Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
The subprime lending crisis in the real estate sector within the United States where in borrowers
with a low or subprime credit rating were given loans to invest in the booming real estate sector in
2004-05 has led not solely to a big slowdown of the US economy but its impact was conjointly
In this project it has been tried in the best means attainable to research the various ways in which
It has also been tried to analyze the way the United States banking and lending agencies
camouflaged their subprime loans into enticing ones and how backed by some credit rating
agencies were able to sell them off to different banks and investors by dividing them into
This project also tries to present a comprehensive image of the losses that the US banking sector
incurred and not simply that but how the complete subprime muddle settled and questioned the
In the end it has been tried to take an Indian view of the whole subprime fiasco and the way India
The economy of the United States has been Earth's largest since the early 1870s by nominal GDP
and the second largest by purchasing power parity. It is a highly developed mixed economy and
private firms make the majority of microeconomic decisions, while being regulated by the
government. The U.S. economy is characterized by a high level of productivity (although not the
world’s highest), high overall GDP growth rate, a low unemployment rate, and high levels of
Subprime Lending
A subprime loan is a type of loan offered at a rate above market rate to individuals who don’t
qualify for prime rate loans. Very often subprime borrowers have been turned down by traditional
lenders attributable to their low credit ratings or alternative factors that recommend they need an
affordable probability of defaulting on the debt reimbursement. Since, these borrowers have been
turned owing to their low credit ratings, they are often charged higher interest rate due to enlarge
risk of default. These loans are generally characterized by higher interest rates and less favorable
subprime car loans, and subprime credit cards, etc. The term "subprime" refers to the credit status
of the recipient (being less than ideal), not the interest rate on the loan itself.
Subprime Lenders
A subprime lender focuses on disposition to borrowers with weak or restricted credit history. A
smaller range of enormous lenders concentrate on subprime lending compared to lenders that
Subprime lenders provide loan to borrowers who are turned down by traditional lenders either due
to their lower credit score, or any other factor that counsel and affordable likelihood of their
defaulting on repayment. Since the amount of risk undertaken by these lenders is way higher than
traditional lenders, they sometimes charge a higher rate of interest. Subprime lenders generally
apply risk-based pricing systems to calculate the terms of the loans and interest rates they charge
to borrowers with variable credit histories. Risk-based pricing appearance at factors like a
consumer’s credit score, adverse credit history, employment status, and income.
Subprime Borrowers
A subprime borrower is a personal with a less-than-perfect credit rating. Subprime borrowers are
charged a slightly higher interest rate on loans; as a result, they’re viewed as having a greater risk
of defaulting. Borrowers may use this credit to purchase homes, or finance different kinds of
payments such as purchasing a car or refurbishing a building. A subprime borrower may not
perpetually stay in its subprime category as this disposal conjointly give a technique for ‘credit
repair’, if borrowers maintain an honest payment record, they ought to be ready to refinance back
onto mainstream rates after a period. Typical traits of subprime borrowers include:
● Two or additional 30-day default within the last twelve months or one 60-day default
Subprime Mortgages
A subprime mortgage is one that's normally issued to borrowers with low credit ratings. A prime
conventional mortgage isn't offered because the lender views the borrower as having a greater-
than-average risk of defaulting on the loan. Subprime mortgages are considered more risky loans
since borrowers with weakened credit histories that include payment defaults and severe problems
such as charge-off, judgments and bankruptcy are provided loan. Subprime borrowers are those
who have FICO (formerly the Fair Isaac Corporation) scores below 620 on a scale that ranges from
300 to 850.
Sometimes to avoid higher mortgage payments, most borrowers take adjustable-rate mortgages
that provide them lower initial interest rate. But with annual adjustments later, these ARMs end
A subprime credit card is a usual credit card but is issued specifically to borrowers with lower
credit scores or limited credit histories. These cards carry relatively higher rate of interest than
credit card issued to prime borrowers. Sometimes they may also come with extra fees and lower
credit limits.
Moreover, subprime credit cards can help a consumer improve poor credit scores. Consumers that
pay their bills on time may see an improvement in their credit rating by major credit reporting
agencies.
OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
● To find out the causes and consequences of the Subprime crisis in USA.
