Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Biofilm Dev. Jackson2014 PDF
Biofilm Dev. Jackson2014 PDF
Purpose. The purpose of this study was to assess the development of hyphal and blastospore biofilms on abraded denture
acrylic resin specimens and measure the ease of removal of these biofilms.
Material and methods. Biofilms were grown for 48 hours on abraded 1-cm2 denture acrylic resin specimens from adhered
hyphal phase C albicans or from adhered blastospores. Subsequently, all specimens were stained with Calcofluor White and
examined with confocal scanning laser microscopy. Biofilms were removed by vortex mixing in sterile phosphate buffered
saline solution. Removed cells were filtered (0.2-mm pore size). Filters were dried at 37 C for 24 hours for dry weight
measurements. Any cells that remained on the acrylic resin specimens were stained with 0.03% acridine orange and examined
with epifluorescence microscopy.
Results. Biofilms grown from both cell types contained all morphologic forms of C albicans. Although the underlying
surface topography did not affect the amount of biofilm produced, biofilms grown from hyphal phase Candida were
visibly thicker and had greater biomass (P<.05). These biofilms were less easily removed from the denture acrylic resin,
especially in the case of rougher surfaces, evidenced by the higher numbers of retained cells (P.05).
Conclusion. The presence of hyphae in early Candida biofilms increased biofilm mass and resistance to removal. Increased
surface roughness enhances retention of hyphae and yeast cells, and, therefore, will facilitate plaque regrowth. Therefore,
minimization of denture abrasion during cleaning is desirable. (J Prosthet Dent 2014;-:---)
Clinical Implications
Abrasive denture cleansing has hygiene implications, increasing
susceptibility to denture plaque accumulation. Denture plaque
harboring large amounts of yeast and hyphal cells is extremely difficult
to eradicate from the denture surface and if not managed may lead
to the onset of denture stomatitis, clinically impacting on the oral
health status of denture wearers.
a
Postgraduate student, School of Health Care Science, Manchester Metropolitan University.
b
Senior Lecturer, School of Health Care Science, Manchester Metropolitan University.
c
Interim Dean, Touro College of Pharmacy; Professor, Pharmaceutical & Biomedical Sciences, New York Medical College.
d
Senior Lecturer, School of Computing, Maths and Digital Technology, Manchester Metropolitan University.
e
Professor, School of Health Care Science, Manchester Metropolitan University.
Jackson et al
2 Volume - Issue -
Candida albicans is a known etiologic which allows dissemination of the or- These surfaces were subjected to the
agent of chronic erythematous ca- ganism and aids infection.14 Recent dentifrices with 800 strokes by using a
ndidosis (denture stomatitis). This attention to contact sensing, or thig- soft nylon bristle toothbrush (Oral B,
inflammatory disorder affects approxi- motropism, highlights a possible mech- GlaxoSmithKline Consumer Healthcare)
mately 60% of denture wearers and anism for this invasion, where hyphal tip that was rotated 180 degrees after 400
causes inflammation of the oral mu- extension is directed in response to strokes and compressed with a 2.9 N
cosa in close contact with the denture.1 contact.15 The effect of substratum sur- force. Four different degrees of rough-
As with natural dentition, dentures face topography, specifically of denture ened surfaces were used in the investi-
provide hard nonshedding surfaces that acrylic resin surfaces, on this phenome- gation: control (washed with water), low
enable the build-up of plaque biofilms non has not been investigated. Implica- abrasion (washed with Colgate cavity
over time. Candida biofilm development tions for denture hygiene and oral health protection 25:40 paste-water ratio;
on denture acrylic resin begins with also are apparent. Colgate Ltd), medium abrasion (washed
adhesion, which can either occur di- Candida morphogenesis and, specifi- with Colgate Total Whitening 25:40
rectly to the conditioned surface or via cally, the transition from yeast to hy- paste-water ratio), and the high-
a layer of pre-existing denture plaque.2 phal states are considered important abrasion test group (washed with neat
The surface topography of the denture factors in virulence. Candida biofilm Colgate luminous). After abrasion, these
has been shown to greatly influence development on denture acrylic resin is surfaces were rinsed for 30 seconds in
adhesion and subsequent retention, affected by surface topography, but the running distilled water. These test sub-
with more roughened surfaces retaining effect of topography on different strata were used to compare biofilms
more organisms.3-5 The topography of morphologic forms of Candida has not visually and evaluate biofilm mass. The
