Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bronchiolar Disorders
A Clinical-Radiological Diagnostic Algorithm
Arun Devakonda, MD; Suhail Raoof, MD, FCCP; Arthur Sung, MD, FCCP;
William D. Travis, MD, FCCP; and David Naidich, MD, FCCP
Bronchiolar disorders are generally difficult to diagnose because most patients present with non-
specific respiratory symptoms of variable duration and severity. A detailed clinical history may
point toward a specific diagnosis. Pertinent clinical questions include history of smoking, collagen
vascular disease, inhalational injury, medication usage, and organ transplant. It is important also
to evaluate possible systemic and pulmonary signs of infection, evidence of air trapping, and
high-pitched expiratory wheezing, which may suggest small airways involvement. In this context,
pulmonary function tests and plain chest radiographs may demonstrate abnormalities; however,
they rarely prove sufficiently specific to obviate bronchoscopic or surgical biopsy. Given these
limitations, in our experience, high-resolution CT (HRCT) scanning of the chest often proves to
be the most important diagnostic tool to guide diagnosis in these difficult cases, because different
subtypes of bronchiolar disorders may present with characteristic image findings. Three distinct
HRCT patterns in particular are of value in assisting differential diagnosis. A tree-in-bud pattern
of well-defined nodules is seen primarily as a result of infectious processes. Ill-defined centrilobu-
lar ground-glass nodules point toward respiratory bronchiolitis when localized in upper lobes
in smokers or subacute hypersensitivity pneumonitis when more diffuse. Finally, a pattern of
mosaic attenuation, especially when seen on expiratory images, is consistent with air-trapping
characteristic of bronchiolitis obliterans or constrictive bronchiolitis. Based on an appreciation
of the critical role played by HRCT scanning, this article provides clinicians with a practical algo-
rithmic approach to the diagnosis of bronchiolar disorders. CHEST 2010; 137(4):938–951
bronchi acts as an antigenic stimulus for the production diagnoses included under bronchiolar disorders. How-
of IgE and IgG antibodies, resulting in wide ranging ever, a prolonged expiratory phase associated with expi-
bronchiolar disorders, including bronchiectasis. ratory wheezing favors both infectious and constrictive
Ethnic background is relevant in diffuse panbronchi- bronchiolitis over hypersensitivity pneumonitis (HP)
olitis (DPB), especially in Japanese, Chinese, and Korean and cryptogenic organizing pneumonia.
populations, where this rare, chronic inflammatory
lung disease of unknown cause is prevalent. In elderly
Step 2: Chest RadiographicⲐPulmonary Function
bedridden patients, especially those with significant
Correlations
oropharyngeal dysphagia, diffuse aspiration bronchi-
olitis (DAB) should be considered. Following detailed history and physical examina-
Onset of symptoms may be relatively acute in bron- tion, posteroanterior and lateral chest radiographs
chiolitis from infections, inhalational injury, or drugs; (CXRs) and pulmonary function tests (PFTs) are typ-
subacute in organizing pneumonia; and indolent ically obtained in no particular order.17 Unfortunately,
and chronic in patients with atypical mycobacterial these rarely establish specific diagnoses and often
disease. Cough with copious expectoration may be prove of only limited value in directing the diagnostic
seen in infectious bronchiolitis and DPB. A detailed workup. CXRs in bronchiolar disorders may be nor-
history of symptoms suggestive of connective tissue mal or may demonstrate nonspecific abnormalities,
disease, as well as exposure to inhalational irritants, including variable degrees of hyperinflation, peri-
drugs, and radiation, should be elicited in order to pheral attenuation of the vascular markings, and,
identify a possible cause. sometimes, nodular or reticulonodular opacities.18,19
On physical examination, the chest may demonstrate Increased bronchial wall thickening may also be seen
air trapping with increased anteroposterior diameter (Figs 7A-C).
