Professional Documents
Culture Documents
designs from leading markets and are manufactured to the
highest standards
A cornerstone of a global marketing mix program is the set
of product policy decisions that multinational companies
(MNCs) constantly need to formulate.
The range of product policy questions may include:
PRODUCT What new products should be developed for what
markets?
• a product is anything that can be offered What products should be added, removed, or
modified for the product line in each of the countries
to a market that might satisfy a want or in which the company operates?
need. However it is much more than just
a physical object. It is the complete Global product examples
Gillette razor blades
bundle of benefits or satisfactions that
–
3
Localization and adaptation both involve some Herzberg's Two-Factor Theory of management
changes or accommodations in product design provides a useful analogy for understanding
to meet local demand and use factors. the different dynamics of localization versus
However, localization refers to changes needed adaptation. Herzberg identified both hygiene
to make a product functional, usable, and factors and motivators which affect the relative
minimally acceptable to customers in a given level of one's job satisfaction. Hygiene factors,
market area. For example, electric appliances such as pay, working conditions, policies and
require voltage accommodations and plug practices, and interpersonal relations, have to
design that allow them to be used in certain be at an acceptable level for workers to avoid
local markets; and laundry detergents may job dissatisfaction and the organization to
have to undergo some composition changes to avoid turnover and attrition. Motivators include
work properly with local water, which may be aspects such as meaningful work offering
harder or softer, and therefore mitigate the core intrinsic rewards, accomplishment recognition,
functioning of the detergent. No matter how and growth and advancement opportunities.
great the brand awareness or product benefits The presence of these factors directly increase
associated with the product, customers cannot the level of satisfaction with work, thereby
use them until they are localized. turning a "bearable" or "acceptable" job into a
desirable and sought after job.
Adaptation, on the other hand, refers to
modifications made in product design to Localization acts in much the same way as
enhance the customer's perception of value and hygiene factors do such that they create
ultimate satisfaction with the product. acceptability of the product and avoid product
Adaptations are made to better meet dissatisfaction and rejection. Adaptation has
customers' tastes or preferences. Products an impact similar to motivators in that it
may be functional and usable in a given market, enhances the desirability of the product offered
but possess insufficient competitive advantage and enhances product image, demand, and
over other product alternatives that cater more customer satisfaction.
closely to local customs and preferences.
4
kdacanay
Why do Global Product Lines Differ?
History
Different local products were well established before
standardization was feasible
M&A (Mergers & Acquisitions)
Complete integration is often difficult in M&A cases
Preferences
Differences in preferences force product line
customization
Capacity
Localization, in and of itself, does not preempt a
Global product lines need large production capacity
standardized product approach. The primary
features and benefits of a product may remain Channels
the same even when localization is required. In
products designed to have multisystem Channel loyalties makes it difficult to drop local
compatibility, the product may be made to products.
accommodate many local operating scenarios
in one version, as with laptop computers which
have built-in adapters to make them usable all Product and Gamble offers some product lines in a
over the world. Adaptation, however, moves in variety of countries but also offers local products
a direction opposite that of standardization, in certain markets. Tide and Cheer are sold
and is applied in markets where tastes and globally but Vizir is a regional detergent.
preferences have not yet converged and show Benetton changes its product line based on the local
no immediate signs of doing so. market’s level of discretionary income, climate
and fashion style since wool sweaters are likely to
prove more popular in New York than in Miami.
Nokia offers different models in different markets based
on a country’s technological infrastructure and
local demand sophistication.
kdacanay
6
There are numerous possible advantages to such
standardization when applied to global marketing
activities.
*cost reduction - cost per unit is most typically the
focus since standardization allows economies of
scale and scope. Obtaining standardized materials
and components or applying standardized production *global customers - additionally, products
techniques provides lower costs per unit produced. which are going to be used by the purchaser in
Therefore, prices can be more competitive and/or multiple countries are more attractive when
profit margins may be larger. When the same media they are standardized. One example would be a
can be used across markets or the same brand name, traveler who uses a laptop computer when he
bulk purchasing and carryover effects reduce the costs goes to other countries. He will prefer to be
of promoting and supporting products. able to get software, repairs, service, hook-ups
etc. that are compatible with his model. If it is a
globally standardized product, this is more
*enhanced customer preference - this is also a likely. In a different scenario, companies who
function of carryover or spillover effects from one want to use computers in multiple locations of
market to another. As had been noted, in a number of their business need standardized products so
countries well-known global brands are preferred over software can be shared, electronic networking
domestic ones because of their perception of quality may be enhanced, and so forth.
and superiority.
*global segments - increasingly marketers are
*improved quality - more research and development discovering segments of consumers which are
and other up- front product investments can be made identifiable across many of the world's markets.
This is especially evident when the
when the product is expected to have a global
segmentation characteristics are high income,
customer base. This follows the same logic as high levels of education, lifestyle variables, and
presented in cost reduction. Therefore overall quality business/industry markets. These common
should be enhanced. segments provide sensible rationale for a
standardized approach.
kdacanay
7
disadvantages of standardization. These include: *strong local competitors - standardized
approaches often suffer from lack of presence
*being off-target - a standardized product or other or a "feel" for the local market. Therefore, local
marketing activity runs the risk of being "something competitors may be able to construct a total
for everyone, but everything for no one". That is, core and augmented product package which
products designed to have satisfactory or acceptable offers customers more overall value than a
features for a mass global market may not be globally standardized offering. The same may
sufficiently tailored to beat out competing be true with distribution channels and after-sale
alternatives which are more directly customized for support as well as promotional themes,
various target markets. This is more critical in vehicles, and execution.
markets with sophisticated or diverse consumers
who have differences in tastes, preferences, or uses. The likelihood that global marketing and
implementation will not succeed increases
*lack of uniqueness - following the same logic, when:
standardized global products have no novelty nor do
they contribute to a consumer's unique self-concept. o Insufficient marketing research is performed in
This may be particularly important for socially relevant market areas.
conspicuous products, those which convey some
level of status, and those which are considered value- o Products are overstandardized, especially
expressive or personality/culture related. relative to the positioning.
