Professional Documents
Culture Documents
5fu Vs Bev Glaucoma
5fu Vs Bev Glaucoma
Abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the efficacy and complications of bevacizumab versus 5-fluorouracil (5-FU)-augmented
bleb needling of failed filtration blebs following trabeculectomy.
Methods: Twenty-seven eyes of 27 patients with bleb failure were included. Patients were randomly assigned to
receive either 5-FU or bevacizumab. Needling was performed in the operating room under sterile conditions.
After the needling procedure, a viscoelastic material was injected subconjunctivally around the bleb area to
avoid the entrance of 5-FU or bevacizumab into the anterior chamber. Bevacizumab (1.25 mg/0.1 mL) was
injected into 12 eyes and 5-FU injected into 15 eyes subconjunctivally. All of the patients were controlled weekly
until a filtration bleb was maintained. Intraocular pressure (IOP), bleb appearance, and complications were
noted in each group. Success was defined as absolute if the IOP 21 mmHg or less without any medication or
surgical intervention at last visit, and qualified if the IOP 21 mmHg or less with topical antiglaucomatous
medications. The patients were followed from 11 to 26 (median, 17) months.
Results: The IOP decreased, from 31.2 – 3.2 mmHg to 16.1 – 2.1 mmHg, in the bevacizumab group on the first
postoperative day. The IOP was within normal limits in 1 (8.3%) patient without medication and controlled with
topical antiglaucomatous drops in 2 (16.7%) patients. The total success rate was 25% at the time of the last visit.
Success was not achieved in 9 (75%) eyes. The IOP was 32.0 – 4.6 mmHg preoperatively and 12.2 – 2.6 mmHg on
the first postoperative day in the 5-FU injected patients. The total success rate was 80%; 8 (53.3%) eyes showed
absolute success, whereas 4 (26.7%) eyes showed a qualified success. A statistically significant difference be-
tween groups in terms of success rates was observed (P = 0.04).
Conclusions: Subconjunctival 5-FU application is a more effective therapy than bevacizumab application for
needling procedures in failed trabeculectomy blebs.
Glaucoma Division, Ulucanlar Training and Research Eye Hospital, Ankara, Turkey.
This study was carried out at the Ulucanlar Training and Research Eye Hospital.
542
NEEDLING AND BEVACIZUMAB OR 5-FLUOROURACIL APPLICATION FOR FAILED BLEBS 543
nonselective cell death and apoptosis.10 Therefore, the use ration of the overlying conjunctiva and subconjunctival blood
of these agents is associated with sight-threatening compli- vessels. Then, the needle was moved into the bleb cavity,
cations such as hypotony, blebitis, endophthalmitis, and underneath the scleral flap, until the fistula between the
wound leakage. anterior chamber and subconjunctival space was reformed. A
Bevacizumab is a full-length humanized monoclonal anti- viscoelastic material was injected subconjunctivally around
body directed against all isoforms of vascular endotelial the bleb area to avoid the entrance of 5-FU or bevacizumab
growth factor-A. It is extensively used for metastatic colo- into the anterior chamber before exiting the wound. The
rectal cancer. Wound dehiscence at the colorectal anastomosis entry site was closed with a single 8-0 Vicryl suture when
has been reported several months to years after original sur- necessary. At the end of the procedure, a single sub-
gery in patients with metastatic colorectal cancer treated with conjunctival injection of 5-FU at a dose of 5 mg/0.2 mL or
intravenous bevacizumab.11,12 Based on this situation, it has bevacizumab at a dose of 1.25 mg/0.1 mL were administered
been proposed that bevacizumab may inhibit the wound- outside the viscoelastic material. Patients were examined
healing process in a long-term period. Recent studies showed daily for the first week, and weekly for the first month or as
that subconjunctival injections of bevacizamub could reduce necessary, depending on the IOP and the appearance of the
scarring in animal models of glaucoma.13 filtration bleb. Topical prednisolone acetate (1%) was ad-
The key players in generating scar tissue after trabecu- ministered every 2 h while awake for the first month. The
lectomy are the fibroblasts in the Tenon’s capsule. It has been dose was then tapered according to the clinical signs of
demonstrated that bevacizumab affects both vascular and fi- conjunctival inflammation and bleb function. Topical oflox-
broblast proliferation directly in glaucoma filtration surgery. In acin (2%) eye drops were administered 5 times per day for 1
addition, it modulates the inflow of proinflammatory cyto- week. The patients were followed for 11–26 (median, 17)
kines into the bleb from surrounding vessels.14 For this reason, months. In control examinations, the IOP, bleb appearance,
anti-VEGF agents may also exhibit beneficial effects during and complications were noted. Absolute success was defined
glaucoma surgery. The use of subconjunctival injections of as an IOP 21 mmHg or less without antiglaucomatous
bevacizumab to salvage failing blebs has been described in a medications measured at the last visit. A qualified success
small number of case reports.15,16 To our knowledge, no re- was defined as an IOP 21 mmHg or less with topical anti-
ported study has compared 5-FU and bevacizumab for the glaucomatous medications.
