Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lally Black Thornock y Hawkins 1979
Lally Black Thornock y Hawkins 1979
occupant (SRO) hotels were studied using both observational and interviewing methods. The study
reveals a population of elderly women with work histories in trades traditionally dominated by men, with
a life-style based on mobility, extreme individualism, and independence. Residence in SROs appears to be
part of a natural life history progression for these women rather than a result of social pathology.
The study discusses implications of these findings for interpreting current social service utilization
patterns of SRO women and for planning service delivery to this population.
In recent years a number of social programs vestigators have suggested that SRO elderly
have been mounted on behalf of the aged, yet women may represent a distinct subgroup, psy-
subpopulations of older adults can be found chologically and socially distinct from their
whose needs are little understood and whose male counterparts, and worthy of greater re-
access to delivery systems remains minimal. search attention (Stephens, 1976).
One such group is older women who live in Available information on SRO elderly women
downtown hotels in urban communities. is somewhat contradictory. Stephens (1976)
Historically, studies of low-income urban studied residents of one SRO hotel and found
residents who live downtown have focused on subjects of both sexes to have a high need for
skid road residents (Bahr, 1970). Until recently, privacy and independence, to relate in a super-
the impression lingered that low-income people ficial and utilitarian way with others and to iso-
who reside in urban centers are downwardly late themselves from, and be resistant to, close
mobile, often emotionally disturbed and "dis- social contacts. Stephens interpreted the avoid-
affiliated" (Bahr, 1976; Stephens, 1976). Re- ance of ties as a primary coping skill in an en-
cently, investigators have begun to recognize vironment with high potential for deviance.
that a number of elderly people who reside In contrast to Stephens, Shapiro's study of nine
downtown must be distinguished from what is SRO hotels (1971) found that black SRO elderly
primarily a younger "skid road" population. women were leaders in an interdependent social
Several studies have investigated the charac- environment, forming the matriarchal center
teristics of some of these older people, known of intricate mutual aid networks with more de-
as SRO (single room occupancy) hotel elderly pendent, often alcoholic males. Bahr's (1970)
(Ehrlich, 1971; Erickson & Eckert, 1977; Sha- study of "disaffiMated" women living downtown
piro, 1976; Stephens, 1976). suggested two distinct subgroups: (1) women
Research indicates that older men are found reduced to the life-style because of old age,
in greater numbers in SRO environments than illness, or poverty; (2) women whose whole
older women, and studies of SRO elderly have life has been characterized by interpersonal
generally based conclusions on predominately failures — broken marriages, alcoholism,
male populations (Ehrlich, 1976; Erickson & and the like. In spite of these differences, re-
Eckert, 1977; Stephens, 1976). Recently in- searchers have agreed that SRO elderly of both
sexes are generally suspicious of social service
agencies and underutilize the services for
'An earlier version of this paper was presented at the 30th Annual Scientific
Meeting of the Cerontological Soc., San Francisco, Nov. 1977. which they are eligible.
'School of Social Work, Univ. of Washington, Seattle 9 8 1 0 5 .
3
lnst. on Aging, Univ. of Washington, Seattle 981 OS.
The present study was undertaken to further
4
Ctr. for Social Welfare Research, School of Social Work and Ctr. for Law assess the characteristics and needs of SRO
& Justice, Univ. of Washington, 1417 N.E. 42nd St., Seattle 98105. Address
correspondence and requests for reprints to J. David Hawkins. elderly women in urban communities in light
68 The Gerontologist
me;" "not demonstrative." Fathers were was 10.5 years for the group studied (1977).
consistently portrayed more positively: "my The Seattle women reported a significantly
father was the best provider a man could be;" higher educational level than the national aver-
"I took after my father more than my mother." age. Ten of the sixteen (62%) had completed
A close identification and strong affect for high school, seven reported some college edu-
fathers has not been previously documented cation, and two had completed college and had
for SRO women; neither has the antipathy teaching careers.
towards mothers. Childhood experiences may
have had a strong influence in the personality History of Downtown Living
development of these women and should be Five (31%) of the women had lived in down-
further explored. It is possible that some of the town hotels all their adult lives. Eleven (69%)
traits of SRO residents reported in the literature moved downtown after a major life change in-
and discussed later in this study, such as strong cluding widowhood, divorce, or retirement.
verbalized norms of independence, can be Hotel hopping was common. Generally, the
traced back to early family relationships and women portrayed their residence in SRO hotels
socialization experiences. as a purposeful choice made for the inherent
Another important, and perhaps related, find- advantages rather than as a last resort. While a
ing is the work experience of the women. Four- few spoke of how their lives would be different
teen (87%) of the Seattle women had been in if they could afford to live elsewhere, they were
paid employment most of their adult lives, hold- quick to describe the merits of their current
ing a variety of jobs over the years. Interest- situations. Seven (43%) of the women said they
ingly, Vi of the subjects had spent a consider- chose to live in downtown hotels because of
able portion of their work careers in traditional ly convenience factors including proximity to
male dominated occupations including work department stores, and availability of maid
as longshoremen, truck drivers and electricians. service. Four also noted an economic advan-
Two had been school teachers. tage of lower rent than for a comparable size
Erickson and Eckert (1977) found nearly Vfc of apartment. The women also mentioned factors
the middle-class hotel dwellers in San Diego such as privacy and independence afforded by
had held clerical jobs, while the skid road and hotel living, as well as the security provided
working-class groups had more mobile and by hotel staff.
