Professional Documents
Culture Documents
No.35
SEPTEMBER 2015
Lack of access to financial services can represent perspective as a 10 per cent rise in remittances
a major impediment to income opportunities and may contribute to 3.5 per cent reduction in the
economic welfare of individuals, particularly for share of people living in poverty, and it is estimated
the poor, women and youth, rural populations, that a 5 per cent reduction on remittance transfer
migrants and those engaged in the informal costs could yield $15 billion in savings. This is
economy, as well as for firms, particularly SMEs recognized by the SDGs proposal, through target
and microenterprises. In 2014, 61 per cent of 10.c to reduce costs to less than 3 per cent of
people over 15 years old held an account with remittances and eliminate corridors with costs
a formal financial institution. Women, with 57 per higher than 5 per cent by 2030, and also underlined
cent, and youth, with 45 per cent, are worse off. in the synthesis report from the United Nations
Although this represents a great improvement
Secretary-General on the post-2015 sustainable
with respect to 2011 (51 per cent of people over
development agenda. Financial services such as
15 years old held an account, with 47 per cent for
savings, loans and insurances, are also important
women and 37 per cent for youth), it is necessary
to maximize the development role of remittances
to go much further. Financial services are more
by facilitating options to invest these private
available to the 8.4 per cent of the world population
funds in productive activities, social services and
that concentrate 83.3 per cent of total wealth,
infrastructure. These investment options may
even if the remaining 91.6 per cent, although with
modest average wealth holding, represent more comprise diaspora funds and this channelling
than $40 trillion. The share of adults in developed may be enhanced through financial education
countries with an account with a formal financial and tax and credit incentives. As indicated in the
institution is more than twice that of developing following table, remittances represent a relatively
countries. In developing economies, only 34 per stable source of revenue for recipient countries
cent of firms take out bank loans, compared to and support their development. On the other
51 per cent in developed economies. hand, remittances represent a promising source
of demand for financial services and may thus
contribute to financial inclusion.
Financial inclusion and
remittances Personal remittances receipts as percentage of GDP
by type of economy, 2008-2013
Actions towards financial inclusion could
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
contribute to facilitated, speedier, safer and less
costly transfer of remittances. Such reduction Developed 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3
in costs can in fact be promoted, for instance, Transition 1.4 1.7 1.4 1.4 1.4 1.4
by regulation promoting interoperability, shared Developing 1.8 1.7 1.6 1.5 1.5 1.5
infrastructure, the combined use of banking, Africa 3.4 3.3 3.3 3.2 3.3 3.2
postal and telecommunication networks, America 1.5 1.4 1.2 1.1 1.1 1.1
competition policies, financial infrastructure as
Asia 1.7 1.6 1.5 1.5 1.4 1.4
payment systems, and transparency on transfer
costs. This is important from a development Source: UNCTADStat.
Barriers and strategies for making available data analytics on customers’
financial inclusion financial lives. Depending on a critical mass of
users and on the specific regulatory environment,
Several barriers of access to financial services mobile money schemes are not a panacea for
have been identified, encompassing lack of financial inclusion. Operations are limited by low
money, irregular income, unemployment, costs levels of liquidity in network agents, and some
– including high interest rates, ownership of an are less suitable for the elderly and people with
account by a family member, distance and low disabilities.
connectivity, documentation constraints, lack of The regulatory focus for digital financial services
trust, lower education or financial literacy, and low should be on promoting network interoperability,
availability of financial providers. Efforts towards enabling innovation without prescribing a specific
the identification of barriers and determinants of bank or telecom-centric model, licensing for a
financial inclusion are important to design policy level playing field, and on addressing information
responses. security risks. The coordination between
Innovative business models have emerged, different regulators is important and applies to
addressing barriers to access to financial services the interaction between financial and telecom
and creating new business opportunities. regulators and also to the interaction between
State-owned, cooperative, development and regulators of different countries. Standardization
community banks have proved to be particularly of systems used in digital financial services
amenable in extending access to finance to a businesses is important as the fragmentation of
broader range of untapped population and income standards can create barriers to the proliferation
groups. These banks – as examples may be cited of technology that requires economies of
the Brazilian Development Bank, and cooperative scale. Decisions on technology convergence
models in China, northern Italy, Germany and or coexistence should ensure that standards
Switzerland – have supported productive do not become barriers for developing-country
investment, promoted competition, and operators in their endeavour to participate and
contributed to proven resilience in compensating serve their populations.
credit crunch. New payment technologies and
the use of banking correspondents have enabled The central role of public policy
the combined use of banking, postal and retail mix and regulatory frameworks
networks to expand coverage and reduce
costs in the provision of financial services. The Furthermore, financial services have market
banking correspondent models range from cash- failures. When not adequately regulated,
merchants to fully fledged banks, with associated information asymmetry or weak consumers’
proportional adjustments in regulation. The postal protection laws could result in undersupply
bank in Brazil has opened 10 million accounts in of credit for particular population groups and
10 years, and it is estimated that 1 billion people cause excess supply and indebtedness for
in over 50 countries are banked through postal others. Imperfect competition could lead to
systems. market concentration, raising costs and market
segmentation, and causing undersupply in
New technologies may reduce physical and
rural areas, for the poor, and for the economy
economic barriers to access to financial
in general. Undiversified financial sectors could
services by improving enabling infrastructure
be vulnerable to external shocks and disrupt
readiness such as interconnection platforms,
stable supply. These market failures point to
and identification and authentication systems.
