Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Eponyms in Medicine Revisited: Cogan's Syndrome: An Oculo-Audiovestibular Disease
Eponyms in Medicine Revisited: Cogan's Syndrome: An Oculo-Audiovestibular Disease
com
Keywords: Cogan’s syndrome; hearing loss; Cogan’s syndrome is a disease of young adults characterised by acute IK with
autoimmune disease audiovestibular dysfunction, associated in close temporal proximity to flares of
IK, clinically indistinguishable from episodes of Ménière’s disease (acute onset
of nausea, vomiting, tinnitus and vertigo, rapidly followed by bilateral loss of
hearing). Atypical disease presents with a significant inflammatory eye lesion in
addition to or instead of IK. Thus, patients who developed scleritis, episcleritis,
retinal artery occlusion, choroiditis, retinal haemorrhages, papilloedema, exoph-
thalmos or tenonitis with or without IK were classified as having atypical
Cogan’s syndrome by Haines et al.2 Cases in which conjunctivitis, iritis or sub-
conjunctival haemorrhage was present in the absence of IK were also classified
as atypical disease.2 If the audiovestibular symptoms were not similar to those of
Ménière’s disease, or occurred more than 2 years before or after the onset of eye
symptoms, the patient was again considered to have atypical Cogan’s syndrome.2
Eye
x interstitial keratitis (T)
x scleritis, episcleritis, retinal vascular disease, uveitis, iritis, conjunctivitis, papilloedema,
exophthalmos, tenonitis (A)
Ear
x recurrent Ménière-like attacks (T)
x sudden hearing loss (A)
Systemic features (more frequent in A, except for aortic insuYciency)
Clínica Puerta de Hierro, Universidad x fever, headache, malaise, myalgias
Autónoma, San Martín de Porres 4, x gastrointestinal signs and symptoms (abdominal discomfort, peptic and colonic
28035 Madrid, Spain ulceration with bleeding)
Service of Otorhinolaryngology x musculoskeletal involvement (myalgias, arthritis or arthralgias)
J R García Berrocal x cutaneous lesions (skin rash, nodules)
R A Ramírez-Camacho x cardiac findings (aortic insuYciency, cardiomegaly, congestive heart failure)
Service of Internal Medicine I x genitourinary involvement (mild abnormalities on urinalysis)
J A Vargas x splenomegaly, lymphadenopathy
Service of Ophthalmology x hypertension
M Vaquero x eosinophilia
Service of Pathology
S Ramón y Cajal T: typical disease; A: atypical disease
Certain entities may mimic the clinical picture of Cogan’s syndrome. There is a
DiVerential diagnosis in clear association between upper respiratory tract infection and the onset of both
Cogan’s syndrome (modified typical and atypical Cogan’s syndrome, and a number of viral infections have
from2) been associated with IK and deafness (mumps, herpes zoster, and rubella).
In atypical forms of the disease, inflammation can spread to other parts of the
Infections eye (scleritis, uveitis or conjunctivitis) and association with systemic vasculitis
x congenital and acquired syphilis and related disorders occurs in 20% of cases.2 3
x Chlamydial infections
x viral infections
x tuberculosis with streptomycin therapy Diagnosis
Connective tissue diseases
x systemic necrotizing vasculitis, The clinical diagnosis is based on the audiovestibular symptoms, the ocular
including polyarteritis nodosa inflammation and nonreactive serologic tests for syphilis. The diagnostic suspi-
x rheumatoid arthritis cion based on the clinical course must be completed with an immunological
x relapsing polychondritis work-up. The existence of a population of deficient naive cytotoxic T cells could
x aortitis syndrome (Takayashu’s suggest a priori a poor response to steroid therapy. The decrease in this cell
disease)
population might be implicated in a possible deficiency of the cytotoxic mecha-
Other diseases nisms in response to the antigen that triggers the process.4 This finding provides
x Wegener’s granulomatosis
x sarcoidosis additional support for a cell-mediated type IV response.5
x Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada disease The observation of hyperintensity within the membranous labyrinth on
x Ménière’s disease with eye symptoms precontrast T1-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has been reported
in a patient with Cogan’s syndrome6 and probably represents haemorrhage and
Box 2 leakage through the abnormal labyrinthine membrane due to active disease
(inflammation of the blood vessels of the stria vascularis).
