Professional Documents
Culture Documents
12 - Chapter 3 - Review of Literature
12 - Chapter 3 - Review of Literature
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
13 | P a g e
Literature review was focused on the developments in the following four aspects of RA.
1. RA animal models
Animal models are developed to evaluate the potential therapeutic drugs as well as understand
the pathogenesis of RA. The choice of the animal model depends on the following criteria (25).
Many models have been developed to study the anti- rheumatoid activity. At present there is no
ideal model that produces typical RA as seen in humans. However genetic animal models
14 | P a g e
Rat models
Mouse models
Genetic models
1. K/BxN (41)
2. HuTNF Tg (42)
15 | P a g e
Among these models RA induced in Rats/ Mice with FCA and type II collagen are considered
the most economic and appropriate models to assess the efficacy and safety of newer agents to
As there are no reported differences in the immuno pathogenesis of arthritis induced in both the
models. FCA induced RA model is selected for the current study (44).
tuberculosis bacilli suspended in 10 ml of heavy paraffin oil. FCA is found to release PGE2,
TNF-α and nitric oxide and increase the level of myeloperoxidase contributing to the
suppressive agents and considered relevant for the study of patho-physiological and
pharmacological control of inflammatory process as well as for the evaluation of analgesic drugs
(45).
Procedure
In this model, 0.1 ml of FCA is injected subcutaneously into the left hind paw of rats on zero
day. Clinical evidence of arthritis occurs from day 8-9 with swelling of hind paw (onset of
disease). After about 12 days it becomes difficult for the rats to move due to paw swelling. Drug
therapy is started either on day 0 (prophylactic model) or day 9 (therapeutic model) (25).
16 | P a g e
3.2 Recent understanding of pathogenesis of RA
Faulty immune response is identified as the cause for RA. The complex interaction between
environmental and genetic factors induces an antigenic response stimulating the CD4+ T cells
present in the synovium. Activation of CD4 T cells results in two major responses 1) activation
of B cells resulting in the production of plasma cells which release immunoglobulins such as RF
and anti-CCP. 2) Differentiation of CD4 Th cells into Th-1 and Th-2. Another type of Th cell,
Th-17 has been identified recently which is found to play an important role in the pathogenesis
of RA. Inflammatory mediators released by Th-1, Th-2 and Th-17 have been given in the Figure-
1. All these pro-inflammatory cytokines and inflammatory mediators initiate the inflammatory
response in the joint resulting in neutrophil infiltration, macrophage and fibroblast activation (46,
47).
TNF-α is the main inflammatory inducer that drives pathogenesis and development of RA. It has
been clinically confirmed that TNF blockade can effectively control the severity of RA.
Activated T cells and macrophages can produce not only TNF- α but also IL-1, IL-6 and IL-17,
which cause chronic inflammation in the synovium by different mechanisms (48). TNF-α can
degrade the articular cartilage and bone by stimulating osteoclast activity and the activity of
enzymes such as MMP, leading to joint deformity. RANKL which is a target for TNF is found to
be highly expressed in RA and is associated with the bone loss (49). Additionally, the
rheumatoid factor released by B cells may form an immune complex with self-antigens and
developed against citrulline also stimulate T-cells and initiate inflammatory process (20). The
17 | P a g e
abnormality in the normal programmed cell death may be also involved in joint inflammation in
TNF-ɑ causes :
IL-1:
Increase in the release of synovial fibroblast and monocyte cytokine, chemokine, MMP
and PG
Activation of osteoclasts
IL-6:
Activation of osteoclasts
Recruitment of neutrophils
18 | P a g e
VEGF production
Formation of pannus
IL-17:
All these mediators contribute to the progressive pathological changes that occur in RA
19 | P a g e
Inflammatory pathway in Rheumatoid arthritis
Macrophages- IL 1, IL 21, IL 23
Synovial fibroblast- IL 18, RANKL
Thus, controlling the key cellular and humoral immune responses and the dominant pro-
inflammatory cytokine production may be the possible therapeutic targets for treatment of RA.
