Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 Introduction
In this paper we will study the liquid vapor interface in microscopic level. Here we
will study the system where it has density variation only in one direction, i.e the
one dimensional case. We consider one component system at constant tempera-
ture and volume. As we all know from the thermodynamics that in equilibrium
the free energy that minimizes at constant temperature and volume is Helmholtz
free energy. So the density profile in one dimension of such a system will be ob-
tained by minimizing the free energy. We express the Helmholtz free energy as a
integral of local free energy density which is a functional of local molecular num-
ber density and its derivative. Here the determination of equilibrium molecular
number density profile becomes a problem of calculus of variation. Here the ex-
tremization of the integral is constrained by total number of molecule is constant,
i.e. vapour becoming liquid or liquid becoming vapour, no external ingrained is
being mixed to the system. From that variational method the Euler-Lagrange
equation can be obtained with a Lagrange undetermined multiplier. Solving the
Euler-Lagrange equation a density function is obtained in a given chemical po-
tential. From the analysis of the one dimension differential equation we obtain
description of the cases of a single phase and two coexisting phases.
Figure 1: Density profile for a pure system in the neighborhood of the gas-liquid interface
day experience that the density interior to the liquid is almost constant and as we
go towards the surface it start to decreasing and in the flat interface the vapour
density is high but as we go further the vapour density also start decreasing and
after some distance it also get constant(figure 1). But the density is no where
discontinuous. We are starting from the integral of Helmholtz free energy density.
We can see in appendix 1 that the Helmholtz free energy can be expressed as the
2
integral of local free energy density of the form.
Z
F = d3 r ψ(ρ(r), ∇ρ(r), r) (1)
When the molecular number density ρ(r) is sufficiently slowly varying in its spacial
dependence on a scale set by the interaction range, we find ψ(r) is given by
1
ψ(ρ(r), ∇ρ(r), r) = U (r)ρ(r) + ψ̃(ρ(r)) + A(ρ(r))(∇ρ(r))2 (2)
2
U(r) is the external potential energy function and ψ̃(ρ) is the free energy density
of an equilibrium uniform system having density ρ. A(ρ) is related to the direct
correlation function C(r, ρ) of a uniform system having density ρ by
Z
kT
A(ρ) = d3 r r2 C(r, ρ) (3)
6
with respect to number density gives the chemical potential as in equation 11.
Since the equation 9 has no explicit x dependence so we can argue that if ρ(x)
is a solution of the differential equation then ρ(x + c) is also a solution of that
differential equation. Where c is an arbitrary constant. Since the boundaries of
the system are fixed at a and b so replacing ρ(x) by ρ(x+c) is equivalent to moving
the phase boundary to −c, i.e. we are decreasing one component and increasing
other and interestingly this is not effecting the phase equilibrium. So we can
conclude that the phase equilibrium does not depend on amount of substance in
each phase. Now let us analyse the equation 9.
5
Figure 5: (a) g1 (ρ) can be made to be zero at ρ1 or at ρ2 (b) Density profiles which approaches ρ1 or ρ2
6
Figure 7: (a) g1 (ρ) when µ is chosen so that the two minima are at the same height. (b) The density profile for
physical solution. (c)Maxwell equal area construction
P V = µN − P V + σ0 ã (20)
Thus the interestingly we have not consider the surface as true discontinuity
but the surface contribution to the free energy has come automatically.
2.3 Conclusion
So we have derived the surface energy term in terms direct correlation function
and the derivative of density. So for any particular type of potential we can
find the direct correlation function then from the equation 3 we can derive a
functional form of A. And on other hand solving for a particular type of chemical
potential isotherm numerically equation 9 we can find the density profile.With
the functional form of ρ(x) and A(ρ) we can find the surface energy functional.
