Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.elsevier.com/locate/foar
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Department of Architectural Engineering and Building Systems, Alzaytoonah University of Jordan, Amman 11733, Jordan
Received 24 June 2012; received in revised form 23 August 2012; accepted 24 August 2012
KEYWORDS Abstract
Geometry; This paper discusses geometric proportions which serve as a design tool, especially for Islamic
Proportions; pattern design. The key role of geometry in Islamic patterns is discussed with relation to
Islamic patterns proportions which act as the underlying structure of the design process. Evaluations based on
spatial structure and esthetic criteria are integrated into the conceptual phase of the design
process. Proportions serve two objectives; firstly, in pattern design, proportions are strongly
linked to geometry, which can be viewed as a self-guiding method of esthetically proven design.
Secondly, geometric proportions regulate primarily the order of patterns; while at the same
time they mediate between the two poles of order and diversity as well as among different
esthetic levels. This paper analyzes geometric principles and design features of traditional
Islamic patterns, involving geometric proportion analysis. It also describes the syntheses of
Islamic patterns from the perspectives of Islamic cosmology, philosophy and metaphysics of
geometry, which can be seen as following a pre-established principle of geometric and
proportional design with high accuracy and great precision. Furthermore, the underlying
relationship between cosmology and geometry is manifested in Islamic patterns where
geometry acts as the vocabulary underpinning the pattern language. These findings support
the argument that geometry was independently discovered and applied by Islamic culture as a
universal language, constituting one of the most important multicultural symbols in design.
& 2012. Higher Education Press Limited Company. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V.
Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
n 1. Introduction
Tel.: +962 796978940.
E-mail addresses: l.dabbour@zuj.edu.jo,
loai_dabbour@hotmail.com. The word geometry refers to the science of properties and
Peer review under responsibility of Southeast University. relations of magnitudes such as points, lines, surfaces, or
solids in space and the way the parts of a particular object
fit together (Concise Oxford English Dictionary, 1999).
Geometry is well known based on two Greek words ‘‘geo’’,
meaning the earth, and ‘‘metry’’, meaning to measure.
2095-2635 & 2012. Higher Education Press Limited Company. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.foar.2012.08.005
Geometric proportions 381
So geometry literally means ‘‘the measurable earth’’ or mathematical ratios and proportions which represent the
‘‘earthly measurements’’. Geometry, according to Plato, very heart of Islam (Critchlow, 1976).
can also refer to the science of stereo-metry or ‘‘spatial Geometry is the blueprint of the Creation and the
measurements’’. The very laws of how things are allowed to generator of all forms. It is a science that deals with
be by the ‘‘Divine will’’ are the laws of ‘‘Harmony of Being’’. numbers in space on four basic levels: the first one is
Tradition holds that, as engraved over the entrance to arithmetic (pure numbers), i.e., any measurement or
Plato’s Academy, ‘‘Only he who is familiar with geometry proportion is a geometrical measurement. The second level
shall be admitted here’’ (Critchlow, 1976). is numbers in space which represent proportional geometry.
Geometry has existed in many buildings and design forms They reflect the meanings and ‘‘Ideas’’. The third level
across centuries. The first confirmed record of geometric is numbers in time, which is the foundation of music. The
knowledge and its relationship to astronomy, human and fourth level is numbers in space and time which represent
music can be traced back to the ancient Greeks, in the cosmology of the universe. Geometry explores and
particular, Pythagoras and Plato. However, prior to the explains the patterns that unify and reveal the structure
Greeks, many old civilizations have left clear geometric of the Creation within all natural patterns of growth
footprints by applying sacred geometry in their construc- or movement and their conformity with geometric shapes.
tions. The prehistoric carved stones found in Scotland All life forms emerge out of timeless geometric codes.
representing the Platonic Solids.1 can be dated back to Viewing and contemplating these codes allow us to under-
over a thousand years earlier than the Greeks.2 The Greeks stand the wisdom of the inner workings of the universe in
may well have been the first to have offered geometry to order to fully comprehend and appreciate its beauty based
the public, but they were, by no means, the first to realize on the concept of proportions. Ikhwan Al-Safa wrote, ‘‘One
it (Critchlow, 1987; Hecht, 1988; Critchlow, 1987). of our aimsy consists of demonstrating clearly that the
Geometric ratios and proportions existed and were whole world is composed in conformity with arithmetical,
employed in the design of ancient sacred and ceremonial geometrical, and musical relations. There, we have
sites in all traditional civilizations. They were invariably built explained in detail the reality of universal harmony’’
with dimensions that incorporate mathematical numbers, (Nasr, 1978).