20 | P a g e
3. 3 Current trends in the therapy
The treatment is aimed at targeting these mediators relieving pain, improving mobility and
arresting articular damage. Anti-inflammatory analgesics and immunomodulators are the main
groups of drugs used and these include NSAIDs, DMARDs and Immunosuppressives.
NSAIDs & steroids are commonly used initially in the treatment of RA, Both act at different
PGs are the main inflammatory mediators. The production of PGs from arachidonic acid is
mediated by the enzyme cyclo-oxygenase (COX). NSAIDs inhibit COX enzyme there by the
production of PGs. COX exists in two isomeric forms COX-1 and COX-2. COX-1 is a
constitutive enzyme present in all normal tissues especially platelets, stomach and kidney. COX-
2 is produced at the site of and during inflammation. COX-1 is mediates the release of PGs in the
stomach which causes mucus production, improves blood flow and thus offers protection against
gastric ulceration. In the kidney prostaglandin production by COX-1 maintains renal blood flow
and in platelets inhibits their aggregation. When non selective COX inhibitors such as
indomethacin, ibuprofen and diclofenac are used, though they offer relief from joint swelling and
pain, they cause adverse effects such as peptic ulcer, nephro-toxicity and bleeding diathesis as a
result of COX-1 inhibition. Hence selective inhibitors of COX-2 such as rofecoxib, valdecoxib
which act only at site of inflammation were introduced so that these adverse effects can be
avoided but COX-2 inhibitors caused lethal cardiac toxicity hence withdrawn from use (50).
Because of the adverse effects of NSAIDs, glucocorticoids like predinisolone and methyl
prednisolone are used either alone or along with NSAIDs so that the dose of both the drugs can
be minimized. Glucocorticoids act at a higher level in the inflammatory process by inhibiting the
21 | P a g e
production of arachidonic acid from cell membrane phospho lipid. The immunosuppressive
effects of glucocorticoids further help the treatment of RA. But unfortunately long term use of
glucocorticoids leads to several systemic side effects such as peptic ulcer, hypertension, immune
penicillamine and leflunomide. These agents decrease the inflammatory process and its
consequent destructive changes in RA by their immuno-modulatory effects. But long term use of
thrombocytopenia (50).
The next groups of drugs used are biologic DMARDs, which include etanercept, adalimumab,
infliximab, certolizumab and golimumab. They act by inhibiting TNF, one of the main
The drugs which inhibit cytokines like IL-1, 6, TNF-α inhibit the initiation of inflammation.
Drugs which inhibit the cytokines are the biologicals. There are two groups of cytokines. One
which facilitates the inflammatory process is called pro-inflammatory cytokines and others
which inhibit inflammation are the anti-inflammatory cytokines. Both together maintain
Hence the biologicals are used to inhibit pro-inflammatory cytokines or facilitate the production
of anti-inflammatory cytokines.
The first direct and selective IL-1 receptor antagonist, anakinra is used alone or in combination
with any of the DMARDs, except etanercept and infliximab because of the risk of development
of neutropenia. In addition to cytokine modulators drugs are also produced which can act against
22 | P a g e
other proteins involved in co-stimulation in inflammation such as cytotoxic T lymphocyte
receptor proteins.
For example abatacept is a CTLA 4 fusion protein and is a selective co-stimulation modulator
Similarly rituximab is anti CD 20 antibody; toclilizumab is anti IL-6 antibody and tofacitinib
Janus kinase inhibitor are often combined with methotrexate or other DMARDs to improve
efficacy (53).
All these biological DMARDs can also cause adverse effects such as hypotension, severe
Thus the treatment of RA is incomplete and one has to use many drugs to control the disease
process at different levels. Multiple drug therapy can cause multiple organ toxicity and other
23 | P a g e
3.4 Medicinal plants evaluated for their effects in animal models of RA.
Among the plants screened for their effects in RA, 10 plants used in FCA induced arthritis have
1. Calotropis procera
V. L. Kumar and S. Roy had studied the effect of methanolic extract of Calotropis procera in
FCA induced arthritis. FCA caused the release of PGE2, TNF-α and nitric oxide and increased
extract of 500 mg/kg produced marked reduction in the inflammatory mediators and response to
the same extent as that of standard drug rofecoxib (100 mg/kg) (54).
