Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Crispian Scully1
T
his series of five papers summarises some of the
most important oral medicine problems likely to be
encountered by practitioners.
Some are common, others rare. The practitioner cannot
be expected to diagnose all, but has been trained to
recognise oral health and disease, and should be
competent to recognise normal variants, and common
orofacial disorders. In any case of doubt, the practitioner
is advised to seek a second opinion from a colleague. The
series is not intended to be comprehensive in coverage
either of the conditions encountered, or all aspects of Figure 1: Torus mandibularis.
diagnosis or treatment: further details are available in
standard texts, in the further reading section, or from the
internet. The present article discusses aspects of lumps through fear, perhaps after hearing of someone with
and swellings. ‘mouth cancer’. Thus some individuals discover and worry
about normal anatomical features such as tori, the parotid
Lumps and swellings papilla, foliate papillae on the tongue, or the pterygoid
Lumps and swellings in the mouth are common, but of hamulus. The tongue often detects even a very small
diverse aetiologies (Table 1), and some represent swelling, or the patient may first notice it because it is sore
malignant neoplasms. Therefore, this article will discuss (Figure 1). In contrast, many oral cancers are diagnosed far
lumps and swellings in general terms, but later focus on too late, often after being present several months, usually
the particular problems of oral cancer and of orofacial because the patient ignores the swelling.
granulomatosis, presentations of which can also include Many different conditions, from benign to malignant,
oral ulceration. may present as oral lumps or swellings (see Tables 1 to 5)
Most patients have only a passing interest in their mouths including:
but some examine their mouths out of idle curiosity, some Developmental Unerupted teeth, and tori are common
causes of swellings related to the jaws
Inflammatory Dental abscess is one of the most common
causes of oral swelling. However, there are a group of
1Professor Crispian Scully CBE, MD, PhD, MDS, MRCS, BDS, BSc, conditions characterised by chronic inflammation and
MB.BS, FDSRCS, FDSRCSE, FDSRCPS, FFDRCSI, FRCPath, FMedSci, granulomas, which can present with lumps or swellings.
FHEA, FUCL, DSc, DChD, DMed (HC), Dr HC. Emeritus Professor,
University College London (UCL); Professor of Oral Medicine,
These, which include Crohn’s disease, orofacial
University of Bristol; Visiting Professor at Universities of Athens, granulomatosis, and sarcoidosis, are discussed below
Edinburgh, Granada, Helsinki and Peninsula Neoplasms Oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC),
Common
Squamous cell carcinoma
Less common
Salivary gland tumours
Malignant melanoma
Lymphomas
Neoplasms of bone and connective tissue
Some odontogenic tumours
Maxillary antral carcinoma (or other neoplasms)
Metastatic neoplasms (breast, lung, kidney,
stomach, liver)
Langerhans cell histiocytoses
Kaposi’s sarcoma
are characteristically tender, although clearly palpation Ulceration Some swellings may develop superficial
must be gentle to avoid excessive discomfort to the ulceration such as squamous cell carcinoma. The character
patient of the edge of the ulcer and the appearance of the ulcer
Discharge Note any discharge from the lesion (e.g. clear base should also be recorded
fluid, pus, or blood), orifice, or sinus Margins Ill-defined margins are frequently associated
Movement The swelling should be tested to determine if with malignancy, whereas clearly defined margins are
it is fixed to adjacent structures or the overlying suggestive of a benign lesion
skin/mucosa such as may be seen with a neoplasm Number of swellings Multiple lesions suggest an
Consistency Palpation showing a hard (indurated) infective or occasionally developmental, origin. Some
consistency may suggest a carcinoma. Palpation may conditions are associated with multiple swellings of a
cause the release of fluid (e.g. pus from an abscess) or similar nature, e.g. neurofibromatosis.
cause the lesion to blanch (vascular) or occasionally cause
a blister to appear (Nikolsky sign) or to expand. Investigations
Sometimes palpation causes the patient pain (suggesting The medical history should be fully reviewed, since
an inflammatory lesion). The swelling overlying a bony some systemic disorders may be associated with intra-
cyst may crackle (like an eggshell) when palpated or oral or facial swellings (Table 1). The nature of many
fluctuation may be elicited by detecting movement of lumps cannot be established without further
fluid when the swelling is compressed. Palpation may investigation:
disclose an underlying structure (e.g. the crown of a tooth • Any teeth adjacent to a lump involving the jaw should
under an eruption cyst) or show that the actual swelling is be tested for vitality, and any caries or suspect
in deeper structures (e.g. submandibular calculus) restorations investigated.