About 44% of Americans owned homes in 1940, this percentage roused to around 68% in 2007.
This huge jump in ownership of houses by Americans was mainly due to a surge in subprime
mortgages. Figure below shows this rise in mortgages over the years 1994-06.
Subprime mortgages are generally provided to those borrowers who don’t qualify to get a loan
from conventional or prime sources. These are, by contrast, more risky when compared to the
mortgage loans, i.e purchaser would receive accrued payments even if the borrower defaulted.
Most mortgage bankers usually rely more on the capital markets than on direct borrowings as a
source of funds for their mortgage originations. These mortgage loans are bundled into portfolio
to sell to the investors through the issuance of new securities whose cash flows are collateralized
by the underlying loan pool. This process is also known as Securitization. The cash proceeds
received by originators through securitizations are used to finance the ongoing production of new
loans.
The credit crisis began as early as in 2005 with disruptions starting in U.S real estate market.
Although, initially this disturbance was considered independent of other markets, it started
spreading to other credit markets by 2007, which led to a system-wide banking panic. This
widespread panic and near-meltdown of financial system continued till the collapse of several
Essentially, this crisis happened due to excessive pressure on the U.S mortgage market. In a report
issued on November 30, 2005, for example, S&P stated: “The credit performance of mortgage
loans and HELOCs is expected to decline from year-to-date measures, due to several factors: rising
short-term interest rates, which are the basis for the repricing of many adjustable-rate mortgages
(ARMs) and HELOCs; more layering of risk; and weaker underwriting standards in some
mortgage products.” Despite such concerns, housing price appreciation continued for some time
Rising prices of homes came to a standstill during 2006, mortgage default and foreclosures began
to rise and mortgage lenders started realizing losses. In a Special Report issued on December 11,
2006, Fitch Ratings indicated that more subprime-backed MBS were downgraded between July
and October 2006 than in any previous four-month period. Fitch further cautioned: The increase
in bond credit risk has been notable in the sub-prime sector, where serious delinquencies have
increased almost 50% and the number of downgrades has jumped in recent months. Additionally,
the sensitivity of subprime performance to the rate of and the large number of borrowers facing
scheduled payment increases in 2007 should continue to put negative pressure on the sector. Fitch
expects delinquencies to rise by at least an additional 50% from current levels throughout the next
year and for the general ratings environment to be negative, as the number of downgrades is
The United States subprime mortgage crisis that appeared in the majority of newspapers
throughout 2007-08 has been said to have the potential to bring the US economy on the verge of a
recession. It has led to the removal of top executives of many renowned financial institutions such
The United States subprime mortgage crisis was a nationwide financial crisis, set off by an
oversized decline in home prices after the collapse of the housing bubble during 2007-10 that led
to the US recession of December 2007 to June 2009. A fall in housing prices resulted in mortgage
The housing bubble prior to the crisis was financed with mortgage-backed securities (MBSs) and
Collateralized Debt Obligations (CDOs), which initially offered higher interest rates than
government securities, along with attractive risk ratings from rating agencies. While elements of
the crisis first became more visible during 2007, several major financial institutions collapsed in
September 2008, with significant disruption in the flow of credit to businesses and consumers, and
A subprime loan is available to potential borrowers who face severe financial problems and are
therefore labeled risky, because of factors like low-income or a poor credit history. Naturally,
owing to their poor credit history they are charged a higher than normal rate of interest. Such
individuals are referred to as subprime borrowers. Subprime lending is a general term that refers
The subprime mortgage crisis was a sharp decline in the prices of homes leading to mortgage
defaults and foreclosures which started in the United States in late 2006 and became a global
The crisis was triggered after the bursting of the housing bubble in the US and high default rates
on "subprime" and other adjustable rate mortgages (ARM) made to higher-risk borrowers with
lower income or lesser credit history than "prime" borrowers. Higher loan incentives given by
lenders and a long-term trend of rising housing prices motivated borrowers to assume mortgages,
believing they would be able to refinance at more favorable terms later. However, once housing
prices started to drop moderately in 2006-2007 in many parts of the U.S., refinancing became more
difficult. The risk spread into mutual funds, pension funds, and corporations who owned these
or collection of mortgages. The mortgages are aggregated and sold to a group of individuals (a
government agency or investment bank) that securitizes, or packages, the loans together into a
