Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Background: Jackson Pratt (JP) drain fluid bilirubin levels may be assayed in the evaluation of possible bile leaks.
Although fluid color and bilirubin level may prompt additional evaluation, there are no reference data available.
Objective: To assess the JP drain fluid-to-serum bilirubin ratio in patients with documented bile leaks.
Design: Prospective case series.
Setting: Tertiary referral center.
Methods: Patients referred for ERCP for the management of documented bile leaks with a JP drain in place were
included. Demographic data, bile leak etiology, and serum bilirubin levels were recorded. JP drain fluid was sent
for color evaluation and bilirubin concentration. Control subjects included both patients after nonbiliary surgery
with a JP drain in place and medical patients with ascites undergoing paracentesis.
Results: JP drain fluid-to-serum bilirubin concentration and fluid color evaluation was performed on 23 patients
with documented bile leaks by ERCP and compared with 26 controls (16 surgical and 10 medical). The JP drain
fluid/ascites-to-serum bilirubin ratio was significantly higher in those with bile leaks (mean ratio 45.6) compared
with combined controls (mean ratio 0.9). Use of a cutoff JP drain fluid-to-serum bilirubin ratio of 5 would be
100% sensitive and specific for the prediction of a bile leak in the selected control group. There was overlap
in fluid color evaluation between the groups.
Limitations: Controls did not include those with suspected bile leaks and negative technetium 99m–HIDA scin-
tigraphy or ERCP findings.
Conclusions: JP drain fluid-to-serum bilirubin concentration ratio greater than 5 seems to be highly sensitive
and specific for the detection of a bile leak. Used along with clinical criteria, this ratio could be used to select
patients to proceed directly to ERCP. (Gastrointest Endosc 2010;71:99-104.)
Endoscopic therapy has proven beneficial as a first-line has difficulty lying flat for the approximate 1 hour required
treatment for the management of most bile leaks.1,2 Tech- for the study. There are also potential logistical consider-
netium 99 m–HIDA scintigraphy (HIDA) has a high accu- ations during off hours, recent issues with HIDA tracer
racy for predicting the presence of bile leaks and is often availability, and the additional time and cost required.4
used as a noninvasive guide to determine those in need Patients with a Jackson Pratt (JP) drain in place may have
of endoscopic management.3 However, it may be difficult fluid visually inspected or bilirubin concentration assayed
to mobilize trauma patients for the transport to the nuclear to determine the presence of a potential bile leak. This is
medicine department, and an occasional unstable patient often done when the output is high, the output increases,
or color appears compatible with bile. However, color eval-
Abbreviations: HIDA, technetium 99m–HIDA scintigraphy; JP, Jackson
Pratt.
uation may be subjective, and there are few reference data
to use as a guide when evaluating JP drain fluid bilirubin
DISCLOSURE: All authors disclosed no financial relationships relevant levels. If reliable for detecting leaks, JP drain fluid evalua-
to this publication. tion for bilirubin concentration would be less time-con-
See CME section; p. 139. suming and costly than an HIDA scan before ERCP.
Copyright ª 2010 by the American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy
We performed this study to evaluate JP drain fluid-to-
0016-5107/$36.00 serum bilirubin level ratio in patients with bile leaks docu-
doi:10.1016/j.gie.2009.08.015 mented by ERCP, as well as in both surgical and medical
TABLE 1. Mean serum bilirubin, Jackson Pratt drain output bilirubin, and ratio of Jackson Pratt drain output-to-serum bilirubin in
patients with bile leak compared with medical and surgical controls
Mean serum bilirubin, mg/dL Mean JP drain output bilirubin, mg/dL Mean ratio: JP drain output–serum
Controls (95% CI) (95% CI) bilirubin, mg/dL (95% CI)
Clear 1 1 0 2
Yellow 5 6 8 19
Straw 2 2 0 4
Amber 2 0 5 7
Orange 1 1 1 3
Red 3 0 0 3
Figure 2. Mean JP drain fluid-to-serum bilirubin ratio: patients with bile
leak compared with medical and surgical controls. *P ! .0001 for com- Brown 0 0 7 7
parison with all control groups. Green 0 0 2 2
a JP drain left in place at the time of surgery. In addition, may be initially managed with endoscopic therapy, provid-
postoperative pain or collections may prompt laparo- ing successful outcomes in a majority of cases.13 However,
scopic or percutaneous drain placement. To further assess endoscopic therapy is not without risks and is often
patients with a high drain output (O200 mL/day), ERCP or pursued only when leaks are documented by HIDA scan.
