Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10 - Gender Stereotypes and The Media 1 Slide1 PDF
10 - Gender Stereotypes and The Media 1 Slide1 PDF
2019
Outline
2
2019
Testable Videos
3
Slide 9
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3JDmb_f3E2c
Slide 47
http://www.upworthy.com/advertising-seems-
harmless-until-you-see-it-for-what-it-really-
is?c=hpstream
2019
Reverse Engineering Gendered Products
4
2019
Gendered Bread! From the CBC story: “A recent
entry into the Canadian market is
from Stonemill Bakehouse. It's a
Toronto-based bakery that sells its
products in several
provinces. It released "his and her"
breads last month.
The men's bread comes in dark
green packaging and is high in
Feb 2015 protein and fibre, while the
women's bread comes in pink
packaging and is high in calcium
and vitamin D.
Within days of the product release,
the company's marketing effort was
lambasted by experts and
consumers as condescending and
flat-out stupid.
A headline in the Hamilton
Spectator read a
sarcastic, "Decisions decisions
… thank goodness for his and her
bread!" The Huffington Post called
it "the bread product you didn't
know was necessary."
5 2019
‘Lady Doritos’
6
From the New York Times story (Feb 2018)
Watch Ellen
DeGeneres ‘critique’
this idea (not required)
https://www.youtube.com
/watch?v=RnOAzmZQd_c
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/06/business/lady-doritos-indra-nooyi.html
2019
Pointlessly Gendered Products
http://www.buzzfeed.com/erinchack/pointl
7 essly-gendered-products
2019
Bic “Pens for Her” !!!!!
Check out
Amazon.com for
some scathing
“reviews”
8 2019
- so that they can sell more versions of the same toys - so they segment9the market
2019
Media Representations Rely on Gender Stereotypes
- for advitising they use Gender difference hypothesis - that man and woman are more different than they are similar but gender similarity
hypothesis is more preferred 13
Gender stereotypes: beliefs and
attitudes about what
activities/behaviours are appropriate
for men (masculinity) or women
(femininity)
GenderAds.com
2019
14
2019
The 2 Main Trends in Contemporary Media
Study Men Women
1) Movies: Trends of Sexual and Male Violence: 15Male characters Women as sex objects:
Violent Content by Gender in were more likely to be involved in “Female characters were found to
Top-Grossing U.S. Films, 1950– violence than female characters be twice as likely to be seen in
2006, Bleakley et al (2012) (42% vs 30%) explicit sexual scenes as males.
Study Design: Analyzed 855 top Across all films, the average
30 box-office films from 1950 to proportion of female characters
2006 involved in any sexual content
was 57%, compared to 30% for
male characters”
2) Music Videos: Performing Male leads more likely to be Female leads more likely to be
Gender: A Content Analysis of presented as aggressive (e.g. presented as (1) sex objects
Gender Display in Music Videos. displayed force, aggressive (e.g. displayed sexual self-touch)
Wallis (2011) gestures) & (2) fragile (e.g. displayed
Study Design: Analysis of gender delicate self-touch)
displays (i.e. using Goffman’s
framework, ‘Codes of Gender’) by
lead performer in music videos
3) Video Games: Video Game 83.1% of male characters showed 81.1% of female video game
Characters and the Socialization stereotypical characterizations = characters depicted as
of Gender Roles. Dill & Thill depicted as ‘hypermasculine’, sexualized
(2007) & see Behm-Morawitz aggressive
(2014) Study Design: Content
analysis of images of video game 2019
characters from magazines
The two main trends of how men and women are represented in
mainstream media in North America (citations on previous slide)
16
Men Women
_________________ ______________
2019
The Gender Differences Hypothesis
marketed to children
17
From Elizabeth
Sweet’s research
(presented in The
Atlantic):
“In the Sears
catalog ads from
1975, less than 2%
of toys were
explicitly marketed
to either boys or
girls… By 1995,
gendered toys
made up roughly
half of the Sears
catalog offerings.”
2019
LEGO Advertising Remixer
18
http://www.genderremixer.com/lego/#
2019
Gender Portrayals in Advertising over Time
19
2019
Portrayal of Women
22
Trend #3 =Magazine
advertising shows an
increasing trend over
time of more public role
portrayals of
women…but…
- women tend to be shown more in public role
- women are achieving something outside of the house
2019
Ads found at genderads.com
23
Trend #4: Also an
increasing trend over time
of females portrayed in
ritualized subordinate
poses**
- shown in subordinate position
-
‘Ritualization of
Subordination’: e.g. “Women
shown lying down. In Canting
postures. Women presented as
defenseless.”
