You are on page 1of 10

TECHNICAL JUSTIFICATION

FOR STEEL PIPE ON JETTY

1 TROUBLE REPORT

Based the observation and also regarding the inspection report for thickness of steel pipe. The steel pipes have corroded, and thickness
become 9 mm (The smallest). This technical justification will clarify the calculate of pile bearing capacity with assumed the thickness of
steel pipe around 9 mm.

2 THE CONCEPT OF TECHNICAL JUSTIFICATION

Where the concept of calculation is, the steel pipe will recalculate with data from calculation sheet with assumed thickness of steel pipe is
9 mm.

3 SUMMARY DATA (CALCULATION SHEET) AND ANALYSIS OF JETTY FOUNDATION

3.1 MOORING FOUNDATION


3.1.1 COMBINATION LOAD DATA
Based the calculation sheet,, the support
pp reaction list as below :

DATA
DATA :
P max = 111.6 k.N
Lateral Load = 14.6 k.N
Moment = 25 kN.m
Length of steel pipe = 36 m; A36
Diameter of Steel Pipe = 457.2 mm

3.1.2 PILE BEARING CAPACITY


This analysis
y use the allpile
p software which the thickness assumed for steel pipe
p p is 9 mm.
‐ AXIAL CAPACITY
*****************************************************************
ALLPILE 7
VERTICAL ANALYSIS SUMMARY OUTPUT
Copyright by CivilTech Software 2005
www.civiltechsoftware.com
*****************************************************************
Licensed to
Date: 5/28/2016 File: D:\2x7 MW\Justifikasi Teknik\STEEL PIPE JETTY\MOORING FOUNDATION
FOUNDATION.alp
alp

Title 1: MOORING FOUNDATION


Title 2:

TOTAL LOADS:
Vertical Load, Q: 111.6 -kN
Load Factor for Vertical Loads: 1.0
L d Supported
Loads S t d by
b Pile
Pil Cap:
C 0%
PILE PROFILE:
Pile Length, L= 36.0 -m
Top Height, H= 8.3 -m
Slope Angle, As= 0
Batter Angle, Ab= 6.00 Batter Factor, Kbat= 0.99

SINGLE PILE:
Deduction factor due to Group Effect, R= 1.00
Vertical Load= 111.60 -kN

Single Pile Vertical Analysis:


Total Ultimate Capacity (Down)= 941.074-kN Total Ultimate Capacity (Up)= 831.299-kN
Total Allowable Capacity (Down)= 313.691-kN Total Allowable Capacity (Up)= 271.540-kN
Weight aboN *Soil Weight is not included
Side Resistance (Down)= 839.648-kN Side Resistance (Up)= 839.639-kN
Ti Resistance
Tip R i t (D
(Down)=
) 101
101.426-kN
426 kN TiTip R
Resistance
i t (U
(Up)=
) 0
0.000-kN
000 kN
Negative Friction, Qneg= 0.000-kN, which has been subtracted from Total Ultimate Capacity (Down)
Negative friction does not affect Total Ultimate Capacity (Up)

At Work Load= 111.60-kN, Settlement= 0.06970-cm


At Work Load= 111.60-kN, Secant Stiffness Kqx= 1601.18-kN/-cm
At Allowable Settlement= 2.500-cm, Capacity= 824.30-kN
Work Load, 111.60-kN, OK with the Capacity at Allowable Settlement= 2.50-cm, Capacity= 824.30-kN
Work Load, 111.60-kN, OK with the Allowable Capacity
p y (Down)=
( ) 313.69-kN

____________________________________________
FACTOR OF SAFETY:
FSside FStip FSuplif FSweight
3.000 3 3 1

‐ LATERAL CAPACITY
*****************************************************************
ALLPILE 7
LATERAL ANALYSIS SUMMARY OUTPUT
Copyright by CivilTech Software 2005
www.civiltechsoftware.com
*****************************************************************
Licensed to
D t 5/26/2016 Fil
Date: File: D
D:\2x7
\2 7 MW\J
MW\Justifikasi
tifik i T
Teknik\STEEL
k ik\STEEL PIPE JETTY\MOORING FOUNDATION.alp
FOUNDATION l