7
3 Appendix
3.1 Derivation of free energy density
where,
N
X
Vext = Φ(ri ) (23)
i=1
i.e. the external field is the sum of the single particle contributions. The micro-
scopic one particle density is
N
X
ρM = δ(r − ri ) (24)
i=1
so, Z
Vext = d3 ρM Φ(r) (25)
8
We define f (rN , pN ) as the probability density function,i.e having first particle at
position r1 and momentum p1 , second particle at position at r2 with momentum p2
etc. So, having the probability density for the positions are i.e having first particle
at position r1 and second particle at r2 and so on irrespective of all momentum
is given by Z
n(rN ) = d3N p f (rN , pN ) (33)
Now,
P |pi |2
T r ρM exp {−β( N
R 3
i=1 2m + V int ) + d r ρM u(r)}
< ρM > = (34)
Ξ
δ ln Ξ
= (35)
δu
Now, the probability that particle 1 will be in the vicinity 1 irrespective of the
other particle is
Z
1
n(1/n) (r1 ) = d3 r1 d3 r2 .... d3 rN n(rN ) = (36)
V
Now, the probability of any particle at r1 is
N
X Z
(1/N ) (1/N )
ρ = n (r1 ) = ρM n( 1/N ) d3 r (37)
i=1
N
= = ρM n(1/N ) (r1 ) =< ρM > (38)
V
So,
δlnΞ
< ρM >= (39)
δu
Now, The Helmholtz free energy is defined by
1
F = µN − P V = µN − lnΞ =⇒ βF = βµN − lnΞ (40)
β
In our case the Hamiltonian itself depends the one particle number like µN de-
pends in the case of Grand Canonical partition function. Here µ is replaced by
u(r) and defined. We define a dimension less free energy as
Z
F0 = d3 r u(r) ρ(r) − lnΞ (41)
9
from equation 40 and 41 we get
Z
βF = βµN − F 0 − d3 r u(r) ρ(r) (42)
Z Z
= β d3 r ρ(r) µ + F 0 − d3 r u(r) ρ(r) (43)
Z
= d3 r (βµ − u(r)) ρ(r) + F 0 (44)
Z
= F0 + d3 r β Φ(r) ρ(r) (45)
So,
Z
−3
lnΞ = λ d3 r exp {u(r)} (51)
δlnΞ
ρ(r) = (52)
δu(r)
exp {u(r)}
= (53)
λ3
=⇒ u(r) = ln{λ3 ρ(r)} (54)
so,
Z
lnΞ = ρ(r) d3 r (55)
Z Z
F00 = d3 r ln[λ3 ρ(r)]ρ(r) − d3 r ρ(r) (56)
Z
= d3 r ρ(r)[ln{λ3 ρ(r)} − 1] (57)
10
Now, let consider the interaction in the system and in that case for the density
ρ(r) let the free energy is
ρ→0 (66)
F00 = F 0 (0) (67)
φ(0) = 0 (68)
and1
11
So,
Z Z 1
3
φ(ρ) = d r1 sdsC(r1 , sρ)ρ(r1 ) (74)
0
Z Z 0 Z Z 1
1
= ∗2 d3 r1 sds d3 r2 C(r1 , r2 , ss0 ρ) ρ(r1 )ρ(r2 )(75)
2
Z Z1 Z 1 Z 01
1
= ∗2 d3 r1 d3 r2 sds s0 ds0 C(r1 , r2 , ss0 ρ)ρ(r1 )ρ(r(76)
2)
2Z Z 0 0
1
= C̄(r1 , r2 )ρ(r1 )ρ(r2 )d3 r1 d3 r2 (77)
2Z Z
1
=⇒ F00 − F 0 = C̄(r1 , r2 )ρ(r1 )ρ(r2 )d3 r1 d3 r2 (78)
2 Z Z
1
=⇒ F 0 = F00 − C̄(r1 , r2 )ρ(r1 )ρ(r2 )d3 r1 d3 r2 (79)
2Z Z
1