Surface texture The surface characteristics should be • The periodontal status of any involved teeth should also
noted: papillomas have an obvious anemone-like be determined.
appearance; carcinomas and other malignant lesions and • Imaging of the full extent of the lesion and possibly
deep fungal and other chromic infections tend to have a other areas is required whenever lumps involve the
nodular surface and may ulcerate. Abnormal blood vessels jaws. OPT and special radiographs (e.g. of the skull,
suggest a neoplasm sinuses, salivary gland function), computerised
Figure 2: Gingival swelling caused by nifedipine. Figure 3: Oral squamous cell carcinoma.
amounting to around 3% of total cancers. OSCC is seen Some other potentially malignant (precancerous)
predominantly in males but the male: female differential is conditions include:
decreasing. OSCC is seen predominantly in the elderly but is • Actinic cheilitis (mainly seen on the lower lip)
increasing in younger adults. • Lichen planus (mainly the non-reticular type)
• Submucous fibrosis (mainly in users of areca nut)
Potentially malignant states • Rarities such as:
Some potentially malignant (precancerous) lesions, which • Dyskeratosis congenita
can progress to OSCC, include especially (Table 3): • Discoid lupus erythematosus
• Erythroplasia (erythroplakia (Scully, 2003)), - this is the • Paterson-Kelly syndrome (sideropenic
most likely lesion to progress to carcinoma, and is very dysphagia; Plummer-Vinson syndrome).
dangerous
• Leukoplakias (Scully, 2003), particularly: Predisposing factors (risk factors)
• Nodular leukoplakia OSCC is most common in older males, in lower socio-
• Speckled leukoplakia economic groups and in ethnic minority groups. In the
• Proliferative verrucous leukoplakia developed world, OSCC is seen especially in tobacco and
• Sublingual leukoplakia alcohol users.
• Candidal leukoplakia Tobacco releases a complex mixture of at least 50
• Syphilitic leukoplakia compounds including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons
1V Any T4,N2,N3 or M1 10
• Immune defects may predispose to OSCC, especially lip second primary tumour rather than a recurrence of the
cancer, which is increased in, e.g. immunosuppressed initial primary.
renal transplant recipients.
Diagnosis
Pathogenesis Management of early cancers appears to confer survival
OSCC arises as a consequence of multiple molecular advantage and is also associated with less morbidity and
events causing genetic damage affecting many needs ess mutilating surgery. Thus it is important to be
chromosomes and genes, and leading to DNA changes. suspicious of oral lesions - particularly in patients at high
The accumulation of genetic changes leads to cell risk, such as older males with habits such as the use of
dysregulation to the extent that growth becomes tobacco, alcohol or betel. There should thus be a high
autonomous and invasive mechanisms develop - this is index of suspicion, especially of a solitary lesion. Clinicians
carcinoma. should be aware that single ulcers, lumps, red patches, or
white patches - particularly if any of these are persisting
Clinical Features for more than three weeks may be manifestations of
Most oral cancer is carcinoma on the lower lip; the other malignancy.
main site is the postero-lateral border/ventrum of the Frank tumours should be inspected and palpated to
tongue (Table 3). determine extent of spread; for tumours in the posterior
OSCC may present as a red lesion (erythroplasia); a tongue, examination under general anaesthetic by a
granular ulcer with fissuring or raised exophytic margins; specialist may facilitate this.