denture surfaces is difficult to regulate. previously been investigated. The null second set of surface specimens were
Newly fabricated dentures present a hypothesis for the study was that the made in house (Manchester Metropol-
topography that reflects the mucosa presence of adhered C albicans hyphae itan University) from pink, heat-
of the patient and are potentially as opposed to blastospores will not polymerized PMMA (Bracon Dental
additionally abraded during fabrication affect the development and removal of Laboratory Products). These specimens
and use. Cleaning regimens that subsequent Candida biofilm. were 1 cm2 in size and were abraded
involve the use of hard brushes or manually with p100 (162-mm grit size)
abrasive cleansers also may alter the MATERIAL AND METHODS emery paper (Wetordry; 3M) with 10
surface topography and thus may be strokes in 1 direction (downward) par-
undesirable.6 Preparation allel to the edge of a ruler.
Candida biofilm formation on den-
ture acrylic resin surfaces has been One colony of C albicans GDH 2346 Hyphal induction and biofilm
investigated and described previously.7 (NCYC 1467) cultured on Sabouraud development
In vitro, attached budding yeast cells (SAB) dextrose agar (Oxoid Ltd) was
(2-4 hours) begin to filament after 4 used to inoculate 100 mL of SAB broth, A total of 40 mL of the standard-
hours and form pseudo and true hyphae which subsequently was incubated ized cell suspension were added to 4
until after 8 hours; neighboring cells and overnight at 37 C in an orbital shaker sterile Petri dishes, each contained 3
their filaments become entwined and (DMS 360; Fisher Scientific) at 150 rpm. replicates of the test materials (PMMA
form spatially organized woven struc- The cells were harvested by centrifuga- set 1), which were then incubated for
tures. After 24 to 48 hours of undis- tion, washed twice in sterile phosphate 1 hour at 37 C without agitation.
turbed growth, the Candida biofilms buffered saline solution (PBS) (Oxoid), After adhesion, test specimens were
increase in complexity, which consists of and resuspended in PBS to an optical removed and washed gently by im-
several different layers and all morpho- density of 1.0 at 540 nm, approximately mersion in sterile water and agitation
logic fungal forms.8 The ability of C 1.23 0.14 107 cells/mL. Two differ- (while immersed) by raising and
albicans to alter its morphology is ently prepared sets of denture acrylic lowering (parallel to the base of the
considered to be an important contrib- resin specimens were used for the inves- vessel) 10 times. With sterile forceps,
utor to its virulence,9 with particular tigation of biofilm growth. Specimens, half of the replicates were subsequently
focus on hyphal forms. Candida hyphae 2 cm2, of pink, heat-polymerized poly- placed into sterile 25-mL bottles that
have been reported to enhance adhesion methyl methacrylate (PMMA) (Mead- contained 10 mL SAB broth and were
to surfaces10 and are known to bind way heat cure polymer/liquid monomer; incubated for 48 hours at 37 C to
specifically to several human proteins, Bracon Dental Laboratory Products) produce blastospore biofilms. The
including fibrinogen, c3d, and lama- were produced and abraded by Glaxo- broth was replaced with fresh sterile
nin.11-13 Candida hyphal formation also SmithKline Consumer Healthcare by medium after 24 hours. Hyphal pro-
has been suggested as being important using commercially available dentifrices duction was induced in adhered cells
for the invasion of the host epithelium, with varying levels of abrasive activity.16 on the remaining half of the test
The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry Jackson et al
- 2014 3
surfaces by incubating them in 50% XTT assay count measurements were made on
horse serum (Oxoid) (diluted with replicates, and the counts showed a
sterile water) in a preheated 37 C wa- To compare the susceptibility of hy- considerable degree of overdispersion
ter bath for 3 hours. Each test spec- phal or blastospore biofilms to denture compared with that of a Poisson distri-
imen was then washed, placed in SAB cleansers, biofilms grown from both cell bution, the negative binomial distribu-
broth, and incubated at 37 C for 48 types on the 1-cm2 PMMA surfaces tion was tested and found to adequately
hours as above (fresh medium added (abraded with p100 grit emery paper) fit the data in this respect. In addition,
after 24 hours) to produce hyphal were prepared as previously described the repeated nature of the counts made
biofilms. and incubated for 1 hour at room tem- it necessary to estimate parameters by
perature in either a denture cleanser using a generalized estimating equation
Confocal scanning laser microscopy (1 tablet [Polident; GlaxoSmithKline approach to take into account possible
Consumer Healthcare] in 200 mL sterile dependences between observations.