Pathogenesis
Diagnosis of Cogan’s syndrome
Recent experiences strongly suggest that Cogan’s syndrome is an autoimmune
Clinical picture disease,7–10 mediated by means of a hypersensitivity response to one or more
x immunological work-up
x erythrocyte sedimentation rate
infectious agents associated with vasculitis. Several authors have noted an
x serum IgG, IgA, IgM immediately preceding upper respiratory tract infection. Thus, it is quite prob-
x complement system (C3, C4) able that a virus infection prompts an antibody response that develops a cross-
x autoantibodies: antinuclear antibodies, immunity with similar proteins in the tissues of the audiovestibular system, eye,
extractable nuclear antigen and occasionally other organs as well.2–11 Temporal bone pathology includes
x rheumatoid factor endolymphatic hydrops, atrophy of the organ of Corti, plasma cell and
x immunophenotype analysis of
peripheral blood lymphocytes
lymphocytic infiltration of the spiral ligament, osteoneogenesis of the round
window, spiral ganglion cell degeneration, cystic degeneration of the stria vascu-
Microbiology
x syphilis: VDRL, fluorescent
laris, middle ear eVusion, demyelination of the eighth cranial nerve and vasculi-
treponemal antibody absorption tis of the internal auditory artery.11–13
x Mycoplasma pneumoniae Lymphocyte transformation has reportedly been detected when the patient’s
x Epstein-Barr virus lymphocytes are exposed to corneal antigen, scleroprotein, and inner ear
x Herpes simplex virus antigen, suggesting the presence of cell-mediated autoimmune reactivity.7 9 14
x Varicella- zoster virus
x cytomegalovirus
x respiratory syncytial virus
Treatment
x influenza A, B, and parainfluenza 1, 2,
3 Therapy consists of high-dosage corticosteroids; the outcome varies from com-
x adenovirus group plete recovery of the hearing level, if treatment is given early during the course
x mumps of illness, to no improvement whatsoever.15 When a limited vasculitis results in
MRI study labyrinthine ischaemia, a beneficial response to treatment can be predicted. Over
the long term, the organ of Corti can degenerate and fibrosis and osteoneogen-
Box 3 esis can develop within the perilymphatic space; thus, significant improvement
should not be expected with steroid treatment. Subepithelial keratitis usually
responds to local atropine and corticosteroid therapy. Systemic vasculitis
complicates Cogan’s syndrome and should be treated initially with prednisone
Treatment of Cogan’s and, occasionally, cytotoxic agents. Aortic insuYciency can be controlled with
syndrome the administration of prednisone and surgical replacement of the aortic valve.
x eye inflammation: topical atropine and
Our patient’s hearing did not improve. This lack of response may be directly
ocular corticosteroids related to the intensity of the hearing loss, similar to cases of idiopathic sudden
x audiovestibular dysfunction: systemic deafness,16 and correlates with the MRI findings; a good correlation between
corticosteroids labyrinthine enhancement and loss of cochlear and/or vestibular function will
x systemic vasculitis: prednisone with or only be seen in patients with severe loss of function.16–18 Moreover, the decrease
without cytotoxic drugs in naive cytotoxic T cells has been related to a worse prognosis for the recovery
x aortic insuYciency: prednisone and
surgical replacement of the aortic valve
of the hearing loss.4
Although Cogan’s syndrome is the prototype of immune-mediated inner ear
Box 4
disease, the variability of ocular and audiovestibular clinical manifestations
complicates its diagnosis, which should be suspected whenever there is a close
temporal association between ocular abnormalities and cochleovestibular symp-
toms. On the other hand, the application of a study protocol including MRI and
a series of immunological tests might facilitate the establishment of the progno-
sis for the auditory injury, opening new lines of research focusing on the patho-
physiological mechanisms of the disease.
