Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AN UNDERGRADUATE THESIS
Presented as Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements
for the Degree of Sarjana Sastra
in English Letters
By
MONICA CHRISTANTI VINNEY
Student Number: 134214085
AN UNDERGRADUATE THESIS
Presented as Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements
for the Degree of Sarjana Sastra
in English Letters
By
MONICA CHRISTANTI VINNEY
Student Number: 134214085
i
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
AN UNDERGRADUATE THESIS
Presented as Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements
for the Degree of Sarjana Sastra
in English Letters
By
MONICA CHRISTANTI VINNEY
Student Number: 134214085
ii
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
THEODORE ROOSEVELT
vii
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
AND OF COURSE
MY FABULOUS FRIENDS
viii
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The finishing of this thesis cannot be separated from the God’s hand which
guides me through the times and the people around me who always support me that
I would like to thank. Firstly, my biggest gratitude is for the Almighty God Jesus
Christ who gives me full strength to pass through all over the difficulties I might
find on the way to finish this thesis. Secondly, a great gratitude goes to my parents
who always pray for me and support me with their endless love. I give my endless
thank also to all of my family for the pray and support that can raise my spirit up to
do this thesis.
My great gratitude is also for my advisor Anna Fitriati S. Pd. M.Hum who
has guided me along the process of finishing my thesis. I thank her for the ideas to
help me solve the problems in finishing my thesis. I also would like to thank my co.
advisor Harris Hermansyah Setiajid, M. Hum. for the advice to help me revise this
thesis to be better. A special thank is also for my loyal editor, Dina Febriyani, who
always has time to help me to edit the format. I thank her for the kindness and her
Last but not least, this thesis is dedicated for all my great friends, especially
Bu. Bagyo’s family who can always be my second family to lay on whenever I was
in good or even bad times. Thank you very much for the smile, laugh and the
warmth I could feel whenever we are together. I will see you all on top.
ix
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
TABLE OF CONTENTS
x
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
xi
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
LIST OF TABLES
xii
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
LIST OF ABBREVIATION
A / Adj : Adjective
ADV : Adverb
Af : Affix
N : Noun
P / Prep : Preposition
pℓ : Plural
V : Verb
xiii
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
ABSTRACT
Words are important things in a language as the medium to send the message
in a communication. Based on the form, there are two kinds of word; simple words
and complex words. In forming the complex words, there are several kinds of word-
formation processes and one of them is compounding. Compounding is divided into
three types; open, closed and hyphenated. This thesis will discuss the English closed
compounds that are found in the articles related to Kartini Day in The Jakarta Post
April 2016 and 2017.
There are two problems in this thesis. The first is the distribution of all the
type of compounds (open, closed and hyphenated) in the articles. The second is how
the compound words are formed.
This thesis is population study which is done by collecting all of the data
from the articles related to Kartini Day in The Jakarta Post 2016/2017. There are
22 open compounds, 42 closed compounds and 32 hyphenated compounds. From
the data, the highest amount of compound is closed compound, therefore, this type
of compound is discussed further. The analysis is divided into two forms; first is
based on the form of structure which uses morphological process and second is
based on the meaning of compound which uses dictionaries to consult the meaning
of compounds.
Based on the form of structure, there are 17 inflectional compound or
40,48% and 25 un-inflectional compound or 59,52% whereas based on the meaning
of compound, there are 38 endocentric compounds or 90,48% and 4 exocentric
compounds or 9,52%. As the conclusion, closed compounds that are mostly found
in the articles related to Kartini Day in The Jakarta Post 2016 and 2017 are un-
inflectional compounds and endocentric compounds.
xiv
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
ABSTRAK
xv
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
English as the language used around the world has two forms that people
use to communicate; written and spoken language. Both of those forms have their
speaking form or from the words spoken by someone while written English
provides language through the words writing. From this importance of spoken and
writing English, we can see that words are the necessary thing in providing the
language.
In language, there are thousands words provided and new words that might
enter our mind in daily basis. These words might be the simple words or the
complex words. Complex words are produced from the process called
are also as the part of morphology courses. Those types of words formation are
complex words) and compounding in which all of these types explain how the
1
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
much smaller category of phrasal words, that is items that have the internal structure
interest about how the combination of two different words can produce new word
with new meaning. Unlike the other types of word formation which do not use other
different words, compounding uses the other different words that are joined
together to create new words and new meaning. The new words produced from
the text; open compounds (written in separated words), closed compounds (written
as single word) and hyphenated compounds (words joined by hyphen). The words
like cell phone and high school are the examples of open compound. Football and
peanut are the examples of closed compound while in-depth and runner-up are the
Besides the forms, compounding also has two kinds of compound based on
compound can be divided into compound noun, compound adjective and compound
verb. Some common words such as wallpaper, girlfriend, and blackboard are the
example of compound nouns. Compound verbs may be found in the words outrun,
underestimate, overcome and compound adjectives may also be found in the words
There are still many other examples of compound words out of those
words can be found in any text form around us, for examples in articles, textbooks,
novels, magazines, newspapers or dictionaries. The topic can be about sport, politic,
words that are found in the articles particularly related to Kartini Day. Kartini Day
is chosen as the topic of articles for the reason that it is not only because of a recent
national event in Indonesia, but it is also an annual special day to celebrate women
emancipation.
As a woman, in her young age, Kartini has become a role model for
Indonesian women in proving that women also have roles in society. She tried to
erase people’s mindset toward women that women’s role are no more than in the
house as housewife and taking care of their child or husband. Through her action,
she showed that women also have their right to participate in society and it is
reflected in her book Habis Gelap Terbitlah Terang which tell her desires toward
women written in letters to her cousin and her friends. This is truly her effort to
make gender equality between men and women arises. Now Kartini’s spirit has
become the reflection for all women in Indonesia to get their rights and to take a
role in all social aspects without leaving their nature as women. Therefore, in
emancipation.
The object of this study are the articles related to Kartini Day taken from
The Jakarta Post April 2016 and 2017. These two publishing years are considered
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
as the most recent time of Kartini Day and they are selected as the object in order
to get sufficient data to be analyzed. Due to the fact that all the data do not contain
words that reflect about women or Kartini, this thesis just focuses on identifying
compound words found in the articles. The analysis of the data are divided in to two
categories. The first is based on the structure form of compound and the second is
B. Problem Formulation
In order to analyze this topic, the writer has formulated these problems of
1. What forms of compound words are found in the articles related to Kartini
2. How are the dominant form of compound words in the articles related to
Kartini Day found in The Jakarta Post April 2016 and 2017 formed?
discussed in this study. The first is to identify the forms of compound words in the
articles related to Kartini Day in The Jakarta 2016/2017 by reading all articles
thoroughly. After finding all of compounds, the second is to analyze the dominant
form of compounds, which are mostly found in the articles using morphological
analysis will be divided into two categories; the first is based on the structure form
D. Definition of Term
information about the terms used in this research. The terms used in this research
The first term is word. “Word is the basic unit of language” (McCarthy,
It seems that a word is not just a building block of sentence, it is a building block
with a meaning which English learner may need to consult a dictionary to discover
it. Like in the example above, the word “women” has several words to describe the
definition of it. Those words perform not only as the former of a sentence but also
a former of a meaning.
formed by combining roots, and the much smaller category of phrasal word, that is
item that have the internal structure of phrase but function syntactically as word”
(2002: 59). The internal structure of compound seems the same as the phrase which
has the head and the modifier. Nevertheless, it performs as a word which is formed
combination between two words, black and board with each meaning and combined
as one with a new meaning that is the board used for writing using chalk.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
in 1879 who was the national Indonesian heroine and as the pioneer of Indonesian
wearing such of traditional costume to symbolize the unity of the nation. Especially
women, they usually wear kebaya in replicating Kartini’s attire which also
The last term is The Jakarta Post. According to the official website of The
newspaper in Indonesia which gives any kinds of news in Indonesia. The Jakarta
Post is available not only in printed but also online editions that are free to be
accessed in the internet but in this study The Jakarta Post in printed edition is used
as the object of the study. The address of general and editorial building is located
in Jl. Palmerah Barat 142-143 Jakarta. It is published by PT. Bina Media Tenggara
since 1983 and lead by Jusuf Wanandi, Cherly P. Santoso, Endy M. Bayuni and
CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
In this part, there are three studies reviewed from previous researches done
by other researchers which are similar to this topic research. The first one is from
compounding from the new entry words of Oxford dictionary from May 2014 to
May 2015. Leihitu, in her research, tries to focus on the exocentric compounding
by analyzing the part of speech of each new entry word and finding the meaning
each of them.
The object of her research was taken from Oxford dictionary from May 2014
to May 2015. The data was found in the Oxford dictionary from internet (electronic
dictionary) since most of exocentric compounds contains two words and cannot be
found in the printed dictionary. Leihitu also uses morphological process to make
the result between parts of the speech more significant with the meaning of those
data. The findings are 54 new entry words in which 46 noun as the most part of
speech that she found and the rest are adjectives and verbs. The meaning of each
Limjadi (2005) which discusses the similar topic to the present research, compound
words. The data of this research are found in the Longman dictionary of
7
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
tries to focus on the compound adjectives. He figures out the elements and
adjectives performed. The data collection of his research is taken from Longman
in the word with letter A to C to avoid too much data in his research. In order to
describe all of the findings, Limjadi uses descriptive linguistic method in his
study aims to describe the meaning extension of huvud (‘head’) in modern Swedish
compound words. All compound words that contain the word huvud, with the total
of 223, are extracted from Svenska Akademins Ordlista (2006, 13) published by the
productivity as well as translating into English and Spanish in which the meaning
extension is examined.