a HIDA scan may be performed.2 However, JP drain fluid Although HIDA scintigraphy is noninvasive, there are
volume may be confounded by ascites from portal hyper- logistical considerations in ill patients as well as added
tension or other causes. A persistent or abruptly increas- time and cost. There has also been a recent shortage of
ing JP output may also indicate an ongoing leak. Our tracer available for clinical use. If reliable in patients with
general policy is to monitor serial 24-hour output and a drain in place, JP drain fluid-to-serum bilirubin concentra-
pull such drains when the output decreases to less than tion ratio for the diagnosis of bile leaks could be used to
20 mL/day. Clinically, fluid color that appears bilious or select those in need of endoscopic therapy and avoid
fluid bilirubin concentration may be used to stratify those HIDA scan or diagnostic ERCP. However, HIDA scintigraphy
at high risk of leak who require intervention, but there are before ERCP may still play a role in selected cases to help
few reference data to guide management. define the site of the leak before therapy.
ERCP has proved to be effective for bile leak manage- Our results demonstrate that subjective color evalua-
ment. Endoscopic obliteration of the transpapillary pres- tion of JP drain fluid has variable results, and there is
sure gradient with short stents allows flow of bile into not a classic fluid appearance in proven cases of bile
the duodenum and is an effective method of pressure leak. However, JP drain fluid bilirubin is significantly
equalization in postsurgical leaks.12 Endoscopic sphincter- higher in those with bile leaks compared with surgical
otomy alone or in combination with nasobiliary drainage and medical controls. Using the JP drain output/ascites-
has also been used as therapy. Similarly, traumatic bile leaks to-serum bilirubin ratio also demonstrates a marked
difference between the groups. A similar ascites-to-serum pected leak, high JP drain fluid bilirubin, and negative
bilirubin ratio has been evaluated in patients with cirrhosis HIDA/ERCP findings or distinguish between those leaks
and malignancy. Bilirubin levels in cirrhotic ascites are that may or may not respond to endoscopic therapy. Fur-
know to be lower than serum levels.14 A ratio greater ther study would be required to address these questions
than 0.6 has been used as a marker for distinguishing with a HIDA scan and ERCP in all patients. Based on the
transudates from exudates,15 but the serum-to-ascites above limitations, the JP drain fluid–serum bilirubin con-
albumin ratio has been most widely used for this purpose. centration ratio should not be used as an isolated indica-
Runyon16 measured this ratio in 65 patients with various tor of those patients who could benefit from endoscopic
types of ascites to determine the normal range. The therapy. The management of patients with suspected
mean ratio was similar to our medical control group at bile leaks still relies on clinical criteria including serial
0.38 0.44. One patient in this series had a ruptured gall- drain fluid volume assessment if a JP drain is in place.
bladder with a ratio of 7.1. An ascites–to-serum bilirubin However, the control group used in this study does give
ratio greater than 1.0 was suggested as a threshold for baseline reference JP drain fluid bilirubin levels in patients
the diagnosis of choleperitoneum. However, the mean ra- postoperatively. In theory, this group should reflect those
tio in our surgical controls without biliary tract manipula- patients without a leak after cholecystectomy.
tion was higher than this threshold. In summary, evaluation of JP drain fluid bilirubin or JP
Posthepatic resection bilirubin levels have been shown drain output/serum bilirubin concentration ratio would
to increase in drain discharge late in the postoperative seem accurate in patients with documented leaks as dem-
course,17 but there is otherwise scant literature on fluid/ onstrated by ERCP. Postoperative or trauma patients with
serum bilirubin level in postsurgical patients. Truedson18 an elevated JP drain output bilirubin or a ratio greater
evaluated drainage fluid–conjugated bilirubin in a series than 5 along with a high or persistent JP drain output
of patients after open cholecystectomy, but no correlation should be considered at high risk of a bile leak. Even
with serum values or evaluation of possible leaks was per- though such patients with an elevated JP drain output af-
formed. In our study, using a JP drain fluid bilirubin level ter cholecystectomy could proceed directly to a therapeu-
greater than 4.9 mg/dL or a JP drain fluid–serum ratio cut- tic procedure, referring physicians often order a HIDA
off greater than 5.4 would include all patients with a docu- scan to confirm the diagnosis. JP drain fluid bilirubin as-
mented leak. The combination of cirrhosis/ascites with sessment is quicker and less costly if a confirmatory test
a bile leak could not be evaluated because there were before intervention is desired.
no such patients in our series.