Title 1: BH 19
Title 2:

PILE PROFILES:
Pile Length, L= 36.0 -m
Topp Height,
g , H= 8.3 -m
Slope Angle, As= 0
Batter Angle, Ab= 6.00

FACTORS AND CONDITIONS:


Load Factor for Vertical Loads: 1.0 1.0
Load Factor for Lateral Loads: 1.0
Loads Supported by Pile Cap: 0 %
Shear Condition: Static

SINGLE PILE:
Deduction factor due to Group Effect, R= 1.00
Vertical Load= 111.60 -kN
Shear= 14.60 -kN
Slope Restain, St= 0.00 -cm/-cm

Results:
Top Deflection, yt= 0.19400-cm
M
Max. M
Moment, t M=
M 30.60-kN-m
30 60 kN
Top Deflection Slope, St= 0.00000
Top Deflection, 0.1940-cm, OK with the Allowable Deflection= 2.50-cm
3.1.3 CHECKED BEARING CAPACITY

Pile Bearing capacity Design


Axial Ultimate Capacity = 941.1 kN
Max.Moment = 30.6 kN.m

- Axial Capacity
Ultimate bearing capacity => Load x Safety factor

941.1 kN = 111.60 kN x 3
941.1 kN > 334.8 k.N (Ok)

- Lateral Capacity
Ma Moment = > Moment cr
Max
30.6 kN.m > 25.00 (Ok)

3.2 BERTHING FOUNDATION


3.2.1 COMBINATION LOAD DATA
Based the calculation sheet, the support reaction list as below :

P max = 321.90
321 90 kN
Horizontal load = 39.6 kN
Moment = 157.9 kN.m
Length of steel pipe = 42 m; A36
Diameter of Steel Pipe      =  457.2 mm

3.2.2 PILE BEARING CAPACITY ANALYSIS


*****************************************************************
ALLPILE 7
VERTICAL ANALYSIS SUMMARY OUTPUT
Copyright by CivilTech Software 2005
www.civiltechsoftware.com
*****************************************************************
Licensed to
Date: 5/28/2016 File: D:\2x7 MW\Justifikasi Teknik\STEEL PIPE JETTY\BERTHING FOUNDATION.alp

Title 1: MOORING FOUNDATION


Title 2:

TOTAL LOADS:
Vertical Load, Q: 321.9 ‐kN
Load Factor for Vertical Loads: 1.0
Loads Supported by Pile Cap: 0 %
PILE PROFILE:
Pile Length, L= 42.0 ‐m
Top Height, H= 8.3 -m
Slope Angle, As= 0
Batter Angle, Ab= 6.00 Batter Factor, Kbat= 0.99

SINGLE PILE:
SINGLE PILE:
Deduction factor due to Group Effect, R= 1.00
Vertical Load= 321.90 -kN

Single Pile Vertical Analysis:


Total Ultimate Capacity (Down)= 1642.818-kN Total Ultimate Capacity (Up)= 1525.729-kN
Total Allowable Capacity (Down)= 547.606-kN Total Allowable Capacity (Up)= 546.177-kN
Weight aboN *Soil Weight is not included
Side Resistance (Down)= 1469.324-kN Side Resistance (Up)= 1469.328-kN
Tip Resistance (Do
(Down)=
n) 173
173.494-kN
494 kN Tip Resistance (Up)
(Up)= 00.000-kN
000 kN
Negative Friction, Qneg= 0.000-kN, which has been subtracted from Total Ultimate Capacity (Down)
Negative friction does not affect Total Ultimate Capacity (Up)

At Work Load= 321.90-kN, Settlement= 0.23769-cm


At Work Load= 321.90-kN, Secant Stiffness Kqx= 1354.26-kN/-cm
At Allowable Settlement= 2.500-cm, Capacity= 1518.08-kN
Work Load, 321.90-kN, OK with the Capacity at Allowable Settlement= 2.50-cm, Capacity= 1518.08-kN
Work Load, 321.90-kN, OK with the Allowable Capacity
p y (Down)=
( ) 547.61-kN