Furthermore, this study, on the one hand, tries to compare between English
and Spanish in order to find similar patterns of meaning extension and on the other
hand to look for traits that have gone along non-parallel paths. Therefore, it could
be considered as traits that are distinctive for the Swedish language. According to
Olausson, this study is a kind of great importance for native speakers as well as for
understand what is said and written in different contexts and in different areas.
Based on those three previous studies, the writer concludes some points
compared to this study. First, there are similarities between those studies and the
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
current study. This study is similar to the study conducted by Limjadi in term of
order to describe all of the findings. The study conducted by Leihitu is also quite
similar to this study. Leihitu uses morphological process in identifying the part of
speech and the meaning of the data, and so does the writer. The data of this study
are identified the part of speech of each word formed in each compounding.
However, some differences are also found despite the main topic between
the previous and current study is just the same. Unlike the previous study, the object
of this study is taken from articles related to Kartini Day in The Jakarta Post April
2016 and 2017. In this study, the writer just focuses on the closed compound while
other studies, like the study conducted by Leihitu just focuses on analyzing
This study is also different from the study conducted by Ollauson that he tries to
words while this study analysis not only the meaning but also word formation of
compounding.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
10
1. Morphology
morphology refers to the mental system involved in word formation or to the branch
of linguistics that deals with word, their internal structure and how they are formed
(Aronoff and Fudeman, 2011:2). It means that the major point in morphology is to
investigate words, their internal structure and how they are formed through the
indivisible units of semantic content or grammatical function which word are made
the smallest unit which has meaning. It cannot be divided into smaller units which
the word fee [fi:], which contain just one morpheme, cannot be divided into [f] and
[i:] since these sounds do not have any meaning but the word birds, arms, trees can
be divided into two morphemes which functions separately; first is singular bird,
arm and tree and followed by a second morpheme (s). This is what we call as plural
The word birds, arms and trees previously give us a simple description of
internal structure in each word or how such a word can form from morphemes.
Here, morphological process is essentially needed to discuss how the words are
11
2. Word-Formation
as “the branch of morphology which deals with the relations between a complex
lexeme and simple(r) lexeme” (1991: 36). The forms catch, catches, catching,
caught are different representation of the lexeme CATCH. They all share a core
meaning although they are spelled differently. The forms of catch above are the
–ion, associate is a verb and after the suffix is added in the final position it changes
morphology.
Szymanek.
a. Reduplication
involves reiteration of the whole base or just a part of it (initial or final segment or
of the word serves derivational or inflectional purposes, one can have suffix form
which results final reduplication (repetition in the end of the base) or infix form that
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
12
result infixal reduplication in which the structure of the base itself is broken into .
medially or finally.
b. Affixation
morpheme with a steam or root” (1989:62). The morpheme added to the stem called
The linguists divides affix into three types; suffix, prefix and infix.
An affix that is attached to the front of its base is called a prefix, while an affix that
is attached to the end of its base is called a suffix. Here are some examples of prefix
The last type that is less common than prefix and suffix is infix, a type of
affix that occurs within a base. There is a bound morpheme that is inserted into the
base form. It seems hard to find many example of infix in English but certain swear
words or other expressive lexemes like bloody, blooming, etc. may be inserted into
13
c. Conversion
existing word to a new syntactic category. In his book, Szymanek assumes that
to the base. Even though it does not add any affix, conversion resembles derivation
because of the change in category and meaning that it brings about. Some examples
d. Back-derivation
of new word by the deletion of a suffix or supposed suffix from another complex
14
concept of back-derivation is talking about the origin of individual words. Here are
Beggar to beg
Peddler to peddle
Editor to edit
Negation to negate
Television to televise
The following type of word formation is compounding which will be
explained further in the next theory with deep comprehension.
3. Compounding
independent word. It crucially involves putting together two or more lexical item
greenhouse contains the bases green (A) and house (N), which can occur as a
where X and Y are the variables, X is for Adjective (A) and Y is for Noun (N); their
It is the same case as blackboard (black (A) and board (N)) and blackbird (black(N)
and bird(N)). From the examples mentioned, we can say that compounding is
distinguished from the syntactic phrases, for example greenhouse and green house.
Both of these words sound as the same but different in structure and meaning.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
15
Greenhouse is a compounding which means the building that has glass walls used
for growing plant but green house is a phrase which means a house with the color
of green.
with or without a hyphen like breakfast and ice-cream. However, many other
a words like free trade sometimes written as two separated word by a space or
underived lexeme which are referred to as modifier and its head. Since there are
common compounds are right-headed in English, modifier and head can be easily
found in such compound like what has been mentioned before, blackboard. Board
functions as the head while black functions as its modifier. To get more
comprehension about compounding, there are some further explanations in the next
a mark of punctuation that not only unites but also separates the component of
16
pronunciation. Words that are hyphenated mainly to express the idea of a unit and
Shell-like long-term
Well-to-do low-water
East-central plug-in
East-northeast up-to-date
is a combination of two words that are so closely associated. They convey the idea
of single concept but are spelled as unconnected words, for examples fruit juice,
high school students, banana split, rocking chair, middle class, post office.
written in a single word. Some examples that have been discuss in the previous
part like blackbird, blackboard and greenhouse are the examples of closed
compound. The other examples are copyeditor, wildlife, and audiovisual and there
are more examples of closed compound in the data found that will be displayed in
head is generally used to refer to the most important unit in a complex linguistic
structure (Plag, 2003:135). The head of compound is modified by the other member
17
that is their head usually occurs on the right-hand side. The compound as a whole
inherits semantic and syntactic information from its head. Thus, if the head is a
noun, the compound will be noun (e.g. blackboard, bathroom), if the head is a verb,
pluralized, the plural marking occurs on the head not in the non-head (Plag,
2003:136). Thus, parks commissioner is not the plural form of park commissioner.
This rule is applied when the words in compound noun are joined by hyphen
when the compound noun is single word or closed compound, the plural (-s) is
usually added in the end of the word (e.g. toothbrushes not toothsbrush). It means
that the head and the meaning of compound is taken from the second member of
compound.
[X Y]Y
X = {root, word, phrase}
Y = {root, word}
Y = grammatical properties inherited from Y
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
18
(derived from two or more simpler lexeme) that may be sketched as follows
(1991:82):
X and Y are variables, the first ranging over Adjectives (A) and the second over
Nouns (N); their combination is turn into a Noun. Thus, by the same process,
[greyhound]N is derived from [grey]A and [hound]N, blackthorn is from black and
From the structure above, it shows us that they are binary and which kinds
of element may occupy which position. Furthermore, it also shows us that the right-
hand member is the head which the grammatical properties merge to the compound
as the whole.
c. Meaning of Compound
The meaning of compound is not always the sum of the meanings of its
parts; a blackboard may be green or white. The same case also happen in redcoat.
Not everyone who wears a red coat is a Redcoat. This would be different in the
sentences “she has a red coat in her wardrobe” and “she has a Redcoat in her
wardrobe” which have been highly significant in America in 1776, since Redcoat
Other compounds reveal other meaning relation between the parts, which
are not entirely consistent because many compounds are idiomatic (Fromkin,
Rodman & Hyam, 2009: 59). A boathouse is a house for boat but a cathouse is not
a house for cat (slang for house of prostitution or whorehouse). Peanut oil and olive
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
19
oil are oils that are made from something, but how about baby oil? It refers to oil
In the examples above show that the meaning of compound includes at least
compounds do not seem to relate to the meaning of the individual parts at all
(2009:59). A highbrow does not necessarily have a high brow, nor a does a big wig
have a big wig, nor does an egghead have an egg-shaped head. In conclusion, the
meaning of many compounds must be learned as if they are individual whole words
and some of the meanings may be figured out from the head of compound, but not
all.
divided into three kinds of compounds; compound noun, compound verb and
The first is compound noun. It is a compound that has a noun as the head. It
followed by a noun (AN) (PN), or a verb followed by noun (VN). In this research,
the researcher provide summary of some examples of compounds noun taken from
some books, such as (Carstairs, McCarthy, 2002) and (Katamba, 1993). In order to
get better view of list of the examples, the table is displayed below.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
20
the head. It can contain noun followed by an adjective (NA), adjective followed by
of compound adjectives are displayed in the table below, which are also the
Third, compound verb, is compound that has verb as the head. Variety types
of compound verb can be verb followed by verb (VV), noun followed by verb (NV),
adjective followed by verb (AV) and preposition followed by verb (PV). There is a
table of examples provided below, which also summary from the two books
21
compound which do not contain element that function as the semantic head which
is modified by the unhead element (Katamba, 1993: 319). It means that its lexical
category or meaning are not determinable from the head. It seems the meaning of
semantic relationship since the meaning is not a house that is green but a building
with glass wall for growing plants. The same way apply in butterfingers and
finger N) is neither a kind of fingers nor kind of butter, but rather than a person who
blockhead (block N + head N) is neither a kind of block nor head but rather than an
idiot.
at all with the sum of the meanings of its constituents. For this reason exocentric
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
22
creating new words. Therefore, Katamba says that Exocentric compound becomes
Tree diagram also shows syntactic structure of word analysis. The word itself is not
a simple sequence of morpheme but it has internal structure (Fromkin, Rodman and
Hyam, 2009:49). The following examples are taken from compounding which
called inflected compounds (Katamba, 1993: 312) like airports and underestimated
examples, according to Katamba, are described using the tree diagram as follows:
23
C. Theoretical Framework
There are some theories reviewed in this study as the tools in order to answer
the problem formulations. This part explains how these theories are used to answer
those problem formulations. In this study, morphology is the main core theory to
explain compounding. Morphology itself is the study of word form and structure,
thus analyzing the internal structure of compounds and how they are formed using
morphology is needed.
The next theory discussed in this study is word formation as the branch of
morphology which deals with the relations between a complex lexeme and
simple(r) lexeme. In this theory, word formation explains the formation of word
which contains elements or parts to build a word. There are several types of word
next theory. Through this theory, the readers are given deep explanations about the
difference between compounds and phrases since they are almost similar in writing.