After 48 hours incubation, all the water at room temperature as directed by For these reasons, the count data
specimens were removed from the manufacturer guidelines) or 200 mL of were analyzed by first taking logs of the
25-mL bottles and washed as described sterile water at room temperature. The counts to stabilize the variance and
above, to remove nonadherent cells. 1-cm2 acrylic resin specimens with then using a repeated measures model
Biofilms on surfaces were dried in a class attached biofilm were removed and to account for the possible dependence
II laminar flow cabinet (BH-EN 2003, placed into small 5-mL bottles to which between successive counts. This was
Safe Lab Systems Ltd) (for 1 hour), 790 mL sterile PBS, 200 mL XTT (Sigma found to successfully stabilize the count
stained with 0.5% Calcofluor White Aldrich) dissolved in PBS to a final con- variance. Several covariance structures
diluted with 10% potassium hydroxide centration of 1 mg/mL and filter sterilized were fitted to the data to account for
(Sigma Aldrich), and incubated at room with a 0.2-mm pore size filter, and 10 mL the repeated measures, and a simple
temperature in the dark for 45 minutes Menadione (Sigma Aldrich), prepared in autoregressive model was found to
according to the manufacturer’s staining acetone to a 0.44 mM concentration provide an adequate fit.
protocol. Biofilms were visualized with immediately before each assay, was
the 40 oil immersion (Type F immer- added.17,18 The 5-mL bottles were incu- RESULTS
sion liquid; Leica) lens with confocal bated at 37 C for 3 hours, which allowed
scanning laser microscopy (DM 2005, the XTT components to interact with the Biofilms grown from blastospores
LCS SPE 1000; Leica). Ten fields were metabolically active cells in the biofilms or hyphae consisted of networks of
examined per test specimen. and which released a colored formazan budding yeast cells, hyphae, and pseu-
by-product into the supernatant. After 3 dohyphae. However, the biofilms grown
Measuring biofilm mass hours, 200 mL of supernatant from each from hyphal phase Candida contained
5-mL bottle that contained each test longer hyphae compared with the hy-
To assess biofilm mass, individual specimen was transferred to a sterile 96- phae in biofilms grown from adhered
test surfaces with attached cells were well microtiter plate (U bottomed) and blastospores, which were much shorter
vortex mixed for 30 seconds in 25-mL analyzed for optical density at 492 nm and tended to be oriented downward
bottles that contained 10 mL of sterile with a microplate reader (Multiskan toward the surface (Fig. 1). Most
water. The resuspended cells were Ascent; Thermo Lab Systems). notably, the biofilms grown from hy-
filtered through 0.2-mm pore filter phal phase Candida were abundant in
paper disks (Whatman International Statistical analysis branching hyphae that fed through the
Ltd), which were then dried for 24 biofilm structure and often appeared to
hours in a 37 C incubator and weighed The repeated observations on each join at several points, a phenomenon
against a sterile filter control. After replicate used in biofilm mass and XTT that was not seen as frequently in the
removal of the biofilms, test surfaces work were tested for any evidence of blastospore biofilms. Biofilms grown
were stained with 0.03% acridine or- dependence, and, because none was from adhered hyphal phase Candida had
ange (Sigma Aldrich) diluted with 2% found, normal linear models were fitted a significantly higher biomass (P.01)
glacial acetic acid (BDH Laboratories) to the data, and the significance of the than those grown from adhered blas-
and examined with epifluorescence effects were tested by using ANOVA. A tospores on control, low, medium, and
microscopy (Nikon Eclipse 6000; Bur- post hoc analysis of the residuals from high abraded test surfaces (Fig. 2). The
gerweeshuispad) for any remaining the fitted models suggested that the degree of surface roughness did not
attached cells. The number of retained assumption of normality was justified. significantly affect the biofilm mass.