unstable work histories. Stephens (1976) found When asked what they thought about down-
the Detroit population to have had episodic town living and residence in a hotel, the Seattle
and marginal work situations with very few women volunteered twice as many positive
having "formal" careers. In the Seattle sample, comments as negative comments. There was
five of the women had been members of unions no consistency in descriptions of what the
whose membership was largely male. These women did not like about living in a hotel.
women ventured into occupational areas Individuals expressed concerns about rents
where women were rarely found long before being too high, noise caused by other tenants,
the current concern with sex-role stereotyping. dishonest or unfriendly management, presence
It is interesting to speculate whether their of racial minorities in the area, and drunk/de-
fathers' influence affected their career choices, viant behavior. Only three mentioned fear of
especially in light of Hennig and Jardim's crime or violence. The low reporting of unde-
(1977) study of 25 women managers which em- sirable environmental aspects of SRO living
phasized the influence of father on choice of contrasts with results of prior SRO studies. In
occupation. An alternative hypothesis worthy hotels studied by Erickson and Eckert (1977),
of further investigation is that these Seattle Shipiro (1971), and Stephens (1976), environ-
women entered male-dominated trades during mental factors such as crime, threat of fires,
World War II while men were off fighting and and physical violence, were frequently identi-
continued in these fields after the war.
fied as stressful by SRO residents. One possible
National demographic data on the edu- interpretation of this failure to volunteer greater
cational level of the population 65 and over concern about environmental factors is that
indicates that 50% have not completed eight not identifying such concerns is a way of coping
years of elementary education and 8% have with tenuous downtown conditions. However,
graduated from college. In Erickson and Eckert's the fact that Seattle women did volunteer con-
San Diego population, the average education cerns about other issues such as money suggests
70 The Gerontologist
Both Shapiro (1971) and Stephens (1976) of the normative system shared by all these
characterized SRO populations as socially women. It is a fundamental building block of
deviant. Erickson and Eckert (1977) found that their self-concepts.
nearly Vi of the SRO population they studied Accompanying this belief system is an ob-
had been in jail, and also found a high per- jective life-style. Perhaps the most important
centage of ex-mental patients in the study popu- characteristic of this life-style is the restrictive
lation. The sample of Seattle women studied nature of the social networks of these women.
did not display the extent of social deviance The social contacts of most of these women are
described in other studies. As noted above, limited primarily to interactions with hotel staff
three had experienced hospitalization for mental and proprietors of the downtown businesses
disorders. However, none manifested indica- the women frequent. MacElveen (1974) has
tions of other deviance, such as heavy drinking characterized "restricted" networks: "iso-
or criminal activities. lated persons who are strongly bonded with
no one or only a few people who are sometimes
fairly isolated also." She has noted that, like
Hotel Employees
these SRO women, individuals with restricted
Interestingly, hotel employees were extremely networks characteristical ly value independence,
knowledgeable about individual social and believing that they are responsible for solving
personal traits of these older women. They their own problems. Such individuals typically
were generally sympathetic to the needs of give and receive little support and help from
older tenants, especially to more frail women, others.
and were frequently involved in providing extra
attention or special favors for them including According to social network theorists, an
rent reductions, delivering meals to rooms, and important characteristic of restrictive networks
the like. Discussion with the hotel managers is that they are easily exhausted by prolonged
revealed a shared perceived dilemma regard- or multiple crises because they do not provide
ing the conflict between trying to cover inflating a "cushion" of potential support which a more
costs by raising rents and the impact such rent extensive social network can provide. Startling
increases would have on these elderly women. evidence has been uncovered by Berkman
(1977) of the impact of social network on mor-
tality and morbidity. In a study of mortality
Discussion and Implications of 7,000 adult residents of Alameda County,
Seattle SRO women are a population of con- California, over a 10-year period, she found
trasts. They express concern over their eco- that people with fewest social contacts had the
nomic situations and at the same time voice highest mortality rates form all causes. The
optimism about the future. They are better extent of social contacts predicted mortality
educated than average for their age cohort, but rates independent of self-reported health, socio-
live in near poverty in low-income neighbor- economic status, life satisfaction, or preventa-
hoods. Almost all are currently experiencing tive health behavior. Apparently a restricted
serious health problems, yet they assert their network increases vulnerability to both disease
independence and desire to be on their own. and mortality. The high prevalence of health
They boast of solitary independent lives, yet problems among Seattle SRO women may be
a few admit loneliness. They claim to have directly related to their social isolation.