a white or mixed white and red lesion; a lump sometimes The whole oral mucosa should also be examined as
with abnormal supplying blood vessels; an indurated there may be widespread dysplastic mucosa (‘field
lump/ulcer i.e. a firm infiltration beneath the mucosa; a change’) or even a second neoplasm, and the cervical
non-healing extraction socket; a lesion fixed to deeper lymph nodes and rest of the upper aerodigestive tract
tissues or to overlying skin or mucosa; or cervical lymph (mouth, nares, pharynx, larynx, oesophagus) must be
node enlargement, especially if there is hardness in a examined.
lymph node or fixation. OSCC should be considered
where any of these features persist for more than three Investigations
weeks. An incisional biopsy is invariably required. The biopsy
It is important to note that in patients with OSCC, a should be sufficiently large to include enough suspect and
second primary neoplasm may be seen elsewhere in the apparently normal tissue to give the pathologist a chance
upper aerodigestive tract in up to 25% over three years. to make a diagnosis and not to have to request a further
Indeed, many patients treated for OSCC succumb to a specimen. Since red rather than white areas are most
likely to show dysplasia, a biopsy should be taken of the cancer is suspected. Patient communication and
former. Some authorities always take several biopsies at information are important. If the patient is to be referred
the first visit in order to avoid the delay and aggravation to a specialist for a diagnosis and insists (rightly) on a full
resulting from a negative pathology report in a patient explanation as to why there is a need for a second
who is strongly suspected as suffering from a malignant opinion, it is probably better say that you are trained more
neoplasm. Attempts to clinically highlight probably to be suspicious but hope the lesion is nothing to worry
dysplastic areas before biopsy, e.g. by the use of about, though you would be failing in your duty if you did
chemiluminescence, toluidine blue dye and other vital not ask for a second opinion. However, you should leave
stains, may be of some help where there is widespread discussion of actual diagnosis, treatment and prognosis to
‘field change’. Molecular techniques and DNA ploidy are the specialist concerned, as only they are in a position to
being introduced for prognostication in potentially give accurate facts to the patient concerned.
malignant lesions and tumours, and to identify nodal Cancer treatment and planning involves a team including
metastases. a range of specialities including surgeons, anaesthetists,
It is essential to determine whether bone or muscles are oncologists, nursing staff, dental staff, nutritionists, speech
involved or if metastases - initially to regional lymph nodes and physiotherapists, and others. Increasingly, Head and
and later to liver, bone and brain - are present. Imaging Neck Tumour Boards are being developed along with Cancer
may be needed. Another important aspect in planning Networks to facilitate the collaboration of providers of cancer
treatment is to determine if there is malignant disease services to provide seamless care based on best practice (see
elsewhere, particularly whether other primary tumours are http://www.eastman.ucl.ac.uk/hntb/index.html). Consensus
present, and therefore endoscopy may be necessary. guidelines to treatment are now being published.
Finally, the specialist also needs to ensure that the OSCC is now treated largely by surgery and/or
patient is as prepared as possible for the major surgery radiotherapy to control the primary tumour and
required, particularly in terms of general anaesthesia, metastases in cervical lymph nodes. Treatment and
potential blood loss and ability to metabolise drugs, and prognosis depend on the TNM classification (Tables 4 & 5).
to address any potential medical, dental or oral problems The planning phase includes discussions regarding
pre-operatively, to avoid complications. Therefore almost restorative and surgical interventions required before
invariably indicated are: cancer treatment, including osseointegrated implants and
• Medical examination jaw and occlusal reconstruction and therapy is also
• Biopsy of equivocal neck lymph nodes planned to avoid post-operative complications. As much
• Jaw and chest radiography oral care as possible should be completed before starting
• MRI or CT cancer treatment.
• Electrocardiography Oral care is especially important when radiotherapy is to
• Blood tests be given, since there is a liability particularly to mucositis,
xerostomia and other complications, and a risk of
Selected patients may also need: osteonecrosis - the initiating factor for which is often
• Bronchoscopy - if chest radiography reveals lesions trauma, such as tooth extraction, or ulceration from an
• Endoscopy - if there is a history of tobacco use appliance, or oral infection.
