Professional Documents
Culture Documents
be true or false (they are truth-apt), which noncognitivists deny.[1] Cognitivism is so broad a thesis
that it encompasses (among other views) moral realism (which claims that ethical sentences express
propositions about mind-independent facts of the world), ethical subjectivism (which claims that
ethical sentences express propositions about peoples' attitudes or opinions), and error theory (which
claims that ethical sentences express propositions, but that they are all false, whatever their nature).
Contents
1Overview
2Cognitivism and subjectivism
3Cognitivism and objectivism
4See also
5Notes
6Further reading
7External links
Overview[edit]
Propositions are what meaningful declarative sentences (but not interrogative or imperative
sentences) are supposed to express. Different sentences, in different languages, can express the
same proposition: "snow is white" and "Schnee ist weiß" (in German) both express the proposition
that snow is white. A common belief among philosophers who use this jargon is that propositions,
properly speaking, are what are true or false (what bear truth values; they are truthbearers).
To get a better idea of what it means to express a proposition, compare this to something that does
not express a proposition. Suppose someone minding a convenience store sees a thief pick up
a candy bar and run. The storekeeper manages to exclaim, "Hey!" In this case, "Hey!" does not
express a proposition. Among the things that the exclamation does not express are, "that's a thief
there"; "thieving is wrong"; "please stop that thief"; or "that thief really annoys me." The storekeeper
isn't saying anything that can be true or false. So it is not a proposition that the storekeeper is
expressing. Perhaps it is an emotional state that is being expressed. The storekeeper is surprised
and angered, and expresses those feelings by saying, "Hey!"
Ethical cognitivists hold that ethical sentences do express propositions: that it can be true or false,
for example, that Mary is a good person, or that stealing and lying are always wrong. Cognitivists
believe that these sentences do not just express feelings, as though we were saying, "Hey!" or "Yay
for Mary!"; they actually express propositions that can be true or false. Derivatively, a cognitivist or a
realist would say that ethical sentences themselves are either true or false. Conversely, if one
believes that sentences like "Mary is a good person" cannot be either true or false, then one is
a non-cognitivist.
Notes[edit]
1. ^ "Moral Cognitivism vs. Non-Cognitivism". Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
2. ^ Brandt 1959, p. 153: "[Objectivism and subjectivism] have been used more vaguely, confusedly, and
in more different senses than the others we are considering. We suggest as a convenient usage,
however, that a theory be called subjectivist if and only if, according to it, any ethical assertion implies
that somebody does, or somebody of a certain sort under certain conditions would, take some
specified attitude toward something."
3. ^ "moral subjectivism is that species of moral relativism that relativizes moral value to the individual
subject". Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy