Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2016
~
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELifii
(EXTRA ORDINARY WRIT JURISDICTION)
VERSUS
INDEX
S.NO P ARTICULAR(S) PAGE NO
FILED BY:-
New Delhi
Date : 21.03.2016 N. SAIVINOD
ADVOCATE FOR THE PETITIONER
D-131 (Basement),
Panchsheel Enclave,
New Delhi -110 017
E: nayanisavinod@gmail.com
M: (0)88 26 56 1767
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
(EXTRA ORDINARY WRIT JURISDICTION)
VERSUS
PRELIMINARY SUBMISSIONS
·.-.
'
2. The Respondents have effectively acknowledged and
admitted to the widespread statutory breaches and
irregularities by Patentees in disclosing patent working
.information, as per the Patents Act, 1970. Despite their
complete knowledge, it is evident that the Respondents
have failed to take any corrective measures for ensuring
compliance with the patent disclosure norms. More
egregiously, the Respondents have attempted to justify
their callous disregard for an important statutory
provision and their inaction against errant patentees by
stating that the imposition of statutory penalties, as
mandated under Section 122, may discourage Patentees
;
Sections 146 read with 122 of the Patents Act and Rules
thereunder.
A. Public consultation
;I
. ·~"""-"'""''···=··----~=='•"'''•'"'~,,
rt:
,,, 3 r~·
:'.'·
TOTAL
NATURE OF DEFECTS
F-27s %
Undisclosed 79 38.3
QUANTITY
Indeterminate Units 71 58.1
Undisclosed 84. 38.3
VALUE
Forei n Denomination 4 0.1
MANUFACTURE Location Undisclosed 109 50.3
LICENSING Undisclosed 89 33.5
INFORMATION Undisclosed Details 33 50.4
..
NON-WORKING Reasons Undisclosed 28 66.7 !:
(a) The latest format has done away with the vaguely
worded phrase 'give zohatever details available'.
(b) The latest format compels the Licensee to state the
nature of license received from the Patentee (i.e.,
exclusive or otherwise).
(c) The latest format has done away with the
requirement to self-attest '·whether reasonable public
requirements have been met partially, sufficiently or
adequately?'.
(d) The latest format imposes a requirement to disclose
the details of products commercialized by using the
said patent.
,_ ..
(d) The latest format of FORM-27 has rightly done away ;:..
: .;
authorities had the complete knowledge of various
l •. ,,
,,
i
by repeating the present submissions by way of an;
I
.
additional formal representation. Nevertheless, it IS
I
,'/'
15. The contents of Paragraph Nos. (i) and (ii) do not require
any reply.
~:'
,.
i
~·
i:
l
;,
38. The contents of the Counter Affidavit in reply to
Paragraph Nos. 65 is matter of record, hence, no reply is
necessary.
40. The contents of the reply to Ground B are denied and the
corresponding submissions made in the Writ Petition are
reiterated and not repeated herein for the sake of brevity.
t-3
f;'-
,.
19 '.
I
r-~~~~·~~
I ~ «)3 20
~~~
[.·.;
FILED BY:
~·
Date : 21.03.2016 N. SAIVINOD
Place: New Delhi Advocate for the Petitioner
D-131, Panchsheel Enclave,
New Delhi -110 017
IN THE HIGH COl,JRT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
(EXTRA ORDINARY WRIT JURISDICTION)
VERSUS
AFFIDAVIT
. .·
·'
~~g~~~ru~~i~~:C~~~~~!!j) ........ .
(' • e b. ~I'
CERTIFIED THAT THE CONTENTS EXPLAINED TO THE
DEPONENT EXECUTANT WHO fS SEEMED PERFECT TO
UNDERSTAND &AF'FIRMED DEP:li5SED
B E MEAT
DELHI ON.
( 9 'ID~TJ ~·~·~·Jk;;~ . . . . . IN NT~ED.BY ~
SIGNE~N MY PRESENCE H1/i
4hA./CUi~-~11'l
, . -, .. , -
f"··4ir-~,~
, •t, .. 1::.\
!: WfJ. S ·.. ::
ot.SE.~Cl"''
· ~ . \~lr\tP"
s....... ~"'
.··-
_.· ~~
2/1/2016 https://i pi ndiaonl i ne.gov. i n/patentsearch/Gr antedSearch/ReportProjectPopU p.aspx?Appi_N o= fbfqk89YKfj6D69(3wzU Uks36cqxh5QcsrGe+ 3sh3iko% ...
