Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MASTER THESIS
Ext. Tutors:
Jorge Cardona (Zamorano)
Academic Years
2016-2017
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
DEDICATION
2
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
ABSTRACT
The cascara or dry coffee cherries tea is one trendy coffee derivative gaining
more and more attention from the hot beverage drinkers. Origin countries are
exporting a very small (but increasing) amount of cascara every year to small
roasters across the world.
Very few studies have been made regarding the cascara’s chemical, nutritional,
and sensorial components in order to compare them with other tea infusion
ingredients or coffee itself. It is known to have much less caffeine than other
tea beverages, a natural source of antioxidants, more tannins which can be
beneficial for health (Fonseca-Garcia et.al, 2014), but probably not quantified
and measured into the correct amounts for human consumption.
The starting point of this work was to gather samples of cascara, not only from
my country of origin, Honduras, but also from other Central American regions.
Since there are proven and significant differences amongst the coffee beans
grown in the signature areas of these countries, I would only expect there to be
a difference as well in the dried cherries.
The present investigation analyzed the dried cascara brew in the certified lab at
the Escuela Agricola Panamericana Zamorano in Honduras. The sensory
analysis lab was used to test the acceptance, discrimination capability and
preference of the two brews. Color and sugar contents were measured by
equipment to correlate mostly with the data taken by the panelists.
3
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I would like to thank sincerely those who contributed and supported me in this
project, especially my co-workers and friends at Molinos de Honduras who
supported meanwhile I was in Italy and helped me source all the material I
needed to work freely and uninterrupted.
4
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
CONTENTS
1. Chapter 1: What is Cascara
1.1. Main goals 6
1.2. General Introduction 6
1.3. Consumption methods 7
5
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
General Introduction
Coffee pulp, a long time thought of as a waste product, an irrelevant and
unused sub product of many coffee farmers around the world. Most often
thought of only as an additional weight or a conversion factor used to calculate
the real earnings or profits from a farm.
The evolution of coffee pulp as a useful sub product was first stated as an
agronomical practice and fertilizing aid for producers. Many studies have
stated the benefits of using the pulp as compost, fertilizer for the farms, or as
filling component for animal nutrition (Murthy PS, Madhava Naidu M, 2012).
Coffee pulp was shown to reduce by 30% the costs of production of a dairy
farm by replacing up to 20% commercial concentrates with dried pulp.
Meaning that at the end of a period a pig would have consumed 50 kg less of
corn by this substitution (Rajkumar & Graziosi, 2005)
It is not new that cascara has been used for tea infusions in past years; it is a
very common drink in Yemen called Qishr, where most of the people think the
Cascara tea was born.
Looking at Cascara tea nowadays, many people have tried to track down where
does it come from, what are the health benefits, how much caffeine does it
contain, and how to brew it correctly. Very little scientific information is found
about cascara, since it is just recently being commercialized as a food based
product. It has found its way up a very niche market in specialty coffee shops
and roasters around the world. These coffee connoisseurs are the ones writing
6
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
blogs on their web pages and studying on their own the endless possibilities of
transforming these dried cherries into a consumable product.
Consumption Methods
French Press: 20 grams of cascara for every 500 ml of water at 90°C. Pour over
and let it steep for 3-4 minutes before plunging.
Chemex: 20 grams of cascara for every 500 ml of water at 90°C. The only
difference is we don’t use a filter for cascara since it’s not a coffee like brew,
but more an extraction. The pour over of water is done over the cascara sitting
at the bottom of the Chemex and let is steep for 4 minutes before serving.
Having mentioned the coffee farm structure above, with an estimated 270,000
Ha of planted coffee area (IHCAFE, 2009) we will focus on the technified and
semi technified farms for the coffee pulp recollection of our study. Having in
mind that in order to meet a certain level of optimal cherry quality, ideal for tea
7
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
infusion we should look for the best and well managed farms, from the trees
that were properly fertilized and managed by the producer to develop and
harvest the best quality coffee bean.
Washed process
The washed process is the most common way of processing coffee in our
countries. After the pickers have gone through the farm and selecting only the
ripe and red color cherries, they are transported to a wet milling facility.
A wet mill has several stations or steps that the cherry pulp has to go through
before it is separated from the bean. Ideally we want to select and sort the best
cherries that would give the best coffee beans, and therefore a good quality
pulp. The cherries are passed through a machine called depulper that is
responsible for separating the bean from the cherry. After this point the bean is
covered in mucilage, which is later dispatched to fermentation tanks where this
mucilage is removed from the bean, leaving what we call “wet parchment
coffee.