____________________________________________
FACTOR OF SAFETY:
FSside FStip FSuplif FSweight
3.000 3 3 1

*****************************************************************
ALLPILE 7
LATERAL ANALYSIS SUMMARY OUTPUT
Copyright by CivilTech Software 2005
www.civiltechsoftware.com
*****************************************************************
Licensed to
Date: 5/27/2016 File: D:\2x7 MW\Justifikasi Teknik\STEEL PIPE JETTY\BERTHING FOUNDATION.alp

Title 1:
Titl 1 BERTHING FOUNDATION
Title 2:

PILE PROFILES:
Pile Length, L= 42.0 ‐m
Top Height, H= 8.3 ‐m
Slope Angle, As= 0.0
Batter Angle, Ab= 6.00
g ,

FACTORS AND CONDITIONS:
Load Factor for Vertical Loads: 1.0    1.0
Load Factor for Lateral Loads: 1.0
Loads Supported by Pile Cap: 0 %
Shear Condition: Static

SINGLE PILE:
Deduction factor due to Group Effect R= 1 00
Deduction factor due to Group Effect, R= 1.00
Vertical Load= 321.90 ‐kN
Shear= 39.60 ‐kN
Slope Restain, St= 0.00 ‐cm/‐cm

Results:
Top Deflection, yt= 2.10000‐cm
Max. Moment, M= 283.00‐kN‐m
Top Deflection Slope, St= 0.00000
T Deflection,
Top D fl ti 2.10000-cm,
2 10000 OK with
ith th
the All
Allowable
bl DDeflection=
fl ti 2
2.50-cm
50
3.2.3 CHECKED BEARING CAPACITY
PILE BEARING CAPACITY DESIGN

Axial Capacity
Ultimate bearing capacity => Load x Safety factor

1642.82 kN = 321.90 kN x 3
1642.82 kN > 965.7 k.N (Ok)

Lateral Capacity
Max Moment = > Moment cr
283 kN.m > 157.90

3.3 JETTY FOUNDATION
3.3.1 COMBINATION LOAD DATA
Based the calculation sheet, the support reaction list as below :

P max   = 68.44 kN
Max. Lateral Load = 5.11 kN
Max. moment = 3.82 kN.m
Length of steel pipe = 42 m; A36
Diameter of Steel Pipe = 457.2 mm

3 3 2 PILE BEARING CAPACITY ANALYSIS


3.3.2
*****************************************************************
ALLPILE 7
VERTICAL ANALYSIS SUMMARY OUTPUT
Copyright by CivilTech Software 2005
www.civiltechsoftware.com
*****************************************************************
Licensed to
Date: 5/28/2016 File: D:\2x7 MW\Justifikasi Teknik\STEEL PIPE JETTY\JETTY FOUNDATION.alp

Title 1: JETTY FOUNDATION


Title 2:

TOTAL LOADS:
Vertical Load, Q: 68.4 -kN
Load Factor for Vertical Loads: 1.0
Loads Supported by Pile Cap: 0 %
PILE PROFILE:
Pile Length, L= 42.0 -m
Top Height, H= 8.3 ‐m
Slope Angle, As= 0
Batter Angle, Ab= 6.00 Batter Factor, Kbat= 0.99

SINGLE PILE:
SINGLE PILE:
Deduction factor due to Group Effect, R= 1.00
Vertical Load= 68.44 -kN

Single Pile Vertical Analysis:
Total Ultimate Capacity (Down)= 1642.818-kN Total Ultimate Capacity (Up)= 1457.386-kN
Total Allowable Capacity (Down)= 547.606-kN Total Allowable Capacity (Up)= 477.834-kN
Weight abo kN *Soil Weight is not included
Side Resistance (Down)= 1469.324-kN Side Resistance (Up)= 1469.329-kN
Tip Resistance (Do
(Down)=
n) 173
173.494-kN
494 kN Tip Resistance (Up)
(Up)= 00.000-kN
000 kN
Negative Friction, Qneg= 0.000-kN, which has been subtracted from Total Ultimate Capacity (Down)
Negative friction does not affect Total Ultimate Capacity (Up)
  