constants and ratios such as the ‘‘golden/sacred mean’’, Geometric proportions in architectural patterns repre-
and the use of geometries based on proportional roots, sent a design language, as words do in a spoken language.
proportional rectangles and Pythagorean triangle (Pennick, They determine the frameworks within which elements may
1994). For example, Christian cathedrals incorporated sym- be arranged into a pattern, a relation between one element
bolic geometry, while the design of Hindu and Buddha temples and another, and a proportional relation within one ele-
was based on sacred geometry. In Islamic art, geometric ment. They address and reflect the natural laws that govern
elements have been employed since its origin and were used the basic harmonies of nature, being describable by means
to create unique geometric formations, serving as the under- of mathematics and geometry.
lying structure of Islamic design process. Islamic art favors geometry because of its intelligible
Geometry or proportional geometry is a sacred art form aspect. Geometry possesses abstraction and the capacity to
due to its fundamental association with the Creation’s express and reveal objectively immutable and spiritual
principal laws. The visual expression of the order of these truths. Geometry involves proportions and prime roots that
laws is best represented through the discipline of geometry. are considered the most beautiful proportions (the propor-
Geometry is both quantitative and qualitative in nature. Its tions of beauty). As such, beauty, for the Muslim artists, is
quantitative dimension regulates the order and construction objective and self-expression of truths, which is the essen-
of design forms. Its qualitative nature sets the proportions tial nature of beauty as Plato stated, ‘‘Beauty is the
of design forms and represents an expression of the order of splendor of the truth’’ (Burckhardt, 1987).
the universe as a visual representation of the truth. Each The language of Islamic design springs primarily from the
figure or geometric shape, when seen from the perspective abstract. Therefore, geometry in general and geometrical
of its symbolic meaning, represents an echo of unity and a proportion in particular carry great importance in the design
reflection of the values and principles within the larger process of Islamic art, presented in its primary elements,
frame beyond that unity (universal unity) (Ardalan and geometry, biomorphic forms, and calligraphy, which are all
Bakhtiar, 2000). Seyyid Hossein Nasr argued that geometry based on and ruled by the underlying geometric laws
and rhythm manifest a doctrine of unity which is central to (proportions). It follows that the Islamic design principles
Islam, upon which Islamic art developed based on are reflected in geometry. In other words, geometry plays a
central role in Islamic design.
This paper examines Islamic pattern design, which can be
1
The ‘‘Platonic solids’’ are the names given to the five three- viewed as a key method of expressing Islamic cosmological
dimensional solids—tetrahedron , hexahedron, octahedron, dode- esthetics. In addition to representing cosmological and
cahedron, and icosahedrons—(perfect shapes) formed when divid- philosophical structures at the level of form, geometric
ing a sphere based on the exact shape and angle. For the Greeks,
patterns can also be seen as efficient and powerful repre-
these five solids were the core patterns of physical creation. They
were seen as the archetypal patterns behind the four elements
sentations of some of the central concepts that characterize
(earth, air, fire, and water), while the fifth was held to be the Islamic debates on the divine nature. Islamic pattern was
pattern behind the life force itself, the ether. developed as visual tools for contemplating the underlying
2
Small carved stones found in Scotland conform to the five mathematical nature of the universe, leading to the nature
Platonic solids, which suggest an association with this mathematical of beauty, by virtue of God’s creation of the universe (the
principle. nature of the divine itself).
382 L.M. Dabbour
Figure 2 The proportional roots: (a) the O2 proportion, (b) the O3 proportion, and (c) the golden mean (Phi) proportion.
Square √2 √3 √4
√2 √3 √4 √5
3.1. Man
Figure 6 Spirals, the mathematical products of ‘‘Fibonacci sequence’’ and the sacred mean.