Therefore, it helps in answering the first problem formulation that is to get the
In the sub-theory, compounding are divided into some details. The first is
the forms of compound which includes closed compound (written in single word)
as the focus of the data in this study. The second is the structure of compound which
explains how compounds are formed and what elements in compounds; their head
and modifier, grammatical categories or part of speech in each word. Therefore, the
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
24
formulation. The third is meaning of compound which helps to find the meaning of
compounds whether the meaning has the relation with the member of compound or
not. In this matter, the head of compound can help to find the related meaning easier,
The last theory in this study is tree diagram to support the analysis by
CHAPTER III
METHODOLOGY
The data of this study are compound words found in the articles related to
Kartini Day in the The Jakarta Post 2016 / 2017. Like what have been mentioned
in the definition of term, The Jakarta Post is daily English newspaper in Indonesia
that gives any kinds of news like crime, politics, economy, features and sports. The
Jakarta Post is available in both printed and online edition, and this study also uses
these two editions as the object of the study. There are 8 articles that are related to
Kartini Day; 5 articles from the Jakarta Post in 2016 and 3 articles from The Jakarta
Post in 2017.
The approach that the writer uses in this study is morphological approach.
Morphology itself is the study of word form and structure. As the branch of
linguistics, morphology also deals with word, its internal structure and how it is
formed (Aronoff and Fudeman, 2011: 2). Therefore this approach is important in
this thesis as the basic theory in analyzing the data, which is compound words as
25
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
26
1. Data Collection
In this study, the writer used population data collection. According to Best
and Kahn, population is defined as “a group of individuals with at least one common
Through population data collection we can collect all the data which depend on the
characteristic of interest.
The data were closed compound words found in the articles related to
Kartini Day in the newspaper The Jakarta Post 2016 and 2017. In this study, the
writer focused on the closed compound words since this kind of compound was
mostly found in the articles than open and hyphenated compound. Therefore, the
The first step to find the data was by reading all of the articles which
related to Kartini Day. The second was identifying the dominant compound which
is closed compound from the composition number of open, closed and hyphenated
compounds. The most exists compound words found in the articles were then
exocentric).
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
27
2. Data Analysis
After finding all of compound words in the articles, the writer got the data
of how many compounds for each form (open, closed and hyphenated) displayed
on a table later. From this composition, there would be found which compound
that mostly exist in the articles related Kartini Day and the result is closed
compounds. The analysis of this data was divided into two forms, first was based
on the structure of compound and second was based on the meaning of compound.
compounds and the meaning analysis was divided into endocentric and exocentric
compounds and also displayed the tree diagram, particularly for inflectional
compounds, the writer provided a table containing the morphological process and
deeper analysis was needed to describe the formation of the additional item
After analyzing the structure, the next analysis was the meaning of
compounds. In finding the meaning of each compound, the writer used Merriam
Webster English online dictionary which provides the etymology of the words to
check the word origin and Cambridge English online dictionary which gives the
28
When the meaning of separable words and the whole compound were
related, it meant that it had literal meaning or endocentric compound. It was also
easier to decide the head of the compound. However, if the meaning of the whole
compound had no relation with the two separable words, it was considered as
(of the color green) and house (a building in which a family lives). The meaning is
not a house that is green but a building with glass wall for growing plants.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
CHAPTER IV
This chapter aims to answer the problem formulations with the deep
discussion of the data. This chapter is divided into two subchapters based on the
problem formulations. The first subchapter describes the distribution of the data in
The first table presents the distribution of compounds (open, closed and
hyphenated) with the amount and the percentage of each compound. The total result
from this table also shows the highest percentage that represent the most exist
compound in the articles. The next table presents the distribution of inflectional –
the structure of each compound or what elements that create a compound. The
analysis of the structure also describes the two separable words that are combined
into one word as a closed compound with each part of speech. After that, determine
the type of compound that may be produced based on the head of compound and
In purpose to get a better view of how compounds are formed, the analysis
of compounds also displays the tree diagrams, particularly for the compounds
29
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
30
Total 96 100,00%
From the table above, the highest percentage is closed compound that is
43,75%. It means that closed compound is the form of compound which mostly
found in the articles. Therefore, the table presented below is about the further
Part of
Compound Suffix Amount Percentage
speech
(-s/-es) 9
(-er) 2
N
(-d) 1
Inflectional (-er) + (-s) 2
40,48%
V (-ed) 1
(-d) 1
Adj
(-ing) 1
Total 17
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
31
the form of structure, there are 17 inflectional compounds with three part of speech;
noun (N), verb (V) and adjective (Adj) from the total closed compound which is 42
compounds with the percentage of 40,48%. There are five suffixes inflected in those
closed compounds such as suffix (-s/-es), suffix (-er), suffix (-d) and (-ed), suffix (-
Part of
Compound Amount Percentage
speech
N 17
Un-inflectional V 3
59,52%
Adj 5
Total 25
based on the form of structure, un-inflectional compound has the highest percentage
that is 59,52% than the inflectional compound that is 40,48%. There are 25
inflectional compounds from the total of 42 closed compounds and noun un-
verb.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
32
Amount
Part of speech
Endocentric Exocentric
N 29 1
V 3 2
Adj 6 1
38 4
Total 90,48% 9,52%
100,00%
only has 4 compounds with the percentage of 9,52%. These findings will be
a. Un-inflectional Compounds
inflected. Un-inflectional compounds just consist of two simple words without any
described in the table below along with the morphological process, the head and
modifier. (Note: slash marker (-) in the head and modifier column represents that
33
UN-INFLECTIONAL COMPOUNDS
PART OF MORPHOLOGICAL
NO SPEECH COMPOUNDS HEAD MODIFIER
PROCESS
1 Childbirth [child]N + [birth]N Birth Child
[childbirth]N
2 Grandfather [grand]ADJ + [father]N Father Grand
[grandfather]N
3 Grandmother [grand]ADJ + [mother]N Mother Grand
[grandmother]N
4 Tracksuit [track]N + [suit]N Suit Track
[tracksuit]N.
5 Dockside [dock]N + [side]N Side Dock
[dockside]N
6 Footage [foot]N + [age]N - -
[footage]N.
7 Storyline [story]N + [line]N Line Story
[storyline]N
8 Masterpiece [master]ADJ + [piece]N Piece Master
[masterpiece]N
9 Hometown [home]N + [town]N Town Home
N
[hometown]N
10 Graveyard [grave]N + [yard]N Grave Yard
[graveyard]N
11 Handicraft [handy]ADJ + [craft]N Craft Handy
[handicraft]N
12 Birthday [birth]N + [day]N Birth Day
[birthday]N
13 Herself [her]PRONOUN + [self]N Self Her
[herself]N
14 Everyday [every]ADJ + [day]N Day Every
[everyday]N
15 Playwright [play]N + [wright]N Wright Play
[playwright]N
16 Wrongdoing [wrong]ADJ + [doing]N Doing Wrong
[wrongdoing]N
17 Lifetime [life]N + Time Life
[time]N[lifetime]N
18 Upheld [up] ADV + [held]V - -
[upheld]V
19 Highlight [high]ADJ + [light]V Light High
V
[highlight]V
20 Foreseen [fore]ADV + [seen]V Seen Fore
[foreseen]V
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
34
PART OF MORPHOLOGICAL
NO SPEECH COMPOUNDS HEAD MODIFIER
PROCESS
21 Household [house]N + [hold]V - -
[household]ADJ
22 Widespread [wide]ADJ + [spread]V Wide Spread
[widespread]ADJ
23 Seaborne [sea]N + [borne]ADJ Borne Sea
Adj [seaborne]ADJ
24 Straightforwar [straight]ADJ + Straight Forward
d [forward]ADV
[straightforward]ADJ
25 Teenage [teen]ADJ + [age]N Teen Age
[teenage]ADJ
All of the un-inflectional compounds in the table 9. are also categorized into
three part of speech; noun, verb and adjective and described the formation using the
compounds presented above have the head in the second member of compound and
b. Inflectional Compounds
the final word. In this analysis the suffix(es) which occur in the compounds are
plural (s/es), suffix (-er), suffix (-ed), suffix (-ing) and combination of suffix (-er)
and (–s). There are seventeen inflectional compounds with these suffixes displayed
afterward with the tree diagrams of each compound to show the formation of the
complex elements.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
35
INFLECTIONAL Part of
NO COMPOUNDS
SUFFIXES speech
1. Spokespersons
2. Bookshops
3. Bookstores
4. Sunglasses
5. Suffix (–s) / (-es) N Soulmates
6. Themselves
7. Mindsets
8. Textbooks
9. Tribesman
10. Filmmaker
Suffix (–r) / (-er) N
11. Housekeeper
16. Policymakers
Double suffixes (–r) and (-s) N
17. Headliners
Table 10. shows that there are seventeen inflectional compounds with five
suffixes attached on each of compound. The most dominant suffix is suffix (-s)/(-
es). The following analysis just takes one or two compounds from the table 10. to
be analyzed that has represented other compounds derived from the same suffix.
All of compounds that are inflected by plural suffix are noun. Some examples
noun. There are three morphemes; (spoke), (person) and plural inflection (-s) which
occurs in both spoke and person. The morphological process of this compound is
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
36
quite different with other ordinary plural words. It has plural inflection not only in
the second member or in the end of the word person(s), but also in the first member.
Spoke(s), which we usually see it as simple past of speak, originally is from spoke
is displayed below:
N [+pℓ ]
N [+pℓ ] Af [+pℓ ]
N [+pℓ ] N
Spokes person s
From the diagram, we can see that compounding is done first while the
inflection of plural affixation takes place later. It is to show that the plural is owned
spokesperson.
The second compound is bookshops. The part of speech of this word is noun.