2. Hemidesmus indicus
The anti-arthritic activity of four different extracts, hydroalcoholic extract (450 mg/kg)
chloroform extract (60 mg/kg), ethyl acetate (75 mg/kg) and residual fraction (270 mg/kg) of
Hemidesmus indicus root in adjuvant induced arthritis in rats was evaluated by Mehta A. The
ethyl acetate extract was found to be better than other fractions and it contained the phyto-
chemicals terpenes, sterols and phenolic compounds which could have contributed to the anti-
3. Tridax procumbens
The anti-arthritic activity of T. procumbens was studied in FCA induced arthritis in rats in the
doses of 250 and 500 mg/kg. This study had shown dose dependant anti-arthritic effect is
24 | P a g e
comparable to that of Indomethacin. T. procumbens in addition inhibited the increase in liver
4. Gymnema sylvestre
The anti arthritic effects of petroleum ether extract (300 mg/kg) and aqueous extract (300 mg/kg)
of Gymnema sylvestre were evaluated in FCA induced arthritis in rats. Paw volume and blood
parameters, TC DC, ESR, Hb were measured. The authors have concluded that both the extracts
Tannins and saponins are the main phytochemicals present in Gymnema sylvestre and are known
5. Syzygium cumini
The anti-arthritc activity of methanolic extract of Syzygium cumini seeds at the doses of 250
mg/kg and 500 mg/kg on FCA induced arthritis was evaluated by Eshwar kumar et.al. Treatment
Syzygium cumini showed significant effect in preventing PV and improved RBC count, Hb level
and ESR to normal level and significantly decreased the WBC count when compared to
untreated RA group. The effect was found to be equal to standard drug indomethacin (58).
6. Terminalia chebula
Ramani YR et.al, have reported the anti-arthritic activity of acetone extract of fruits of
Terminalia chebula in FCA induced arthritis in Wistar rats. Terminalia chebula at the doses of
160 and 320 mg/kg showed good reduction in ESR, paw edema and joint thickness which is
25 | P a g e
inflammatory and anti-arthritic activities at the dose of 320 mg/kg and the mechanism attributed
was inhibition of hyaluronidase and collagenase, preventing the degradation of articular cartilage
(59).
7. Ficus bengalensis
The methanolic extract of Ficus bengalensis bark was evaluated in three doses of 100, 200 and
300 mg/kg (i.p) in FCA induced arthritis, Formalin induced arthritis and Agar induced arthritis in
rats by Manocha N et.al. The extract had shown anti-rheumatic activity in a dose dependent
Cheng-Jian Zhenga et.al, screened the effects of Vitex negundo. Linn seeds extract (EVNS) on
FCA induced arthritis in rats. EVNS in 2 doses- 340 mg/kg and 85 mg/kg had significantly
inhibited the PV, reduced the arthritis score and decreased the inflammatory markers. EVNS had
potential therapeutic benefit in arthritis and the mechanism attributed was by reducing TNF-α,
IL-1β and IL-6 levels and elevating IL-10 in serum and in addition down-regulation of COX-2 &
5-LOX (61).