Figure 7 Vitruvian man, with proportions based on the sacred mean (Critchlow, 1976).
the Venus rotates around it eight times. The connection Venus’ orbit from the Earth’s orbit. It can be seen from the
between 5 and 8, both of which are Fibonacci numbers, is agreement between eightfold and fivefold geometries that
the golden mean proportion (8/5=1.6). The result of this eight touching circles are drawn from the Venus’ mean
motion is that the Venus ‘‘draws’’ a pentagon around the orbit. In turn, the circumference circle is enclosing these
sun every eight years (Skinner, 2009; Figure 9A). eight circles, defining the Earth’s mean orbit (Martineau,
Figure 9B shows that a circle is drawn, which represents 2001; Figure 9C).
the Venus’ mean orbit. A pentagon is constructed inside it The conclusion from these diagrams shows that, mathema-
and a small circle placed through the arm-crossing points. tically speaking, the ratio of the mean orbits of the Venus’s to
The radius of this small circle divides the radius of the large the Earth is O2 proportion. The geometric representation of
one into golden sections and can be used to space the these orbits creates the golden mean proportion.
386 L.M. Dabbour
The same proportions can be observed between the Earth causes and the reality of the nature, the principles govern-
and the Mercury. Two circles defined by the arm-crossing ing existence, the material universe, and the perception of
points of the pentagon are both the Earth’s and the physical phenomena, as well as to analyze human behaviors.
Mercury’s mean orbit. Their sizes are their relative physical God speaks through these forms. Virgin nature was the
bodies (Martineau, 2001; Figure 10). first book, which made the Truth visible. ‘‘From the bosom
Sacred geometry describes the assertions of a mathematical of nature, man seeks to transcend nature and nature herself
order of the intrinsic nature of the universe. Scientists see the can be an aid in this process, provided man can learn to
same geometric and mathematical patterns as contemplate her, not as an independent domain of reality
arising directly from natural principles. ‘‘Traditional art has but as a mirror reflecting a higher reality, a vast panorama
rules that apply to cosmic laws and universal principles’’. of symbols which speaks to man and has meaning for him’’.
(Schuon, 1984) (Nasr, 1997)
These and other similarities are seen in sacred geometry Geometry is the very basis of our reality. Therefore, we
to serve as the further proof of the cosmic significance of live in a coherent world governed by underlying laws. They
geometric forms. Islamic architecture is created based on are always manifested in our world. The golden mean and
the essential harmonies of nature together with various proportional roots govern the proportion of our world,
symbolic meanings and theories of perfect proportions. The which can be found in the proportions of all living and
designers based their geometrical vocabulary on what they nonliving forms.
have seen in the nature around them, in an attempt to
develop a codified series of proportions which may improve
our psychological comfort with buildings (Skinner, 2009). 4. Geometric proportions as a tool of design:
It has been proposed that the understanding of sacred study model
geometry was extended into time and space. We may never
know for sure whether such geometry was identified first Geometric proportions are used by Muslim designers as the
from the observation of natural formations, or alternatively, most valuable tool of design process to produce ordered
it came as a result of an intellectual quest. However, patterns that govern esthetic beauty in designed spaces,
whichever it would be, it is clear that these mathematical surfaces and objects. They present us the ‘‘Principles of
codes derived from nature began to be applied in the design Nature’’ in their own language. By applying the golden mean
of many important man-made structures. (Phi) and the root proportions, geometric patterns are
Geometry constitutes a graphic description of the uni- produced to be applied to the fields of building crafts, such
verse. Geometric analysis is an attempt to understand the as tiles, mosaic, plaster and wood, as well as to the field of
book art.
By diminishing the polygon contained in the circle of
Unity toward the center until the stars, which control the
shape of the pattern, appear, the Muslim artists preserve
the esthetics of these proportions and grant them exquisite
beauty at a higher level than direct, material expression.
The system of geometric design starts from the circle (the
basic unit), from which the pattern starts to unfold,
creating harmonious divisions of the circle in four stages:
Figure 10 Proportions of the Mercury’s and the Earth’s mean orbits are based on the sacred mean (Martineau, 2001).
Geometric proportions 387
of points that can be used in the development of patterns. space, is a symbol of the divine throne and its application
This type of framework forms the driving geometry for within architecture is reflected in a Moroccan ceramic (Zilij)
the relatively simple Islamic patterns with which we are panel and in the harmonic diminishing of the eight-fold star
familiar. in the Alhambra Palace, The Hall of The Abencerrajes, and
4) Desired pattern revealing: establishing the geometric the Hall of the Two Sisters (Figure 13).
variations of the pattern and defining its boarder lines.
