Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/283004319
CITATION READS
1 92
2 authors, including:
Chongdu Cho
Inha University
371 PUBLICATIONS 1,790 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Chongdu Cho on 28 September 2018.
(Manuscript Received November 4, 2014; Revised May 7, 2015; Accepted May 20, 2015)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract
This paper presents a method for measuring torque applied to the rotating shaft of a gear box without physical modifications. As a re-
sult, the new measurement unit can detect the applied torque with an error of less than 1 % for the whole targeted speed range of 100 -
500 rpm. A Magnetic sensor band (MSB) is used to eliminate any need for calibration during the use of the unit. The major disadvantage
of this system is the fact that it is not suitable for measurement of torque under the stopped condition. This shortcoming is found to be
unable to overcome, and therefore the new unit has only limited application. However, the sensor module has sufficient engineering mer-
its, since it is implemented with a simple hardware method and is associated with a lower cost than current, commercially available
torque sensors.
Keywords: Noncontact torque sensor; Magnetic intensity monitor; Dynamic torque; Hall sensor; Magnet sensor band
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
the torque applied to the shaft by measuring the angle of twist. Table 1. Specification of hardware components used.
Properties PTFE PC PP
Density (g/cm3) 2.18 1.2 0.91
Melt temp. (℃) 327 155 168
Bond-ability (Epoxy) No Yes No
Fig. 6. Twist angle per unit torque variation against rotational speed
within the range of 100-500 rpm.
Fig. 5. Temperature dependency effect on elastic modulus E.
coming from the gap of the sensor shaft and the body of the
elastic modulus value was also considered, as shown in Fig. 5. measuring unit. This gap is main root cause of changing the
During the experiments the temperature was measured by a distance of the sensor and magnets. Because of this effect,
thermocouple sensor, however it was measured at the connect- even if the axle induced vibration, the proposed methodology
ing part near to the shaft instead of the actual rotating shaft elicited stable values, even in the cases of shaft and sensing
because of difficulty associated with the insertion of the slip- block vibration.
ring during shaft rotation. Furthermore, the structure could
become complicated, and reduce life time just in the same
5. Results and discussion
manner as the strain gauge type torque sensors.
The variation of the temperature test is not included herein Fig. 6 shows experimental data of the twisting angle per
because of the limitations of the experimental apparatus. If the unit torque applied to specified range of rotational speeds to
influence of temperature on the measurement is accounted for, measure the reliability and repeatability of the sensitivity of
G in Eq. (1) must not be constant, and it may be represented the fabricated sensor module. A total of four experiments were
by Eq. (4), using the interpolation formula listed in Fig. 5. evaluated for reliability in a week, or two- week periods. At a
rotational speed of 100 rpm a slope deviation of about 3.6 %
E of full scale is estimated, while the data of 200-500 rpm show
G= less than 1 % deviation. As shown in the hardware configura-
2(1 + n )
tion of Fig. 1, as well according to our expectation, the data
-284.769 Tp3 + 30508.665 Tp2 - 49 ´ 106Tp + 202 ´ 109
» . variation within the range of 100-200 rpm comes from the
2(1 + v) difference between the position of the new sensor and com-
(4) mercial sensor. A variation at speed of 300 rpm or above is
very small, because the dynamic friction coefficient is smaller
In the present study, we decided not to consider effects of than static friction coefficient. In practical applications, the
temperature because the maximum variation of temperature of calculated mean value of 2.24x10-5 rad/N·m must be applied
the test device was only about 5°C. in the dynamic friction effect zone; however, Eq. (6) was also
After increasing the number of magnets to eight, uniformly used for correction to compare with the measured data from
mounted on the shaft, each of 25 mm in diameter, we obtained inline torque sensor in this experiment. We know that the cali-
a modified sine curve with a nearly uniform period, using the bration must do in the linear region that act dynamic friction to
MSB. The linear data were obtained without nonlinearities or get designed data without uncertainty.
singular points, even at the initial twisting conditions,
achieved by bonding the MSB (which has a large contact area) 2L rad
F= T = 2.244 ´ 10-5 *T (5)
between the ring and the shaft, without deformation of contact p R 4G N×m
point between band and magnet.
