Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/282804363
Testing Reading
CITATIONS READS
0 10,162
1 author:
Fernandes Arung
Universitas Sulawesi Tenggara
21 PUBLICATIONS 4 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Fernandes Arung on 13 October 2015.
TESTING READING
Abstract
This paper focuses on testing reading which provides four general
types of test, and the purposes of the test which distinct between a
test itself and the assessment. This paper provides the general
preparations prior to conducting the test but each test is completed
also with special feature of preparation and what points to be
assessed. The significance of this paper is hopely to provide teachers
in conducting the test especially testing reading so that they can
understand what testing reading is, what to assess, how to prepare it,
and how to cunduct it.
A. Introduction
Reading is an art to comprehend the writers’ aim to be connected to the readers’
conceptualization. The art here refers to an aesthetics and reliability to what is being
read. The art refers to as finding out a burried treasures from a word, phrase,
sentence, paragraph, and discourse. Comprehending; reading context, means the
ability to understand written text in order to get the gist of what is written.
Conceptualization refers to a prior knowledge of the reader that is being in reader’s
mind used as a flexible filter in doing reading. In order to understand what reading is
and how to do and improve it, it is better to see what Shepherd & Mitchell showed as
follow:
In order to understand how we read and how reading may be improved, we must
first look a little at how the eye works. Light entering the eye is focused by the
lens onto the retina, which lines the inside of the eye. The retina itself consists of
hundreds of millions of tiny cells responsive to light. Some cells - the cones -
respond to specific colors; others - the rods - to the overall light intensity. These
cells are connected to a web of nerves extending over the retina, which relay
information to the visual cortex. The centre of the retina, called the fovea, is a
small area in which the cells are much more tightly packed, so that the perception
of images falling on the fovea is much sharper and more detailed than elsewhere
on the retina. When we focus our attention on something, the light from that item
is focused onto the fovea - this is called a fixation (Shepherd & Mitchell, 1997)
1
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
Reading is not easy as what people think, it needs an intereset as the substantive
step to go on reading comprehension. Many other things needed to do reading to go
further to the level of keen on reading then to the level of reading fluency and
comprehension.
In order to know such level of reading, it is important to do a test and assessment.
The previous research showed reading comprehension as a low achievement. The
National Center for Education Statistic (2002) in Rathvon (2004) reported as follows:
On the 2002 NAEP reading assessment, 36% of fourth graders scored at the
Below Basic level in reading, indicating that they are unable to read and
comprehend a simple paragraph from a grade-level text. Moreover, there are
profound differences in reading achievement among racial/ethnic groups.
Among African American, Hispanic, and American Indian/Alaska Native
students, the respective percentages of fourth graders reading at the Below
Basic level were 60%, 56%, and 49%, compared with 25% and 30% for
white and Asian/Pacific Islander students (National Center for Education
Statistics, 2002).
Again, reading comprehension is not easy to do. In Asia, it indicated that the
students in fourth graders were very low in reading ability and in comprehending a
simple paragraph from a grade-level text. Rathvon further said that “many questions,
controversies, and challenges remain regarding the most effective way of identifying
children at risk for reading problems”.
Testing reading is important to do in order to evaluate the aspects that can be
used to arise the effective way of analyzing and identifying the needs to be put into
account concern reading.
B. Discussion
Testing reading seems to be cofusing since no understanding what items to be
tested. Reading comprehension, fluency, speed, includes making the text of the test,
the validity, reliability, difficulty, and types of the test should be absolutely
considered at all. The followings are the discussion on testing reading in the hope that
teachers can understand how to do testing reading for the students.