and may be hyperresonant to percussion. Findings on PFTs may yield variable results depending on the
auscultation include any combination of prolonged predominant physiology. Acute infectious bronchi-
expiratory phase, expiratory wheeze, and coarse or fine olitis may demonstrate airway obstruction affecting
crackles. It is important to highlight that the ausculta- mainly the small airways, often associated with air
tory findings are not specific for the various etiologic trapping.20 Similar air trapping also occurs in patients
Step 3: HRCT
Predominant Tree-in-bud opacities
YES NO Step 4: Predominant
Centrilobular nodules
YES NO
Figure 6. Algorithmic approach to bronchiolar disease. The algorithm takes into consideration
important history and physical findings that should tip the clinician to suspect bronchiolar disease.
The plain chest radiograph (CXR) may not always show evidence of hyperinflation. Small air-
ways dysfunction on PFT should trigger a request for an HRCT scan of the chest, performed dur-
ing inspiration and exhalation. Further classification is based on the pattern seen on the HRCT
scan. A tree-in-bud pattern generally signifies an infectious bronchiolitis. On the other hand, cen-
trilobular nodules in a smoker point toward RB-ILD, whereas the same pattern in nonsmokers
may indicate HP. Evidence of air trapping on the HRCT scan may be due to constrictive or oblit-
erative bronchiolitis. Finally, if histologic confirmation is required, especially in conditions
such as subacute HP, constrictive or obliterative bronchiolitis, RB-ILD, or bronchoalveolar cell carcinoma,
a tissue diagnosis may be obtained. Generally, surgical biopsy is preferred because of difficulty in
recognizing and classifying bronchiolitis in transbronchial biopsies. Conditions diagnosed by lavage
(PLCH) or where infections are suspected (Mycobacterium avium-intracellulare, bacterial, parasitic,
and fungal), or BAL may be performed. In lung transplant patients suspected of having constrictive
bronchiolitis, five or more pieces of tissue, obtained by transbronchial biopsy, are recommended.
ABPM 5 allergic bronchopulmonary mycosis; BAC 5 bronchoalveolar cell carcinoma; CF 5 cystic
fibrosis; CHF 5 congestive heart failure; HP 5 hypersensitivity pneumonitis; PFT 5 pulmonary
function test; PLCH 5 pulmonary Langerhans cell histiocytosis; RB-ILD 5 respiratory bronchiolitis-
interstitial lung disease; TBBx 5 transbronchial biopsy. See Figure 3 legend for expansion of other
abbreviation.
with constrictive bronchiolitis, which often shows doned at this stage, if the clinical history suggests
nonreversibility with inhaled bronchodilators. In otherwise. Clinicians should maintain a high index
addition, these patients also demonstrate reduced of suspicion for bronchiolar disorders and proceed
diffusion capacity. Obstructive defect is the predomi- with ordering an HRCT scan of the chest to further
nant abnormality in follicular constrictive bronchi- evaluate.