*sensitivity to protectionism - protectionist measures o Frequent follow-up on initial plans and
distort market mechanisms in countries where they activities does not take place.
are implemented. Protectionist measures still would
not be an overbearing problem if they were applied
uniformly across markets, but in most instances, o The vision emanating from headquarters or
trade barriers are unique to specific country markets, upper management is too narrow and inflexible.
making standardized approaches impractical and
unfeasible. o Implementation and execution are centrally
dictated such that excessive rigidity and lack of
market responsiveness occurs.
kdacanay
8
Honda’s Non-Global Car Models
kdacanay
9
Pitfalls of Standardization
Pitfalls of Standardization
kdacanay
10
New product development
Differences between European and North American
new product development programs:
kdacanay
11
“64 ideas make one successful product”
Number of
surviving
new product
ideas
kdacanay
12
Five Stages of the New Product Development Process
New Products’ Speed of Diffusion
Idea Generation
Local subsidiaries are likely to have some
ideas from their respective markets and Relative advantage – how much better is the new product?
new technology is a common source of
new product ideas The perceived marginal value of the new product relative
the old
Preliminary Screening
The most immediate evaluation of an idea is
whether it is compatible with the company Compatibility – can the product be used in terms of local
objectives, strategies, and resources. infrastructure & customs?
Its compatibility with acceptable behavior,norm,values
Concept Research
Focus Groups offer the development team a
chance to hear spontaneous reactions to a Complexity – is it easy to use?
new concept and hear suggestions for
improvement. The degree of complexity associated with product use
commercialization
Observability – are the advantages obvious?
The ease with which the product benefits can be
communicated
kdacanay
13
Degree of product/service newness
Degree of product/service newness
Refers to the extent to which a product or service
is new to the market Innovation
A product new to the world
New product to existing market Radical innovation
The creation of new industries or new standards of
a product never before offered to the market management,manufacturing,and servicing that
represent fundamental changes for consumers,
entailing departures from established
new product to existing company consumption
A new product that the company offers to the Dynamically continuous innovation
market;the product competes with similar Innovation that does not alter significantly consumer
competitor offerings behavior but still entails a change in the
consumption pattern
has more disruptive effects than a continuous
New line innovation,although it generally does not involve
new consumptions patterns,mean the creation of a
A new product category offered by the company new product or considerable alteration of an
existing one designed to fulfill new needs arise
from changes in lifestyles or new expectations
New item in an existing product line brought about by change
A new brand that the company offers to the Continuous innovation
market in an existing product line Product innovation where there is no disruption in
consumption patterns;such innovation involves
product alterations such as new flavors or new
Modification products that are improvement over the old
The alteration of an existing company product offering
Has the least disruptive influence established
consumption patterns. Alteration of product is
almost always involved rather than the creation of
a new product
kdacanay
14
Counterfeit Products
Counterfeit products are damaging to the brand’s equity & must
be controlled, often by direct intervention.
A Rolex watched bought from
Design counterfeiting. Copying designs or scents of another a sidewalk vendor in New York
company is certainly more likely to be
Brand name counterfeiting. Selling counterfeit products as brand counterfeit when purchased
name originals for $20 as compared with a
$2000 watch acquired from an
authorized distributor. It will be
1. COUNTERFEITS OR KNOCKOFFS ARE FAKE PRODUCTS far more difficult determining
THAT ARE DESIGNED AND LABELED SO AS TO whether a gray good has been
MISLEAD THE CUSTOMER INTO ASSUMING THAT purchased unless the
THEY ARE “THE REAL DEAL.” consumer knows which
2. WORLDWIDE LOSSES DUE TO COUNTERFEITING IS product lines are available in
OVER $20 BILLION ANNUALLY certain markets and whether
the vendor advertises styles
3. COUNTERFEITERS OPERATE AT ALL LEVELS OF THE
ECONOMY, JUST ABOUT ANY PRODUCT OR and prices that are not
TECHNOLOGY DEVELOPMENT IS FAIR GAME customary for a particular
brand.
CODING DEVICES –
firms encode unique signatures to products
(e.g. Levi’s micro-weave patterns, Microsoft’s Windows 95
tracking codes)
kdacanay
15
Global product elements
kdacanay
16
Global Brands
kdacanay
17
Johansson, Johny K., and Hirano, Masaaki
(1999), "Brand reality: the Japanese perspective"
Journal
, of Marketing Management , January-
April, p. 93.
Brands are more important since global
The Japanese conception of brand identity has
started to change as Japanese companies face
consumers have become more pervasive.
increasing competition from Western rivals. As more people travel, work or study in
Traditionally, brands in Japan have symbolized various parts of the world, consumers
not only the company and the product, but also become attracted to familiar brands that
the individual employee's sense of identity and are available in a variety of different
belonging to the company. Brand management locations. The risk associated with new
is a concept that is developing slowly in Japan. product trial can be totall eliminated by
. Johansson, Johny K., and Hirano, Masaaki the globalization of consumer goods
(1999), "Brand reality: the Japanese perspective"
markets. Clearly brands play a more
Journal
, of Marketing Management , January-
April, p. 93. major role in higher involvement
purchases, since consumers will be less
willing to try an unknown brand when the
The Japanese conception of brand identity has
started to change as Japanese companies face financial risk is higher. Items bought
increasing competition from Western rivals. infrequently are also likely to be
Traditionally, brands in Japan have symbolized dominated by brands, since consumers
not only the company and the product, but also will have fewer bases for evaluating
the individual employee's sense of identity and alternatives.
belonging to the company. Brand management
is a concept that is developing slowly in Japan.
kdacanay
18
19
Intellectual property
• A patent may be granted for a new, useful, and
• deals with patents, trademarks and copyrights. non-obvious invention, and gives the patent
These are intangible assets: the right to protect holder a right to prevent others from practicing
your invention from imitation, your brand name the invention without a license from the
from appropriation, or a song you wrote from inventor for a certain period of time (typically
performance and plagiarism. 20 years from the filing date of a patent
application).