=⇒ F 0 = F00 − C̄(r1 , r1 + r2 )ρ(r1 )ρ(r1 + r2 )d3 r1 d3 r2 (80)
Z 2
=⇒ F 0 = d3 r ρ(r)[ln{λ3 ρ(r)} − 1]
Z Z
1
− C̄(r, r + r2 )ρ(r)ρ(r + r2 )d3 rd3 r2 (81)
Z 2
=⇒ F 0 = d3 r ρ(r)[{ln{λ3 ρ(r)} − 1}
Z
1
− d3 r2 C̄(r, r + r2 )ρ(r + r2 )] (82)
Z 2
=⇒ F 0 = d3 r f¯(r) (83)
Where,
Z
1
f¯(r) = ρ(r)[ln{ρ(r)λ − 1} − 3
d3 r2 C̄(r, r + r2 )ρ(r + r2 )] (84)
2
Z
δ C̄(r, r2 )
C̄(r, r2 ) = C̄(r, r2 ; ρ(r)) + [ρ(r3 ) − ρ(r)]dr3
δρ(r3 ) ρ(r)
δ 2 C̄(r, r2 )
Z
1
+ [ρ(r3 ) − ρ(r)][ρ(r4 ) − ρ(r)]dr3 dr4
2! δρ(r3 )δρ(r4 ) ρ(r)
+ ................ (85)
12
Z
C̄(r, r2 ) = C̄(r, r2 ; ρ(r)) + C̄(r, r2 , r3 ; ρ(r))[ρ(r3 ) − ρ(r)]dr3
Z
1
+ C̄(r, r2 , r3 , r4 ; ρ(r))[ρ(r3 ) − ρ(r)][ρ(r4 ) − ρ(r)]dr3 dr4
2!
+ ................ (86)
where
Z 1 Z 1
C̄(r, r2 ) = 2 sds C(r, r2 ; ss0 )d0 (87)
Z0 1 Z0 1
C̄(r, r2 , r3 ) = 2 sds C(r, r2 , r3 ; ss0 )ds0 (88)
0 0
Z 1 Z 1
C̄(r, r2 , r3 , r4 ) = 2 sds C(r, r2 , r3 , r4 ; ss0 )ds0 (89)
0 0
13
Z
C̄ 0 (r2 ) = C̄ 0 (r2 ; ρ(r)) + C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 ; ρ(r))[ρ(r + r3 ) − ρ(r)]dr3
Z
1
+ C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 , r4 ; ρ(r))[ρ(r + r3 ) − ρ(r)][ρ(r + r4 ) − ρ(r)]
2!
dr3 dr4 + ........................ (97)
Z Z
1
f¯(r) = ρ(r)[ln{λ ρ(r)} − 1] − ρ(r)
3
C̄ (r2 ; ρ(r)) + C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 ; ρ(r))
0
2
Z
1
[ρ(r + r3 ) − ρ(r)]dr3 + C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 , r4 ; ρ(r))[ρ(r + r3 ) − ρ(r)]
2!
[ρ(r + r4 ) − ρ(r)]dr3 dr4 ρ(r + r2 )dr2 (99)
Z
1
f¯(r) = ρ(r)[ln{λ ρ(r)} − 1] − ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 ; ρ(r))ρ(r + r2 )dr2
3
Z 2
1
− ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 ; ρ(r))ρ(r + r2 )[ρ(r + r3 ) − ρ(r)]dr2 dr3
2 Z
1
− ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 , r4 ; ρ(r))ρ(r + r2 )[ρ(r + r3 ) − ρ(r)]
4
[ρ(r + r4 ) − ρ(r)]dr2 dr3 dr4 (100)
Taylor Expansion
A Taylor series is a series expansion of a function about a point. A one
dimensional Taylor expansion of a single variable real function f (x) about a point
x = x0 is given by
00 (3)
0 2f (x0 ) 3 f (x0 )
f (x) = f (x0 ) + (x − x0 )f (x0 ) + (x − x0 ) + (x − x0 ) +
2! 3!
(n)
nf (x0 )
................ + (x − x0 ) + .................. (101)
n!
An alternate form of one dimensional Taylor series may be obtained by letting
14
x − x0 = ∆x (102)
x = x0 + ∆x (103)
00 (3)
0 2f (x0 ) 3 f (x0 )
f (x0 + ∆x) = f (x0 ) + ∆x f (x0 ) + (∆x) + (∆x) +
2! 3!
