Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Or
Submitted by:
Maxine B. Pasia
BPA 1-1
Submitted to:
The passage of the Bangsamoro Organic Law has been very tough and persistent
after years and decades of the struggle in peace in Mindanao. From the very beggining
of peace talks and consolidate efforts between the Government of the Philippines and the
Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF), Bangsamoro Organic Law has been ratified under
Going back in the history, when the first exploratory talks happened during the regime of
former president Fidel V. Ramos with the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF). The 1996
Final Peace Agreement, also called the Jakarta Accord was signed on September 2, 1996
Yan and Nur Misuari of the Moro National Liberation Front. The culmination of four years
of peace talks, the agreement established mechanisms designed to bring about the full
And the peace talks pursued up to the reign of the former president and now Mayor
Joseph Estrada, who declared an all-out war against the MILF after a series of terrorist
attacks in Mindanao. The 2000 Philippine campaign against the Moro Islamic Liberation
Front (MILF) was a military campaign coordinated and organized by the Armed Forces of
the Philippines (AFP) against a Muslim withdrawal group that took place during the
presidency of Joseph Estrada in the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao in the
Philippines.
Entity (BJE) was scheduled to be signed by the government and MILF. But the signed
and declared by the Supreme Court as unconstitutional and illegal. The Moro Islamic
Liberation Front and the Government of the Philippines signed a preliminary peace
agreement in the Malacañang Palace last October 15, 2012. It was under the
administration of President Benigno Aquino III, This was the Framework Agreement on
the Bangsamoro, which called for the creation of an autonomous political entity named
The Framework Agreement was later fleshed out by four Annexes and an
addendum:
process for the establishment of the Bangsamoro, and detailed the creation of the
Bangsamoro Basic Law. This Annex was signed on Feb. 27, 2013.
The Annex on Revenue Generation and Wealth Sharing - enumerated the sources of
wealth creation and financial assistance for the new Bangsamoro entity. This Annex was
government, the Bangsamoro government and the local government units under the
The Annex on Normalization - paved the way for the laying down of weapons of MILF
members and their transition to civilian life. Normalization is the process through which
the communities affected by the conflict in Mindanao can return to peaceful life and
pursue sustainable livelihood. This Annex was signed on Jan. 25, 2014.
Signed on Jan. 25, 2014, this addendum detailed the scope of waters under the territorial
jurisdiction of the Bangsamoro (12 nautical miles from the coast), and Zones of Joint
Cooperation or bodies of water (Sulu Sea and Moro Gulf) within the territory of the
Benigno Aquino III signed Executive Order 120 creating the Bangsamoro Transition
Commission (BTC) that composed with 15 members and order it to create a draft for a
Bangsamoro Basic Law. It was followed by the signing of the Comprehensive Agreement
on the Bangsamoro on 27th of March 2014, which would serve as basis for the BBL. Under
the agreement, the Islamic separatists would turn over their firearms to a third party, which
would be selected by the rebels and the Philippine government, the MILF had agreed to
decommission its armed wing, the Bangsamoro Islamic Armed Forces (BIAF). In return,
provide guidelines for the workings of the envisioned Bangsamoro government that will
replace the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM) by which the ARMM has
been the poorest region in the country, with its provinces occupying the lowest level of
pay and status of the Philippine’s human development ladder. The ARMM was described
by many as a failed experiment including the Malacañang Palace called the ARMM a
"failed experiment" and a "failed state", among the issues that has been investigated are
several failed and ghost projects and the failure of ARMM government to remit monthly
(GSIS). The peace agreement signed by the Philippine government and the Moro Islamic
Liberation Front (MILF) last March, that pursues to end the decades' long conflict in
Mindanao will manifest by the Bangsamoro Basic Law. The BBL establishes the new
Bangsamoro political identity in its place, provided its basic structure of government
aiming for the rights of the Bangsamoro people, and describes as indigenous or primordial
citizens of Mindanao and the Sulu archipelago and the adjacent islands including
Palawan. The Bangsamoro bill has been crafted and finalized after 5 months.