olitis or DPB.21 In distinction, a restrictive or mixed
obstructiveⲐrestrictive pattern is observed in patients
Step 3: HRCT Scan Evaluation: Tree-in-Bud Opacities
with HP, respiratory bronchiolitis (RB), respiratory
bronchiolitis-interstitial lung disease (RB-ILD), and The main features on HRCT scan of patients with
organizing pneumonia.22 predominant bronchiolar disorders can be classified into
It is important to note that in some bronchiolar three distinct, easily identifiable patterns: (1) centri-
diseases, both the CXRs and PFTs may appear nor- lobular branching or clustered nodular opacities—
mal or only minimally abnormal. The search for the latter appropriately labeled as tree-in-bud opac-
bronchiolar disorders, however, should not be aban- ities; (2) poorly defined centrilobular ground-glass
nodules absent tree-in-bud opacities; and (3) mosaic diagnosis for this pattern of disease is infectious
attenuation, especially when apparent on expiratory bronchiolitis.24
scans. A particular advantage of this approach is that It should be pointed out that endobronchial infec-
following strict definitions of the various patterns tion results in mucoid impaction with a variable
mentioned allows consistent differentiation between degree of extension into the adjacent peribronchiolar
these patterns.15,23 alveolar sacs. Both these mechanisms make the nod-
Of these, the most common is the tree-in-bud ules appear well defined, a feature that distinguishes
pattern. Defined by the presence of clusters of them from the ill-defined, ground-glass, and hazy
well-defined nodules attached to centrilobular nodules (emanating from peribronchiolar inflamma-
branching or tubular structures, tree-in-bud opacities tion without impaction) seen in HP. Other entities
result from extensive bronchiolar mucoid impac- causing predominantly tree-in-bud opacities include
tion with or without the additional involvement immunologic disorders, such as allergic bronchopul-
of adjacent alveoli. The most important differential monary aspergillosisⲐmycosis25; congenital disorders,
such as CF and dyskinetic cilia syndrome; juvenile surprisingly, superimposed infections that respond to
laryngotracheobronchial papillomatosis26-29; DAB30; antibiotic therapy, even in these settings, are often
and diffuse panbronchiolitis.31 The important clin- implicated.
ical, radiologic, and histopathologic characteristics Diffuse tree-in-bud pattern is commonly seen in
of the diseases resulting in tree-in-bud opacities DAB, allergic bronchopulmonary aspergillosis (ABPA),
are described in Table 1. Depending on the extent diffuse panbronchiolitis, and congenital disorders,
of disease, this group can be further classified into including CF and primary ciliary dyskinesia. DAB
focal and diffuse tree-in-bud patterns. The proto- presents with recurrent episodes of bronchorrhea,
type of focal tree-in-bud pattern on HRCT scan is bronchospasm, and dyspnea. It is characterized by dif-
acute infectious bronchiolitis. Symptomatic acute fuse bronchiolar involvement secondary to chronic
bronchiolitis is relatively rare in adults and is aspiration.29 It occurs most commonly in elderly
caused by viral or bacterial infections.32-34 Local- patients with neurologic deficits or dementia,
ized tree-in-bud opacities are more often seen in bed-ridden patients, or patients with oropharyngeal
patients with chronic infections, including those dysphagia.30,37 DPB is a rare form of bronchiolitis
seen in patients with AIDS, for example, or espe- mainly in Japanese and Korean adults and is charac-
cially in patients with TB and atypical Mycobacte- terized by bronchiolar inflammation.37-40 The most-
rium. In this regard, it should be noted that some affected individuals are middle-aged men, nonsmokers,
patterns of distribution may suggest specific diag- and almost all have chronic sinusitis. Histopathology
noses. For example, localized tree-in-bud opacities is characterized by presence of acute and chronic
restricted to or predominantly involving one lung inflammation involving the bronchiolar wall or the
apex or upper lobe are often seen in patients with lumen associated with epithelial necrosis and slough-
Mycobacterium tuberculosis, often due to the ing. There may be associated edema as well as
endobronchial spread of disease, whereas similar inflammatory exudates and mucus in the bronchiolar
findings predominantly involving the middle lobe lumen. A characteristic feature is the accumulation of
and lingual are often seen in patients with atypical foamy macrophages within the peribronchiolar inter-
mycobacterial infection.35,36 stitium (Fig 8).31 Again the pattern of distribution
Rheumatoid arthritis and Sjögren syndrome may may provide a key to the correct diagnosis. The pres-
also affect the small airways resulting in focal tree- ence of central bronchiectasis associated with a tree-