Sanmugapriya Ekambaram et.al evaluated the effects of the aqueous extract and the whole seed
powder of Strychnos potatorum Linn seeds on the FCA induced arthritis in rat. The group treated
with extracts, showed significant reduction in PV. Hb, RBC, WBC, ESR, blood urea, serum
creatinine, total proteins and acute phase proteins were significantly brought back to near normal
26 | P a g e
level by the extract at the dose of 200 mg/kg/p.o. Further the histopathological and X-ray studies
Brijesh Rathore et.al evaluated the impact of long term use of aqueous and ethanolic extracts of
the leaves, fruits and seeds of Nyctanthes arbor-tristis (NAT) on the modulatory effect of pro-
and anti-inflammatory cytokines in FCA induced arthritis in mouse. It was found that treatment
with extracts from leaves and fruits of NAT at the dose of 25 mg/kg had reduced the TNF-α, IL-
1β and IL-6 from day 14 while seed extracts were ineffective, suggesting that the active
A) FCA induced arthritis in rats can be selected as the appropriate economic model for
B) Pro-inflammatory cytokines IL-1, IL-5, IL-6, IL-17, IL-21, IL-22 and IL-26, TNF-α, GMCSF
& IFN-γ and anti-inflammatory cytokines such as IL-4, IL-10, IL-11 and IL-13 are in
homeostasis to prevent inflammation in RA. Hence agents that facilitate the release and activity
C) Several medicinal plants have been studied for their effects in RA. In these studies FCA
induced arthritis model has been mainly used. The evaluated plants are all found to be effective
in FCA induced RA. These plants are individually evaluated but not in combination and they are
27 | P a g e
Hence the two plants OS and SI which are used domestically in day to day life, readily available,
easy to collect and less expensive have been selected for evaluation in FCA induced arthritis in
rats with the objectives of assessing their safety and efficacy individually and in combination as
well as their mechanism of action in comparison with standard drugs diclofenac and
methotrexate.
28 | P a g e
3.5 Ocimum sanctum
Introduction of plant:
Ocimum sanctum L (Holy basil) is one among the 60 species of the genus Ocimum and belongs
to the family Lamiaceae. It is indigenous to the tropical regions of Asia and America. OS is
wildly cultivated in India. A wide range of medicinal properties have been attributed to OS and
different parts of the plants such as leaves, flowers, stems, roots and seeds are extensively used
in Indian systems of medicine for different disorders such as fever, common cold, sore throat,
headache, eye diseases, dental and skin disorders, insect bites, renal stones and stress disorders
(64).
The different species of OS are used in food, drug development and perfumary (65). Holy basil
has also been described as Ocimum tenuiflorum or Ocimum gratissimum (66). OS is the most
commonly used name due to the wide range of its uses in religious and cultural traditions. It is
closely related to sweet basil (Ocimum basilicum), a commonly used herb in Europe and North
America.
OS is locally known as Tulsi. Three types of Tulsi are in use; Tulsi with green leaves is Sri
Tulsi or Rama Tulsi and is the commonest type. The plant with dark green to-purple leaves is
known as Krishna Tulsi and the third one is a wild variety called Vana Tulsi that often grows in
the forest.
Of these, the Rama and Krishna holy basil are most commonly grown in homes as well as
commercially produced for use in ayurvedic preparations. The plant is found mainly in
subtropical and tropical areas of Asia including India, China, Malaysia, Sri Lanka, and Thailand
29 | P a g e
in addition to Australia and Africa, at altitudes of up to 1800 meter in India to sandy dry
Morphology
OS is an erect shrub, with many branches and growing to about 30-60 cm height with green or
purple leaves placed opposite on hairy stems. Leaves are about 5 cm long, usually somewhat
Kingdom Plantae
Division Magnoliophyta
Class Magnoliopsida
Unranked Asterids
Order Lamiales
Family Lamiaceae
Genus Ocimum
Species O. sanctum
30 | P a g e
Vernacular names of Ocimum sanctum
Hindi Tulsi
Tamil Thulasi
Kannada Tulasi
Telugu Tulasi
Malayalam Trittavu
A) B) C)
31 | P a g e
Phytochemicals present in OS
Os contains many nutrients and active biological compounds, the ratio of which will be
different among different strains and even among strains cultivated in same area which may be
due to variation in the way of growing, harvesting, processing and storage (68).
terpenoids, cardiac glycerides, eugenol, euginal (also called eugenic acid), ursolic acid,
cyclopentane, benzene methanamine and octadecane, palmitic acid, stearic acid, oleic acid,
Nutritional content
Vitamin C and vitamin A, calcium, zinc and iron, chlorophyll and many other nutrients are
present in OS. The Protein content is 4.2 g; carbohydrate 2.3 g; fat: 0.5 g; calcium: 25 mg;
phosphorus 287 mg; iron: 15.1 mg and edible portion contains 25 mg vitamin C per 100 g (71).
