Professional Documents
Culture Documents
c da j o u r n a l , vo l 3 6 , n º 5
Clinically Based
Diagnostic Wax-up for
Optimal Esthetics:
The Diagnostic Mock-up
harel simon, dmd, and pascal magne, dmd, msc, phd
O
authors acknowledgments btaining a predictable cess, the wax-up, is a 3-D model of teeth
Harel Simon, dmd, is a The authors would like
esthetic result is one of the built in wax that represent the desired
prosthodontist, clinical as- to acknowledge Takanori goals of prosthodontic and contours of the teeth to be restored.
sociate professor, Univer- Tani, CDT; Masahiro restorative dental treatment.
sity of Southern California Kitsukawa, CDT; and Take Esthetic and functional Applications
School of Dentistry, and in Katayama, CDT, from Den-
treatment outcomes should be known The diagnostic wax-up is a tool that
private practice in Beverly tech International for the
Hills, Calif. laboratory work presented
prior to placement of a definitive res- can be used for diagnosis and treatment
in Figures 1, 5 and 6; and toration. Respecting this principle will of dentate patients, partially edentulous,
Pascal Magne, dmd, Michel Magne, CDT, for the prevent major disappointments and and completely edentulous patients us-
msc, phd, is associate work presented in Figure 7. unnecessary remakes.1 A diagnostic ing wax or denture teeth set in wax as
professor, Don and Sybil
wax-up has been advocated to enhance media.7 This tool can provide important
Harrington Foundation
chair in esthetic dentistry, the predictability of the treatment.2-5 diagnostic information that will indicate
Division of Primary Oral the need for a specific treatment.2,8 It can
Health Care, University of Definition assist in the selection of proper restora-
Southern California School A diagnostic wax-up is defined by tion and determine the need for prepros-
of Dentistry.
the glossary of prosthodontic terms as thetic surgery, periodontal, orthodontic,
a dental diagnostic procedure in which or endodontic treatment. The wax-up
planned restorations are developed in can assist in estimating the amount of
wax on a diagnostic cast to determine restorative space available and point out
optimal clinical and laboratory procedures any need for treatment in the opposing
necessary to achieve the desired esthetics arch to obtain such space. It can help in
and function.6 The result of this pro- evaluating the planned occlusal scheme
m ay 2 0 0 8 355
wax-up
c da j o u r n a l , vo l 3 6 , n º 5
3 5 6 m ay 2 0 0 8
c da j o u r n a l , vo l 3 6 , n º 5
f ig ur e 2a. Patient presented with a desire to f igure 2 b. Smile demonstrating inadequate f i g u r e 2 c. Consequence of excessive tooth
improve her smile: Rest position. incisal display. wear.
f ig ur e 2d. Composite mock up done on the f igure 2 e . Mock-up evaluated at rest position. f i g u r e 2 f. Mock-up at smile.
maxillary right central incisor to determine incisal
edge position.
the correct occlusal scheme is prescribed. teeth are being modeled intraorally using integrate with the face and lips (figures
This article will discuss methods to a tooth-colored material in a reversible 2a-f ). Different lip positions can be
predictably communicate desired teeth way to demonstrate the desired esthetic evaluated to confirm an acceptable smile
contours and positions to be waxed ac- result. Although a direct intraoral waxing and rest position. Phonetic tests can
cording to information obtained clini- technique using wax over the natural be performed to evaluate the tentative
cally. This will allow the formation of an teeth has been documented, the use incisal edge position vertically and buc-
accurate and clinically valid diagnostic of tooth-colored resin materials seems colingually in relation to the vermilion
wax-up for a predictable esthetic result. to be more practical.20 It is important border of the lower lip in F,V sounds.21
to select a proper tooth-colored mate- At the same time, potential altera-
Obtaining Clinical Information rial to avoid any bias, since perception tion in phonetics can be observed and
of shape may be influenced by opacity discussed with the patient as adaptation
freehand method and color. This procedure can be done to the new position will be required.15,16
Using this technique, the desired before or after the diagnostic wax-up. In many cases, the patient may
positions of the teeth are communi- not be able to perceive the clinician’s
cated in relation to the existing denti- Types of Diagnostic Mock-ups diagnosis and treatment plan with-
tion. The technician is instructed to wax out a visual aid. In those cases, the
the teeth while modifying the length, preliminary diagnostic mock-up mock-up would be a critical step in
width, or midline of the existing teeth A preliminary diagnostic mock-up is educating the patient without which,
by a given amount in relation to the a powerful tool to obtain clinical infor- treatment would not be performed.
