Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.elsevier.com/locate/powtec
Abstract
The continuous production of 3 to 4.5 mm NPK-granules is achieved by spraying an appropriate mixture onto recycle or reflux (undersize)
product in a rotating drum. Hot air is used to evaporate the water. An extensive study was performed on an industrial granulator to evaluate mass
and energy balances, to define the average residence time of the reflux-particles and to develop a model for particle growth.
The average residence time was measured from tracer experiments. The mechanism of granulation follows the particle growth principle of
drying and layering. Model equations developed by Nienow for a batch fluidized bed granulation were modified to predict continuous operations.
The model equation defines the thickness of the coating layer in terms of the initial particle size and mass flow rate of the reflux particles, the
mass flow rate of the sprayed mixture, and both the average residence time of the particles and their contact time with the spray. The resulting
equation is
Predictions using the model equations were compared with experimental findings. An acceptable degree of fitting was obtained for all
operating conditions, although the model underestimates the growth rate of smaller particles.
The use of the model is further illustrated to predict the effects from variations in reflux granulometry, rotational speed of the drum or increased
throughput.
© 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Distributor
lAir
Coarse screen
Furnace
Dedusting
Rotary cooler
Recycle
Granulator Ambient air
(rotating drum) Distributor
NPK-mix Product screen
Reflux
BFHE
Conveyor belt
To silos
Recycle
of error. Deviations can be attributed to neglecting the fines 15 Product
evacuated to the dedusting, to neglecting heat losses through the 10
drum wall and to neglecting heat losses over the screening/
5
crushing and reflux cycle.
0
The major objectives of the study, subject of the present
0 1 2 3 4 5
paper, were the assessment of a granulator model and its use to dpi (mm)
predict expected product characteristics when altering operating
conditions. The text below summarizes the findings. Fig. 2. Particle size distribution (PSD) of the recycle and product streams.
190 J. Degrève et al. / Powder Technology 163 (2006) 188–195
NPK-
spray
α
reflux
1
w
A A A B
h
Fig. 3. Dimensions of the rotary granulator (∅ 4.285 m, 12 m long), including hold-up ring (∅ 2.485 m) and lifting scoops of length l = 1.122 m, height
h = 0.27 m and width w = 0.67 m. A single scoop is illustrated. Sections A contain 24 scoops at angle α = 15°; section B contains 12 scoops at angle
α = 30°.
by the feed material, followed by solidification of the material 2.2. The batch fluidized bed granulator model of Nienow
on the particle surface. Theoretical expressions to describe particle
growth by both mechanisms have been presented by Nienow and Nienow developed model equations for an idealized layer-
Rowe [5], based upon earlier work by mainly Smith and Nienow growth in a batch fluidized bed granulator. The resulting
[6,7]. equations relate the rate of particle growth to the initial particle
Kapur [8] also developed equations for the kinetics of size (dp0), to the quantity of particles in the bed (M0), to the bulk
granulation by the crushing and layering mechanism. (ρB) and true particle density (ρp) and to the constant feed rate
Additional phenomena and treatments have subsequently (mb = dMb / dt). The equation is given by
been presented in literature, considering various effects and sys-
tems, e.g. batch and continuous fluidized-bed granulation with
ddp dA mb
binder [19]; coalescence, layering and abrasion [9]; binder- ¼2 ¼ ð1Þ
dt dt qp
agglomeration in a drum [4]; growth and attrition for continuous M0 qB
3
dp0 þ 12A
d2
þ 12A2
3
dp0
fluidized-bed granulation [10,18]; coalescence growth [11], and p0
nucleation with a binder liquid [12].
A model by a two-stage auto-layering principle in contin-
uous drums has been presented by Venkataramana et al. [13], The annular volume of the coating surrounding each particle,
whereas the dynamic behaviours of fluidized-bed granulation Vb, is given by :
has been studied by Drechsler et al. [14].
Pictures of halved particles (Fig. 5) revealed a typical layer- Vb ¼ k=6½ðdp0 þ 2AÞ3 −dp0
3
¼k=6½6dp0
2
A
structure (onion-ring) thus confirming this auto-layering mech- ð2Þ
anism: the ring-structure is made visual through application of a þ 12dp0 A2 þ 8A3
dye on the reflux particles. This finding enabled us to assess the
applicability of a modified “onion-ring” model, initially
presented by Smith and Nienow [6,7] for batch fluidized 2.3. Modification of the Nienow et al. approach for continuous
granulation. The mechanism corresponds to the time-dependent granulation in a rotary drum
growth of the particle by application of a coating layer, of
thickness A, as illustrated in Fig. 6. The model equation can be adapted according to the
following procedure.
Fig. 4. Possible mechanisms of particle growth. Fig. 5. Photograph of halved NPK-granule showing the layered structure.
J. Degrève et al. / Powder Technology 163 (2006) 188–195 191
The total volume (VGR, in cubic meters)of the drum The velocity vv is calculated for a falling particle, discharged
granulator, with diameter D (m), is : from the lifter at a given height hv in the drum as shown in
Fig. 7. The falling height can assume values between hv1 and
VGR ¼ k=4½D2 L ð4 aÞ
hv2, and an average of both values has been taken into account
The volume occupied by the particles, Vp, can be calculated in further calculations. The falling time tv can be obtained from
by considering a layer of particles retained ahead of the ring and [17]:
a particle layer of gradually decreasing height towards the exit 0 rffiffiffiffiffiffi 1
K2
of the drum (after the ring). B −vv C
1 B K C
Since the ring has a height of 0.9 m, and with the tv ¼ − pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi lnBrffiffiffiffiffiffi1 C ð8Þ
approximation of a horizontal level of particles across the 2 K1 K2 @ K2 A
þ vv
bottom of the drum ahead of the ring (section of 6.2 m long) and K1
a steadily decreasing thickness after the ring (section of 5.8 m
long), the particle volume becomes : 3CD qf gðqp −qf Þ
K1 ¼ K2 ¼ ð9Þ
2
4dp qp qp
ðD=2Þ sinh
Vp f ð6:2 þ 5:8=2Þf19:8 m3 ð4 bÞ
2 It is assumed here that particles behave individually. Possible
cluster formation will increase the falling velocity and reduce
For a reflux feed rate R is expressed as kilograms per hour,
the falling time. Incorporating the contact time in the modified
the Eq. (3) defines the particle hold-up X, since:
R
F¼ kD2 in m3 =m2 min ð5Þ
qB 4 60
thus
Om
Rs
X ¼ kD2 ð6Þ h v2
qB 4 L60
h v1
The average residence time was determined by a peak
addition of 200 kg of colored tracer particles with the reflux
flow. The concentration of the tracer particles at the exit of the
drum was determined by sampling of a 1 l exit mix every 30 s
and by continuous color imaging. The samples taken were also
used to evaluate the size distribution. Fig. 7. Falling particles being discharged from lifters.
192 J. Degrève et al. / Powder Technology 163 (2006) 188–195
100 7
90
6
80
70 5
Basis
60
xicum (%)
Measured 4
xi (%)
+10% large particles
50 Predicted
3 +20% large particles
40 Reflux-feed
+30% large particles
30 2
20 1
10
0
0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
dpi (mm)
dpi (mm)
2
If the thickness of the coating layer is very small in
X kD comparison with the initial particle size, or A ≪ dp0, then
Vp0 ¼ XVGR where; VGR ¼ L ð10Þ
4 Vb ≅ πdp0
2
and the equation can be simplified to:
!
Mb q B s
Combining this equation with the previous expression for dp0 ¼ A ð15Þ
hold-up yields: Rqp 10
dA 1 ddp 30M
5
¼ ¼ ð18Þ
4 Basis dt 2 dt qp 3
þ 12A
þ 12A2
xi (%)
0
Simplification is again possible for A ≪ dp0 so that:
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
dpi (mm)
ddp dA dMb dp0 qB M
¼2 i20 ð19Þ
Fig. 9. Sensitivity of PSD with respect to crusher output.
dt dMb dt Rqp s
J. Degrève et al. / Powder Technology 163 (2006) 188–195 193
7
The initial batch model of Nienow is hence adapted to the
6
continuous operation of the granulator through inclusion of the
5
flow rate of NPK-mix M, and the reflux flow R.
4
X (%)
The thickness of the coating layer is obtained by integrat- 5.2 rpm
3 6.2 rpm
ing the evolution equation for t from 0 to tc and for dp from
2
dp0 to dp0 + A. This results in a cubic equation for the unknown
A: 1
0
0 2 4 6 8
3A 12A 12A 30M ð1−eÞtc
2 3
þ 2 þ 3 ¼ ð20Þ dpi (mm)
dp0 2dp0 3dp0 Rs
Fig. 12. Sensitivity of PSD with respect to the rotational speed of the drum.
or, in its simplified form (if A ≪ dp0)
1 dp0 qB Mtc 3.2. Predictive use of the model equations
A ¼ Ddp ¼ 10 ð21Þ
2 Rqp s
The model equations enable the assessment of the effect of
where ε represents the bed voidage. varying operating parameters such as the modification of the
Coating only occurs when the particles are in contact with sieves, the reduction of crusher speed, the increase of NPK-
the NPK-spray, i.e. during a time tc, referred to as the “time of spray or the modification of the rotational speed of the drum.
contact” and previously calculated from the known geometry Although these parameter influences could not be established
and rotational speed of the granulator. by modifying the operations in the continuous BASF-process,
Both the average residence time of the particles (hold-up) in the following examples illustrate the predictive use of the model
the drum, and the contact time between the particles and the equations.
