC 310 = 2007 (1 ) JT 390 = 2007 (1
) SCALE 62
3. PANCHDEO SINGH .Vs. STATE OF BIHAR DOJ : 07/12/2001 JUDGEMENT
DYING DECLARATION -SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE -CONVICTION -SUSTAINABILITY
Citation(s) 2002 AIR 526 = 2001 ( 5 ) Suppl. SCR 503 = 2002 ( 1 ) SCC 577 = 2001 (10 ) JT 322 = 2001 ( 8
) SCALE 393

CASE LAW ON EVIDENCE Page 79 of 79

You might also like