existing condition. This method can be mation in a simplified way prior to the The mock-up procedure is completely
practical when only limited alterations diagnostic wax-up.5,15,16 In this tech- reversible and is done without any tooth
to the existing dentition are needed. nique, composite resin is used freehand preparation, without acid etching or
intraorally to contour one or more teeth bonding to the teeth. The composite is
diagnostic mock-up and evaluate the affect on the patient’s simply placed on the teeth in a freehand
A diagnostic mock-up is the clinical appearance. This allows the clinician technique and contoured to become
equivalent of a laboratory made diag- to visualize the change and see if the a guide for the wax-up. If there is any
nostic wax-up.19 In this approach, the tentative teeth contour and position existing composite resin on the teeth, it
m ay 2 0 0 8 357
wax-up
c da j o u r n a l , vo l 3 6 , n º 5
f ig ur e 5a. Composite mock-up (from Figure 2) f igure 5 b . Mock-up placed on the diagnostic f i g u r e 5c. Wax-up is made based on information
removed intact from the tooth. cast. obtained from diagnostic mock-up.
3 5 8 m ay 2 0 0 8
c da j o u r n a l , vo l 3 6 , n º 5
m ay 2 0 0 8 359
wax-up
c da j o u r n a l , vo l 3 6 , n º 5
f ig ur e 6i. Teeth preparation is done using depth f igure 6 j. Considerable reduction is done on the f i g u r e 6 k . The preparation is verified using
cutting burs on the mock-up which acts as a full mock-up, which results in minimal tooth reduction a silicone matrix made from the final diagnostic
contour preparation guide and not on the original, and preservation of enamel while obtaining optimal wax-up. Symmetrical trimming of the matrix and
worn tooth contour. preparation depth. consistent viewing angle are essential for accurate
evaluation. Notice correct trimming of the matrix
with proper viewing angle on the patient’s left side
compared to incorrect trimming and improper view-
ing angle on the contra lateral side.
f ig ur e 6l. A provisional restoration made using f igure 6 m . The definitive porcelain veneers f i g u r e 6 n. Patient’s smile is adapting to the new
the same silicone template is inserted. follow the diagnostic wax-up made using information incisal edge position.
obtained clinically with the preliminary and second-
ary mock-ups.
removable mock-up provisional nary evaluation of the design in a social to prosthodontic principles, by establish-
restoration environment outside the clinical setting.16 ing the incisal edge position and midline
If the mock-up is designed to be If the mock-up followed a purely ad- and following anatomical landmarks such
removed intact, it can be used as a ditive wax-up (without any tooth reduc- as the retromolar pads to communicate
removable overlay prosthesis for the tion) and only spot etching was used to the desired occlusal plane, the entire
patient to wear over the teeth. This will bond it, it can be easily flicked off and dentition can be designed on mounted
allow the discerning patient to evaluate the teeth can be polished. This is not casts in proper esthetic arrangement.24,25
the design among friends and fam- the case when the mock-up is based on If these principles are to be applied
ily members who may influence the a subtractive wax-up (tooth reduction to fixed prosthodontics, an intraoral pre-
patient’s decision. This mock-up pro- needed for wax-up) or when the entire liminary diagnostic mock-up of a single
visional is used until final approval of surface of the teeth was etched. It is central incisor will be adequate to commu-
the teeth arrangement is obtained.3 important to note that in this approach nicate with the technician the incisal edge
the patient needs to be committed to position and midline and will function like
fixed mock-up provisional restoration treatment and proper consent is essential. the complete denture wax-rim. Using this
Another approach is to use the information, the technician will be able
mock-up as a preliminary fixed provi- Discussion to predictably wax the entire dentition.
sional restoration. The unaltered teeth are It is well accepted today that the The secondary mock-up will simu-
etched and a silicone matrix made from concepts of modern esthetic dentistry are late the anterior teeth wax trial place-
the diagnostic wax-up is used to bond the founded in complete denture prosthodon- ment of complete dentures and once it
mock-up to the teeth.13,15,16 This prelimi- tics. Designing an esthetic smile in both is approved the work can be continued
nary provisional restoration is designed to edentulous and dentate patients requires with a higher level of confidence.