2
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
A test is just to assess, measure, and evaluate, it is not a judgement at all. Testing
is closely related to assessing and they should walk together. A test is done by
teacher for the students but assessment is done by the teacher and the student. A
test includes formal and informal assessment and self-assessment. A formal
assessment is a test or exam conditions are established, is certainly an important
way of assessing learners while informal assessment is assessment carried out by
the teacher not under special test conditions, but in the normal classroom
environment or a way of collecting information about our students’ performance
in normal classroom conditions (for example with students helping each other
when necessary). Self-assessment is that carried out by students themselves of
their own progress and problems (Harris & McCann, 1994).
An assessment is a part of a test, it is usually done before, in progress, and or
after the learning. To assess means to estimate and not to judge to be said as
success or not but a test might be said to decide as success or failure. An
3
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
4
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
3. Assessment of Learning
This assessment is done when teachers use evidence of students’
learning to make estimations on students’ achievement against goals and
standards. This assessment is included in summative test.
b) Testing Reading
There will be four skills that can be tested deal with language proficiency. If
we deal with testing of reading then we may involve speaking and listening
because when someone is tested in reading such as reading aloud then s/he seems
to speak and listen to some items that will be tested such as the intonation, sterss,
sounds, applying phonics, etc. Testing reading seems to be very easy at first
glance but it would be very difficult when trying to conduct at various level and
types of the tests. Hughes said (2003) that the basic problem is that receptive
skills exercises (reading and listening) does not necessarily manifest itself
directly in the overt behaviour because when people write and speak, we can see
and hear but when people read and listen, we often have nothing to observe.
There are some considerations to be involved when doing the test of reading and
those should be put into account such as what to test and assess, types of test,
how to test, and when to test.
In doing test of reading, it is urged to decide what to assess so that we can
determine the type of the test appropriately to take out. After deciding the first
step, tester should identify the level of testee and the ages because each level of
ages has different ability concerns reading ability. Preparation for expeditious
reading test will be the tester’s ability in how to test whether it will be skimming,
search reading, and or scanning (Hughes, 2003). Mohamad (1999) said that when
tester is preparing the assessment, s/he may go through some of the
considerations such as ensuring that tester selects an appropriate text, making
sure that the language used in the text is suitably pitched to his/her students'
5
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
proficiency, and scrutinising the text to ensure that the information in each
paragraph is tested.
Dealing with the operation or the preparation of the test, Hughes further
suggests careful reading operation as follow:
1. Identifying proniminal reference.
2. Identifying discourse markers.
3. Interpreting complex sentences.
4. Interpreting topic sentences.
5. Outlining logical organisation of a text.
6. Outlining the development of an argument.
7. Distinguishing general statements from examples.
8. Identifying explicitly stated main ideas.
9. Identifying implicitly stated main ideas.
10. Recognizing writer’s intention.
11. Recognizing the attitudes and emotions of the writer.
12. Identifying addressee or audience for a text.
13. Identifying what kind of text is involved (e.g. editorial, diary, etc.)
14. Distinguishing fact from opinion.
15. Distinguishing hypothesis from fact.
16. Distinguishing fact from rumour or hearsay.
After making preparation, then a tester should be better to make some inferences
such as the following:
1. Inferring the meaning of an unknown word from context.
2. Making propositional informational inferences, answering questions
beginning with who, when, and what.
3. Making propositional explanatory inferences concerned with
motivation, cause, consequence and enablement, answering questions
beginning with why and how.
4. Making pragmatic inferences.
6
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
7
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
8
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
9
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
Filling, Information Transfer, Matching the Two Parts of Split Sentences, The
Cpmpletion of Sentences-Summaries-Diagrams-Tables-Flow Charts- Notes, and
Matching Paragraph Headings.
All the things above should be considered in testing reading in order to
postulate all characteristics that are significant to embed in and to find all
domains the test of reading.
10
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
2. Allowing the candidates spell the letters prior to giving them correct
spelling.
3. Writing all misspelling letters and aspects that the candidates did.
4. Allowing the candidates to repeat spelling from the beginning to three
times.
5. Concluding all aspects that candidates did during spelling the letters.
Telling them what letters were misspelled.