• Intellectual property laws confer a bundle of
exclusive rights in relation to the particular form • A trademark is a distinctive sign which is used
or manner in which ideas or information are to distinguish the products or services of
expressed or manifested, and not in relation to different businesses.
the ideas or concepts themselves The term "
intellectual property" denotes the specific legal
rights which authors, inventors and other IP • An industrial design right protects the form of
holders may hold and exercise, and not the appearance, style or design of an industrial
intellectual work itself. object (e.g. spare parts, furniture, or textiles).
• Intellectual property laws are designed to protect
different forms of subject matter, although in • A trade secret (which is sometimes either
some cases there is a degree of overlap. equated with, or a subset of, "confidential
information") is secret, non-public information
• Copyright may subsist in creative and artistic concerning the commercial practices or
works (e.g. books, movies, music, paintings, proprietary knowledge of a business, public
photographs, and software) and give a copyright disclosure of which may sometimes be illegal.
holder the exclusive right to control reproduction
or adaptation of such works for a certain period • Patents, trademarks, and designs rights are
of time (historically a period of between 10 and sometimes collectively known as industrial
30 years depending on jurisdiction, more recently property, as they are typically created and used
the life of the author plus several decades). for industrial or commercial purposes.
kdacanay
20
International pricing
Price is the only marketing mix Several options exist to lower the export
instrument that creates revenues. price:
All other elements entail costs.
Global pricing
Channels (markups)
kdacanay
21
International pricing decisions
Prices higher in the home market Prices lower in the home market
Setting prices in the home market than in the Setting prices lower in the home country,
international market is justified by, among compared to company prices in the
others,one or a combination of the following: international market,is justified among other by
one or a combination of the following
A lower labor or raw material cost in the
international market There may be no cost advantages to producing
Strong local competition in the international overseas, such as economies of scale and labor
market to justify a lower price
A lower buying power of host country There may be few or no challenges from
consumers relative to consumers in the competition in the international market
company's home market The market potential might be limited
A firms goal to increase market share by using Buyers in the international market can afford to
a penetration pricing strategy in the the higher price
international market,
kdacanay
22
International pricing decisions
kdacanay
23
Why is it so difficult to set and control uniform standard Price escalation, price quotes, trade credit: Price
prices in global markets? escalation is a problem that primarily plagues the export
marketer. Prices in foreign markets are generally higher than
Pricing in a domestic setting is a complex and imprecise those at home because of the increased costs arising from
task, but that complexity is magnified geometrically when tariffs, duties, exchange rate fluctuations, transportation
extended to international markets. A large number of and customs costs, etc. These costs can, as mentioned, be
factors affect price setting outside the domestic market: hard to estimate in advance, and therefore make advance
price quotations difficult to determine. Price escalation may
be thwarted somewhat through knockdown assembly
Costs and experience curves: the Cost-plus formulas shipping, a change in the location of origin of the product
may be hard to use, especially in exporting, since all the or foreign direct investment. Final price quotes on exports
relevant costs may be hard to determine in advance. In must also consider how much of the logistics costs are to
addition, headquarters usually has to make a decision be assumed by the buyer and how many by the seller. And
whether only the direct costs will be charged against the total price quote may not be as important on very
products in foreign markets, leaving domestic prices to expensive purchases as the favorability of trade credit
cover fixed overhead and administrative costs, or what arrangements. Producers who can obtain, offer, or arrange
percentage of overhead and administrative costs those favorable payments and terms for buyers are able to charge
products should carry. Marginal cost coverage is often a total price that is higher than competitors who are unable
preferred when penetrating new markets or reducing to offer these services.
excess inventory. When those products are treated as
stand-alone profit centers, full cost accountability is usually
allocated. Low introductory prices may also be used in Exchange rates, hedging: For exporters there is also
anticipation of experience-curve effects with increased the problem of exchange rate fluctuations. Prices quoted
production and sales volume. Expanding into other well in advance based on exchange rates at the time may
markets increases output and therefore scale and scope result in a windfall profit or a large loss if exchange rates
economies, however, per unit cost reductions in unknown between the relevant currencies are significantly different at
markets can be difficult to forecast accurately. the time payment becomes due. Hedging is a method of
protecting one or more of the parties against these
uncontrollable changes. It may involve forward purchasing
Competition and demand: Competition may take the of currencies, exchange of currencies, or other methods to
form of foreign vs. domestic, not only in terms of insure the same "value" of exchange when the transaction
nationalistic perceptions, but also the ability of foreign is complete.
imports to compete on the same cost/price basis as
domestic offerings. Competitive parity may be an
approach used when comparing prices of other foreign government intervention: Foreign governments may
product alternatives in the marketplace. Further, a affect price setting by artificially inflating or deflating the
competitive price basis may be determined by assessing a values of their home currencies. They may also set price
product's unique or competitive features/benefits package controls which usually prohibit setting prices above a
and adjusting price with a premium price differential. predetermined level without approval by the government.
Demand is also considered in determining what the market Governments also have different approaches to regulating
will bear. A unique product in a strong demand market has price discrimination - in some countries regulation is strict,
the ability to carry a high profit margin. Conversely, a in some it is lax, and in some it is nonexistent, although
commodity-type product in a soft demand market reduces most, if not all, governments take a stand against bribery, at
markups significantly. Thus uniform prices across markets least in principle.
with different competition and demand structures are not kdacanay
very realistic. 24
characteristics of the three approaches to pricing in Why are so many foreign‑made products
global companies? cheaper in the United States, while very few
American‑made products are cheaper abroad?