And an initial version of the bill was submitted by the Bangsamoro Transition
Commission (BTC) to Aquino's office back in May. Some revisions has took place to the
BTC's draft after it was denied by the MILF. To settle the disputable issues, the
government and the MILF peace panels had to meet several times in Malaysia, Manila
and Davao City. And some of the provisions in the draft law is said to may be
unconstitutional. The contentious issues has been resolve by the peace panels in late
August eventually. Which has indicated and caused to provisions on wealth and the
political entity's form of government. These resolutions were contained in a second draft
submitted to Aquino's office. And finally, Aquino met with MILF chairman Murad Ebrahim
a one on one discussion which Malacañang said finalized the mutually acceptable draft
law. Unfortunately, the deliberations on the proposed bill are suspended in the aftermath
of the deaths of 44 members of the Philippine National Police Special Action Force (PNP-
SAF) following a clash with BIFF and MILF rebels, and other armed groups in
deliberations on the proposed BBL, claiming that their troops acted in self-defense during
conducted, and still president Aquino affirmed to continue working towards peace. After
a marathon of hearings, the House Ad Hoc Committee on the BBL, the passage of the
BBL has been failed before it prorogue to give way to the campaign period.
The passage of BBL was not initially set to be tackled by the 17th Congress. The first
president from Mindanao Rodrigo Duterte is sworn and vowed to finally bring peace to
the region. After being pushed by President Rodrigo Duterte, the Congress began reading
BBL for the first time in the House of Representatives (as House Bill No. 6475) and the
Senate (as Senate Bill No. 1717) on October 3, 2017 and February 28, 2018 respectively.
The MILF and the government launched formal meetings that focused on crafting the new
law that will implement the agreement, given the failure of the Bangsamoro Basic Law.
The two parties also agreed to expand the Bangsamoro Transition Council (BTC) from
15 to 21. BBL passed the second and third readings in both the House and the Senate
on May 30 and 31, 2018. On February 10, 2017 named new members of the Bangsamoro
Transition Committee which includes at least 3 members of the MILF. The 12-member
BTC finalized its draft of the Bangsamoro Basic Law and submitted the draft to Duterte.
The proposed Bangsamoro Basic Law (BBL) was certified by Duterte a day before
Congress adjourns. The release of certification comes after his meeting with Congress
leaders. The proposed BBL was approved by The House of Representatives on the las
Both bills were supposed to be enacted before the third State of the Nation Address
(SONA) by President Duterte, with the Senate ratified the bicameral conference
committee report on the morning of July 23, 2018. The House of Representatives failed
to push through with the measure's ratification of the bicameral conference committee
report before SONA. While the Palace was dismayed by the delayed ratification of the
report by the House, Alvarez was dismissed from the Speaker's seat and replaced by
The House was only able to ratify the bicam report on Tuesday, July 24, 2018 and
then the measure was sent to Malacañang for Duterte's signature. President Duterte
signed the Bangsamoro Organic Law on July 26, 2018, The Commission on Elections
announces that the plebiscite on the landmark law will take place on January 21, 2019. It
sets the campaign period from December 7, 2018 to January 19, 2019. President Rodrigo
Duterte makes a last minute campaign for the ratification of the Bangsamoro Organic Law
(BOL) in Cotabato City despite of the obstruction Cotabato City Mayor Cynthia Guiani
Sayadi. The Commission on Elections announced on January 25, 2019 that the BOL is
"deemed ratified".
II. Salient Points of the Law (highlighting the changes from the present set-
up)
President Duterte’s administration was celebrating together with the Filipino people
especially the Moro Region for recently surpassing and fulfilling the promise of the
Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM). It's also the culmination of a peace deal signed
The BOL perpetuates some of the major provisions that are agreed upon as it
highlights the changes from its present set-up. The Bangsamoro Organic Law aims to
“establish a political entity, provide its basic structure of government in recognition of the
justness and legitimacy of the cause of the Bangsamoro people and the aspirations of
Muslim Filipinos and all indigenous cultural communities in the Bangsamoro Autonomous
Region in Muslim Mindanao to secure their identity and posterity, allowing for meaningful
self-governance within the framework of the Constitution and the national sovereignty as
The new Bangsamoro region is going to have broader autonomy, more powers
and resources, and larger territory than its predecessor. The current ARMM – Tawi-Tawi,
Sulu, Basilan, Maguindanao, and Lanao Del Sur will surely be part of the new region and
the two provinces of Marawi City and Lamitan City. It is also included the 6 municipalities
of Lanao Del Norte (Baloi, Munai, Nunungan, Pantar, Tagaloan and Tangcal) and 39
Pigkawayan and Pikit in North Cotabato, provided that the province and their
municipalities, as results from the first voting day in the Bangsamoro plebiscite. In the
case of Isabela City and Cotabato City, voters were asked if they wanted to join the
BARMM as they are not yet part of the ARMM. They were given the chance to choose
inclusion because many Moros live there and these cities were considered Muslim-
included in the ARMM, but their mother units voted against it.