test the mock-up long term for esthetics the establishment of teeth positions for In the event that tooth structure
and function. This will also allow prelimi- proper esthetics and function. According interferes with the diagnostic mock-
3 6 0 m ay 2 0 0 8
c da j o u r n a l , vo l 3 6 , n º 5
f ig ur e 7 d. A mock-up is formed upon polymer- f igure 7 e. The mock-up tests the design of the f i g u r e 7f. The wax-up was modified and another
ization of the resin. wax-up in relation to the lip line and smile. Utilizing mock-up is tried in. The mock-up will program the lip
patient’s feedback from the mock-up, an additional line and prepare the soft tissues for the definitive
increase in incisal edge is prescribed. restoration.
tion or spot bonding techniques, they may allow a longer trial period and there-
have limited retention and durability. fore provide a reliable provisionalization.
Given that they cannot be predictably Porcelain veneers are conservative
maintained long term, it is unfeasible restorations requiring minimal tooth
to evaluate the new design in function preparation. However, without accu-
over the desired length of time. While rate guidance related to the definitive
some patients need time to accept the restoration contours, the teeth could
new appearance psychologically, in others be under-or overprepared resulting
the phonetics may need to be evaluated in a compromised result. In order to
f ig ur e 7 g. Upon completion, the mock-up is
removed.
for a longer period. Over time, the new allow optimal tooth preparation the ap-
form may alter the patient’s smile pattern proved mock-up is used as a preparation
up, minor tooth modifications may be and “de-program” the smile. This change guide. The teeth are prepared through
needed. Care should be taken to obtain may be unpredictable in magnitude and the resin mock-up that represents the
a complete patient consent as this is may require treatment modifications. definitive tooth contours and allows a
an irreversible diagnostic procedure. The new occlusal scheme may need to be predictable and uniform reduction.
These diagnostic techniques in con- monitored in cases that modify the incisal The various techniques described
junction with the mock-up provisional guidance and the envelope of function. hereby can be used as stand-alone proce-
restoration concept are especially useful The techniques proposed in this article al- dures to obtain a clinically valid diag-
in a treatment plan that involves porce- low this to be done predictably until com- nostic wax-up. However, when needed,
lain veneers. They are designed to address plete approval of the patient is obtained. they can be used in conjunction with
the precision needed in tooth preparation It is important to note that while a each other to allow a more predictable
for these restorations and the difficulty in removable mock-up provisional is used result in difficult and demanding cases.
creating and maintaining long-term provi- according to the patient’s discretion and
sional restorations for porcelain veneers. may be in function for an unknown peri- Conclusion
Since provisional veneers are typi- od or not at all, the fixed mock-up ensures The diagnostic mock-up procedure is a
cally retained using mechanical reten- patient compliance. It is more durable and reasonably quick and straightforward pro-
m ay 2 0 0 8 361
wax-up
c da j o u r n a l , vo l 3 6 , n º 5
f ig ur e 7 h. Progression of diagnostic casts, from preoperative casts to initial wax-up and final wax-up demonstrating a total increase in incisal edge of 3 mm.
f ig ur e 7 i. Bonded porcelain restorations repro- f igure 7 j. Incisal edges are in harmony with
duce the diagnostic wax-up. the lower lip ensuring a predictable esthetic result.
(Figures 7a-j are reprinted with permission from Magne
P, Belser U, Bonded porcelain restorations in the anterior
dentition a biomimetic approach, first ed. Carol Stream,
Ill., Quintessence Publishing Co., pages 221-3, 2002.)
cedure that provides instant clinical feed- 5. Marzola R, Derbabian K, The science of communicating the hanced esthetics. Quintessence Dent Technol 25:155-72, 2002.
art of esthetic dentistry. Part I: Patient-dentist-patient com- 19. Magne P, Magne M, Use of additive wax-up and direct
back prior to the beginning of treatment. munication. J Esthet Dent 12(3):131-8, 2000. intraoral mock-up for enamel preservation with porcelain
The advantages of this technique 6. The glossary of prosthodontic terms. J Prosthet Dent laminate veneers. Eur J Esthet Dent 1(1):10-9, 2006.
