Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Edible coatings minimize fat uptake in deep fat fried products: A review
PII: S0268-005X(16)30996-1
DOI: 10.1016/j.foodhyd.2017.05.006
Reference: FOOHYD 3887
Please cite this article as: Kurek, M., Ščetar, M., Galić, K., Edible coatings minimize fat uptake in deep
fat fried products: A review, Food Hydrocolloids (2017), doi: 10.1016/j.foodhyd.2017.05.006.
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to
our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo
copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please
note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all
legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
1 Edible coatings minimize fat uptake in deep fat fried products:
2 a review
PT
6 10000 Zagreb, Croatia
RI
7
SC
9
10
11
U
AN
12
M
13 *corresponding author:
17 tel: +385 (0)1 4605 003, fax: + 385 (0)1 4836 083,
EP
18 E-mail: mkurek@pbf.hr
C
19
AC
20
21
22
23
24
25
1
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
26 Abstract
27 In the past decades, edible coatings are successful used as a tool to reduce the fat uptake in
28 deep fat fried food products. Significant interests is captured by the scientific society and the
29 food industry sector in order to find the adequate formulation design, film forming polymer
30 properties, components to improve adhesion and active properties. Hydrocolloid coatings can
PT
31 reduce the excessive oil uptake due to their interesting thermogelling properties and at the
RI
32 same time they are invisible and have no negative influence on the sensory attributes of fried
33 foodstuff. Even more, fried products have low fat content with improved nutritional values,
SC
34 higher crispiness and better palatability. This article emphasizes the importance of adequate
35 formulation design for a given product and its action mechanism. Different edible coating
36
U
materials and their effectiveness on fried food are reviewed. Food items, such as potatoes,
AN
37 meat, fruit and vegetables are covered. Synergistic action with other pre-treatment
M
38 technologies is also described. It is to expect that edible oil barrier coatings will become an
39 essential strategy for launching healthier fried products and therefore they might be
D
41
43
C
44
AC
45
46
47
48
49
50
2
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
51 1. INTRODUCTION
53 Edible films and coatings that can be directly consumed with the food are in the service of
54 modern food preserving systems given the changes in the lifestyle of consumers. Deep fat
55 frying takes a big part of food market and is still a culinary method widely used at the
PT
56 domestic, commercial and industrial level. Deep fried foods may be tasty, with improved
RI
57 appearance, aroma, flavour and texture (crispness); but the main problem is that after frying,
58 fried products may contain up to 50% of fat of the total product weight. Additionally, some of
SC
59 lipids were even not in the food before frying. Particularly, saturated fat and trans fat in deep
60 fried foods are key dietary contributor to the high incidence of cardiovascular diseases (high
61
U
cholesterol and heart disease) and higher risk for certain cancers and obesity (Hu, Manson, &
AN
62 Willett, 2001). Deep fried foods may also contain acrylamide, a potential procarcinogen
M
63 (Mesías, Holgado, Márquez-Ruiz, & Morales, 2017). All above mentioned marks these
64 products as definitely not good for human health. Customer’s awareness of healthy diet is
D
65 starting to weigh on customers’ choices and prompting latest research trends. Thus food
TE
66 technologists are continuously making efforts in order to find innovative solutions to decrease
68 Excellent reviews are published in the scientific literature describing the formation and
toxicity of acrylamide in fried products (Morales, Capuano, & Fogliano, 2008; Capuano &
C
69
AC
70 Fogliano, 2011; Medeiros, Mestdagh, & Meulenaer, 2012; Krishnakumar & Visvanathan,
71 2014; Riboldi, Vinhas, & Moreira, 2014; Luning et al., 2016; De Meulenaer et al., 2016).
72 According to authors, it is very likely that complete elimination of acrylamide from fried
73 products is difficult to achieve. In that case, the ALARA principle (as low as reasonably or
3
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
75 Absorption of oil is influenced by a variety of factors. These consider oil quality, frying
76 temperature, frying time, various pre-treatments and the food composition. Currently methods
77 that are proposed in order to reduce the fat absorption include modification of frying
78 techniques by monitoring of frying temperature and oil degradation (i.e. draining and shaking
79 of fried products) (Bouchon, Aguilera, & Pyle, 2003; Mellema, 2003; Math, Velu, Nagender,
PT
80 & Rao, 2004; Mah, Price, & Brannan, 2008), reducing the surface area exposed to oil
RI
81 (altering food surface) (Goni, Bravo, Larrauri, & Saura Calixto, 1997; Moreira & Barrufet,
82 1998) or using edible coatings as lipid barriers. Hydrocolloid edible coatings reduce the oil
SC
83 content of deep-fat-fried food either acting as a lipid barrier when formed as thin films and
84 dried before frying or by their gelation properties during heating (Kulp, 1990). Some of
85
U
commercially available coatings are Fry Shield™ - calcium pectinate that is aimed to reduce
AN
86 fat uptake during frying fish, potatoes, and other vegetables and Seal gum, Spray gum™ -
M
88 In this review, the focus is given on the literature overview of edible coatings currently used
D
89 for minimizing the oil uptake and their mechanism of action. Furthermore, examples of edible
TE
90 coatings applied on different food will be given in details in order to illustrate the possible
92
93
AC
94 An edible coating is defined as a thin layer of edible material, generally not exceeding 0.3
95 mm, applied to the food surface in addition to or as a substitution for natural protective
96 coatings (Embuscado & Huber, 2009). They can be used as thin coatings or as thicker batter
97 formulations. Edible coatings are generally classified according to the molecular structure of
98 film forming molecule. Hydrocolloids are mainly used for frying applications due to good
99 gelling attributes. Polysaccharides (cellulose derivate, corn starch, carrageenan, pectin, gums)
4
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
100 and proteins (egg white, gelatin, sodium caseinate, soy protein, wheat gluten, whey protein)
101 can be used as base components, alone or in a mixture. Functional components in the coating
102 contribute to a product’s added value and serve as a shield to control the diffusion of moisture
103 and fat in fried food. Plasticizers are important in design because they improve the flexibility
104 and handling, maintaining integrity and reducing number of pores and cracks in the polymeric
PT
105 matrix that can be formed during the coating process or during frying.
RI
106 Some proteins such as serumalbumin and ovalbumin; polysaccharides such as high methoxyl
107 pectin, acacia gum, high fructose corn syrup/dextrose/fructose/sucrose, gelatinized amylose,
SC
108 microcrystalline cellulose, xanthan gum and locust bean gum (Albert & Mittal, 2002) are less
109 intensive studied coating materials. This under-utilized agricultural commodities contribute to
110
U
interesting opportunities for creating new market outlets.
AN
111 Edible coatings are able to form a barrier to moisture, oxygen, ultraviolet light and solute
M
112 movement in the food (Guilbert, Gontard & Gorris, 1996). The fact that it’s edible is the best
113 proof of its harmless nature. They must also be acceptable to consumers maintaining the
D
114 original taste, texture, and product appearance and they should not be detectable to
TE
115 consumer’s tongue. Regarding deep fat fried products, the most important function of an
116 edible coating is that it resists to the absorption of oil and to the migration of water to and
EP
117 from the fried foodstuff. A great insight in the explanation of mechanism and reduction of fat
uptake is given by Mellema (2003) and Kim, Lim, Bae, Lee, & Lee (2011). The mechanism
C
118
AC
119 of oil uptake is associated with the heat transfer and the migration of oil droplets in the voids
120 leftover the evaporation of the water (Figure 2). Possible explanations rely on thermogelling,
121 crosslinking and changes of hydrophobicity. During frying process, in the first step water
122 escapes from the crust and in the second step the water in the core of the product migrates to
123 the crust. This results in formation of weakened crust with empty pores that are free to be
124 filled with the fat that migrates from frying medium. Unfortunately, this provides flavours and
5
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
125 fatty nutrients. The quantity of oils absorbed in food during frying depends on the initial
126 moisture content of the surface of frying food stuff, on its size and the shape. It is generally
127 recognized that oils are absorbed by water evaporation and by water condensation (Mellema,
128 2003). Accordingly, pre-drying of foods is a common way to reduce the fat uptake (Krokida,
129 Oreopoulou, Maroulis, & Marinos-Kouris, 2001). If the water losses are reduced, then the oil
PT
130 uptake is also reduced. Edible barrier coating makes protective layer by means of reducing
RI
131 loss of water and by changing the surface structure. During frying it can form more brittle and
132 stronger surface with fewer voids that prevents water and steam escape from the porous
SC
133 surface. Thereby adequate moisture within the sample is maintained and the surface
134 permeability is reduced so the water cannot be replaced by oil (Funami, Funami, Tawada, &
135
U
Nakao, 1999). In a non-coated products, during frying, water in the crust evaporates through
AN
136 the pores and is replaced by the oil resulting in an oil concentrated crust. Daraei Garmakhany,
M
137 Mirzaei, Nejad, & Maghsudlo (2008) stressed that the absorption of oil on the surface of the
138 fried product does not occur to 100% after deep-frying. The oil leftovers can enter into the
D
139 product when samples are removed from the frying medium. During the first 60 s of frying,
TE
140 fast and intensive evaporation of water from the product is due to higher magnitudes of
141 positive gage pressure that is formed inside the food for longer time in uncoated food (Lalam,
EP
142 Sandhu, Takhar, Thompson, & Alvarado, 2013). Additionally, coatings can protect the food
surface from the oil absorption by changing the surface hydrophobicity (Annapure, Singhal,
C
143
AC
144 & Kulkarni, 1999). If there is no adequate binding between polymer and food surface, then
145 punctures can be formed on a coated surface. This can lead to the higher oil uptake due to
146 high capillary forces (Moreira, Sun, & Chen, 1997). When the edible coating has a compact
147 structure, then less water will evaporate and less oil will be absorbed. Firmness of the food
148 surface can be increased by using thermogelling or crosslinking methods. In other words,
149 coated surface will have less wide punctures with low capillary pressures, so less moisture
6
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
150 will evaporate and the oil uptake will remain low. The main characteristic of thermal gelation
151 is the fact that hydrocolloid is in the solid state under the critical gelling temperature. This
152 means that when the food is coated and submerged in a hot frying oil, the migration of oil in
153 and water out from the product is stopped. This is due to the formation of reversible thermal
154 gel that captures water. In the literature, thermal gelling is described as the process that is
PT
155 caused by the dehydration of the polymer with heating (e.g. curdlan, globular proteins, methyl
RI
156 cellulose, starch, etc.) (Saha & Bhattacharya, 2010). This phenomenon is due to the
SC
158 interactions. In a protein matrices, heat leads to unfolding/expansion of native molecule and
159 then a posterior rearrangement into a network occurs (Saha & Bhattacharya, 2010). In order to
160
U
facilitate the understanding of mass and heat transfers during frying there are different
AN
161 mathematical models developed and they are well described in the scientific literature
M
162 (Williams, & Mittal, 1999; Bertolini Suárez, Campañone, Garcȋa, & Zaritzky, 2008).