Although not a primary study aim, JP drain volume alone
was evaluated as a predictor of a bile leak. The 24-hour vol- REFERENCES
ume in both study subjects and surgical controls was
recorded when available. All study subjects had either 1. Katsinelos P, Kountouras J, Paroutoglou G, et al. The role of endo-
scopic treatment in postoperative bile leaks. Hepatogastroenterology
high-volume or persistent JP drain output. Although vol- 2006;53:166-70.
ume evaluation had a lower sensitivity and specificity 2. Ahmad F, Saunders RN, Lloyd GM, et al. An algorithm for the manage-
than JP drain output bilirubin, the daily drain output after ment of bile leak following laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Ann R Coll
cholecystectomy is an important factor in determining Surg Engl 2007;89:51-6.
the need for additional evaluation and therapy. For study 3. Brugge WR, Rosenberg DJ, Alavi A. Diagnosis of postoperative bile
leaks. Am J Gastroenterol 1994;89:2178-83.
purposes, those with outputs that continued to be more 4. Perkins A, Hilson A, Hall J. Global shortage of medical isotopes
than 200 mL/day were considered high output and those threatens nuclear medicine services. BMJ 2008;337:a1577.
that remained more than 20 mL/week were persistent. We 5. Sharif K, Pimpalwar AP, John P, et al. Benefit of early diagnosis and
continue to follow these parameters in our clinical practice. preemptive treatment of biliary tract complications after major blunt
Limitations of this study include a relatively small sam- liver trauma in children. J Pediatr Surg 2002;37:1287-92.
6. Cogbill TH, Moore EE, Jurkovich GJ, et al. Severe hepatic trauma:
ple size and no blinded comparison of HIDA scan with the a multi center experience with 1335 liver injuries. J Trauma 1998;28:
JP drain fluid–serum bilirubin concentration ratio. In addi- 1422-38.
tion, this was a single-center study with no controls with 7. Asenio JA, Demetriades D, Chaahwan S, et al. Approach to the man-
presumed bile leaks that had negative HIDA scan or agement of complex hepatic injuries. J Trauma 2000;48:66-9.
ERCP findings. The control group selected had no possi- 8. Shinhar S, Nobel M, Shimonov M, et al. Technetium-99 m-HIDA scintig-
raphy vs ERCP in demonstrating bile leaks post cholecystectomy.
bility of a bile leak by design. Additional control patients J Nucl Med 1998;39:1802-4.
could have included those after cholecystectomy, biliary 9. Peters JH, Ollila D, Nichols KE, et al. Diagnosis and management of bile
anastomosis, liver resection, and hepatic trauma. Our ini- leaks following laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Surg Laparosc Endosc
tial study design excluded evaluation of such patients be- 1994;4:163-70.
cause we could not exclude a small or sealed leak nor 10. Kaldor A, Akopian G, Recabaren J, et al. Utility of liver function tests
after laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Am Surg 2006;27:1238-40.
justify the added cost/risk of a HIDA scan or ERCP solely 11. Halevy A, Gold-Deutch R, Negri M, et al. Are elevated liver enzymes
for study purposes. The control group selected therefore and bilirubin levels significant after laparoscopic cholecystectomy in
does not allow us to address those patients with a sus- the absence of bile duct injury? Ann Surg 1994;219:362-4.
12. Bjorkman D, Carr-Locke D, Lichtenstein D, et al. Postsurgical bile leaks: 18. Truedson H. Cholecystectomy with intraperitoneal drain. Presence and
endoscopic obliteration of the transpapillary pressure gradient is significance of conjugated bilirubin in the drainage fluid. Acta Chir
enough. Am J Gastroenterol 1995;90:2128-33. Scand 1983;149:179-85.
13. Bridges A, Wilcox CM, Varadarajulu S. Endoscopic management of
traumatic bile leaks. Gastrointest Endosc 2007;65:1081-5.
14. Hedenborg G, Jonsson G, Norman A, et al. Bile constituents in ascites
fluid. Scand J Clin Lab Invest 1988;48:543-52. Received January 25, 2008. Accepted August 23, 2009.
15. Elis A, Meisel S, Tisher T, et al. Ascitic fluid to serum bilirubin concen-
Current affiliations : Division of Gastroenterology-Hepatology (P.D., E.G.),
tration ratio for the classification of transudates or exudates. Am J Gas-
University of Maryland Medical System, Baltimore, Maryland, Division of
troenterol 1998;93:401-3.
Gastroenterology (L.U.), George Washington University, Washington, DC,
16. Runyon BA. Ascitic fluid bilirubin concentration as a key to choleper-
USA.
itoneum. J Clin Gastroenterol 1987;9:543-5.
17. Torzilli G, Olivari N, Del Fabbro D, et al. Bilirubin level fluctuation in Reprint requests: Peter Darwin, MD, Division of Gastroenterology-
drain discharge after hepatectomies justifies long-term drain mainte- Hepatology, University of Maryland Medical System, 22 South Greene
nance. Hepatogastroenterology 2005;52:1206-10. Street, N3W62, Baltimore, MD 21201.