Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/259321633
CITATIONS READS
19 2,234
6 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
IUT20-58 Physical performance and health: adaptational and age-related aspects View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Matthew Wyon on 23 January 2015.
This study compared anthropometric variables, somatotypes, For optimal performance, dancers must be experts in
and aerobic capacity between three groups of dancers: classical the aesthetic and technical sides of their art, psychologi-
ballet dancers (M 33, F 56), contemporary dancers (M 28, F cally prepared to handle the stress of critical situations,
109), and dancesport dancers (M 30, F 30). The assumption
was that different functional requirements should produce dif- and free from injury. They must also be physically fit.24 It
ferences in the anthropometric and aerobic capacity variables has been suggested that functional adaptation due to dif-
among the three groups. Anthropometric data for body mass ferent training regimens may be responsible for the deter-
index (BMI) and somatotypes were measured. Body fat per- mination of some anthropometric15 and physiological32
centage was measured by dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry. changes. The number of hours per day and the days per
Maximal oxygen consumption and aerobic power were meas-
ured during an incremental treadmill test until exhaustion. week that a specific physical activity is performed may
Dancesport athletes were taller compared with same gender result in systematic changes in body composition.4 Hamil-
contemporary dancers (p<0.05). Female ballet dancers had a ton,19 on the other hand, has said that “it is unclear
lower body mass and BMI compared with their contemporary whether ballet selects the perfect body, creates it, or both.”
dance and dancesport equivalents (p<0.001). There was signif- To our best of knowledge, there is no study done that
icant difference between dance styles in endomorphy (F2,221 =
8.773, p<0.001) and mesomorphy (F2,221 = 21.458, p<0.001) has compared anthropometric variables, somatotypes, and
scores. Dancesport dancers had significantly greater VO2max aerobic capacity between classical ballet dancers, contem-
values (p<0.01). It was concluded that female contemporary porary dancers, and dancesport athletes. Dancesport is
dancers are generally more muscular than their ballet counter- defined as partner dancing between a man and woman
parts, while dancesport dancers are taller and heavier, less combining as a couple. It has developed from ballroom
muscular, with slightly greater adioposity compared to the clas-
sical ballet dancers. Ballet dancers had the lowest body fat per- dances performed by couples. Currently recognized disci-
centage, weight, and BMI values. Dancesport dancers had plines in international style dancesport are standard
greater aerobic capacity than the ballet dancers. Based on this dances, Latin American dances, and “ten dance” disci-
study, we conclude that dancers in these three styles differ in plines. Contemporary dance emerged at the beginning of
some aspects of anthropometric variables, somatotypes, and the 20th century as a breakaway from the rigid constraints
aerobic capacity, but we cannot say is it because of the training
or selection or both. Med Probl Perform Art 2013; 28(4):207–211. of classical ballet, which itself started as a performance art
in the French courts in the 16th and 17th century.2
A previous study has found no difference in VO2max
D ancers face the difficult task of combining the aes-
thetic and physical components of their perform-
ance. They have been referred as “performing”23 and or
between ballet, contemporary, jazz, and character dance
students.13 Based on previous research2,25 that reported
“aesthetic”35 athletes who remain subject to the same VO2max values, we can assume that dancesport athletes
unyielding physical laws as in other athletes.2 Dance train- have higher aerobic capacity than ballet and contemporary
ing is a long process of physical, intellectual, and psycho- dancers. However, successful ballet dancers were taller and
logical preparation through physical exercise, often begin- thinner than modern dancers, although these differences
ning in childhood and continuing until retirement.1 were not significant.16 The majority of previous studies
have focused on dancers in one specific dance style, such as
ballet, contemporary, or dancesport. It has been suggested
that ballet, contemporary, and dancesport dancers per-
From the 1Faculty of Exercise and Sport Sciences, University of Tartu,
Tartu, Estonia, and 2Research Centre for Sport Exercise and Perform- formance would benefit from a good aerobic capacity,1,22,25
ance, University of Wolverhampton, Walsall, UK; and 3National Insti- and that performance of ballet and contemporary dancers
tute of Dance Medicine and Science, UK. benefits from physiological capabilities such as muscular
strength and power.7,22 Little published data exist on
Supported by the Estonian Ministry of Education and Science target
dancers’ somatotypes,16 but anthropometrical parameters
financed grant 0489; by the Doctoral School of Behavioral, Social and
Health Sciences created under the auspices of European Social Fund; and such as height and weight are well studied.2,6,12,25,28 It has
by Estonian Science Foundation (ESF) DoRa 6 and DoRa 8 program. been found that body composition is influencing dance
performance.2 Many authors have been concerned about
Address correspondence to: Dr. Helena Liiv, Faculty of Exercise and the low body fat percentage of female ballet dancers,20,31 as
Sport Sciences, University of Tartu, Jakobi 5, Tartu 51014, Estonia. Tel
it can increase the risk of injury and delay healing.30
+372 5291059, +372 737 5372, fax +372 737 5373. liivhelena@gmail.com.