are that the desired changes can be 94(1):10-92, 2005. 20. Dalvit DL, Parker MH, Cameron SM, Quick chairside diag-
7. Carlyle LW III, Richardson JT, The diagnostic wax-up: an aid in nostic wax-up. J Prosthet Dent 87(5):581-2, 2002.
visualized clinically, tested with the treatment planning. Tex Dent J 102(2):10-2, 1985. 21. Heinlein WD, Anterior teeth: esthetics and function. J Pros-
patient’s rest position and smile, as 8. Yuodelis RA, Faucher R, Provisional restorations: An thet Dent 44(4):389-93, 1980.
well as evaluated phonetically. In ad- integrated approach to periodontics and restorative dentistry. 22. Cho GC, Donovan TE, Chee WW, Clinical experiences
Dent Clin North Am 24(2):285-303, 1980. with bonded porcelain laminate veneers. J Calif Dent Assoc
dition, the patient is actively involved 9. Phillips K, Morgan R, The acrylic occlusal plane guide: A tool 26(2):121-7, 1998.
in the diagnostic process providing for esthetic occlusal reconstruction. Compend Contin Educ 23. Donovan TE, Cho GC, Diagnostic provisional restorations
feedback and sharing the responsibil- Dent 22(4):302-4, 306, 2001. in restorative dentistry: The blueprint for success. J Can Dent
10. Magne P, Magne M, Belser U, The diagnostic template: a key Assoc 65(5):272-5, 1999.
ity for the final result. The patient will element to the comprehensive esthetic treatment concept. Int 24. Zarb G, Bolender C, Carlsson G, (eds), Boucher’s prost-
be more likely to accept a result that he J Periodontics Restorative Dent 16(6):560-9, 1996. hodontic treatment for edentulous patients, 11th edition. St
or she visualized and co-diagnosed. 11. Kahng LS, Patient-dentist-technician communication within Louis: Mosby, 1997.
the dental team: Using a colored treatment plan wax-up. J 25. Spear FM, Kokich VG, Mathews DP, Interdisciplinary
Obtaining clinical information to Esthet Restor Dent 18(4):185-93; discussion 194-5, 2006. management of anterior dental esthetics. J Am Dent Assoc
guide the diagnostic wax-up is an impor- 12. Magne P, Magne M, Belser U, Natural and restorative oral 137(2):160-9, 2006.
tant concept. This method will enhance esthetics. Part I: Rationale and basic strategies for successful
esthetic rehabilitations. J Esthet Dent 5(4):161-73, 1993. to request a printed copy of this article, please contact
the predictability of the treatment, 13. Magne P, Belser UC, Novel porcelain laminate preparation Harel Simon, DMD, 9735 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 200, Beverly Hills,
minimize loss of chairtime, and help to approach driven by a diagnostic mock-up. J Esthet Restor Dent Calif., 90212.
obtain patient acceptance from the 16(1):7-16; discussion 17-8, 2004.
14. Doan PD, Goldstein GR, The use of a diagnostic matrix in
beginning of treatment. the management of the severely worn dentition. J Prosthodont
16(4):277-81, 2007.
r efer e nces 15. Gurel G, Bichacho N, Permanent diagnostic provisional
1. Chiche GJ, Pinault A, Esthetics of anterior fixed prosthodon- restorations for predictable results when redesigning the
tics. Chicago, Quintessence Publishing Co., 1994. smile. Pract Proced Aesthet Dent 18(5):281-6, 2006.
2. Preston JD, A systematic approach to the control of esthetic 16. Gurel G, Porcelain laminate veneers: Minimal tooth prepa-
form. J Prosthet Dent 35(4):393-402, 1976. ration by design. Dent Clin North Am 51(2):419-31, ix, 2007.
3. Magne P, Belser U, Bonded porcelain restorations in the an- 17. Romeo G, Bresciano M, Diagnostic and technical approach
terior dentition a biomimetic approach, first ed. Carol Stream, to esthetic rehabilitations. J Esthet Restor Dent 15(4):204-16,
Ill., Quintessence Publishing Co., 2002. 2003.
4. Rufenacht CR, Fundamentals of esthetics. Chicago: Quintes- 18. Simon H, Raigrodski AJ, Gingiva-colored ceramics for en-
sence Publishing Co., 1990.
3 6 2 m ay 2 0 0 8