in-bud opacities with or without associated centrilob- in-bud pattern is commonly seen in patients with
ular ground-glass opacities and bronchiectasis. Not ABPA, for example, whereas a truly diffuse pattern
uniformly identifiable throughout the lungs is highly these entities occur, albeit rarely, in smokers and even
suggestive of panbronchiolitis. more rarely in those with collagen vascular diseases
and mineral dust-induced diseases.40,46-48 HRCT scan-
ning of patients with RB demonstrates characteris-
Step 4: HRCT Scan Evaluation: Poorly Defined tic upper lobe-predominant, ill-defined centrilobu-
Centrilobular Ground-Glass Nodules lar ground-glass nodules, which are typically smaller
If HRCT scan discloses centrilobular opacities appear- and less defined than those seen in HP. Although the
ing as ill-defined ground-glass nodules in the absence extent of ground-glass opacities in patients with RB
of a tree-in-bud pattern, the differential diagnosis is may be exceedingly subtle, in patients with RB-ILD,
distinctly different than if tree-in-bud opacities are small foci of ground-glass attenuation are typically
present. This is despite the fact that ill-defined cen- present as well, simplifying the identification of this
trilobular nodules as well as tree-in-bud opacities entity.48,49 Not surprisingly, emphysema is often pre-
anatomically lie at least 5 to 10 mm from either the sent also (Fig 9). Pulmonary Langerhans cell histio-
pleural and fissural surfaces and may be either focal cytosis (PLCH) is an uncommon disorder of young
or diffuse in distribution.14,41 adults that is also strongly associated with cigarette
The classic example of this appearance is subacute smoking.50,51
HP. HP is a disease usually found in nonsmokers, and
is characterized by diffuse inflammation of lung paren-
chyma and terminal bronchioles in response to the
inhalation of organic and inorganic antigens to which
the patient has been previously sensitized.42 To date,
HRCT scanning has proved of particular value in the
diagnosis of subacute HP, because characteristically
this is one of only a few entities that lead to the pres-
ence of diffuse centrilobular ground-glass nodules uni-
formly noted throughout the lungs (Fig 4). These find-
ings in the appropriate clinical setting are sufficiently
suggestive of the diagnosis to potentially obviate fur-
ther diagnostic procedures, especially bronchoscopy.
Parenthetically, air trapping on expiratory thin-section
images may also be present, which accounts for the
finding of preserved secondary lobules reported with
the chronic, fibrotic form of this disease.43-45 Figure 10. The image is taken from a patient with pulmonary
In patients with smoking history, a substantial nar- Langerhans cell histiocytosis. Note the dilated bronchi, which are
larger than the accompanying pulmonary arteries. In addition,
rowing of the differential diagnosis is possible. RB and there are thick-walled cysts in the periphery of the lungs in both
RB-ILD, in particular, should be considered because upper lobes.
commonly, an element of air trapping. In the context tive bronchiolitis. In patients with constrictive or
of small airways disease, this is mainly from reflex obliterative bronchiolitis, because the predominant
hypoxic vasoconstriction. Mosaic perfusion is a non- pathologic finding is concentric narrowing or oblit-
specific finding and can be seen with any airways or eration of the bronchioles caused by submucosal
vascular disease. When mosaic perfusion is the only and peribronchiolar fibrosis (Fig 12), direct CT scan
or predominant finding, it is more specific and is typ- signs of bronchiolar and peribronchiolar inflamma-
ically seen with constrictive bronchiolitis, HP, asthma, tion (ie, centrilobular opacities) are characteristi-
or chronic pulmonary embolism. The “headcheese cally absent.59
sign” is the combination of mosaic perfusion and A common cause of constrictive bronchiolitis
ground-glass opacities in the same patient. Typically is previous childhood infection, resulting in the
in these patients three densities of lung are seen (nor- so-called Swyer-James syndrome, identifiable as
mal, too dense [ground-glass opacity], and too lucent
[mosaic perfusion]). This is indicative of a mixed
obstructiveⲐinfiltrative disorder and is very suggestive
of HP. Very rarely, headcheese sign may be seen with
other diseases, such as RB, follicular bronchiolitis,
and viral infections. Of note, the history of causative
exposure is elicited in only 50% of cases, increas-
ing the importance of HRCT scan even more. In
distinction, mosaic attenuation due to diffuse infil-
trative lung diseases is not characterized by attenua-
tion of low-density regions on exhalation, as low-
density regions represent normal lung. Therefore,
they demonstrate an increase in density as expected
on exhalation. A similar lack of persistent low den-
sity is noted on exhalation in patients with chronic
thromboembolic hypertension.