This compound is made up from three morphemes; (book), (shop) and plural
[bookshops]N, where book and shop, which are noun, form a compound bookshop
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
37
and added by plural (-s). Then, their combination turns into plural noun bookshops
which has meaning of a place of business where book are the main item offered for
N [+pℓ ]
N Af [+pℓ ]
N N
Book shop s
which the compounding is done first in book and shop to form bookshop while the
inflection of plural (-s) takes place later. The inflection of suffix (-s) after the
bookshop, not just the second element, shop(s). Therefore, bookshops as plural noun
The third is sunglasses. It consists of two words; sun and glasses and three
morphemes; (sun), (glass) and plural (-s). The morphological process is stated as
follows: [sun]N + [[glass]N + [-es]]N]N [sunglasses]N where sun and glass are
noun. Unlike the two previous compound, the inflectional process of suffix (-es) in
sunglasses is done first in the second word, glass(es) because glass cannot be
separated with the plural (-es) to create the meaning of glass for eyes. After that,
the compounding of sun and glasses takes place later. Their combination turn into
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
38
noun too, sunglasses which means dark glasses that you wear to protect your eyes
from bright light of the sun. To get better view of the structure, here is the tree
diagram displayed:
N [+pℓ ]
N N [+pℓ ]
N Af [+pℓ ]
Sun glass es
The tree diagram above shows that the suffixation of plural –es occurs first
in the second word glass(es). It is show that the plural (-s) is owned by glasses, then
The same case also happens in the suffix (–r), where all of the compounds
that are inflected by this suffix are noun. One of them is filmmaker. It consists of
three morphemes; (film), (make) and affix (-r). The morphological process of
film and maker are a noun. Maker is produced from the suffixation of (–r) which
occurs first in the second element make (V). The result shows that there is a change
in the part of speech, from verb, make into noun, maker caused by the suffix (-r).
The change aims to create the meaning of maker that is the people of company that
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
39
make something. Therefore, when maker is combined with the other noun, film, it
results a noun also; filmmaker, means someone who is in charge of making film.
To get better view of the structure, here is the tree diagram of filmmaker:
N N
V Aff
Film make -r
From the diagram, we can see that the inflection of (-r) in the verb, make is done
first and the compounding takes place later. The suffix (-r) in this compound is
There are only two compounds that are inflected by suffix (-d) or (-ed). They
are outdated and highlighted. The first is outdated. It consists of three morphemes;
(out), (date) and affix –d. The morphological process of this compound is described
and date is a noun. Their combination results an adjective, outdate which is attached
by the suffix (-ed) to result an adjective too in simple past, outdated which means
40
ADJ
ADJ Af [past]
ADJ N
Out date d
From the tree diagram, we can see that the compounding of outdate is done
first while the suffix (-d) occurs later. In this compound, this suffix is a mark of
morphemes; (high), (light) and affix (-ed). The morphological process of this
adjective and light is a verb. Their combination results a compound, highlight which
later being attached by the suffix (-ed) to create a new compound, highlighted in
the form of simple past. The tree diagram of highlighted is displayed as follows:
V[past]
V Af [past]
ADJ V
41
The tree diagram above also shares similar structure to the previous
compound, outdated, which the compounding of highlight is done first while the
inflection of suffix (-ed) occurs later. Their combination results a new compound
word, highlighted as verb past. The inflection that occurs in the compound shows
that the suffix (-ed) is owned by the whole compound and not the second element
The suffix (-ing) occurs only in the word snowballing which consists of
three morphemes; (snow), (ball) and affix (–ing). The morphological process of this
from the suffixation of (-ing) which occurs in the verb ball. In order to get better
view about the structure of snowballing, the following tree diagram is displayed:
N V
V Af
From the tree diagram above, the affix (–ing) that occurs in the verb, ball is
done first and creates a new verb, balling. After that, the compounding between the
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
42
noun snow and the verb balling is done later which results snowballing as a
transitive verb.
There are not only a single suffix that can occur in the compounds. There
are found also some compounds that are inflected by two suffixes such as suffix (-
r) and (-s). All of the compounds with these double suffixes are noun and one of the
(make), suffix (-er) and suffix (-s) which occur in the second word, makers. The
where both Policy and makers are noun. This compound has double inflections;
suffix (-r) and suffix (-s) which occur first in the second element of this compound,
make. These suffixes cause the change of the part of speech; from verb make into
noun plural makers. Then, it is combined with the other noun, policy and results a
N [+pℓ ]
N Af [+pℓ ]
N N
V Af
43
The tree diagram above describes that suffix (-er) occurs first in the verb
make which results a noun maker. This suffix creates the meaning of person who
does an action. It is then followed by the combination of policy and maker which
suffix (-s) as a plural mark that is more than one person. The result of these
inflectional compounds that are found in the articles. The first is the suffixes that
are attached in the compound. There are suffixes that change the meaning
(inflectional suffixes) of compound and suffixes that do not change the meaning
suffixes is just to mark the plural form and the past tenses, therefore when they are
snowballing. Suffix (–r)/(-er) can change the meaning which refers to people who
does an action while suffix (–ing) can change the meaning of compound as a verb
into an adjective.
The second character is the inflection of compound itself. From the analysis,
there are found two ways where the suffix is inflected, the first is after the
44
2. Meaning of Compounds
a. Endocentric Compound
This following table is to show the compound words that are found with
45
As table 11. has been presented above, noun endocentric compound has the
is followed by adjective 6 compounds and verb 3 compounds. For the analysis, each
category (noun, adjective, and verb) will explain the meaning of all compounds.
All of the meaning of compounds in this analysis is taken from Merriam Webster
1. Childbirth (N)
It is formed from two simple words child (N) and birth (N). Child means a
young person while birth means the time when a baby comes out from the body of
its mother. Their combination results childbirth (N) which means the act or process
of giving birth to children. The head is birth as a noun and it’s modified by the other
It is formed from the words; grand (ADJ) and mother (N), grand (ADJ) and
father (N). Grand means higher and large in degree while father or mother means
a male or female parent. Thus, if these words are combined, the meaning of
becomes the mother of a person’s mother or father. The head is in the noun, father
3. Tracksuit (N)
It is made from two simple words track (N) and suit (N). Track is a noun,
means a sport in which people compete with each other by running a race on a
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
46
specially prepared circular path. Suit also is a noun, means a set of cloths or a piece
This combination create a new meaning of tracksuit; a loose top and trousers, worn
either by people who are training for a sport or exercising, or as informal clothing.
By the meaning of tracksuit, the head of this compound is suit (N) and it is modified
by track (N).
4. Dockside (N)
It is made from the words dock (N) and side (N). Dock is a noun which
means an area of water in a port that can be closed off and that is used for putting
goods onto and taking them off ships or repairing ships. Side also is a noun which
means a place next to something. The head of this compound is side (N) and it’s
modified by dock. The combination of this head and modifier results a noun;
dockside which has new meaning of the area next to a dock where goods can be
stored before being put onto or after being taken off ships.
5. Storyline (N)
It is made from the words story (N) and line (N). Story means a description
either true or imagined of a connected series of event while line means a way of
result a new word with new meaning of storyline that is the plot or the series of
events that happen in book, film, play, etc. The head of this compound is line which
47
6. Masterpiece (N)
It is made from the words master (ADJ) and piece (N). Master itself means
extremely skilled while piece means something that has been created by an artist,
which means a work of art such as painting, film or book that is made by great skill.
The head of this compound is piece (N) and the modifier is master (ADJ).
7. Hometown (N)
It is made from the words home (N) and town (N). Home means someone’s
or something’s origin, or the place where a person feels they belong. Town means
a place where people live or work, containing many houses, shops, places of work,
places of entertainment etc., and usually larger than a village but smaller than a city.
When home and town are combined into hometown, it results a new meaning of the
town or city that a person is from, especially the one in which they were born and
lived while they were young. The head of this compound is town as a noun and it’s
8. Herself (N)
It is made from the words her and self. Her is a pronoun which means
which means the entire person of an individual. Their combination results herself
as a noun which means her own self. It is used as the object of a verb or preposition
to refer to a woman, girl, or female animal that has already been mentioned. The
head of this compound is self and it’s modified by her. Thus, it can be categorized
as a compound noun.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
48
9. Graveyard (N)
It is made from the words grave (N) and yard (N). Grave means a hole in
the ground for burying a dead body while yard means an outdoor area next to a
building that is often bordered. Their combination also results a noun; graveyard
which means a place where people are buried. By the meaning of these two
separated word, it is clear that the head of this compound is grave and it’s modified
by yard.
It is made from the words handy (ADJ) and craft (N). Handy is an adjective
which means clever or skillful in using your hands, doing small jobs, etc. Craft is a
noun which means an activity that involves making something in a skillful way by
using your hands. Their combination turns into noun, handicraft which means an
activity that involves making something in a skillful way by using your hands. The
head of this compound is craft which has the same part of speech with handicraft
It is made from the words birth (N) and day (N). Birth means the time when
a baby comes out from the body of its mother while day means a period of 24 hours
beginning at midnight: one of the seven time periods that make up a week. Their
combination turns into a noun too, birthday which means the day when someone
was born or the anniversary of that day. The head is birth (N) and it’s modified by
49
It is made from the words life (N) and time (N). Life means the experience
of being alive while time means the thing that is measured as seconds, minutes,
hours, days, years, etc. Their combination creates a new noun lifetime which means
the time during which a person is alive. The head is in the noun time and it is
It is made from the words play (V) and wright (N). Play is a noun which
word that refers to a person who constructs or repairs something. The head of this
compound is the second noun, wright which is modified by the first noun, play.