At Work Load= 68.44-kN, Settlement= 0.05358-cm
At Work Load= 68.44-kN, Secant Stiffness Kqx= 1277.40-kN/-cm
At Allowable Settlement= 2.500-cm, Capacity= 1531.71-kN
Work Load, 68.44-kN, OK with the Capacity at Allowable Settlement= 2.50-cm, Capacity= 1531.71-kN
Work Load, 68.44-kN, OK with the Allowable Capacity
p y (Down)=
( ) 547.61-kN

____________________________________________
FACTOR OF SAFETY:
FSside FStip FSuplif FSweight
3.00 3 3.00 1

*****************************************************************
ALLPILE 7
LATERAL ANALYSIS SUMMARY OUTPUT
Copyright by CivilTech Software 2005
www.civiltechsoftware.com
*****************************************************************
Licensed to
Date: 5/26/2016 File: D:\2x7 MW\Justifikasi Teknik\STEEL PIPE JETTY\JETTY FOUNDATION.alp
Title 1: JETTY FOUNDATION
Titl 2:
Title 2

PILE PROFILES:
Pile Length, L= 42.0 ‐m
Top Height, H= 8.3 ‐m
Slope Angle, As= 0.0
Batter Angle, Ab= 6.00

FACTORS AND CONDITIONS:


Load Factor for Vertical Loads: 1.0    1.0
Load Factor for Lateral Loads: 1.0
Loads Supported by Pile Cap: 0 %
Shear Condition: Static

SINGLE PILE:
Deduction factor due to Group Effect, R= 1.00
Vertical Load= 68.44
68 44 -kN
Shear= 5.11 ‐kN
Slope Restain, St= 0.00 -cm/-cm

Results:
Top Deflection, yt= 1.00000-cm
Max. Moment, M= 29.90-kN-m
Top Deflection Slope, St= 0.00000

Top Deflection, 1.0000-cm, OK with the Allowable Deflection= 2.50-cm


3.3.3 CHECKED BEARING CAPACITY

Axial Capacity
Ultimate bearing capacity => Load x Safety factor

1643 kN = 68.44 kN x 3
1643 kN > 205.32 k.N (Ok)

Lateral Capacity
Max Moment = > Moment cr
29.9 kN.m > 3.77 (Ok)

3 4 SHIP UNLOADER
3.4
3.4.1 COMBINATION LOAD DATA
Based the calculation sheet, the support reaction list as below :

P max   = 145.87 kN
Max. Lateral Load = 14.70 kN
Length
g of steel pipe
pp = 42 m;; A36
Diameter of Steel Pipe = 457.2 mm
better angle = 6

3.4.2 PILE BEARING CAPACITY ANALYSIS
*****************************************************************
                 ALLPILE 7
      VERTICAL ANALYSIS SUMMARY OUTPUT
    Copyright by CivilTech Software 2005
          www.civiltechsoftware.com                 
www.civiltechsoftware.com
*****************************************************************
Licensed to        
Date: 5/28/2016  File: D:\2x7 MW\Justifikasi Teknik\STEEL PIPE JETTY\SHIP UNLOADER FOUNDATION.alp

Title 1: SHIP UNLOADER
Title 2: 
TOTAL LOADS:
Vertical Load, Q: 145.9 ‐kN
  Load Factor for Vertical Loads: 1.0
L d F t f V ti l L d 1 0
Loads Supported by Pile Cap: 0 %
PILE PROFILE:
Pile Length, L= 42.0 ‐m
Top Height, H= 8.3 ‐m
Slope Angle, As= 0
Batter Angle, Ab= 6.00    Batter Factor, Kbat= 0.99

SINGLE PILE:
Deduction factor due to Group Effect, R= 1.00
Vertical Load= 145.87 ‐kN

Single Pile Vertical Analysis:


Total Ultimate Capacity (Down)= 1642.818‐kN  Total Ultimate Capacity (Up)= 1457.386‐kN
Total Allowable Capacity (Down)= 547.606‐kN  Total Allowable Capacity (Up)= 477.834‐kN
Weight abov Total Weight= ‐11.94‐kN      *Soil Weight is not included
Side Resistance (Down)= 1469.324‐kN  Side Resistance (Up)= 1469.329‐kN
Ti R i t
Tip Resistance (Down)= 173.494‐kN  Tip Resistance (Up)= 0.000‐kN
(D ) 173 494 kN Ti R i t (U ) 0 000 kN
Negative Friction, Qneg= 0.000‐kN, which has been subtracted from Total Ultimate Capacity (Down)
Negative friction does not affect Total Ultimate Capacity (Up)