The prototype for this characteristic radiologic
Figure 12. The lumen of this bronchiole from a bone marrow
finding is constrictive bronchiolitis, also commonly transplant patient shows marked narrowing by prominent submu-
referred as bronchiolitis obliterans (BO) or oblitera- cosal fibrosis (hematoxylin-eosin, 3 20).
asymmetric hyperlucent lung on routine chest radio- 50% of patients.61 Because it is inappropriate to per-
graphs (Figs 13A, 13B). Other conditions resulting in form a biopsy on transplanted lung to make this diag-
a pattern of mosaic attenuation include connective nosis, the diagnosis of BO is based on clinical symp-
tissue disorders, bone marrow and transplantation, toms and spirometry.62 Constrictive bronchiolitis is
toxic fume inhalation, drugs, and cryptogenic con- seen as a manifestation of graft vs host disease in 10%
strictive bronchiolitis (Table 3).9,60 of people who have received allogeneic bone marrow
Of particular note, constrictive bronchiolitis transplants.63 Other less common causes have also
remains the most common form of chronic rejection been described. Rheumatoid arthritis-associated
in patients with lung transplants, occurring in up to constrictive bronchiolitis, for example, has been
described as a rare pleuropulmonary complication,
presumably as a result of autoimmune reaction.64,65
Table 3—Causes andⲐor Underlying Disorders
Most of the reported cases have marked irreversible
Associated With Constrictive Bronchiolitis
airways obstruction and a fulminating course of the
Postinfectious disease. Most have had long-standing rheumatoid
Viral (adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus, influenza, arthritis, although in rare cases, pulmonary abnor-
parainfluenza)
malities antedate rheumatologic manifestations. In
Mycoplasma
Collagen vascular diseases some cases, use of D-penicillamine therapy66 has been
Rheumatoid arthritis implicated as a potential causative factor. Silo filler’s
Systemic lupus erythematosus lung (nitrogen dioxide) is a classic cause of toxic
Eosinophilic fasciitis exposure-related constrictive bronchiolitis. Other
Transplant related toxic fumes, such as chlorine, sulfur dioxide, ammo-
Graft vs host disease
Allograft recipients
nia, and phosgene, have been reported to cause
Bone marrow transplant constrictive bronchiolitis.10,67 Most recently, work-
Heart-lung transplant related inhalation of flavoring agents (diacetyl used in
Toxic fume exposure making popcorn) has been found to result in a clinical
Nitrogen dioxide presentation and imaging pattern typical of con-
Sulfur dioxide
Ammonia
strictive bronchiolitis.68
Chlorine Other causes and associations with constrictive
Phosgene bronchiolitis are listed in Table 3 and include neuro-
Diacetyl (popcorn workers) endocrine cell hyperplasia or multiple carcinoid
Ingested toxins tumorlets, Sauropus androgynus ingestion,69 and
Sauropus androgynus
Drugs
drugs, such as D-penicillamine,10 gold,70 cocaine,
D-penicillamine and lomustine. Clinically, dyspnea is the most com-
Gold mon complaint. The clinical criteria used for diag-
Cocaine nosing constrictive bronchiolitis include evidence of
Carmustine severe irreversible airflow obstruction measured by
Cryptogenic constrictive bronchiolitis
spirometry, with an FEV1 of , 60% of predicted
value in the absence of other pathologic causes for Bronchiolitis is a nonspecific inflammation of the
airway obstruction, such as emphysema or chronic respiratory bronchioles and peribronchiolar alveolar
bronchitis. The midexpiratory phase of forced expi- sacs that has variable causes, clinical manifestations,
ratory flows is a measure of small airways disease; a and evolution. However, suggestive, specific diagnoses
marked decrease (ie, , 30% of predicted) is a par- are rarely made based on clinical history alone. As both
ticularly sensitive indicator of BO. Obtaining expira- CXR and PFT findings are also frequently nonspecific,
tory HRCT scans increases the likelihood of identi- a high index of clinical suspicion should be maintained
fying areas of air trapping that are not apparent on in order to diagnose andⲐor exclude bronchiolar disease.
