26 MWp PV Power Plant in Kom Ombo

DOCUMENT COMMENT SHEET

TSK ELECTRONICA Y ELECTRICIDAD S.A

Juan Vigil
Parque Científico y Tecnológico de Gijon
calle Ada Byron 220
33203 Gijon,(Asturias), Spain

Dear Sir,

Enclosed please find our comments to the documents enumerated on the attached list. Please
implement and elaborate the commented items and re-submit the report accordingly.

Best Regards,

New and Renewable Energy Authority

Project: 26 MWp PV Power Plant in Kom Ombo

Doc. Title: Comment Sheet Referring to K594-TSK-IC-DIA-0001-

IFA-01
Doc. No. K594-CS-0230 Date: 16.10.2018 Page: 1 of 5
 26 MWp PV Power Plant in Kom Ombo
DOCUMENT COMMENT SHEET

The documents enumerated on the attached list have been reviewed by the following disciplines & people:

Abbr. Client’s Abbr.

Reviewing discipline ILF Name Date Date
Name

a) Project Management K. Lorungroj KL 11.06.2019

b) NREA NREA 10.04.2019
c) Electrical Engineer O. Wannakit OW 11.06.2019

The Approval Codes given for each document on the attached list have following meanings:

CODE REMARKS
A Approved
B Approved if comments will be incorporated
C Not approved – revise and resubmit
D Taken for information only

Important note: The term “Approved” means that you may proceed with your work on the basis shown on the relevant
document. “Approving” a document by the Client does in no case replace your internal quality control. You remain
responsible for the correctness of your documents. Under no circumstances the term “Approved” relieves you from any
of your contractual obligations. The comments do not change the Contract.

Project: 26 MWp PV Power Plant in Kom Ombo

Doc. Title: Comment Sheet Referring to K594-TSK-IC-DIA-0001-

IFA-01
Doc. No. K594-CS-0230 Date: 16.10.2018 Page: 2 of 5
 26 MWp PV Power Plant in Kom Ombo
DOCUMENT COMMENT SHEET

Detailed Comments

Approval Code

K594-TSK-IC-DIA-0001-IFA-01 - Control System Architectural Diagram

Comment Status: open / closed / Info

Item Comment
No.
Abbr. Comments Status

10 April 2019
1 NREA NREA’s approval is subject to TSK comply with the contract requirements
open
Reply: This document is according to the contract requirements unless
1R EG 25-04-2019
there is any inconsistency in the contract
CCTV system in the PV area system, equipment in the control building such Open
2 OW as UPS, fire alarm, Main Switchgear system should be connected and
17-04-2019
shown on Control System Architectural Diagram.
Reply: The connection of the CCTV system with the PV system is shown in
the drawing:

2R EG 25-04-2019

All the elements that have an ethernet connection will be connected directly
with the switch 01 or switch 02. The rest of elements will be connected with
an I/O module connected with Switch 01. These connections will be
included in the final version of this document when all connections have
been defined.
The picture as replied is only CCTV in control building. All components and
system shall be shown in the drawing.,
 CCTV system in the PV area system,
Open
2C(a) OW  Equipment in the control building such as UPS, fire alarm, Main
11-06-2019
Switchgear system
Those equipment shall be connected and shown on Control System
Architectural Diagram.
Reply: It has been included except the information about CCTV which will
2R(a) EG be included in the Surveillance & security system layout “K594-TSK-IC- 15-09-2019
DWG-0002-IFA”.
Communication of Main Switchgear system including metering, protection, Open
3 OW
breaker status(digital I/O) shall be shown on the drawing. 17-04-2019

Project: 26 MWp PV Power Plant in Kom Ombo

Doc. Title: Comment Sheet Referring to K594-TSK-IC-DIA-0001-

IFA-01
Doc. No. K594-CS-0230 Date: 16.10.2018 Page: 3 of 5
 26 MWp PV Power Plant in Kom Ombo
DOCUMENT COMMENT SHEET

Comment Status: open / closed / Info

Item Comment
No.
Abbr. Comments Status

Reply: These connections will be included in the final version of this

3R EG 25-04-2019
document when all connections have been defined
The drawing should be done. All equipment monitored shall be shown for Open
3C(a) OW
review and construction. 11.06.2019

3R(a) EG Reply: Included in the new version 25-09-2019

Open
4 OW Type of protocal shall be shown on the drawing.
17-04-2019
Reply: The drawing indicates the type of protocol in the legend:

4R EG 25-04-2019

Closed
4C OW Noted.
12/06/2019
Connection and communication including type of protocal to substation shall Open
5 OW
be shown on the drawing. 17-04-2019
Reply: As indicated in our document, the protocol considered for the
5R EG 25-04-2019
communication with the substation is Modbus.
EPC to check the limitation of length of Modbus with actual length at site.

Open
5C(a) OW
11-06-2019

5R(a) EG Reply: Modbus has not limitation 25-09-2019

Reference cell shall be shown. It is apart from weather station. Detail of Open
6 KL
each components in weather station shall be shown. 18-04-2019
Reply: These details are not included in the Control System Architectural
6R EG 25-04-2019
Diagram. They will be sent in a separate document.

6C(a) KL All components or sensor in weather station, shall be shown in this drawing. Open

Project: 26 MWp PV Power Plant in Kom Ombo

Doc. Title: Comment Sheet Referring to K594-TSK-IC-DIA-0001-

IFA-01
Doc. No. K594-CS-0230 Date: 16.10.2018 Page: 4 of 5
 26 MWp PV Power Plant in Kom Ombo
DOCUMENT COMMENT SHEET

Comment Status: open / closed / Info

Item Comment
No.
Abbr. Comments Status
11.06.2019

Reply: The information about weather station will be sent separately, as an

6R(a) EG attachment to the document “K594-TSK-IC-DWG-0001-IFA- 25-09-2019
00_Meteorological Station layout”

7R Reply:

8R Reply:

9R Reply:

Project: 26 MWp PV Power Plant in Kom Ombo

Doc. Title: Comment Sheet Referring to K594-TSK-IC-DIA-0001-

IFA-01
Doc. No. K594-CS-0230 Date: 16.10.2018 Page: 5 of 5