Paper ID: E024

Paper Title: Dynamic Power Injection for Solar PV Constant Power Generation
The review of your manuscript, submitted to 2019 International Conference on Design,
Mechanical and Electrical Engineering (DMEE 2019) in Bali, Indonesia, Sep. 7-9, 2019, has
been completed. The reviews recommend the need for minor revisions. Please revise your
manuscript according the reviewers’ comments attached below, and submit your revised version of
the manuscript as your final paper.
For your guidance, reviewer’ comments are appended below:

Recommendation to Editors

Strongly Marginally Strong

Reject Accept
Reject Accept Accept

Recommendation X
Comments

The paper writing needs to be improved before acceptance. I have the following comments:
1. Sentence formation and grammar needs to be corrected. Therefore, thorough proof read is
required.
2. Full form of DPI = Dynamic Power Injection. This information need to be provided in the
paper.
3. The authors should mention what is P&O algorithm.
4. PMPPT>Plimit should be written as PMPPT>Plimit.
5. Technical contribution should be clearly highlighted compared to the work done in
literature, as currently it seems like a test implementation of the algorithm already
proposed in the literature.
6. The figures are not clear, nor is the order in which they are numbered.
7. Some figures are not referred in text. I will suggest to refer to figure number always
instead of writing figure above or figure below.
8. The equations should be provided equation number.
9. Some words are written in Bahasa. Kindly change them to English.
10. It is mentioned that ramp rate is important. However, how and why it is important is not
mentioned. It plays a vital role as how fast the battery and PV can support each other.
Therefore, for the designed system its importance should be provided.
11. The authors should discuss about delay in communication and error in results due to
different ramp rates.

Once again, thank you for your interest in DMEE 2019.

Yours Sincerely,
Editor
DMEE 2019