needle revision of failed filtration blebs. The purpose of this The study followed the tenets of the declaration of Hel-
study was to compare the efficacy and complications of needle sinki. Written informed consent was provided by each pa-
revision and subconjunctival 5-FU-versus-bevacizumab ap- tient after an explanation of the nature and possible
plication in bleb failure after trabeculectomy. consequences of the study. The protocol was approved by
the Institutional Ethics Committee.
Methods Statistical analyses were performed using the SPSS soft-
ware (ver. 15.0). The normality of data was evaluated using a
This is a prospective and comparative case series of pa- Shapiro–Wilk test. Descriptive statistics were used to evalu-
tients who underwent needle revision augmented with ate the demographic characteristics of the patients. Differ-
bevacizumab or 5-FU for failed trabeculectomy blebs be- ences in success rates among the groups were compared
tween November 2008 and February 2011. Twenty-seven using the chi-squared test. A statistically significant differ-
eyes of 27 patients with bleb failure were included. All of the ence was defined as one with a P value < 0.05.
eyes had failing filtering procedures with or without the use
of antifibrotic agents, and an intraocular pressure (IOP) Results
> 21 mmHg. Signs of a failed bleb included an unacceptably
high IOP, an open corneoscleral window at gonioscopy, Patients with failed filtration blebs were included (n = 27).
vascularization, thickening and flattening of the bleb, and Table 1 shows the demographic and clinical characteristics of
loss of the conjunctival microcysts. Patients were randomly the patients. No statistically significant difference between
assigned to receive either 5-FU or bevacizumab. demographic characteristics was observed (P > 0.05). No di-
Demographic properties of the patients, previous surger- agnostic difference between the groups was evident. The
ies, the type of glaucoma, antimetabolite use in last trabe- baseline IOP was between 27 and 42 (mean, 32.0 – 4.6) mmHg
culectomy, the time interval between the last trabeculectomy, in the 5-FU group and 26–35 (mean, 31.2 – 3.2) mmHg in the
and the needling procedure were noted. Visual acuity test- bevacizumab group. No statistical difference was observed
ing, IOP measurements, anterior segment, and fundus ex- between the groups (P = 0.638). Needling and subconjunctival
aminations were then performed. 5-FU or bevacizumab were applied between 4 and 12 (me-
A single surgeon (T.S.) performed all of the bleb revisions dian, 5) weeks following trabeculectomy.
