Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nicely2011 PDF
Nicely2011 PDF
N
means of locomotion for the newborn, knowledge
and theory for nursing, give us the scaffolding on practicing Henderson’s theory can be the voice unheard,
which to build excellent care. ensuring that the decisions the patient made while still
independent are realized. As a nurse educator, theo-
Background rist, and researcher, Henderson derived much of her
After serious injury of the brain and when death concept from her practice and education.13 She wrote
is imminent, the patient becomes a potential organ of the difficulty of pinning down 1 nursing process,
donor, usually when an established set of criteria, proposing instead that the nursing process be “an ana-
referred to as clinical triggers,5 are met, prompting a lytical process . . . used by all health care providers.”13
referral to the organ procurement organization with
which the hospital is affiliated.6 The criteria might be Application of Hendersonʼs Model to the
a decreased score on the Glasgow Coma Scale, poor Management of Organ Donors
results of a neurological examination, or a physician’s Normal Breathing
order to test for brain death.7 A procurement coordi- Henderson’s first activity is “normal breathing.”13
nator, a transplant professional trained in the donation Potential organ donors have suffered devastating neu-
process, responds on-site to the hospital to assess the rological injuries, either from internal malfunction
situation and evaluate the potential for organ donation. (eg, ruptured aneurysm, intracranial hemorrhage) or
The procurement coordinator may have a background external injury (eg, gunshot wound, hanging). With
as a physician’s assistant, paramedic, or another allied the body’s automatic systems severely compromised,
health professional, but most are registered nurses.8 it is important to establish and maintain adequate oxy-
A key event in the process is declaration of death genation. If the patient has lost the ability to breathe
based on neurological criteria, or brain death, an irre- independently, intubation and ventilation is necessary
versible cessation of all brain functions, including the and is not negotiable in a brain-dead patient. This
brainstem. Most of the 50 states in the United States intervention is typical in trauma response care, but an
have adopted the Uniform Determination of Death Act, astute nurse who is aware that organ donation may be
governing the declaration of death. Although this law possible will understand the effects that early airway
requires the physician to use “accepted medical stan- and oxygenation management will have on organ via-
dards,” it does not define what those standards are.9 bility later.14 Inadequate oxygenation in the early hours
Most laws leave the mechanism for testing to the can damage or destroy organs.15 Because of the phys-
physician, but most physicians rely on a combination iological assault on the body from a severely injured
of cranial nerve examination and apnea testing, taken brain, an imbalance in the body’s circulating blood
together with the full clinical picture, including nature volume, which should be rich with oxygen, can occur.
and mechanism of injury, normothermia, absence of An imbalance can compromise or destroy organ func-
sedatives, and normotension.9 An apnea test requires tion, if oxygenation is insufficient.
determination of baseline levels of blood gases, fol-
lowed by disconnection from the ventilator for a time, Eating and Drinking
followed by a second blood gas test.10 The main indi- “Eating and drinking”13 are the next activities that
cator of brain death is apnea, a 20 mm Hg increase in Henderson names. Neurological devastation com-
the level of arterial carbon dioxide over baseline, cou- pletely eliminates the patient’s ability to voluntarily
pled with a failure to breathe.9 In the absence of brain- take nutrition. The critical hour between the initial
stem reflexes and with no other explanations for the injury and the determination of brain death requires a
symptoms, brain death is declared. The time of death shrewd nurse who can suggest fluid and electrolyte
is documented by a licensed physician when it has infusions, along with possible blood product transfu-
been determined that the patient has met the criteria. If sion, to maintain organ function, and pharmacological
more than 1 examination is performed (eg, in states that interventions, such as administration of desmopressin
require 2 independent examinations), time of death is acetate and mannitol, to prevent diabetes insipidus,
the time of the second confirmation.2 A search is per- third spacing, or volume depletion. Nurses may need
formed for any organ donation decision made by the to assert themselves at this juncture. Physicians and
patient before death, often referred to as first-person others may see the situation as hopeless and begin to
consent.11 In the absence of a first-person consent doc- de-escalate care. If the primary health care team sees
ument, the decision about organ donation falls to the blood transfusion to a “hopeless” patient as unneces-
legal next-of-kin in hierarchical order, including sary and wasteful, they may need instruction and
health care power-of-attorney.12 reminders about the potential recipients of donated
Henderson identified 14 activities for patient organs should the patient in question become an organ
assistance that she believed would help return patients donor. Because of the catastrophic instability and
to independence. Although it is clear that a brain-dead increased metabolic rates due to stress in potential
patient will not be returned to independence, a nurse organ donors, liver glycogen stores are depleted.16
Although most organ procurement organizations human person is not lost to the circumstances leading
do not include nutritional supplementation in organ to death. Nurses caring for potential donors must
donor management, some evidence suggests that the remain mindful that the donor in their care may have
potential organ donor would benefit from supplemen- links to other living patients. The potential donor has
tation of dextrose, amino and fatty acids, and gluta- worth, and the nurse can preserve the dignity that goes
mine.17 Nutrients such as dextrose, glutathione, with his or her worth. Basic nursing instruction teaches
adenosine, and raffinose are included in the various us to preserve privacy and maintain proper draping. In
preservation solutions delivered directly to the organs the surgical suite, the culture regarding surgical recov-
during recovery and transport.18 For the potential ery of organs can be uncomfortable for nurses and oth-
organ donor, Henderson’s concept of assisting a client ers who are not familiar with the process. The nurse
to “eat and drink adequately” is expanded to estab- working in organ donation will be the guardian of that
lishing and maintaining hydration and normovolemia privacy throughout the process, including in the surgi-
to support adequate organ function. cal suite, assuming donation occurs.