How will global electronic commerce change
Polycentric pricing - Prices are set locally in this?
each market without constraints from
headquarters. Prices may vary considerably
Because of its size, the United States is an
across markets, but local adaptability to
important market for many foreign producers,
changing market conditions is enhanced. in some cases their greatest market. It is also a
very free and open market, with strong
Geocentric pricing - This is the most common of competitive pressure on prices. Regulations are
the pricing strategies employed in foreign kept to a minimum internally, and lack of
markets and it revolves around the use of a enforceable resale price maintenance has
global or regional standard plus a markup that resulted in strong intra-brand competition. The
same brand of a product is often sold at widely
is variable across countries. The comparison
varying prices in different types of retail outlets.
price is derived for the home country or some This is also why American consumers tend to
other lead country for the world or regional be very price conscious -- widely different prices
trading bloc. Coordination across markets can mean that you need to find out whether you
be difficult so gray trade is a consideration. might get a better deal somewhere else. In their
Geocentric pricing poses the greatest execution home markets, many of these foreign producers
challenges when considering product line are often protected by natural and artificial
pricing, but still is probably the most well- entry barriers, and their dominance there makes
balanced compromise to pricing strategy. it possible for them to maintain higher prices
than in the United States. Examples include
Japanese camera makers and European auto
Ethnocentric pricing - Using this approach, the manufacturers and apparel makers. In contrast,
same price is charged to all customers American companies have often less direct
regardless of their location. This produces the protection, and their wavering allegiance to
most uniform prices worldwide, but may not be American workers and American plants has
realistic. It is generally based on a cost-plus discredited any pro-American buying sentiment
formula and works best with highly on the part of their consumers. As a result, they
standardized products and marketing cannot keep prices high at home. At the same
approaches. time, their large home market makes any one
market abroad often seem insignificant, and
kdacanay
makes it tempting for them to keep prices 25
higher there, only skimming the foreign markets.
From a marketing viewpoint, what are the . Samli, Coskun, and Jacobs, Laurence (1994), "
advantages and disadvantages of allowing Pricing Practices of American Multinational
local units to set their own prices? Firms: Standardization vs. Localization
Dichotomy", Journal of Global Marketing , vol. 8,
From a traditional marketing perspective the no. 2, pp. 51-71.
local units should be allowed to set prices so as
to adapt optimally to local market conditions. This article discusses findings regarding the
This means that the local units should set their international pricing practices of a sample of
own prices -- the classic case of what economic Fortune 500 companies. Specifically, an
theory calls "price discrimination." The local attempt is made to determine if these
units maximize their profits, and the firm companies behave in an "A" or "J" manner on
maximizes its total profits. the basis of their pricing practices. The "A"
firms are global while "J" companies are
The main drawback of such a practice is that multilocal. The authors also explore some of
local markets are not often completely the specific international pricing activities of
separable from each other. Customers can these firms and try to make an implicit
move between markets. One supplier can ship connection between these activities and the
to several markets, especially with the help of a international growth of their businesses.
gray trader. This means that price
discrimination will be unworkable -- the lower 2. Cavusgil, S. Tamer (1996), "Pricing for global
price markets will sell a lot, the higher price markets",Columbia Journal of World Business ,
markets little, as customers shift their buying to Winter, vol. 31, no. 4, pp. 66-78.
the lower price alternative. There is need for
coordination -- for "joint optimization," in the Many factors contribute to the complexity of
economic theory language. pricing in international markets. Among these
are multiple currencies, trade barriers,
Apart from the sales effects of gray trade, additional cost considerations, and longer
different prices in different markets can also distribution channels. This article discusses the
lead to a diffusion of brand image and key questions asked by any firm making price
positioning. Finding a Seiko watch at a rock- decisions across borders. First the article
bottom price in a Hong Kong store makes it suggests international price setting decision
difficult to maintain a high quality image of the rules and processes. In addition, the topics of
make -- which is why Swatch attempts to key pricing considerations, location of pricing
maintain its premium pricing in its markets by responsibility in the multinational corporation,
limiting its distribution to a controllable number. price setting approaches,kdacanay
and transfer pricing
are addressed. 26
Marketing channel
An organized network of agencies
and institutions, which performs the
activities required to link producers
with user to accomplish the
marketing task
Global distribution
Distribution-
Nature & Importance of Marketing
Channels activities that make products available to
customers when and where they need them.
Channel choices affect other
decisions in the marketing mix The distribution system:
Pricing, Marketing determines a product's marketing
communications presence and the buyers' accessibility to
the product
A strong distribution system can be
a competitive advantage entails a long-term commitment, easier to
change other aspects of the marketing
Channel decisions involve long-term mix.
commitments to other firms
Changing Distributors
How Channel Members Add Value The distribution channel configuration for
Intermediaries require fewer entry into a foreign markets is rarely
contacts to move the product optimal once the product is established
to the final purchaser. on the market
Intermediaries help match
The traditional reason for termination of a
distributor is
product assortment demand The exporting firm finds that the
with supply. distributor is not doing a good enough
Intermediaries help bridge job in the market
major time, place, and Multiple Channels (Parallel Distribution)
possession gaps that separate Channel changes do not necessarily
products from those who involve termination of contracts
would use them. In some cases multiple channels emerge
or are created
kdacanay 27
How is systematic screening and assessment
of countries performed? How is the information
needed for this process obtained?
