Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Susan Scott, RN, RM, MA, Senior Lecturer, School of Health and Social Sciences,
Massey University, Wellington Campus
Abstract
The shift in health care towards primary health services and health promotion requires nursing education to ensure
students learn to practice in partnership with communities. In primary health care settings opportunities for students
to learn the participatory communication skills required for collaborative practice have been found to be constrained
by a range of factors. An innovative approach increasingly being reported is for nurse educators and students to work
with groups in the community, for example with teenage mothers. In mental health this approach is common, with
consumers willingly working with nurse educators and students to complement the experience students gain working
alongside health care professionals. This paper describes a partnership between a New Zealand nursing programme and
a community trust whereby nursing students together with youth enrolled at a local high school promoted health. The
nursing students reported that the experience encouraged them to view their practice from the perspective of the young
people with whom they were working, and to see their efforts in the school setting as part of the wider community's health.
It is argued that this strategy successfully contributed to the students' acquisition of the collaborative skills required to
develop nursing partnerships within communities.
Key Words: Health promotion, clinical learning, partnership, primary health care, nursing students.
health nursing practice (ACHNE; Swearingen). These (ACHNE, 2010). In New Zealand the imperative to ensure
essential competencies include partnership skills which self-determination by honouring the special relationship
are highly valued in the NZ context where the principles with Maori in accordance with the relationship between
of Te Tiriti o Waitangi underpin health care policy the Crown and the Te Tiriti o Waitangi drives partnership
(Ministry of Health [MOH], 2001). goals (MOH, 2001).
One educational approach which addresses the Nursing in NZ has been identified as being "crucial
concerns outlined is well established in mental health to the implementation" (MOH, 2001, p. 23) of the
nursing both in NZ and internationally, and is popular in Primary Health Care Strategy which is designed to
other areas of nursing internationally including primary address the health needs of the NZ population. A
health care. This requires nurse academics to have a range of approaches has been implemented in recent
direct relationship with consumers of health services years to upskill student nurses and graduates working
(Bennett & Baikie, 2003; Hayward & Weber, 2003; in this sector (Finlayson, Sheridan, & Cumming, 2009;
Repper & Breeze, 2007; Schneebeli, O'Brien, Lampshire, Haggarty, McEldowney, Wilson, & Holloway, 2009; MOH,
& Hamer, 2010; Whittaker & Taylor, 2004). Repper 2003a, 2005, 2008). Given the blurring of boundaries
and Breeze in their literature review of educators who between community-based care which can include
involve users in the preparation of health professionals, nursing activities in secondary care, disease prevention
found that when educators work with consumers and community health promotion (ACHNE, 2010;
students were supported to develop the skills that McMurray & Clendon, 2010) defining the particular
consumers prioritise. This finding is especially useful skills needed for primary health care nursing practice
in primary health care and health promotion where has been acknowledged as complex. In NZ the largest
notions of partnership and empowerment underlie group of nurses working in the primary health care
policy goals in population based community health. area is practice nurses whose role includes both health
Repper and Breeze caution that there is a need to track maintenance and health promotion (Hefford et al.,
relationships between consumers, health professional 2010). This paper uses the terms primary health care
educators and students. Therefore, this paper describes and community based health care interchangeably. Both
a service-based learning partnership in New Zealand incorporate the notion of health promotion.
where a nurse educator worked with a community trust
to enable undergraduate nursing students to develop There are clear changes in the employment settings
their health promotion skills with local high school of the nursing workforce in NZ reflecting the move in
students. direction of health care service delivery both in NZ and
internationally. In North America 68.1% of nurses in
New Zealand Context 1984 worked in hospitals, by 2006 this number had
dropped to 56.2% (Benner et al., 2010). The pattern is
When practising in the area of primary health care, the same in NZ and, although actual figures are hard to
nurses in New Zealand are required, as are nurses obtain, Cook (2009) claims 50% of nurses are working
internationally, to provide care which reflects the in primary health care. The Nursing Council of New
principles of social justice (Department of Health, (DOH) Zealand, however, report that 20-22% are working in this
2003; MOH, 2001, 2003a, 2010; Piper, 2008). This goal area, with another 4-7% working in community health,
requires nurses to relinquish the role of expert and Maori and Pacific services and 48% of nurses working
become partners with their populations of practice in acute hospital settings (NCNZ, 2010a).
