Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CONTRAST EFFECTS
Optical illusions:
considerably, as well as the ability to evaluate color in a clear, concise, and objective
figures are all of equal length and size; however, owing to the optic illusion of
converging lines, as our eyes move to the right side of the diagram, it appears that the
far right figure is considerably larger than the far left figure
Perspective; the figures are of all equal length and size; however, owing to the
optical illusion of converging lines , as our eyes move to the right side diagram , it
86
CONTRAST EFFECTS
is essential to understand that value, chroma and contrasts between an object
Simultaneous Contrast :
Areal contrast :
When the same colors are observed, appearing in diffferent size areas.
Spatial contrast :
Successive contrast :
Simultaneous Contrast :
brighter; if the surrounding background is light, the object is perceived as less bright .
The perceived brightness is inaccurate, even though the reflectivity of the object is
87
CONTRAST EFFECTS
constant. The retina is very sensitive to changes in light, and the phenomenon is
The relative brightness is affected by the contrasting back-ground, owing to the light and
dark contrasts. Even though the teeth represented are in the same light/ darkness , the
background influences the appearance (the upper left is lighter; lower right is darker).
88
CONTRAST EFFECTS
redness of the gums - and consequently the background - act to distort our color
perception abilities. The restoration invariably appears too bright when it actually is
too dark. When the tissues heal, the crown is too low in value, since the perception
When the inflamed tissues heal, and the color returns to normal , the selected
crown value may be too low (dark).
89
CONTRAST EFFECTS
HUE CONTRAST:
When two chromatic colors are combined, the perceived hue varies closer to the
complementary color than to that of the background . The perceived hue of the mock
tooth against a red background takes on a green color tone; against a green
background it takes on a red hue against a yellow background its hue is purple; and
against a purple background it appears to be yellow. Note how the same A3 Vitapan
shade tab appears to be quite different in hue when imaged against a red versus a
blue background. We use this phenomenon to our advantage when taking shades by
preconditioning our eyes to see tooth shades more effectively. For instance, tooth
shades fall predominantly into the orange hue family, and if we want to be able to see
the orange tones more discriminately, we can precondition our eyes by first looking at
a light blue background, i.e. immediately prior to the shade selection process. The
closer the colors-to-be-combined are to the complementary colors, the more vibrant
When two chromatic colors are combined, the perceived hue varies closer to the
complementary color than to that of the background.
90
CONTRAST EFFECTS
91
CONTRAST EFFECTS
92
CONTRAST EFFECTS
93
CONTRAST EFFECTS
The same A3 vitapan shade tab appears quite different when placed agsinst blue-
background –its takes on a darker , more orange hue.
This contrast follows the same effect as the value and hue contrasts. This
image appears darker against a light background, which is low in chroma (light), and
However, there is a variation to the theme: the closer the tooth is to the hue and
chroma of the surrounding background, the less visible it becomes, and therefore it is
94
CONTRAST EFFECTS
Against a background that is low in chroma, the tooth appears much more vibrant
when compared to the same tooth against a background that closely matches the
chroma of the tooth. The ceramic tooth against the orange background is not as
visible because the orange is a similar chroma. The ceramic tooth against the
AREAL CONTRAST:
Visual color perception is also influenced by the size of the object. optical illusion
is present even though the object reflects the same wavelength of light in the visible
spectrum. The size of the object can also influence visual color perception. For
instance, a larger object appears brighter than a smaller object of the same color.
Likewise, a brighter object appears to be larger than a darker object of the same size.
This type of contrast accounts for the fact that darker clothes have a tendency to make
an individual look smaller and thinner, while whiter clothes tend to make the individual
95
CONTRAST EFFECTS
Area contrast.visual color perception is also influenced by the size of the object:
a large-size object will appear lighter, a small-size darker.
SPATIAL CONTRAST:
Spatial contrast can be equated to brightness and size as well. An object that is
more recessed will appear to be smaller in size and not as bright; an object closer to
the observer will appear larger and brighter . This phenomenon is frequently seen with
rotated and overlapped teeth. The teeth that are recessed appear to be darker, they
96
CONTRAST EFFECTS
tend to be more difficult to clean. However, once the stain is removed, the teeth will
Posterior teeth appear to be darker, since they are more recessed in the oral
cavity. The shadows in the mouth further contribute to the darker appearance.
