Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Costing MARATHON PDF
Costing MARATHON PDF
COSTING
1 Day Marathon Revision
CA RAHUL GARG
B.COM, FCA, LCS, ACMA, DISA (ICAI),
CFA (ICFAI), MBA, ADV. DIP. MGT.
ALL INDIA RANKHOLDER
in CA, CS, CMA (incl. AIR 1)
GOLD MEDALIST
Faculty for CA Inter COSTING & Indirect Tax (GST) at Swapnil Patni Classes
Live Classes at Pune & Virtual Classes Across India
Tribute to my Beloved Elder Brother
SACHIN GARG
(Inspiration for me and all my students)
who left for heavenly abode on 3rd May, 2015
CA Rahul Garg B.Com, FCA, LCS, ACMA, CFA (ICFAI), DISA (ICAI), MBA, Adv Dip Mgt.
Gold Medalist All India Rankholder in CA, CS, CMA (incl Rank 1) +91-9876932270
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
Page |i
1. Broke LIMCA BOOK OF RECORDS by being youngest in India to clear all the 3
professional courses CA, CS, CMA at the age of 22 years 7 months with Ranks (A
Record).
2. 5 times All India Rankholder in Professional Exams (A Record).
3. Scored SINGLE DIGIT RANK 3 times (including All India Rank 1).
4. Undisputed achiever of all 3 professional exams with ALL INDIA RANK in ALL.
5. Achieved exemption in 40+ papers out of total 50 papers held by CA, CS, CMA
institutes in his academic career.
6. Awarded by Mr. Atal Bihari Vajpayee in 2010 for exceptional performance in
Academics.
7. One of the best motivator in India.
8. Covered by the National Magazine ‘Career 360’ amongst 12 National Toppers in
2010.
9. Specialist in Time management and Stress management skills.
CA Rahul Garg B.Com, FCA, LCS, ACMA, CFA (ICFAI), DISA (ICAI), MBA, Adv Dip Mgt.
Gold Medalist All India Rankholder in CA, CS, CMA (incl Rank 1) +91-9876932270
P a g e | ii
RANK Certificate for All India Rank 41 (May 06) in CA PE II Exam (now CA Inter)
CA Rahul Garg B.Com, FCA, LCS, ACMA, CFA (ICFAI), DISA (ICAI), MBA, Adv Dip Mgt.
Gold Medalist All India Rankholder in CA, CS, CMA (incl Rank 1) +91-9876932270
P a g e | iii
RANK Certificate for All India Rank 4 (June 08) in CS Inter Exam
CA Rahul Garg B.Com, FCA, LCS, ACMA, CFA (ICFAI), DISA (ICAI), MBA, Adv Dip Mgt.
Gold Medalist All India Rankholder in CA, CS, CMA (incl Rank 1) +91-9876932270
P a g e | iv
RANK Certificate for All India Rank 13 (June 09) in CS Professional (Final) Exam
CA Rahul Garg B.Com, FCA, LCS, ACMA, CFA (ICFAI), DISA (ICAI), MBA, Adv Dip Mgt.
Gold Medalist All India Rankholder in CA, CS, CMA (incl Rank 1) +91-9876932270
Page |v
RANK Certificate for All India Rank 1 (June 08) in CMA Inter Exams
CA Rahul Garg B.Com, FCA, LCS, ACMA, CFA (ICFAI), DISA (ICAI), MBA, Adv Dip Mgt.
Gold Medalist All India Rankholder in CA, CS, CMA (incl Rank 1) +91-9876932270
P a g e | vi
Institute’s Gold Medal for All India Rank 1 (June 08) in CMA Inter Exams
CA Rahul Garg B.Com, FCA, LCS, ACMA, CFA (ICFAI), DISA (ICAI), MBA, Adv Dip Mgt.
Gold Medalist All India Rankholder in CA, CS, CMA (incl Rank 1) +91-9876932270
P a g e | vii
RANK Certificate for All India Rank 3 (June 09) in CMA Final Exams
CA Rahul Garg B.Com, FCA, LCS, ACMA, CFA (ICFAI), DISA (ICAI), MBA, Adv Dip Mgt.
Gold Medalist All India Rankholder in CA, CS, CMA (incl Rank 1) +91-9876932270
P a g e | viii
CA Rahul Garg B.Com, FCA, LCS, ACMA, CFA (ICFAI), DISA (ICAI), MBA, Adv Dip Mgt.
Gold Medalist All India Rankholder in CA, CS, CMA (incl Rank 1) +91-9876932270
CA INTER MAY 2018 QUESTION PAPER ANALYSIS
(held on 7 May 2018)
CA RAHUL GARG
B.COM, FCA, LCS, ACMA, DISA (ICAI), CFA (ICFAI), MBA, ADV. DIP. MGT.
ALL INDIA RANKHOLDER in CA, CS, CMA (incl. AIR 1)
GOLD MEDALIST
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
G
AR
G
L
U
AH
R
A
C
CA RAHUL GARG
All India Rankholder
in all 3 professional degrees
CA CS CMA
Gold Medalist (AIR 1)
Basics…
The term, “supply” has been inclusively defined in the Act. The meaning and scope of supply under GST can be understood
in terms of following six parameters, which can be adopted to characterize a transaction as supply:
1. Supply of goods or services. Supply of anything other than goods or services does not attract GST.
2. Supply should be made for a consideration.
3. Supply should be made in the course or furtherance of business.
4. Supply should be made by a taxable person.
5. Supply should be a taxable supply.
6. Supply should be made within the taxable territory
CA Rahul Garg B.Com, FCA, LCS, ACMA, CFA (ICFAI), DISA (ICAI), MBA, Adv Dip Mgt.
Gold Medalist All India Rankholder in CA, CS, CMA (incl Rank 1) +91-9876932270
Page |2
Modes of Supply
Sale Meaning The term sale was defined under various state VAT laws. Sale means
a sale of goods made within the State for cash or deferred payment
or other valuable consideration but does not include a mortgage,
hypothecation, charge or pledge.
Sale involves transfer of property in goods from one person to
another person for consideration. Under CGST Law sale is treated as
supply leviable to GST. However, the definition of Sale has not been
provided under the GST Law.
Example Mr. X sold laptop worth Rs. 1,00,000 and issued invoice in favour of Mr.
Y. Now ownership in laptop transferred to Mr. Y. Such transaction shall be
covered in sale. It is a supply of goods leviable to GST.
Transfer Meaning The definition of Transfer has not been provided under the GST Law.
The term transfer means, where the ownership may not be
transferred but the right in the goods is transferred.
Example Mr. A is the owner of Xerox machine. He transferred the right to operate
the Xerox machine to Mr. B for a consideration of Rs. 10,000 per month
for four months. Hence, ownership of the machine is not transferred but the
right in the machine is transferred. It is supply of service leviable to GST.
Barter Meaning Barter means the exchange of goods and productive services for other
goods and productive services, without the use of money.
Example Mr. C, a practicing Chartered Accountant provided services to M/s A Ltd.,
dealer of laptops. In return M/s A Ltd. gave a laptop to Mr. C. Here, two-
way supply takes place. Mr. C is making taxable supply of service and M/s A
Ltd., is making taxable supply of goods. Hence, tax is payable by both.
Exchange Meaning When two persons mutually transfer the ownership of one thing for
the ownership of another, neither thing nor both things being money
only, the transaction is called an exchange. Exchange offers on
products such as televisions, mobile phones and refrigerators are
leviable under GST.
Example Mr X is a dealer of new cars. He sells new cars for Rs. 8,25,000 but
agrees to reduce Rs. 1,25,000 on surrendering of old car. Mr. Y who
intends to buy new car worth Rs. 8,25,000 agreed to exchange his old car
with new car. Under GST law, it will be treated as Mr. Y has made supply
of old car to dealer Mr. X and Mr. X has made supply of new car to Mr. Y.