(n)
nf (x0 )
................ + (∆x) + .................. (104)
n!
In general
∞ n
X 1 ∂
f (x0 + ∆x) = ∆x f (x) (105)
n=0
n! ∂x x=x0
∂f (x, y) ∂f (x, y)
f (x0 + ∆x, y0 + ∆y) = f (x0 , y0 ) + ∆x + ∆y
∂x ∂y x=x0 ,y=y0
2
1 ∂f (x, y) ∂f (x, y)
+ ∆x + ∆y
2! ∂x ∂y x=x0 ,y=y0
3
1 ∂f (x, y) ∂f (x, y)
+ ∆x + ∆y
3! ∂x ∂y x=x0 ,y=y0
+ .................................. (106)
In general
15
∞ n
X 1 ∂ ∂
f (x0 + ∆x, y0 + ∆y) = ∆x + ∆y f (x, y) (108)
n=0
n! ∂x ∂y x=x0 ,y=y0
In general
In vector form
∞ n
X 1
f (r0 + ∆r) = ∆r· ∇ f (r)
n=0
n! r=r0
The only contribution to the integrals in Eq.(100) comes from the points near
to the field point r. Thus we can Taylor expand ρ(r + r2 ) about the point r:
1
ρ(r + r2 ) = ρ(r) + r2 · ∇ρ(r) + (r2 · ∇)2 ρ(r) + .................... (111)
2!
Keeping above equation upto second order in gradient and substitute it into
Eq.(100), we obtain
16
Z
1
f¯(r) = 3 0
ρ(r) ln{λ ρ(r)} − 1 − ρ(r) C̄ (r2 ; ρ(r)) ρ(r) + r2 · ∇ρ(r)
2
Z
1 1
+ (r2 · ∇)2 ρ(r) dr2 − ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 ; ρ(r)) ρ(r) + r2 · ∇ρ(r)
2! 2
1
(r2 · ∇)2 ρ(r) ρ(r + r3 ) − ρ(r) dr2 dr3
+
2!
Z
1 0 1 2
− ρ(r) C̄ (r2 , r3 , r4 ; ρ(r)) ρ(r) + r2 · ∇ρ(r) + (r2 · ∇) ρ(r)
4 2!
ρ(r + r3 ) − ρ(r) ρ(r + r4 ) − ρ(r) dr2 dr3 dr4 (112)
Taylor expand all the terms. The above equation becomes
Z
1
f¯(r) = ρ(r) ln{λ3 ρ(r)} − 1 − ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 ; ρ(r))ρ(r)dr2
Z 2
1 0 1 2
− ρ(r) C̄ (r2 ; ρ(r)) r2 · ∇ρ(r) + (r2 · ∇) ρ(r) dr2
2 2!
Z
1 1
− ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 ; ρ(r)) ρ(r) + r2 · ∇ρ(r) + (r2 · ∇)2 ρ(r)
2 2!
1
ρ(r) + r3 · ∇ρ(r) + (r3 · ∇)2 ρ(r) − ρ(r) dr2 dr3
2!
Z
1 1
− ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 , r4 ; ρ(r)) ρ(r) + r2 · ∇ρ(r) + (r2 · ∇)2 ρ(r)
4 2!
1
ρ(r) + r3 · ∇ρ(r) + (r3 · ∇)2 ρ(r) − ρ(r)
2!
1 2
ρ(r) + r4 · ∇ρ(r) + (r4 · ∇) ρ(r) − ρ(r) dr2 dr3 dr4 (113)
2!
Z
1 1
f¯(r) = f0 (ρ(r)) − ρ(r) C̄ (r2 ; ρ(r)) r2 · ∇ρ(r) + (r2 · ∇) ρ(r) dr2
0 2
2 2!
Z
1 1
− ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 ; ρ(r)) ρ(r) + r2 · ∇ρ(r) + (r2 · ∇)2 ρ(r)
2 2!
1
r3 · ∇ρ(r) + (r3 · ∇)2 ρ(r) dr2 dr3
2!