Focusing on the pulp that was separated by the depulper, this is collected and
dryed carefully in African solar beds.
Natural Process
Natural processed coffee pulp is quite different from washed process mainly
because the cherry skips the wet mill process.
After the coffee is harvested and only the red cherries are selected, they are
sundried in patios or African beds. The whole cherry undergoes an immediate
drying process along with the bean.
This process allows the bean to absorb most of the sugars enclosed in the
cherry as it dries up. This drying period is over until the bean reaches 11 – 12
% humidity and the cherry is totally dehydrated.
The following step is the separation of the bean from its husk. The cherry now
goes through a hulling machine responsible for removing the cherry from the
bean, without causing any damage to it. We now have a totally different
looking coffee pulp from our washed processed one, but fulfilling the same
function.
8
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
Our coffee pulp was collected from a cooperative in the western side of
Honduras called COCAFELOL (Cooperativa Cafetalera Ecologica La Labor).
The quality of the coffee was gourmet type, mainly from caturra, catuai, and
parainema plants with harvest periods from December to April.
The designated farms for the selection of the pulp were at an altitude of 1,150
to 1750 masl with an average annual temperature of 16 – 21°C. Soil
descriptions are Sandy loam soils, medium in organic matter, with medium
filtration capacity.
There is not a specific and standardized way of brewing these infusions. There
are many methods that can be used to achieve this final product, from different
kind of brewing machines, different timings and proportions used, the addition
of other ingredients like cinnamon or sugar, or even coffee itself.
Out of all the possibilities that can be used it seemed that French press was the
most common, therefore for the purposes of this experiment we did all tests
using a French press method, using 20 grams of cascara for every 500 ml of
water at 90°C for both processes.
9
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
Sensory Panels
The sensory analysis was done in the Sensory Analysis laboratory of the
Escuela Agricola Panamericana Zamorano,located in Valle de Yeguare,
Honduras. Panels were mostly students from the University and most of them
had already taken the illy-coffee course from the recent partnership agreement
done by these two institutions.
For the acceptance sensory analysis the panelist were given two separate sheets
of paper for the two different cascara brews. The tests involved a Hedonic scale
of 9 points to measure the acceptance of different attributes of the product,
using “1” as extremely Dislike and “9” as extremely like (Lawless & Heymann
1999). The attributes to measure were Taste, color, sweetness and general
acceptance.
As seen in the table below, the results from 30 panelists were evaluated for the
washed processed cascara brew.
Also 30 panelists were evaluated for the natural processed cascara brew and
their results are shown in table 2.
10
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
Natural process cascara brew found the same balance within their attributes in
the infusion. The ranges between the scores of each attribute were evaluated in
the same range, within the same punctuation. This means that the panelists
found a smooth and consistent brew throughout their evaluation.
Interesting to notice that if it is true that the components and attributes within
the same processes don’t differ significantly from each other. When compared
one process with the other we find that the panelists scored significantly lower
the natural processed cascara from the washed processed one. With this it only
states that attributes like color, taste and sweetness were evaluated in a slightly
lower range than the washed ones.
As shown in table 3, panels could clearly identify the different sample and
were easily convinced that sample #212 was different from the rest. The cups
used for this experiment were completely black and the laboratory lights were
dimmed so the color differences were not obvious to the panel. Forcing and
ensuring the panelists were only using their taste sense.
11
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
This correlates with the previous acceptance sensory analysis were panels
(some of them not the same) evaluated different one sample from the other.
Giving us certainty there is sensorial differences between one another. We
should keep in mind this does not in any way proves one brew method is better
than the other or more liked. This is just merely a differentiation test in which
we analyze the panelist’s ability to differentiate one sample amongst the rest.
Once the individual acceptance analysis was done for each of the cascara
processes and the discrimination analysis proved that there are detectable
differences between samples (as we expected), a preference analysis was
carried out. This analysis compared directly one brew with the other and
panelists had to choose the sample they thought was best for them.
PL was the washed processed cascara (Pulpa Lavada) and PN was the natural
processed cascara (Pulpa Natural).
Table 4 shows us that panelists choose washed processed cascara (PL) over and
better than natural processed cascara (PN). This time they had the samples
served in transparent cups, where they could observe and analyze color, taste,
and sweetness of each brew.