L
(
i·~. •J'INTELLECTUAL
PROPERTY INDIA
PATENTS I OESIGNS I TRAOE MARKS """""'""'""
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
Controller General of Patents,Designs and Trademarks
Department of lndustnal Policy and Promotion
Ministry of Commerce and Industry
GEO(ii\APHitALINOICATIONS
Details
Application Number: IN/PCT/2001/00799/MUM
l~:~::::~.~::~.~:.'!w~.:EJ l.~~.::::.~--~.:.:.w:.::~:~:.'.:~2J
CARBOXY ARYL
1312008 ; 28/0312008 215758 0310312008 SUBSTITUTED DIPHENYL 0510712001
UREAS
l nf Pi)!~'Pl CL~:.,:,_tn~
'\·umiJt~r '·,_._.
Applicant Details
\amc OfPalcncc~
BAYER CORPORATION
Inventor Details
r-----------------------r---------------------------~
BEREND RIEDL
JACQUES DUMAS
101 TANGLEWOOD DRIVE.
#203, 5-7 CHITOSE-CHO,
210 SADDLE HILL DRIVE.
65 WJNTERHILL ROAD.
134 PARK AVENUE,
113 EDGECOMB STREET.
11 WALL STREET,
1187 MT. CARMEL AVENUE,
I1 I2
Abstract Text
A compound selected from the group consisting of the 4-chloro-3-(trifluoromethyl)phenyl ureas: N-(4-
chloro-3-(trifluoromethyl)phenyi)-N'-(3-(2-carbamoyl-4- pyridyloxy)phenyl)urea. N-(4-chloro-3-
(trifluoromethyl)phenyi)-N'-(3-(2-(N-methylcarbamoyl)-4- pyridyloxy)phenyl)urea, N-(4-chloro-3-
(trifluoromethyl)phenyi)-N'-(4-(2-carbamoyl)-4- pyridyloxy) phenyl)urea. N-(4-chloro-3-
(trifluoromethyl)phenyi)-N'-(4-(2-(N-methylcarbamoyl)-4- pyridyloxy)phenyl)urea and N-(4-chloro-3-
(trifluoromethyl)phenyi)-N'-(2-chloro-4-(2-N- methylcarbamoyl)(4-pyridyloxy)phenyl)urea, the 4-bromo-
3(trifluoromethyl)phenyl ureas: N-(4-bromo-3-(trifluoromethyl)pheny)-N'-(3-(2-(N-methylcarbamoyl)-4-
pyridyloxy)phenyl)urea, N-(4-bromo-3-(trifluoromethyl)phenyi)-N'-(4-(2-(N-methylcarbamoyl)-4-
pyridyloxy)phenyl)urea, N-(4-bromo-3-(trifluoromethyl)phenyi)-N'-(3-(2-(N-methylcarbamoyl)-4- pyridylthio)
phenyl)urea, N-(4-bromo-3-(trifiuoromethyl)phenyi)-N'-(2-chloro-4-2-(N- methylcarbamoyl)(4-
pyridyloxy))phenyl)urea, and N-(4-bromo-3-(trifluoromethyl))phenyi)-N'-(3-chloro-4-2-(N- methyl carbamoyl)
(4-pyridyloxy)phenyl)urea. the 2-methoxy-4-chloro-5-(trifluoromethyl)phenyl ureas: N-(2-methoxy-4-chloro-
5-(trifluoromethyl)phenyi)-N'-(4-2-(N-methylcarbamoyl)-4-pyridylo3cy)phenyl)urea. N-(2-methoxy-4-chloro-
5-(trifluoromethyl)phenyi)-N'-(2-chloro-4-(2-(N-methylcarbamoyl)(4-pyridyloxy))phenyl)urea. or a
phanmaceutically acceptable salt thereof.
https://ipindiaonline.gov.in/patentsearch/GrantedSearch!ReportProjectPopUp.aspx?Appi_No=fbfqk89YKfj6D69GwzUUks36cqxh50csrGe+3sh3iko%3d&P... 1/1
2/1/2016 Display Uploaded PDF Document
PDF Document
2157 5 &-CQrresJ;londence-12Q215 .pdf
-
IN-PCT-200 1-00799-MUM -CORRESPONDE~CE(4-,8-20 1O).pdf
in-pct-20Q1-00799-mum-abstract(grantecO-C3-3-2008).J?df
-- --
IJ'i-PCT-200 1-0Q799-MUM--AFFIDA VIT(6-2-20 13).Qdf
IN-PCT-2001-Q0799-MUM-APPLICATION FOR TERMINATION OF COMPULSORY
I I . , I
~
LICENSE(29-1 0-20 .