Pharmacological actions of OS
for anti-inflammatory activity in carrageenan induced paw edema in rats and analgesic activity
using hot plate method in mice by Hannan, J. M. A., et al. and they have reported that OS at the
dose of 250 mg/kg and 500 mg/kg had caused significant reduction of PV and an increase in
reaction time to pain establishing its anti-inflammatory and analgesic activity (72).
32 | P a g e
Antioxidant and wound healing: Shetty et.al. had evaluated the in-vitro antioxidant & wound
healing activity of ethanolic and aqueous extracts of OS leaves in Wistar albino rats. 400 and
800 mg/kg of both the extracts had shown increased levels of hydroxyproline, hexuronic acid,
hexosamines & wound breaking strength and decreased percentage of wound contraction. The
antioxidants SOD, catalase, GSH levels had been significantly elevated and LPO level was
reduced in treated group. Aqueous extract of 800 mg/kg had shown greater effect compared to
ethanolic extract. OS leaves extracts was found to contain phenolic compounds which had
Anticancer activity: Shivpuje P et.al evaluated the anti-proliferative effect and cytotoxic
activity of aqueous extract of OS leaves on KB mouth epidermal carcinoma cell line by MTT
assay. The extract had significant cytotoxic effect against oral cancer cell line. (74)
Diuretic effect: The diuretic effect of ethanolic extract of OS leaves was studied in animal
model by Preethi G Pai. 250 mg/kg and 500 mg/kg of the extract had shown increased diuretic
index to 1.65 and 2.26 respectively and the saluretic index as reflected by the Na/K ratio to 2.2
at 250 mg/kg and 2 at 500 mg/kg which was greater than that of furosemide which showed a
significant reduction in blood sugar in diabetic rats and enhanced the action of exogenously
Anti-fatigue activity: The anti-fatigue activity of alcoholic extract of OS leaves in rats was
evaluated by Prasad et.al. Fatigue was induced by subjecting the rats to weight loaded forced
33 | P a g e
swim test every alternate day for 2 weeks. 150, 300 and 450 mg/kg of OS extract were
administered orally. Blood parameters like MDA and LA, glycogen, Hb, BUN and CK levels
were measured. The OS treatment resulted in significant increase in swimming time from day 1
to 14. MDA and LA levels in liver and muscle tissues, BUN and CK activity were significantly
reduced. 300 mg/ kg had showed better performance against fatigue than other two doses (77).
and aqueous extracts of OS leaves. Aqueous extract was found to be a better inhibitor of gut
bacterial and fungal species than alcoholic extract. In addition the alcoholic extract showed
broader zone of inhibition for vibrioe cholera especially at a higher dose of 60 mg (78).
induced Myocardial infarction (MI) in rats was evaluated by Sharma M et.al. 25, 50, 75 & 100
mg/kg of OS significantly reduced the glutathione, SOD, LDH levels and inhibited lipid
gastric ulcer in rats was reported by Dharmani P. OS at the dose of 100 mg/kg and 200 mg/kg
had 33.07% and 52.52% protection whereas omeprazole showed 60% protection against
Anti-cataleptic activity: Pemminati Sudhakar, et.al evaluated the effect of ethanolic extract of
OS leaves on catalepsy induced by haloperidol. 1.75 mg/kg and 4.25 mg/kg body weight of OS
had better protection against catalepsy when compared to scopolamine & ondansetron in acute
34 | P a g e
Immunomodulatory activity: The immunomodulatory activity of aqueous extract of OS in rat
was reported by Jeba CR, et.al. Antibody titration, passive haemagglutination and chromic
chloride assays were performed. 100 & 200 mg/kg of OS extract produced significant elevation
in antibody titre and increased the RBC, WBC and Hb level (82).