security that investors can buy. Similarly, a Collateralized Debt Obligation is an instrument backed
by a pool of loans, mortgages and other assets which is then sold to investors. Since the value of a
collateralized debt obligations (CDO), which offered a higher rate of interest to investors as
compared to the T-bills. While some elements of crisis became visible during 2007, the picture
became clearer by September 2008, when there was a significant disturbance in the flow of credit
As home prices fell, banker lost trust in each other. Due to this they couldn’t price the value of
these assets and hence were reluctant to lend to each other since they could receive mortgage
backed securities (MBS) as collateral. As banks didn’t lend to each other, the whole financial
The mortgage lenders that retained credit risk (the risk of payment default) were the first to be
affected, as borrowers became unable or unwilling to make payments. Major Banks and other
financial institutions around the world have reported losses of approximately U.S. $150 billion as
of February 2008. Due to securitization, many mortgage lenders had passed the rights to the
mortgage payments and related credit/default risk to third-party investors via mortgage-backed
securities (MBS) and collateralized debt obligations (CDO). Corporate, individual and institutional
investors holding MBS or CDO faced significant losses, because of the declining value of the
Lending capacity of financial institutions was severely affected due to the losses on their mortgage-
related securities, which led to overall economic slowdown. Concerns regarding the stability of
key financial institutions resulted in government bailing out some of them to encourage lending
and reinstate investor confidence in markets. Restoration of faith in markets was important at that
time since losses in stock markets and a fall in housing values had already put downward pressure
on consumer spending.
A downtrend in the housing market and following crisis in financial markets led to several
decisions around the world to cut interest rates and governments to implement economic stimulus
packages. Effects on global stock markets due to the crisis were substantial. On an average,
Risks Involved
Due to innovations in securitization the risks related to the inability of homeowners to meet
mortgage payments have been distributed broadly, with a series of consequential impacts. The
crisis can be attributed to a number of factors, such as the inability of homeowners to make their
mortgage payments; poor judgment by either the borrower or the lender; inappropriate mortgage
incentives, and rising adjustable mortgage rates. Further, declining home prices have made
refinancing more difficult. There are three primary risk categories involved:
Credit risk: The risk of default (called credit risk) would be assumed by the bank from where the
loan is originating. However, due to more innovations and developments in securitization, credit
risk is now shared more broadly with the investors, because the rights to these mortgage payments
have been repackaged into a variety of complex investment vehicles, generally categorized as
purchasing the MBS (mortgage-backed securities) and CDO (repacking of existing debt), third-
party investors receive a claim on the mortgage assets, which become collateral in case of
defaulting events.
Asset price risk: CDO (Collateralized Debt obligations) valuation is quite complex and related
"fair value" accounting for such "Level 3" assets are subject to wide interpretation. This valuation
basically derives from the collectibles of subprime mortgage payments, which is quite difficult to
many Corporations. Companies often obtain short-term loans by issuing commercial paper (which
is an unsecured, short-term debt instrument issued by a corporation, typically for the financing of
accounts payable and inventories and meeting short-term liabilities) pledging mortgage assets or
CDO as collateral. However, because of concerns regarding the value of the mortgage asset
collateral linked to subprime and Alt-A loans, which basically affected the issuing ability of
Commercial paper for many corporations due to which the amount of commercial paper issued
falls by approximately 25% to $888 billion as on October 8. In addition, Investors charged higher
Causes
Disintegration of houses:
Subprime borrowing was a significant contributor to an increase in home ownership rates, and the
demand for housing. Between 1997 and 2006, American home prices inflated by 124%. Some
owners used the inflated property worth knowledgeable about within the housing bubble to
refinance their homes with lower interest rates, and remove second mortgages against the
supplementary worth to use the funds for consumer outlay. U.S. home debt as a proportion of
income rose to 130% during 2007, versus 100% earlier within the decade. A culture of
consumerism may be a factor. Overbuilding during the boom period, increasing proceedings rates
and unwillingness of many homeowners to sell their homes at reduced market prices have
considerably inflated the supply of housing inventory available. Sales volume (units) of new
homes dropped by 26.4% in 2007 versus the prior year. By January 2008, the inventory of unsold
new homes stood at 9.8 months based on December 2007 sales volume, the highest level since