• Gastroscopy - if PEG (per-endoscopic gastrostomy) is to
be used for feeding post-surgery Orofacial granulomatosis
• Liver ultrasound – to exclude metastases Orofacial granulomatosis (OFG) is an uncommon but
• Doppler duplex flow studies and angiography: to help increasingly recognised condition seen mainly in
in planning free flaps for reconstruction. adolescents and young adults which usually manifests
with facial and/or labial swelling, but which can also
Management manifest with angular stomatitis and/or cracked lips,
If you are concerned, phone, email or write for an urgent ulcers, mucosal tags, cobble-stoning, or gingival swelling
specialist opinion, which is indicated if you feel a diagnosis (Table 4). A minority of patients with similar features have
of cancer is seriously possible or if the diagnosis is unclear. gastrointestinal Crohn’s disease, swelling or have
One of the most difficult clinical situations in which sarcoidosis.
clinicians find themselves is with the patient in whom The aetiology of OFG is unknown but there may be an
HLA association (A3, B7, DR2). In some there is a gingiva, hyperplastic folds of the oral mucosa (thickening
postulated reaction to food or other antigens (particularly and folding of the mucosa producing a ‘cobblestone-type’
to additives such as benzoates or cinnamon), or metals of appearance, and mucosal tags), ulcers (classically linear
such as cobalt. Reactions to paratuberculosis, Borrelia vestibular ulcers with flanking granulomatous masses),
burgdorferi or mycobacterial stress protein mSP65 have facial swelling and angular cheilitis.
been hypothesised but not proven. Most patients appear
to develop the problem in relation to dietary components Diagnosis
such as chocolate, nuts, cheese or food additives. Oral biopsy, haematological, gastrointestinal and other
Conditions related to OFG include Miescher’s cheilitis - investigations may be required in suspected Crohn’s
where lip swelling is seen in isolation, and Melkersson- disease especially to exclude sarcoidosis. Specialist care is
Rosenthal syndrome- where there is facial swelling with usually indicated. Histologically, the epithelium is intact
fissured tongue and facial palsy. but thickened, with epithelioid cells and giant cells
surrounded by a lymphocytic infiltration.
Diagnosis
Diagnosis is clinical, supported by blood tests, endoscopy, Management
imaging and biopsy to differentiate from Crohn’s disease, Topical or intralesional corticosteroids may effectively
sarcoidosis, tuberculosis and foreign body reactions. control the oral lesions but more frequently systemic
Specialist care is usually indicated. corticosteroids, azathioprine or salazopyrine are required.
Management Reference
Management is to eliminate allergens such as chocolate, Scully C (2003). Oral medicine for the General Practitioner, part four: white
nuts, cheese or food additives and treat lesions with colour. Independent Dentistry 8(1) (to be published)
intralesional corticosteroids or occasionally systemic
clofazimine or sulphasalazine. Further reading
Mashberg A and Samit A (1995). Early diagnosis of
Crohn’s disease asymptomatic oral and oropharyngeal squamous cancers.
Crohn’s disease is a chronic inflammatory idiopathic CA Cancer J Clin 45: 328-351
granulomatous disorder. Many causal factors have been Prince S, Bailey BM (1999). Squamous carcinoma of the
hypothesised, one of the most recent being that it may be tongue: review. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg 37: 164-174
caused by Mycobacterium paratuberculosis. This remains Sciubba JJ (2001). Oral cancer. The importance of early
to be proved. Crohn’s disease affects mainly the small diagnosis and treatment. Am J Clin Dermatol 2: 239-251
intestine (ileum) but can affect any part of the Scully, C, Ward-Booth, P (1995). Detection and
gastrointestinal tract, including the mouth. There may also treatment of early cancers of the oral cavity. Crit Rev
be features of gastrointestinal involvement such as Oncol Hematol 21: 63-75
abnormal bowel movements, pain, or weight loss. Scully C, Porter SR (2000). Orofacial Disease; update for
About 10% of patients with Crohn’s disease of the the dental clinical team: 11. Cervical lymphadenopathy.
bowel have oral lesions. Oral lesions may be seen in the Dental Update 27: 44-47
absence of any identifiable gut involvement and are the Silverman S (1994). Oral cancer. Semin Dermatol 13:
same as those seen in OFG - reddish raised lesions on the 132-137