can cause fragile emotions, which left unchecked, can of all invasive sites, through bathing, can help control
lead to a difficult environment. infection. In-line suction and frequent oral hygiene are
helpful in minimizing the risk of hypoxemia and
Maintain Body Temperature Within Normal Range infection, particularly ventilator-acquired pneumo-
by Adjusting Clothing/Modifying Environment nia.19 Until a patient is declared dead, everything pos-
“Maintain body temperature within normal range sible must be done to save his or her life. If death
by adjusting clothing and modifying environment” is comes, practitioners are equally bound by relation-
Henderson’s next activity.13 Along with loss of volun- ships to those important to the patient to deliver
tary nervous control, neurological devastation also appropriate postmortem care. Showing respect, com-
compromises the hypothalamus, weakening the body’s passion, and empathy are all efforts that can help a
ability to regulate temperature. It is not uncommon for family experiencing the death of a loved one in the
a brain-injured patient to experience body temperatures intensive care unit.23
ranging from hypothermic to hyperthermic. Hyperther-
mia increases the metabolic and oxygen consumption Communication With Others
rates. Hypotension causes a left shift in the oxyhemo- The next of Henderson’s activities is of critical
globin dissociation curve, impairing oxygen delivery importance to the nurse facilitating organ donation:
to the tissue and decreasing the ability of the kidneys “Communicate with others in expressing emotions,
to concentrate urine. External adjustments are required needs, fears, or opinions.”13 The nurse would commu-
to prevent further damage.16 Additionally, some patients nicate to the patient in soothing, reassuring tones,
who become donors have succumbed to meningitis, explaining everything that is going on, announcing pro-
either bacterial or viral, which causes even more tem- cedures, and generally comforting the patient. This
perature fluctuation. Warming—or cooling—the patient type of communication is appropriate until death is
should be a routine part of trauma care, and, as Hen- determined. Once death has been determined, how-
derson implies, the nurse provides this care when the ever, it is important that the nurse cease any verbal
patient cannot. The nurse must respond to temperature communication directed toward the patient. Speaking
extremes with cooling blankets, heating lamps, or directly to the patient could send a confusing message
other technological interventions. to the family. Spending additional time with families,
explaining brain death and allowing them to ask ques-
Grooming/Protecting the Integument tions, will enhance their experience at the end of life.23
Next on Henderson’s list of activities is “keeping In addition to the family and friends of the patient, the
the body well groomed and protecting the integu- nurse may find that other nurses and even physicians
ment.”13 Protection of the skin and basic cleanliness may need gentle, clear communication in order to come
are 2 activities that provide opportunities for nurses to to grips with the situation. Young patients, patients
interact with patients in a very caring and nurturing who are victims of senseless trauma, and patients with
manner. While respecting the patient’s privacy and whom the staff is familiar can make death more per-
dignity, the act of bathing the patient and providing sonal and difficult to handle. Organ donation nurses
skin protection, as well as the physical motion, can be must call upon their skills to actively listen, probe, and
an extension of the care the nurse is providing. The provide concise, honest answers. Clear, consistent
goal for brain-dead patients is not recovery, but the communication is critical.
caring measures provided by the nurse send important Nurses should take great care in the use of spe-
messages to the patient’s family about the scope of the cific language when communicating with the family.