We also replaced the ball bearing with an angular ball bear- where L = 0.065 m, R = 0.0125 m, and G = 78 GPa with the
ing with preload to make the isolation effective, and improve chosen material being SUS316 stainless steel. The constant
the repeatability and reproducibility by reducing the vibration values (rad/N·m) from Eq. (5) are 99.9 % similar to the aver-
K. Lee and C. Cho / Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology 29 (9) (2015) 3897~3903 3901
Fig. 7. Initial torque error measured for the range of rotational speeds
from 100-500 rpm.
Fig. 8. Real measurement data of twist angle versus testing torque for a
rotational speed of 400 rpm.
age slope of Fig. 6, as indicated by the experimental results. It
means the theoretical value is highly matched with the ex-
perimental result. Therefore, the new torque measurement
system has adequate reliability and the ratio of F and T can
be determined from the theoretical calculation instead of cali-
bration.
F
T= + Foff ( n )
Fsen ( n )
(6)
106 ´ F
= + Foff ( n ) .
-0.074n + 0.928n3 - 3.953n 2 + 6.226n + 20
4
ence of slope from Figs. 6 and 7. In addition, the major disadvantage of the measurement
Fig. 10 shows a graph of sensing detects the variable torque concept is that it cannot measure torque at the zero or slow
at the actual program, it can be verified that to obtain the de- rotation speed, but it might be overcome according to apply-
sired value. The solid line represents the measured values of ing specified purpose. For example, we can make the excep-
the inline sensor and the dotted line the measured values of the tion processing of the control loop at very low driving speeds,
proposed sensor module. The strain gauge type torque sensor because does not require changing of transmit gears or apply
can operate in real time, but the proposed sensor with the cur- on the system need to rotate shaft always after system turning
rent hardware system cannot, because it uses an average value on like helicopter or turbine.
of the number of cycles to overcome the limitations of the Future considerations will focus on the tester to allow its
hardware specification. Symptoms from applying average application to rotational speeds, over 500 rpm up to 5000 rpm,
method can make signal delay compare with real time data. in the high regime and to confirm effects of high temperature.
This phenomenon can be improved with the application of a
high-speed DAQ board in planned future work.
Acknowledgment
This work was supported by Inha University.
6. Conclusions
In this study, a torque measuring method that uses permanent Nomenclature------------------------------------------------------------------------
magnets and hall sensors has been demonstrated to prove preci-
sion and reliability. More accurate results could be obtained by G : Shear modulus
using real-time feedback data of rotational speed as an impor- n : Rotational speed of shaft
tant parameter. It is shown that sensor calibration is one of the R : Radius of shaft
most important factors that must be executed at high rotational L : Distance between two sensors
speed operations to allow accurate parameter estimation. The Φ : Twist angle of shaft
initial offset values from each magnet pair signal must be set J : Polar moment of inertia
from calibration but the ratio of torque and twist angle can be Tp : Temperature of shaft
set either by calibration or from theoretical calculation.
The measurement results within the range of 100-500 rpm
References
depicted an overall error under 1% after processing calibration.