using a standard protocol. The procedure was performed in The IOP was found to be 12–19 (mean, 15.8 – 1.9) mmHg
the operating room under sterile conditions. A sterile cotton following the procedure in the bevacizumab group. The mean
swab soaked with proparacaine was placed over the super- IOP after the procedure was 12.4 – 2.3 (range, 8–18) mmHg in
otemporal quadrant for approximately 5 min. Brimonidine the 5-FU group. Through an analysis with an independent
eye drops were used preoperatively to prevent bleeding sample t-test, the difference between the preprocedure and
from the conjunctival vessel during the procedure. With the after-procedure IOP was statistically significant in both
eye infraducted, the subconjunctival space was entered at groups (P = 0.001). There was also a significant difference in
least 5 mm from the site of the filtration bleb using a 29- terms of after-procedure IOP between groups (P = 0.00). In 8
gauge needle. Multiple passes and back and forth sweeping (53.3%) eyes, the IOP remained below 21 mmHg with no
movements were performed to disrupt any episcleral fibro- medication (complete success), while in 4 (26.7%) eyes, it was
sis. Careful attention was given to avoid inadvertent perfo- controlled with topical antiglaucomatous agents (qualified
544 SIMSEK, CANKAYA, AND ELGIN
lower concentration may reduce the occurrence of hypotony The wound-healing response is a complex process; con-
and other complications. sequently, more than 1 agent may be needed to inhibit scar
It has been shown that hydrocortisone-21-phosphate and formation in the bleb area. Recently, How et al. found that
AGM-1470 are angiogenesis inhibitors that display signifi- bevacizumab in combination with 5-FU offers greater anti-
cant effects on Tenon’s fibroblast proliferation and migration. fibrotic effect over monotherapy in a rabbit model of glau-
Researchers have thus suggested that angiogenesis inhibitors coma filtration surgery.26 They concluded that bevacizumab
may be used for wound modulation in glaucoma filtration and 5-FU have synergistic effect in reducing the fibroblastic
surgery.22,23 The use of subconjunctival bevacizumab for activity of the wound-healing process. Combined treatment
bleb failure following trabeculectomy has been reported.16 with 5-FU and bevacizumab may also be effective in the
The wound-healing process is carried out with both fibro- treatment of failed filtration blebs. This treatment modality
blastic activity and angiogenesis.22 For this reason, anti-VEGF might be advantageous to lessen corneal complications of 5-
agents would be expected to decrease the new vascular growth FU. Kahook reported that the combination of intravitreal
and inhibit the fibroblastic activity. However, the antifibrotic ranibizumab and MMC at the time of trabeculectomy re-
effects of bevacizumab have not been experimentally demon- sulted in more diffuse blebs with less vascularity compared
strated. Yoeruek et al. found that bevacizumab did not display to the use of MMC alone.27
toxic effects on human corneal fibroblast cells even at high Several complications such as wound leak, choroidal effu-
concentrations.24 Unpublished data have shown that the in- sion, a shallow anterior chamber, bleb-related endophthalmitis,
hibition of the neovascular cascade by anti-VEGF agents de- hypotony maculopathy, suprachoroidal hemorrhage, corneal
creases fibroblast proliferation through cytokines, including epitheliopathy, and subconjunctival hemorrhage have been
fibroblast growth factors. reported to be associated with needle revision and sub-
We found that 5-FU was more effective than bevacizumab conjunctival 5-FU application.2,6,28,29 In this study, no signifi-
for this procedure. The total success rates were 25% in the cant difference was observed between the groups in terms of
bevacizumab group and 80% in the 5-FU group. The differ- complications. However, the anterior chamber reaction was
ences in the success rates may be due to the different anti- thought to be due to the injection of bevacizumab, and the
fibroblastic activity of the adjuvant agents. Grewal et al., in a corneal punctuate epitheliopathy due to 5-FU injection. The
pilot study with a small number of subjects and 6 months intravitreal injection of bevacizumab may cause IOP spikes,
follow-up, suggested that subconjunctival bevacizumab is a particularly in suspected or confirmed cases of glaucoma.
potential adjunctive treatment for reducing the incidence of Kahook and coworkers30 found that bevacizumab displayed a
bleb failure after trabeculectomy.15 The limited sample size, toxic effect on trabecular meshwork cells. Other reports have
short-term follow-up, and the lack of a control group were stated that bevacizumab may physically accumulate in the
the limitations of this study. These prevent us from making trabecular meshwork and block aqueous outflow, leading to an
firm conclusions regarding the efficacy of bevacizumab in- increased IOP. It is not yet known whether IOP elevation oc-
jections in reducing bleb failure. curs after the subconjunctival injection of bevacizumab.
