You are on page 1of 2

A-Owner of the landB-Builder planter or sowerC-Owner of materials

Art 447

AB-GF

C-GF

a.AB-Right of Appropriation

b. C-Limited right of removal

AB-BF

C-GF

a.AB- no right

b.C –a. right of reimbursement plus D

b. Absolute right of removal plus D

Art 448

A-GF

BC-GF

a. A - a. Right of Appropriation

b.Right to demand price of land or rent

BC – a. Right to reimbursement of necessary and useful expenses if A elect first option

b.Right of retention if A elects first option.

Art 449

A-GF

BC-BF

a. A- a. Right of appropriation plus D

b.Right to demand removal or demolition plus D

c.Right to demand price of land or rent plus D

b. BC - No right except reimbursement of necessary expenses for preservation of land


Art 449-452

(A-GF)

(BC-BF)

(a) A- a. Right of appropriation plus D


b.Right to demand removal or demolition plus D.
c.Right to demand price of land or rent plus D
BC-No right except reimbursement of necessary expenses for preservation of land

Art.453

A-BF

BC-BF

Same as Art 448

Art 454

A-BF

BC-GF

Same as art 447

Art 455

A-GF or BF

B-GF or BF

C-GF

a. First determine rights of A and B


b. Then C can hold B primarily liable and A subsidiary liable except under Art 450

A-GF or BF

B-GF or BF

C-BF

a. First determine rights of A and B.


b. Then, with respect to C, apply Arts 449-452 since B shall be considered agent of C

You might also like