1981. Further, a record of nearly four million unsold existing homes was offered.
This excess supply of home inventory places vital downward pressure on prices. As prices decline,
more homeowners were at the risk of default and legal proceedings. According to the S&P/Case-
Shiller housing price index, by November 2007, average U.S. housing prices had fallen
approximately 8% from their 2006 peak. However, there was significant variation in price changes
across U.S. markets, with several appreciating and others depreciating. The price decline in
Borrowers
Easy credit, combined with the assumption that housing prices would still appreciate, conjointly
encouraged several subprime borrowers to obtain ARMs they could not afford after the initial
incentive period. Once housing prices started depreciating moderately in many parts of the U.S,
refinancing became tougher. Some homeowners were unable to refinance loans and started to
default on loans as their loans reset to higher interest rates and payment amounts. Other
homeowners, facing declines in the home market value or with limited accumulated equity, are
selecting to prevent paying their mortgage. They’re primarily "walking away" from the property
Financial institutions:
A variety of factors have caused lenders to supply an increasing array of higher-risk loans to
higher-risk borrowers, the risk premium required by lenders to offer a subprime loan declined.
This occurred even if subprime borrower and loan characteristics declined overall during the 2001-
2006 period, which should have had the opposite effect. The combination is common to classic
boom and bust credit cycles. Some believe that mortgage standards became apathetic due to moral
hazard, wherever every link within the mortgage chain collected profits while believing it was
passing on risk.
Securitization:
are acquired, classified into pools, and offered as collateral for third-party investment. Because of
securitization, investor appetite for mortgage-backed securities (MBS), and therefore, the tendency
of rating agencies to assign investment-grade ratings to MBS, loans with a high risk of default
could be originated, packaged, and the risk promptly transferred to others. Asset securitization
began with the structured financing of mortgage pools in the 1970s. The securitized share of
subprime mortgages (i.e., those passed to third-party investors) increased from 54% in 2001, to
75% in 2006.
Mortgage Brokers:
Mortgage brokers do not lend their own money. There is not a direct correlation between loan
performance and compensation. They need massive money incentives for selling complex,
adjustable rate mortgages (ARM's), since they earn higher commissions. The chairman of the
Mortgage Bankers Association claimed brokers profited from a home loan boom however didn't
A subprime loan is one that is offered at an interest rate higher than A-paper loans because of the
enhanced risk. Subprime, therefore, isn’t identical as "Alt-A” because Alt-A loans qualify for the
"A-rating" by Moody's or alternative rating corporations, albeit for an "alternative" means. Higher
ratings were theoretically due to the multiple, independent mortgages held in the MBS per the
Central banks:
Central banks are primarily concerned with managing the rate of inflation and avoiding recessions.
They are also the “lenders of last resort” to ensure liquidity. They are less concerned with avoiding
asset bubbles, such as the housing bubble and dotcom bubble. Central banks have usually chosen
to react after such bubbles burst to minimize collateral impact on the economy, instead of
attempting to avoid the bubble itself. This is often as a result of identifying an asset bubble and
determining the proper monetary policy to deflate it is not proven concepts. A potential
contributing factor to the increase in home prices was the lowering of interest rates earlier in the
decade by the Federal Reserve, to diminish the blow of the collapse of the dot-com bubble and
The widespread dispersion of credit risk and the unclear impact on financial institutions caused
lenders to reduce lending activity or to make loans at higher interest rates. Similarly, the ability of
corporations to obtain funds through the issuance of commercial paper was impacted. This aspect
of the crisis is consistent with a credit crunch. The liquidity concerns drove central banks around
the world to take action to provide funds to member banks to encourage the lending of funds to
The subprime crisis also places downward pressure on economic growth, because fewer or more
expensive loans decrease investment by businesses and consumer spending, which drive the
economy. A separate but related dynamic is the downturn in the housing market, where a surplus
inventory of homes has resulted in a significant decline in new home construction and housing
prices in many areas. This also places downward pressure on growth. With interest rates on a large
number of subprime and other ARM due to adjust upward during the 2008 period, U.S. legislators
and the U.S. Treasury Department are taking action. A systematic program to limit or defer interest
rate adjustments was implemented to reduce the impact. In addition, lenders and borrowers facing
defaults have been encouraged to cooperate to enable borrowers to stay in their homes. The risks
to the broader economy created by the financial market crisis and housing market downturn were
primary factors in the January 22, 2008 decision by the U.S. Federal reserve to cut interest rates
and the economic stimulus package signed by President Bush on February 13, 2008. Both actions
are designed to stimulate economic growth and inspire confidence in the financial markets.