care being given. A family facing a ventilated, but When a patient is declared brain dead, health care pro-
dead, loved one can be devastated. Seeing their loved fessionals commonly use terminology such as “brain-
one disheveled, bloody, and unclean can make the sit- dead” rather than “dead” and “life-support” when
uation worse. By the time the brain-injured patient is referring to the ventilator. These terms can be confus-
admitted to the intensive care unit, time must be made ing to the patient’s family. Using the term “dead” sends
to take care of the patient’s basic grooming needs. The a more definitive message to the family that their
nurse may want to encourage the family to participate loved one is, in fact, dead.22 Terms such as “retrieval,”
in this type of care. “procurement,” and “harvest” are often used to
The nature of the injury and the presence of unfa- describe the surgical procedure through which organs
miliar medical equipment may leave the family are removed from the donor. Richardson24 argues that
deprived of the experience of being with or caring for the word “retrieval” implies that the organs belong to
their loved one. The simplest acts of love, such as someone other than the donor and we are merely tak-
stroking an arm, smoothing of sheets, combing of hair, ing them back while “procurement” refers to com-
or holding a hand are extremely valuable to a grieving merce and commodities and tends to focus on the
family.22 Also of paramount importance, proper care recipient rather than the donor. Although one might
argue that “harvest” refers to a time of plentitude and going outside, walking around, or by just experiencing
thanksgiving, harvesting of crops was traditionally their heartache.26 Nurses may need to remind patients’
done by “sickle or scythe, the same implements used families of the need to take care of themselves.
by the Grim Reaper, Death.”24 For these reasons, nurses Nurses must also recognize the need for their own
should use the term recovery. Recovery implies heal- care. As a consequence of stress relating to caring for
ing, and although the donor will not be healed, it can suffering patients and their families, caregivers can
aid in the healing of the donor family by offering some experience compassion fatigue, a secondary traumatic
solace or comfort in their grief by looking at donation stress disorder.27 Recreational activities such as taking
as a way to bring meaning to the death of their loved a walk, hiking, biking, running, or other forms of
one.22 Many people encounter organ donation with physical activity recharge the spirit and help combat
misconceptions that nurses should work to correct, compassion fatigue.26 The bedside nurse and donation
and nurses must do so with great finesse so as not to coordinator may also find themselves susceptible to
undermine individual belief systems or values. the same stress a caregiver experiences and may ben-
efit from the interventions described.
Worship According to Oneʼs Faith
Henderson lists “worship according to one’s Learn and Discover
faith” as the next activity.13 Most of the practice of Henderson’s last activity for the client/patient is
nursing, and certainly death and dying, may prompt to “learn, discover, or satisfy the curiosity that leads to
nurses to call upon their own spiritual beliefs. Patients normal development and health and use the available
and patients’ families may have different beliefs, which health facilities.”13 Again, the activity is no longer rel-
nurses must respect. Nearly all religious groups sup- evant for brain-dead patients; however, many families
port organ donation as long as it does not impede the of donors may be encountering grief and bereavement
life or hasten the death of the donor.25 In the case of an for the first time. Most people who are experiencing
organ donor, clergy may be called in to support the grief benefit from information, education, and ongo-
family. When considering donation, the family may ing support. A mourning family begins at the bedside
look to a faith leader for answers.25 Nurses may find to transition the relationship with the decedent from
opportunities not only to communicate information to one of presence to one of memory.26 Nurses have oppor-
the clergy, but perhaps also to facilitate worship or tunities to provide grief support initially and to give
end-of-life rituals for the family at the bedside to out- some guidance to the family—and perhaps other
wardly express their grief.26 Additionally, repeated health care staff—through resources for grief. Nurses
exposure to episodes of death may prompt nurses to should affirm the normalcy of family members’ feel-
further explore their own spiritual journey and give ings.25 The nurse may stay in contact with the family
them a choice to participate in worship as grief sup- after the donation. The nurse may choose to study
port for themselves. more about grief and grieving and may write or design
programming to support the families of donors. The
Play and Recreation nurse may also vigorously pursue more education
“Play and recreation” are next on Henderson’s list about physiological management of organ donors, or
of activities.13 Nurses working in organ donation will about teaching others, or about nursing in general.
encounter many situations where play has gone horri- According to Henderson,1
bly wrong. Children playing with guns, teenagers hood-
surfing, people diving into shallow water, various of all health providers, nurses render the
vehicular accidents, and other common recreational most intimate personal service. . . . Perhaps
activities that simply go wrong are examples of play the quality people most often seek in the
leading to death. It is not uncommon for the patient’s nurse is that of a comforting presence. If
family to experience guilt and self-blame. Nurses may there is a universal concept of nursing it
find that the patient’s family and friends blame the embodies the characteristics of a service that
event, the equipment, themselves, or each other for the is intimate, constant and comforting.
death of someone they love. Nurses may need to
remind them of the specifics of the event and that bad Conclusion
things sometimes happen. Nurses may also find them- Virginia Henderson’s Activities for Client Assis-
selves needing a reality check of their own to make tance within her concept of nursing apply logically
sure they do not become unreasonably overprotective and easily to the complex process of organ donation
or careful to the point of inactivity. Play and recreation for transplantation. Applied within the broader context
will no longer apply to the organ donor, but remain of the nursing metaparadigm—person, environment,
important for the family and for the health care team. health, and nursing—Henderson’s activities provide
The family may benefit during times of tragedy by an excellent framework within which nurses can work