163 Another important point to consider is the rate of heat transfer. During frying, two types of
D
164 heat transfer occur. First, from the frying medium to the food surface the heat is transferred
TE
165 due to convection and second, from the surface to the inner part of food due to conduction.
166 This transfer causes the formation of water vapour bubbles from the food surface upwards
EP
167 toward the top of the oils. If the heat transfer coefficients are reduced than less oil is sorbed in
the sample. Edible coatings are shown to contribute to a reduced heat transfer coefficients.
C
168
AC
169 Edible coatings should be easily applicable and good film forming materials, non-toxic,
170 biocompatible, transparent, and flexible; with good thickening and binding properties should
171 be produced. Additionally, oil barrier edible coatings could be used to this end, contributing to
172 tender, moist and soft core and uniform crispy crust while preserving visual and structural
173 qualities. Result is increased food palatability and decreased product wilting. The choice of
7
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
174 film forming material is related to its effects on quality attributes as well as effectiveness in
176 Apart from nutritive and sensorial benefits of edible coatings applied to deep fat fried food,
177 they could play essential role in hindering the formation of acrylamide. This substance
178 commonly formed during frying has been classified by the International Agency for Research
PT
179 on Cancer (IARC) (1994) as a probable human carcinogen. According to Zeng et al. (2010)
RI
180 alginic acid and pectin reduce over 50% of formed acrylamide in model systems. Only alginic
181 acid reduced fat up to 20% in fried potato strips, while carob gum, carrageenan,
SC
182 hydroxypropyl distarch phosphate, pectin and xanthan gum gave elevated values. Pectin was
183 efficient in snack systems. For positive outcomes, authors speculate that it is possible that
184
U
hydrocolloid coating interfere with the molecular interactions that occur during the formation
AN
185 of acrylamide, whereas, heat treatment provides kinetic energy for glucose and asparagine, as
M
187
D
189 Applying edible coating prior to frying has some technological challenges. In the first
190 preparation step, film forming components (polymer, plasticizers, emulsificators, and
EP
191 functional compounds) are always solubilized. Then, depending on the main polymer
characteristics, film forming solution can be either heated or not, it can be crosslinked or in
C
192
AC
193 the case of proteins it is common to adjust pH. Plasticizers are mostly added to the polymer
194 once that it has been completely solubilized. They are low molecular weight components that
195 increase the free volume between the polymer chains by reducing the number of active
196 centres available for rigid polymer–polymer contacts or macromolecular mobility of the
197 polymer. The effective plasticization is achieved if there is adequate compatibility between
198 plasticizer and polymer including polarity, hydrogen bonding, dielectric constant and
8
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
199 solubility parameters (Vieira, da Silva, dos Santos, & Beppu, 2011). Glycerol, polyethylene
200 glycol and sorbitol are most commonly used plasticizers for edible oil barrier coatings. Each
201 plasticizer could change the performance of the final coating so its activity mechanism must
202 be known. For example, Tavera-Quiroz, Urriza, Pinotti, & Bertola, (2012) found that sorbitol
203 was more compatible with methylcellulose than glycerol in reducing fat absorption of potato
PT
204 chips. Main methodologies used to coat the fried products include dipping and spraying. The
RI
205 choice affects thickness, texture, smoothness and applicability of a coating. Dipping include
206 samples submersion in a specific coating solution for exact time. After draining off the
SC
207 excessive liquid, food samples are subjected to the frying process. In the case of spraying, its
208 applicability depends on apparent viscosity of the film forming solutions, consistency
209
U
coefficient and the flow behaviour index. The spraying procedure is done as following: food
AN
210 samples are firstly placed on a rotating platform, sprayed using a commercial spray gun, dried
M
211 and fried. It can be repeated several times to ensure uniform coating on the food surface
212 (Figure 2). The main factors influencing the selection of the coating procedure are polymer
D
213 type and its concentration. It is preferable that coating material is hydrophilic and not
TE
214 hydrophobic because the later would most likely rupture during frying due to the evaporation
215 of water. Coatings that have high viscosity even at low concentrations (like gums) are much
EP
216 easily applicable than those with low viscosities where higher concentration is required (such
as proteins). In the later, thickeners (such as gums) can be added to increase the viscosity
C
217
AC
218 range. In order to create the effective, that is to say non porous barrier with low permeability,
219 the ubiquitous factors are the uniformity of a coating thickness, its flexibility and adherence to
220 the food product. To evaluate the effectiveness of edible coatings, it is needed to determine its
221 barrier properties with the accent on the moisture and fat contents in the surface layer and in
222 the interior core. The moisture content is determined by drying a sample to a constant weight
223 either in a convection oven or by freeze drying. The fat content of dried samples is usually
9
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
224 determined using the Soxhlet extraction method with hexane as the solvent. Less intensive
225 studied methods such as differential scanning calorimetry, confocal scanning laser
226 microscopy, magnetic resonance imaging, infrared imaging, and scanning electron
227 microscopy could also be used for the same purpose. Mostly, coatings are applied as a single
228 layer structures. However, double and triple-layer coatings are also technically feasible, but
PT
229 they are not recommended for some fried products such as chips or French fries neither for
RI
230 the ones that are expected to have a tender structure (Daraei Garmakhany, Mirzaei,
231 Maghsudlo, Kashaninejad, & Jafari, 2014). Another interesting approach is the use of blended
SC
232 formulations such as a protein/polysaccharide or crosslinked coatings. Whey protein/pectin
233 based blends were reported to reduce water loss with respect to the coated samples confirming
234
U
the ability of blend coating to act as an effective water barrier in doughnut and French fries
AN
235 (Rossi Marquez, Di Pierro, Esposito, & Porta, 2014). Crosslinking of starch based coatings
M
236 was shown to lower the disintegration of a starch granule that is predominant factor for the
237 reduction of the oil content. Wheat starches that were crosslinked to a different extent
D
238 enhanced the crispness perception of a deep-fried battered food (Preimo-Martín, 2012), while
TE
239 crosslinked tapioca starch based coating reduced the pickup and the oil absorption in chicken
241 The composition of food product and the porous character of the food surface are main factors
influencing the quantity of oil that is absorbed during frying (Pinthus, Weinberg, & Saguy,
C
242
AC
243 1992). Uniform layer on the food surface is a crucial in order to limit the mass transfers
244 during frying and to create a good oil barrier (Huse, Mallikarjunan, Chinnan, Hung, &
245 Phillips, 1998). Inadequate adhesion could result with a poor final appearance and it definitely
246 complicates product handling (Garcia, Ferrero, Bertola, & Zaritzky, 2004). The adhesion of
247 the coating is influenced by the surface properties and by the chemical similarity between the
248 coating solution and the surface (Hershko & Nussinovitch, 1998). If properly formed,
10
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
249 coatings can provide a high index value (reduction in fat uptake/decrease of water loss) with
250 reducing the fat uptake up to 99.8% (Albert & Mittal, 2002).