Memarzadeh et al. studied the usefulness of the sub- In conclusion, needle revision and subconjunctival 5-FU
conjunctival injection of bevacizumab on bleb morphology in application was a more effective procedure than needling
rabbits.13 They found that bevacizumab created a more favor- and subconjunctival bevacizumab injection for bleb failure
able bleb morphology compared with 5-FU and control groups. following trabeculectomy. Further controlled clinical studies
However, unlike our study, bevacizumab was injected after are required to determine the time and route of administra-
trabeculectomy in this study. Therefore, the early injection of tion of bevacizumab in the glaucoma surgical procedure.
bevacizumab after trabeculectomy would be more effective
for bleb survival than postneedling injection. Kahook et al. Author Disclosure Statement
reported a case in which a significant decrease in IOP was ob-
served after needling and subconjunctival injection of bev- None of the authors have a conflict of interest with the
acizumab. In this case, the IOP decrease was transient.16 For this submission.
reason, it may be that the IOP reduction resulted from bev-
acizumab injection or solely from the effects of the needling References
procedure. It is obviously difficult to answer this question with
1 case report; further controlled clinical and experimental 1. Skuta, G.L., and Parrish, 2 R.K. Wound healing in glaucoma
studies are required to understand the effectiveness of anti- filtering surgery. Major review. Surv. Ophthalmol. 32:149–
147, 1987.
VEGF agents in glaucoma surgery and needling procedures. In
2. Azuara-Blanco, A., and Katz, L.J. Dysfunctional filtering
the present study, bevacizumab injection was performed at
blebs. Surv. Ophthalmol. 43:93–126, 1998.
different stages of the wound-healing response in each patient.
3. Scott, I.U., Greenfield, D.S., Schiffman, J., et al. Outcomes of
This may be a reason of the failure of needling and bev- primary trabeculectomy with the use of adjunctive mitomi-
acizumab injection. If needling and bevacizumab injection were cin C. Arch. Ophthalmol. 116:286–291, 1998.
performed on the new vessel formation stage of the wound- 4. Durak, I., Özbek, Z., Yaman, A., et al. The role of needle
healing response, the success rate would be expected to in- revision and 5-fluorouracil application over the filtration site
crease. In addition, repeat injection of the bevacizumab would in the management of bleb failure after trabeculectomy: a
be more effective than a single injection in reducing angiogen- prospective study. Doc. Ophthalmol. 106:189–193, 2003.
esis and fibrosis. Li et al. demonstrated that 1 injection of a high 5. The Fluorouracil Filtering Surgery Study Group. Five-year
dosage of bevacizumab (25 mg/mL) during the surgery re- follow up of the Fluorouracil Filtering Surgery Study. Am. J.
duced the angiogenesis and fibrosis in a rabbit model of glau- Ophthalmol. 121:349–366, 1996.
coma filtration surgery. They stated that bevacizumab was only 6. Palmberg, P. The failing filtering bleb. Ophthalmol. Clin.
effective in increasing the bleb area and did not affect the IOP.25 North Am. 13:517–529, 2000.
546 SIMSEK, CANKAYA, AND ELGIN
7. Greenfield, D.S., Miller, M.P., Suner, I.J., et al. Needle ele- 21. Broadway, D.C., Bloom, P.A., Bunce, C., et al. Needle revi-
vation of the scleral flap for failing filtration blebs after sion of failing and failed trabeculectomy blebs with ad-
trabeculectomy with Mitomycin C. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 122: junctive 5-fluorouracil: survival analysis. Ophthalmology
195–200, 1996. 111:665–673, 2004.
8. Shin, D.H., Juzych, M.S., Khatana, A.K., et al. Needling re- 22. Wong, J., Wang, N., Miller, J.W., et al. Modulation of human
vision of failed filtering blebs with adjunctive 5-fluorouracil. fibroblast activity by selected angiogenesis inhibitors. Exp
Ophthalmic Surg. 24:242–248, 1993. Eye Res 58:439–451, 1994.
9. Mardelli, P.G., Lederer, C.M., Murray, P.L., et al. Slit-lamp 23. Nissen, N.N., Polverini, P.J., Koch, A.E., et al. Vascular en-
needle revision of failed filtering blebs using mitomycin C. dothelial growth factor mediates angiogenic activity during
Ophthalmology 103:1946–1955, 1996. the proliferative phase of wound healing. Am. J. Pathol.