NPK-spray are of paramount importance. The sieves contribute to 75% of the reflux stream, whereas
the crusher only contributes for 25%. Changes in crusher out-
3. Results and discussions put therefore hardly affect the particle growth as illustrated in
Fig. 9.
3.1. Experimental validation If the sieves are changed to yield larger particles (10% to
30%), model predictions illustrate that more particles of
Data were collected at different operating conditions. The commercial grade (3–4.5 mm) will be produced. This is
Illustration of the modelling results is given in Fig. 8, for shown in Fig. 10.
experimental data at given reflux and product size distributions, Fig. 11 illustrates that operating the rotary drum granulator at
while the granulator was operating at a reflux flow rate of a 20% higher NPK-mix (spray) will only slightly alter the
95,700 kg/h, a bulk density of 1140 kg/m3 and an average air distribution of particle sizes, with a slight shift toward the larger
temperature of 220 °C. size range.
Although model predictions underestimate the growth of The influence of the rotational speed of the drum is also
smaller particles, the prediction of the commercial grade predicted. Increasing the speed will produce more particles of
product (3–4.5 mm) is very fair. The reasons for the discrepancy the desired size range. Increasing the speed from the current 5.2
at smaller particle sizes may be due to the combined effects of to 6.4 rpm will enable to increase the spray capacity by 20%, as
(i) the fact that terminal velocities were calculated with the same illustrated in Fig. 12.
formula, only valid for the turbulent flow regime; (ii) the fact
that sieve analysis of smaller particle sizes are subject to larger 4. Conclusions
errors than larger particles; and (iii) neglecting agglomeration of
fines with the layering approach. Experiments were carried out on an industrial rotating drum
granulator used to produce 3 to 4.5 mm commercial grade NPK-
granules by spraying an appropriate mixture onto recycle
6 (undersize) product in a rotating drum. Hot air is used to
5 evaporate the water. Mass and energy balances were assessed,
4 the average residence time of the reflux particles in the drum
Basis
xi (%)
The model equation determines the thickness A of the tv particle falling time (s)
coating layer in terms of: vv falling velocity of particle (m/s)
Vb shell volume added to growing particle (m3)
– dp0, the initial particle size of reflux particles as determined VGR volume of granulator drum (m3)
by the operation characteristics of sieves and crusher; Vp0 volume of particles with diameter dp0 in granulator
– M, the mass flow rate of the sprayed mixture; (m3)
– ε, the average voidage of the particle bed in the drum; Vtot total volume of solid particles in granulator (m3)
– R, the mass flow rate of the reflux stream; X percentage or fraction of granulator volume filled with
– tc, the contact time of each size range of reflux particles with solid material (%)
the spray;
– τ, the average residence time of the particles in the rotating Greek letters
drum. ε granulator bed voidage (−)
ρB bulk density (kg/m3)
The resulting equation is ρf fluid density (kg/m3)
ρP particle density (kg/m3)
3A 12A2 12A3 30M ð1−eÞtc τ average residence time of solid material in granulator
þ 2 þ 3 ¼
dp0 2dp0 3dp0 Rs drum (h)
applying numerical simulation tools, Chem. Eng. Sci. 60 (14) (2005) [18] S. Heinrich, L. Mörl, Fluidized bed spray granulation — a new model for
3817–3833. the description of particle wetting and of temperature and concentration
[15] S.J. Friedman, W.R. Marshall, Studies in rotary drying (Part 1: hold-up and distribution, Chem. Eng. Process. 38 (1999) 635–663.
dusting), Chem. Eng. Progress. 45 (8) (1949) 482–493. [19] B. Waldie, D. Wilkinson, L. Zachra, Kinetics and mechanisms of growth in
[16] De Laet, S. (1999) Study of rotary dryer for fertilizers, Engineering Thesis batch and continuous fluidized-bed granulation, Chem. Eng. Sci. 42 (4)
K.U. Leuven (in Dutch), 104 pages. (1987) 653–665.
[17] W.J. Beek, K.M.K. Muttzall, J.W. van Heuven, Transport Phenomena, 2nd
edition, John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, 1999, pp. 107–113.