251
253 Polysaccharides are with proteins the most widely investigated biopolymers in the field of
PT
254 edible coatings. Polysaccharide based coatings are prepared with fully or partially water
RI
255 soluble, long chain biopolymers that exhibit unique colloidal properties and the ability to form
256 strong gels. In the reaction with multivalent cations such as CaCl2 they become insoluble, and
SC
257 provide excellent mechanical, structural, gas and oil barrier properties. However, their
258 moisture barrier remains very low. Polysaccharides used for edible coatings for frying can be
259
U
derived from plants (e.g. cellulose derivate, pectin and starch), seaweed extracts (e.g.
AN
260 carrageenan), and those secreted by bacteria (e.g. gellan gum) (Rojas-Graü, Soliva-Fortuny, &
M
261 Martín-Belloso, 2009). Examples of polysaccharide based edible coatings application for
262 reducing the oil uptake in different foodstuffs are given in Tables 1-3.
D
263
TE
265 Cellulose derivatives are polysaccharides composed of linear chains of β (1–4) glucosidic
EP
266 units with methyl, hydroxypropyl or carboxyl substituents. Only four cellulose derivate
possess good film forming properties so they are suitable for edible coatings including
C
267
AC
269 methylcellulose (HPMC), and methyl cellulose (MC) (Table 1). They are generally easily
270 available, odourless, tasteless, transparent, good oil barriers, water soluble, flexible, and
271 moderately water and gas permeable (Debeaufort, Voilley, & Meares, 1994; Krochta &
272 Mulder-Johnston, 1997). At the beginning of frying, cellulose coating forms a protective layer
273 due to thermally induced gelation above 60°C (Balasubramaniam, Chinnan, Mallikarjunan, &
11
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
274 Phillips, 1997). Then it delays and/or minimizes the transfer of moisture and fat from the
275 sample and in the frying medium without modifying neither texture characteristics nor
276 sensory properties. In the final product, nutritional qualities are improved and in addition they
278 Influence of CMC coating and its combination with other polymers on the quantity of the oil
PT
279 uptake and on the sensory attributes of potato (chips or French fries) is well reported in the
RI
280 scientific literature (Albert & Mittal, 2002; Garcia, Ferrero, Bertola, & Zaritzky, 2004; Daraei
SC
282 Maghsudlo, Kashaninejad, & Jafari, 2014; González, Alvis, & Arrázola, 2015). CMC
283 coatings are shown to be efficient in reducing the oil uptake by 21.2% without influencing the
284
U
sensory properties (21.2% and 50.4% for 1% w/v and 10% w/v coating, respectively) (Daraei
AN
285 Garmakhany,Mirzaei, Nejad, & Maghsudlo, 2008; Angor, 2016). Moisture loss during frying
M
286 decreased, and hence the oil uptake of potato products was reduced. Coating with CMC (1%
287 w/v) and pectin (1% w/v) mixture led to a higher decrease (70%) in fat content of fried potato
D
288 strips due to the synergistic effect of both hydrocolloids (Daraei Garmakhany, Mirzaei,
TE
289 Maghsudlo, Kashaninejad, & Jafari, 2014; Mirzaei, Salehi, Garoumi, & Farhadpour, 2015).
290 Interaction between protein and starch (amylose and amylopectin) is shown to be important
EP
291 for the quality and for the texture of the final product. Hence, pectin and CMC can react with
the elements in the cell wall (calcium) of potato and lead to a harder texture which requires a
C
292
AC
293 higher cutting force (Mirzaei, Salehi, Garoumi, & Farhadpour, 2015).
294 Methylcellulose coatings are shown to reduce the oil uptake from 35% (Garcia, Ferrero,
295 Bertola, & Zaritzky, 2004) to 99.8% (Albert & Mittal, 2002), depending on the fried product
296 (potato strips and cereal product, respectively). The efficiency of MC and CMC coatings can
297 be improved by the synergistic effect with the pre-frying treatments. Rimac-Brnčić, Lelas,
298 Rade, & Šimundić (2004) found that when potato strips were blanched in 0.5% CaCl2 solution
12
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
299 following the immersion in 1% (w/v) solution of CMC, the oil content was reduced up to 54%
300 in comparison to <30% in only blanched samples. In another study, Luvielmo, DeArmas,
301 Paiva, Krolow, & Ferri (2015) showed that when potato chips were blanched, immerged in
302 salt solutions and coated with MC, the fat absorption decreased for 13% and the sensory
303 acceptance was 85.9%. Similarly, Pahade & Sakhale (2012) observed that pre-treatment of
PT
304 French fries with 0.5% aqueous solution of CaCl2 in a combination with edible coating led to
RI
305 the better moisture retention and to the lower oil uptake in the following order
SC
307 Further, MC coatings were found to reduce the fat uptake in dough discs (around 40%)
308 (Garcia, Ferrero, Bertola, & Zaritzky, 2004) and chicken breasts (up to 14%) (Maskat et al.,
309
U
2005). MC and HPMC were also used for the traditional African food named akara, a product
AN
310 that is prepared from whipped cowpea paste (Huse, Mallikarjunan, Chinnan, Hung, &
M
311 Phillips, 1998). Compared to the control, edible coating on akara balls reduced the fat
312 absorption into the crust (up to 45.7% reduction) and into the core (55.2% reduction) for two
D
313 different applications, spraying and dipping technique, respectively. Increases in the oil
TE
314 content was correlated with the decreases in a moisture content, so the decrease in the oil
315 absorption was an indirect result of the removal of moisture by the edible coatings. Better
EP
316 barrier properties for dipped MC coatings was attributed to the increase in the film thickness
317
AC
318 One must not forget that the concentration and the thickness of the coating are both very
319 important parameters that must be considered when designing frying experiment. A too thin
320 film could favour too much loss of moisture and result in an inadequate resistance to the oil,
321 while a thick coating could lead to a rupture of the film from excessive pressure built up
323
13
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
324
325
326 4.2.Pectin
328 galacturonic acid residues, wherein the uronic acid carboxyls are either fully (high methoxy
PT
329 pectin) or partially (low methoxy pectin) methyl esterified. High methoxy pectin forms
RI
330 excellent films mostly of variably methylated galacturonan segments separated by rhamnose
331 residues, some of which may be linked to a short neutral sugar side chains (Perez Espitia et
SC
332 al., 2014). Pectin has been intensively used as edible coating for fresh cut fruits and
333 vegetables; however, in the case of reducing the oil uptake, only few investigations have been
334
U
reported. Some examples of pectin based edible coatings application for reducing the oil
AN
335 uptake in different foodstuffs are given in Table 2.
M
336 Albert and Mittal (2002) pointed out that pectin lowers the water loss but it did not essentially
337 reduce the fat uptake in a cereal product. Accordingly, pectin coating on cassava roots led to a
D
338 great retention of moisture during frying that was proportional to the increase in the coating
TE
339 concentration (Freitas et al., 2014). This indicates greater moisture retention by the thicker
340 films, despite to their proportional increase in the water vapour permeability. The smallest
EP
341 water loss in the pectin coated samples did not directly result in a smaller absorption of fat.
The reason could be due to a reduced film thickness or to a damage made to the coating
C
342
AC
344 On the contrary, when used on French fries, Daraei Garmakhany, Mirzaei, Maghsudlo,
345 Kashaninejad, & Jafari (2014) and Mahajan, Sonka, & Surendar (2014) reported that pectin
346 lead to the low oil uptake. The combination of CMC and pectins (0.5 and 1% w/w,
347 respectively) was used as one layer in a double coating, formed by guar and xanthan gums
348 (1% w/w), or in a three-multilayer coating with CMC (1% w/w) as the third layer. Reductions
14
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
349 in the oil absorption were observed in the fried food coated with multilayer systems, but the
350 high moisture content of the final products led to the decrease in the crunchiness and to the
352 Synergistic effect of a low-methoxyl sunflower head pectin (SFHP) and CaCl2 was also
353 reported (Hua, Wang, Yang, Kang, & Yang, 2015). Coatings prepared with 1% (w/v) pectins
PT
354 solutions induced by CaCl2 (< 0.1 mol·L−1) effectively decreased the lipid uptake of fried
RI
355 potato chips by about 30%. These authors also observed that the interaction between protein
356 and starch (amylose and amylopectin) is important for the quality, brittleness and crispiness of
SC
357 the final product. It was attributed to reaction of pectin and mixture of pectin and CMC with
358 the cell wall constituents of potato that led to a harder texture (Mirzaei, Salehi, Garoumi, &
361 example, Abdullah (2015) found that pectin coating on falfalel product could be applied only
363 Pectin was shown to be the most effective for preparing a low fat fried banana chips. .
TE
364 Besides, pectin treated chips had better organoleptic attributes and crunchiness than CMC
365 treated samples and reduced acrylamide content (around 33%) (Singthong, & Thongkaew,
EP
366 2009; Suyatma, Ulfah, Prangdimurti, & Ishikawa, 2015). In addition, higher reduction of
acrylamide in fried banana chips up to 91.9% was achieved due to a synergic effect of pectin
C
367
AC
368 and blanching treatments (Suyatma, Ulfah, Prangdimurti, & Ishikawa, 2015).
369
370 4.3.Starch
371 Starch is easily available, inexpensive natural polymer. It is a mixture of the predominantly
372 amylose and the highly branched, high molecular weight amylopectin. Amylose is a better
15
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
373 film forming component due to its linear nature. So, coating can be made from any type of
375 Angor (2014) found that the starch edible coating at different levels (from 1% to 5% w/v)
376 reduced fat absorption of potato pellet chips (up to 27%). Starch coatings at different levels
PT
378
RI
379 4.4.Carrageenans
380 Carrageenan is a complex mixture of at least five different water-soluble galactose polymers
SC
381 designated as λ, κ, ι, µ, and ν-carrageenan. Gelation of ι and κ-carrageenan occurs in the
382 presence of monovalent or divalent cations. In the first step a three-dimensional network is
383
U
formed by polysaccharide double helices during moderate drying and then after the solvent is
AN
384 evaporated a solid films remain (Karbowiak, Debeaufort, & Voilley, 2007). Some examples
M
385 of carrageenan based edible coatings application for reducing the oil uptake in different
387 Archana et al. (2016) used carrageenan based edible coating (1% Okra (Abelmoscus
TE
388 esculentus polysaccharide) and 1% Okra + carrageenan) for frying potato slices in sunflower
389 oil. A considerable reduction in fat uptake was observed. The combination of 1% Okra +
EP
390 carrageenan was shown to be better barrier in reducing the oil uptake during frying (45%).
Authors found that the gelatinization of potato starch happened in the control chips without
C
391
AC
392 carrageenan coating. Structure changes in the cell membranes and the cell walls were
393 attributed to the decrease in the firmness and to the loss of the texture in the control chips.
394 Albert & Mittal (2002) evaluated carrageenan/konjac flour blends since the pure carrageenan
395 was not heat stable. Authors observed that the oil uptake in a deep fat fried biscuit based
397
16
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
398 5. GUMS
400 Guar gum, a galactomannan obtained from the Indian cluster bean (Cyamopsis tetragonoloba
401 (L.) Taub), is a water soluble polysaccharide. The backbone of guar gum is a linear chain of β
402 1,4-linked mannose residues to which galactose residues are 1,6-linked at every second
PT
403 mannose, forming a short side-branches (Dea & Morrison, 1975).
RI
404 The application of a guar gum as a coating agents on the quantity of oil uptake and on sensory
405 attributes of potato is well investigated (Daraei Garmakhany,Mirzaei, Nejad, & Maghsudlo,
SC
406 2008; Daraei Garmakhany, Mirzaei, Maghsudlo, Kashaninejad, & Jafari, 2014; Kim, Lim,
407 Bae, Lee, & Lee, 2011; Pahade & Sakhale, 2012; Yu, Li, Ding, Hang, & Fan, 2016). Some
408
U
examples of application of gum based edible coatings for reducing the oil uptake in different
AN
409 foodstuffs are given in Table 3. Gum based coatings can enhance the barrier properties of
M
410 fried potato chips by lowering the formation of pores and cracks in the fried food. When the
411 polymer concentration is increased, more coating solution remains on the sample, so likewise
D
413 Kashaninejad, & Jafari, 2014; Izadi, Ojagh, Rahkmanifarah, Shabanpour, & Sakhale, 2015).
414 This might be linear but it is not a general rule. Coatings lead to a more pronounced and
EP
415 apparent changes in the heat transfer coefficients at higher concentration levels with a good
polynomial correlation. Then, a rapid heat transfer leads to an increase in the oil content of the
C
416
AC
417 fried products. Additionally, lower oil uptake was related to the reduction of the heat transfer
418 coefficients (Kim, Lim, Bae, Lee, & Lee, 2011). Izadi, Ojagh, Rahkmanifarah, Shabanpour, &
419 Sakhale (2015) found that there were no significant differences between CMC and guar gum
420 with similar concentrations in the coating pick-up in shrimps after deep fat frying. In addition,
421 the lightness of the samples was decreased by increasing the guar gum concentration, so the
422 darkest colour was observed in the coated shrimps with 1.5% guar gum solution. Sothornvit
17
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
423 (2011) found that the combination of guar gum (1.5% w/w) and the highest centrifugation
424 speed (280 rpm) reduced the oil absorption in vacuum fried banana chips (33.7%). Thus, a
426
PT
428 Tragacanth is a natural gum obtained from the dried sap of several species of Middle Eastern
RI
429 legumes (Ewans, 1989). Gum tragacanth is a less common in food products than other gums
430 that can be used for similar purposes, so the commercial cultivation of tragacanth plants has
SC
431 generally not seemed economically worthwhile in the West.
432 When used as a coating agent, tragacanth (2%) did not decrease the fat content of a fried
433
U
potato but it had a positive impact on the sensory properties (flavour, texture and colour)
AN
434 (Daraei Garmakhany,Mirzaei, Nejad, & Maghsudlo, 2008; Mirzaei, Salehi, Garoumi, &
M
435 Farhadpour, 2015). In another study, shrimp samples were coated with 1.5% tragacanth gum.
436 It was observed that samples had higher water content and less fat due to the good coating
D
437 pick-ups. Possible explanations were related to the high apparent viscosity of tragacanth
TE
438 coating or to its high adherence (Izadi, Ojagh, Rahkmanifarah, Shabanpour, & Sakhale,
439 2015).
EP
440
5.3. Xanthan
C
441
AC
443 of a pure Xanthomonas campestris culture. It is widely used in the food industry, mainly due
444 to the good film forming properties such as a highly viscous character even at low
445 concentrations and it has a high water binding capacity (Soares, Lima, Oliveira, Pires, &
18
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
447 Even though it is commonly used in the food formulations, so far, very little research was
448 done on the oil barrier edible coatings. Comparing with the cellulose derivatives, xanthan gum
449 had a lower impact on decreasing the oil uptake in French fries. Daraei Garmakhany,Mirzaei,
450 Nejad, & Maghsudlo (2008) found that 0.5% (w/v) xanthan coatings reduced the oil uptake in
451 potato chips by 24.8% and Pahade & Sakhale (2012) reported only a 6% reduction (for 1%
PT
452 (w/v) coating). The synergistic effect was observed in the combination with locust beam gum
RI
453 (ration 1:1, 0.35%). In this study, deep fat fried cereal products had 32% of fat less than
454 uncoated controls (Albert & Mittal, 2002). When coating banana slices, xanthan attributed to
SC
455 the reduction of the oil uptake by 17.2%, without influencing neither crispiness, colour,
456 flavour nor overall quality. This was a good indication of its suitability for use and of
460 Almond gum is a natural hydrocolloid produced by almond trunks, mainly composed of a
D
462 (Bouaziz et al., 2016). Its applications are limited and largely ignored. From our knowledge
463 only one work can be found in the scientific literature. Bouaziz et al. (2016) found that the
EP
464 almond gum based coating (2% w/v) decreased the oil uptake of potato chips by 34% and it
increased moisture by 29.5%. Additionally, colour, appearance, crispiness, taste, odour, and
C
465
AC
466 appetence were better in the coated than the uncoated potato chips, and the ones coated with
468
19
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
470 Basil seed gum (BSG) is a mixture of polysaccharides extracted from basil seed, mostly
471 glucomannan (43%) and (1 → 4)-linked xylan (24.29%), and a minor fraction, glucan (2.31%)
473 In a recent study, the effect of coatings made from novel hydrocolloid basil seed gum, salep
474 (plant), and a mixed solution of BSG and salep on the oil content in deep-fried potato strips
PT
475 was evaluated. In addition, the influence of the oil origin (canola or palm olein) was also
RI
476 screened (Karimi & Kenari, 2016). The most effective coating formulations were 0.5% (w/v)
477 BSG and 1.5% (w/v) salep. For these formulations, the maximum reduction was reported in
SC
478 potato strips (28.8% and 28.7% for BSG and salep, respectively) compared to the uncoated
479 samples. Consequently, the moisture content was increased for 29.1% and 17.5 %, for BSG
482 decreased the oil uptake and the moisture loss of fried shrimps by 34.5% and 13.9%,
483 respectively. However it is difficult to compare results since not the same food item was
D
484 tested.
TE
485
487 Protein based coatings can be made from various sources of protein, such as corn, milk, soy,
wheat and whey. When selecting protein for its use in edible films, as nowadays a
C
488
AC
489 considerable part of the population is allergic to a certain proteins, especially to the soy and
490 wheat, one must consider about its functionality but also about its GRAS
491 (Generally Recognized As Safe) status. Their major advantage is the physical stability and the
492 molecular structure that offers interesting sites for chemical interaction. This can allow the
493 improvement of a coating properties, its functionalization and tailoring. Some examples of
20
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
494 application of protein based edible coatings for reducing the oil uptake in different foodstuffs
496
498 Corn zein is a class of water insoluble prolamine proteins found in corn. Zein has excellent
PT
499 film forming properties; it is odourless, tasteless and can be used for fabrication of
RI
500 biodegradable films (Momany et al., 2005).
501 Several authors reported that corn zein reduced the fat uptake by 28% to 59% on mashed
SC
502 potato balls and potato cuts, respectively (Feeney, Haralampu, & Gross, 1993; Mallikarjunan,
503 Chinnan, Balasubramaniam, & Phillips, 1997). Zein edible coating was shown to be less
504
U
effective than MC but more effective than HPMC when applied on the mashed potato balls.
AN
505 Another example is the efficient reduction of fat uptake in a dish made from peeled beans
M
506 named akara (18%). The only reported failure in this study was the fact that fried product had
507 a crisp thick crust with a rough texture that is was acceptable in comparison to a shiny and a
D
508 smooth surface. The later gives a product a glazed appearance and can be obtained with a
TE
509 cellulose based coatings (Huse, Mallikarjunan, Chinnan, Hung, & Phillips, 1998)
510
EP
Soy protein is isolated from a soybean and it is made from a soybean meal that has been
C
512
AC
513 hulled and defatted. Edible coatings can be produced from a soy protein in either of two ways:
514 surface film formation on a heated soymilk or film formation from solutions of a soy protein
516 It was mentioned earlier in this review that SPI coatings (2%, 6%, 10% and 14% w/v) reduced
517 more fat than all CMC formulations in potato pellet chips (Angor, 2016). All tested coating
518 samples contributed to the better sensorial features of potato pellet chips compared to control.
21
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
519 The most effective treatment in reducing fat (18%) was 10% SPI. Similarly, Rayner, Ciolfi,
520 Maves, Stedman, & Mittal (2000) used SPI solutions (10% w/v) with gellan gum (0.05% w/v)
521 as a plasticizer. A significant fat reduction (55.12%) was observed with a positive impact on
522 the sensory attributes of the coated French fries. Additionally, no significant difference in the
523 texture was observed between the textures of coated (SPI with gellan gum) and uncoated fried
PT
524 samples.
RI
525 In another study, SPI was shown to be one of the best coating materials for the reduction of
526 fat during frying of cereal products. Multiple soy protein, MC and whey protein isolate mixed
SC
527 coatings provided the highest index value (reduction in fat uptake/decrease of water loss), and
528 reduced the fat uptake up to 99.8% (Albert & Mittal, 2002).
529
U
A high occurrence in allergic reactions is the reason that nowadays all the food allergens are
AN
530 eliminated from the sensitive patient diet. Soy allergy is one of the most common food
M
531 allergies, especially among babies and children. So it is to be expected that these coatings will
533
TE
535 Casein is a type of a milk protein with good thermoplastic and film forming properties. It has
EP
536 been extensively used in the food and pharmaceutical industry, in medical applications and as
edible coating (Rhim & Ng, 2007). It can form weak intermolecular interactions, i.e. in order
C
537
AC
538 to form a coherent matrix, partially denatured peptide chains bond together primarily through
539 hydrophilic and hydrogen bonds (Audic & Chaufer, 2005; Rhim & Ng, 2007).
540 In a recent study, sodium caseinate coating (from 6% to 8% w/v) was used as the oil barrier in
541 fried potatoes. (Perone, 2011). Tested films did not reduce the oil absorption during frying
542 process. Oil absorption is known to depend on several factors including coating formulation
543 and homogeneity of the coated surface. Thus it is the mostly probable that in this study there
22
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
544 was the need for further optimization of the coating formulation. Similarly, Albert & Mittal
545 (2002) reported that when cereal product was coated with sodium caseinate, in a first it
546 formed bubbles during frying and then it crumbled away. Thus, the casein coated samples had
547 even a higher fat content than the non-coated ones and are shown as not suitable coatings for a
PT
549 On the contrary, Aminlari, Ramezani, & Khalili (2005) found that potato chips coated with
RI
550 sodium caseinate had 14% less oil than control samples. In coated chips the water retention
551 and the protein content was significantly increased, and the peroxide value was decreased
SC
552 between 30% and 50%. Sensory evaluation showed that at all storage time intervals, flavour
553 of sodium caseinate coated chips were more acceptable than non-coated ones or those coated
557 Whey protein is a by-product from the cheese production. The potential of its two fractions
D
558 (α-Lactalbumin (α-LA) and β-Lactoglobulin (β-LG)) and whey protein isolate (WPI) has been
TE
559 intensively studied for the formation of edible films and coatings. In the last decade it
560 prompted a great interest because of its functional properties and industrial surplus (McHugh,
EP
561 Aujard, & Krochta, 1994; Kaya & Kaya, 2000; Fabra, Talens, & Chiralt, 2010).
Aminlari, Ramezani, & Khalili (2005) and Angor (2014) found that whey protein coatings led
C
562
AC
563 to a significantly lower oil uptake of potato chips. Coating based on whey protein concentrate
564 reduced the oil uptake for 5% (Aminlari, Ramezani, & Khalili, 2005). Furthermore, the results
565 showed that the addition of a sodium bisulphite in the blanching solution improved the
566 binding of proteins to potato slices. In another study, it was shown that the most effective
567 level for whey protein and WPI was around 5% (Angor, 2014). In addition, protein isolate
568 was shown to be more performant than whey protein for all levels. Also, in all coated samples
23
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
569 all sensorial features of potato pellets chips were improved. Contrarily, when 10% WPI was
570 used to coat chicken strips, no changes in the fat reduction could be observed (Dragich &
571 Krochta, 2010). The difference in results might be because of the difference in the food.
572 Freitas et al. (2014) described the positive synergistic effect on cassava purée fingers.
573
PT
574 7. Conclusion remarks
RI
575 In summary, all these results indicate that the use of edible coatings in pre-frying treatments is
576 a promising process to reduce the lipid uptake and additionally to reduce the acrylamide
SC
577 content in deep fat fried products. But really, how often do we eat a deep fat fried foods?
578 Actually, despite the awareness of low nutritive value of fried foodstuff, French fries are daily
579
U
consumed domestically, in the restaurants or even in the school cantina. The fast food
AN
580 industry is also aware of changing dietary demands. As potatoes are commonly fried food,
M
581 there are a number of studies performed on this food item. There is no magic formulation that
582 would be the winning solution for all kind of food. So, even though efforts are made in order
D
583 to investigate the impact of edible coatings on other food items than potato, there is still a gap
TE
584 in the reported results. The frying system (characteristics of food, frying procedure, i.e.
585 temperature, time, oil) must be well known in order to reduce the oil uptake optimally in final
EP
586 product. However, the positive impact of edible coating is more than evident. These
challenges are looking forward to improve customer satisfaction with better quality products.
C
587
AC
588 In recent years, consumers have become more concerned about what they eat, so the edible
589 packaging become one vector of innovation for food product development. Foods are sources
590 of nutritive compounds and are designed to meet the biological needs. Edible coatings are
591 very popular within consumers and serves as a tool for adding value to a final product. It is to
592 expect that they will become an essential strategy for launching healthier fried products and
24
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
593 their differentiation for market competition and therefore they might be interesting for
595 National regulatory bodies specify safe levels of the substances that could be added into food.
596 Safety requirements are of global significance along the whole food production chain.
PT
598 particularly on the individual components, coatings applied to food need to be properly
RI
599 declared. Such materials in any case should not have a negative impact on human health and
600 must be approved by the official institutions for food safety and materials in contact with
SC
601 food, such as the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) or The Food and Drug
603
U
Nowadays, fried food has become very popular especially among young people. However it is
AN
604 often considered as a junk food. Nutritionists are making strong efforts in raising awareness of
M
605 the unhealthy saturated fat and trans fat that are formed in the deep fat fried products. Thus,
606 all the methods, including edible coatings that could decrease the final unhealthy composition
D
607 of these kind of products are welcome. As it can be seen from this review edible coatings are
TE
608 not a novelty. However there is still a space in finding an active/functional composition that
609 will contribute to a development of new and healthy fried snacks. Would it be the
EP
610 incorporation of functional compounds that will decrease the impact of saturated fats and
prevent the oxidation (like bran or vitamins) or a kind of completely new edible polymer it is
C
611
AC
612 yet to see? In addition, there is quite scarce literature data on the effects of this kind of edible
614 are popular subject in the past decade. There is definitely a potential of nanoreinforced edible
615 coatings with functional compounds with the aim of reducing oil uptake. We suspect that in
616 the future, more studies will focus on this problem. One thing is for sure, as the market of
25
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
617 low-fat foods grow, the research must be continuously made from a more scientific point of
618 view in the serve of both consumer’s health and a fast food industry.
619
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
C EP
AC
26
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
620 References
621 Abdullah, T. (2015). Reduction of oil uptake in deep fat fried falafel. Journal of Nutritional
623 Abtahi, M.S., Hosseini, H., Fadavi, A., Mirzaei, H., & Rahbari, M. (2016). The optimization
624 of the deep-fat frying process of coated zucchini pieces by response surface methodology.
PT
625 Journal of Culinary Science & Technology, 14(2), 176-189.
RI
626 Akdeniz, N., Sahin, S., & Sumnu, G. (2006). Functionality of batters containing different
627 gums for deep-fat frying of carrot slices. Journal of Food Engineering, 75, 522–526.
SC
628 Albert, S., & Mittal, G.S. (2002). Comparative evaluation of edible coatings to reduce fat
629 uptake in a deep-fried cereal product. Food Research International, 35, 445–458.
630
U
Aminlari, M., Ramezani R., & Khalili M. H. (2005). Production of protein-coated low-fat
AN
631 potato chips. Food Science and Techology International, 11(3), 177–181.
M
632 Angor, M.M., Radwan, A., Al-Rousan, W., & Al-Abdullah, B. (2013). Effect of starchy
633 coating films on the reduction of fat uptake in deep-fat fried potato pellet chips. Italian
D
635 Angor, M.M. (2014). Application of whey protein and whey protein isolate as edible coating
636 films on potato pellets chips to reduce oil uptake during deep frying. Contemporing
EP
Angor, M.M. (2016). Reducing fat content of fried potato pellet chips using carboxymethyl
C
638
AC
639 cellulose and soy protein isolate solutions as coating films. Journal of Agricultural Science,
641 Annapure, U.S., Singhal, R.S., & Kulkarni, P.R. (1999). Screening of hydrocolloids for
642 reduction in oil uptake of a model deep fat fried product. Fett/Lipid, 101(6), 217–221.
643 Archana, G., Babu, P.A.S., Sudharsan, K., Sabina, K., Palpandi Raja, R., Sivarajan, M., &
644 Sukumar, M. (2016). Evaluation of fat uptake of polysaccharide coatings on deep-fat fried
27
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
645 potato chips by confocal laser scanning microscopy. International Journal of Food
647 Audic, J. L., & Chaufer, B. (2005). Influence of plasticizers and crosslinking on the properties
648 of biodegradable films made from sodium caseinate. European Polymer Journal, 41, 1934–
649 1942.
PT
650 Balasubramaniam, V.M., Chinnan, M.S., Mallikarjunan, P., & Phillips, R.D. (1996). Battered,
RI
651 and breaded chicken patties using whey protein isolate as a postbreading dip: effect on lipid
SC
653 Balasubramaniam, V.M., Chinnan, M.S., Mallikarjunan, P., & Phillips, R.D. (1997). The
654 effect of edible film on oil uptake and moisture retention of a deep-fat fried poultry product.
655
U
Journal of Food Processing and Engineering, 20, 17-29.
AN
656 Bertolini Sua´rez, R., Campan˜one, L.A., Garcı´a, M.A., & Zaritzky, N.E. (2008).
M
657 Comparison of the deep frying process in coated and uncoated dough systems. Journal of
659 Bouaziz, F., Koubaa, M., Neifar, M., Zouari-Ellouzi, S., Besbes, S., Chaari, F., Kamoun, A.,
TE
660 Chaanouni, M., Ellouz Chaabouni, S., Chaabouni, S., & Ellouz Ghorbel, R. (2016).
661 Feasibility of using almond gum as coating agent to improve the quality of fried potato chips:
EP
662 Evaluation of sensorial properties. LWT - Food Science and Technology, 65, 800-807.
Bouchon, P., Aguilera, J.M., & Pyle, D.L. (2003). Structure oil–absorption relationships
C
663
AC
665 Burey, P., Bhandari, B.R., Howes, T., & Gidley, M.J. (2008). Hydrocolloid gel particles:
666 formation, characterization, and application. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition,
28
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
668 Capuano, E., & Fogliano, V. (2011). Acrylamide and 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF): A
669 review on metabolism, toxicity, occurrence in food and mitigation strategies. Food Science
671 Daraei Garmakhany, A., Mirzaei, H. O., Maghsudlo, Y., Kashaninejad, M., & Jafari, S.M.
672 (2014). Production of low fat french-fries with single and multi-layer hydrocolloid coatings.
PT
673 Journal of Food Science and Technology, 51(7), 1334–1341.
RI
674 Daraei Garmakhany, A., Mirzaei, H.O., Nejad, M.K., & Maghsudlo, Y. (2008). Study of oil
675 uptake and some quality attributes of potato chips affected by hydrocolloids. European
SC
676 Journal of Lipid Science and Technology, 110, 1045–1049.
677 Dea, I.C.M., & Morrison, A. (1975). Chemistry and interaction of seed galactoman-nans.
678
U
Advanced Carbohydrate Chemistry and Biochemistry, 31, 241.
AN
679 Debeaufort, F., Voilley, A., & Meares, P. (1994). Water vapor permeability and diffusivity
M
680 through methylcellulose edible films. Journal of Membrane Science, 91(1), 125-133.
681 Dilek, M., Polat, H., Kezer, F., & Korcan, E. (2011). Application of locust bean gum edibe
D
682 coating to extend shelf life of sausages and garlic-flavored sausage. Journal of Food
TE
684 Dragich, A.M., & Krochta, J.M. (2010). Whey protein solution coating for fat-uptake
EP
685 reduction in deep-fried chicken breast strips. Journal of Food Science, 75, 43-47.
Embuscado M.E., & Huber, C.E. (2009). Edible films and coatings for food application.
C
686
AC
688 Ewans, W.C. (1989). Treas and Evans Pharmacognosy. (13th ed.). London, ELBS.
689 Fabra, M.J., Talens, P., & Chiralt, A. (2010). Water sorption isotherms and phase transitions
690 of sodium caseinate–lipid films as affected by lipid interactions. Food Hydrocolloids, 24,
691 384–391.
29
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
692 Feeney, R.D., Haralampu, S.G., & Gross, A.T. (1993). Potato and other food products coated
694 Funami, T., Funami, M., Tawada, T., & Nakao, Y. (1999). Decreasing oil uptake of
695 doughnuts during deep-fat frying using curdlan. Journal of Food Science, 64(5), 8883-8888.
696 Freitas, G.C.D., Berbari, S.A.G., Prati, P., Fakhouri, F.M., Queiroz, F.P.C., & Vicente, E.
PT
697 (2009). Reducing of fat uptake in cassava product during deep-fat frying. Journal of Food
RI
698 Engineering, 94, 390–394.
699 Gamonpilas, C., Pongjaruvat, W., Methacanon, P., Seetapan, N., Fuongfuchat, A., &
SC
700 Klaikherd, A. (2013). Effects of cross-linked tapioca starches on batter viscosity and oil
701 absorption in deep-fried breaded chicken strips. Journal of Food Engineering, 114, 262–268.
702
U
Garcia, M.A., Ferrero, C., Bertola, N.C., & Zaritzky, N.E. (2004) Methylcellulose coatings
AN
703 applied to reduce oil uptake in fried products. Food Science and Technology International,
M
705 Gennadios, A., McHugh, T. H., Weller, C. L. & Krochta, J. M. (1994). Edible coating and
D
706 films based on protein. In Krochta, J. M., Balwin, E. A. & Niperos-Carriedo, M.O. (Eds.),
TE
707 Edible coatings and films to improve food quality (pp. 201-277). Lancaster. Basel: Technomic
708 Publishing.
EP
709 Goni, I., Bravo, L., Larrauri, J.A., & Saura Calixto, F. (1997). Resistant starch in potatoes
710
AC
711 González, A., Alvis, A., & Arrázola, G. (2015). Effect of edible coating on the properties of
712 sweet potato slices (Ipomoea Batatas Lam) cooked by deep-fat frying. Part 1: Texture.
714 Guilbert, S., Gontard, N., & Gorris, L.G.M. (1996). Prolongation of the shelf-life of
715 perishable food products using biodegradable films and coatings. Food Science and
30
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
717 Hershko, V. & Nussinovitch, A. (1998). Relationship between hydrocolloid coating and
718 mushroom structure. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 46(8), 2988-2997.
719 Holownia, K.I., Chinnan, M.S., Erickson, M.C., & Mallikarjunan, P. (2000). Quality
720 evaluation of edible film-coated chicken strips and frying oils. Journal of Food Science,
PT
722 Hosseini-Parvar, S.H., Mortazavi, S.A., Razavi, S.M.A., Matia-Merino, L., & Goh, K.K.T.
RI
723 (2010). Steady shear flow behavior of gum extracted from basil seed gum (Ocimum basilicum
724 L.): effect of concentration and temperature. Journal of Food Engineering, 101, 236–243.
SC
725 Hu, F.B., Manson, J.E., & Willett, W.C. (2001). Types of dietary fat and risk of coronary
726 heart disease: A critical review. Journal of the American College of Nutrition, 20(1), 5-19.
727
U
Hua, X., Wang, K., Yang, R., Kang, J., & Yang, H. (2015). Edible coatings from sunflower
AN
728 head pectin to reduce lipid uptake in fried potato chips. Food Science and Technology, 62,
M
729 1220-1225.
730 Huse, H.L., Mallikarjunan, P., Chinnan, M.S., Hung, Y.-C., & Phillips, R.D. (1998). Edible
D
731 coatings for reducing oil uptake in production of akara (Deep fat frying of cowpea paste).
TE
733 IARC (1994). Some industrial chemicals (Vol. 60, p. 398). International Agency for Research
EP
734 on Cancer.
Izadi, S., Ojagh, M., Rahkmanifarah, K, Shabanpour, B., & Sakhale, B.K. (2015). Production
C
735
AC
736 of low-fat shrimps by using hydrocolloid coatings. Journal of Food Science and Technology,
738 Karbowiak, T., Debeaufort, F., & Voilley, A. (2007). Influence of thermal process on
739 structure and functional properties of emulsion-based edible films. Food Hydrocolloids, 21(5–
31
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
741 Karimi, N., & Kenari, R.E. (2016). Functionality of coatings with salep and basil seed gum
742 for deep fried potato strips. Journal of American Oil Chemistry Society, 93, 243–250.
743 Kaya, S., & Kaya, M. (2000). Microwave drying effect on properties of whey protein isolate
745 Khazaei, N., Esmaiili, M., & Emam-Djomeh, Z. (2016). Application of active edible coatings
PT
746 made from basil seed gum and thymol for quality maintenance of shrimp during cold storage.
RI
747 Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, doi: 10.1002/jsfa.7984.
748 Kim, D.N., Lim, J., Bae, I.Y., Lee, H.G., & Lee, S. (2011). Effect of hydrocolloid coatings on
SC
749 the heat transfer and oil uptake during frying of potato strips. Journal of Food Engineering,
751
U
Kramer, M.E. (2009). Structure and function of starch-based edible films and coatings. In
AN
752 Embuscado, M.E., & Huber, K.C. (Eds.), Edible films and coatings for food application (pp.
M
754 Krishnakumar, T., & Visvanathan, R. (2014). Acrylamide in food products: A review. Journal
D
756 Krochta, J.M. & Mulder-Johnston, C.D. (1997). Edible and biodegradable polymer films:
758 Krokida, M.K., Oreopoulou,V., & Maroulis, Z.B. (2000). Water loss and oil uptake as a
759
AC
760 Krokida, M. K., Oreopoulou, V., Maroulis, Z. B., & Marinos-Kouris, D. (2001). Effect of pre-
761 drying on quality of French fries. Journal of Food Engineering, 49, 347–354.
762 Kulp, K. (1990). Batters and breadings in Food processing. American Association of Cereal
763 Chemists.
32
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
764 Lalam, S., Sandhu, J.S., Takhar, P.S., Thompson, L.D., & Alvarado, C. (2013). Experimental
765 study on transport mechanisms during deep fat frying of chicken Nuggets. LWT - Food
767 Luvielmo, M.M., DeArmas, D.s., Paiva, F.F., Krolow, A.C.R., & Ferri, N.M.L. (2015).
768 Physicochemical and sensory characteristics of potato chips made from blanched potatoes of
PT
769 the cultivar BRS Ana and coated with methylcellulose. Brasilian Journal of Food
RI
770 Technology, 18(3), 211-219.
771 Mah, E., Price, J., & Brannan, R.G. (2008). Reduction of oil absorption in deep-fried,
SC
772 battered, and breaded chicken patties using whey protein isolate as a postbreading dip: effect
773 on lipid and moisture content. Journal of Food Science, 73(8), 412-417.
774
U
Mahajan, I., Sonka, C., & Surendar, J. (2014). Study on the effective reduction of oil up-take
AN
775 by the application of edible hydrocolloid coatings on French fries. International Journal of
M
777 Mallikarjunan, P., Chinnan, M.S., Balasubramaniam, V.M., & Phillips, R.D. (1997). Edible
D
778 coatings for deep-fat frying of starchy products. Lebensm.-Wiss. u.-Technology, 30, 709–714.
TE
779 Maskat, M.Y., Yip, H.H., & Mahali, H.M. (2005). The performance of a methyl cellulose-
780 treated coating during the frying of a poultry product. International Journal of Food Science
EP
Math, R.G., Velu, V., Nagender, A., & Rao, D.G. (2004). Effect of frying conditions on
C
782
AC
783 moisture, fat, and density of papad. Journal of Food Engineering, 64(4), 429–434.
784 McHugh, T.H., Aujard, J.-F., & Krochta, J.M. (1994). Plasticized whey protein edible films:
785 water vapor permeability properties. Journal of Food Science, 59, 416–419.
786 Medeiros, V.R., Mestdagh, F., & De Meulenaer, B. (2012). Acrylamide formation in fried
787 potato products - Present and future, a critical review on mitigation strategies. Food
33
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
789 Mellema, M. (2003). Mechanism and reduction of fat uptake in deep-fat fried foods. Trends in
791 Mesías, M., Holgado, F., Márquez-Ruiz, G., & Morales, F.J. (2017). Impact of the
792 characteristics of fresh potatoes available in-retail on exposure to acrylamide: Case study for
PT
794 Mirzaei, H.O. Salehi, F., Garoumi, H., & Farhadpour, F. (2015). Role of MC compounds at
RI
795 less of oil absorption of French fries potato. Journal of Nutritional Health and Food
SC
797 Momany, F.A., Sessa, D.J., Lawton, J.C., Selling, G.W., Hamaker, S.A.H., & Willett, J.L.
798 (2005). Structural Characterization of α-Zein. Journal of Agricultural Food Chemistry, 54(2),
799 543-547.
U
AN
800 Morales, F., Capuano, E., & Fogliano, V. (2008). Mitigation strategies to reduce acrylamide
M
801 formation in fried potato products. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1126, 89–
802 100.
D
803 Moreira, R.G., & Barrufet, M.A. (1998). A new approach to describe oil absorption in fried
TE
805 Moreira, R. G., Sun, X. Z., & Chen, Y. H. (1997). Factors affecting oil uptake in tortilla chips
EP
Nishinari, K., & Zhang, H. (2004). Recent advances in the understanding of heat set gelling
C
807
AC
809 Pahade, P.K, & Sakhale, B.K. (2012). Effect of blanching and coating with hydrocolloids on
810 reduction of oil uptake in French fries. International Food Research Journal, 19(2), 697-699.
811 Pérez Espitia, P.J., Du, W.X., Avena-Bustillos, R.J., Ferreira Soares, N.F., & McHugh, T.H.
812 (2014). Edible films from pectin: Physical-mechanical and antimicrobial properties - A
34
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
814 Perone, N. (2011). Role of constituents on structure and properties of polysaccharides proteins
815 edible films. Doctoral thesis. Univerista degli studi di Napoli Federico II.
816 Pinthus, E.J., Weinberg, P., & Saguy, I.S. (1992). Gel-strength in restructured potato products
817 affects oil uptake during deep-fat frying. Journal of Food Science, 57, 1359-1360.
818 Primo-Martín, C. (2012). Cross-linking of wheat starch improves the crispness of deep-fried
PT
819 battered food. Food Hydrocolloids, 28, 53-58.
RI
820 Rayner, M., Ciolfi, V., Maves, B., Stedman, P., & Mittal, G.S. (2000). Development and
821 application of soy-protein films to reduce fat intake in deep-fried foods. Journal of Science of
SC
822 Food and Agriculture, 80, 777-782.
823 Rhim, J.W., & Ng, O.K.W. (2007). Natural biopolymer-based nanocomposite films for
824
U
packaging applications. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 47(4), 411–433.
AN
825 Riboldi, B.P., Vinhas, Á.M., & Moreira, J.D. (2014). Risks of dietary acrylamide exposure: A
M
827 Rimac-Brnčić, S., Lelas, V., Rade, D., & Šimundić, B. (2004). Decreasing of oil absorption in
D
828 potato strips during deep fat frying. Journal of Food Engineering, 64, 237–241.
TE
829 Rojas-Graü, M.A., Soliva-Fortuny, R., & Martín-Belloso, O. (2009). Edible coatings to
830 incorporate active ingredients to fresh-cut fruits: a review. Trends in Food Science and
EP
Rossi Marquez, G., Di Pierro, P., Esposito, M., Porta, R. (2014). Application of
C
832
AC
833 transglutaminase-crosslinked whey protein/pectin films as water barrier coatings in fried and
835 Saha, D., & Bhattacharya, S. (2010). Hydrocolloids as thickening and gelling agents in food:
836 a critical review. Journal of Food Science and Technology, 47(6), 587–597.
837 Singthong, J., & Thongkaew, C. (2009). Using hydrocolloids to decrease oil absorption in
35
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
839 Soares, R.M.D., Lima, A.M.F., Oliveira, R.V.B., Pires, A.T.N., & Soldi, V. (2005). Thermal
840 degradation of biodegradable edible films based on xanthan and starches from different
842 Sothornvit, R. (2011). Edible coating and post-frying centrifuge step effect on quality of
PT
844 Suyatma, N.E., Ulfah, K., Prangdimurti, E., & Ishikawa, Y. (2015). Effect of blanching and
RI
845 pectin coating as pre-frying treatments to reduce acrylamide formation in banana chips.
SC
847 Tavera-Quiroz, M.J., Urriza, M., Pinotti, A., & Bertola, N. (2012). Plasticized methylcellulose
848 coating for reducing oil uptake in potato chips. Journal of Science and Food Agriculture, 92,
849 1346–1353.
U
AN
850 Varela, P., & Fiszman, S.M. (2011). Hydrocolloids in fried foods. A review. Food
M
852 Vieira, M.G.A., da Silva, M.A., dos Santos, L.O., & Beppu, M.M. (2011). Natural-based
D
853 plasticizers and biopolymer films: A review. European Polymer Journal, 47, 254–263.