Downloaded from http://pmj.bmj.com/ on March 10, 2015 - Published by group.bmj.com
Box 6
1 Cogan DG. Syndrome of nonsyphilitic intersti- 8 Cogan DG, Sullivan WR. Immunologic study of 14 Peeters GJ, Cremers CW, Pinckers AJ, Hoef-
tial keratitis and vestibuloauditory symptoms. nonsyphilitis interstitial keratitis with vestibulo- nagels WHL. Atypical Cogan’s syndrome: an
Arch Ophthalmol 1945;33:144–9. auditory symptoms. Am J Ophthalmol 1975;80: autoimmune disease? Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol
2 Haynes BF, Kaiser-Kupfer MI, Mason P, Fauci 491–4. 1986;95:173–5.
AS. Cogan syndrome: studies in thirteen 9 Hughes GB, Kinney SE, Barna BP, Tomsak RL, 15 Mc Donald TJ, Vollertsen RS, Younge BR.
patients, long-term follow-up and a review of Calabrese LH. Autoimmune reactivity in Cogan’s syndrome: audiovestibular involvement
the literature. Medicine 1980;59:426–41. Cogan’s syndrome: a preliminary report. Arch and prognosis in 18 patients. Laryngoscope
3 Cheson BD, Bluming AZ, Alroy J. Cogan’s
syndrome: a systemic vasculitis. Am J Med Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1983;91:24–32. 1985;95:650–4.
1976;60:549–55. 10 Schuknecht HF. Ear pathology in autoimmune 16 Byl F. Sudden hearing loss: eight year’s experi-
4 García Berrocal JR, Vargas JA, Ramírez- diseases. Adv Otorhinolaryngol 1991;46:50–70. ence and suggested prognostic table. Laryngo-
Camacho RA, et al. Deficiency of naive T cells 11 Fisher ER, Hellstrom HR. Cogan’s syndrome scope 1984;94:647–61.
in patients with sudden deafness. Arch Otolaryn- and systemic vascular disease. Arch Pathol 1961; 17 Sergent JS, Christian CL. Necrotizing vasculitis
gol Head Neck Surg 1997;123:712–7. 72:96–116. after acute serous otitis media. Ann Intern Med
5 DornhoVer JL, Arenberg JG, Arenberg IK, 12 WolV D, Bernhard WG, Tsutsumi S, Ross IS, 1974;81:195–9.
Shambaugh GE. Pathophysiological mecha- Nussbaum HE. The pathology of Cogan’s 18 Mark AS, Seltzer S, Nelson-Drake J, Chapman
nisms in immune inner ear disease. Acta syndrome causing profound deafness. Ann Otol JC, Fitzgerald DC, Gulya AJ. Labyrinthine
Otolaryngol (Stockh) 1997;256(suppl):30–6. Rhinol Laryngol 1965;74:507–19. enhancement on Gd-MRI in patients with sud-
6 Casselman JW, Major MHJM, Albers FW. MR 13 Schuknecht HF, Nadol JB. Temporal bone den deafness and vertigo: correlation with
of the inner ear in patients with Cogan pathology in a case of Cogan’s syndrome. audiologic and electronystagmographic studies.
syndrome. Am J Neuroradiol 1994;15:131–8. Laryngoscope 1994;104:1135–42. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1992;101:459–64.
7 Brinkman CJ, Broekhuyse RM. Cell-mediated
immunity after retinal detachment as deter-
mined by lymphocyte stimulation. Am J Oph-
thalmol 1978;86:260–5.
Downloaded from http://pmj.bmj.com/ on March 10, 2015 - Published by group.bmj.com
These include:
References This article cites 16 articles, 3 of which you can access for free at:
http://pmj.bmj.com/content/75/883/262#BIBL
Email alerting Receive free email alerts when new articles cite this article. Sign up in the
service box at the top right corner of the online article.
Notes