Posterior teeth appear to be darker because they are more recessed in the oral
cavity.
97
CONTRAST EFFECTS
Teeth that are rotated and/or recessed relative to the adjacent teeth appear to be darker.
The clinical example on the right shows a mandibular right central incisor that appears
darker than the other teeth because of its recessed position.
VALUE CONTRAST:
appear light. However, if the same object is placed against a lighter background, it is
perceived as darker.
This illustrates that the perceived brightness can vary, even though the
reflectivity of the object is constant. This is because the retina is very sensitive to light.
It expands and contracts in response to varying light intensities as they are interpreted
by the brain. If the background is darker than the object, the retina must adapt to the
relatively brighter object, causing the brain to perceive it as brighter than it would be if
the object were viewed by itself. If the background is lighter than the object, the
opposite effect results. However, because the eye adapts much more quickly from
dark to light than from light to dark, the effect of a darker object on a lighter
98
CONTRAST EFFECTS
brighter. As a result, a crown that is too low in value (dark) may be chosen. The
mistake becomes apparent when the tissues heal and the crown appears too dark
because the shade was selected falsely dark under those pretenses and poor
The value contrast effect makes the same tooth appear increasingly lighter as the
background becomes darker.
Value contrast effects have clinical significance when dealing with excessively
inflamed gingival tissues. The dark value of the inflamed gums will trick the eyes
into perceiving the tooth shade as being lighter than it actually is. As a result, the
fabricated restoration will appear too dark once the tissues have healed.
99
CONTRAST EFFECTS
SUCCESSIVE CONTRAST:
is an example of successive contrast when the visual perception remains after the eye
has left the object. Afterimages are categorized as positive (similar) or negative
(different). Positive afterimages have the same color as the original perception;
the retina are quickly depleted during prolonged staring. Therefore, the ability to see
that color is no longer a physical reality. Note how - by changing the background paper
- the phenomenon of value, chroma, and hue contrast affects the appearance of the
Placed against a gray background, the object will appear lighter in color.
100
CONTRAST EFFECTS
Placed against a white background, the maxillary central incisors restored with
ceramic veneers. Note the difference of the incisal edges and the darker
appearance of the teeth
101
CONTRAST EFFECTS
102
CONTRAST EFFECTS
CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE OF CONTRAST EFFECTS
103
CONTRAST EFFECTS
COLOR IN DENTISTRY:
One of the best descriptions of the importance of color was offered by Bergen.
creation of color of hard and soft oral tissues, while maxillofacial prosthodontists are
dealing with color in the entire maxillofacial area. Therefore, this section is related to
color‐related clinical and dental technology applications. What is the practical meaning
color threshold)? A ΔE* of 0 corresponds to perfect match—it is rarely seen and not
really necessary. Visual thresholds are also known as industry tolerances, and these
differ from one industry to another. A 50:50 perceptibility threshold is the difference in
color that can be detected by 50% of observers. The other 50% of observers will
notice no difference in color between the compared objects. A nearly perfect color
50% of observers. The other 50% of observers would replace the restoration or correct
its color. An acceptable color match in dentistry is a color difference at or below the
104
CONTRAST EFFECTS
TOOTH COLOR:
Color of human teeth differs by dentition: permanent teeth are darker and less
chromatic than primary teeth. It differs by individual and by tooth type for the same
person: incisors are in general the lightest while the canines are the darkest and most
chromatic. It also differs for the same tooth, by the tooth area: from gingival to incisal,
mesial to distal and buccal to lingual and throughout the lifetime; “older” teeth are in
ranged from 56 to 90, a* ranged from − 4 to 7, b* ranged from 4 to 39, C* ranged from −
4 to 39, while H* ranged from 73 to 119.15 When color of permanent teeth was
compared by gender: female teeth were lighter, less red, and less chromatic, and the
overall color difference (ΔE*) was 3.0. The same was found for comparisons between
bleached and nonbleached teeth, and teeth of smokers and nonsmokers: bleached and
nonsmoker teeth were lighter, less red, and less chromatic, with ΔE*=4.6 and 3.4,
are less chromatic and less red, regardless of all variables mentioned above. Based on
the literature, the 50:50 perceptibility threshold for teeth ranges from ΔE* of 1 to 2, 17,
18 while the 50:50 acceptability threshold ranges from ΔE* of 2.7 to 3.5.