Given the acceptance analysis scores of each one of the samples we can link
that panelists maintained their opinion to think that the washed processed
cascara has better liked attributes than natural cascara, hence their preference
shown in this analysis.
Physical analysis
Sugar content: While making the brews for each round of panelists and
making sure to follow and maintain a consistent brewing protocol, the sugar
contents of each brew process were measured.
12
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
Alan Adler, the aeropress inventor and frequent lecturer at Stanford University
is a keen user of the same refractometer used in this study. In an online post for
coffee geek, he writes about how he has measured brix content for coffees and
came to conclude that a standard measurement is 1.5 Brix. This in correlation
with SCAA recommended 1.25 Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) for ordinary
coffees (SCAA cupping protocols).
Café imports on their web page study and publish a blog on a wet mill in Costa
Rica called Las Lajas. The family owned mill and farm specializes in honey-
processed coffee that is sold to Café Imports later on. As their way to ensure a
good quality bean, Francisca (farm owner) measured the Brix content on the
coffee cherry to determine the optimal time to harvest the cherry. It is said that
cherrys in their optimal time for picking can measure up to 21-22% Brix
content (Café Imports, Las Lajas – Cascara perla negra). This is clearly
concentrated sugars measured in that will fade as the bean absorbs part of this
moisture and sugar content when dried.
Color: Color was measured using L, a, b color scale. Hunter Lab describes
these components as L for Luminosity ranging from 100(white) to 0 (black).
The “a” component is responsible for red (a+) and green (a-) color, they don’t
have numerical limits but positive and negative signs. Same for “b” component
where yellow (+b) and blue (-b) have positive and negative signs. See figure 1
for matrix reference.
13
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
Several data was taken measuring the color of the brews, each treatment was
separated into independent brews and an average data of all brews and data
was consigned in the table above.
If we were to space both processed cascara brew into the color matrix in the
figure above it would be in the top right quadrant. This means the variation of
color ranges in similar intensity for red and yellow colors within white
spectrum luminosity.
natural
washed
Hue describes the quality by which we distinguish a color from the other. HLS
is very similar to Munsell's color wheel. Although Munsell uses a different
method for indicating hue, both arrange the colors in a circular pattern and be
located using the L, a, b data provided by any color meter.
Figure 2. HSL color meter wheel. Figure 3. Munsell color meter wheel
washed
natural
14
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
The results in table 5 showed a clear difference between Hue of both processes.
Natural cascara when brewed showed an average Hue of 54°, tilting a little
more towards the yellowish color. Washed cascara brew stayed a little lower in
with a 31° Hue towards the red color.
Natural processed cascara (left) appears lighter colored than washed (right)
mainly because of the inner husk of the bean. When natural coffee is dried and
reaches the correct humidity level it is hulled as it is. The result after the bean
separation is a mixture of the original coffee pulp or outer husk, combined with
the inner husk, also known as parchment. It is this dry parchment that changes
the tone of the original dry cherry into a lighter color.
15
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
The different color of the pulp is clearly carried over to the brew. Natural
processed cascara brew gave a lighter tone than washed brew.
16
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
A full chemical analysis and caffeine content on every treatment over time.
This could’ve been done in this project but because of time and high costs of
these procedures it wasn’t possible.
17
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
Bibliography
2. "Cascara and Caffeine." Square Mile Coffee. N.p., 30 Aug. 2013. Web.
<http://www.squaremileblog.com/2013/08/30/cascara-and-caffeine/>.
18
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”
Title of the Paragraph (ex. Abstract)
<http://www.ihcafe.hn/index.php?option=com_phocadownload&view=categor
y&id=5&Itemid=147>.
14. "Cafe Imports - Beanology." Las Lajas - Cascara Perla Negra. Cafe
Imports, n.d. Web. 27 Sept. 2016.
<http://www.cafeimports.com/beanology/view/las-lajas-cascara-perla-negra-
grainpro-2203>.
17. "Defining Color." Systems for Precise Color Validation (2007): n. Munsell
Color.
<https://www.pantone.com/downloads/articles/pdfs/L10_315_Defining_Color_
Munsell_en.pdf>.
19
Carlos Umanzor
Master Thesis “Sensory characterization and analysis of tea infusions from dry coffee cherry pulp “Cascara” from
washed and natural processed coffee”