District Health Boards (DHBs) employ 62% of nurses have been identified between nurses and groups in the
with most working in hospital areas with high acuity community with these being described as: embracing
(District Health Board NZ Future Workforce, 2009). patterns of partnership (Kool et al.); partnering across
Most graduates practice within the DHB's (Haggarty sectors (Northrup et al); extending practice to include
et al., 2009). These statistics are likely to explain why afterschool programmes (Speroni et al.); advocating for
acute care dominates undergraduate nursing education 'latchkey' programme parental preferences (Murphy &
(NCNZ, 2010b). However it is also likely that there may Povlika); negotiating to overcome gatekeeper barriers to
be wider constraints on access for nursing students to promote youth sexual health (Cleaver & Rich); working
primary health care nursing settings (NCNZ, 2010b). alongside students, teachers and parents (Barnes et
In the programme in which the students who took al.); and finally, gathering survey data to shape practice
part in the project to be described in this paper were (Summers et al.). These practices meet the call for
enrolled, the majority (88%) of undergraduate clinical nurses to "... no longer adopt the role of 'expert' but
experience hours were accessed in environments other work 'for' and 'with' rather than 'on' the people for
than community health. whom the change is intended" (Carlson & Warne, 2007,
p. 511; MOH, 2001).
Background
Gaining access to practice where nurses use these
An important issue arising from the dominance of participatory skills which enable partnerships to be
acute care for undergraduate clinical learning is that established with consumers in the community has
hospital-based nurses have been found to focus on been reported as difficult for nurse educators in the
health education rather than health promotion in its UK. Holt and Warne (2007) found in a study of 100
broadest sense (Carlson & Warne, 2007; Dympna, second year pre-registration nursing programmes
2007; Piper, 2008). Piper, in a qualitative study of 32 that they experienced a "dichotomy" (p. 373) and
registered nurses working in an acute care hospital in the a need for "greater congruence" (p. 379) between
UK, found that "for the most part the narrow meaning health promotion theory and practice. Kenyon and
given to health promotion ... was related to limited Peckover (2008) studying the issue from the perspective
forms of intervention and not activities associated with of the registered nurses and academics, found that
the Ottawa Charter" ( p. 195). One participant referred placing students in community and primary health
to population targets in relation to health promotion as care settings was best described as a juggling act for
"government propaganda" (p. 193). both clinicians and educators. In their UK qualitative
study with 28 staff in a Primary Care Trust (PCT) the
In contrast to the limited understanding of health difficulties encountered during clinical placements of
promotion by some nurses working in hospitals, recent nursing students included managing a 'different' kind
research with primary healthcare nurses working of relationship between clients and nurse. Organising
in school communities reveals nursing practice that opportunities for students to engage with clients was
incorporates the wider social determinants of health found to be hampered by the changing context in
and also partnership perspectives (Barnes, Courtney, which care is delivered in community settings, such as
Pratt, & Walsh, 2004; Cleaver & Rich, 2005; Kool et in home visiting and other outreach services. As was
al., 2008; Murphy & Polivka, 2007; Northrup, Cottrell, pointed out by Kenyon and Peckover this environment
& Wittberg, 2008; Speroni, Earley, & Atherton, 2007; contrasts with institutional settings where the close
Summers et al., 2003). Collaborative relationships working relationships found in these environments.
such as hospitals, limited students independent and promoting and delivering the Bachelor of Nursing (BN)
self directed learning. programme. The Community Trust, which is funded
jointly by a community and the Ministry of Social
Working directly with communities offers another way Development, was assisting local youth to transition
for nursing education to develop and complement into the workforce or tertiary education and the
nursing students' clinical experiences (Hjalmhult, school was developing the health component of their
2009; Lasater, Luce, Volpin, Terwilliger, & Wild, 2007; curriculum. The Trust invited educators from the nursing
Repper & Breeze, 2007; Whittaker & Taylor, 2004). programme, as a regional education provider, to support
This could address the problems which have been its goals and to work through them with the school.
reported between primary and community health care The nursing programme recognised this invitation as an
practitioners and nurse educators (Carlson & Warne, opportunity to develop undergraduate nursing students'
2007; Dympna, 2007; Holt & Warne, 2007; Kenyon & skills and to concurrently promote youth health.
Peckover, 2008; NCNZ, 2010a; Piper, 2008; Whitehead,
2007). What this means is that the nurse educators The curriculum topic chosen by the school was nutrition,
(the academics) work alongside the students as they exercise and health reflecting the Health Promoting
develop partnerships with consumers, thus offering the Schools Organisation 'Healthy Eating Healthy Action'
opportunity to gain access to consumers where they live (HEHA) (MOH, 2003b) campaign. This was described
and work in the community thereby extending clinical as a strategic approach towards improving nutrition,
experience beyond the recognised healthcare services. increasing physical activity and achieving healthy weight
For example, Bentley and Ellison (2005) found that where people live, work and play. The second year
undergraduate students working cooperatively with baccalaureate nursing students who participated in the
teen mothers as part of the Early Head Start initiative project were enrolled in a course, the learning outcomes
in Alabama, developed their understanding of the teens of which emphasised health promoting practice in
health care concerns and cultural difference, as well as primary healthcare settings. The project consisted of a
developing a sense of responsibility towards community group of eight students working with the school teachers
groups. Partnerships between nursing education and and youth to develop an interactive classroom session
communities indicate that they develop the students' held in both semesters of each year over the four years
collaborative skills which are a pre-requisite for effective of the partnership with the school.
promotion of primary health care in the community
(Hayward & Weber, 2003; Whittaker & Taylor, 2004). The nursing students worked directly with senior school
students (16) to plan and deliver an hour long workshop
The Project: Promoting Health in a New session to junior students (>200) during a day designated
Zealand Community Setting for delivery of components of the 'health' curriculum.
Planning consisted of these senior school students
A tripartite partnership between a Community Trust, and the nursing students meeting at the school three
the University nursing programme and a local high times early in each semester and negotiating topics and
school in a NZ community enabled undergraduate activities for the session. The nursing students then
nursing students to work with youth to promote health went away and prepared the resources, and in this stage
in the school classroom over a four year period from of the project visited members of the local community
2005-2008. The goals of the partners in this project to gain support. This led to one supermarket supplying
were complementary. The nursing programme was food samples for demonstration purposes during the
Evaluation of the Project The nursing students also reported making links
between this project work and their clinical placements
Through participating in this project the nursing with primary health care nurses, where some had
students reported in their written evaluations that taken part in home visiting and screening clinics in the
they had enjoyed promoting health with youth and same community in which the school was located. The
engaging in health education on a topic in which the nursing students talked about understanding the school
school students had enthusiastically participated. students within their wider communities.
The Trust analysis of their written evaluations showed
that the school students' understanding of nutritional Discussion
requirements had improved and that the high school
reported the project had successfully contributed to During the conduct of this project the health needs of
the schools' expansion of the health component of the community were aligned with the learning needs of
the curriculum. nursing students. Working in a partnership relationship
During their planning discussions with the school required the nursing students to focus on the needs of
References
Association of Community Health Nurse Educators. (2010). Essentials of baccalaureate nursing education for entry-level community
public health nursing. Public Health Nursing, 27, 371-382. doi:10.1111/j.l525-1446.2010.00867.x
Barnes, M., Courtney, M. D., Pratt, J., & Walsh, A. M., (2004). School-based youth health nurses: Roles, responsibilities, challenges and
rewards. Public Health Nursing, 21, 316-322. doi:10.111/j.0737-1209.2004.21404.x
Benner, P., Sutphen, M., Leonard, V., & Day, L. (2010). Educating nurses: A cali for radical transformation. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Bennett, L., & Baikie, K. (2003). The client as educator: Learning about mental illness through the eyes of the expert. Nurse Education
Today, 23(2], 104-111. doi:10.1016/50260-6917(02)00193-4
Bentley, R., & Ellison, K. J. (2005). impact of a service-learning project on nursing students. Nursing Education Perspectives, 26, 287-290.
Carlson, G. D., & Warne, T. (2007). Do healthier nurses make better health promoters? A review of the literature. Nurse Education
Today, 27, 506-513. doi:10.1016/j.nedt.2006.08.012
Organisation Regionai Office for the Western Pacific Short Term Consuitant. Wellington, New Zealand: Department of Health.
Chappie, M., & Aston, E. S. (2004). Practice learning teams: A partnership approach to supporting students' clinical learning. Nurse
Education in Practice, 4, 143-149.
Cleaver, K., & Rich, A. (2005). Sexual health promotion: The barriers school nurses face. Community Practice, 78, 429-432.
Cook, L. (2009). A nurse education and training board for New Zeaiand: Report to the Minister of l-ieaith: An evaluation of the need
for a nurse education and training board for the oversight of nursing education and training in New Zeaiand. Wellington, New
Zealand: Committee on Strategic Oversight for Nursing Education.
Department of Health. (2003). Liberating the talents: Helping primary care trust nurses deliver the NHS Pian. London: HMSO.
District Health Boards New Zealand (DHBNZ) Future Workforce. (2009). Current status of the nationai reguiated nursing workforce
2009. Wellington, New Zealand: DHBNZ.
Dympna, C. (2007). Nurses perceptions, understanding and experiences of health promotion. Journai of Clinical Nursing, 16, 1039-
1049. doi:10.111/j.l365-2702.2007.01640.x
Finlayson, M., Sheridan, N., & Cumming, J. (2009). Nursing deveiopments in primary health care. Wellington, New Zealand: Health
Services Research Centre.
Haggarty, C, McEldowney, R., Wilson, D., & Holloway, K. (2009). Growing our own: An evaiuation of the nurse entry to practice
programmes in New Zeaiand 2006-2009. Wellington, New Zealand: Ministry of Health.
Hayward, K. S., & Weber, L. M. (2003). A community partnership to prepare nursing students to respond to domestic violence. Nursing
Forum, 38(3), 5-10.