2019
24
2019
There is a lot of research out there that suggests it does…
25
2019
Harrison (2003)
26
Rehabs.com
From a rehabs.com study: “In recent decades, two conflicting images
appear to have merged into a modern synthesis of what is considered
beautiful: an almost unhealthily thin and bony frame, combined with a
substantial bust.” 2019
Harrison (2003)
27
Study Design: PART 1
1) Female university students looked at a set of adult female
drawings
2) Asked which of 9 drawings looked like their own figure and
which looked like the figure they would “most like to have”
PART 2
1) Had participants tell the author which TV shows they
habitually watched (of 36 top-rated Nielsen TV shows): shows
chosen (1) because they were popular with young adults and (2)
contained characters with a diverse sampling of body types (e.g.
Baywatch, Ally McBeal)
2) Body sizes of female characters in these programs coded by a
separate group of researchers ; programs rated according to how
thin the coders perceived the lead female characters to be (scale
of 7 to 1: the midpoint was deemed the “average” score)
2019
28
Hypothesis: Exposure
to ideal-body television
images will be positively
associated with women’s
idealization of a slimmer
female waist and hips,
but not a smaller bust
2019
Mass Media & the Curvaceously Thin Ideal
29
Results: Female students who
watched shows with
“curvaceously thin” female
characters = were more likely
to choose an “ideal” for
themselves that had a smaller
waist, smaller hips and
medium-sized bust vs students
who watched other shows
This was the first study to
empirically link the
“curvaceously thin” ideal to
media exposure
2019
What is going on?
30
Media “cultivates”/ influences The Outcome? Different
the way we think= groups of people develop a
- similar systems of stories, media depicted world common (media-depicted)
(1) Cultivation Theory: (based on
outlook on the world =
the work of Gerbner et al 1994)
“One of the assumptions of cultivation (2) Mainstreaming:
theory is that the mass media, and “Mainstreaming is described as the
television in particular, present similar typical pattern of worldview
systems of stories.” change that cultivation, as a
“That television exposure “cultivates” process takes.”
beliefs, attitudes, and ideals about the “Mainstreaming occurs when
real world that match the media- groups who are initially divergent
depicted world” (Harrison 2003) in their worldviews come to hold
"The primary proposition of cultivation similar views with greater
theory states that the more time people television exposure. Their views
spend 'living' in the television world, the converge to reflect the “reality”
more likely they are to believe social that is most commonly presented
reality portrayed on television.“ (Cohen on television.” (Harrison 2003)
& Weimann 2000) 2019
Objectification & Objectification Theory
31
2019
32
2019
Internalizing an Observer’s Perspective
33
2019
Evolution of Male Body Images
35
Up to mid 1990s:
media images of men
focused on face not body;
or showed men in action
shots or sports
2019
36
Mid-1990s onwards:
male body/physique
starts to move to centre
stage
2019
David Beckham’s Armani Underwear Ads (2011)
37
2019
“Men’s Grooming Products” Market
38
“There has been a pivotal shift in male pampering culture during the last
decade. Men’s toiletries used to consist of shampoo, deodorant, shaving
cream and not much else. But from London to New York to São Paulo, bathroom
cabinets of middle-class homes now brim with moisturizers, facial cleansers, eye serums,
bronzers, concealers, anti-agers and even mud masks—all designed specifically for men.
Based on current trends, it is only a matter of time before a full portfolio of
men’s makeup becomes part of daily ablutions [hygiene], too.”
“A key occurrence happened in 2013 when, for the first time, men spent more cash
on male-specific toiletries than on shaving products. Sales of skin care, in particular,
boomed. And there will be no going back now. More and more men, it seems, are
putting higher stock in looking good. It’s about self-confidence as much as anything
else, and the desire to feel more attractive, more successful, and, increasingly, more
youthful. For similar reasons, men also are spending more on apparel and fashion
accessories.”
- See more at: http://www.gcimagazine.com/marketstrends/consumers/men/Its-a-
Mans-World-Mens-Grooming-Breaks-New-Ground-
246591491.html#sthash.ffyD0V6T.dpuf
2019
The Challenge
40
“Beauty in our culture is seen to be a female attribute,” said
cultural anthropologist Victor Barac, a marketing consultant
in Toronto (quoted in Globe & Mail Feb 24, 2010) . “So you'd
call them male grooming products instead [of “beauty
products” or “cosmetics”]
(1) Repackage products as “masculine”: “It's a world in
which eyeliner becomes “guyliner,” anti-wrinkle cream turns
into moisturizer, and bronzer changes to “power bronze.”