At Work Load= 145.87‐kN,  Settlement= 0.11419‐cm
At Work Load= 145.87‐kN,  Secant Stiffness Kqx= 1277.40‐kN/‐cm
At Allowable Settlement= 2.500‐cm,  Capacity= 1531.71‐kN
Work Load, 145.87‐kN, OK with the Capacity at Allowable Settlement= 2.50‐cm, Capacity= 1531.71‐kN
Work Load, 145.87‐kN, OK with the Allowable Capacity (Down)= 547.61‐kN
p y( )

____________________________________________
FACTOR OF SAFETY:
FSside FStip FSuplif FSweight
3 3 3.00 1

*****************************************************************
ALLPILE 7
LATERAL ANALYSIS SUMMARY OUTPUT
Copyright by CivilTech Software 2005
www.civiltechsoftware.com
*****************************************************************
Licensed to

Date: 5/26/2016 File: D:\2x7 MW\Justifikasi Teknik\STEEL PIPE JETTY\SHIP UNLOADER FOUNDATION.alp
Titl 1:
Title 1 SHIP UNLOADER PILE
Title 2:

PILE PROFILES:
Pile Length, L= 42.0 -m
Top Height, H= 8.3 -m
Slope Angle, As= 0.0
Batter Angle,
g , Ab= 0.00

FACTORS AND CONDITIONS:


Load Factor for Vertical Loads: 1.0 1.0
Load Factor for Lateral Loads: 1.0
Loads Supported by Pile Cap: 0 %
Shear Condition: Static

SINGLE PILE:
Deduction factor due to Group Effect
Effect, R= 1.00
1 00
Vertical Load= 145.87 -kN
Shear= 14.70 -kN
Slope Restain, St= 0.00 -cm/-cm
Results:
Top Deflection, yt= 0.19000-cm
Max. Moment, M= 30.30-kN-m
Top Deflection Slope, St= 0.00000
Top Deflection, 0.1900-cm, OK with the Allowable Deflection= 2.50-cm
3.3.3 CHECKED BEARING CAPACITY

Axial Capacity
Ultimate bearing capacity => Load x Safety factor

1643 kN = 145 87
145.87 kN x 3
1643 kN > 437.61 k.N (Ok)

Lateral Capacity
Max Moment = > Moment cr
30.3 kN.m > 14.70 (Ok)

3.5 SOIL PROPERTIES


5 CONCLUSION OF ANALYSIS

SUMMARY ANALYSIS
PILE BEARING SAFETY
STRUCTURE NAME AXIAL LOAD (kN) NOMINAL (kN) REMARKS
CAPACITY (kN) FACTOR

MOORING 941.10 111.60 3 334.8 UNDER CAPACITY


BERTHING 1,642.8 321.90 3 965.7 UNDER CAPACITY
JETTY 1,642.8 68.4 3 205.2 UNDER CAPACITY
SHIP UNLOADER 1642.8 145.4 3 436.2 UNDER CAPACITY

Based on calculation jetty


j y head structure,Berthing,
, g, Mooring
g and Shipp Unloader. The steel pipe
p p which thickness 9 mm,, can
use due to pile bearing capacity still able to withstand the axial load times 3 (safety factor).

Regarding the inspection report the lot of steel pipe have thickness more than 9 mm (excatly thickness between 9 - 10
mm, see the attachment)
ATTACHMENT

1 ATTACHMENT # 1 - CALCULATION SHEET JETTY, ANALISA PONDASI & KESIMPULAN


2 ATTACHMENT # 2 - VERTICAL ANALYSIS OF ALL PILE SOFTWARE
3 ATTACHMENT # 3 - BOR LOG
4 ATTACHMENT # 4 - THE RESULT REPORT OF THICKNESS INSPECTION
5 ATTACHMENT # 5 - CALCULATION SHEET JETTY, MOORING, BERTHING, SHIP UNLOADER

You might also like