chosen SRO residence, but admit that their The strong value placed on independence,
hotels and neighborhoods are populated by privacy, and autonomy exhibited by the Seattle
types with whom they prefer not to associate. women, coupled with their apparently limited
Through all these contrasts one theme repeats: social networks, suggests they may be both
the claim of self-sufficiency and independence. more statistically susceptible to illness and
These assertions of independence and self- more vulnerable to the physical and emotional
sufficiency can be understood as an ideology consequences of illness and other stresses
or belief system which allows these women to than older individuals rooted in more extensive
continue to perceive themselves as purposeful, interpersonal networks. Recalling that 14(87%)
choice-making individuals in control of their of the sample had one or more serious medical
own destinies. Whether or not this self-percep- conditions at the time of the study, we begin
tion is "objectively" accurate, it is essential to wonder how long many of these women will
that we recognize that it is a central element be able to retain their life downtown if their
72 The Gerontologist
(money, community gratitude or acknowledge- cises. Finally, we would suggest that instead
ment, etc.) will need to be offered to potential of extensive traditional needs-assessment sur-
helpers, and it will be important to determine veys used to plan for this population, research
what services are realistic to expect from these on this population be carried out in a low-keyed,
people. nondirective, and nonthreatening manner,
One obvious possibility would be for social informally in hotels or restaurants and other
service agencies to provide information and frequented settings in order to allow subjects
education to hotel management and staff re- the greatest latitude to define who they are
garding the services available for older women and what needs they face in their environment.
living in their hotels. Hotel managers and staff We hope this paper will do more than draw
already supportive of SRO residents and trusted attention to the necessity for more research
by them could function to some extent as out- about this unique and little-known population.
reach workers for social services, suggesting We hope it will encourage those involved in
appropriate services to tenants for which they planning and service delivery to inner-city
were eligible. It might be possible, with ap- residents to consider the culture of independent
propriate resources and training, to involve SRO women and to develop service approaches
some hotel personnel as direct conduits for which complement rather than depreciate
services and financial assistance. Serving as their chosen life-styles and self-concepts.
gatekeepers for services to the population could
be advantageous both to hotel personnel and
their tenants. Obtaining adequate resources References
for tenants could help ensure that rent bills Bahr, H. M. Disaffiliated man: Essays and bibliography
would be paid, that hotel residents would en- on skid row, vagrancy and outsiders. Univ. Toronto
counter fewer disruptive health emergencies Press, Toronto, 1970.
Bahr, H. M., & Garrett, G. R. Women alone. Heath &
and that chronic health needs would be met Co., Washington, 1976.
with adequate services. Ultimately this ap- Berkman, L. F. Social networks, host resistance and mor-
proach might enable the elderly women to tality: A follow-up study of Alameda County residents.
stay in the hotels rather than facing the prospects School of Public Health, Dept. of Epidemiology, Univ.
of rapid deterioration and the dreaded move to California, (dissertation), Berkeley, 1977.
Collins, A., & Pancoast, D. Natural helping networks: A
a nursing home. strategy for prevention. NASW Publ., Washington,
There are other approaches which would not 1976.
necessarily change the restricted network style Dumont, M. Tavern culture: The sustenance of homeless
of these women but enhance the coping skills men, American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 1967, 37,
938-945.
and style in which they wish to live. For ex- Ehrlich, P. A study: Characteristics and needs of the St. Louis
ample, instead of moving SRO women into downtown SRO elderly, In The Invisible Elderly. The Na-
high-rise senior communities, the possibility tional Council on the Aging, Inc., St. Louis, May 1976.
of providing rent subsidies to help maintain Ehrlich, P. Housing Committee Report, unpubl. paper, 1976.
Erickson, R., & Eckert, K. The elderly poor in downtown San
their current autonomy within their environ- Diego hotels, Gerontologist, 1977, 17, Part I, 440-446.
ment could be explored. A program of direct Feldman, F. L. Reaching rural Alaskan Natives through
cash payments or food vouchers usable in human service aides, Welfare in Review, 1971, 9,
neighborhood restaurants could also be es- 9-14.
tablished in addition to the usual low-cost meals Hennig, M., & Jardim, A. The managerial woman. Anchor
Press, New York, 1977.
at senior citizen centers which this population MacElveen, P. M. Social networks, in Clinical Practice in
rarely attends. Rather than insisting on group Psychosocial Nursing. Appleton-Century Co., New
involvement with this population, one-to-one York, 1974.
instruction in individual techniques of coping Shapiro, J. Communications of the alone, working with
and stress reduction could be offered. Examples single room occupants in the city. Association Press,
New York, 1971.
could include various conventional relaxation Stephens, J. Loners, lovers and losers: Elderly tenants in
techniques, biofeedback, or meditation exer- a slum hotel. Univ. Washington Press, Seattle, 1976.