the importance of sound regulations to promote
Technology also allows for new payment systems
effective financial inclusion, universal access,
and networks, including mobile money schemes
and competition. For instance, microfinance
that capitalize on mobile telephony uptake to
is credited with providing financial services to
offer a variety of financial services with lower
underserved segments, although with risks of
infrastructural costs, increase coverage, and tend
microcredit oversupply and over indebtedness.
to be more gender-neutral and youth-friendly. An
often cited example is M-PESA in Kenya that Governments can play an important role in financial
had, at the end of March 2012, 15 million active inclusion by developing a sound regulatory and
customers. This digital dimension can contribute institutional framework that envisages efficient
further to financial inclusion in particular services. markets and equitable and affordable access to
It can, for instance, facilitate remittances by financial services, and moving from principles to
making viable the transfer of small amounts, specific actions. A tailored and comprehensive
provide information enabling the assessment of policy mix towards financial inclusion should
credit risk, and increase willingness to save by include building a robust institutional environment
and ensuring adequate infrastructure, including regulation of foreign firms has become a salient
communications and energy. It should promote issue with their substantial presence in domestic
technological innovation and the collection and financial markets and with the risk of “cherry
analysis of data towards evidence-based policies. picking”. Therefore, trade liberalization efforts
Furthermore, it must promote competition and need to be carefully coordinated and synchronized
consumer protection. Governments can also with adequate domestic regulations to promote
consider direct measures, such as subsidies and financial inclusion and stability. A coherent
mandatory requirements, particularly towards approach that ensures the right to regulate is
universal access. These may encompass the necessary between multilateral efforts under the
obligation to offer basic or low-fee accounts such Doha Round and parallel liberalization processes
as the no-frills accounts in India, exemptions from such as the Trade in Services Agreement and
some onerous documentation requirements and regional trade agreements (RTAs), including
other universal services obligations. Applying mega-regional trade agreements, which go
regulation in a proportionate manner by defining deeper in influencing domestic regulation.
differentiated requirements to attend different
Regarding credit services, global efforts
needs, whenever feasible, is central to support
regarding financial inclusion need to focus
many of these financial inclusion initiatives. In the
on channelling financial resources to the real
Philippines, requirements on risk management,
economy in a sustainable way in both developing
capital, liquidity and others were applied in
and developed countries. The importance of this
a proportionate way to non-bank providers,
focus is supported by recent examples, such as
with the application of transaction limits and of
the new strong relationship between corporate
ring fencing of e-money operations. Policies
borrowing and shareholders’ payouts in the
should also aim at promoting demand through
United States, and interfinancial credits much
financial literacy and availability of information,
higher than financing used by the real economy
including the use of standards for disclosure and
in the Euro area. Financial inclusion efforts need
transparency; and, when adequate, increasing
to pay particular attention to the poor, women,
the use of financial services by the government.
and youth. Although it is necessary to continue
The Reserve Bank of India promotes payment
supporting all economic activities, policy and
of direct benefit transfers, such as pensions,
regulatory frameworks should aim in particular
through electronic transfer.
towards higher value added economic activities.
The regulatory framework should pursue financial In this context, the adoption of financial inclusion
inclusion simultaneously with financial integrity policies by decision makers, together with an
and stability. Further research is needed to identify enabling mix of macroeconomic, trade, industrial
possible synergies or compromises between and other policies, needs to ensure that financial
these regulatory objectives. Trade liberalization services, including savings, credit, insurance
also impacts the financial inclusion regulatory and other services, remain in support of the real
framework, specifically in measures related economy and of the SDGs in the post-2015
to universal access. In particular, the effective world.
Contact
Mina Mashayekhi
Head Trade Negotiations
and Commercial
Diplomacy Branch For more on this topic and references, refer to the following documents:
DITC, UNCTAD
UNCTAD (2015). Services Policy Review: Paraguay. United Nations publication. UNCTAD/DITC/TNCD/2014/2.
Press Office New York and Geneva.
+41 22 917 58 28
UNCTAD (2014). Report on the Expert Meeting on the Impact of Access to Financial Services, including by
unctadpress@unctad.org
Highlighting Remittances on Development: Economic Empowerment of Women and Youth. TD/B/C.I/EM.6/3. 15
www.unctad.org December.
UNCTAD, 2014, Impact of access to financial services, including by highlighting remittances on development:
Economic empowerment of women and youth, 3 September, TD/B/C.I/EM.6/2.
UNCTAD/PRESS/PB/2015/7 (No. 35)
UNCTAD (2014). Services Policy Review: Nicaragua. United Nations publication. UNCTAD/DITC/TNCD/2013/13.
New York and Geneva.
UNCTAD (2014). Services, development and trade: The regulatory and institutional dimension. TD/B/C.I/MEM.4/5.
3 February.
UNCTAD (2013). Services Policy Review: Lesotho. United Nations publication. UNCTAD/DITC/TNCD/2012/1. New
York and Geneva.
UNCTAD (2013). Report of the Multi-year Expert Meeting on Trade, Services and Development on its first session.
TD/B/C.I/MEM.4/3. 12 March.