Just as the term sport covers a wide variety of different
© 2013 Science & Medicine. www.sciandmed.com/mppa. disciplines, dance is an umbrella term that includes diverse
Anthropometry, Body Mass Index, Percent Body Anthropometrical characteristics of the subjects are pre-
Fat, and Somatotypes sented in Table 1. There were significant differences
between dance styles in height (f2,280 = 9.677, p<0.001), body
Body height (Martin metal anthropometer, GPM SilberHeg- mass (f2,280 = 11.912, p<0.001), and BMI (f2,280 = 18.822,
ner, Zürich, Switz.) and body mass (A&D Instruments, p<0.001) values. Post hoc tests indicated that male and
Abingdon, UK) of the participants were measured to the female dancesport dancers were taller compared to same
nearest 0.1 cm and 0.05 kg, respectively. The body mass gender contemporary dance participants (p<0.05). Female
index (BMI) was calculated as weight/height2. Body compo- contemporary dance and dancesport dancers had higher
body mass and BMI values compared with female ballet ballet dancers had higher mesomorphy scores compared
dancers (p<0.001). Female contemporary dancers had to female dancesport participants. Male (p<0.05) and
higher BMI values than female dancesport dancers female (p<0.001) contemporary dancers had higher meso-
(p<0.05). There was a significant difference in age (p<0.05), morphy values than same-gender dancesport dancers.
height, body mass, and BMI (p<0.001) between genders. There was a significant difference between genders in
There was a significant difference in VO2max values body fat percentage, endomorphy, and mesomorphy
between three dance styles (f2,112 = 33.724, p<0.001), and values (p<0.001). There were no significant differences in
post hoc tests indicated VO2max values of dancesport ectomorphy scores.
dancers were significantly higher (p<0.01) (Table 2).