1975), where the origin of spokesman itself is spoke (irregular as noun) + s + -man
which was used in 1510-1520. However, if we look into the meaning of the
separated word, we might find that spoke which is the simple past of speak which
means to say words in order to express your thoughts, feelings, opinions, etc., to
someone : to talk to someone. The word persons means human being considered as
means a man or woman who speaks for or represents someone or something. The
50
These compounds are made from the words; book (N) and shop (N) or stores
(N) which later being inflected by the suffix (s). Book is a noun which means a set
of printed sheets of paper that are held together inside a cover. Shop also is noun
which means a building or room where goods and services are sold while store
means a large shop where you can buy many different types of goods. Their
combination turns into plural noun bookshops and bookstores. These compounds
are quite similar in term of structure and meaning since bookshop is another word
of bookstore which has meaning of a place of business where book are the main
item offered for sale. The head of these compounds are in the second word shops
(N) and stores (N) and modified by the first word book (N).
It is made from the words sun (N) and glasses (N). Sun is a noun, means the
star that provides light and heat for the earth and around which the earth moves.
Glasses is also noun, means two small pieces of specially made glass or transparent
plastic worn in front of the eyes to improve sight and held in place with a frame that
reaches back over the ears Their combination turn into noun too, sunglasses which
means dark glasses that you wear to protect your eyes from bright light of the sun.
The head of this compound is in the noun glasses which is modified by the other
noun sun.
It is made from the words soul (N) and mate (N) which later being inflected
by the suffix (s) to form soulmates. Soul means the part of a person that is not
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
51
physical and experiences deep feelings and emotions while mate means friend. The
combination of both words result a noun also, soulmates which means someone,
usually your romantic or sexual partner, who you have a special relationship with,
and who you know and love very much. The head of this compound is mates and it
It is made from the words them and selves. Them (objective case of they) is
things, animals, situations, or ideas that have already been mentioned. Selves is the
plural form of self as a noun which means the entire person of individual. Their
combination results noun also; themselves which is used as the object of a verb or
preposition to refer to people, animals, or things that have already been mentioned.
The head of this compound is the plural noun selves and it’s modified by the
pronoun them.
It is made from the word mind (N) and set (N) which later being inflected
by the suffix (s) to form mindsets. Mind means the part of a person that thinks,
reasons, feels, and remembers while set means mental inclination, tendency, or
habit. Their combination produce a noun; mindsets which means a particular way
of thinking: a person's attitude or set of opinions about something. The head of this
compound is sets (N) and it’s modified by mind. This is the reason that the
compound, mindsets has the same part of speech with the head of itself.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
52
It is made from the words text (N) and book (N) which later being inflected
by the suffix (s) to form textbooks. Text means the original words of a piece of
writing or a speech while book(s) means a set of printed sheets of paper that are
held together inside a cover: a long written work. Their combination create a new
noun word; textbooks which means a book about a particular subject that is used in
the study of that subject especially in a school.the head of this compound is books
It is made from the words tribes (N) and man (N). Tribes is noun which
means a group of people that includes many families and relatives who have the
same language, customs, and beliefs. Man also is a noun which mean an adult male
human being. Their combination results a new noun word, tribesman which means
from tribe + ‘s + -man which has been used in 1790-1800. That is the reason suffix
(–s) occurs in the middle of the word tribesman not tribemen. The head of this
It is made from the words film (N) and maker (N). Film is a noun which
often telling story. Maker is also a noun which means the people of company that
make something. The combination of both nouns result a noun also; filmmaker,
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
53
means someone who is in charge of making film. The head of this compound is the
It is made from the words house (N) and keeper (N). House means a building
in which a family lives while keeper means a person whose job is to guard or take
cleaning, etc. The head of this compound is keeper (N) and it’s modified by house
(N).
It is made from the words under (PREP) and privileged (ADJ). Under is a
advantages that most people do not have. Even though underprivileged is formed
be able to open schools for women and the underprivileged.”), which is the polite
word for poor people. Through the meaning of underprivileged, it can be concluded
that it is a compound noun despite the head of this compound is privileged which
performs as an adjective. In this case, the meaning of the whole compound based
it is considered.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
54
It is made from the words wrong (ADJ) and doing (N). Wrong is an adjective
which means not correct while doing is a noun which means to be done or caused
by someone. Even though we might look that doing is the result from a suffixation
of do (V) plus (-ing), it cannot be separated into two elements because it is seen as
a whole word, noun. Their combination turns into noun wrongdoing, means a bad
or an illegal action. The head of this compound is in its noun, doing and the modifier
It is made from the words policy (N) and maker (N) which later being
inflected by the suffix (-s) to form policymakers. Policy is a noun which means a
party, or a group of people. Makers also is noun which means the people or machine
that make something. Their combination also results noun, policymakers; a member
for making new rules, laws, etc. The head of this compound is in the second noun
It is made from the words head (N) and line (N) which later being inflected
by the suffix (-r) and suffix (-s) to form headliners. Head means the liners or
performers which becomes the head. Line means a long narrow mark on a surface.
However, when they are combined into headline (V), it means to be a main
performer in a show or concert. Thus, the inflection of suffix (-r) create this
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
55
the noun, headliners which means the main performer in a show or concert. The
head of this compound is liners (N) while the modifier is the first word head.
It is made from the words teen (ADJ) and age (N). Teen is an adjective and
age is a noun. Teen is another word of teenage in informal while age means the
period of time someone has been alive or something has existed. The meaning of
teenage (as an adjective) itself is being, or relating to people in their teens (between
13 to 19 years old). The head of this compound is teen (ADJ) and it’s modified by
It is made from the words wide (ADJ) and spread (V). Wide is an adjective
which means used to describe something that includes a large amount or many
different types of thing, or that covers a large range or area. Spread is a verb which
means to (cause to) cover, reach, or have an effect on a wider or increasing area.
Their combination results a new word and new meaning of widespread; that is
common over a wide area or among many people. The head of this compound is
It is made from the words sea (N) and borne (ADJ). Sea is a noun which
means the salt water that covers much of the Earth's surface. Borne is an adjective
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
56
seaborne which means carried in a ship sailing across the sea. The head is the
It is made from the words straight (ADJ) and forward (ADV). Straight is
an adjective which means not having curves, bends, or angles. Forward is an adverb
which means toward the front, to or toward what is ahead or in front. The
word, it can be analyzed that the head of straightforward is straight as the adjective
It is made from the words out (ADV) and dated (ADJ). Out is an adverb
adjective which means coming from or belonging to a time in the past or old-
fashioned. Their combination produces new word with new meaning that is
current. In this compound, this adjective performs as the head which is modified by
It is made from the words every (ADJ) and day (N). Every is an adjective
which means including each person or thing in a group or series. Day is a noun
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
57
which means day means a period of 24 hours beginning at midnight: one of the
seven time periods that make up a week. Their combination turns into an adjective,
everyday which is used or seen every day: suitable for every day. The part of speech
of the compound is just the same as the head; every (ADJ). The adjective is modified
It is made from the words fore (ADV) and seen (V). Fore is an adverb
which means at an earlier time or period while seen is the past participle of see
foreseen, means to know about something before it happens. The head of this
compound is seen as the verb and its modifier is fore as the adverb.
It is made from the words high (ADJ) and light (V). High is an adjective
which means having power, an important position or great influence while light is
a verb which means to produce light that makes an object or area bright or easy to
see. Their combination results highlight as a verb which means to make or try to
make people notice, easy to see and know or be aware of (someone or something):
58
It is made from the words high (N) and light (V) which later being inflected by
the suffix (-ed) as simple past marker. High is an adjective which means having
produce light that makes an object or area bright or easy to see. When they are
combined and attached by the suffix (-ed) it results highlighted which means to
attention to (someone or something). The head of this compound is in the verb, light
b. Exocentric Compounds
meaning with the elements of the compound or the word combination. Therefore,
exocentric compounds also do not head and modifier that can be identified through
1. Footage (N)
It is made from the words foot (N) and age (N). Foot is noun which means
the part of the body at the bottom of the leg on which a person or animal stands.
Age also is a noun which means the period of time someone or something has been
alive. The combination of both nouns results a noun also, footage; a piece of film
especially one showing an event. If we look at the meaning of each separated words
between foot and age, there is no any relation when they are written as one
independent word footage. It is not the age of someone’s foot or how many time
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
59
the foot has been alive, but footage is scenes on film that shows a particular events.
whole compound do not take from the meaning of at least one member of its
compound.
2. Household (ADJ)
It is made from the words house (N) and hold (V). House is a noun which
means family while hold is a verb simple past of held which means to take and keep
something in your hand or arms. Their combination forms a new word with new
meaning; household as an adjective. It is not about to take or keep the family or the
exocentric compound.
3. Upheld (V)
It is made from the words up (ADV) and held (V). Up is an adverb and held
is a verb. Up means in a high position while held which is the simple past of hold
means to take and keep something in your hand or arms. Their combination creates
new word, upheld as a verb, with new meaning. It does not mean to hold up or hold
in high position but it means to support or defend (something, such as a law). It can
be seen in the sentence where upheld appears: “…the law was upheld by the Court
even though child marriage largely leads to disruption of the constitutional right to
education.” This sentence means that the marriage law was supported by the court.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
60
It seems that upheld has no correlation meaning from the word combination up and
held. The meaning of the whole compound is not determinable from the head which
is held (V) and the modifier, up (ADV). Thus, it can be categorized as exocentric
compound.