The new region may also see even more areas added to its territory as a second
voting day that took place on February 6. That will be for the inclusion of 6 towns in Lanao
minister and officials. A transition government will be created for the mean time before it
is officially become the BARRM. The Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF), the
erstwhile rival organization of the MILF, will also be represented in the BTA. Indigenous
Aside from this, the 25 elected officials of the ARMM will automatically be part of the body.
This includes ARMM Governor Mujiv Hataman and current members of the ARMM's
regional assembly. If in case members of the BTA are not immediately appointed, the
Bangsamoro region. This is to prevent any power vacuum and help ensure smooth
transition until the BTA is formed. All of the ARMM's powers, functions, assets, facilities,
and funds, among others, will be transferred to the new Bangsamoro government. After
that, the election will be conducted in 2022 where the constitution of the parliament
which will be headed by a chief minister and two deputy chief minister they will also
include a Wali that will act as a ceremonial head. If the chief minister will be coming from
the main land which is Lanao Del Sur or Maguindanao then the two deputy chief minister
will be coming from the other islands of the region for it to show geographical
representation. And the 80 parliamentary members will be compose of 50% local political
parties, 40% district and 10% sectoral. The sectoral seats will also composed of women,
They have the power to build their own revenue stream and the 75% of the taxes that will
be collected from the region will give back to the Bangsamoro government. The new
region will automatically have an annual block grant which is the 5% of the internal
revenue of the national government which the BTA will allocate this funds to provide the
basic services, health, education, and social welfare and development of the region.
BARMM will also have a 5 billion pesos per year for ten years in total of 50 billion pesos
which is the special development fund for the rehabilitation of the conflict affected areas
like the Marawi City. It is also a part of normalization process of the region especially the
most affected areas from the conflicts and wars that happened before for the past
decades. They will also be given the half of the revenue from the natural resources such
For the judiciary, both autonomous regions give Shari'ah court’s jurisdiction
over cases exclusively involving Muslims in the region. The Shari'ah law is a justice
system that applies for the Muslim people in the region that is still accordingly based
on the Philippine Constitution. But it is also applies for the people who are Muslims
outside the region because there are Muslim laws existing already. In Shari'ah law, a
person who is not a Muslim but involve in a case can voluntarily choose this system if
the other party of the case is Muslim. The Islamic laws shall not apply on non-Muslims.
The OLBARMM gives the Supreme Court the authority to grant the incumbent
Shari'ah District and Court judges, who are not regular members of the Philippine Bar
a period to qualify. Tribal laws will still apply to disputes of indigenous peoples within
the region.
The MILF’s armed wing will gradually surrender their weapons and back to
their civilian life. It is also part of the normalization process. Programs for BIAF
members will be created to facilitate this, while MILF camps will be transformed into
joint peace and security teams (JPST) will be temporarily created to take care of
security in the region while regional police are strengthened. The national government
will still retain powers over military and police, and will be responsible for the defense
and security of the BARMM despite of having its own separate military and police.
This does not mean that BARMM will have its own separate military and police. The
national government will still retain powers over military and police, and will be
of the MNLF and MILF to join in the Bangsamoro Police Force that will be under the
supervision of the Philippine National Police. The National Police commission will
have the authority to waive age, height and educational attainment requirements to
facilitate the entry of the MILF and MNLF member into the police force according to
III. Comparative Analysis with existing Laws such as the Local Government
Code
This new autonomous region is the third autonomous region that has been passed
in the Philippines. The first is the Lupang Tagapagpaganap ng Pook in 1997 during the
regime of former president Ferdinand Marcos but the Muslims refused it. The second
autonomous region is the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM) and now is
believed and hoped to be the start of a new chapter and the beginning of attaining the
most awaited peace and development of the whole Bangsamoro region, as well as the
country of course. Due to the countless peace talks agreements, laws that has been
signed of the past administrations and the culmination efforts of the people involved in
Mindanao, replacing the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM). The powers
and provisions that has been ratified to this organic law is broader and more complex
than other existing laws such as the Local Government Code also known as The Republic
Act No. 7160. It is a fulfillment state policy, as enshrined in the 1987 Philippine
Constitution, to decentralize governance and allow autonomy for local government units
(LGUs). The Local Government Code is enacted to provide for a more responsive and
Constitution. And the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region will have land and water
among others. They most likely to have similarities about their provisions. But the BOL
has its own government wherein they have the freedom of self-governing and political
entity.