In the low speed region, even though there was a mechanical [1] W. J. Fleming, Overview of automotive sensors, IEEE Sen-
improvement due to the torque and vibrations occurring in the sors Journal, 1 (4) (2001) 296-308.
bearing, the results cannot be confirmed that the error is less [2] T. Tsujisawa and K. Yamakawa, Improvement of the angu-
than 1% because of calibration data in Fig. 6. If measurement lar-dependent noise in a magneto-striction type torque sensor,
unit is configured with frictionless bearings instead of the International Journal of Automotive Engineering, 2 (3)
current experimental apparatus, result will show small initial (2011) 75-80.
angle gap difference in every rotation speed. [3] T. Tsujisawa and K. Yamakawa, Proposal and performance
The MSB that has been studied in this paper with engineer- evaluation of a magneto-striction type torque sensor consist-
ing plastic has the following four advantages: ing of small-sized coils connected in series, ISRN Electron-
- It possesses features that complement the nonlinearity and ics, article ID 738597 (2012).
non-uniformity of the initial deformation occurring by at- [4] H. Wakiwaka and M. Mitamura, New magnetostrictive type
tachment of a number of separate magnets directly to the torque sensor for steering shaft, Sensors and Actuators, 91
drive shaft with heat-resistant glue, instead of using a me- (1-2) (2001) 103-106.
chanical method to maintain the original shape of the [5] H. Ruser, U. Troltzsch and M. Horn, Low-cost magnetic
shaft. torque sensor principle, Sensors, 2 (2) (2002) 901-904.
- It requires a frequent calibration because the strength of [6] C. M. Cai, K. Mohri, Y. Honkura and M. Yamamoto, Im-
K. Lee and C. Cho / Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology 29 (9) (2015) 3897~3903 3903
proved pulse carrier MI effect by flash anneal of amorphous Kyungshik Lee was born in Seoul, Korea,
wires and FM wireless CMOS IC torque sensor, Magnetics, in 1976. He received the B.S. degree in
IEEE Transactions, 37 (4) (2001) 2038-2041. mechanical engineering from Inha Uni-
[7] V. Kalinin, Wireless physical saw sensors for automotive versity in 2010. He is currently pursuing
applications, Ultrasonics Symposium 2011 IEEE Interna- the Ph.D. degree with the College of Me-
tional (2011) 212-221. chanical Engineering, Inha University,
[8] C. Piao, Study on wireless torque sensor by monitoring Incheon, Korea. His research interests
magnetic field, Ph.D. Dissertation, Inha University (2006). include noncontact torque meters.
[9] G. Shi, Research of a non-contact torque sensor based on mag-
netic field detecting, Master’s Thesis, Inha University (2011). Chongdu Cho has been teaching as a
[10] G. Shi, N. Wang and C. Cho, Design of a new non-contact professor of Mechanical Engineering at
torque sensor for rotating stepped shaft by monitoring mag- Inha University, Incheon, South Korea
netic field, Applied Mechanics and Materials, 44-47 (2010) since 1992. He has won a fellow profes-
547-551. sorship at Inha University since 2008.
[11] J. Fraden, Handbook of modern sensors: physics, designs, Dr. Chongdu Cho received his Ph.D. in
and applications, 4th Ed., Springer, USA (2010). Mechanical Engineering and Applied
[12] C. M. T. Lee, On algorithms for ordinary least squares Mechanics from the University of
regression spline fitting, Journal of Statistical Computation Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA. He received his
and Simulation, 72 (8) (2002) 647-663. Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering at Seoul Na-
[13] J. Astola, P. Haavisto and Y. Neuvo, Vector median filters, tional University and a Master in Science at KAIST, South
Proceedings of the IEEE, 78 (4) (1990) 678-689. Korea. His major research area is the thermo-mechanical be-
[14] Y. D. Cheong, J. W. Kim, S. H. Oh and C. W. Lee, Analy- havior of materials and composites and their fracture mechan-
sis and development of the angular twist type torque-meter, ics. He also has numerous publications on NEMS/MEMS in
Composite Structures, 47 (1-4) (1999) 457-462. the field of Carbon nanotubes, micro switches and biosensors.
[15] K. S. Lee and C. D. Cho, A Feasibility Study of a Noncon- He has published more than 160 SCI(e) peer reviewed interna-
tact Torque Sensor with Multiple Hall Sensors, Journal of tional papers, 135 international conference proceedings and
Sensors, 2015 (2015) Article ID 126935. numerous domestic articles and papers.