4. Snowballing (V)
It is made from the words snow (N) and ball (V) which later being inflected
by the suffix (-ing) after the compounding. Snow means soft, white pieces of frozen
water that fall to the ground from the sky in cold weather while ball means to make
into a ball. When these two separated words are combined and added by (-ing) in
the final, the meaning is not to make snow into a ball shape or round like a ball but
snowballing (V) means to increase or grow at a faster and faster rate. If we take a
CHAPTER V
CONCLUSION
that have been answered in the analysis result and discussion. From the distribution
of the data, there are forty two (42) closed compound words found in the seven
articles related to Kartini Day in the Jakarta Post 2016 and 2017. This compound
has the highest percentage 43,74% than the two other which are 22,91% of open
formation is not only using morphological process but also the tree diagram to
The analysis based on the form of the compounding structure shows that
there are twenty five (25) or 59,52% compounds which are formed from two simple
which have suffix(s) in the final words or inflectional compounds. It means that un-
There are five kinds of suffixes inflected in the compounds; nine (9) compounds
61
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
62
with suffix (-s/-es), two (2) compounds with suffix (-r/-er), three (3) compounds
with suffix (-d/-ed), one (1) compound with suffix (-ing) and two (2) compounds
with double suffix (-r) and (-s). From the inflection of these suffixes, there are found
that the inflections are done in two ways; first is after the compounding and second
endocentric compound has the highest result that is 38 compounds or 90,48% than
the exocentric that is 4 compounds or 9,52%. It concludes that the most exist
telling the fact and compound words that are used also should have the literal
compounds.
verb or compound adjective. In the analysis, compounds noun are mostly found in
the article which are twenty seven (27) compounds while compound adjective has
seven (7) compounds and compound verb has three (3) compounds.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
BIBLIOGRAPHY
63
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
64
APPENDICES
65
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
66
67
Meanwhile, modern feminist groups reclaim her as the representation of the early
Indonesian feminist, who was not only concerned about women’s issues, but also
about the struggle for the independence from Dutch colonialism.
Before colonialization, women appeared to have access to high status. The historian
Cora Vreede-De Stuers shows that Acehnese women participated in local forces to
combat Dutch rule, while many Javanese women became leaders. The modern
economy, alongside Western education, significantly transformed society. The
historian Denys Lombard asserts that the emergence of ports, urban society and
Islam further limited women’s roles. Some local traditions also restricted women
from enjoying equal opportunities with men.
Motherhood, being child bearers and child educators gave women a reason to be
involved in public life, increasing their importance in preparing the next generation
for the nation’s progress. Hence, motherhood became a vehicle of empowerment.
In one of her letters, Kartini wrote that Europe was the center of civilization and
advancement. However, as a female native living under colonial oppression, Kartini
witnessed injustice and exploitation, as noted by literary scholar Katrin Bandel.
Furthermore, her interest in Western knowledge coincided with her love and respect
for her family and nation. Consequently, although she was fascinated with the
advancement of women’s rights in the West, she could not entirely detach herself
from either Javanese culture or Islamic values. Some resources even indicated that
she was a disciple of famous Islamic scholar K. Saleh Darat as-Samarani (1820-
1903).
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
68
Unlike the modern feminist notion, Kartini instead emphasized that the
empowerment of Indonesian women could not simply be separated from their roles
of mother and husband. In a letter she highlighted the importance of women and
motherhood. “It is from women that humans receive their first education — on a
woman’s lap, a child gradually learns to feel, think and speak; I came to realize
more and more that the effect of the first education is not insignificant to human
life ...”
In line with the concept of “maternal feminism” cited by the scholar Elisabeth
Locher-Scholten, Kartini thus followed the Javanese gender ideal of being a wife a
mother working together with her husband to educate her children, to prepare the
next generation. In this context, women’s empowerment also should not conflict
with a harmonious marriage.
Kartini thus believed that, “God created women to be men’s partners, and their
ultimate purpose in life is to have a husband… I gladly declare that women’s
ultimate happiness for now and the next centuries will be to live harmoniously with
men!” Kartini clearly reappropriated women’s empowerment discourse to fit the
dominant ideologies, such as Islam, nationalism and the Javanese ideal of being a
woman.
Sadly, in 1903, Kartini was forced to marry the regent of Rembang and became his
fourth wife. She passed away after giving birth to her first child. Yet her figure
remains an example of the fluidity of cultural discourses and how feminist discourse
in Indonesia cannot be separated from its interactions with local aspects. It is no
exaggeration to say that Kartini is a national figure with a transnational mind.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
69
By: Missiyah
Executive Director of Kapal Perempuan (Women’s Ship) Institute
Jakarta Fri, April 22, 2016
Stand up for the rights -- School children take part in a peaceful rally to call for a
greater state protection on the rights of Indonesian children in Semarang, Central
Java, in December 2015. Home Minister Tjahjo Kumolo said on Monday all
children in Indonesia will have an identity card with a single number, which will
remain valid throughout their lifetime. (Tempo/-)
For hundreds of years, women have been struggling to seize their rights, through
organizing themselves and galvanizing a women’s movement to push for better
government policies, among other things.
However, many women, particularly those from poor rural families, are still
vulnerable to dropping out of school, giving them no other option but to settle for
work in the informal sector, leaving them exposed to violence.
Denied of protection and security, they can work up to 15 hours a day for only
meager wages and are still expected to do household work. The 2013 Social
Barometer Survey revealed women are 1.5 times more likely to earn wages lower
than Rp 500,000 (US$38.07) per month, compared with men. Given this situation,
what is the significance of Indonesia’s position as the only permanent ASEAN
member in the G-20, and the optimism that it will be one of the world’s seven
largest economies in the next ten years?
Amid the continued economic growth and rapid development, women remain poor.
One factor that perpetuates this cycle among women is child marriage.
One woman in East Lombok, for instance, studied only until second grade and was
married at 15. Her two children fared a little better; yet the cycle of poverty may
continue for them as with her earnings as a vendor, she only managed to send them
to junior high school. As a single parent she tried to avoid the local stigma against
widows, and remarried four times. All marriages failed, she said, owing to
unfaithful husbands and domestic violence.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
70
This was just one story shared in sessions of Sekolah Perempuan (informal
Women’s School, facilitated by NGOs) which have been held in Pangkajene islands
in South Sulawesi, Gresik in East Java, Jakarta, Kupang in East Nusa Tenggara,
Padang in West Sumatra, and other areas.
Unlike these poor women the heroine RA Kartini, born on April 21, 1879, was from
a noble family; but was similarly unable to go against her parents, and was forced
to enter a polygamous marriage. Since her teenage years she had already tried to
resist what was then seen as the inevitable fate for girls, and continued to fight for
girls’ right to education.
According to a 2014 World Bank study, inequality in Indonesia has worsened and
it is girls who are bearing the brunt. Children from poor families fall back into
poverty as 71 percent of them are likely to drop out of high school. An earlier 2007
study on education by E-net for Justice, a coalition of NGOs, already showed the
dropout rate in poor families reached 77.85 percent.
When the Millennium Development Goals expired in 2015, Indonesia had failed to
meet the goal of reducing maternal mortality to 108 per 100,000 live births — which
were traced to a high rate of child marriage, as well as poor access to safe pregnancy
and delivery services.
Child marriage here rema ins widespread; we rank second among Southeast Asian
countries in terms of the number of early marriages. According to the 2010 Basic
Health Research, child marriage in Indonesia accounts for 46.7 percent of all
marriages.
However, apart from failing to attract wide attention, 137 years after Kartini, whose
birthday we commemorate each year as Kartini Day, we also see resistance against
the fight to end child marriage. Under the pretext of culture, religion and morality,
the issue is conveniently swept under the carpet. The state continues to endorse
child marriage through the 1974 Marriage Law, which sets the legal minimum
marrying age for girls at 16, while it is 19 for boys.
A Constitutional Court ruling last year turned down a judicial review request of the
1974 Marriage Law. Though advocates for females had urged the minimum
marrying age be increased to 18, the law was upheld by the Court even though child
marriage largely leads to disruption of the constitutional right to education.
The Court said an increased marriage age would not guarantee a reduction in health
problems and divorce. It disregarded Article 31of the Constitution, which states,
“every citizen should receive mandatory basic education and the government must
take responsibility for its financing”.
Marriage of children under 18 also flouts the National Development Priorities that
explicitly stipulates 12 years of compulsory basic education. Apart from violating
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
71
the 2003 education law, child marriage contravenes the 1999 Human Rights Law,
and the 1984 ratification of the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of
Discrimination against Women.
It also violates the 2002 law on child protection that states that a child is anyone
under the age of 18, and other international commitments, as well as the recently
adopted Sustainable Development Goals.
If President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo’s mental revolution aims to create a new life
for the nation, changing mindsets and cultural and political practices are a must to
reconstruct a new life for children, especially girls, as the foundation of our future.
Let’s not leave half of tomorrow’s generation stuck in the trap of poverty. Child
marriage must immediately be ended by transforming mindsets and shedding
conservative views that legitimize the practice.
It is now time for the House of Representatives to revise the outdated 1974 marriage
law and the education law to guarantee children’s right to education through the 12-
year compulsory education policy. Such a move would be a decisive step to break
the chains of poverty in Indonesia.
In the early 20th century, a woman not yet 20 years old, named Kartini, thought a
lot about the people of her time, especially women.
Not long ago came the sad news on the death of a young woman from a village in
the West Java regency of Karawang, a 29-year-old dangdut singer named Irma
Bule, who left behind three children.
She died after being bitten by a poisonous snake during a performance. Irma Bule
worked hard, singing from village to village, with a snake as a gimmick.
It appears she used the snake, not only as an extra attraction to her performance, but
also to keep audience members, usually men, at bay.
72
As an activist working with maids and their families for several years, I have seen
the horrors they suffer: rejected by hospitals because they had no money, scarred
for life by the cruelty of employers, sources of profit for the hordes of “agents”
shipping them overseas.
Then there are the thousands working for a pittance at malls, hotels, cafes and
beauty salons.
I witnessed close the lines of aching backs and fingers of hundreds of young women
slaving for less than the minimum wage in factories on the edge of Jakarta, on so-
called “long shifts”, scared even of asking permission to go to the toilet.
__________________________________
Kartini Day celebrations are meaningless […] if Irma Bule is ignored.