The Local Government Code will provide “a system of decentralization with effective
mechanisms of recall, initiative, and referendum, allocate among the different local
government units their powers, responsibilities, and resources, and provide for the
qualifications, election, appointment and removal, term, salaries, powers and functions
and duties of local officials, and all other matters relating to the organization and operation
of the local units.” LGC is a political subdivision of a nation or state constituted by law,
which has substantial control over local affairs, including the power to impose taxes, the
governing body of which is elected or appointed according to the SECTION 2. Declaration
of Policy.
In BOL, “subject to section 20, article X of the constitution and this Organic Law,
the Bangsamoro government shall exercise its authority over the following matters without
prejudice to the general supervision of the President of the Republic of the Philippines:
The Bangsamoro government will have exclusive authority over the following aspects of
food security, ancestral domain and natural resources, barter trade and counter-trade,
budgeting, business name registration, cadastral land survey, civil service, classification
revenues, cultural exchange and economic and technical cooperation, culture and
language, customary laws, development programs and laws for women, labor, the youth,
the elderly, the differently-abled, and indigenous people, disaster risk reduction and
management, ecological solid waste management and pollution control, economic zones,
industrial centers, and free ports, education and skills training, eminent domain,
fishery, marine, and aquatic resources, grants and donations” according to the Article 5,
Section 2. Therefore, the powers and authority of the BOL is very comprehensive and
inclusive especially for the Moro people. It is indeed that no one is left behind because
the rights and the development of the non-Moros and IPs are included to the BOL.
Local government units or LGUs, are divided into three levels – provinces and
independent cities; component cities and municipalities; and barangays. In one area,
Region of Muslim Mindanao for example. Below barangays in some cities and
municipalities are sitios and puroks. All of these, with the exception of sitios and puroks,
elect their own executives and legislatures. Sitios and puroks are often led by elected
barangay councilors. Unlike in the BARMM, LGU are Provinces and independent cities
are organized into national government regions but those are administrative regions and
not separately governed areas with their own elected governments. The form of the
government is very different, in the BOL they have their own chief minister and the
governors will be replaced as well as the congressmen and other government official by
the parliamentarian members. Unlike in the LGC, BOL has provided sectoral seats that
will represent the different settlers in the region. While in LGC there is no sectoral and
geographical representative, whoever wins the election, he/she will sit in the position.
There is also a provision in the BOL wherein the identity is being considered and give
current structures)
It is indeed a major life changing and a historic event not just for the Mindanao but
also for the whole country. The Bangsamoro Organic Law does not end by just passing
and ratifying the law, it is also a continuous struggle and process for completely achieving
the development and peace of the region. There are still some part of the law that still
The Philippine Constitution Association believes that the Bangsamoro Organic Law
will lead to the destruction and dismemberment of the Philippines. They also view the
provision as unconstitutional saying that the constitution must be amended since it only
Region as a distinct political entity to the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao. It also
criticized the powers given to the Bangsamoro regional legislature which it says are
originally reserved to the Philippine Congress. It also objects to some revenue from
taxation going straight to the Bangsamoro region which it says gives "unfair" advantage
If there is a major support and approval to the law, there is also some oppositions
and hesitations about the law. Regarding to the type of the government which is
parliamentary, it may cause to political dynasties that can truly affect the governance of
the elected officials and members of the government itself. But the bicameral conference
committee did not include the Anti-Political Dynasty provision in the final version of the
proposed BOL after some members “strongly opposed” it. However, the rejection of the
under the BOL according to the UST Political Science Department chairperson Dennis C.
Coronacion. That which is needed to be strengthened to avoid any problems and issues
in the long run. If the Anti-Political Dynasty is added to the provisions it could affect the
major of its structure, the parliamentary government itself. Since the 50% of the
parliament members will be designated for the parties, political dynasty is inevitable. So
it could really affect the whole structure and maybe the entire organic law itself.
Another is the annual block grant that will be given to the new region which is 5%
of the national interval revenue that is approximately more than or lower than 50 billion
pesos. It is needed to be guided and supervised throughout its allocation to make sure
that these funds will be allotted veraciously. As well as the 5 billion pesos per year special
development fund for the rehabilitation of the destructed areas in Mindanao wherein the
processes.