kdacanay 29
Three modes of entry
LICENSING
Host Country
Home country Blueprint : “how to do it”
Ho
st
Co
Host County
u nt
ry
kdacanay
30
Exporting
Degree of goods and services produced and based in
one country that are sold abroad
Direct exporting,
using market country agent or distributor
who takes ownership of the merchandise
when it enters their country
using own sales representatives which
entry mode represents only its products,not those of
other companies
indirect exporting
Practice by which a company sells its products t
intermediaries who then resell to buyers in a target
Three categories of entry modes available to market
companies
via agents (individuals or organizations that
represent one or more indirect exporter in a
1. Exporting and counter trade target market)
2. Contractual entry
export management companies( company
3. Investment entry that exports products on behalf of indirect
exporters)
export trading companies ( company that
provides services to indirect exporters in
addition to activities related directly to clients
exporting activities)
kdacanay
31
Why companies export
1. Expand sales Selecting and managing entry modes
2. Diversify sales
3. Gain experience
Imports
goods and services brought into a country that
are acquired from organizations located
abroad
Counter trade
Practice of selling goods or services that are paid for ,
counter purchase
in whole or in part,with other goods or is the sales of goods or service to a country
services by a company that promises to make a future
purchase of a specific product
Types:
Switch trading
barter Proactive in which one company sells to
another its obligation to make purchase
exchange of goods or services directly for in a given country
other goods and services without the use of
money
Buyback
Is the export of industrial equipment in
return for products produced by that
equipment
kdacanay
32
Contractual entry modes
The products of some companies simply
cannot be traded in open markets because they Selecting and managing entry modes
are intangible
Contract options:
Licensing
a practice by which one company owning
intangible property grants another firm the right
to use that property firm a specified period of
time
Disadvantages
Can lose control over the core competitive
advantage of the firm.
The licensee can become a new competitor to
the firm
kdacanay
33
Advantages:
1. franchiser can use franchising as a
low cost,low risk entry mode into new
Selecting and managing entry modes markets
2. allows rapid geographic expansion
3. Franchiser can benefit from the cultural
knowledge and know how of local
managers
4. The basic “product” sold is a well-
Franchising recognized brand name.
5. The franchisor provides various market
support services to the franchisee
Practice by which one company supplies 6. The local franchisee raises the
another with intangible property and other necessary capital and manages the
assistance over an extended period franchise
kdacanay
35
Selecting and managing entry modes Manufacturing alliances
Shared manufacturing examples
Strategic alliance Volvo and Renault share body parts and
components
relationship whereby two or more entities corporate Saab engines made by GM Europe
to achieve the strategic goals of each
Advantages
Typically a collaborative arrangement
between firms, sometimes competitors, Convenient
across borders Money saving
Based on sharing of vital Disadvantages
information, assets, and technology The organization must deal with two
between the partners principals in charge of production, harder
Have the effect of weakening the tie to communicate customer feedback
between potential ownership Can put constraints on future growth
advantages and company control
R&D Alliances
Provide favorable economics, speed of
Distribution Alliances access, and managerial resources and are
Also called “piggybacking”, “consortium intended to solve critical survival
marketing” questions for the firm
Examples Used to be seen as particularly risky, since
SAS, KLM, Austrian Air, and Swiss Air technological know-how is often the key
competitive advantage of a global firm
STAR Alliance (United Airlines, Lufthansa, Air
Canada, SAS, Thai Airways, and Varig The risk of dissipation has become less of
Brazilian Airlines) a concern, however, as technology
diffusion is growing ever faster anyway.
Chrysler and Mitsubishi Motors
kdacanay
36
Entry Modes and Local business Control
The local business can be controlled to varying degrees,
quite independent of the entry mode chosen. The
typical global firm maintains a sales subsidiary to
manage the local business. Examples:
m a r k e tin g c o n tr o l
m o d e o f e n tr y in d e p e n d e n t a g e n t jo in t w ith a llia n c e p a r tn e r o w n s a le s s u b s id ia r y
e x p o r tin g A b s o lu t v o d k a in th e U S T o s h ib a E M I in J a p a n V o lv o in th e U S
lic e n s in g D is n e y in J a p a n M ic r o s o ft in J a p a n N ik e in A s ia
s t r a t e g i c a l l i a n c e a u to s in C h in a E u r o D is n e y B la c k & D e c k e r in C h in a
FDI G o ld s ta r in th e U S M its u b is h i M o to r s in U S P & G in th e E U
kdacanay
37
Seiko’s Channels of Distribution
Europe Hong Kong Japan North America
Broken arrows denote the flow of Seiko watches through unauthorized channels of distribution.
Solid arrows denote the flow of Seiko watches through authorized channels of distribution.
kdacanay
38
Global retailing
Global retailing
All the activities involved in selling products and
services to final international consumers for
their personal consumption
Retailing and Lifestyles
The logistical and operational know-how of The retailing structure has to adapt to the
leading retailers is helping to increase the trend varying living conditions (the lifestyles) of
of retailing being globalize at a fast rate individual households
Retailers are the middlemen who buy from Global expansion of retailing is still difficult.
wholesalers and manufacturers and sell directly Most large retailers are still pre-dominantly
to the ultimate consumer. domestic.
Theretailing structure involves stores The Body Shop is one success story. The
(supermarkets, department stores, specialty factors that helped its global expansion include:
stores) as well as banks, restaurants, mail-order,
etc. 1. STANDARDIZED PRODUCTS, GLOBAL BRAND
2. GLOBAL SEGMENTS
Different economies have different retail 3. A STRONG STORE “CONCEPT”
structures (e.g. Gillette blades are sold through 4. CONCEPT MOBILITY
drugstores in the US, tobacco shops in Italy, 5. SIMILAR INFRASTRUCTURE (REPLICABILITY )
department stores in Germany, on the street in
Moscow, at movie counters in Thailand, & from
traveling vans in India)
kdacanay
39
various characteristics of retailing across local country
markets? How has retailing become an increasingly
globalized activity?
The variety within retailing across countries is greater in
general than that in wholesaling. The types of retailing
outlets and the number of retailers are notable variables.
The U.S. has many stores and many employees in retail,
while Europe has fewer stores and fewer employees per
store. Japan, as in wholesaling, has many stores, but few
people employed in each one. The great variations are
most closely associated with different lifestyles in the
countries being served. Since retailers deal with ultimate
consumers and different infrastructures, their services and Fram, Eugene H., and Ajami, Riad (1994), "Globalization of
structure have traditionally been much more localized. Markets and Shopping Stress: Cross-Country
Overall, as economic development progresses, some Comparisons",Business Horizons , vol. 37, no. 1, pp. 17-23.
aspects of lifestyle become more convergent, and the
potential for retailing to become more globalized is greater.