12).udf
. . '
in-}2ct-200 1-00799-mum-claims(granted)-(3-3-2008).Qdf
- --
IN-PCT-2001-00799-MUM-COMPULSORY LICENSE APPLICATION(29-7-2011).J2df
t • •
~
L~£3NICT-2001-00799-MUM-COMPULSORY LICENSE(6-2-2013).pdf
~..~~-~: ·' ~--)?;,
K ·::;;:'tT-200 1-00799-MUM-CORREAPONDENCE( 13-11-2009).12df
...;..·,<····· .
in-12ct-2001-00799-mum-corres12ondence I (29-7-2008).J2df
§;i~:~ -'---=-· • . ·- - . --------------··--------------------··----------
in-,llct-200 1-00799-mum-correspondence 2( 10-7-2008).pdf
~- --- .. ... . . ·- ...... . ---------·····-··-···········-·--·-·--------·-··----------···-······-··--·-----·
....
II
IN-PCT-2001-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCEC09-Il-2009).12df
---
IN-PCT-2001-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE( 10-4-20 I3).pdf
:?1~ IN-PCT-2001-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE(l I-11-2009).pdf
Ifl
IN-PCT-200 1-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE( 16-6-201 O).Qdf
'
IN-PCT-2001-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE(l7-11-2002).Qdf
IN-PCT-200 1-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE( 18-9-20 I 2).gdf
I
,,m
IN-PCT-200 1-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENC£(2-2-20 1O}.pdf
b·'"
!;':i:',£CT-200 1-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE(23-8-20 11 ).gdf
v····t:•
~i;({l:PCT-2001-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE(26-11-2002).Qdf
--
---
I
~-···"
IN-PCT-200 1-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE(26-5-20 1O).gdf
---
Y.>~ IN-PCT-200 1-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE(28-l1-20 11 ).pdf
~
~~~~ IN-PCT-2001-00799-MUM-CORRESPO~DE~C-~(29-1~-20_99)~1?df
e~ -- ---------
y~:<Q
~,
1
IN-PCT-2001-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE(?.9-3-_?_010).J2d!' -·------------------
IN-PCT-200 1-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE(30-9-20 11 ).Qdf
IN-PCT-2001-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE(3-1 I-2010).Qdf
IN-PCT-2001-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE(4-6-201 O).pdf
IN-PCT-2001-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE(5-11-2009).gdf
IN-PCT-2001..;00799-MUM-CORRESPONDE~CE(6-2-2~I2).pdf
----------------------
IN-PCT-200 1-00799-M~M-CORRESP9NDENCE(6.~2-2Q 1_~)Jldf ···---~~---------------------------
IN-PCT-2001-00799-MUM--CORRESPONDENCE(6-2-2013).pdf
IN-PCT-200 1-00799-MUM -CORRESPOND;EN CE-(8-6-2009).pdf
IN-PCT-2001"00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE(8-6-2010).pdf
IN-PCT-2001-00799-MUM-CORRESPONDENCE(9-6-2010).pdf
https:/lipindiaonline.gov.in/patentsearch/GrantedSearchlviewdoc.aspx?id=lbf~kB9YKfj6D69GwzUUks36cqxh5QcsrGe+3sh3iko=&loc=vsnutRQWHdTHa1... 1/3
Jci~
~
,,, t:l5
211/2016 Display Uploaded PDF Document
https://ipindiaonline.gov.in/patentsearch/GrantedSearch/viewdoc.aspx?id=fbfqk89YKfj6069GwzUUks36cqxh5QcsrGe+3sh3iko=&loc=vsnutRQWHdTHa1... 213
21112016 Display Uploaded PDF Document
i'
'·
'