It is derived from all the vital proportion systems based
on a single unit. The process can be repeated indefi- 4.2. Fivefold to tenfold pattern
nitely, presenting the same center everywhere and
nowhere. It is ratio, rather than measurement, that This part of geometric study shows a construction of the
determines the relative lengths of crucial dimensions. geometric panel based on proportional geometry. Its
esthetic advantage is related to the golden section, showing
one of the many ways to apply the geometry to form
The infinitely repeating geometrical patterns and the different patterns using a variety of materials.
rules of geometric construction are a reflection of the Figures 14 and 15 show the construction systems of a five-to-
unchanging laws of God. They are based on esthetic tenfold pattern which appears on the body of Salah Al-Din
proportions as seen in the rhythm of the Creation and can wooden Minbar (Pulpit) at Al-Aqsa mosque (Jerusalem), on a
be presented according to the design process in the follow- wooden door from Mumluk period (Cairo) and on a frontispiece
ing study models. at a Mamluk Quran. Ten pointed geometry lends itself to a wide
variety of design possibilities through relatively small variations
in the underlying relationships and to the creation of different
4.1. Fourfold to eightfold pattern patterns at different scales as a unified design.
Figure 13 Applications of the octagon based on eight pointed patterns in architecture ‘‘And the angels will be on its sides, and
eight will, that Day, bear the throne of thy Lord above them’’ (The Holy Quran, Chapter 69, verse 17).
employing the technique of cutting the tiles in such a way as to Figure 17 shows how a relatively simple pattern based on six-
imply the interweaving of the running lines. pointed geometry might be developed into so many potential
The pattern is both logical and rhythmical, i.e., both choices for the designer, which accounts for the great number
mathematical and melodious, which is the most significant of design variations that are possible.
characteristics of the spirit of Islam, showing its balancing—‘‘u- It is surprising that how many variations can be made
nity in multiplicity’’ or ‘‘multiplicity in unity’’ within a series of from a simple geometric shape. Figure 18 illustrates
regular geometrical figures contained within a circle, or a series a pattern based on a study using six-fold geometry. The
of regular polyhedral contained within a sphere (Burkhardt, first diagram illustrates the basic construction, beginning
1986; Burckhardt, 1987). with the development from a circle. The second one shows
Geometric proportions 389
the six pointed divisions. It is these selections shown in the The Ikhwan Al-Safa (the Brothers of Purity) stressed the
third diagram that create the possibility for different important symbolism of number six, regarding number 6 as
patterns to evolve. The fourth is the result of this drawing a perfect number. The number 6 consists of 1 2 3; at the
and selecting process. same time also 1+2+3. Any number with this quality is
390 L.M. Dabbour
Figure 17 Potential variations of 6–12 pointed patterns based on the same structure as in Figure 16 based on O3 proportions.
considered a perfect number. Also, it was on the sixth day Figure 19 shows the applications of 6–12 pointed patterns
of the Creation that God created man. There are six directions based on O3 proportions in a wooden panel and a paper
of space as well. The six-sided hexagon is therefore a symbol of based geometric stars (medallion).
the universal man (Ardalan and Bakhtiar, 2000). These studies illustrate only a small number of numerous
Figure 18 shows the significant study on tile patterns and possibilities out of the variations of proportional patterns
their underlying geometry, particularly the visual strength based on simple polygon geometries. The ways of altering
of the geometric structure in the application of these the relationship between the elements of these geometries
patterns. The construction of such natural geometries forms appear to be relatively simple. However, every decision
the basis upon which artisans on building sites set out their results in diversified complex patterns that are quite diff-
designs and work. erent from each other.
Geometric proportions 391
Islamic patterns, by their very nature, do not have any Burckhardt, Titus, 1987. Mirror of the Intellect. State University of
direction underlain in their geometry. Rather, they tend to New York Press, New York, USA, p. 219,227.
be formed in fields with no apparent ending. The framing of Burkhardt, Titus, 1986. Sacred Art in East and West: Its Principles
patterns tends to be controlled by proportion systems. In and Methods. Perennial Books, Indiana, USA, p. 101.
other words, it is an objectively intellectual qualitative Concise Oxford English Dictionary, 1999. Oxford University Press
geometry, reflecting Truth in space. Ibn Khaldun states: Inc., USA.
Critchlow, Keith, 1976. Islamic Patterns: An Analytical and Cosmo-
‘‘Geometry enlightens the intellect and sets one’s mind
logical Approach. Schocken Books, Thames and Hudson, London,
right. All its proofs are very clear and orderly. It is hardly UK, p. 4,9.
possible for errors to enter into geometric reasoning, Critchlow, Keith, 1987. Order in Space: A Design Source Book.
because it is well arranged and orderly. Thus the mind that Thames and Hudson, USA, p. 9.
constantly applies itself to geometry is unlikely to fall into El-Said, Isasam, 2001. Islamic Art and Architecture: The Systems of
error’’. (Ibn Khaldun, 1958) Geometric Design. Garnet Publishing Ltd., UK, p. 15.
Guenon, Rene, 1995. The Reign of Quantity and the Sign of the
Times. Sophia Perennis, Ghent, p. 8,170.
5. Conclusion Guenon, Rene, 1994. The Great Triad. South Asia Books, New York,
USA, p. 23.
We can conclude that proportion is a characteristic of (tradi- Hambidge, Jay, 1920. The Elements of Dynamic Symmetry. Yale
tional) Islamic patterns, serving as a tool of self-guiding process University Press, NewHaven, USA, p. 23.
for esthetically proven design. Muslim builders knew of the Hecht, Laurence, 1988. Mysterium microcosmicum: the geometric
autonomy or ‘‘inner laws’’ in constructing spaces and patterns. basis for the periodicity of the elements. 21st Century Science,
The relations among various parts can be seen everywhere in 18.
ancient buildings. In other words, buildings were designed with Ibn, Khaldun, 1958. The Muqaddimah Franz Rosenthal. Pantheon
Books, New York, USA 378.
particular care, exhibiting mastery in pattern design of their
Lawlor, Robert, 1989. Sacred Geometry: Philosophy and Practice.
spaces and surfaces.
Thames and Hudson, New York, p. 3,48,82,92.
Geometric proportions regulate the order of patterns based Lings, Martin, 1976. The Quranic Art of Calligraphy and Illumina-
on mathematical ratios, which is influential in understanding tion. Tajir Trust, London, p. 13.
the universe, man and nature; these proportions are, by their Martineau, John, 2001. A Little Book of Coincidence. Walker and
nature, the essential ingredients in sacred geometry, as Company, New York, U.S.A, p. 15,21.
Pythagoreans stated that these harmonic ratios render music Nasr, Sayyed Hussein, 1978. An Introduction to Islamic Cosmological
in a balanced pattern. Doctrines. Thames and Hudson, UK, p. 45.
Geometric proportion is strongly linked to Islamic cosmology, Nasr, Seyyid Hossein, 1997. Man and Nature. ABC International
philosophy and metaphysical dimensions. It brings meanings and Group, Chicago, USA, p. 95.
Pennick, Nigel, 1994. Sacred Geometry—Symbolism and Purpose in
spiritual exercises for the viewer, deconstructing the meanings
Religious Structures. Capall Bann Publishing, San Francisco, USA,
underpinning the geometric framework. As such, the viewer is
p. 67.
more than an observer; he or she is a participant in the Rawles, Bruce, 1997. Sacred Geometry Design Sourcebook. Elysian
establishment of a strong link with geometry symbolizing man, Publishing, Eagle Point, Oregon, p. 87.
nature and cosmos. Schneider, Michael, 1994. A Beginner’s Guide to Constructing the
The geometry as well as its rhythm shown in Islamic patterns Universe: The Mathematical Archetypes of Nature, Art and
illustrates an infinite variety, permitting and encouraging Science. Harper Collins, New York, p. 10.
contemplative reflections. It is one of the most powerful forms Schuon, Frithjof, 2003. Survey of Metaphysics and Esoterism. World
of sacred art It is a source of contemplation that allows our Wisdom, Indiana, USA, p. 48.
minds to wander and contemplate the infinite. These patterns Schuon, Frithjof, 1984. The Transcendent Unity of Religions. Quest
Books, USA, p. 62.
were developed with strict geometric rules, relating to the
Singer, Lynette, 2008. The Minbar of Saladin: Reconstructing a
understanding of natural forms based on geometric ratios in the
Jewel of Islamic Art. Thames and Hudson, London, UK, p. 110.
cosmos, set as the prime mover behind design. Skinner, Stephen, 2009. Sacred Geometry: Deciphering the Code.
Sterling, New York, p. 7,91,107.
References The Holy Quran. Chapter 95, verse 4 (95:4).
Ardalan, Nader, Bakhtiar, Laleh, 2000. The Sense of Unity: The Sufi
Tradition in Persian Architecture. Kazi Publications, p. 21.