With differing infrastructures and channel alternatives, With the purported and often celebrated convergence of
some frequently used methods of retailing for a given consumers across countries and cultures, this article
product may not exist or be available to the marketer for examines whether significant differences exist between
competitive reasons. This will usually require new channel countries in how shoppers perceive the shopping process.
creation. Forms of retailing penetrating foreign markets Four different country settings were employed - The US,
include catalogs, convenience and/or self-serve stores, Singapore, Turkey, and Jordan. Specifically, shopping
discount stores, and franchises. Sometimes channel stress is a variable of focus. Three of the four countries
systems which have been replaced domestically are reflected significant shopping stress, with Singapore being
resurrected in foreign markets due to their particular the exception. Comparisons of other perceived shopping
effectiveness in those areas. An example is door-to-door aspects across countries are also discussed.
selling which, because of trends like increased crime and
dual career families, has largely been retired in the U.S. but 5. Howard, Kim (1994), "Global Retailing 2000",Business
which enjoys great success in Japan and other countries. Credit , February, pp. 22-24.
Retailing has been among the least globalized of the Retailing has been traditionally "local" because it required
marketing activities, but that appears to be changing rather knowledge of the needs and habits of specific groups of
rapidly. Leading companies in different types of retailing (i.e. consumers. However, with more trade barriers dropping,
, Wal-Mart in discount stores, Makro in wholesale clubs, retailing has been added to the list of businesses that must
Delhaize and Marks & Spencer in supermarkets, etc.) are sell globally to stay competitive. The author contends that
heading the expansion into foreign markets. Some have markets will be divided into three regional blocs: the
been notable successes while others have yet to take hold. Americas, Europe, and the Far East, with little integration
And while globalized retailing holds opportunities for between the three. Retail is also moving toward
manufacturers who want to have central coordination of specialization with store examples such as Home Depot
channel activities, it also poses the likelihood that these and Foot Locker. The report makes general conclusions
large worldwide retailers will become the dominant about the next decade of global retailing. Several strategies
members of the channel structure, therefore reducing the for success are given, including implementing micro-
power and influence of those same manufacturers. marketing, developing retail technology, and investing in a
partner.
kdacanay
40
global logistics?
Competition and Technology forces combine to drive
logistics toward globalization even though decentralizing
to maximize customer satisfaction in local markets has
been a prevailing strategy. Since transportation,
warehousing, materials management and inventory control
are areas in which large costs may be incurred, companies
are looking to streamline and consolidate to reduce those
costs. Technologies in equipment and communications Overland Transport is crucial once overseas
systems have enabled faster, more efficient logistics which goods leave air or sea ports and move inland.
can be controlled through more centralized operations. The inland road and rail systems in the
These innovations have allowed closer tracking of
shipments, shorter lead times on orders, tighter inventory European Union are predicted to be strained
control, and more centralized storage of goods until the with the greater movement of goods between
time they are needed. member countries, not to mention those foreign
goods being shipped from more centrally
Air Express systems are increasingly cost efficient, which, located distribution centers. While North
although air is the most expensive transport method, American rail systems pale in comparison to
makes it a more attractive alternative for shipping goods those in Europe when it comes to transporting
overseas. Air Express companies like FedEx, DHL, UPS and people, North American systems are much
others are becoming oriented to offering a wider range of
services to their customers. They offer pick-up, sorting, further ahead in freight management systems
customs clearance, one or two day delivery, and some of and technologies than European counterparts.
these systems even rent out space for storage of goods Improved rail systems will need roll-on-roll-off
which, when ordered, can then be shipped directly through capabilities and RoadRailers, and expensive
air express services from their facilities. truck/rail terminals will have to be constructed.
This will not occur overnight.
Ocean Carriers are better for shipment of bulky, non-
perishable, lower unit value goods. Global carrier alliances
pool their resources to share routes, vessels, port facilities, Warehousing is becoming more centralized in
provide more cargo destinations and faster, more response to the ability to deliver goods faster
economical customs clearance. Technology has driven the and cheaper than before. Now it is not as
creation of large-capacity lifting cranes, bigger and faster
ships, more current warehousing facilities, and
crucial to have distribution centers in the
computerized processing. Future technologies will be customers' back yards to provide prompt
used to upgrade port systems. service. Fewer facilities definitely increase
overall efficiency and decrease total logistics
costs.
41
General merchandising stores
Specialty stores
Retailer that offer a narrow product line and
wide assortment
Specialized markets
Markets that contain specialty stores
specializing in particular product Category specialist/category killer
Large general merchandise discount stores that
Department stores carry a narrow variety of merchandise and a
General retailers that offer a broad variety of wide assortment
goods wand wide assortments
Off price retailers
General merchandise discount Retailers who sell brand name products and
Retailer that sell high volumes of merchandise, designer merchandise below regular retail prices
offer limited service,and charge lower prices
Catalog showrooms
All purpose discount Showrooms displaying the products of catalog
General merchandise discount stores that offer retailer,offering high turnover,brand name goods
a wide variety of merchandise and limited at discount prices
depth
kdacanay
42
Food retailers
Retailers selling selling primarily food products
Conventional supermarkets
Self service food retailer with annual sales of
more than $2 million and with an area less
than 20,000 square feet Warehouse clubs/wholesale clubs
Stores that require members to pay an annual
fee operating in low overhead, warehouse type
Superstores
facilities, offering limited lines of brand name,
Larger retailers such as combination stores or and dealer brand groceries,apparel,appliances
hypermarkets that sell food, drugs, and other and other goods at a substantial discount
products
Convenience stores
Combination stores Small retailer located in residential area,open
Medium sized retail stores that combine food long hours, and caring limited lines of high
and drug retiling turnover necessities
Hypermarkets
Very larger retail stores that combine
supermarkets, discount and warehouse
retailing principles
kdacanay
43
kdacanay
44
Non store retailing Direct mail retailing
Retailing using catalogs and other direct mail,
Interactive home shopping/ electronic retailing/ instead of brick and mortar stores
internet retailing
Selling through the internet using websites to Catalog retailer
increase market penetration and market Retailers selling products through catalogs
diversification
Direct selling
Vending machines Selling that involves a salesperson,typically an
Interactive modes of retailing convenience independent distributor,contacting a consumer
goods at a convenient location-at his or her home or
workplace, demonstrating product use and
TV home shopping benefit,taking orders,and delivering the
Retailing through cable channels selling to merchandise
consumers in their homes, through infomercial
and through direct response advertising shown Network marketing/multilevel marketing
on broadcast and cable TV Using acquaintance networks through an
alternative distribution structure for the purpose
of distribution
kdacanay
45
2. Costco Wholesale Corporation
Costco Wholesale Corporation (NASDAQ: COST) is
a membership-only warehouse retail chain with
operations in nine countries. The company reported
The World's Top 10 Retailers (WMT, COST) worldwide revenue of $112.6 billion for fiscal year
By J. William Carpenter | December 24, 2015 2014, including more than $2.4 billion in revenue
Investopedia attributed to annual customer membership fees.
Year-on-year revenue growth amounted to about
7.1%. Costco operates 671 warehouse locations
around the world, including 474 locations in the U.S.
1. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. The company opened 30 new warehouse locations
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. (NYSE: WMT) is the world's in 2014 and plans to open another 34 locations in
largest brick-and-mortar retailer by a substantial 2015. As of December 2015, Costco has a market
margin. The company reported worldwide revenue of capitalization of $73.6 billion.
$485.7 billion for its 2015 fiscal year, a year-over-
year increase of about 2%. It operates 11,453 store
locations in 27 countries. About $228 billion of its
3. Kroger Company
2015 revenue, nearly 60% of the total, is attributed to Kroger Company (NYSE: KR) is the third-largest
operations in the United States. Most of the retailer in the world by revenue and the largest
company's store locations worldwide operate under grocery retailer in the U.S. It reported total sales of
the Walmart brand. However, the company also $108.5 billion for fiscal year 2014, an increase of
operates a number of other retail chains, including 10.2% over the prior year. Kroger operates 2,625
Sam's Club membership warehouse stores around supermarkets and multi-department stores, which
the world, ASDA stores in the United Kingdom, combine to make up 93% of company revenue. The
Bodega Aurrera stores in Mexico and Seiyu stores in company also operates 782 small-format
Japan. As of December 2015, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. convenience stores and 326 jewelry stores. It
has a market capitalization of about $194 billion. operates stores under more than 30 different brand
names, including Kroger, Ralphs, Fry's, Fred Meyer,
Food4Less, Littman Jewelers and QuikStop. Kroger
has a market capitalization of $40.4 billion.
kdacanay
46
4. Walgreens Boots Alliance, Inc. 6. Carrefour SA
Walgreens Boots Alliance, Inc. (NASDAQ: WBA) is France's Carrefour SA reported sales of €74.7
a holding company formed during the merger of billion excluding VAT, equivalent to approximately
drugstore giants Walgreen Company and Alliance $99.1 billion at average exchange rates for the
Boots at the close of 2014. For the fiscal year period. Revenue growth amounted to 2.9% on the
ending on Aug. 31, 2015, Walgreens Boots year. At the close of 2014, Carrefour had 10,860
Alliance reported sales of $103.4 billion. However, store locations in 33 countries. It operates stores in
this figure only includes sales arising from a variety of formats, including small convenience
Alliance Boots operations after the merger was stores, mid-size supermarkets and large-scale
completed on Dec. 23, 2014. Consequently, true superstores offering both food and general
full-year results for the combined company are merchandise. Carrefour opened or acquired a total
not yet available. The combined company of 1,128 new stores during the 2014 year, adding
operates more than 12,800 drugstore locations in more than 650,000 square meters of retail space.
11 countries. It has a market capitalization of The company has a market capitalization of about
$92.2 billion. $22 billion.
7. Amazon.com, Inc.
5. Tesco PLC Amazon.com, Inc. (NASDAQ: AMZN) is the world's
Tesco PLC is a global grocery retailer top online retailer. It reported sales of
headquartered in the U.K. For fiscal year 2015, the approximately $89 billion for the 2014 fiscal year,
company reported revenue of £62.3 billion an increase of about 19.5% over the previous
excluding value-added tax (VAT), equivalent to period. The company operates 14 country-specific
approximately $101.3 billion at average exchange retail websites and ships products to customers
rates for the reporting period. This represents a around the globe. About 62% of Amazon.com
2% decline in revenue compared to the prior year, sales take place outside the U.S. Both domestic
making Tesco one of only two companies on this and international sales figures have
list not experiencing sales growth. Tesco operates shown continued fast growth in recent years. Sales
6,814 stores in 11 countries. In addition to its of media products account for 25.3% of net sales,
grocery stores in the U.K. and Europe, Tesco has while electronics and other general merchandise
major operations in Thailand, Malaysia, India and account for about 68.4%. As of December 2015,
China. The company has a market capitalization Amazon.com has a market capitalization of $314
of $19.9 billion. billion, the highest market cap of any company on
this list by a substantial margin.
kdacanay 47
9. The Home Depot, Inc.
The Home Depot, Inc. (NYSE: HD) is the world's
biggest home-improvement retailer. It reported
sales of $83.2 billion for the 2014 fiscal year, an
increase of about 5.5% over the previous year.
The company operates 2,273 stores in total,
including 1,977 in the U.S. and its territories,
and the remainder in Canada and Mexico. The
Home Depot offers a variety of proprietary and
exclusive brands in its stores, including
8. Metro Group AG Hampton Bay home products, Glacier Bay
home fixtures, Vigoro lawn care products and
Germany's Metro Group is a European retail giant
Husky tools, among others. As of December
with far-flung operations in Russia, China, Japan, 2015, The Home Depot has a market
Thailand, Pakistan and India. The company reported capitalization of just over $170 billion.
sales of €63 billion excluding VAT, equivalent to
approximately $85.5 billion at average exchange
rates for the period. Sales were down about 4% from 10. Target Corporation
the prior year. Metro Group operates 2,200 stores Target Corporation (NYSE: TGT) reported
under several brands, including the warehouse retail revenue of $72.6 billion for fiscal year 2014, an
chain, Metro Cash & Carry, which is responsible for increase of 1.9% over the prior year's results.
more than 48% of the company's sales. Other Metro Target is a big-box retailer with 1,790 stores
Group retail operations include the supermarket across the U.S. In addition to its large-format
chain Real, the consumer electronics retailers Media stores, the company also operates eight
Markt and Saturn, and the department store chain CityTarget stores in an ongoing test phase.
Galeria Kaufhof. Metro Group has a market CityTarget locations are designed as small-
capitalization of $9.9 billion. format stores for densely populated urban
areas. Further expansion in this segment is
planned for fiscal year 2015. Target has a
market capitalization of $45.3 billion.
kdacanay
48
Top 25 retailers in Europe
European turnover 2015 in Billion €
Medium/media
The channel of communication that a
International promotion mix company uses to send to the target
consumer a message about its product or
The different modes of communication with
service
international consumers about products
and services, using international advertising,
international sales force management, Receiver
international sale promotion, public The target market that receives the
relations and publicity advertising message for a sender
kdacanay
50
kdacanay
51
International
advertising
A non personal communication by an identified
sponsors across international borders, using
broadcast,print and or interactive media Media format,features, and turn around the world
media advertising that is more or less uniform
across many countries, often, but not Advertising posters on kiosks and fences
necessarily in media vehicles with global reach Advertising on sides of private homes
Advertising on plastic shopping bags
Advertising on outdoor umbrellas
Media infrastructure
The omnipresent billboards
Provides different challenges in countries of
different levels of economic development. Advertisements in public areas appearing
on large posters or electronic panels
The dominance of global media
Media challenges Infomercials
long TV advertisements that are positioned
Media availability as programming
the extent to which media are available to TV shopping networks
communicate with target consumers Cable channels that sell products to
Media reliability a TV audience
The probability of the media to air advertising Product placement
messages on time, at an acceptable quality,and The strategy of placing brands in
with the agreed upon frequency. movies with the purpose of
Media restriction promoting the products to viewers
legal or self-imposed restrictions on the types and
numbers of advertisements aired or published
Media costs
kdacanay
52
The advertising infrastructure
Advertising agencies
The most common types of relationships between
international corporations and the agencies
providing advertising support are as follows:
IDENTICAL ADS – ads are identical, usually with localization only in terms of language voice-over
changes & simple copy translations (e.g. the Marlboro cowboy ads)
PROTOTYPE ADVERTISING – the same ads, but the voice-over may be changed to avoid language
& cultural problems, & the ad may be re-shot with local celebrities (e.g. Drakkar Noir)
PATTERN STANDARDIZATION – similar but less structured global approach, wherein the
positioning theme is unified & some alternative creative concepts are planned, but execution
differs between markets (e.g. Xerox)
kdacanay
55
56
57
Media Usage in % of Ad Expenditures
A d v e r tis in g E x p e n d itu r e s
C o u n tr y T o ta l ( $ b illio n ) $ p e r c a p ita
N o r th A m e r ic a
C anada 4 .8 157
U n ite d S ta te s 1 2 0 .2 445
L a tin A m e r ic a
A r g e n tin a 2 .7 76
B r a z il 5 .2 32
C h ile 0 .6 43
A s ia
C h in a 3 .4 0 .3
H ong K ong 2 .8 419
I n d ia 1 .2 1 .2
Ja p a n 3 3 .3 262
S in g a p o r e 0 .7 222
S o u th K o r e a 3 .3 70
A u s tr a lia 4 .6 246
N e w Z e a la n d 0 .7 185
E u ro p e
F ra n c e 9 .3 157
G e rm a n y 1 8 .9 230
I ta ly 6 .8 118
S p a in 4 .7 120
S weden 1 .9 211
S w itz e r la n d 2 .5 356
U n ite d K in g d o m 15 252
R u s s ia 0 .0 4 0 .0 2
kdacanay
58
Top Global Advertisers
kdacanay 59
TOP ADVERTISING AGENCIES
kdacanay
60
In-Store and Trade Promotion Sponsorships and Cross-Marketing
IN-STORE: promotional activities inside the store SPONSORSHIPS increase with the advent
of global media and global events (e.
TRADE: promotional activities targeted at
g. World Cup, Olympics).
channel intermediaries
Products associate themselves with
globally recognized sports figures (e.
• In-store promotions are more localized than g. Tiger Woods & Nike)
advertising
• In-store promotions need to be supported by
trade promotions CROSS-MARKETING of related products
• Different countries/cultures have different leverage a strong brand name into product
attitudes towards coupons line extensions (e.g. Burberry’s baby
products)
• Different countries have different distribution
infrastructures that limit transferability of
certain in-store/trade promotions
• Sales promotion needs to be localized because
of country-unique restrictions/regulations
kdacanay
61
Country Regulations of Promotions
kdacanay 62
Global Publicity
Global promotion
kdacanay
63
Global promotion
kdacanay
64
kdacanay
65
E-Commerce
Global promotion
PROS
Culture affects the “people skills” of the global (e.g. salesperson costs escalate in countries
marketer. where fringe benefits are high)
• GEOGRAPHIC & PHYSICAL DIMENSIONS
Good salesmanship varies across countries.
(e.g. climate, transportation conditions,
Personal selling is usually the least global of all population density)
marketing activities.
Presentations made during a sales visit usually consist of five distinct stages:
In foreign markets, these stages are still valid but the salesperson needs to
adapt these stages to the local culture.
kdacanay
67