Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract-This paper presents a versatile laboratory test sedan and Honda released its Insight and Civic Hybrid in
bench built up for carrying out researches and experimental Japan. These HEVs have historical value in that they are the
tests about hybrid propulsion trains, without the availability
first hybrid vehicles commercialized that responded to the
of a real vehicle and an automotive test track. The test bench
is realized by using a relatively low-power engine that can be
problem of fuel consumption and gas emission reduction
combined with one or more electrical machines for emulating [1], [2]. They have also the merit to have triggered a lively
different hybrid architectures. In addition to the test bench activity of R&D on the topic of the Hybrid Propulsion
structure, some examples of usage are also described in the Trains in a variety of academic and industrial laboratories
paper.
in which high performance and automotive dedicated elec
Index Terms-Hybrid Electric Vehicle; Test Bench; PM trical motors, power converters, energy storage systems and
Motors; Integrated Starter/Alternator; Sensorless Drives. advanced control strategies are deeply investigated. The
most of the laboratories cannot exploit a real vehicle and an
I. INTRODUCTION automotive test track and therefore the studies are validated
N the recent years the interest to Hybrid Electric Vehi experimentally by appropriate test benches [3]-[6] like that
I cles (HEVs) is growing up. Nevertheless the concept of presented in this paper that emulate real situations in the
this kind of vehicle is almost as old as the automobile itself Laboratory of the authors.
[1], [2]. Formerly, the electric machine assisted the Internal
Combustion Engine (ICE) to provide an acceptable level of II. TEST BENCH OV ERVIEW
performance, because the dawn of ICE technologies was The Electric Drives Laboratory (EDLab) at the Univer
less advanced than Electric Machine (EM). So the lower of sity of Padova is equipped with the Hybrid test bench,
fuel consumption was not considered as primary purpose shown in Fig. 1 in one of its most used configurations.
of this technologies. During the Ph.D. course of one of the authors (M.M.), the
The first HEV was a Pieper vehicle presented at the Hybrid test bench has been designed and realized as part
Paris Salon of 1899 [1]; it was realized by the Pieper of the Ph.D. activities [7]. The core of the test bench is
establishments of Lige, Belgium in collaboration with the a single cylinder Diesel ICE (recovered from a previous
Vendovelli and Priestly Electric Carriage Company, France. project), whose data are shown in Table I.
The Pieper vehicle hybridization scheme was a parallel
type; it was composed by a small air-cooled gasoline TABLE I: ICE data.
ICE assisted by an electric motor supplied from lead-acid
batteries. The tasks of the EM were the engine startup and Parameter Value
the support of the ICE when driving power required was Type combustion cycle Diesel
greater than that of the latter. The batteries were charged Number of cylinders Single
by the ICE when the vehicle was standstill. Piston displacement 280 cm3
Maximum power 4 kW
Another HEV introduced at the Paris Salon of 1899, but Maximum speed 4000 rpm
with series hybridization philosophy, was derived by an Minimum speed 900 rpm
EV commercially built by the French firm Vendovelli and Start torque 18 Nm
(b) Prototype
40
E30
� MTPA
� 201�nm�nm..������nw���nm��
E"
� 10
0
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 4000
10
[ : MTPA
� 24
a.
attracting more interest in the field of the automotive The Integrated Starter/Alternator (ISA) [S] machine used
electrical propulsion. in this work is shown in Fig. 6. It is a IS-pole and 27-slot
TABLE II: Parameters of the SPM brake electric machine. TABLE III: Parameters of the ISA machine.
20
10 @ ConstantTorqueLoci MTPA
8 f-t;------l---.....;j ..•.• MTPATrajectory
E15
�
6 �1
E!
� 4 0
I-
5
C
2
� 0
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500
:::l
" 0
Vl
'x
ro -2 5
I
C" MTPA
-4 4
-6 [iii 3
-8 3: 2
0
C-
-10
-10 -5 o 5 10
d-axis current [A] O 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000
Mechanical speed [rpm]
Fig. 5: Constant torque maps of the SPM brake machine.
Fig. 7: ISA machine torque and power characteristics.
20
machine able to deliver ION Tn of nominal torque and more
1"-__---1 :II--II @ constantTorqueLocili
18
than twice that as peak torque. Principal electric machine I ..•.• MTPATrajectory n
data are collected in Tab. III. 16 6 16 1&-
Fig. 7 reports the ISA electric machine torque and power 14 · ·-'1 4
-_ �4 -'- 1 4-'-
�
C 12 r----12
1 -
' -� __1 2
1 ' ----1 2--
�:::l
"
10
Vl
'x
ro
8 8 8
I
C"
6
22 2 2
effect [15]). Therefore, the REL machines and the Ferrite o 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000
PM assisted REL (PMAREL) machines are becoming Mechanical speed [rpm]
competitors of both SPM machines and induction machines Fig. 10: Machine torque and power characteristics.
in many applications, in particular in the automotive field.
A sketch of the geometry of the REL machine is shown in 22
Fig. 9(a) and a picture of EM prototype is in Fig. 9(b).
20
18
16
� 14
C
� 12
::J
� 10
·x
'{l 8
rr
I
I
'--....:.i'-"---l-........
.:c
I
-----------
[18] or ICE active torque damping [19] have been also the engine control and increase its efficiency because
carried out the engine operates at its optimum speed. In addition
the engine can be located anywhere in the vehicle.