inspiratory scans.61,71 Bankier et al72 showed that Given these limitations, in our experience, HRCT
expiratory air trapping achieved a sensitivity and scanning may play a critical role in both suggesting
specificity of 87.5% for the detection of BO specific causes of bronchiolar disease and directing
syndrome; in another study, Lee et al73 demon- optimal management in select cases. Tree-in-bud opac-
strated a sensitivity of 74% and a specificity of 67% ities, for example, typically signify an infectious cause
for air trapping in histologically proven BO in lung with a pattern of distribution often suggestive of par-
transplant patients. ticular causes, including Mycobacterium tuberculosis,
atypical mycobacterial infection, CF, and ABPA. Even
when nonspecific in appearance, as typically occurs
Step 6: Role of Lung Biopsy
in AIDS, the finding of tree-in-bud opacities is often
Histologically, bronchiolitis can have a wide vari- sufficiently specific for infection to suggest empirical
ety of patterns, as summarized in Table 4.74-76 Most treatment obviating biopsy. Poorly defined centrilobular
of these have already been mentioned here. In sur- ground-glass nodules commonly indicate subacute HP
gical lung biopsies, it is usually possible to recognize in a nonsmoker, whereas RBⲐRB-ILD and PLCH are
these patterns, and these terms can be applied when typically seen in smokers. In select cases, these findings,
the histologic findings are clear. Bronchiolar pathol- coupled with appropriate clinical history and serologic
ogy is often patchy, and severity of clinical manifes- testing, also may obviate more invasive diagnostic
tations frequently exceeds that of the histologic testing. In distinction, other causes of centrilobular
changes. Thus, it is important to obtain wedge biopsies nodules usually require open lung biopsy rather than
from multiple lobes. It is also not uncommon for transbronchial biopsy for definitive diagnosis. Finally,
bronchiolitis to be seen among a mixture of histo- mosaic attenuation is characteristically associated with
logic patterns of lung injury, such as an interstitial constrictive bronchiolitis. It is anticipated that the
pneumonia or pleuritis. Occasionally, bronchiolar application of the algorithmic approach presented in this
pathology may be very subtle, and on biopsy alone it article will facilitate the timely diagnosis andⲐor optimal
is difficult to be certain if the morphologic observa- management of bronchiolar disorders that may other-
tion is an incidental or clinically significant finding. wise be difficult to identify. In many cases, a diagnosis
In such cases, careful clinical and HRCT scan corre- may be made solely using HRCT scans in combina-
lation is required. tion with the history and clinical presentation.
It can be difficult to recognize and classify bron-
chiolitis in transbronchial biopsies because of the
limited sampling size. However, in certain clinical Acknowledgments
settings, such as heart-lung or bone marrow trans- FinancialⲐnonfinancial disclosures: The authors have reported
plantation, these are the most common specimens to CHEST that no potential conflicts of interest exist with any
obtained. In these patients with appropriate clinical companiesⲐorganizations whose products or services may be dis-
cussed in this article.
and HRCT scan findings, the presence of submuco- Other contributions: We thank Ms. Patrice Balistreri for her
sal fibrosis may support a diagnosis of constrictive invaluable secretarial assistance and coordination.