Z
1 0 1 2
− ρ(r) C̄ (r2 , r3 , r4 ; ρ(r)) ρ(r) + r2 · ∇ρ(r) + (r2 · ∇) ρ(r)
4 2!
1 1
r3 · ∇ρ(r) + (r3 · ∇)2 ρ(r) r4 · ∇ρ(r) + (r4 · ∇)2 ρ(r)
2! 2!
dr2 dr3 dr4 (114)
17
where
Z
1
f0 (ρ(r)) = ρ(r) ln{λ3 ρ(r)} − 1 − ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 ; ρ(r))ρ(r)dr2
(115)
2
Z
1 1
f¯(r) = f0 (ρ(r)) − ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 ; ρ(r)) r2 · ∇ρ(r) + (r2 · ∇)2 ρ(r) dr2
2 2!
Z
1 1
− ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 ; ρ(r))ρ(r) r3 · ∇ρ(r) + (r3 · ∇)2 ρ(r) dr2 dr3
2 2!
Z
1 0 1 2
− ρ(r) C̄ (r2 , r3 ; ρ(r)) r2 · ∇ρ(r) + (r2 · ∇) ρ(r)
2 2!
Z
1 1
r3 · ∇ρ(r) + (r3 · ∇)2 ρ(r) dr2 dr3 − ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 , r4 ; ρ(r))
2! 4
1 2 1 2
ρ(r) r3 · ∇ρ(r) + (r3 · ∇) ρ(r) r4 · ∇ρ(r) + (r4 · ∇) ρ(r)
2! 2!
Z
1
dr2 dr3 dr4 − ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 , r4 ; ρ(r)) r2 · ∇ρ(r) +
4
1 1
(r2 · ∇)2 ρ(r) r3 · ∇ρ(r) + (r3 · ∇)2 ρ(r) r4 · ∇ρ(r) +
2! 2!
1
(r4 · ∇)2 ρ(r) dr2 dr3 dr4 (116)
2!
Dropping all terms of higher than second order in gradients from above equa-
tion, we obtain
Z
1 1
f¯(r) = f0 (ρ(r)) − ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 ; ρ(r)) r2 · ∇ρ(r) + (r2 · ∇)2 ρ(r) dr2
2 2!
Z
1 1
− ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 ; ρ(r))ρ(r) r3 · ∇ρ(r) + (r3 · ∇)2 ρ(r) dr2 dr3
2 2!
Z
1
ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 ; ρ(r)) r2 · ∇ρ(r) r3 · ∇ρ(r) dr2 dr3
−
2 Z
1
ρ(r) C̄ 0 (r2 , r3 , r4 ; ρ(r))ρ(r) r3 · ∇ρ(r) r4 · ∇ρ(r)
−
4
dr2 dr3 dr4 (117)
Using rotational invarience we can write equation 117 as
f¯(r) = f0 (ρ(r)) − f1 (ρ(r))∇2 ρ(r) − f2 (ρ(r))(∇ρ(r))2 (118)
Where,
Z Z
ρ(r)
f1 (ρ(r)) = d3 r2 r22 C¯0 (r2 , ρ) + ρ d3 r3 C 0 (r2¯, r3 , ρ) (119)
12
18
and
Z Z
ρ(r) ρ
f2 (ρ(r)) = d32 r d r3 r2 .r3 {C¯0 (r2 , r3 , ρ) +
3
d3 r4 C¯0 (r2 , r3 , r4 , ρ)}
6 2
(120)
With the help of the symmetry properties of correlation functions, f2 (ρ) can be
written as
Z
ρ
f2 (ρ) = d3 r1 d3 r2 d3 r3 (r2 − r1 ).(r3 − r1 )
6V Z
ρ
∗{C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , ρ) + d3 r4 C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , r4 , ρ)} (121)
Z 2
ρ
= d3 r1 d3 r2 d3 r3 (r12 − r1 r2 )
6V Z
ρ
∗{C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , ρ) + d3 r4 C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , r4 , ρ)} (122)
Z 2
ρ
= d3 r1 d3 r2 d3 r3 (r1 − r2 )2
12V Z
ρ
∗{C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , ρ) + d3 r4 C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , r4 , ρ)} (123)
Z 2
ρ
= d3 r2 d3 r3 r22
12V Z
ρ
∗{C¯0 (r2 , r3 , ρ) + d3 r4 C¯0 (r2 , r3 , r4 , ρ)} (124)
2
Calculation for symmetricity in equation 121 to 124
let,
Z
I = d3 r1 d3 r2 d3 r3 (r2 − r1 ).(r3 − r1 )
Z
ρ
∗{C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , ρ) + d3 r4 C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , r4 , ρ)} (125)
2
(126)
Now,
r22 − r2 r1 − r2 r3 + r2 r3 (130)
19
So, from this argument we can say
Z
2I = d3 r1 d3 r2 d3 r3 (r12 + r22 − 2r1 r2 )
Z
ρ
∗{C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , ρ) + d3 r4 C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , r4 , ρ)} (131)
Z 2
= [ d3 r1 d3 r2 d3 r3 (r12 − 2r1 r2 )
Z
ρ
∗{C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , ρ) + d3 r4 C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , r4 , ρ)}]
Z 2
+[ d3 r1 d3 r2 d3 r3 (r22 )
Z
ρ
∗{C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , ρ) + d3 r4 C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , r4 , ρ)}] (132)
2
Again using the symmetric properties we can write
Z Z
ρ
I= d3 r1 d3 r2 d3 r3 (r12 − 2r1 r2 ) ∗ {C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , ρ) + d3 r4 C̄(r1 , r2 , r3 , r4 , ρ)}
2
(133)
putting equation 133 in equation 121 we get equation 122.
Again
r12 − r1 r2 (134)
can be written as
r22 − r2 r1 (135)
Adding equations 134 and 135 we get
(r1 − r2 )2 (136)
∂ C¯0 (r2 , ρ)
Z
= d3 r3 C¯0 (r2 , r3 , ρ) (142)
∂ρ
and
∂ C¯0 (r2 , r3 , ρ)
Z
= d3 r4 C¯0 (r2 , r3 , r4 , ρ) (143)
∂ρ
Substituting equation 142 and 143 for in equation 119, 120 and 138
ρ2 ∂ 2 ¯0
Z
1 ∂
A(ρ) = d3 r2 r22 (1 + 2ρ + )C (r2 , ρ)
6 ∂ρ 2 ∂ρ2
1 ∂2 2
Z
= 2
ρ d3 r2 r22 C¯0 (r2 , ρ) (144)
12 ∂ρ
Now,
1 1
1 ∂ 2 2 ¯0 ∂2 2 0
Z Z
{ρ C (r2 , ρ)} = sds ds 2 {ρ C (r2 , ss0 ρ)}
0
2 ∂ρ2 ∂ρ
Z0 1 0
Z 1
1 d 1 d
= ds ds0 0 {ss0 ρ2 C 0 (r2 , ss0 ρ)}
0 ρ ds ρ 0 ds
0
= C (r2 , ρ) (145)
21
INTEGER I
PI = 3.1415926
RHO = 1.1200
ETAA = RHO*PI/6D0
DO I = 0, 10000
R = 0.0002D0*FLOAT(I)
C = (1.0D0 - ETAA)*(1.0D0 - ETAA)*(1.0D0 - ETAA)*(1.0D0 - ETAA)
A = -(1.0D0 + 2*ETAA)*(1.0D0 + 2*)/C
B = 6*ETAA*(1.0D0 + 0.5D0*ETAA)*(1.0D0 + 0.5D0*ETAA)/C
IF(R.LT.1D0) THEN
CPY = A + B*R + 0.5D0*ETAA*A*R*R*R
ELSE
CPY = 0D0
END IF
PRINT*,R, CPY
WRITE(10,*)R, CPY
ENDDO
END
With the value of correlation function C one can calculate A(ρ(r)) and solving
the differential equaltion withe the boundary condition one can find the density
profile. And with that value of A(ρ(r)) and ρ(r) one can plot the surfacetension
w.r.t r.
22