(Barac quoted in Globe & Mail Feb 24, 2010)
(2) Men’s Sections in Cosmetic Departments
(3) Use Sports sponsorships as a marketing vehicle;
e.g. Nivea for Men sponsors Montreal Canadians & Toronto
Maple Leafs; Dove Men sponsors CFL & NHL
2019
How Grooming Products are Advertised to Men
41
Dove Face Torture
Brandon Shanahan
Old Spice
2019
The Rise of the “Body-as-Self” Paradigm
42
Consequences:
(1) The body is on display like never before
(2) We are encouraged to buy things to fix/
transform our bodies like never before
2019
What is going on?
43
Unattainable body = good
for business
“Using the male body in an
objectified manner can be seen
as part of a consumerist
trend…Male dissatisfaction with
body image may be a gold mine
for consumerism such as it has
been for females. Thus, showing
a male or female body part
results in a focus on that part of
the body (e.g., abdomen, lips,
hair), highlighting an area that
“needs work” and that is ripe
for product promotion (Coward
1985).” Mager & Helgeson 2010
2019
44
Men are falling into the
same appearance-
oriented cultural trap
that women have
experienced
2019
Consequences of Self-Objectification for Men
45
Meta-analyses of the effects of media
images on men’s body-image
concerns (2008). CP Barlett et al.
Exposure to media images
of ‘ideal’ body associated
with:
Negative body satisfaction
Negative self-esteem
Increased likelihood of
experiencing negative
psychological outcomes
(including depression) &
negative behavioural outcomes
(including bulimia, excessive
exercising)
2019
From the National Post story:
“A study of Canadian, British, and
American students found that today’s
college graduates feel greater pressure
46 to be perfect that previous generations.
The researchers analyzed studies carried out
between 1989 and 2016, where college and
university students in Canada, Britain and the
United States had completed the
Multidimensional Perfectionism Scale. The
authors of the study say it is one of the first to
look at how the phenomena of
perfectionism has changed over time.”
2019
It’s “good” business: an
6 studies published in the Lancet, a top
analogous situation in medical journal, in 2015
the food industry From the CBC story: “An estimated 2.1
51 billion people [around the world] are
overweight, which accounts for about 2.8
million deaths per year. Children face some
of the highest risk, according to the authors,
as they're falling prey to colourful and fun
fast-foods ads.
As one of the authors puts it, "fat children
are an investment in future sales." The
average American kid is 11 pounds heavier
than three decades ago. That's a $20 billion
boon to the food industry every year.”
"I don't think they want to make people ill.”
says researcher Christine Roberta. “ That's
not their goal. They're just working
within a system that requires them to
Feb 2015 make profit. And a way to do that is
certainly to explore these vulnerabilities that
we have to foods that are high in sugar, high
in salt, high in fat. From a business
perspective it makes sense that they
would do that.”
2019
52
Data from the Lancet articles
(US data):
Kids are on average 5 kg
heavier than 30 years
Consume 200 kcal/day more
than a child in the 1970s
=73,000 kcal/year/child
=extra $1.22/day/child
=$400/ year x 50 million
school age children in the US
= combined excess food
consumption approaches $20
billion/year
2019
53
2019
54
2019
55
2019
(3) Gender polarization doesn’t exist in all societies
(Gender, Horticulture, and the Division of Labour in Vanatinai in GCCP)
56
Vanatinai: Small island in the
South Pacific, btw Papua New
Guinea & Australia
Largely egalitarian society:
p. 178 in GCCP: “The rights,
privileges, constraints and degrees
of personal autonomy of both sexes
are largely congruent throughout
the life course, even though they are
not perfectly symmetrical. This is a
hallmark of a gender egalitarian
society, a society that tends toward
equality.”
2019
To read about: Gender Arrangements
57
2019
To read about: Gender Arrangements
58
2019
Bringing it back to Advertising & Gendered Products…
60
2019
To sum up: What’s going on?
61
2019
When really we are like this…and this…and this…
62
2019
Take-Home Points:
63
2_________________
- man and women are more identical
3_________________
- is is no one way to be masculine, on innate to masculinity or feminity
2019
64
2019