Stock Markets
When the mortgage market liquefied down in 2007, it had a way broader impact than plummeting
home values. As mortgages went down, they additionally combined with alternative broader
economic problems to clean up credit markets and cause the securities market to lose worth.
Although, as of July 2013, the market as a full has recovered from its post-mortgage crisis lows,
The bigger picture is that the mortgage crisis caused a lack of confidence in the financial system
and the economy. The mortgage market is a major part of global finance, and finding out that it
was on shaky grounds scared investors. In addition, the loss of housing values and the inability of
homeowners to pull money out of housing led to a recession that stalled corporate growth, further
causing prices to plummet. The mortgage crisis had specific effects on some stocks and industries.
discounted costs, wiping out billions of dollars of stockholder worth. Companies in the housing
Many banks, mortgage lenders, real estate investment trusts (REIT), and hedge funds suffered
February 19, 2008, financial institutions had recognized subprime-related losses or write-downs
exceeding U.S. $150 billion. Other companies from around the world, such as IKB Deutsche
Industriebank, have also suffered significant losses and scores of mortgage lenders have filed for
bankruptcy. Top management has not escaped unscathed, as the CEOs of Merrill Lynch and
Citigroup were forced to resign within a week of each other. Various institutions followed-up with
merger deals.
Home owners
According to the S&P/Case-Shiller housing price index, by November 2007, average U.S. housing
prices had fallen approximately 8% from their 2006 peak However, there was significant variation
in price changes across U.S. markets, with many appreciating and others depreciating. By January
2008, the inventory of unsold new homes stood at 9.8 months based on December 2007 sales
supply) is reduced to more typical levels as home prices have declined following the rise of home
prices caused by speculation and as refinancing standards have tightened, a number of homes have
been foreclosed and sit vacant. Rents have not fallen as much as home prices with the result that
in some affluent neighborhoods homes that were formerly owner occupied are now occupied by
renters. In select areas falling home prices along with a decline in the U.S. dollar have encouraged
foreigners to buy homes for either occasional use and/or long-term investments.
International Trade
The United States is the most significant nation when it comes to international trade. For a long
period of time, the US has led the world in imports while at the same time it remains as one of the
top three exporters of the world. Due to its presence in foreign trade around the globe a large
amount of U.S. dollars in circulation all around the planet; about 60% of funds used in international
trade are U.S. dollars. The dollar is also used as the standard unit of currency in international
Since the US plays a central role in international trade, it enjoys several leverages, one being
because it is the world's leading consumer; it is the number one customer for all other countries.
Many businesses compete for a share of the United States market. In addition, the United States
occasionally uses its economic leverage to impose economic sanctions in different regions of the
world. USA is the top export market for almost 60 trading nations worldwide.
HOW CRISIS WAS ADDRESSED
President George W. Bush announced a plan to voluntarily and temporarily freeze the mortgages
of a limited number of mortgage debtors holding ARMs. A refinancing facility called Federal
Housing Administration- FHA-Secure was created. This is part of an ongoing collaborative effort
between the US Government and private industry to help some subprime borrowers called the
Hope Now Alliance. The Hope Now Alliance released a report in February, 2008 indicating it
helped 545,000 subprime borrowers with shaky credit in the second half of 2007, or 7.7 percent of
7.1 million subprime loans outstanding in September 2007.During February 2008, a program
called "Project Lifeline" was announced. Six of the largest U.S. lenders, in partnership with the
Hope Now Alliance, agreed to defer foreclosure actions for 30 days for homeowners 90 or more
days delinquent on payments. The intent of the program was to encourage more loan adjustments,
to avoid foreclosures.
President Bush also signed into law on February 13, 2008 an economic stimulus package of $168
billion, mainly in the form of income tax rebates, to help stimulate economic growth.
Other actions
Some lenders have taken action to reach out to homeowners to provide more favorable mortgage
terms (i.e., loan modification or refinancing). Homeowners have also been encouraged to contact
their lenders to discuss alternatives. Corporations, trade groups, and consumer advocates have
begun to cite statistics on the numbers and types of homeowners assisted by loan modification
programs.
Credit rating agencies help evaluate and report on the risk involved with various investment
alternatives. The rating processes can be re-examined and improved to encourage greater
transparency to the risks involved with complex mortgage-backed securities and the entities that
provide them.
Regulators and legislators can take action regarding lending practices, bankruptcy protection, tax
policies, affordable housing, credit counseling, education, and the licensing and qualifications of
lenders. Regulations or guidelines can also influence the nature, transparency and regulatory
reporting required for the complex legal entities and securities involved in these transactions.
IMPACT OF SUBPRIME CRISIS ON INDIA
Even though the Indian markets were experiencing the echo, the Indian banking system had
remained fairly insulated from any direct impact of the subprime crisis in the US. This was because
the Indian banks did not have significant exposure to subprime loans in the US. However, there
was a major impact on the equity Markets as many foreign institutional investors (FIIs) sold off
their investments into Indian Companies to cover their huge losses. International Trade also
suffered due to lack of demand for exports and Export growth suffered due to external demand
shocks which leads to fall of export from 40% to 22% in 2008-09. Also, a subprime like scenario
in India seems unlikely given the current state of affairs. First and foremost, thing, the mortgage
market in India stands nowhere in comparison with the developed economies like the United
States, China, UK, despite of rapid growth in the nation. Mortgages as a percentage of GDP in
India are still at a small percentage as compared with the US and the UK. Secondly, Balanced and
Forward-looking approach has been accepted by the Indian regulators. Its continuous doses of
monetary tightening aim to ensure that the money supply (and hence inflation) is kept within
manageable limits so they reduced the CRR by cumulative 400 basis points to 5%, Repo rate
reduced by 425 basis points to 4.75% and Reverse repo rate was reduced by 275 basis points to
3.25%. Also, no Doubt Housing prices in India got affected but it has more to do with Demand
A subprime loan is given to individuals that don't qualify for a traditional loan, owing to factors
like low financial gain or a poor credit history. A subprime loan usually carries a higher rate of
Subprime loans are most common in mortgage loans and also it has the ability to endanger the
entire financial system. These formed nearly one fifth of all U.S. mortgage loans in 2006, going
up from 9 per cent till 2004. Subprime loans were meant for such borrowers that couldn’t borrow
In order to attract borrowers, lenders adopted predatory practices. They did it intentionally
knowing there will be default, and if that occurred, seized the houses mortgage and sell them off
to make a profit. The main reason behind lenders taking this amount of risk was credit derivative
instruments based on these mortgages which were then sold to investors. Moreover, investors were
also willing to accept these derivatives (CDOs) since the rate of return was way higher than the
Usually, a bank or mortgage finance company lent to a subprime borrower to finance the purchase
of a house. To lure its borrowers, lenders started adjusted-rate mortgage in which the interest rate
applied on the outstanding balance that vary throughout the life of the loan. For instance consider
a 2-28 loan. During the first two years of a 30-year mortgage loan, interest was pegged at a low
fixed rate of 4 per cent and then in the following 28 years, the rate was floating at around 5 per
its downward course during 2006-07. In order to sell the mortgage loans to investors, these lenders
had converted these mortgages into baskets and created Collateralized Debt Obligation. The basket
was divided on the basis of different risk and return characteristics. These CDOs were bought by
some big investment banks in which super rich invested for higher returns. They in turn financed
these investments by borrowing from banks against the security of CDOs. The whole arrangement
crumbled when things turned adverse with falling home prices and rising interest rates.
As a result of this downtrend in housing market, confidence in the banking system was rudely
shaken. Due to a lack of trust among banks, interbank money market fell to its lowest level.
Authorities in Europe and also the U.S. had to pump in cash to avert the system from collapsing.
These developments had their impact on Indian stock markets during which several hedge funds
and investment banks had invested with. Once they faced liquidity issues within the U.S., they
sold a part of their Indian holdings, causing the share indices down.
REFERENCES