Next is the special provisions for the rebel groups of MNLF and MILF to join the
decommissioning of the MILF's armed forces. The dissolution of private armies and
weapons owned by many clans on the region. This is needed to be strengthened because
the possibility of rebellion is still at risk and the special development funds can possibly
use by the MILF to fund their weapons and armies. And going back to the special
provision of joining the Bangsamoro Police Force of the MNLF and MILF, the programs
for the BIAF members that will be created and MILF camps that will be transformed into
regional government. In 2015, various indigenous people groups rejected the formation
of the Bangsamoro due to lack of consultation with all stakeholders, especially the non-
Muslim indigenous people who form a huge minority in the proposed region, meaning
they oppose the possible of the enforcement of the Sharia Law. That is why the provision
in Article IV, section 9 states that “the Bangsamoro government shall recognize and
promote the rights of non-Moro Indigenous peoples within the framework of the
constitution and national laws” should be strengthened for them not to feel left out about
And most importantly the exclusive authority powers over the given aspects of
governance to them.
In conclusion, the ratification of the Bangsamoro Organic Law can pave the way to
the recognition of the posterity, identity, cause and aspirations of the Moro people as well
as the non-Moro which are the IPs, Christians and other people that is also part of the
new region. Through this organic law the aspiration of preserving the heritage, culture
and traditions of the Moros will be reinforce. And of course for the non-Moros this is also
essential because there is now a legal tool and framework that will be used by them to
officially claim their rights in peace and social, political and economic development. Giving
the opportunity of seats and representatives for the settlers and non-Moros is highlighting
the concept of inclusivity. And with this concept, the people will feel the presence of the
government, the fact that the government really cares over its jurisdiction and they include
all the people without discrimination in building the whole region. And throughout this law,
the conflict and struggle in the region will be minimized, because when there is diversity
and when there is respect on differences, the quarrels will be lessen. The social, political
and economic development are easier to achieve if there is peace because without peace
there is no development thus conflict will expectedly to commence. And this could be also
a model for the government to be applied for the whole country someday if this will be
properly implemented.
And I also have a strong feeling that if this BOL is successfully implemented this
will be the basis that a Federalism type of government could be applied for the whole
example that we can use someday for us to see if a federal type of government is really
effective and efficient to attain the development and peace. Actually, the concept and idea
of the Federalism is really good it is just our country is not ready and even the implementer
and administrators is not ready. If we pressed this type of government it has a big
possibility of failure and we could not put the whole nation at that risk. That is why this
organic law is a really good basis for us to know how we are going to achieve it slowly but
"Panukalang Batas Blg. 4994" (PDF). Office of the Presidential Adviser on the Peace
Process. Archived from the original (PDF) on 10 July 2015. Retrieved 8 July 2015.
"FAQs about the Bangsamoro Basic Law". GMA News Online. GMA Network. September
07-26.
"Archived copy" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2015-09-24. Retrieved 2015-
09-05.
Marcelo, Ver (July 24, 2018). "Road to peace in Mindanao: The Bangsamoro Organic
Andreo Calonzo (September 10, 2014). "PNoy personally submits draft Bangsamoro law
to Congress leaders". GMA News Online. GMA Network. Retrieved February 16, 2015.
"BTC rejects HB 5811; urges Congress to pass BBL "in its original form""
Cayabyab, Marc Jayson (July 25, 2016). "Duterte urges 17th Congress to pass BBL".
Merez, Arianne (11 July 2018). "Duterte to sign BBL before SONA". ABS-CBN News.
Retrieved 2018-07-25.
Placido, Dharel (23 July 2018). "No Bangsamoro law on SONA day dismays Palace".
"After one-day delay, House ratifies Bangsamoro law". Rappler. Retrieved 2018-07-25.
Placido, Dharel (23 July 2018). "Duterte to sign Bangsamoro law in 48 hours". ABS-CBN
Sabillo, Kristine Angeli (26 March 2014). "What is the Comprehensive Agreement on the
Sabillo, Kristine Angeli (2014-03-25). "500 MILF members to attend Bangsamoro accord
Avendaño, Christine (2015-05-26). "BBL: Gov't hit for lack of consultations with
https://www.rappler.com/nation/207171-bicameral-conference-committee-approval-
shariah-high-court-bangsamoro
"The Constitution of the Republic of the Philippines". www.gov.ph. Archived from the
Local Government Code of the Philippines, Book III Archived 2014-10-31 at the Wayback
Commission on Elections (18 August 2015). "COMELEC Resolution No. 9982". Republic
Congress of the Philippines (26 November 1991). "Republic Act No. 7166 - An Act
Providing for Synchronized National and Local Elections and for Electoral. Reforms,
Authorizing Appropriations Therefor, And For Other Purposes". Retrieved 23 May 2017.
"Local Government Code of 1991 (Book III: Local Government Units)". Chan Robles