TE
854 Yu, L., Li, Y., Ding, S., Hang, F., & Fan, L. (2016). Effect of guar gum with glycerol coating
855 on the properties and oil absorption of fried potato chips. Food Hydrocolloids (Part A), 211-
EP
856 219.
Williams, R. & Mittal, G.S. (1999). Water and fat transfer properties of polysaccharide films
C
857
AC
859 Zeng, X., Cheng, KW, Du, Y., Kong, R., Lo, C., Chu, I.K., Chen, F., & Wang, M. (2010).
860 Activities of hydrocolloids as inhibitors of acrylamide formation in model systems and fried
862
863
36
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
864
865
866
867 Table 1. Application of edible coatings from cellulose derivates for reducing oil uptake in
PT
869 PEG – polyethylene glycol
RI
Reduction
Concentration
COATING Plasticizer in oil Food References
SC
(%)
uptake (%)
Mallikarjunan,
U Chinnan,
AN
Potato
2 PEG 61.4 Balasubramani
balls
M
1997
Hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC)
Huse,
TE
Mallikarjunan,
Hung, &
C
Phillips, 1998
AC
Holownia,
Chinnan,
Chicken
1; 3 no 5 Erickson, &
strips
Mallikarjunan,
2000
37
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
strips Sakhale, 2012
Balasubramani
am, Chinnan,
Chicken
2 PEG 84 Mallikarjunan,
balls
& Phillips,
PT
1996
RI
Hydroxypropyl Williams &
1.5; 2 no 51 Pastry mix
cellulose (HPC) Mittal, 1999
SC
Daraei
Garmakhany,
U Mirzaei,
AN
1 no 21.2 Potato
Nejad, &
M
Maghsudlo,
2008
D
Carboxymethylcellulose (CMC)
Daraei
TE
Garmakhany,
Mirzaei,
EP
Maghsudlo,
AC
2008
Rimac-Brnčić,
2004
38
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
pellet
chips
Izadi, Ojagh,
Rahkmanifara
PT
Shabanpour, &
RI
Sakhale, 2015
Abtahi,
SC
Hosseini,
U Mirzaei, &
AN
Rahbari, 2016
M
Daraei
Garmakhany,
D
Potato Mirzaei,
TE
0.5; 1 no 56.7-65.1
slices Maghsudlo,
Kashaninejad,
EP
Daraei
AC
Garmakhany,
CMC + pectin ; 2
Potato Mirzaei,
layer: guar + 1 (1-1-1) no 70-76
slices Maghsudlo,
xanthan
Kashaninejad,
ose
(M
lce
39
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
balls Chinnan,
Balasubramani
1997
Garcia,
PT
Potato Ferrero,
1 Sorbitol 35-40
RI
strips Bertola, &
Zaritzky, 2004
SC
Garcia,
Dough Ferrero,
U
1 Sorbitol 35-40
disc Bertola, &
AN
Zaritzky, 2004
M
Williams &
3 no 91 Pastry mix
Mittal, 1999
D
Mallikarjunan,
TE
Chinnan,
Potato
2 PEG 83.6 Balasubramani
EP
balls
am, & Phillips,
C
1997
AC
Mirzaei,
Salehi,
1 no 40.6 Potato
Garoumi, &
Farhadpour,
40
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
2015
Tavera-
Bertola, 2012
PT
Luvielmo,
RI
Potato DeArmas,
1; 2 Glycerol 13.4
chips Paiva, Krolow,
SC
& Ferri, 2015
Holownia,
U Chinnan,
AN
Not Chicken
1; 3 no Erickson, &
suitable strips
M
Mallikarjunan,
2000
D
Hua, Wang,
TE
Potato
3 no 30 Yang, Kang, &
chips
Yang, 2015
EP
870
871
872
41
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
873 Table 2. Application of edible coatings from polysaccharides other than cellulose derivate for
Reduction
Concentration
COATING Plasticizer in oil Food References
PT
(%)
uptake (%)
RI
Angor,
SC
Corn starch 1; 2; 3; 4; 5 Glycerol 44.3 pellet Rousan, Al-
chips Abdullah,
U 2013
AN
k carrageenan- Glycerine, Cereal Albert &
1; 2 54
M
Potato Archana et
D
Okra 1 Glycerol 45
chips al., 2016
TE
Daraei
Garmakhany,
Pectin
Potato Mirzaei,
0.5; 1 no 47-63
slices Maghsudlo,
Kashaninejad,
& Jafari,
42
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
2014
Pectin (low-
Hua, Wang,
methoxyl Potato
1 no 30 Yang, Kang,
sunflower head chips
& Yang, 2015
pectin)
PT
Karimi &
Salep 1,5 no 29 Shrimps
RI
Kenari, 2016
876
SC
877 Table 3. Application of edible coatings from gums for reducing oil uptake in deep fat fried
878 products
U Reduction
AN
Concentration
COATING Plasticizer in oil Food References
(%)
M
uptake (%)
Almond Potato
D
1999
AC
43
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Cereal Albert & Mittal,
2 no 55
products 2002
Daraei
Garmakhany,Mirzaei,
0.3 no 22.4 Potato
Nejad, & Maghsudlo,
PT
2008
RI
Daraei
Garmakhany,Mirzaei,
SC
0.5 no 33.2 Potato
Nejad, & Maghsudlo,
2008
U Izadi, Ojagh,
AN
Rahkmanifarah,
0.5; 1; 1.5 no 12.4-16.5 Shrimps
M
Shabanpour, &
Guar gum
Sakhale, 2015
D
0.3 no 11.8
strips & Lee, 2011
0.6 no 10.3
strips & Lee, 2011
C
44
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
chips & Fan, 2016
Banana
1.5 no 25.2 Sothornvit, 2011
chips
PT
Daraei Garmakhany,
RI
Potato Mirzaei, Maghsudlo,
0.3; 0.5; 1 no 57.5-60.2
slices Kashaninejad, &
SC
Jafari, 2014
Deep fried
U
Albert & Mittal,
0.35-0.7 no 32 cereal
AN
Locust 2002
products
beam gum
M
Daraei
TE
Garmakhany,Mirzaei,
2 no 41.7 Potato
Nejad, & Maghsudlo,
EP
2008
C
Daraei
Tragacanth
AC
Garmakhany,Mirzaei,
1 no 26.7 Potato
Nejad, & Maghsudlo,
2008
Izadi, Ojagh,
Shabanpour, &
45
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Sakhale, 2015
Daraei
Garmakhany,Mirzaei,
0,5 no 21.7 Potato
Nejad, & Maghsudlo,
2008
PT
Daraei
RI
Garmakhany,Mirzaei,
1 no 24.8 Potato
Nejad, & Maghsudlo,
SC
2008
Xanthan
Banana
U
1,5 no 17 Sothornvit, 2011
chips
AN
Potato Pahade & Sakhale,
1 no 6.1
M
strips 2012
Daraei Garmakhany,
D
Jafari, 2014
EP
Izadi, Ojagh,
C
Rahkmanifarah,
Zedo gum 0,5;1;1,5 no 53-55 Shrimps
AC
Shabanpour, &
Sakhale, 2015
879
880 Table 4. Application of edible coatings from proteins for reducing oil uptake in deep fat fried
881 products
46
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
(%) oil uptake
(%)
Aminlari,
Khalili, 2005
PT
Cereal Albert &
Gelatine 5; 20 Glycerin Not suitable
RI
products Mittal, 2002
SC
3; 5; 7; 10; 15 Glycerin 16
products Mittal, 2002
Sodium Aminlari,
caseinate 3 no
U 14 Potato chips Ramezani, &
AN
Khalili, 2005
M
10 no 51
products Mittal, 2002
TE
Potato pellet
2; 6; 10; 14 Glycerin 54.4 Angor, 2016
Soy protein chips
EP
Ciolfi,
Glycerin,
AC
Mittal, 2000
Deep fried
Wheat Albert &
15 no 48 cereal
gluten Mittal, 2002
products
47
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Potato pellet
1; 3; 5; 7 Glycerin 49.9 Angor, 2014
chips
Whey
Deep fried
protein Albert &
10 no 54 cereal
isolate Mittal, 2002
products
PT
(WPI)
Potato pellet
1; 3; 5; 7 Glycerol 54.4 Angor, 2014
RI
chips
Whey Aminlari,
SC
protein 3 no 5 Potato chips Ramezani, &
882
U
AN
883
M
D
TE
C EP
AC
48
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
1 Figure captions
2 Figure 1. Scheme showing the mechanism of oil reduction in deep fat fried food.
3 Figure 2. Scheme showing the use of edible coating in deep fat frying.
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
C EP
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
Figure 1.
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
Figure 2.
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
1
2 Highlights
3 >Edible coatings can reduce the excessive oil uptake in deep fat fried food
4 >Edible oil barriers are invisible with no negative influence on sensory attributes
5 >Coatings are successfully used as oil barriers during frying meat and fruits
6 >Oil barrier coatings will become an essential strategy for launching healthier fried products
PT
7
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
C EP
AC