And many, like Irma, end up forced into the dark alleys of prostitution and even
become victims of trafficking.
That is the fate of most women in the real Indonesia. The feminism that focuses
only on a slogan demanding “the freedom to be me” won’t resonate among that
majority.
The freedom they seek is from structural abuse and exploitation, from poverty and
sexism that poverty, and the exhaustion it can cause, forces them to endure. I do not
mean to be pessimistic about the future of Indonesian women. However, real
change will only happen if we face reality honestly.
Kartini was designated a national hero by Sukarno in 1964. Since then, every April
21, Kartini’s birthday, the country is invited to celebrate the “the success” of
Indonesian women.
In celebrations, women and girls are paraded in a kebaya blouse, their hair in a
sanggul or traditional bun, or they join competitions like cooking. Today, there are
often also fashion shows or discounts at malls for those women with the money to
enjoy consumerism.
But who was Kartini and what did she think? Indonesian men and women living
under the New Order regime know little about her.
The beautiful and sharp writings of this heroine are still not taught at school with
any seriousness, just as the real, everyday work and social situation of most women
is never seriously discussed.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
73
Any idealization of Kartini, without adequate discussion of what she struggled for,
collides with everyday reality, as experienced by Irma Bule and by the hundreds of
thousands of women migrant workers and the tens of millions of others living in
poverty or just above it.
Or where they are present, they are used for distorted symbolic purposes. The
National Awakening Party ( PAN ) recently elevated another dangdut singer,
Zaskia Gotik, as their ambassador to promote the state ideology of Pancasila.
Then the Defense Ministry, not wanting to be outdone, appointed her as a doctor
for the so-called Pancasila Clinic. Zaskia is renowned for two things. One was her
“sexy duck wiggle” which has catapulted her to fame and earned her celebrity
status. The other was her notoriety after answering a question on Pancasila saucily,
incurring criticism for being disrespectful. Asked about the symbol on the national
emblem representing the fifth principle of social justice, she answered “a duck
bending over”.
Politicians and state officials are easily smitten with the popularity of a celebrity (
usually female ones ) who they then make spokespersons on important issues. It is
the gimmick of hypocrisy.
Kartini Day celebrations are meaningless if the real situation of most women is not
addressed, if Irma Bule is ignored.
Such celebrations will only turn into hypocrisy when most women are still
entangled in poverty, when they face great risks of death during childbirth due to
lack of nutrition and a lack of access to health care.
Also, the actual words and ideas of Kartini must be made available, especially to
women and young people. It would not at all be beyond the government’s means to
reprint on a massive scale Kartini’s collection of letters titled Habis Gelap Terbitlah
Terang ( Out of darkness into light ) and distribute the collection to all schools and
sell it cheaply in bookshops.
The manipulation of Kartini and of women as a symbol must end. The real Kartini
must be studied. The real life of the majority of women must be understood.
Perhaps getting the state to help achieve Article Five of Pancasila, namely social
justice for all the Indonesian people, including women, is going to need us, women
and man to act together.
The writer is a playwright, a theater producer and director and the founder of
Institut Ungu ( Purple Institute, Women’s Art and Cultural Space ).
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
74
75
This year marks 71 years of independence for Indonesia, which begs the
question: How long does it take for a nation to build a strong library of national
literature? The answer: It depends. Development of a nation’s literature depends on
intent, the education system, the motivation of individual writers, the accessibility
of publication processes and the value of intellectual property.
To be fair, there are several internationally known contemporary Indonesian
authors; Dorothea Rosa Herliany, Dewi Lestari, Linda Christanty, Andrea Hirata,
Laksmi Pamuntjak and Leila Chudori.
Meanwhile, the literature of Pramoedya Ananta Toer (2006) and Mochtar Lubis
(2004) continues to live on.
Yet, thousands of stories remain untold, stories that are crying out to be heard,
that need to be recorded in order to construct and share a rich tapestry of Indonesian
culture.
In honor of Kartini, the writer, Indonesians need to write. Is there a book you
wish you could read but does not yet exist? Do you have information or a unique
perspective you want to share with others? Write it. We are living in the present
moment, but this moment will quickly become the history of our future. Writing
allows us to preserve our stories, to share them with our contemporaries as well as
those who will come after us.
As we celebrate the legacy of futuristic writer Kartini, let us encourage parents
and teachers to give Indonesia energetic, intelligent young writers, to rise of
national literature will only be a matter of time.
76
Ken has heard about Buru Island since she was little from her father’s stories.
“My dad told me stories about what happened in the prison. The food they ate
[or lack thereof], how he and his friends were treated [or mistreated] and the songs
they sung,” the 34-year-old said.
She said her father’s experiences were so central to her family that they became
part of her. In fact, it was probably her father’s stories that helped her live a normal
childhood. She told the Post her childhood was not hard, as she “didn’t feel anything
in particular”.
“It may sound strange, but I can’t really imagine my childhood without those
stories, and I cannot imagine myself not being the daughter of a former political
prisoner. It’s just who I am,” Ken said.
She wrote for an online publication that she was proud to be the daughter of a
political prisoner.
“When I was 6 years old, I told my classmates: ‘My Dad went to jail […] for
nothing!’ — and I was proud,” she wrote.
Ken’s story is different from the tragic accounts shared by many family
members of victims from 1965, who have suffered from discrimination and
mistreatment from society and the government, forcing them to cover up their real
identities.
Born in 1981, Ken spent her childhood in Jakarta, until she was 6 years old. The
family then moved to the Netherlands after Ken’s mother, Dutch writer Jitske
Mulder, became terminally ill.
“My parents feared that if she passed away in Indonesia […] there would be no
one there to protect me, after all, as an ex-political prisoner my father could be
arrested at any time,” she said, adding that her mother passed away in 1989.
The decision to move was also made to secure Ken’s future. Her parents
believed that by living in the Netherlands, Ken would be able to access a good
education more easily.
Growing up in a family where human rights issues are a topic of interest has
influenced Ken’s study interests. Besides studying human rights, she was also an
active youth member of Amnesty International.
“I wrote letters urging governments to release prisoners of conscience and to
abolish the death penalty. I was interested in other areas where I saw injustice, such
as access to education [particularly for girls], access to clean water and
deforestation,” she said.
Her parents’ friend told her recently that as a child she had once aspired to
become a human rights lawyer. Well, Ken may not be a human rights lawyer, but
she has chosen a career path that still promotes the same ideas, but as a researcher
and lecturer.
Ken launched her academic career as a research and teaching associate at Leiden
University in 2005 after obtaining a master’s degree from the same university.
Her career expanded as she started teaching in other universities Down Under.
Her CV includes teaching experiences at Australian National University in
Canberra and Australian Catholic University and the University of Melbourne, both
in Melbourne.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
77
She obtained a PhD in law from Leiden University for her research on national
human rights commissions in Indonesia and Malaysia, and her final thesis has been
published into a book.
Starting 2015, she became a fellow for the prestigious McKenzie Postdoctoral
Program at the University of Melbourne. She now resides in Melbourne with her
small family.
Despite having an established career as an academic, it seems that Ken still can’t
move on from her family’s past.
Therefore, she has initiated a blog, living1965.org, to share her story and those
of others that are affected by the 1965 tragedy. She runs the blog with artist Tintin
Wulia, who lost her grandfather in that darkest of periods in Indonesian history.
“We talk about our families’ pasts and what they mean to us,” she said.
Through her profession and her blog, Ken wants to continuously bring
discussion on the 1965 massacre into the public domain to remind the government
of its homework — that is, to resolve this human rights issue.
“There’s still so much resistance, from within the government and state bodies,
as well as from societal groups that keep denying any wrongdoing and refusing to
face the past,” she said.
But those disheartening attitudes do not stop Ken from moving forward in her
fight for justice for the 1965 victims. She keeps revealing the truth behind the
tragedy, including to her two children.
“I think it’s important not only to understand what happened to my father and
therefore our family, but also to understand other injustices in the world,” Ken said.
Film director Hanung Bramantyo might not have foreseen that his new film Kartini
would be in resonance with the snowballing ideas on women’s resistance in the
country, which gained momentum on National Women’s Day in December amid
heightening pluralism and religious intolerance.
When he started two years ago, cowriting the script based on extensive
documentary and field research, his purpose was merely to present the true story of
a young lady from a noble Javanese family whose progressive ideas on equality and
the right of women to be educated at the turn of the 20th century led her to be named
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
78
a national heroine for female emancipation and to her birth date on April 21 to be
commemorated as Kartini’s Day.
However, the film revealed much more than what was written in school history
textbooks.
Kartini was not the first slice-of-life film about the rebellious princess of coastal
Jepara, Central Java, but by far it was the only one that explored her wide spectrum
of interests and her influences.
Hanung was eager to put in the movie the issues of the family in which Trinil —
the childhood name Kartini was affectionately called – was brought up, her relations
with her siblings, her biological mother and her father’s wife.
As the film focuses on Kartini’s life as she reached the proper age for marriage —
which traditionally was right after she had her first menstrual period — it follows
the titular character’s struggle in realizing her objectives to study abroad and to see
the world beyond the walls of her palace, her place of confinement.
She negotiates and compromises with her father and other older male members of
the family to be able to play on the beach, to continue her relationships with her
Dutch friends and later with her would-be husband in a pre-arranged marriage to be
able to open schools for women and the underprivileged.
Hanung also inserted Kartini’s ideas to expose to the world the wood carving art of
Jepara, the region’s signature handicraft for which it is known today, as well as her
understanding of Islam and her suggestion to translate the Quran into the vernacular
Javanese language so that people could avoid committing sins in the name of
religion out of false interpretations.
With all that crammed into a 119-minute duration it’s understandable that conflict
is tense from the beginning and that some narration that influenced the character’s
development is excluded.