GINGIVAL COLOR:
Color range of healthy human gingiva is far beyond the “ideal” light pink. A
lightness range from 27 to 81, a* range from 4 to 38, and b* range from 5 to 27 were
105
CONTRAST EFFECTS
reported.20 Wide ranges of color coordinates make restoring color of the gingiva
human tissues are used. Restorations that do not primarily involve gingiva can also
affect its color: partial dentures, implants, crowns, and veneers. Inflammation and tooth
SKIN COLOR:
thresholds for human skin replications were evaluated, significant differences were
found by primary specimen color and type of threshold. CIELAB perceptibility thresholds
for light and dark skin replications were 1.1 and 1.6, respectively. Corresponding values
Color matching remains a "trial and error" method, in which the professional
places shade guides in the mouth with the purpose of establishing the best match,
ignoring the characteristics of color and natural phenomena that change tooth color.
Since the first color shade guides made an appearance early in the 20th century, they
were designed to match the color of natural teeth with no particular arrangement or
method (1). In 1929 shade guides were classified by tonalities. In 1939 the "Lumin
effect" (color consistency) was described in natural teeth, and this led to the birth of
106
CONTRAST EFFECTS
dental shade guides as we know them today (2), providing us since that time with
The best- known shade guide ,the Vita lumin vacuum guide (Vident) has
existed since 1956, and its philosophy is still revelant today. It was not until 1998 that
only changes made in this new system were a different nomenclature scheme.
Electronic color matching is showing very positive and promising data, but much
technology remains to be developed and evolved before perfectly reliable data can be
Recent attempts to produce a different color matching system date back only a
few years. These include selective and personalized color matching based on
scientific color principles and the differentiation of the diverse tissues of the tooth.
There are five color shades that form a natural tooth; the combination of
Each of the five basic colors is commonly found at particular locations of the
107
CONTRAST EFFECTS
YELLOW/ORANGE: Dentin
characteristics
Each of the different shades present in a tooth has a specific location, offering features
and optical properties common to most tooth.
108
CONTRAST EFFECTS
THE IN LAYER :
We call the dentin the In Layer, We call the dentin the In layer, because it
The base Chroma (Hue and Chroma) is given by the dentin, which
dominates the chromatic nature of teeth. Dentin is the most abundant tissue in
the tooth; it provides resistance and elasticity to the dental complex. Despite its
different. Generally, dentin is reddish yellow and has a high chromaticity and a
throughout life. The dentinal thickness increases, while the diameter of the
tubules, the volume of the pulp, and the permeability and opacity of the dentin
decrease.
109
CONTRAST EFFECTS
Under normal conditions there are two types of dentin, the primary dentin,
developed since the formation of tooth germ, and the secondary dentin, which
usually begins its formation at the moment of contact with the opposing tooth and
changes the optical properties of both kinds of dentin, which is why the
desaturation phenomenon occurs: The center of the tooth is more chromatic, and
closer to the surface the dentin becomes less saturated. For example, in an A2
tooth, the dentin near the pulp would likely be shade A3.
The gradual change of Chroma is also evident from the cervical third to the
incisal third; the closer to the incisal edge, the more desaturated and more
THE IN LAYER :
We call the dentin the In Layer, We call the dentin the In layer, because it
The base Chroma (Hue and Chroma) is given by the dentin, which dominates
the chromatic nature of teeth. Dentin is the most abundant tissue in the tooth; it
provides resistance and elasticity to the dental complex. Despite its apparent
dentin is reddish yellow and has a high chromaticity and a remarkable opacity. It is
also a highly fluorescent tissue, because of the presence of certain proteins, such as
photochrome.
110
CONTRAST EFFECTS
The physiologic aging process causes changes in dentinal color throughout
life. The dentinal thickness increases, while the diameter of the tubules, the volume
of the pulp, and the permeability and opacity of the dentin decrease.
Under normal conditions there are two types of dentin, the primary dentin,
developed since the formation of tooth germ, and the secondary dentin, which
usually begins its formation at the moment of contact with the opposing tooth and
the optical properties of both kinds of dentin, which is why the desaturation
phenomenon occurs: The center of the tooth is more chromatic, and closer to the
surface the dentin becomes less saturated. For example, in an A2 tooth, the dentin
The gradual change of Chroma is also evident from the cervical third to the
incisal third; the closer to the incisal edge, the more desaturated and more opaque
consider is the appropriate level of translucency and opacity. The dentin acts as a
very efficient opaquer: It hides dark colors but can let light pass through efficiently.
Several studies have reported numeric data for the translucency and opacity
the translucency parameters of natural enamel and dentin. In this way, we will be
111
CONTRAST EFFECTS
able to choose the appropriate composite resin in each clinical situation. For
and reflect the underlying tooth structure. For a large restoration, we would suggest
an opaque material for buildup, because if it were too translucent it would be unable
and human enamel to range between 16.4. and 18.7. For comparison, the same
thickness of several composites showed values between 6.3 and 17.2. Higher
112
CONTRAST EFFECTS
In the young tooth,the dentin has low chromaticity. The high value enamel hides
the dentinal color and increases the overall value of the tooth.
113
CONTRAST EFFECTS
In the older tooth, the dentin has high chromaticity. The enamel increases the
value of the tooth very little.
ELASTICITY:
Dentin is the most resistant human tissue, despite not being the hardest, and is
responsible for supporting the enamel, which is a much harder tissue and brittle in the
FLUORESCENCE:
A large percentage of the light that hits the dentin is reflected back. This light
is returned with more energy than the original, because such tissues are fluorescent
visible light within the visible light spectrum. What is responsible for the
114
CONTRAST EFFECTS
fluorescence? The dentin layer and its proteins that bind it to the enamel are the
most fluorescent
114
CONTRAST EFFECTS
compounds in the body. Enamel is also fluorescent but to a considerably
lesser degree.
stands out significantly, although less obviously, under natural light. Because some
invisible light is bounced back from the teeth with . higher energy (visible ·light), it
In the beginning, these materials had a large number of detractors, and many did not
esthetic material.
some layers of these teeth with more fluorescent materials than would normally be
used.
glow" that contributes to the vital appearance of the natural tooth, that is, the light
115
CONTRAST EFFECTS
Aging results in a decrease in the fluorescence of dentin because of protein
116
CONTRAST EFFECTS
DENTINOENAMEL JUNCTION:
collagen protein fiber bundles that penetrate the enamel and dentin, the two tissues
fluorescence and the natural appearance, increase Value, and provide elasticity
forces and prevents the propagation of fractures into the enamel. It is a highly
fluorescent layer, has a very high Value (white), and is highly translucent at the same
time. Besides being a strong bond between two different tissues, this layer acts as a
light transmitter and scatterer toward the dentin, providing an appearance of depth
composites that simulate the properties of the protein layer (eg, glass connecto
Enamel Plus HFO, Micerium, and DE Connector, Ultra dent) and must be stratified
between the dentin and enamel. However, many modern composites do not require
117
CONTRAST EFFECTS
Section from a natural tooth under direct light. The dentinoenamel junction is
evident as a clearly defined line. Where the light is highly diffused, the dentinoenamel
junction appears as a glint.
118
CONTRAST EFFECTS
Section from a natural tooth under transmitted light, which reveals the luminous effect of
the connecting line between enamel and dentin and the strong diffusion that occurs.
Section from a natural tooth section under black light, used to evidence
fluorescence. The dentinoenamel junction shines under black light but is hardly
distinguish able because of its thickness.
119
CONTRAST EFFECTS
120
CONTRAST EFFECTS
Same tooth sections under black light ,the protein layer provides extremely high
fluorescence
121
CONTRAST EFFECTS
The tooth without the protein layer has a deeper blue under black light.
factors, including dehydration , loss of internal dentinal volume and the breakdown of
122
CONTRAST EFFECTS
It is important to restore these teeth with an inside layer that serves a source of
restored with non fluorescent or semi fluorescent materials has a non vital
appearance.
fluorescent layer but also with a fluorescent dentin ; if a post is needed , it should be
fluorescent a well.
The dentin surrounding the pulp is highly fluorescent, and its lose becomes a problem
that must be solved. When endodontically treated teeth restored with non-fluorescent
material are sectioned, they suffer a loss of fluorescence and therefore the total value of
the tooth decreases.
123
CONTRAST EFFECTS
The color dynamics and optical phenomena we have discussed also apply to
posterior teeth. The main differences between anterior and posterior teeth result from
the differing proportions in enamel and dentin thickness.
124