There were significant difference between dance styles DISCUSSION
in body fat percentage (f2,112 = 5.524, p<0.05). Female con-
temporary and dancesport dancers had higher body fat The aim of the present study was to assess the homogenity
percentage than female ballet dancers (p<0.001). There was of professional dancers for anthropometric variables and
no significant difference among male dancers in body fat aerobic capacity. Within the exercise science literature,
percentage. there have been very few studies that have compared the
There was significant difference in endomorphy (f2,112 = different dance genres to ascertain whether there are uni-
8.773, p<0.001) and mesomorphy (f2,112 = 21.458, p<0.001) form characteristics such as body shape and aeriobic fit-
characteristics between dance styles. Female dancesport ness among the three dance genres classical ballet, contem-
dancers had lower endomorphy values compared to porary dance, and dancesport. Within sport, it is well
female ballet and contemporary dancers (p<0.001). Female established that different sports require participants to
ballet dancers had lower mesomorphy values compared to have specific anthropometric and physical characteristics
female contemporary (p<0.05) dancers. In contrast, female to compete at an elite level.4,17 It has also been suggested
TABLE 2. Mean Percent Body Fat, Maximal O2 Uptake, and Somatotype of Dancers in Different Dance Styles
Ballet Contemporary DanceSport
____________________________ ____________________________ ____________________________
Male Female Male Female Male Female
that functional adaptation due to different training regi- Previous research has reported the somatotypes for aes-
mens may be responsible for the determination of some thetic sports like gymnastics and figure skating are as fol-
anthropometric changes.15 Height, body weight, body fat lows: figure skating, males 1.7–5.0–2.918 and females 3.4–
percentage, and VO2max values of classical ballet dancers, 3.7–2.926; gymnastics, male 2.6–6.2–1.58 and females 2.6–
contemporary dancers, and dancesport dancers were simi- 4.4–2.6.8 Compared to other aesthetic sports such as figure
lar to those reported in previous studies.5,6,10,21,25 skating and gymnastics, male dancers of all three genres
Female ballet dancers had lowest body fat percentage, (ballet, contemporary and dancesport) were less mesomor-
body mass, and BMI compared with female contemporary phic than male gymnasts8 and figure skaters.18 Male con-
dance and dancesport dancers, confirming the genre’s temporary dance and dancesport participants were more
requirements for female dancers to be light, low body fat ectomorphic compared to male figure skaters18 and gym-
content, and low body weight in order to perform the tasks nasts.8 Male ballet dancers were more ectomorphic com-
related to classical ballet.29 Female ballet dancers lower pared to male gymnasts.8
body fat percentage, body mass, and BMI compared with Female figure skaters26 and gymnasts11 were more
female contemporary and dancesport dancers may relate mesomorphic compared to female dancesport and ballet
to different aesthetic values of ballet, contemporary, and participants. Female contemporary dancers, on the other
dancesport dancers. The observed higher height of dance- hand, were more mesomorphic than female figure
sport athletes compared to contemporary dancers may be skaters26 and gymnasts.11 Female dancers of all three
related to the fact that dancesport does not have lifts genres were more ectomorphic compared to female figure
within its choreography, which require the female dancer skaters26 and gymnasts.11
to be lifted above the partner’s head where her weight It has been suggested that dancers would benefit from
could become an issue. The choreography, especially with aerobic training1 and a high anaerobic threshold to limit
standard dances, requires large movements and shapes, the effects of fatigue, such as a decrease in balance, poise,
especially in the upper body, which is enhanced by having and coordination.3,25,33 The dancesport participants
a taller frame and longer limbs. Standard dance is one of recorded the highest relative oxygen uptake, while classical
three dancesport disciplines where five standard dances ballet dancers demonstrated lower maximal oxygen
(waltz, tango, Viennese waltz, slow foxtrot, and quickstep) uptake than contemporary dancers.2 These differences
are performed. All standard dances demand wide move- could be due to the variation in the physical demands of
ment and big shapes, and in dance hold, greater height dancing in the different genres.13,34 Classical ballet and
probably helps to achieve this. modern dance are noncompetitive, and dancers do not
There was significant difference in mesomorphic and need to strive against others during performance. Dances-
endomorphy scores between the three dance styles (Fig. 1). port, in contrast, requires competing throughout the day
Female danceport dancers are less mesomorphic and endo- and to be recalled through a number of rounds before
morphic than females of the other two dance styles, and reaching the final. This difference between the genres is
female contemporary dancers are more mesomorphic than especially highlighted in the aerobic capcity of female
female ballet dancers. The reason for higher mesomorphy dancers, where the dancesport participants had signifi-
scores for contemporary dancers may be because, unlike cantly higher VO2max than the other two genres. This
most ballet dances, contemporary dance has less of a could be due to the training and competitive requirements
gender divide within the choreographed movements34 and of dancesport and especially standard dances, which
the dancers often come from a multidisciplinary back- require the female dancers to match their male partners
ground (e.g., gymnastics).23 stride for stride.