IV. TESTING C A PA BILITIES This configuration is emulated by the test bench
by removing the torque meter and connecting the
Due to the dual power sources, in the HEVs there are
propulsion DC bus to the ISA DC bus.
several available power-train architectures to combine the
• Parallel hybrid: Fig. 13(b) reports the configuration
electric machine power with the ICE one and different con
of a parallel hybrid power-train. The EM and ICE can
trol strategies to control each power sources. In Fig. 13 the
both deliver power in parallel to the wheels. The en
principal power-train configurations that can be reproduced
gine and electric machine are coupled by mechanical
by the developed test bench are reported [2], [20]-[22].
mechanism as clutch or gears. Both power sources can
deliver power to the wheels in combined or separated
[ Fuel tank � ICE
mode. The EM can be used as generator to recover
the kinetic energy and as a motor during the engine
boost phase. A clutch is foreseen in the test bench
combined or in place of the torque meter to allow full
electric behaviour or during ICE start-up.
One of the more frequent and significant study in which
the test bench has been intensively used is the design and
(a) Series hybrid test of the train power flow, in particular in the parallel
configuration. In the parallel hybrid power-train, the power
[ Fuel tank � ICE
flow control can be summarized by four operating modes
that are reported in Fig. 14 [23], [24].
The parallel hybrid scheme needs only two propulsion
devices, the ICE and the EM, which can be used in the
following mode:
• Startup/acceleration: during the startup of engine the
EM provides the request high torque while the vehicle
(b) Parallel hybrid is mechanically decoupled. During the acceleration
both ICE and EM proportionally supply power to the
Fig. 13: Power-train classification of HEVs.
wheels. For mild HEVs typically the power is split as
80 % from engine and 20 % from electric machine.
The most used power-train architectures are: In both phases the EM is used as electric motor.
• Series hybrid: the series hybrid configuration is re • Normal driving and battery charging: during this
ported in Fig. 13(a), it is one of the first hybrid phase, in order to preserve the battery charge level,
topologies that was in commercial vehicles because normally the EM remains in the off mode and then
there is no mechanical coupling of the power sources. only the ICE supplies the necessary power to the
The ICE is commonly used to complement the energy vehicle. In parallel hybrid configuration the ICE and
shortage of batteries. Therefore, the EM can receive EM are coupled to the same transmission therefore
electricity directly from the ICE, or from the batteries, the battery can be charged during the driving when
or both. Decoupling between the engine and the the vehicle is at light load. So in this phase the EM
wheels allows to control the ICE speed independently is used as electric generator.
from the vehicle speed. This behavior can simplify • Deceleration/braking: in both phases the EM is used
[ Fuel tank � ICE is braked by SPM electric machine fed by torque controlled
C¢ drive, and the ICE speed is controlled by the throttle
commanded by the DC motor. Fig. 16 shows experimental
(a) Startup/acceleration
III(>
(c) Deceleration/braking
surement is carried out. A block scheme of the efficiency The aim of the Hybrid bench in this test is to emulate
measurement setup is reported in Fig. 15. As can be noted a vehicle running on a regulated cycle. With the rated
the fuel quantity is measured by a fuel sensor, the ICE shaft Diesel ICE power of the bench the chosen vehicle is a
14
---- Nominal torque and the inertia of the vehicle.
In order to find the best Hybrid bench control perfor
mance three ditlerent control schemes have been consid
ered and tested, as reported in Fig. 20. Fig. 20(a) shows the
(al Scheme 1
Throttle ICE control
350 ,------,-----
- c==========il
- Experimental Measurement
- - - Manufacturer Data (b) Scheme 2
:c
� 300
�
c
o
E.
E
=>
"'
c
o
U 250 (cl Scheme 3
0;
=>
u..
Fig. 20: Hybrid bench control schemes.
2��L
OO::----20::-: 0� 0::----::-:25�00::----30::-: �00::----::-::' 3500 bench control Scheme 1 configuration. The speed reference
Speed [rpm]
w;;:LTP is compared to the actual value Wm and the error
Fig. 18: Experimental fuel consumption of Diesel ICE. is the PI regulator input. Its output is the reference for the
throttle positione;�tottle given as opening percentage. The
result concerning Scheme 1 can be seen Fig. 21. During
light vehicle and its main characteristics and features are the speed ramp the error is almost constant and non-zero.
summarized in Table V. Therefore, for this application The first effort to improve the bench performances was
made by increasing Kpe and K1e' As a consequence of
TABLE V: Vehicle data. this, oscillations appeared in the speed shaft meaning that
the control system is getting near to its stability limit.
Specification Value
In order to have a null ramp error a second integrator has
Weight 400 kg been used after the PI regulator. This scheme is shown in
Width 1.5 m
Fig. 20(b). The speed curve related to Scheme 2 in Fig. 21
Height 1.5 m
Number of gear 4 highlights that the error during the ramp is actually zeroed.
Wheel radius 28 em However oscillations can be noticed after the first gear
changing. The maximum oscillation's amplitude reaches
the Worldwide harmonized Light vehicles Test Procedures 190 rpm.
(WLTP) - Class 1 has been considered. WLTP is used Looking at the relationship between the throttle position
for low power vehicle with its propulsion power lower and the rotating speed of the ICE, the next effort consisted
then 22 kW/ton. The WLTP-Class 1 is shown in Fig. 19. in adding at the PI regulator output (feed-forward) a
As indicated in Fig. 12 the ICE throttle is controlled, by quantity that depends on the speed reference. For this case,
Scheme 3, the control system configuration is reported
75 in Fig. 20(c). Fig. 21 shows the positive etlect of the
:E 60 feed-forward. During the speed ramp the error is zeroed
E
� 45 and after the first gearshift the reference is still precisely
Z followed.
'0
o
�
For these reasons Scheme 3 has been chosen as definitive
200 400 600 800 1000 bench configuration. Fig. 22 reports the first 60 s of the
Time [s]
WLTP - Class 1. In particular it is highlighted the rotor
Fig. 19: WLTP - Class 1. speed and the equivalent velocity of the simulated vehicle.