6. In order to let the candidates learn, tester should teach them how to
correctly spell the letters.
Tests used to measure the candidates’ reading comprehension should be
based on candidates’ level and provide various techniques.
Reading Fluency. Reading fluency refers to accurate and automatic
decoding of the words in the text, along with expressive interpretation of the text,
to achieve optimal comprehension. Wagaman (2013) in eHow Contributor
defined fluency as the combination of speed of reading and the ability to read
with expression. In this test, candidates are supposed to read with appropriate
phrasing and interpretation. Fluent reading requires speedy recognition of words,
decoding accuracy, and oral expressiveness; these are to be assessed. One of the
simple tests to assess children’s reading fluency is by oral reading. This is also
important to improve their reading speed adn develop stronger vocabulary. The
way is simple where the parent reads out loud at the rate they'd like their child to
attain. This is done while their child reads along with them. This should model
what reading fluency looks like. It helps the child read at a faster rate. This
activity should be done with a grade appropriate book so that the child does not
get frustrated. Wagaman recommeded some instructions in conducting reading
fluency test as follow:
1. Choosing a book or passage for the student to read. The child may need
to read several different levels of books before the proper reading level
is determined, so it is a good idea to have several levels on hand prior to
11
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
beginning the test. The optimal level is one in which the child is able to
read fluently, but not perfectly. Perfect reading would indicate the child
has mastered this level of reading, known as the independent level.
2. Telling the child to begin reading aloud while starting a stopwatch. The
amount of time it takes the student to read the book will help determine
the child's fluency.
3. Take a running record while the child is reading. A running record is a
written record of the child's reading. It is basically a shorthand method
of writing down everything the child reads, correctly and incorrectly.
Some of the basic notations include a check mark for a correctly read
word, a dash for a word left out, and a carrot to insert a word if the child
adds an extra word to the sentence. If the word was read incorrectly, you
should write whatever the child said, phonetically. For example, if the
word was "house," you might right "hos." If the child self-corrects, or
says a word incorrectly but then repeats it correctly, add the letters SC
next to the notation, indicating the fact that the student corrected
himself.
4. Observe the student's ability to read with expression. Expressive reading
involves changes of pitch, volume, rhythm and tone of voice while
reading. Students who do not read with expression will often sound
choppy or speak in a monotone. Reading with expression should sound
like normal conversation.
5. Determine reading accuracy. After the child has completed the reading,
you need to decide if any of the mistakes changed the meaning of the
story. Errors that do not change the meaning do not count against the
student for determining fluency. Examples of mistakes that do not
change the meaning include mispronounced names. A 90 percent to 96
percent accuracy rate is considered instructional level, or the level at
which the child should read at school. To determine accuracy rate,
12
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
divide the number of words read correctly by the total number of words.
So for example, if the student read 187 words correctly out of a total of
200 words, the student's accuracy rate is 94 percent. This would be a
book at an instructional level for this child.
6. Determine reading rate. To determine the child's reading rate, you need
to know how many total words there were in the story that the child
read, how many words the child read correctly and how long it took the
child to read the story. Then divide the total number of words read
correctly by the total amount of time it took to read the story.
Continuing our example from above, if the student read 187 words
correctly in a minute and a half, the student read 125 words per minute.
This is in the instructional range for a fifth grader.
7. Determine reading fluency by looking at the accuracy rate, reading rate
and child's ability to read with expression. The accuracy and reading
rates should be in the instructional range, and the child should read with
some expression to be considered to be reading fluently.
Tests used to measure the candidates’ reading fluency should be based on
candidates’ level and provide various techniques.
Reading Speed. This test is almost the same as testing reading fluency but
the speed in time is prominent. Hughes (2003) explained speed as follow:
Reading speed may be expressed in words per minute. Different speed will
be expected for careful and expeditious reading. In the case of the latter, the
candidates is, of course, not expected to read all of the words. The expected
speed of reading will combine with the number and difficulty of the items to
determine the amount of time needed for the test, or part of it.