If Mr. Y is registered person, he will be liable to pay GST on Rs. 1,25,000.
Mr. X will be liable to pay GST on Rs. 8,25,000 whether Mr. Y is a
registered person or not.
Licence Meaning Where one person grants to another, or to a definite number of
other persons, a right to do or continue to do in or upon the
immovable property of the granter, the right is called a licence.
Example Mr. X is a developer of information technology software and holder of licence
CA Rahul Garg B.Com, FCA, LCS, ACMA, CFA (ICFAI), DISA (ICAI), MBA, Adv Dip Mgt.
Gold Medalist All India Rankholder in CA, CS, CMA (incl Rank 1) +91-9876932270
Page |3
thereon. License to use software was given to different clients and total
considerations was Rs. 18 lakhs; hence, Mr. X is liable to pay GST.
Rental Meaning Rental means a periodical payment for use of another’s property.
Example Mr. A owns a large vacant land in prime commercial locality. He gives it on
rent of Rs. 1,80,000 per month to a parking contractor, Mr. B who has
set up a parking facility on the said land. It is a taxable supply of service
and hence, Mr. A is liable to pay GST.
Lease Meaning A lease is an agreement whereby the lessor conveys to the lessee, the
right to use an asset for an agreed period of time in return for a
payment or series of payments. A lease may be financial lease or
operating lease.
Example M/s X Ltd. gives an asset worth Rs. 5,00,000 on lease to M/s Y Ltd. The
total payments by Y over the time of lease amount to Rs. 6,50,000.
Thus, it’s a finance lease and GST is payable.
Licenses, leases and rentals of goods were earlier treated as services where the goods were transferred without transfer of right
to use (effective possession and control over the goods) and were treated as sales where the goods were transferred with
transfer of right to use. Under the GST regime, such licenses, leases and rentals of goods with or without transfer of right to
use are covered under the supply of service because there is no transfer of title in such supplies.
Disposal Meaning Disposal consists of selling the assets when the organization is about
to close down. Such transactions will also be considered as supply and
liable to tax under GST Law.
Example Z Ltd. wants to shut down its business owing to depression phase. It is
selling various assets at Rs. 60,00,000. GST will be payable.
Consideration
Insights One of the essential conditions for the supply of goods and/ or services to fall
within the ambit of GST is that a supply is made for a consideration.
However, consideration does not always mean money. It covers anything which
might be possibly done, given or made in exchange for something else. Thus,
consideration includes non-monetary consideration.
Further, a consideration need not always flow from the recipient of the supply. It
can also be made by a third person.
Example Alia Travels Pvt. Ltd., a travel agent books ticket for a customer Mr. Z. Travel agent
raises invoice on customer Mr. Z for transportation of passenger by air of Rs. 10,000 and
his commission of Rs. 500. The entire amount of Rs. 10,500 is not his consideration.
The amount of Rs. 500 retained by the air travel is to be considered as his consideration.
A Sports Club agrees to hire services of cricket player Mr. C for a consideration of Rs. 2
crores. In addition to this, the agreement provides that the player shall be provided with
the car valued for Rs. 20 lakhs. The entire value of Rs. 2.20 crores will be considered as
consideration and subject to tax.
Exclusions The following generally not considered as consideration:
• Grant of pocket money
• Gift or reward (which has not been given in terms of reciprocity) or
• Amount paid on alimony for divorce
CA Rahul Garg B.Com, FCA, LCS, ACMA, CFA (ICFAI), DISA (ICAI), MBA, Adv Dip Mgt.
Gold Medalist All India Rankholder in CA, CS, CMA (incl Rank 1) +91-9876932270
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
C
A
R
AH
U
L
G
AR
G
G
AR
G
L
U
AH
R
A
C