Divorce bill?

Villanueva
says 'over my dead
body'
UPDATED) While Senator Joel Villanueva opposes divorce, he supports
'equal access' to annulment. Divorce advocates say an annulment's scope
is limited.

MANILA, Philippines (UPDATED) – "Divorce? Over my dead body."

This is what Senator Joel Villanueva had to say about talks of a

divorce bill this 18th Congress, as two senators have already filed
their own versions of the measure.

While Villanueva opposed divorce, he said on Monday, August 5 that

he supports "equal access" to annulment, which he branded "anti-
poor."

"Ang problema kasi sa ating bansa ngayon ay madali for rich people
na magpa-annul ng kanilang kasal. Pero sa mga mahihirap, nuknukan
ng tagal, nuknukan ng mahal. Nagiging anti-poor itong annulment na
provision ng batas," Villanueva told reporters in a media interview.

(The problem in our country now is that it's easy for rich people to
have their marriages annuled. But for the poor people, it takes a long
time; it is expensive. Annulment becomes an anti-poor provision of our
laws.)

Villanueva said he supports the annulment of marriages that are

"violent and broken." Apart from that, he said that it shouldn't be
backed because it's not "part of Philippine culture."
"We should not be embracing this kind of culture. Marriage is such as
sacred thing. We believe that we shouldn't allow people to be
separated. But of course there are exemptions and there is a way to
go over it which is annulment," said Villanueva in a mix of English and
Filipino.

Apart from Villanueva, Senator Cynthia Villar and Senator Manny

Pacquiao are not in favor of the measure.

Issue with semantics

In a separate media interview, Senate President Vicente Sotto III said

senators would be “more open to support” the measure sans the word
“divorce.”

Other Stories

LIVE: Senate hearing on the divorce bill

Watch the hearing live on Rappler

SolGen role in annulment 'waste of taxpayers' money' – group

(3rd UPDATE) Senator Risa Hontiveros says advocates support the term
'dissolution of marriage' if other lawmakers have an issue on the word 'divorce'
Bello now supports creation of new OFW department
But senators are not completely sold on the need to create a new government
agency

“There is more probability of support if it is not called ’divorce’ but if we

are talking about dissolution... Yes, there will be more support,” Sotto
told reporters.

Dissolution of marriage has the same effect as divorce, Sotto said.

Lawmakers want to relax the requirements to make legal termination

of marriage have a “more efficient process,” which may include
removing the review powers of the Office of the Solicitor General on
annulment cases.

Senate Majority Leader Juan Miguel Zubiri, who opposes divorce, said
he’s open to discussion of the measure. However, he raised the
possibility of the President vetoing the bill if approved by the
Congress, similar to what happened with the anti-endo bill.

“Ang tanong papayag ba si Pangulo? Eh kung ayaw niya, bat pa tayo

magdi-discussion ng divorce? (The question, will the President
approve of it? If he doesn’t want it, what’s the point of discussions?)”
Zubiri told reporters.

'Not realistic'

Senator Risa Hontiveros, the Senate committee on women chair, and

Senator Pia Cayetano both filed absolute divorce bills that seeks the
legal termination of marriages by Philippine courts. (READ: IN
NUMBERS: The state of the nation's marital woes)

The absolute divorce bill seeks to go beyond psychological incapacity,

lack of consent, incapability to bear children, among others, as the
acceptable reason for annulment.
Legalizing divorce, according to Hontiveros, would allow couples to
"free themselves from abusive, loveless, and unhappy relationships."

Recently, Senator Grace Poe and Senator Francis Tolentino also

expressed support for divorce.

On Monday, Hontiveros met with major advocacy groups.

Mark Luna of the Divorce Advocates of the Philippines told reporters

that legalizing divorce is more grounded to reality, when it comes to
the reason of why couples seek to be separated.

Luna has been physically separated with his wife due to infidelity.
(READ: 'Til divorce do us part?' PH struggles to marry religion and
reality)

"Nilagawan ko. Minahal ko. Pinakasalan ko. (I courted her. I loved her.
I married her.) Then you have to tell me that my marriage can only be
[declared] null and void because of psychological incapacity?" Luna
told reporters.

Apart from being expensive, advocates want lawmakers to make the

process of being separated "more truthful."

"Let there be annulment for church [marriages] and let us have the
option for divorce for civil [marriages]," Luna said.

In March 2018, a Social Weather Station survey found that majority of

Filipino support legalizing divorce in the country.

In the 17th Congress, the House of Representatives passed on 3rd

and final reading the divorce bill, but its Senate counterpart measure
was left pending in the committee level.