35 | P a g e
3.6 Sesamum indicum
Sesamum indicum (Sesame) belongs to the family, Pedaliaceae and one of the first known plants
used for its seeds. It has been used since ancient times as spice and is still an oil seed of global
significance. Its seed oil has a rich content of protein and is used in cooking and margarine
production (83).
Morphology
Sesame is an erect usually annual shrub reaches a height of 1.5 meter, depending on the type
and cultivating conditions. Some species are highly branched, whereas others are un-branched.
Seeds are black, brown or white, 2.5–3 mm long and about 1.5 mm wide. It is found in tropical,
subtropical, and southern temperate areas of the world, particularly India, China, South America
and Africa.
Kingdom Plantae
Unranked Angiosperms
Unranked Eudicots
Unranked Asterids
Order Lamiales
Family Pedaliaceae
Genus Sesamum
Species S. indicum
36 | P a g e
Vernacular names of Sesamum indicum
Sanskrit Tila
Tamil Ellu
Kannada Ellu
Telugu Nuvvulu
Malayalam Ellu
A) B) C)
Image-2: A) Sesame plant, B) White sesame seeds and C) Black sesame seeds
37 | P a g e
Chemical composition of SI
glycosides and terpenes, sesamol, sesamin and sesamolin, oleic acid, α-tocopherol, γ-
tocophereol, palmitic acid, stearic acid and linoleic acid, α –linolenic acid (84, 85, 86).
Nutritional value
SI contains vitamin B1: 0.28 mg, 1.48 mg of copper, 0.88 mg of manganese, 120 mg of
Pharmacological activities
Analgesic and antioxidant activity: Was evaluated by Nahar, L. 250 and 500 mg/kg of
alcoholic seed extract had produced 48.19% and 75.46% writhing inhibition respectively and
was found to be similar to ibuprofen which produced 71.82% inhibition with 25 mg/ kg.
SI had produced maximum antioxidant effect at the concentration of 120 µg/ml which was 92%
compared with standard antioxidant, ascorbic acid had produced 56% (88).
carbon tetrachloride (CCL4) induced liver damage was studied by Kumar et.al. 400 mg/kg and
700 mg/kg of extract had reduced the protein synthesis and TG production and histological
Antimicrobial activity: The antimicrobial effect of the silver nano-particles produced using SI
leaf extract against multi-drug resistant Escherichia coli (E. coli) had been evaluated by
Bokaeian M. The silver nano particle of SI leaf extract (400 mg/ml) inhibited all the micro-
38 | P a g e
organisms. Maximum inhibition was seen with E. coli followed by S. aureus and K. pneumonia
and no inhibition was observed for S. aureus. The least zone of inhibition was observed against
S. typhii. The highest and lowest MIC values against five isolates of E. coli were found to be
mice was reported by Uma Advani. 10 ml/kg of S. indicum oil reduced the duration of MES
produced tonic hind limb extension. S. indicum oil was effective against PTZ and lithium +
Antiobesity activity: Chinnala KM et.al evaluated the anti-obesity effect of methanolic extract
of SI in obesity induced rats using high fat diet. The extract of SI produced significant reduction
in BW, food intake, blood glucose level, protein, total cholesterol, LDL, VLDL, TG and an
protein, albumin and globulin and decreased the levels of urea, creatinine, uric acid and
Anti cancer activity: Noor A et.al investigated the cytotoxic activity on Hep-2, AMN-3, RD
cell lines and one normal embryo rat cell line. The cytotoxic activity was observed at
concentration of 1000 μg/ml after 72 h. The percentage of cellular damage was 85.83%, 40.06%,
39 | P a g e
Fertility action: The ethanolic extract of SI and vitamin C in promoting fertility in male rats was
reported by Ashamu EA et.al. Significant increase in BW, seminal parameters, testosterone level
and antioxidant activity were observed with SI extract and vitamin C (95).
anticancer, anti-obesity as well as hepato and nephro protective activities. In addition the
40 | P a g e