Hefford, M., Cumming, J., Finlayson, M., Raymont, A., Love, I , & van Essen, E. (2010). Practice nurse cost benefit analysis: Report to
the Ministry ofi-iealth. Wellington, New Zealand: LECG
Hjalmhult, E. (2009). Learning strategies of public health nursing students: Conquering operational space. Journal of Clinical Nursing,
18, 3136-3145. doi:10.1111/j.l365-2702.2008.02691.x
Holt, M., & Warne, T. (2007). The educational and practice tensions in preparing pre-registration nurses to become future health
promoters: A small scale explorative study. Nurse Education in Practice, 7, 373-380. doi:10.1016/].nepr.2006.11.009
Kenyon, L., & Peckover, S. (2008). 'A juggling act': An analysis of the impact of providing clinical placements for pre-registration
studentsontheorganisationof community nursing and health visiting work. Nurse Education Today, 28, 202-209. doi:10.1016/j.
nedt.2007.03.014
Kool, B., Thomas, D., Moore, D., Anderson, A., Bennetts, P., & Earp, K. (2008). innovation and effectiveness: Changing the scope of
school nurses in New Zealand secondary schools. Australian & New Zeaiand Journal of Public i-leaith, 32(2), 177-180. Retrieved
from http://www.cinahl.com/cgi-bin/refsvc?jid=1491&accno=2009908168
Lasater, K., Luce, L, Volpin, M., Terwilliger, A., & Wild, J. (2007). When it works: Learning community health nursing concepts from
clinical experience. Nursing Education Perspectives, 28, 88-92.
McMurray, A., & Clendon, J. (2010). Community heaith and Wellness: Primary heaith care in practice. Sydney, Australia: Elsevier.
Ministry of Heaith. (2001). Primary Health Care Strategy. Weilington, New Zealand: Author.
Ministry of Health. (2003a). investing in heaith: Whakatohutia te orange tangata: A framework for activating primary heaith care
nursing in New Zeaiand (4th ed). Wellington, New Zealand: Author.
Ministry of Health (2003b). The heaith promoting schoois process. Wellington, New Zealand: Author.
Ministry of Health. (2005). Evolving models of primary health care nursing practice. Wellington, New Zealand: Author.
Ministry of Health. (2008). Clinicai Training Agency purchase intentions 2008/2009. Wellington, New Zealand: Author.
Murphy, M., & Polivka, B. (2007). Parental perceptionsof the schools' role in addressing childhood obesity. 7oürno/o/Sc/7oo/A/urs/ng,
23(1), 40-46.
Northrup, K. L., Cottrell, L. A., & Wittberg, R. A. (2008). L.i.F.E.: A school-based heart-health screening and intervention program.
Journal of School Nursing, 2 (1), 28-35.
Nursing Council of New Zealand. (2010a). The New Zealand nursing workforce. Wellington, New Zealand: Author.
Nursing Council of New Zealand. (2010b). Report on the review of education programme standards for the registered nurse scope of
practice. Wellington, New Zealand: Author.
Piper, S. (2008). A qualitative study exploring the relationship between nursing and health promotion language, theory and practice.
Nurse Education Today, 28,186-193. doi:10.1016/j.nedt.2007.03.010
Repper, J., & Breeze, J. (2007). User and carer involvement in the training and education of health professionals. A review of the
literature. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 44, 511-519. doi:10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2006.05.013
Schneebeli, C, O'Brien, A., Lampshire, D, & Hamer, H.P. (2010). Service user involvement in undergraduate mental health nursing in
New Zea\aná. International journal of Mentoli-iealth Nursing, 19(1), 30-35. doi:10.1111/j.l447-0349.2009.00642.x
Speroni, K. G., Earley, C, & Atherton, M. (2007). Evaluating the effectiveness of the KID LIVING FIT program: A comparative study.
Journal of School Nursing, 23, 329-336.
Summers, L. C, Williams, J., Borges, W., Ortiz, M., Schaefer, S., & Liehr, P. (2003). School-based health centre viability: Application of
the COPC model community oriented primary care, issues in Comprehensive Pédiatrie Nursing, 26(4), 231-51.
Swearingen, C. D. (2009). Using nursing perspectives to inform public health nursing workforce development. Pubiic Health Nursing,
26{1), 79-87. doi: 10.1111/j.1525-1446.2008.00756.x
Whitehead, D (2007). Reviewing health promotion in nursing education. Nurse Education Today, 27, 225-237. doi:org.ezproxy.massey.
ac.nz/10.1016/J.nedt.2006.05.003
Whittaker, K. A., & Taylor, J. (2004). Learning from the experience of working with consumers in educational developments. Nurse
Education Today, 24, 530-537. doi:10.1016/j.nedt.2004.06.005