(Hughes, 2003, p. 141)
Speed reading is the art of silencing subvocalization (Spreeder.Com, 2010-
2012). Nordquist in About.Com said that subvocalization means saying words
silently to oneself while reading (Nordquist, R. 2013) but subvocalization is
unnecessary to the adult reader, except perhaps when reading poetry (Shepherd
13
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
& Mitchell, 1997). One of the best techniques in fasting reading is to less eyes
movement. Cutler (1993) flatten the study result that slow reader may make as
many or more visual stops per line as there are letters in the words on that line.
Good reader may stop (fixate) only once every two or three words, taking larger
visual “bites” as they move forward. Excellent readers seldom stop (visually
fixate) more that twicw per line, and only once on the shorter line-lenghts.
In testing reading speed, the only thing to assess is the speed. How many
words per minute a reader can read clearly and accurately. There are at least
some preparartions to conduct the reading speed such as follow:
1. Determining the level of candidates that is intended to test.
2. Providing stop-watch in order to count minute and a recorder to record.
3. Providing any text that depends on candidates’ level.
4. Asking the candidates one by one to read as a tester starting to turn on
the watch.
5. Asking the candidate to stop reading as the time is enough for a minute.
6. Counting how mwny words that the candidate has read during minute.
Tests used to measure the candidates’ reading speed should be based on
candidates’ level and provide various techniques. This website
http://www.studygs.net/reading.htm and http://www.readingsoft.com/ are
recommended if anyone wants to test his/her reading speed by online.
Reading Comprehension. It is better to define comprehension in terms of
reading that it refers to be able to find meaning of what is read or the ability to
understand what is being read, Gunning (2010) said that comprehension is a
constructive process in which students create meaning based on their background
knowledge. He further said that the more background knowledge you bring to an
article or story, the better you will understand it. It indeed needs time to be being
comprehension, Blachowicz & Ogle (2008) stated that comprehension does not
happen in one point; rather, it is a process that takes place over time. It of course
needs times to be able to comprehend what is read so it needs to read as a habit.
14
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
After going through the preparation, it is then important to decide what level
to assess. Mohamad (1999) said that there are actually three main levels or
strands of comprehension as follow:
15
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
C. Conclusion
Each type of testing has different points to consider but all of test is not easy to
make or to do. Every tester should be aware of how to prepare, conduct, and involve
some important thing to include in the test that is going to conduct.
In testting reading, some points should be understood in order to be best in
conducting the test. Starting to make preparation such as decide what to assess,
determining the level of testee, and providing them the understanding of doing the
test.
Dealing with what to assess, there are some types of tests that can be conducted
such as Reading Decoding which aims to assess whether the children are able to code
or decipher sounds and phonics in a letter and or words or not and there are at least
six steps to do to prepare the test. The next test is Reading Fluency which aims to
16
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
assess the accuracy and automatic decoding of the words in the text, along with
expressive interpretation of the text, to achieve optimal comprehension and there are
at least seven instructions to be followed in conducting the test. Reading Speed is one
of the tests in testing reading. This test aims to assess the speed; how many words
attained or read in minute and of course clearly and accurately. There are at least six
steps to follow to preapare the test. The last type of reading test is Reading
Comprehension that is the general testing of reading because this includes the ability
to decode, fluency, and speed. It is not only three of the things mentioned before but
it is more to how to understand what is read.
REFERENCES
Cutler, Wade E. 1993. Triple Your Reading Speed-Third Edition. New York:
Macmillan General Reference
Hughes, Atrhur. 2003. Testing for Language Teacher – Second Edition. United
Kingdom: Cambridge University Press
17
Language Testing & Evaluation
Fernandes Arung
2013
Shepherd, Peter. & Mitchell, Gregory U. 1997. The Speed Reading Course.
Www.ebusinesshelpcenter.com
18