cells and/or hyphae and the percentage The usual model for cell counts such as This difference in biofilm mass is visible
of a microscope field covered by cells those collected in this work would be to without magnification (Fig. 3).
were determined for each replicate assume a Poisson log-linear model for The effects of cell type and rough-
specimen. the counts. However, because repeated ness level of the surface on cell
Jackson et al
4 Volume - Issue -
low-abrasive cleansing regimens may from the recommended soak time, the 11. Bouchara JP, Tronchin G, Annaix V,
Robert R, Senet JM. Lamanin receptors on
be a step toward reducing Candida parameters in the present study might be
Candida albicans germ tubes. Infect Immun
colonization of denture surfaces and comparable with an overnight soak: in 1990;58:48-56.
denture plaque formation in general. any case, the work enabled the viability 12. Trochin G, Bouchara JP, Annaix V, Robert R,
Biofilms grown from hyphal phase of the different biofilms to be further Senet JM. Fungal cell adhesion molecules in
Candida albicans. Eur J Epidemiol 1991;7:
Candida survived better (indicated by the explored. 23-33.
metabolic assay XTT) than those grown 13. Lopez-ribot JL, Monteagudo C, Sepulveda P,
from adhered blastospores after exposure CONCLUSION Casanova M, Martinez JP, Chaffin WL.
Expression of the fibrinogen binding
to both denture cleanser and water, mannoprotein and the laminin receptor
probably due to the presence of greater The presence of hyphae increased the of Candida albicans in vitro and in infected
numbers of more established hyphae retention of Candida on denture acrylic tissues. FEMS Microbiol Lett 1996;142:
117-22.
and/or increased biomass. The biofilm resin surfaces and, therefore, increased
14. Kumamoto CA, Vinces MD. Contributions of
phenotype is known to confer various its presence in subsequent plaque hyphae and hypha co-regulated genes to
advantages by increasing resistance to formed on the surface. More cells were Candida albicans virulence. Cell Microbiol
antimicrobial challenges and by protect- retained on surfaces that were more 2005;7:1546-54.
15. Gow NAR. Growth and guidance of the
ing cells from mechanical forces.18,20 The heavily abraded. These findings have fungal hypha. Microbiology 1994;140:
denture plaque biofilm, therefore, poses implications in terms of denture hygiene 3193-205.
a challenge to hygiene procedures. There procedures. 16. Charman KM, Fernandez P, Loewy Z,
Middleton AM. Attachment of Streptococcus
are many protocols available for denture oralis on acrylic substrates of varying
cleaning.6 Those protocols that involve REFERENCES roughness. Lett Appl Microbiol 2009;48:
the use of denture cleansers commonly 472-7.
1. Bilhan H, Sulun T, Erkose G, Kurt H, 17. Silva WJ, Seneviratne J, Parahitiyawa N,
consist of a simple 5- to 15-minute soak,
Erturan Z, Kutay O, et al. The role of Candida Rosa EAR, Samaranayake LP, Del Belcury AA.
followed by a rinse. Brushing also is rec- albicans hyphae and Lactobacillus in denture- Improvement of XTT assay performance for
ommended, to ensure that plaque and related stomatitis. Clin Oral Investig studies involving Candida albicans biofilms.
debris are removed from the surface. 2009;13:363-8. Braz Dent J 2008;19:364-9.