10. Simsek, T., Firat, P., Cxitirik, M., Özdamar, Y., Elgin, U. Short 152:1445–1452, 1998.
term effects of subconjunctival injections of 5-fluorouracil on 24. Yoeruek, E., Spitzer, M.S., Tatar, O., et al. Safety profile of
conjunctival epithelium. Cornea 29:727–731, 2010. bevacizumab on cultured human corneal cells. Cornea
11. August, D.A., Serrano, D., and Poplin, E. ‘‘Spontaneous,’’ 26:977–982, 2007.
delayed colon and rectal anastomotic complications associ- 25. Li, Z., Van Bergen, T., Van de Veire, S., et al. Inhibition of
ated with bevacizumab therapy. J. Surg. Oncol. 97:180–185, vascular endothelial growth factor reduces scar formation
2008. after glaucoma filtration surgery. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci.
12. Scappaticci, F.A., Fehrenbacher, L., Cartwright, T., et al. 50:5217–525, 2009.
Surgical wound healing complications in metastatic colo- 26. How, A., Chua, J.L.L., Charlton, A., et al. Combined treatment
rectal cancer patients treated with bevacizumab. J. Surg. with bevacizumab and 5-fluorouracil attenuates the postop-
Oncol. 91:173–180, 2005. erative scarring response after experimental glaucoma filtra-
13. Memarzadeh, F., Varma, R., Lin, L.T., et al. Postoperative tion surgery. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 51:928–932, 2010.
use of bevacizumab as an antifibrotic agent in glaucoma 27. Kahook, M.Y. Bleb morphology and vascularity after
filtration surgery in the rabbit. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. trabeculectomy with intravitreal ranibizumab: a pilot study.
50:3233–3237, 2009. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 150:399–403, 2010.
14. Horsley, M.B., and Kahook, M.Y. Anti-VEGF therapy for 28. Howe, L.J., and Bloom, P. Delayed suprachoroidal
glaucoma. Curr. Opin. Ophthalmol. 21:112–117, 2010. haemorrhage following trabeculectomy bleb needling. Br. J.
15. Grewal, D.S., Jain, R., Kumar, K., et al. Evaluation of sub- Ophthalmol. 83:757, 1999.
conjunctival bevacizumab as an adjunct to trabeculectomy a 29. Potash, S.D., Ritch, R., and Liebmann, J. Ocular hypotony
pilot study. Ophthalmology 115:2141–2145, 2008. and choroidal effusion following bleb needling. Ophthalmic
16. Kahook, M.Y., Schuman, J.S., and Noecker, R.J. Needle bleb Surg. 24:279–280, 1993.
revision of encapsulated filtering bleb with bevacizumab. 30. Good, T.J., Kimura, A.E., Mandava, N., and Kahook, M.Y.
Ophthalmic Surg. Lasers Imaging 37:148–150, 2006. Sustained elevation of intraocular pressure after intravitreal
17. Siriwardena, D., Edwards, B., Wormald, R.P., et al. National injections of anti-VEGF agents. Br. J. Ophthalmol. 95:1111–
survey of antimetabolite use in glaucoma surgery in the 1114, 2011.
United Kingdom. Br. J. Ophthalmol. 88:873–876, 2004.
18. Mastropasqua, L., Corpineto, P., Ciancaglini, M., et al. De- Received: February 16, 2012
layed post-operative use of 5-fluorouracil as an adjunct in Accepted: May 22, 2012
medically uncontrolled open angle glaucoma. Eye 12:701–706,
1998. Address correspondence to:
19. Hefetz, L., Keren, T., and Naveh, N. Early and late post- Dr. Tulay Simsek
operative application of 5-fluorouracil following trabecu- SB Ulucanlar Göz Eğitim Aras
xtırma Hastanesi
lectomy in refractory glaucoma. Ophthalmic Surg. 25:715– Ulucanlar Caddesi
719, 1994. No: 59 Altındağ
20. Pasternack, J.J., Wand, M., and Shields, M.B. Needle revision Ankara
of failed filtering blebs using 5-Fluorouracil and a combined Turkey
ab-externo and ab-interno approach. J. Glaucoma 14:47–51,
2005. E-mail: tulaysimsek@hotmail.com