From the title it’s obvious that Hanung adapted Pramoedya Ananta Toer’s novel
Panggil Aku Kartini Saja (Just Call Me Kartini) that tells how Kartini was
determined to abandon her noble title Raden Ajeng while her biological mother
Ngasirah’s status was reduced to the level of housekeeper after her father Raden
Mas Adipati Ario Sosroningrat, the regent of Jepara, was married to a noble lady,
Raden Ayu Moerjam.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
79
In the film, however, it’s not told that Ngasirah (Christine Hakim) was the daughter
of an Islamic preacher.
A glaring fact that Kartini was a teenage prodigy who spoke and wrote fluent Dutch
and had high curiosity with a knack of climbing walls with her two sisters Kardinah
and Roekmini could not be seen on screen.
Her close relations with his brother Sosrokartono (Reza Rahadian), who at that time
was studying in the Netherlands, in the film was mostly reflected in the package of
books he sent to the three sisters.
The director has a few biopics under his belt, namely 2010’s Sang Pencerah (The
Enlightened One) about Ahmad Dahlan, the founder of the second largest Muslim
organization in Indonesia, Muhammadiyah, and 2013’s Soekarno: Indonesia
Merdeka (Independent Indonesia) about the founding president and a series on the
third president, BJ Habibie.
In theaters since April 19, the film can be seen as a fun alternative to the history
books that tries to look both inward and outside the walls that sent Kartini’s soul
wandering to another continent, but have remained relevant at home until today.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
80
2. Understanding Kartini
By: A. Kurniawan Ulung
When words are not enough to understand Kartini, photos and film may explain
better.
Legendary actress Christine Hakim has conquered a wide range of roles across
dozens of films since beginning her career in 1973, but still faced challenges playing
MA Ngasirah, the mother of Indonesian heroine Raden Ajeng Kartini.
Directed by Hanung Bramantyo, the biopic film Kartini forced Christine to restrain
her ego to adapt to her role as Ngasirah, Jepara regent Ario Sosroningrat’s
concubine, who faced unfair treatment because she was not from a noble family.
“As a cast member, this was the first time I felt I was a slave,” she said, laughing.
Christine, and some of her fellow Kartini cast members, revealed the behind-the-
scene stories of the film during the book launch of Di Balik Layar Film Kartini:
Kumpulan Foto dan Cerita (Behind the Scenes of Kartini: A Collection of Photos
and Stories) at the Galeri Indonesia Kaya auditorium in Grand Indonesia shopping
mall in Central Jakarta.
Published by Grasindo, the book contains 115 behind-thescene photos and stories
from the film-making process, which took 45 days to complete.
During the launch, Christine, actresses Acha Septriasa and Ayu Diah Pasha as well
as singer Gita Gutawa read the letters of Kartini, an icon of female emancipation.
Through her letters, Kartini, who was born to an aristocratic Javanese family in
Jepara, Central Java in 1879, spoke of the prevailing social conditions, particularly
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
81
discrimination against women, in her country, which was then known as the Dutch
East Indies.
She believed that women also deserved the right to study and be involved in public
life, thoughts deemed unusual at the time.
Kartini, who dreamed of studying in the Netherlands and establishing schools for
women, also expressed her disapproval of polygamy in her letters. However, when
her parents arranged her marriage to Rembang regent Djojo Adhiningrat, who
already had three wives, she acquiesced, a decision that still sparks controversy
today.
Kartini, who died in 1904 at the age of 25 after giving birth to her first child, was
declared a national heroine by the late president Sukarno in 1964.
For Ayu, Kartini deserves the title. In her view, Kartini sacrificed herself by
accepting the marriage with the regent in order to benefit many other people. By
becoming the regent’s wife, she would have the power to establish schools for
women.
“[Before the wedding], she stipulated three conditions. First, she wanted to be
allowed to continue her studies in Batavia. Second, she wanted the freedom to do
what she wanted. Third, she wanted to be allowed to open schools for indigenous
women,” Ayu said.
Before Hanung, other directors had already brought the story of Kartini to the big
screen, namely Sjuman Djaja with RA Kartini in 1982 and Azhar Lubis with Surat
Cinta Untuk Kartini (Love Letter to Kartini) in 2016.
“Kartini must be played by someone who is not only an actress but also an icon.
When we met Dian for the first time, we felt she was the perfect fit to be Kartini.
She adores her and already understands her thoughts,” said Robert Ronny, the CEO
of Legacy Pictures.
The idea to produce Kartini came to his mind when he met Hanung in 2014. Before
the production started, his team conducted two years of research.
“After researching for two years, we discovered many surprising things about
Kartini that people do not know,” he said. “Kartini was a tomboy. She was
advanced, structured and modern. We want to highlight this side of her in this film.”
Acha, who plays Roekmini, the younger sister of Kartini, said that she was over the
moon when cast to star in Kartini in December 2015, especially because she would
get the opportunity to work with her idol, Dian.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
82
“I wanted to become a movie star ever since watching Dian’s movie in 2002,” she
said.
Acha said she read Kartini’s letters to explore her role as Roekmini, who always
defended her older sister.
“Roekmini was a thinker, who was open-minded and humble, but she rarely talked,”
she said. “She always defended her sister and her thoughts.”
Christine hopes that Kartini, which hit theaters on April 19, will help people gain a
better understanding of history.
She admitted that before taking part in the movie, she thought Kartini had failed to
fight for her ideas, especially after tying the knot with the Rembang regent.
“To be honest, I did not adore Kartini. She was not my inspiration. But, later I
realized that I was wrong. This film has changed my views on her,” she said.
Herlina Kasim (right) with former president Sukarno (second right). (Rigel
Wahyu Nugroho/File)
Herlina Kasim was Kartini with a gun — bold, brave and determined to compete in
traditional male areas. First journalism, then the military.
She was the only woman parachuted into the Papuan jungle behind the colonialists’
lines. This was during the 1961 to 1962 Trikora (Tri Komando Rakyat — a strategy
for mobilizing the nation) campaign led by general Soeharto, who later became the
republic’s second president.
83
Then she astonished the nation again by giving the prize back to the palace.
She explained her gesture by saying that fighting for her country was honor enough
and that the state needed the money for development.
When she died earlier this year from diabetic complications aged 75, her passing,
unfortunately, was little noticed.
As a feminist she was far ahead of her time, a tomboy before the term became
acceptable. In early photos she looks selfassured as though wearing khaki was as
natural as a floral dress. In one group, she audaciously thrusts hands in pockets.
Herlina was born in Malang, East Java, in 1941, the third of six children. Only one
was a boy. After completing basic high school in Jakarta, she left home in search
of adventure in the Moluccas. It’s not known why she wanted to put about 3,500
kilometers between herself and her family.
In Ternate, she worked as a journalist on a weekly paper and got involved in anti-
colonialism campaigns. It was a time of gross chauvinism.
Emboldened by shipments of Russian weapons and the backing of so-called
nonaligned states, Sukarno started Trikora to wrest Irian Jaya, now called Papua,
from the Dutch. Western diplomats thought the real purpose was to divert attention
from a collapsing economy.
Volunteers were sought to fight behind enemy lines. Herlina offered her services
and must have had a silver tongue because she persuaded the generals that girls
could also be guerrillas.
This was decades before women became active combatants in Western nations,
with restrictions remaining in some armies. Last year, the United States finally
announced that all roles were open to females. In Indonesia, women in the armed
forces are usually assigned to administrative and welfare duties.
After minimal training Herlina was parachuted into Irian Jaya along with 19 men.
Like an earlier seaborne assault that turned into a rout, the drop was not a
professional operation. She missed her target, was knocked unconscious and
regained consciousness in a field of mud. She then set out to find her companions,
not knowing some had been killed.
After a week of fruitless wanderings and with supplies running low, she met local
tribesmen and was led to a fishing village. Three weeks later, Herlina was ferried
to an Indonesian island. She hadn’t fired a shot or seized territory.
Trikora cost 400 Indonesian and 126 Dutch lives, but it showed that Indonesia was
serious about recovering colonial territory and the Dutch no longer had the stomach
for war. Under international pressure, they ceded the province to the United
Nations. In a later referendum, selected Irian leaders voted to join Indonesia.
By then Herlina had left active duty. For a while she worked in Jakarta as an
educator in the Women’s Army Corps, then as a press secretary in the foreign affairs
ministry. There are reports that she was involved in a fake news campaign during
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
84
Konfrontasi when Sukarno sent the Army to oppose the creation of Malaysia, but
these can’t be confirmed.
She also married and had two sons, Rigel Wahyu Nugroho (born 1962), who is now
a trader, and five years later Aurigea Bima Sakti who works as a commercial pilot.
Both men live in Malaysia.
“My mom had a very strong character,” Rigel said by phone and email. “She was
disciplined, straightforward, yet a very humble person. She liked to help people,
especially the poor.
“She hardly ever wore her Army uniform, but didn’t tell me why. She didn’t care
much about her rank — not like others.
“After she left the Army she was involved in a few businesses, as well as social
work together with my dad Harkomoyo. (When Rigel was 9 his parents divorced.
His mother later remarried, but had no more children).”
“In the early 1970s, she got involved in sports and built the Caprina Soccer Club.
Again, it was not for business, but for social activities. It was very successful.”
“I think my mom was the only women who had a soccer team in Indonesia and
maybe in the world.”
Nationally, Herlina kept a low profile until 2011 and the 50th anniversary of
Trikora. She reportedly asked president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono to change the
name of Papua back to Irian.
It seems her motive was to negate the influence of the Free Papua Movement (OPM)
because she believed its independence campaign damaged the reputation of Trikora.
Irian Jaya became Papua in 2002.
Herlina was laid to rest in Jakarta. Her family was offered a place in a heroes’
cemetery, but she had requested an ordinary plot in a public graveyard. To the end,
she stayed determined to do things her way.