2. Pereira-Cenci T, Del Belcury AA, Crielaard W, 18. Ramage G, Vande Walle K, Wickes BL,
As with these findings, some denture Ten Cate JM. Development of Candida asso- Lopez-Ribot JL. Standardised method
cleansers have been demonstrated to be ciated denture stomatitis: new insights. for in vitro antifungal susceptability
effective in reducing, but not eradicating, J Appl Oral Sci 2008;16:86-94. testing of Candida albicans biofilms.
3. Verran J, Maryan CJ. Retention of Candida Atimicrob Agents Chemother 2001;45:
Candida biofilms.21 In this study, the 2475-9.
albicans on acrylic resin and silicone of
cleanser used was tested solely for the different surface topography. J Prosthet Dent 19. Lamfon H, Porter SR, McCullough M,
effectiveness of its chemical formulation, 1997;77:535-9. Pratten J. Formation of Candida albicans
4. Taylor RL, Verran J, Lees GC, Ward AJP. The biofilms on non-shedding oral surfaces.
without effervescence, because the focus
influence of substratum topography on bac- Eur J Oral Sci 2003;111:465-71.
of the assay was on viability of the cells in terial adhesion to polymethyl methacrylate. 20. Chandra J, Mukherjee PK, Leidich SD,
the in vitro biofilm, which enabled com- J Mater Sci Mater Med 1998;9:17-22. Faddoul FF, Hoyer LL, Douglas LJ, et al.
parison of the survival of hyphal and 5. Radford DR, Challacombe SJ, Walter JD. Antifungal resistance of Candida biofilms
Denture plaque and adherence of Candida formed on denture acrylic. J Dent Res
blastospore biofilms. Rinsing also was albicans to denture-base materials in vivo and 2001;80:903-8.
omitted as these mechanical mechanisms in vitro. Crit Rev Oral Biol Med 1999;10: 21. Jose A, Coco BJ, Milligan S, Young B,
would clearly enhance biofilm removal. 99-116. Lappin DF, Bagg J, et al. Reducing the
6. Rathee M, Hooda A, Ghalaut P. Denture incidence of denture stomatitis: are
Additional study limitations include the denture cleansers sufficient? J Prosthodont
hygiene in geriatric persons. Int J Geriat
omission of a salivary conditioning film, Geriontol 2010;6:247a-52. 2010;19:252-7.
which might affect initial attachment to 7. Seneviratne CJ, Jin L, Samaranayake LP.
the surface. In addition, in vivo, denture Biofilm lifestyle of Candida: a mini review.
Oral Dis 2008;14:582-90. Corresponding author:
plaque comprises a complex mixed mi- 8. Ramage G, Saville SP, Thomas DP, Lopez- Dr Joanna Verran
crobial population whose structure and ribot JL. Candida biofilms: an update. Eukar- School of Healthcare Science
physiology might well differ from those of yot Cell 2005;4:633-8. The Manchester Metropolitan University
9. Phan QT, Belanger PH, Filler SG. Role of John Dalton Building
the simple Candida biofilms investigated hyphal interactions of Candida albicans with Chester Street
here. In this study, extended soak times endothelial cells. Infect Immun 2000;68: Manchester M1 5GD
with the denture cleanser of 1 hour 3485-90. UNITED KINGDOM
10. Kimura LH, Pearsall NN. Relationship be- E-mail: J.Verran@mmu.ac.uk
and 12 hours were used compared with
tween germination of Candida albicans and
the 5-minute soak recommended by increased adherence to human buccal Copyright ª 2014 by the Editorial Council for
the manufacturer. Although far removed epithelial cells. Infect Immun 1980;28:464-8. The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry.